Commands & Colors: Medieval Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Commands & Colors: Medieval
Commands & Colors: Medieval is a 2019 entry in the Commands & Colors series from GMT Games, and reviewers generally treat it as a confident, accessible member of a long-running wargame family. The One Stop Co-op Shop approached it through a solo playthrough, and host Mike described the overall system as hugely enjoyable while noting that games move quickly and that the scenarios vary widely in terrain, unit mix, and pacing. The Discriminating Gamer, hosted by Cody Carlson, counts the game among Cody Carlson's favorites in the series and praises its Byzantine and Frankish setting and its scenario design. The two channels diverge on relative standing. Cody still prefers Commands & Colors: Ancients, the system Medieval builds on, while Mike treats Medieval as a worthwhile step within the family without ranking it against its predecessor.
Both reviewers agree that the series rewards commitment. Mike argues that players coming from Memoir 44 will find Medieval a noticeable step up, with more unit types and special rules to track, though that extra depth produces far more varied matchups. That trade-off between accessibility and variety shapes most of the conversation around the game.
Core Mechanics That Define Commands & Colors: Medieval
Card-Driven Flank Activation
Medieval is built on the card-driven system that Richard Borg created for the Commands & Colors line. Each player holds a hand of Command cards, and every card indicates which of the three battlefield sections, left, center, or right, may be activated that turn. Mike describes ordinary orders such as moving two units in one section, along with special cards like Line Command, which lets a player activate a contiguous group of foot units, mounted units, and leaders across sections, and Mounted Charge, which lets up to three mounted units attack with bonus dice. Medieval also adds Inspired Action tokens that Mike notes were not part of Commands & Colors: Ancients. Leaders can spend these tokens to power up actions, ignore a flag, or add a die before an attack, so a single leader can change the result of a turn.
Battle Dice, Retreats, and Leader Survival
Combat is resolved with the system's battle dice, and the dice pool depends on the unit. Mike notes that medium units roll three dice in close combat, heavy units roll four, and light units roll two. Ranged units roll one die if they moved and two if they stayed put, and they score only on the symbol that matches their target. Flags force a unit to retreat, but the retreat can be ignored when the unit has two adjacent allies or a leader present, and a unit that cannot complete its retreat takes damage for each hex it could not move. Swords are the most complicated result, since lighter units can ignore some of them against heavier targets. Leaders add a separate layer of tension. When a unit containing a leader takes damage, a survival check is rolled, and the leader dies only on a double helmet result. Mike puts that chance at one in 36 for a damaged unit, while a unit that is wiped out triggers a single-die check instead.
The Commands & Colors: Medieval Experience
Hidden Information in the Solo System
The most distinctive feeling in the reviews comes from the Card Driven Game solo system. Mike plays both armies, keeps the cards face down, and rolls a die at the start of each turn to reveal a few cards and the choices available. Mike describes the result as a balance of partial information: a player can see what the other side is likely to do, but not with certainty, so every decision carries a sense of risk. Mike notes that the limited hand of two or three cards keeps the game moving because there are fewer options to weigh. In Mike's view, the experience is a steady stream of planning under uncertainty rather than a contest of memorized positions.
Swings of Fortune and Momentum
Reviewers describe combat as a rollercoaster. In Mike's playthrough, a mounted charge breaks a unit, a momentum advance carries cavalry into a bonus attack, and a string of flags sends a formation reeling. Successful attacks chain into follow-up strikes, so one good roll can open a line and reshape the board in a single turn. A bad roll, by contrast, leaves a charging unit exposed to battle back. At one point the Sassanid force reached five of the six banners needed to win, and a late run of counterattacks decided the battle, so the swings are a large part of the tension. The feeling is exciting and occasionally cruel, and it keeps the outcome uncertain until the last turns.
What Makes Commands & Colors: Medieval Stand Out
Varied Scenarios and Asymmetric Forces
Both channels return to the scenarios. Mike's walkthrough uses a cavalry-heavy fourth scenario in which the Byzantines field super heavy cavalry and strong heavy infantry against a Sassanid force holding the hills, and Mike notes that other scenarios lean heavily on foot soldiers. Cody highlights a lot of great scenarios and great battles, connecting the matchups to the Byzantine and Frankish era. Mike adds that the scenarios use different terrain, such as hills that limit attacking dice, along with different unit types, so the battlefield rarely feels like a repeat. The result is a game that keeps producing new arrangements of familiar pieces.
A Solo Mode Built on the Card System
The solo system is what many reviewers remember most. GMT provides free printable materials and a one-page rule sheet for each supported game, and Mike found that the components were easy to proxy. Mike is clear that the mode is not solo in the traditional sense, since the player controls both sides, but considers it a strong way to play without an opponent, and sees the system as applicable to other card-driven games such as Wilderness War and Twilight Struggle. For players who do not mind playing against themselves, the mode extends the life of the game considerably.
Potential Drawbacks
Swingy Dice and Card Draws
Mike's central caveat is that Commands & Colors can be swingy. Combat dice can produce dramatic outcomes, and the luck of the card draw can be more extreme in the solo system, where only two or three cards are available at a time instead of a full hand. A player can be stuck with a weak card, and a single lucky roll can hand one side a decisive advantage. Mike still views the system positively, but players who dislike randomness may find the variance hard to accept. The effect is a long-standing trait of the family, and Mike believes the solo format intensifies it.
A Learning Curve and the Solo Caveat
Reviewers note that Medieval asks more of players than some entry-level titles. Mike suggests that anyone who has only played Memoir 44 may find the step up substantial, because there are more unit types, terrain rules, and special results to track. The solo format also presents a hurdle. Players who expect a true one-faction solo experience may find it strange to make decisions for both armies at once, and Mike acknowledges that the format is most comfortable for people who already enjoy playing against themselves. The depth is rewarded, but the game is not a quick introduction to the series.
If You Enjoy Commands & Colors: Medieval
Players who enjoy Medieval's card-driven flank activation will find similar satisfaction in Commands & Colors: Ancients, the system Medieval builds on and the title Cody Carlson still likes a little better. Players who want the same structure with a more approachable setup should consider Memoir 44, the Days of Wonder title Mike lists first in the family.
- Samurai Battles pairs the core activation system with a deck of extra cards that can disrupt an opponent's plans, a quality Cody singled out for adding spice and surprise.
- Battle Lore brings fantasy armies and manipulation cards to the series, giving fans of Medieval's leaders and special abilities a related flavor of the same battle system.
- Battlecry is the Avalon Hill entry Cody remembers fondly for its Civil War battles and the late-night sessions it inspired, a good choice for players who enjoy the flank structure in a different historical setting.
- Twilight Struggle and Wilderness War are the card-driven games Mike names when discussing the solo system, so players who value hidden information and tough decisions in a card deck will find a closely related experience.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"The big negative already, the Command and Colors games can be a little bit swingy. I mean, not just in the combat. You saw how swingy the combat can be."
— Mike, One Stop Co-op Shop
"I like the battles from the game, and I like the era that you're playing in from the game."
— Cody Carlson, The Discriminating Gamer
"I think at least for me, it's just enough obfuscation, just enough kind of hidden element in the game that I can make decisions quickly and I don't have to kind of obsess over what I can see on my opponent's board. I think actually the limits on which cards you can play help to keep the game moving in a nice clip."
— Mike, One Stop Co-op Shop