Navajo Wars Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Navajo Wars
Navajo Wars, the GMT Games solitaire wargame designed by Joel Toppen, gets a mixed reception on the surface but a fairly consistent verdict underneath: it is hard to learn, and reviewers who stick with it tend to come away impressed. The Box of Delights channel placed it in a personal top 20 countdown and framed its difficulty around genre mashing, describing it as "states of Siege meets Resource Management meets war game." That same review called the game "a beast" to pick up, while still concluding that the effort is worth it.
The Beyond Solitaire channel, which ran several solo war game list discussions with Brandt Gillery of the Armchair Dragoons, treated Navajo Wars as an accessible entry point for players who are new to historical solo play. In one of those discussions, Brandt argued that it deserves more attention than it gets, while the group also noted that the game is not a slam dunk for players who want a light, story-driven experience. Across these videos, the tone is respectful rather than enthusiastic, with reviewers stressing that the game rewards patience.
Reviewers also observed that the game's standing in community polls has been rising. Beyond Solitaire noted that Navajo Wars received a reprint and climbed noticeably in its most recent list, and Brandt pointed out that the game had moved up the rankings over the preceding years. Several reviewers attributed part of that movement to the game being designed for solo play from the start, which makes it easier for players to find a satisfying solo experience.
Core Mechanics That Define Navajo Wars
Siege Defense Meets Resource Management
The central tension in Navajo Wars comes from defending a position against mounting pressure while managing limited resources. Box of Delights describes the game as a blend of familiar parts, with the siege-style defense and the resource economy sitting side by side. Decisions revolve around how much to invest in the community's development and how much to hold back for threats that are closing in. Reviewers compared this to the tower defense format that many solo wargames use, because the enemy forces approach in a predictable way that the player must prepare for.
Two elements in particular create the game's most memorable swings. The ceremony cards offer tempting options that can backfire if the player waits too long to use them, and the victory point checks can either consolidate a strong position or force a sudden shift in priorities. Box of Delights emphasized that these moments are what make the middle of a session feel alive.
The Enemy Instruction Function
The second core system is the enemy instruction function, which determines how opposing forces act each turn. Box of Delights singled it out as a particularly clever solution to a common solo design problem. Rather than making the player look up long sequences of charts, or letting pure randomness decide everything, the system selects enemy actions in a way that keeps the opposition responsive without becoming tedious to run. Reviewers credited designer Joel Toppen for this approach, which is one of the reasons the game holds up for players who dislike chart-heavy solo systems.
The Navajo Wars Experience
A Punishing Struggle That Feels Earned
Navajo Wars feels like a hard fight, and reviewers describe the satisfaction of surviving as the main reward. Paul Wright, speaking on a Beyond Solitaire video, recalled finally winning the game during a business trip to Argentina and cheering loudly in a hotel room while the locals had no idea why. That story captures the way reviewers talk about the game: wins feel hard-won, and the sense of accomplishment is strong precisely because the game pushes back. Beyond Solitaire similarly described the solo experience as one of playing the Navajo as they fend off the colonial powers, a framing that keeps the stakes personal even when the mechanics are abstract.
Puzzling Out the Big Picture
Box of Delights described the early hours of play as a process of decoding. The rulebook walks players through each step in fine detail, but it does not explain how the pieces fit together, and the board state can be difficult to read at first. Reviewers said that the real understanding comes from playing, as players discover the chain of cause and effect that drives toward a win. Once that chain clicks, the game becomes far more rewarding, which is why reviewers often recommend pushing through the early confusion rather than abandoning the game after a single session.
What Makes Navajo Wars Stand Out
A Historical Span Rarely Covered by Wargames
Brandt Gillery highlighted the historical scope as the game's most distinctive feature. The campaign covers a long arc, beginning with the arrival of the Spanish and continuing through the Mexican period and into the American era, just before the Civil War. Brandt described the game as one that stands out because it presents the conflict from the perspective of the Navajo, something reviewers felt was rare for a solo wargame. Paul Wright made a similar point when discussing unusual titles, noting that Navajo Wars departs from typical wargames both in its perspective and in its mechanics.
Rules That Reward Commitment
Box of Delights praised the rules as carefully considered. The reviewer acknowledged that the mix of genres can tangle a newcomer, but argued that the effort pays off with a rewarding experience. Beyond Solitaire also noted that Navajo Wars includes a two-player mode, which adds flexibility for groups who want to play together. Brandt observed that the game seems designed for solo play first and then extended to two players, a choice that some reviewers found to be a good fit for the design.
Potential Drawbacks
A Steep Learning Curve
The most consistent criticism is that Navajo Wars is difficult to learn. Box of Delights argued that the mechanisms are familiar on their own but unfamiliar in combination, so it is not immediately clear what the player should be doing or why. PSzTR, the Beyond Solitaire video that covered the lower half of the list, described the game as a very heavy experience with a substantial rules burden. Reviewers agree that new players should expect a slow start, and that the game may not suit players looking for a quick, low-commitment session.
Reading the Board
Box of Delights raised a presentation issue that other reviewers did not stress as much. The board is attractive, but the game uses fairly ordinary-looking chits, and that combination made the game state harder to read for the reviewer. Players who prefer a clear visual language for tracking pressure and resources may find this frustrating early on. Reviewers who got past the initial phase generally said the board became easier to interpret with experience.
If You Enjoy Navajo Wars
Players who enjoy Navajo Wars's blend of siege defense and resource management will find a natural companion in Comancheria, also designed by Joel Toppen. A PSzTR reviewer described Navajo Wars as the predecessor of Comancheria and said they consider Comancheria the stronger of the two, so it is a logical next step for players who want more of the same style.
- Pax Pamir: Brandt noted that Navajo Wars has an area control feel similar to Pax Pamir, and suggested that Euro-leaning players may find that familiar territory a good way to start. Players who enjoy building position while managing competing priorities will recognize the satisfaction of contesting space.
- D-Day at Omaha Beach: Beyond Solitaire reviewers described this classic as brutally hard and demanding to learn, yet deeply rewarding. Players who enjoy the uphill fight of Navajo Wars, and who accept a steep learning curve in exchange for a memorable struggle, will likely appreciate the same commitment.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"The rules are very well considered and although the mix of genres will tangle you up as you start out it ends up delivering a very rewarding experience like the best cocktail but with a kick."
— Box of Delights
"Navajo Wars is definitely one they should check out. It's got a wide scope of History because it starts with the Spanish coming to North America all the way up through you know right before the Civil War with the US."
— Beyond Solitaire
"I was so thrilled because that game is tough that, you know, I was cheering and I'm sure the Argentines in the hotel had no clue what this strange American was cheering about."
— Beyond Solitaire