Skip to main content
Brass: Birmingham box art

Brass: Birmingham

Game Info
Year
2018
Players
2-4
Age
14+
Playtime
120 min
Publisher
Roxley Games
Collection
Ratings
Mechanic profile
Percentile rank vs. all games
Vibe profile
How this game feels to play
Description

Brass: Birmingham is an economic strategy game sequel to Martin Wallace's 2007 masterpiece, Brass. Brass: Birmingham tells the story of competing entrepreneurs in Birmingham during the industrial revolution between the years of 1770 and 1870.

It offers a very different story arc and experience from its predecessor. As in its predecessor, you must develop, build and establish your industries and network in an effort to exploit low or high market demands. The game is played over two halves: the canal era (years 1770-1830) and the rail era (years 1830-1870). To win the game, score the most VPs. VPs are counted at the end of each half for the canals, rails and established (flipped) industry tiles.

Each round, players take turns according to the turn order track, receiving two actions to perform any of the following actions (found in the original game):

1) Build - Pay required resources and place an industry tile.
2) Network - Add a rail / canal link, expanding your network.
3) Develop - Increase the VP value of an industry.
4) Sell - Sell your cotton, manufactured goods and pottery.
5) Loan - Take a £30 loan and reduce your income.

Brass: Birmingham also features a new sixth action:

6) Scout - Discard three cards and take a wild location and wild industry card. (This action replaces Double Action Build in original Brass.)

Description

Brass: Birmingham is an economic strategy game sequel to Martin Wallace's 2007 masterpiece, Brass. Brass: Birmingham tells the story of competing entrepreneurs in Birmingham during the industrial revolution between the years of 1770 and 1870.

It offers a very different story arc and experience from its predecessor. As in its predecessor, you must develop, build and establish your industries and network in an effort to exploit low or high market demands. The game is played over two halves: the canal era (years 1770-1830) and the rail era (years 1830-1870). To win the game, score the most VPs. VPs are counted at the end of each half for the canals, rails and established (flipped) industry tiles.

Each round, players take turns according to the turn order track, receiving two actions to perform any of the following actions (found in the original game):

1) Build - Pay required resources and place an industry tile.
2) Network - Add a rail / canal link, expanding your network.
3) Develop - Increase the VP value of an industry.
4) Sell - Sell your cotton, manufactured goods and pottery.
5) Loan - Take a £30 loan and reduce your income.

Brass: Birmingham also features a new sixth action:

6) Scout - Discard three cards and take a wild location and wild industry card. (This action replaces Double Action Build in original Brass.)

