Kelp: Shark vs Octopus Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Kelp
Reviewers tend to treat Kelp: Shark vs Octopus as one of the standout two-player releases of 2024. Designed by Carl Robinson, with art by Weberon Santiago and published by Wonderbow Games, the game drew praise from a range of channels. Board Stupid ranked it just behind Ironwood on its list of modern two-player games and gave it the best theme award in its year-end show, while its community voters placed it near the top of their own ballot. The Game Boy Geek described it as an asymmetric game in which the octopus player works with Strateggo-style hidden blocks.
Not every reviewer came away impressed. Board Games UnLocked put Kelp on its list of disappointing games from 2024, and its host said the reviews they had heard described the octopus as heavily favored. In early plays, the channel found the octopus side far too strong, although it acknowledged that its experience was limited and that more time with the game might change its view. This is the one sustained critical take in this set, and it centers on balance rather than on the game's theme or production.
Core Mechanics That Define Kelp
Hidden Movement for the Octopus
The octopus player works from a board of face-down blocks that only they can see, while the shark sees only what has been revealed. Kovray explained that the octopus must reveal blocks to pay for most cards, and that hide cards let the octopus turn revealed blocks back over. Board Stupid described the octopus as playing hide and seek, using its deck to create decoys and to shift its hideouts around the map. The Game Boy Geek pointed out that the blocks hide more than the octopus itself, since food and traps are mixed in, so a strike at the wrong block can hurt the shark.
Deck Building Against Dice Bag Building
The two sides are built on different engines, which is central to how Kelp plays. The octopus draws from four colored card piles, and learn cards add new cards to its discard or new blocks to the board. The shark instead builds a dice bag, rolls dice to swim, search, and strike, and spends leftover energy to buy cards from the board. Kovray noted that buying cards and spending energy fills the shark's hunger track, which ends the game if it fills. The Game Boy Geek summed up the split as one player playing a deck building card game while the other plays a bag building game.
The Kelp Experience
Tension That Runs the Whole Game
Board Stupid's two-player coverage kept returning to how tight the game feels. Its reviewers said the whole game is so tense, and that both sides stay engaging from start to finish. The final confrontation is where that tension peaks. Board Stupid described the showdown as a rock-paper-scissors style choice, and noted that once the octopus escapes, the next showdown shrinks, leaving the shark with what they called a 50/50 chance of getting eaten.
Asymmetry That Feels Like Two Different Games
Board Stupid argued that the two players are doing completely different things, and compared the octopus to the rebels in Star Wars Rebellion, always feeling that they might not make it, while the shark feels like the Empire, where you are very powerful. Board Stupid also noted that you can swap sides and play again, which is a fitting payoff for a game where each seat plays so differently.
What Makes Kelp Stand Out
A Theme Built on Real Animal Behavior
Board Stupid gave Kelp its best theme prize, reasoning that the shark has to eat the octopus, the octopus has to escape, and the mechanics keep both players inside that story. The Game Boy Geek connected the design to the animals themselves, with the octopus channeling camouflage and deception and the shark patrolling the water to hunt its prey. Board Stupid also pointed to the nature of the ending, where the octopus can simply wait until the shark is starving and leaves. Their remark that nature is hardcore sums up why the theme feels honest rather than decorative.
Art and Production Above Its Price
Board Stupid called the art by Weberon Santiago some of their favorite work, and praised the production from the box to the last card. Board Stupid placed Kelp on its all-time top 40 list, citing its beautiful production as one of the strongest reasons to pick it up.
Potential Drawbacks
Balance Concerns Around the Octopus
The main criticism comes from Board Games UnLocked, which argued that the octopus side was overpowered in its experience. Its host described the octopus as far too powerful in the early plays, and said that the reviews they had heard tended to tilt the same way. Board Stupid, by contrast, described both sides as super fun to play, so reviewers disagree about whether the balance holds up over repeated games.
Dice Luck and an Unclear Shark Strategy
The Game Boy Geek noted that shark abilities exist to mitigate luck from the dice, but Board Games UnLocked was not convinced those tools were enough. Its host said the actual strategy for the shark could not be pinned down beyond getting lucky, and preferred randomness drawn from a deck to randomness from rolling dice. Board Stupid called Kelp a one-versus-one game, so groups looking for a larger table will need something else.
If You Enjoy Kelp
- Strateggo: The Game Boy Geek compared the octopus's hidden blocks to Strateggo, a bluffing game of hidden pieces and deduction that shares Kelp's sense of attacking something you cannot fully see.
- Raptor: Board Games UnLocked described Kelp as sitting in the same vein as Raptor, a one-versus-one asymmetric game where one side hunts and the other evades.
- Pagan: Board Games UnLocked noted that Pagan is a one-versus-one game where both sides play completely differently, which is the same asymmetry that drives Kelp.
- 7 Wonders Duel: Board Stupid credited Lord of the Rings Duel for Middle-earth with building on the Seven Wonders Duel system, so players who enjoy that engine will recognize the foundation.
- The Hunt: Board Games UnLocked grouped it with Kelp among one-versus-one asymmetric games that reviewers were excited about, while noting the dice combat that some players found hard to accept.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"The whole way is so tense. Both sides are super fun to play. Yeah, I love Kelp Shark."
— Board Stupid
"As you may have noticed you as the octopus player can see the blocks while the shark player will not until they've been revealed on your turn."
— kovray
"The actual strategy is other than getting lucky."
— Board Games UnLocked