Guards of Atlantis II Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Guards of Atlantis II
Guards of Atlantis II is a team-based, zero-luck board game that reviewers consistently frame as a tabletop take on the multiplayer online battle arena genre. Players control a single hero each, split into two teams, and push minions along the board toward the enemy base or wear down enemy heroes. The second edition is a rebuild of the original rather than a simple expansion. ON TABLE Board Games presents it as a continuation of the first version with changed rules and new content, and notes that the second edition adds a new way to win alongside the traditional push.
Reviewers agree on the core appeal. The game removes randomness from head-to-head play, so outcomes rest on reading the opponent and sequencing cards well. BoardGameBollocks praised how the limited hand keeps options manageable, while Board Games UnLocked called it a highly strategic and tactile game that is still among the simplest to learn. Where opinions diverge is on the pacing and the social rules. Some reviewers find the team dynamic rewarding, while others find the no-talk rule frustrating in practice. All You Can Board described the game as a strong fit for the MOBA style, though they were unsure whether repeated plays would keep it on their table long term.
Core Mechanics That Define Guards of Atlantis II
Simultaneous Reveal
Each round, every hero commits to a card face-down, and the cards are revealed together before any action resolves. All You Can Board described the hand as five cards from which four are played each round, with initiative values on each card deciding the order in which the revealed cards activate. Because nobody sees an opponent's card before locking in their own, each round becomes a read of what the other side intends. Reviewers say the cross-table guessing is what makes the game feel like a MOBA. A well-set-up card can be neutralized by a single counter-play that the player forgot the opponent held, which reviewers treat as a fair loss rather than bad luck.
Combat: Deterministic
Combat in Guards of Atlantis II resolves without dice or draws. Each card carries a sword value for attacks and a shield value for defense, and an attack succeeds or fails based on the numbers involved. ON TABLE Board Games explained that when a hero is attacked, a defending card is used as a shield, and a minion with no defense dies automatically when attacked. Every heroic action is therefore calculable before it is committed. Reviewers consider this the game's defining design choice. When a player loses, the reason is visible on the table, and that transparency is why many describe the game as one where you earn your victories.
The Guards of Atlantis II Experience
Tense, Attritional Push and Pull
Play feels like a tug-of-war. Each round offers four actions, and every attack a hero absorbs costs a card, so a hero who is double-teamed gradually runs out of options. All You Can Board noted the appeal of that exhaustion: a hero that has been pressured has fewer cards to answer with, and the reviewer described a moment where a powerful hero ran out of cards and was overwhelmed by the opponents' accumulated attacks. Reviewers describe the middle of a game as a constant calculation of how many cards each side has left, and that dwindling resource pool produces a steady build of pressure rather than sudden swings.
Chaotic Team Coordination
Because teammates cannot discuss their plays openly, the game asks two players to synchronize without speaking. Reviewers describe the result as chaos in the best sense. BoardGameBollocks pointed out that the rule prevents players from telling each other what to do, which creates the intended battlefield feel but also leads to misplays when partners forget the rule and start discussing their options anyway. Players who enjoy cooperative planning and bluffing with a partner tend to rate the experience highly, while players who prefer clear, uninterrupted control of their own decisions find the restriction awkward.
What Makes Guards of Atlantis II Stand Out
Hero Boards and Skill Progression
ON TABLE Board Games highlighted the hero boards as one of the most useful design features. Each board shows its skill levels on sliders, so a new player can compare heroes before choosing one. Leveling works through coins earned by defeating minions. Spending coins lets a hero discard a card from hand and draw two cards of the matching suit from the hero's deck, which keeps progression tied to in-game actions rather than a separate track. Reviewers say this gives each hero a distinct identity, and the second edition adds new heroes and skills to expand the roster.
A Faithful Translation of MOBA Feel
Many reviewers judge the game against its video game inspiration, and several feel it succeeds where other tabletop attempts stumble. All You Can Board said that many people consider Guards of Atlantis II the best attempt at MOBA style among board games and tabletop experiences, and compared its tension to playing Heroes of the Storm. Minions are handled with restraint. They do not walk along lanes. Instead, they sit in fixed spots and add or subtract from the attack and defense of nearby heroes. That approach keeps the heroes central to the game and avoids the bookkeeping that would otherwise slow a board game version.
Potential Drawbacks
The No-Talk Rule Is Easy to Break
The rule that teammates cannot discuss their plays is the most common criticism. BoardGameBollocks described it as a constant irritation because groups repeatedly fell back into talking through options. Reviewers who want a stricter teamwork experience may see this as a feature, but the rule's enforcement depends on the group, and a game that requires self-policing will not suit every table. Some reviewers suggest that groups agree on house rules before the first game to avoid mid-round arguments.
Longevity and Elimination Pacing
Reviewers are less certain about long-term replay value. Eliminated heroes sit out for a number of rounds, which can make a two-player or lopsided game feel slow once one side has the advantage. All You Can Board admitted that after a first play they liked the game, but they were unsure whether it would hold their interest after five or ten plays. The reviewer also noted that the game's appeal depends on having a stable group that plays regularly, since learning the heroes and their interactions takes time. Players who want a lighter, quicker game may find the commitment too high.
If You Enjoy Guards of Atlantis II
Players who enjoy Guards of Atlantis II's simultaneous reveal and hand-management tension will find similar satisfaction in Heroes of the Storm, the digital MOBA that reviewers use as the benchmark for the genre. For a tabletop option that keeps the team and lane focus, Cloudspire and Toy Battle offer a smaller-scale version of the same competitive rhythm, and Onward is a close relative in the way it handles minion-driven skirmishes. Players who want a deterministic duel with cards at the center should look at Exceed. The original Guards of Atlantis is the natural next step for anyone who wants to compare the two editions directly, since the second edition builds on the first while changing its rules and heroes.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"If you know the first version of Guards of Atlantis you already know what's new in the second edition. This game first of all has a new way to win, in addition to pushing the lines, players can kill heroes until their spawn tokens are exhausted."
— ON TABLE Board Games
"It is a highly strategic and tactile game while also being one of the simplest games to learn."
— Board Games UnLocked
"The fact that you've only got five cards in your hand at any given time means that the options are relatively easy to remember."
— BoardGameBollocks