Ask a Rules Question
All mentions
Browse transcript mentions, sentiments, pros/cons, mechanics, topics, quotes, and references.
Total mentions: 285
This page: 50
Sentiment: pos 36 · mix 3 · neu 3 · neg 1
Mentions per page
Showing 1–50 of 285
Video QbfUpKCTfXE Chairman of the Board Other at 15:36
Chairman of the Board - Brass: Birmingham video thumbnail
Click to watch at 15:36 · YouTube ↗
Pros
none
Cons
none
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • guests which is a great deduction game
  • cartographers pergamon uh karuba and Miyabi these are from the hobby uh habba line
  • the quacks of quettenberg I believe with one expansion inside
  • favorite of the Pharaoh so this is actually a Tom Lehmann um dice rolling game like a yahtzee variant but with loads of player powers and things you can acquire I'm surprised this one didn't take off because it actually has quite a lot of things that tend to be popular so maybe there is um you know this is going to be a bit of a sleeper and there might be a reprint or something which will inject some life into it
  • a Savannah Park hits a table table off and often for me
  • mysterium now this has my copy of detective Club in it as well um if you want a Dixit variant Style game um this is a kind of my go-to box
  • Marrakech concept which is another party game
  • first enroll which is an American football Style game
  • Sheriff of Nottingham this is the is it the first edition or second edition I think it's the first edition with the expansion
  • Ship Shape Can't Stop we have the bunk uh fantastic factories dice minor five minute mystery uh Cryptid tumble Town Martinique and psychic Pizza deliverers go to the ghost town which I didn't really like
  • get on board Patchwork Rapido which is brilliant um kind of pushy luck game
  • shanghai-en a heroba Hashi and next station London
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video hf1fCdgVWBw Chairman of the Board Top List at 5:43 sentiment: positive
Chairman of the Board - Brass: Birmingham video thumbnail
Click to watch at 5:43 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Absolutely phenomenal
  • Genius design
Cons
none
Thematic elements
  • Economic development
  • Industrial era (implied)
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • economic — An economic style game with resource utilization.
  • network building — Involves building and connecting industries.
  • Resource Management — Players utilize resources, including those of other players.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • these games are going to be in alphabetical order
  • this one takes worker dimension to a whole new space as you have a series of gears in these different parts of the board and they're all interconnected
  • this game really did blow me away
  • underwater cities might be the strongest example of an engine builder i have in my collection
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video vqpPmbP-dZA Chairman of the Board Other at 17:37 sentiment: positive
Chairman of the Board - Brass: Birmingham video thumbnail
Click to watch at 17:37 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • one of the best accessories
  • tactile
  • better to play with
  • easy to divide out
  • increase the enjoyment of the gaming experience
Cons
none
Thematic elements
  • Industrial Revolution
  • Birmingham
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Poker chips — Uses Iron Clays (poker chips) for money.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • um Arc Nova actually has a great solo mode as well and much like underwater cities the admin is next to nothing you're simply trying to do as well as you can over a fixed amount of rounds
  • I tend to like succin games I tend to love negotiation games um but this game is like you know it's like hence teeth you cannot find a copy anywhere very expensive you want if you want to get a copy so I'd love to see a reprint of it because I'd love to have it in my collection
  • there's simply a matter of you know availability that's the only reason why I want these games being reprinted
  • now I would say seven to eight times out of ten I would say yes no I play a lot of games I read a lot of rule books and I'm generally writes pretty you know 80 of the time if um if I read the rulebooks I think you know I'm probably going to enjoy this or I'm probably not going to enjoy this
  • um you know on paper I should love everything about guncomono it's got tile placement it's got um a bit of kind of uh Track Climbing it's got tiles on top of tiles little vertical stacking I love all those things but I found the game pretty boring um and it didn't really do it for me
  • um so yeah for me The Sweet Spot is about 200 but that would be absolutely ludicrous to some people some people it's 20 some people it's 50 some people have 500 games you know I could not think of anything worse than having 500 games in your collection for me that'll just be too daunting and I would feel a little bit suffocated by that
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video GTQADZt1z2E Chairman of the Board Review at 0:00 sentiment: positive
Chairman of the Board - Brass: Birmingham video thumbnail
Click to watch at 0:00 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Immersed from start to finish
  • Time flies by
  • Engaged in every decision
  • Mechanisms constantly running through head after play
  • Deep strategy that reveals itself over multiple plays
  • Fantastic engine building
  • Great income generation
  • Viable loan system for early game cash injection
  • Actions don't bleed away quickly
  • Turns feel significant
  • Interactive and passive player interaction
  • Scalability reflects player interaction well
  • Phenomenal aesthetics
  • High quality, robust components
  • Money looks great, cards look fantastic, player boards are useful
  • Remarkable design
  • Pacing is fantastic
  • Best of the best
Cons
  • Takes longer than the box states (60-120 mins, but initial games take longer)
  • Can be fiddly to set up the map at the beginning
  • Longer play time can be an obstacle to get to the table
Thematic elements
  • economic strategy
  • map of England
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • action selection — You're going to get two actions per turn. The actions you can do are scout, take a loan, develop, network, build, and sell.
  • Card Drafting — A big deck of cards which is going to be your driving force in the game. It really is a game of hand management.
  • Engine Building — Generating more and more points by flipping these buildings over and of course you are increasing your income track as well.
  • market — The market dictates the prices or the supply and demand of coal and steel.
  • network building — The network action is going to be how you're going to extend your network and connect cities to cities. It was is about building networks and building routes.
  • player interaction — Other players can use your resources. They can also upgrade your buildings. You can use some pretty cool things in order to kind of block people off for certain regions.
  • Resource Management — You've got this market here which dictates the prices or the supply and demand of coal and steel. Coal is going to need steel, steel is going to need coal. Everything needs money.
  • Set Collection — The cards have particular locations or resources/industries on them which dictates where or what you can build.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • I really enjoy the engine building style feel of things when you are generating more and more points by flipping these buildings over and of course you are increasing your income track as well.
  • The player interaction in Brass is mind-blowing actually.
  • Aesthetically this game looks phenomenal.
  • This game is remarkable from a design standpoint.
  • I'm so so impressed just completely enamored with how this game comes together to be honest.
  • This one comfortably gets my elite shield just the best of the best.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video Pi0kY4EnDqE Chairman of the Board Top List at 21:35 sentiment: positive
Chairman of the Board - Brass: Birmingham video thumbnail
Click to watch at 21:35 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
Extremely Positive
Pros
  • Regarded as one of the best board games ever
  • Economic style game
  • Builds a network
  • Lots of interaction
  • Deep strategy
  • Game of the month
  • Phenomenal, amazing, incredible game
Cons
none
Thematic elements
  • Industrial Revolution
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • action selection — Trying to offload coal.
  • economic — This one is another economic style game.
  • Market Speculation — Can use coal with other players, can use metal with other players.
  • network building — As you're building a network of initially canals and then trains.
  • Resource Management — Trying to sell these resources.
  • Set Collection — Flipping those buildings over and trying to match them with a certain industries.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Glass road by Uwe Rosenberg so this is one of Uwe Rosenberg's lighter games it's still very euro it's a resource management and kind of card play style game
  • I love the resource management in this game because you have these resource wheels where when you collect a certain amount of resources you'll automatically generate other resources which can be a real taxing decision to make and a hard thing to manage
