Deal with the Devil Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Deal with the Devil
Reviewers tend to approach Deal with the Devil as a meeting point between a heavy Euro and a social deduction game, and most come away impressed by how well those halves hold together. Czech Games Edition released it in 2022, designed by Matúš Košút, and it asks four players to build medieval kingdoms while secretly playing one of four roles: two mortals, a cultist, and the Devil himself. The consensus is that the game has a lot going on, yet its appeal rises or falls with the trading between players. People who enjoy negotiation and bluffing tend to praise it highly, while those hoping for a quick or flexible evening often find it demanding. Sentiment is positive but conditional, and the reviews agree that the table you bring matters as much as the box.
Core Mechanics That Define Deal with the Devil
Hidden Roles
Every player holds a secret role, and that role defines what winning looks like. The mortals start with no resources but carry immortal souls, the cultist begins with advanced resources and tainted souls, and the Devil starts without any souls but with tempting wealth. Trades happen through chests that are shuffled and distributed around the table using QR codes and an app, so everyone knows which role made an offer without knowing which player made it. Reviewers point out that the resources changing hands leak small clues about who is who, which turns every exchange into a bit of investigation. The app stays in the background, handling the reveals, so the social work remains with the players.
Negotiation
Trading is the engine that drives the hidden roles forward. Each round, players may give up resources in exchange for money or sell their souls, and the Devil can put generous offers on the table because he does not need to score large set collections like everyone else. Reviewers stress that a fair price is the heart of the game, since collectively selling more souls hands the Devil more points and sends more inquisitors after the rest of the table. Loans add another layer of pressure. Players who borrow money face compounding interest, and letting debts spiral can cost points or worse, so every purchase has a hidden cost attached.
The Deal with the Devil Experience
Interactive and Dynamic
The Euro side of the game is steady and rewarding on its own. Players draft building cards, produce resources, and plan a limited set of actions each round, with the most valuable constructions delivering the bulk of the victory points. Yet the most memorable moments happen between turns, when someone quietly offers a deal, someone else accepts a price that looks suspicious, and the table starts reading each other closely. Reviewers describe the rhythm as constantly shifting, because each round changes who needs what and who is willing to give it up.
Dark and Moody
Selling souls to the Devil gives the game a tone that sits well away from cheerful medieval fare. The Witch Hunts, where players can be accused and an angry mob demands answers, and the Inquisitions, where the church arrives to collect its due, keep the atmosphere tense. Reviewers note that the art and the theme lean toward something much darker than a typical city builder, which suits players who want their board games to carry a little menace. The setting does not feel decorative. It shapes the decisions players make about money, reputation, and conscience.
What Makes Deal with the Devil Stand Out
A Euro Engine With a Social Core
Plenty of games combine engine building with hidden information, but few make the two feel so interlocked. Reviewers highlight the way set collection bonuses, ongoing abilities, and church reputation all feed into the deal making, so that a resource you buy for money might be the exact piece that completes a valuable building. The building options are varied enough to reward planning, and the trades ensure that no two tables build the same kingdom.
Tension Built Into the Scoring
Scoring is where the game's tension peaks. Inquisitors deliver significant negative points, but players can bribe some of them away or ignore them by holding souls or spending indulgences. That makes the church's favor a constant concern, and it forces players to decide whether to chase reputation or risk a fall. The Devil scores for each soul collected, which means the hidden role at the center of the table is always working toward a specific goal.
Potential Drawbacks
Length and Rules Overhead
The game takes a long time to play, and reviewers often mention that a session can stretch to around three hours or longer. Setting up the chests, learning the QR code flow, and keeping track of the hidden roles adds rules overhead that can slow a first game considerably. Some reviewers note that the app is simple once you know it, but the early learning curve is real. Groups that want a quick evening will likely find the time commitment hard to justify.
Needs the Right Group
Deal with the Devil requires four players, and the reviews make clear that this is not a casual title. It works best with players who enjoy negotiation, bluffing, and reading the table, and it can fall flat with people who would rather not haggle over souls. Some reviewers feel that the value of a trade depends on the group sharing a sense of fair play, while others note that repeated plays with the same people help the deals feel more meaningful. Without that buy-in, the game can feel more like a chore than a feast.
If You Enjoy Deal with the Devil
- Alchemists: An app-assisted engine game from the same designer, for players who enjoy a precise, puzzle-like Euro.
- Garden of Earthly Delights: A heavy, thematic Euro for players who like dense planning.
- Terracotta Army: A thematic engine game that rewards careful planning.
- Space Base: A competitive building game with plenty of player interaction.
- Lords of Waterdeep: A worker placement game with shifting goals and plenty of table talk.
- Viscounts of the West Kingdom: A medieval Euro built around city growth and resource management.
- Scythe: A heavy engine game with negotiation and a dramatic tone.
- Ziya: A tactical Euro that rewards careful timing and engine building.
- Everdell: A card-driven engine builder that rewards clever combinations.
- Isle of Skye: A tile-laying Euro with plenty of planning depth.
- Golems of Raq: An engine-driven game with resource pressure and a strong theme.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"With engine building, hidden roles, and tactical trades, Deal with the Devil has a little bit of everything, but it's the careful and collective interplay of the deals which sets it apart. It plays best when players are open to negotiating and recognizing a fair price for their souls, but it never loses its Euro charm."
— Meeple University
"It's just, it's a very fragile Nish game. You need the four players, like, or nothing basically. But you need four people that are into games, you can't play this with casual players."
— The Broken Meeple
"It's not where you're trying to find the devil in the group. It's actually you're building a civilization, you're building your city, you're part of the city, so it's kind of like a city building game."
— Our Family Plays Games