Awkward Guests 2: The Berwick Cases Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Awkward Guests 2: The Berwick Cases
Reviewers see Awkward Guests 2: The Berwick Cases as the two-player sibling of the original Awkward Guests, and they largely judge it against that parent game. Paula Deming, who played it live on a stream, is the most enthusiastic voice. Deming grew up loving Clue, found that few hobby-level games scratched the same itch, and says this title "hits that spot for me better than anything else." The Chairman of the Board, in a ranking of recent releases, places it at number eight and calls it a strong two-player deduction game, while still preferring the original because it supports more players. Tom Vasel of The Dice Tower, reviewing it in a list of lesser-known titles, admits to not having played it yet and says the first game is liked a great deal. The consensus is that the sequel is a faithful, more focused version of a proven formula, and the main disagreement is whether the two-player restriction is a fair trade for the tighter design.
Core Mechanics That Define Awkward Guests 2: The Berwick Cases
Deduction
Deduction is the engine of the game. Each player takes a turn as investigator, rolling three dice and placing the results on a personal sheet to interrogate suspects, question household staff, examine the crime scene, and check police reports. The dice map onto distinct question types. A toe tag die reveals weapon damage, a magnifying glass die checks whether evidence of a motive sits in a room, a multiple choice die asks suspects about their favorite weapon type, and a gossip die asks whether two suspects have spoken about each other. Paula Deming describes the investigation as a process of elimination, where each answer "rules out" a suspect, a room, or a motive. The Chairman of the Board notes that the dice replace the card system of the original, which changes how the questions feel without changing the core logic of working through clues. Reviewers consistently note that the reasoning gets more rewarding as the answers pile up. A single answer rarely solves anything, but two or three well-chosen answers can eliminate an entire column of possibilities at once.
Hidden Roles
Each player is both a mastermind and an investigator, and the roles rotate so that the murder one player plots is the murder the other must solve. The mastermind's side of the board holds the secret. Paula Deming explains that the mastermind chooses a killer, a motive, and a weapon, then traces a route through four doorways to the bedroom where the body is found. Those choices are recorded behind shields, so the investigator never sees them directly. The mastermind also seeds red herrings, such as testimony that points at the wrong suspect, to make the investigation harder. Because both players plan and investigate in the same match, the reviewers describe a race in which each side tries to out-think the other. Deming, playing the mastermind side, joked about deliberately planting two red herrings in one column to mislead the opponent, an approach that worked well enough to win a guess.
The Awkward Guests 2: The Berwick Cases Experience
A Tense, Competitive Race
Reviewers describe the game as a head-to-head race rather than a relaxed mystery. Both players work on their own murder in parallel, so the pressure comes from knowing your opponent may already be close to the answer. Paula Deming repeatedly describes feeling pressure as the investigation narrows, noting that the three guesses allowed each player create a real decision point about when to commit. The Chairman of the Board says the game "would definitely start to peak" if players invest in the same opponent over many sessions and learn each other's habits. The tension builds across rounds as the board fills with marks, and the moment one player decides to solve becomes the high point of each game.
The Playful Awkwardness of Planning a Murder
The second feeling is the pleasure of planning a crime. Paula Deming laughs throughout the stream at the absurd names, the awkward suspect lines, and the fact that an opponent can say "the bathroom" in the wrong way and give away a clue. The mastermind side gives players a chance to be devious, and reviewers describe enjoying the moment they realize they have built a trail that is harder to read than expected. The Chairman of the Board calls the setup "making up the murder mystery yourself," which captures the sense of ownership. The game's dark comedy lands because the themes are playful rather than grim, and the table talk is part of the fun.
What Makes Awkward Guests 2: The Berwick Cases Stand Out
A Two-Player Design Built Around Both Sides of the Mystery
The most consistent praise is for the way the two-player format gives each player both roles. The Chairman of the Board, who calls the sequel "a two-player exclusive version," explains that you are not just solving a predetermined case but building the murder for your opponent. Paula Deming makes a similar point, saying the game fills a gap that had been missing in hobby board games. Because each player designs a case and then has to solve the other's, the game feels symmetrical and fair. Reviewers also appreciate that the head-to-head format keeps the experience competitive without requiring a group.
Dice Replace Cards and Keep the Investigation Fresh
Dice-driven questions are the second standout. The Chairman of the Board notes that the sequel uses dice instead of the cards in the original, estimating the gameplay at roughly 75 percent the same. That change alters the rhythm of a turn. Players roll, choose a face, and decide which question to ask, which makes each turn more deliberate. Paula Deming notes that the dice-driven interface worked well on a live stream, describing the investigator's choices as a series of tradeoffs between gossip, forensic evidence, and connections. Reviewers say the dice keep the game from feeling like a list of questions to read off a card, and they support replay because each new murder is built fresh.
Potential Drawbacks
Strictly Two Players
The most common criticism is that the game supports only two players. The Chairman of the Board is clear that this is why the sequel ranks below the original, which caters to a wider player count and more flexible groups. Paula Deming hit the same limit during the stream, asking whether the game could be turned into a solo digital version in order to play the investigator role alone after the murder was set up. Players who regularly game in larger groups or want to play alone may find the format limiting, even if they enjoy the two-player experience.
Bookkeeping and Setup Load
Several reviewers note that the game asks a lot of players to track information. The mastermind's setup involves choosing a killer, motive, and weapon, marking testimony boxes, tracing a route, removing matching cards from the deck, and placing red herrings. The investigator must record each answer carefully. Paula Deming's stream shows how easily this goes wrong, with a connection marked incorrectly and caught only because the opponent noticed it, an admission that the mistake could have ruined the deduction. Players who dislike heavy note-taking or long setup may find the first few games slow, although reviewers suggest that familiarity reduces the burden over time.
If You Enjoy Awkward Guests 2: The Berwick Cases
Players who enjoy the mastermind and investigator structure will find a natural next step in the original Awkward Guests. The Chairman of the Board calls the first game one of the favorite deduction games of all time and recommends it for groups that want more players at the table. Players who enjoy the Clue-like question-and-answer loop will find Clue familiar. Paula Deming describes Awkward Guests 2 as the hobby-level game that had been missing, which suggests that fans of Clue's core deduction will feel at home with it. Players drawn to the publisher's wider catalog should look at Scandalo. The Chairman of the Board liked Scandalo and its head-to-head version for being so similar in spirit to Awkward Guests. For players who want a longer, harder deduction puzzle, Paula Deming compares the experience to Alchemists, a game played for hours without any player solving it. Players who enjoy the race to deduce a hidden answer should find each of these titles satisfying in a different way.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"I've been looking and looking for like a hobby level board game that would do what Clue did."
— Paula Deming
"This one is a two-player exclusive version of the game where you will actually set the challenge for your opponent, so still competitive but you are actually making up the murder mystery yourself and putting that challenge to your opponent. It's going to be a race to get that murder mystery solved."
— Chairman of the Board
"I really like awkward guests, so why didn't I play the second one?"
— Tom Vasel, The Dice Tower