  • And so much replayability because there are a ton of tiles in this game to make every game feel different
  • Maharaja so this is another 2021 game a recent kickstarter and it's a re-implementation of maharaja um from kramer and kising from years and years ago but this one has some tweaks on it um some redesigns and some um you know some updates by simone luciani
  • I love the uh variability and the player powers in this one
  • This one is modern art so I'm a big fan of auction games and this one is the quintessential auction game I suppose as you are constantly starting new auctions trying to acquire these cards of different artists
  • It's got this real autonomy and this real kind of manipulation of the game as you are constantly trying to get the most popular artists acquire their cards but of course they're going to be worth more money so you've got to manage your money to get those artists in the first place
  • Extremely streamlined extremely streamlined game lots of fun here has a nice party vibe but still with some deep gameplay
  • Fruticular now fruticular is um probably one of the biggest surprises of the year for me
  • However the gameplay is fantastic
  • It's a real nice economic puzzle
  • Because the gameplay is rock solid
  • Santa maria now santa maria I suppose it's pretty natural to think I would like this game this one is a dice drafting game
  • This is a real spatial puzzle here that I find extremely satisfying
  • You can end up taking some really meaty terms if you line up all your buildings properly
  • Very accessible but still some deep decisions here and fun from start to finish in three very simple very digestible rounds
  • Chinatown is another streamlined game so pure in its mechanisms
  • But the trick of this game is that at the start of each round kind of randomly as well sound semi randomly you're drafting for these buildings and you're lying your player pieces all these tokens down on these different buildings to show that you are the owner of those buildings
  • The negotiation in this game is absolutely mind-blowing it's phenomenal
  • Definitely the best negotiation game I've ever played
  • Phenomenal game
  • Brass Birmingham so brass Birmingham is regarded as one of the best ball games ever this one is another economic style game
  • It really is a so much interaction embedded in this game
  • So much depth in this game that I can't cover in a short clip like this
  • Spoiler alert I absolutely love this game
  • Certainly my game of the month
  • Phenomenal amazing just incredible game
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video vLkbQOf3SpU Chairman of the Board Analysis at 4:58 sentiment: positive
Chairman of the Board - Brass: Birmingham video thumbnail
Click to watch at 4:58 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Allows for finding new strategies
  • Enjoyable even when not fully understood
  • Lots to offer
Cons
  • Complex, host admits to not fully understanding it
Thematic elements
  • Economic
  • Industrial Revolution
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • economic engine building — upgrade these buildings to get victory points and money income.
  • Resource Management — try and manage these resources.
  • Route Building — you're basically trying to connect these different routes together.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • this is for the second half of january 2022. so the first half of january was generally pretty good at playing all new games that i got over the christmas period in the second half of january i've got a lot of opportunity to play some old favorites so this is the talk through of those favorites.
  • so it's a really cool um kind of push and pull you know how long do you want to use those powers or when do you want to catch them and get rid of them for points
  • this one i consider a very much unappreciated game that nobody talks about i never hear anybody cover this one.
  • i think it's got staying power power because it is so clean such an easy to understand concept but the actual twists in the game you know those sandstorms are really enjoyable
  • This one is a pretty light and accessible civilization style game card driven
  • but i love the tech trees in this game as you are you know one thing leads to another
  • this one fits a really nice gap of being a pretty involved and satisfying civilization style game but with a very low rules overhead
  • the only thing that i'm slightly concerned about is the replayability
  • what it does it does well and it is a recommendation for me i think this one is terribly overlooked
  • this one is by ryan quincy himself and this one might be my favorite route building game maybe ever
  • i often talk about on the channel games with agonizing decisions this one has that in spades
  • what a brilliant game this is
  • it's so pure so clean loads of ways to score all of them are good all of them inviting interesting player powers you can go for
  • this is a top tier for him
  • be on the lookout for this one being on the rating changes and going upwards because um this game is phenomenal and i love it
  • quite a few games here slightly on the heavier side of things which is nice
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video mMx_UvBKAo0 Chairman of the Board Top List at 9:15 sentiment: positive
Chairman of the Board - Brass: Birmingham video thumbnail
Click to watch at 9:15 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Highly regarded euro and economic game.
  • Features interconnected gameplay where player actions impact each other.
Cons
none
Thematic elements
  • Economic growth and industry building
  • Age of industry in England
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • economic engine building — Flipping tiles to generate points and income as industries are developed.
  • network building — Building routes and linking industries on the map of England.
  • player interaction — Potentially getting in the way of opponents and making them use your resources.
  • Resource Management — Managing resources like coal and iron, and how they are used and impact the market.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • we're really getting into the best of the best of the best
  • The more I play it, the more I think the answer is certainly yes. This is tremendous.
  • I think this is probably a prime example of that out of all of his designs one of his most underrated gems.
  • Everything just connects together well.
  • This game is an absolute delight to play.
  • It really is a brain burner.
  • It has this really dynamic flow of resources throughout the game.
  • All the different parts of the game come together harmoniously.
  • This is a bit of a head trip at times.
  • It really is remarkable and I'm really surprised this game isn't as popular as I think it could be.
  • It really does show how great of a design this one is.
  • This game is certainly amongst the best.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video 8eN1sM7OpFU Chairman of the Board Discussion at 10:20 sentiment: positive
Chairman of the Board - Brass: Birmingham video thumbnail
Click to watch at 10:20 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Best experience so far
  • Enjoyed every play
  • Fun to reveal and discover mistakes
  • Shines at four players
  • Player managed to win despite money struggles
Cons
  • Resource system not intuitive to explain initially
  • Takes time for the penny to drop
Thematic elements
  • Economic development and network building
  • Industrial Revolution England
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • action selection — Choosing actions like building, networking, developing, and selling.
  • network building — Building industries and connecting them via canals and railways.
  • Resource Management — Managing coal, iron, beer, and money.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • I still love this little back and forth game about playing cards at the right time manipulating things to your favor and pressuring your opponent to withdraw from the battle
  • if you like these tactical little two-player games this one is so clever and i love the way the cards work with each other
  • this is a pretty simple little kind of poker variant I suppose as you are trying to control these flags by playing these cards
  • the hand management in this game is so good you need to pace yourself and try to formulate how
  • it's become so bloated now especially to get the optimal experience because the base game alone isn't the best and you do need a few expansion modules
  • it becomes so sprawling there's little bits everywhere that it has kind of tarnished the game for me a bit
  • the gameplay i think is great it's a lot of fun it's um very interesting as you can kind of allocate these dice as you see fit
  • it's just becoming a bit too cumbersome for me to stop me enjoying it as much as i could and preventing it getting to the table
  • this is the second time i've played galaxy trucker and i would admit i did enjoy it more the first time because it was all new to me it was all new and exciting but i still don't dislike this one it's pretty quick it's chaotic it's frantic but the idea of just constructing this ship as you as you see fit i'm doing the best of what you've got and seeing how where there's the storm it's a good fun concept
