If Wishes Were Fishes! Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About If Wishes Were Fishes!
If Wishes Were Fishes!, the economic game published by Rio Grande Games, sits in an unusual spot in reviewer discussions. Its cartoony, almost childlike artwork leads reviewers to expect something light, and those who have played it tend to describe a considerably more substantial game underneath. Adam Porter, who discusses game design on the Adam in Wales - Board Game Design channel, says they find the gameplay really rewarding and reports that it has always gone over well with the gamers they have introduced it to.
Reviewers largely agree on the core strength of the design but differ on how the game lands on a first impression. Adam in Wales ranks it at number 85 on a personal top 100 list and calls it an overlooked title they return to every few months. Chairman of the Board, by contrast, played it only once before reviewing it in a ranked list and placed it eighth, rating it roughly four or five out of ten. That channel's reviewer was careful to say the score might be low balling the game and that a second or third session could change the verdict.
The game's commercial history also comes up in discussion. Adam Porter notes that it ended up in bargain bins and discount stores after release and never received the recognition it deserves, and suspects consumers were confused by the gap between how the box looks and how the game plays. Adam in Wales had a similar experience, finding a copy in a discount store in the UK where it had been sold off cheaply. The overall picture is of a game with a devoted following despite limited mainstream success.
Core Mechanics That Define If Wishes Were Fishes!
Card Drafting With Worm Payments
Players draw cards from a central display, and the cards further up the display carry a cost. Adam in Wales explains that players may have to pay to take cards further up the chain, and the currency is a set of large rubbery worms that function as coins. Chairman of the Board describes the cost as an incentive building mechanism: the more cards a player wants to skip over, the more worms must be left on the cards that were passed. Those worms then go to the player who collected the skipped cards, giving that player more currency for future purchases. Adam Porter calls the drafting a clever central mechanism that gives the game much of its rewarding feel.
Stock Prices and Market Manipulation
The economic core of the game revolves around shares in different types of fish. Adam in Wales describes the fish as having individual stock prices, and players adjust those prices through the way they play. Chairman of the Board explains that the wish abilities let players move meeples around a rondelle that raises or lowers the value of the fish already on the board. Selling is constrained, because each type of fish can only be sold until the market closes for that type. Unsold stock is placed into a separate pool that can cost points if a player holds the most of it. Adam Porter sums up the economic loop as a buy low, sell high affair.
The If Wishes Were Fishes! Experience
Strategic Timing Tension
Reviewers describe the central feeling as the pressure of choosing the right moment to cash in. Chairman of the Board talks about wanting to cash in cards when they are worth the most and to strike when the iron is hot, which captures the sense that every turn is a decision about whether to sell now or wait. Because a market closes once a fish type has been sold enough, the timing decisions carry real stakes. Players who want to score heavily must anticipate both the value of their fish and the moves of opponents who may close the market first.
Charming Incongruity
The second quality reviewers highlight is the odd pleasure of a serious economic game wrapped in a whimsical package. Adam in Wales finds the presentation amusing, with its weird cartoony artwork and rubbery worm currency, and argues that the gameplay is far from childlike. Adam Porter describes the same tension as a disconnect between the apparent promise of the box and the genuine experience of playing it. Reviewers often come away enjoying the contrast, even as they question why the designers made the choices they did.
What Makes If Wishes Were Fishes! Stand Out
A Card Drafting Economy Built on Worms
Reviewers consistently single out the way the worm currency and the card drafting interact. Chairman of the Board praises the passing around of worms between players, which means that skipping cards creates future buying power for opponents as well as the drafter. The result is a flow of resources that rewards patience and punishes careless drafting, and it gives the game an engaging rhythm that reviewers find satisfying.
Replayability Over Years
Adam in Wales describes returning to the game regularly over several years and says it has never fallen out of favor. Rather than treating it as a novelty, Adam in Wales reaches for it when deciding what to play on a given evening. Adam Porter similarly reports that the game has always been well received by new players, which suggests the depth holds up beyond a single session.
Potential Drawbacks
Presentation Sets the Wrong Expectation
The most prominent criticism concerns the box art and components. Adam in Wales asks who the game is for, observing that it looks like a children's game but is too involved for children, while the rubbery worm currency seems to confuse the audience. Adam Porter argues that the fish look as if they were copied from a children's picture book, and that the artwork leads buyers to expect a light experience they will not get. The reviewers still acknowledge that the gameplay itself is solid, so the criticism is about marketing and expectations rather than the mechanics.
Market Rules and Mixed First Impressions
Chairman of the Board raises concerns about the restriction on selling the same type of fish repeatedly, which limits how a player can use a strong market position. The reviewer also found the first play less impressive than expected and felt the early experience was harder to grasp. Those reactions are presented as first impressions, and the channel expects that deeper familiarity may change its view, but the rule set is still identified as a reason the game does not feel instantly rewarding for everyone.
If You Enjoy If Wishes Were Fishes!
Adam in Wales names Arcadia as another game that shares the stock and market feel of If Wishes Were Fishes!. Adam in Wales describes Arcadia as a game about holding stocks and controlling the value of items, with polyomino-style building and a central castle that sets seal values. Players who enjoy the market manipulation in If Wishes Were Fishes! will find a similar satisfaction in Arcadia's investment decisions and its clever scoring structure.
Chairman of the Board compares Bloxon, also known as Linko, to Scout and describes it as a breezy card game with cleverness that fits the same category. Players who enjoy the tension of holding and releasing cards in If Wishes Were Fishes! may find a comparable pleasure in the risk and timing of Bloxon, which the channel recommends for players who like light card games with meaningful choices.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"I find the gameplay really rewarding and it's always gone over well with all the other gamers that I've introduced it to. It is not, however, a game for children, so why do the fish look like they've been copied straight out of a child's picture book?"
— Adam Porter, Adam in Wales - Board Game Design
"The way your drafting cards is fairly interesting. You can using that incentive building mechanism where the further, the more cards you want to skip over, you'd have to leave these worms on them, and the worms are another way of cutting points. I do like that kind of passing around economy of the different worms and trying to cash in the cars when they're worth the most and strike when the iron is hot."
— Chairman of the Board
"This is one I frequently come back to. A couple of times a year I'll be looking for what should I play, there we go, if wishes were fishes, and I've been doing that for years. It's one that's never fallen out of favor with me."
— Adam in Wales - Board Game Design