  • we ordered absolutely terrible on this one we all got very few points and every single round our ships got annihilated which is all part of the fun of course
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video XHOsthNh-3E Chairman of the Board Top List at 12:30 sentiment: positive
Chairman of the Board - Brass: Birmingham video thumbnail
Click to watch at 12:30 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • deserves its hype
  • mind-blowing depth and decisions
  • brilliant design
Cons
  • difficult to master
Thematic elements
  • economic
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • market — I love the kind of the free markets in this game and how that supply and demand works
  • network building — as you are building up a network of trains or I believe it's canals as well
  • Resource Management — loads of decisions on how you're going to manage your hand of cards when you're going to do things how you're going to manage your resources what you're going to invest in
  • Tile Placement — building up a network of trains or I believe it's canals as well and then you are trying to shift resources from these tiles or build up these chains of of resources in order to upgrade your buildings to start generating a points engine
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • So actually only one of these games came out in 2021 and the rest of them are from years you know years past and years gone by but I haven't hadn't have an opportunity to play them until this year.
  • This one is brilliant.
  • This is a real rich experience.
  • I really do love this clean um precise engine building engine that this game offers.
  • I like this clean work replacement
  • so this game is a pretty involved economic style game as you are building up a network of trains or I believe it's canals as well and then you are trying to shift resources from these tiles or build up these chains of um of resources in order to upgrade your buildings to start generating a points engine
  • I love the kind of the free markets in this game and how that supply and demand works where if you can build these chains to the particular resources you can start getting money you can use other players resources but bear in mind you could be helping them from doing so
  • this game has probably one of the the biggest followings and biggest hype trains behind it
  • when a game has that level of hype and I get to the table and I think yeah this deserves it that's you know it's rare for me that that happens and brass birmingham is one of those games that achieves that
  • what it offers is just mind-blowing to me so many things to try loads of decisions on how you're going to manage your hand of cards when you're going to do things how you're going to manage your resources what you're going to invest in
  • brilliant design absolutely phenomenal that is brass birmingham at number two
  • this one is another economic style game this one's pretty involved and has some work of placement in it but I wouldn't say work replacement was the main focus of this game
  • it really is how that game map of the board into or how it works and how how you're going to utilize that the current board state how you're going to cut other players off and how you're going to capitalize on opportunities that become available
  • this is a game about converting sorry water into energy and also trying to get points
  • the board is basically a mountain scape and with all these different kind of basins of water and every round a number of these raindrops or water drops are going to fall and flow down the mountain however you want to be making sure that you're building these dams so that you can capture that water and convert that water through conduits into power stations
  • somebody might build say a damn down here and capture all the water but then I might decide you know what I'm going to invest in building it down further up the mountain and capture that water before it gets to this player and so it's pretty cutthroat it's very in your face and you have to be a bit of a shark in order to be good at this game
  • I've never really played a game like this it is so different to anything else out there
  • I love the resource management in this game as you are using all these different kind of machinery to build new dams to build new conduits and power stations however when you build them those resources are tied up for a certain amount of time
  • there's a whole new dimension of time management in this game as well which just blows my mind
  • it's my number one and this one did extremely well in my top 50 games of all time if you want to check that out this one came in the top 10
  • one of the best games I've ever played
  • I love it when games are different and unique and um barrage certainly is that
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video uaJdkUEVA7E Chairman of the Board Top List at 0:43 sentiment: positive
Chairman of the Board - Brass: Birmingham video thumbnail
Click to watch at 0:43 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Shared economy works well.
  • Restrictive hand of cards prevents overwhelm but provides enough options.
  • Masterpiece of a design.
Cons
  • Host is terrible at the game.
Thematic elements
  • economic
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • action selection — Restrictive hand of cards so you're not overwhelmed with options but you do have enough
  • Hand Management — as you are managing this hand of cards in order to establish this network of railways and build buildings on the map
  • network building — in order to establish this network of railways and build buildings on the map
  • Resource Management — you have to be able to chain these buildings to these relevant areas on the edge of the map in order to flip them over and start generating points but you can also build buildings which will come hand in hand with resources
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Barrage is another pretty involved game but not so much in terms of its rules overhead more so in terms of the consequences to your actions with this one because everything you do matters in this game.
  • It is just an absolutely genius design again so logical in the way it's put together.
  • I was mind blown when I played this the first time every time I played it since I just love it just as much.
  • This is the final game by steffenfeld on my top 100 definitely been the most you know frequent designer here.
  • That mancala is the best I've ever seen a man Carly used before the game is genius and I just absolutely adore it.
  • El Grande is considered to be the textbook you know the Benchmark the grandfather of all area majority games.
  • It's one of those games where if you added anything it would make the game worse if you took away anything it would make the games worse and for me those perfectly engineered games are the ones that really do hold up and stand the test of time.
  • El Grande just a brilliantly put together a game I can't give it enough you know praise it's my number one.
  • I played nearly a thousand games now and none of them are as good as El Grande.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video j-lv3ETUJGk Chairman of the Board Analysis at 0:38 sentiment: positive
Chairman of the Board - Brass: Birmingham video thumbnail
Click to watch at 0:38 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Mechanically an absolute triumph
  • Shared resources and network building are really good design
  • Rules are pretty simple once resource niggles are out of the way
Cons
  • Length (2.5 hours)
  • The people I play it with don't enjoy it as much as I do
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • network building — the network building I think it is just a a really good design
  • shared resources — I love the way um everything works here the the shared resources
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • I think the game mechanically is an absolute Triumph
  • the length you know more and more often or or less and less often I'm having the desire to play longer games
  • it does really Peak at um at three or four players
  • it's one of my favorite games of all time
  • if you like your little two-player cerebral card games this one is a great option
  • I think it's a a work of art
  • it's going to be pretty difficult to knock this one off my top two player game of the year
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video y6fwcHyItT0 Chairman of the Board Discussion at 10:32 sentiment: positive
Chairman of the Board - Brass: Birmingham video thumbnail
Click to watch at 10:32 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
none
Cons
none
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • CH has asked what themes would you like to see more of uh in board games and this is going to be a pretty boring answer um because I love medieval themed games I love Renaissance style games all those traditional Euro trading the medit Mediterranean
  • nerdington has asked uh why do I hate SCI sci-fi themes uh so much um it's not like I hate them I don't hate them they just again they leave me feeling very numb and cold um I just don't have any dra draw or appeal to them or they don't appeal to me at all
  • for me some of the most replayable games are games that are always the same games like Babylonia games like raw you're never chopping and changing me modules or adding new cards in they're always the same but for me the desire to come back to them is so high because it has that depth to complex complexity ratio and those tactical decisions mixed with the um strategic decisions and always getting kind of reacting on the Fly and reacting to the board State
  • all my best friends play board games so that's great um my girlfriend started playing board games um my family all play board games as well
  • looking at my collection I think there's one definitive Tire placement game that is Head and Shoulders Above the Rest and that is Glen Mo 2 Chronicles
  • when you're talking about a balanced board game I want to go into the board game knowing that I have a fair shot of winning the game I'm not going into it with a a ball and chain around my ankles and I'm going to be fighting an uphill battle that for me is a hug huge turnoff
  • for me it was about six out of 10 he's asked what are my thoughts on combo tastic games um I love them these are the kind of games that I do lean towards
  • when does a game stop being a filler game uh for me generally speaking not I'm not strict on it but you want to be setting up the game teaching the game um playing the game and packing up the game in around 30 minutes or or less of course um
  • if you're not aware of what in the year of the dragon is it's a stanfeld game that's probably one of his most polarizing because it's known for being so brutal and so punishing um I love it it's one of my favorite Fel games for me I write I rate it at 8 and a half out of 10
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video xh73C2r7ak0 All You Can Board Analysis at 1:11:09 sentiment: positive
All You Can Board - Brass: Birmingham video thumbnail
Click to watch at 1:11:09 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
Positive (with questions)
Pros
  • Calculations did not feel bothersome despite the game's complexity.
  • Enjoyed the strategic depth.
Cons
  • Reason why calculations are enjoyable in this specific game is unclear and requires further play.
Thematic elements
  • Industrial Development and Trade
  • Industrial Revolution England
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • economic engine — Players develop industries to generate income and victory points.
  • Hand Management — Players use cards to perform actions.
  • network building — Players build transport and industry networks.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Me going for it and then being like, oh, it was actually enough. Like it's they're so similar, but one I think reaps a reward because you're kind of taking that like leap of faith.
  • Randomness is I think the thing that I've come around to most in appreciating in board games compared to like when I first got in the hobby or like when I used to play chess back when I was a kid or teenager or whatever and now I don't really care to play chess because of how deterministic it is.
  • When you pull it off and it wasn't a known that's that's what it comes down to is kind of what I mentioned before about the Babylonian move was like I think either of you would have made the exact same move as me. But in can't stop. If I gamble and go to try and beat someone on that four track when the odds are against it and I actually take it from them and now they have to start at the bottom of other tracks and if I come back and win, I don't think other people might have made that move necessarily.
  • I'm realizing more and more that I really like games that have fewer points um and and they mean more and it's like harder to get them or when you get a point it feels like a bigger deal.
  • I think that maybe what I'm almost getting at is with like the feld stuff you were talking about is like I'd be curious to see and I'm not being I'm not a game designer so I don't know where the limitations are here, but I'd be curious to see like what is like a point salad feld game look like where it's point salad in terms of your options but not in terms of like the highest scores you're achieving.
  • And so when you get a star in Mario Party, it feels so big and and you steal a star, it feels so like insulting. It's just so good. And so that's kind of the feeling I'm missing in a lot of board games aside from like yeah, Dune Imperium bus stuff like that. I want to see more of it.
  • The one I the question that I'll throw to Braden, um, being someone who I know is, uh, because one of my reference games here is Dune Imperium and you being a Dune Dune fan, uh, is how do you personally feel? But overall, how do you like what do you think about this topic in terms of is it affected by a game that is, you know, only you only need 10 points to win versus a game that the scores are going to be in the 400s?
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video Q1nT25-p-AU BoardGameGeek Discussion at 15:19
BoardGameGeek - Brass: Birmingham video thumbnail
Click to watch at 15:19 · YouTube ↗
Pros
none
Cons
none
Thematic elements
  • Industrial England
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • "It's just great to get with people and move some meeples around, play some cards, put some tiles down, and just be present."
  • "I think that we all can make the board game community around us better, right?"
  • "Everyone's journey is different, right?"
  • "I can take some hits for you."
  • "You can literally give each other help. Or you can give them health, or you can give them supplies, just like in Pandemic, you can trade cards."
  • "I would rather work with someone than against them."
  • "Cooperative games have the ability to tell great stories, but sometimes you need to assert your dominance."
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video eS-DTI1uR4o Board Game Dad Analysis at 1:10 sentiment: neutral
Board Game Dad - Brass: Birmingham video thumbnail
Click to watch at 1:10 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
neutral
Pros
none
Cons
none
Thematic elements
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • I think it needs a category of its own.
  • hand-driven action selection. That's what I think makes this game really, really work.
  • The planning is very very interesting.
  • Unlike Lost Ruins of Arnak, there is no discovery.
  • Mage Knight is a very epic epic adventure game.
  • Does it make more sense to name a shelf after a pioneering game?
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video pfam9LFl-Ns Chairman of the Board Top List at 33:06 sentiment: positive
Chairman of the Board - Brass: Birmingham video thumbnail
Click to watch at 33:06 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
Positive
Pros
  • Immensely popular
  • Can use other players' resources
  • Using too many of other players' resources generates victory points
Cons
none
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Hand Management — As you are using a hand of cards to create kind of these industries.
  • network building — As you are using a hand of cards to create kind of these industries planning routes out building networks.
  • Root building — As you are using a hand of cards to create kind of these industries planning routes out building networks.
  • Shared infrastructure — I love this kind of shared infrastructure where you can actually use the resources of other players but using too many of them will actually start generating them victory points.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • RA - an absolute classic auction bidding Style game as you are placing these preset bids um on the board in order to claim a bunch of different tiles which will score you points in different ways
  • KEYFLOWER - a genius piece of design get a hybrid style game that does it to the highest kind of level of quality
  • CHINATOWN - everything in this game is up for negotiation you can trade your shop type you can train your trade your plots of land and of course you can trade money
  • BABYLONIA - very very elegant game streamlined to the core
  • TZOLK'IN - it really is like mini gamees Galore but I love how detailed you can be in the planning here and you know this is one of those games where the best player will always win because it's really going to brain burn your brain to play optimally
  • LA GRANJA - this is going back to the to the mid90s and it feels as fresh as anything on the market which is so surprising considering how many area control games have come out since this one
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video 2Lhj7Yf7Eyg Board Games UnLocked Top List at 39:08 sentiment: mixed
Board Games UnLocked - Brass: Birmingham video thumbnail
Click to watch at 39:08 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
mixed
Pros
  • Improved art and production compared to the original Brass
  • Streamlined gameplay
  • Scouting mechanic adds an interesting layer
  • Plays well with two players
Cons
  • Art style is not particularly creative
  • Game might not deserve its high BGG ranking
  • Played enough times, no longer feels fresh
Thematic elements
  • Industrial Revolution/Route Building
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Action Point Allowance System — you do a lot of the same stuff as the original game just a little more streamlined
  • network building — you're building stuff
  • Route Building — it's a like a route building game it's your trains tracks and all that stuff
  • scouting — you can scout in this one as an actual to get to look through the cards
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Manara which had always seen on Z talk about it and I was like you know what like I'm really into dexterity games now let me try and get a copy
  • this is a Cooperative dexterity game which is very fascinating
  • the stakes are higher because it's fully Cooperative so if you fail then the team fails and I I just love that tension
  • I love the the wacky shapes that these have the challenge cards that are creative and then even the semblance of strategy
  • Manara is like ah we can all be on the same team and everyone can be stressed together because oh man we got old slippery hands over here who's going to mess us over and it's all in good fun
  • Vindication yeah they got their their new their new Vindication coming out
  • it's beautiful the way it is I love the the way it's laid out you know and everything
  • it makes you think with certain with certain actions because you get three actions a turn you're you're manipulating your your potential energies and your conviction all that stuff
  • the exploration is neat you know because you're putting everything out there and you're moving between the hex's
  • it has a really cool ingame mechanism because it starts off with a few and then as you get to those coins as you go around the score track that adds a new one to a new game Deal to the deal
  • pretty much like I mean if you don't know what this is you're starting off as a piece of human garbage that's dropped off on a planet you're trying to redeem yourself and vindicate yourself
  • it's it's it's was a very unique game when it came out it's still unique to this day
  • Vindication I would I would travel with
  • this was in my top 10 I remember way back because it was when you were living in Clinton and we it came out and this was like number seven on my on my list
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video 4_Z5LaDL504 Board Games UnLocked Top List at 1:16:07 sentiment: positive
Board Games UnLocked - Brass: Birmingham video thumbnail
Click to watch at 1:16:07 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
Positive
Pros
  • Deep strategic gameplay
  • Satisfying economic engine
  • Improved from the original Brass
  • Good replayability with variable setup
Cons
  • Can feel unintuitive initially
  • Player interaction regarding shared resources can be frustrating
Thematic elements
  • Industry, trade
  • Industrial Revolution
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • action selection — you get two actions a turn
  • Income/Victory Points — then once the resources pop off then they flip and that's what gets you your income and your victory points
  • Industry — you're just trying to build up your area you know and be the most successful in it
  • network building — you're laying Trail rails and stuff
  • Resource Management — you can build build stuff you can pay in resources
  • scout action — this version adds a scout action because the original didn't know okay into it
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • this is Valeria card kingdoms
  • this is one of those ones I mean I love the art obviously
  • this is a tableau building game where you're uh you set out a grid from one through twelve
  • the cool thing about this is it happens on everybody's turn so so not just your role
  • to me this is the best of the Valeria games
  • there's just a lot for this game and it's there is and uh but it's still it's it's the replayability is awesome and it's it's an awesome one
  • my father's work is kind of an app driven scenario-based worker replacement game
  • the theme is extremely strong in this one especially around that kind of like Halloween time that mad scientists feel
  • it's also more personalized so each character is kind of like hey this is the route that I took
  • the production value is awesome for this
  • the only thing that's kind of weird about this one is it does have audio narration but only sometimes
  • really really good blend of of work replacement Resource Management and uh like kind of and storytelling
  • and that is ah Smash Up
  • this one's just one of those Classics you know
  • this was kind of you know the the mer the uniqueness of This was oh I can take two different things and just shuffle them together
  • the art is always cool Autumn
  • it's such a simplistic game really
  • this is just one of those games that's just always always going to be around just because it's the the replayability and stuff on this is just Bonkers
  • it's a game you're just not gonna take seriously
  • this has been a hit every single time I play it it's it's wonderful
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video NfpJquPivEI JestaThaRogue Top List at 0:33 sentiment: positive
JestaThaRogue - Brass: Birmingham video thumbnail
Click to watch at 0:33 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Deep strategic gameplay
  • Engaging network building
  • Satisfying economic engine building
  • Thematic immersion in the Industrial Revolution
Cons
  • Steep learning curve
  • Can feel punishing if early plays are poor
Thematic elements
  • Building industries, canals, and railroads
  • Industrial Revolution in England
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Action Point Allowance System — Players have a limited number of actions per turn.
  • auction/bidding — Players may bid for certain advantages or resources.
  • Hand Management — Players use cards to perform actions, requiring careful hand management.
  • network and route building — Players build canals and railways to connect locations.
  • Resource Management — Players manage coal, iron, beer, and money.
  • Set Collection — Building sets of industries can be beneficial.
  • Worker Placement — Players place workers to take actions on the board.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Brass Birmingham, a truly monumental game, a 9.5 out of 10, coming in at number three on my list.
  • Spirit Island, 9.4 out of 10, number four.
  • If you want a deep, strategic, cooperative game, this is it.
  • Nemesis, number five, a 9.3 out of 10.
  • Concordia, a 9.3 out of 10, number six.
  • The card play is so elegant.
  • Terraforming Mars, 9.2 out of 10, number seven.
  • It's just a really satisfying engine builder.
  • Hadrian's Wall, a 9.1 out of 10, number eight.
  • Ark Nova, number nine, 9.1 out of 10.
  • Gloomhaven, number 10, a 9 out of 10.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video Vf1B1jKWDPg Top List at 24:19 sentiment: positive
Brass: Birmingham video thumbnail
Click to watch at 24:19 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Perennial favorite at the host's table.
  • Friends have requested repeat plays.
  • Claims the top spot as BoardGameGeek's number one game of all time.
  • Reels participants in with tough hand management and evolving economic conditions.
  • Fun challenge with turn order dictated by spending.
  • Timing can make all the difference.
  • Satisfying mediumweight economic challenge.
Cons
none
Thematic elements
  • Economy, Industry, Supply and Demand
  • Industrial Age
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Area Control — Implied by the mention of cities and industry development.
  • economic — Evolving economic conditions and a dynamic Industrial Age Euro game of supply and demand.
  • Hand Management — Reels participants in with tough hand management.
  • Turn Order — The concept of a critical turn order being dictated by how much money the players spend each turn.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • starting with ier iur is a grower if ever there was any the more you play it the more you discover and the deeper it sinks its hooks into you
  • silos is freaking phenomenal
  • it's El Grande completely turned on its head
  • the most delightfully stressful hour of fun that a game can possibly provide
  • More than any other game we've published ego feels like a miracle
  • combines them into a perfect gaming Symphony
  • the ratio of game length to strategic depth is unmatched in the negotiation genre
  • the opportunities for player interaction cooperation bartering and betrayal are some of the most memorable in my hobbiest career
  • this is the biggest Riner kinesia crowdfunding project ever
  • it's an Avengers level event and board gaming celebration
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video hnaMWA7bQlE Board Stupid Top List at 1:00:39 sentiment: positive
Board Stupid - Brass: Birmingham video thumbnail
Click to watch at 1:00:39 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
highly positive
Pros
  • Tremendous game.
  • Deep and interesting gameplay.
  • Beautiful game.
  • Historically interesting.
  • Ever changing gameplay.
  • Great interaction.
  • S tier game.
Cons
  • Whether it should be number one on BGG is debatable.
Thematic elements
  • commerce and industry
  • Industrial Revolution era England
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • action selection — Players must manage their hand of cards to select actions.
  • network building — Features 'root building'.
  • player interaction — Has 'amazing interaction' and requires consideration of 'your neighbor has what you're going to need'.
  • Resource Management — Involves 'shared resources on the table' and 'hand management'.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • At number two, wow.
  • I find the game very bloated
  • I've never really been a fan of Arnova. Shoot me. I don't care.
  • I'm not having enough fun.
  • Brass Birmingham is my favorite game.
  • It is a tremendous game.
  • It is the number one game on BGG.
  • For me, this is 100% st game.
  • It has lots of amazing um interaction.
  • brutal uncompromising unforgiving nature of the game.
  • If you screw up that very much is going to cost you the game.
  • punishing in a good way. In an interesting way, in a stressful way.
  • I absolutely love Brass Birmingham.
  • It's an S tier game.
  • It's top 10 for my taste.
  • It's not the number one,
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video I0FSsYR76rY Board Game Sanctuary Discussion at 28:04 sentiment: other
Board Game Sanctuary - Brass: Birmingham video thumbnail
Click to watch at 28:04 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
Intrigued
Pros
  • Deep strategy
  • Thematic setting
Cons
  • Only played once at two-player level
Thematic elements
  • Industrial Revolution
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • action selection — Choosing actions to develop industries.
  • network building — Building industries and transport links.
  • Resource Management — Managing resources to build and develop.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Quirky Circuits time to plug this game into your nearest outlet because this is a cooperative game that is inspired by the mind
  • So if you ever played The Mind where you're playing cards out in numerical order but you can't actually talk this game does it but it does it in terms of a programming level
  • The Quacks of Quedlinburg basically you are going to be drawing little elements out of the bag then you're going to be trying to avoid triggering an explosion buying other elements and putting them in your bag so that in the following round you can gain more points move along the track a little bit further
  • So it is a bag building game so just like in a deck building game where you decide what cards go in your deck as you play through them this is all about putting chips in a bag drawing them out it's almost like lottery except each time you're pulling something out you've decided what has gone in the bag so you know that in your bag you have a certain composition of different colors and different elements
  • I create these videos all on my own script them edit them write the music etc and it would mean the world to me if more people could really access just how wonderful board games truly are
  • Goodbye now it's time to bust out Curious Cargo
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video I0FSsYR76rY Board Game Sanctuary Discussion at 28:07 sentiment: positive
Board Game Sanctuary - Brass: Birmingham video thumbnail
Click to watch at 28:07 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Offers deep strategic gameplay
  • Modernized feel
  • Fantastic updated artwork
Cons
  • Played only once at two players
Thematic elements
  • Industrial Revolution
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • network building — Building buildings and moving the provost up and down this little road.
  • Worker Placement — Moving the provost up and down this little road to stop other people from taking actions.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Quirky Circuits time to plug this game into your nearest outlet because this is a cooperative game that is inspired by the mind
  • So if you ever played The Mind where you're playing cards out in numerical order but you can't actually talk this game does it but it does it in terms of a programming level
  • The Quacks of Quedlinburg basically you are going to be drawing little elements out of the bag then you're going to be trying to avoid triggering an explosion buying other elements and putting them in your bag so that in the following round you can gain more points move along the track a little bit further
  • So it is a bag building game so just like in a deck building game where you decide what cards go in your deck as you play through them this is all about putting chips in a bag drawing them out it's almost like lottery except each time you're pulling something out you've decided what has gone in the bag so you know that in your bag you have a certain composition of different colors and different elements
  • I create these videos all on my own script them edit them write the music etc and it would mean the world to me if more people could really access just how wonderful board games truly are
  • Goodbye now it's time to bust out Curious Cargo
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video U4iTpmRJUK0 BoardGameBollocks Review at 0:14 sentiment: positive
BoardGameBollocks - Brass: Birmingham video thumbnail
Click to watch at 0:14 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Fantastic artwork and stunning component quality.
  • Wild cards reduce excuses for not being able to do anything.
  • Requires dynamic strategy and constant thinking about network development.
  • Slim box size makes it easy to store.
Cons
  • Random card draw can be annoying.
  • Some confusing and unclear rules in the rulebook.
  • Difficult to reach higher echelons of industry development.
  • Prone to runaway leaders.
Thematic elements
  • Building canals and railways, placing buildings to produce resources and gain victory points.
  • Industrial Revolution
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • action selection — On your turn, you'll be able to take two actions, discarding a card when you take an action.
  • Card Drafting — Each card has a different thing on it, allowing you to build in specific locations or industries, or acting as wild cards.
  • Development — Remove one or two tiles on your player map to allow access to more advanced level tiles.
  • Income Track — Taking a loan moves your income market down three spots.
  • network building — Building canal links and railway links to connect buildings together to produce resources and gain victory points.
  • Overbuilding — The ability to build over existing structures.
  • Resource Management — Placing buildings on a map hoping that you can flip them that will give you victory points. You need to consume the correct amount of resources.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Roxley Games have really really upped the quality off the charts.
  • The fact that Brass: Birmingham fits into a box the width of Karen Carpenter's elbow is very welcome.
  • The random card draw, I know there's ways to mitigate it but when you draw those two cards at the deck after you've played your actions you draw the that you don't want it's like somebody's put a screwdriver into your ear.
  • It's long, it's a brain burner and it's a brilliant example of long-term planning mixed with a healthy dose of luck mitigation.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video _I4X6T46aq0 BoardGameBollocks Rules Teach at 1:14 sentiment: positive
BoardGameBollocks - Brass: Birmingham video thumbnail
Click to watch at 1:14 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Versatile supplies and strategic depth
  • Engaging network building and resource management
  • Satisfying engine building
Cons
  • Can be complex to learn initially due to numerous icons and rules
Thematic elements
  • Competing entrepreneurs
  • West Midlands during England's Industrial Revolution
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Card Drafting — Players use cards to perform actions like building, networking, developing, selling, taking loans, or scouting.
  • network building — Players expand their empire by establishing canals and rails to connect cities and industries.
  • Resource Management — Players manage resources like coal, iron, and beer, which are needed for building and selling goods.
  • Route Building — Players build canal and rail networks to connect cities and transport goods.
  • Set Collection — Players collect sets of industries and connections to score victory points.
  • Worker Placement — Players place barges in the canal era and trains in the rail era to build and develop industries.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • It's unbelievable it's like all these icons it was just like yeah once you're getting this but then it was fine
  • It's just like mind-boggling
  • Don't be afraid to take loans
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video 7c4bO2-fp7Y BoardGameBollocks Top List at 8:54 sentiment: positive
BoardGameBollocks - Brass: Birmingham video thumbnail
Click to watch at 8:54 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Blew the original Brass out of the water
  • Builds on the brain burner choices of the original
  • Production quality is off the charts
  • Can't stop playing
Cons
  • Grim, cold, and bleak setting
Thematic elements
  • Transporting goods using canals and railways during the industrial revolution.
  • North of England
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • action selection — Implied by the choices players make to expand their network and transport goods.
  • economic — Implied through the transport of goods and industry.
  • network building — Using canals and later railways to transport goods around the map.
  • Resource Management — Transporting goods.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • This is number 30 down to number 21 and we are rapidly approaching that part of cigarette where they secretly put the heroin so don't overdose by yourself
  • My wife will not play this game because she says it induces a sort of a heart attack feeling
  • It's a themeless classic Euro game that we love quite a lot.
  • It ended up being just as bloated as Arkham Horror, if not more bloated than that games
  • It's the way that the worker placement mechanisms fuse with the deck building mechanisms that make this game really really special for me
  • Mathematically it is an absolutely fantastic game yes it's unusual and it's a one-of-a-kind experience
  • It's really really grim up north I can't stand the north of England yeah it's just cold it's Bleak and it's filled with monkeys
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video -llqF7JdpsU Board Games UnLocked Top List at 5:43 sentiment: positive
Board Games UnLocked - Brass: Birmingham video thumbnail
Click to watch at 5:43 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Visually appealing compared to its predecessor
  • Strategic depth with multiple ways to score
  • Improved 'Scout' action makes it more dynamic
Cons
  • Ranking on BGG is questionable due to review bombing
  • Can feel cutthroat at full player counts
  • Not considered top five worthy by the host
Thematic elements
  • Building industries and networks
  • Industrial Revolution era
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • action selection — Players take two actions per round.
  • Card Drafting — Players use cards for actions, locations, or resources.
  • network building — Features railroad building in the second half and canals in the first half.
  • Resource Management — Players manage resources and use them to build industries.
  • Tile Placement — Players place industry tiles.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • um role player back in its time uh was a unique game that kind that popped out you know dice placement you're pretty much just creating your character
  • yeah so the new version um is so Robinson Caruso the adventures on the cursed Island that was done by gamefound uh not gamefound awaken Realms it is impossible to find uh but that's okay because it doesn't exist it doesn't exist yeah
  • this game is honestly clunky as all hell so I'm hoping that the collector's edition kind of cleans that up
  • this game makes me exhausted just thinking about it
  • at the end of the day if you don't roll where you need to roll there's nothing you can do about it
  • but the fact that it's competitive is so unique like because and but here's the other thing you don't want to compete there's a sleuth mode makes it fully Cooperative works just like the other ones
  • this one I agree with you base box very very very meh
  • the one thing that pisses me off about this and this was what FFG failed to do back then was I want more dice right and you just have that one set of dice
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video upCKueZrN0s Top List at 8:27 sentiment: positive
Brass: Birmingham video thumbnail
Click to watch at 8:27 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Route building
  • Shared infrastructure
  • Heavy economic gameplay
  • Strategic depth
  • Solid gameplay loop
Cons
  • Can have a bad first impression (for one player)
  • Potentially less appealing than Lancaster for some (due to cover)
Thematic elements
  • industrial revolution
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • economic — A heavy economic game with interconnected systems and strategic depth.
  • Industry placement — Players buy and place industries in cities.
  • Route Building — Features route building and shared infrastructure.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Agricola is still my number two game of all time
  • For a worker placement game it is incredibly interactive in that way of just like denying your opponent's spots
  • Blood on the clock tower I have had an incredible year on of playing
  • Find a way to play this game it will probably be one of the most interesting novel formative social game experiences you will have
  • My number one first favorite game of all time is still Through the Ages a new story of civilization
  • This is still my definitive civilization board game experience
  • The hero of the whole thing really is that card acquisition that that card row and sort of the timing of using your actions to get cards that you need early before other people can cut you off from them
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video 8E-wlqJ0R5M Top List at 13:52 sentiment: positive
Brass: Birmingham video thumbnail
Click to watch at 13:52 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
Positive
Pros
  • Satisfying arc from canals to rails
  • Symbiotic player interaction
  • Gorgeous production
  • Forces strategic presence on the map
  • Requires forward planning for beer management
Cons
  • Can be frustrating initially
Thematic elements
  • Building industries and networks
  • Industrial Revolution
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Era Progression — The shift from canals to rails is one of the most satisfying arcs in board gaming.
  • network building — Forces you to get out and establish a presence on as much of the map as possible, partly to make network building easier in the future.
  • Resource Management — Beer management is something that I'm thinking about from turn one. If you don't plan for it early, you'll feel it later.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • This was my number one game for a couple of years, and it could absolutely reclaim that spot.
  • The shift from canals to rails is one of the most satisfying arcs in board gaming.
  • It's not cooperative, but it's also not cutthroat. It's symbiotic.
  • This is one of those games where every time I play it, I'm reminded just how elegant the design is.
  • The multi-use cards, and I still think they're one of the smartest implementations of that idea.
  • The deluxe version uses multiple colors which is a big step up.
  • the combination of depth, elegance, and sheer enjoyment is why Lronha sits at number one.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video wj2Ilqhh8do Rolls in the Family Top List at 54:54 sentiment: positive
Rolls in the Family - Brass: Birmingham video thumbnail
Click to watch at 54:54 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
Positive
Pros
  • Clean and brilliant design
  • Interesting strategic gameplay
  • Satisfying progression
  • Plays out interestingly
  • Great reset between canal and rails eras
Cons
  • Has dropped 11 spots on the list
  • Haven't been playing it much
  • Missing some DNA of highly variable games
Thematic elements
  • Economics
  • Industrial Revolution
Comparison games
  • Guild of Merchanting Wars
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Era Progression — The one time you reset and you go into the rails era and it's like okay you can see some remnants of what we did in the canal era and now there's this very different feel.
  • market — Oh, the coal market, you know, adjusted like it's actually a really great time to build an ore mine or whatever so that I could offload it right away back to the market and being connected to things.
  • network and route building — Building these networks.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • And this is Rolls in the Family.
  • And we are back again to continue counting down our top board games of all time.
  • Out of all the games you talked about in this segment, which is your favorite?
  • Most likely I was going to say you do a crazy shot in Dungeon Fighter. That could definitely
  • I need it for recording. No, uh we are in the we are in recovery phrase postshoulder surgery.
  • The board game channel needs me.
  • You know what's funny, Ryan? You know, I I with your kid, you know, you I know you got that time like a thing to like hold cards. I was thinking about getting one of that for myself game, right? Kid card holder.
  • We also as part of this game countdown do a game giveaway.
  • Giveway. Not even just to one person, but to three lucky winners.
  • Um, and I've been doing my uh my secret words based off of the the first game I'm going to talk about.
  • So, I'm going to say that the secret word for today's entry is river.
  • It's great to have the new second edition of this.
  • It's just been so fun to explore this.
  • And like this brings a little bit of what we like about sports to board gaming of the the pressure shots, the it's all on you, the uh kind of continuous uh space of what can happen.
  • This one's seeing a bit of a resurgence with me, which I think is largely powered by the new edition is just so good.
  • I think there's so many groups out there that would have amazing experiences with this game that haven't tried it.
  • Being an excellent dexterity cooperative dexterity game.
  • This is a game that also, you know, we were talking about this with Millennium Blades, but kind of feels like not going to ever leave the collection because what in the world is going to ever replace this cooperative dice throwing, you know, dungeon crawling experience?
  • The Ultimate Edition just offers, you know, it takes what we love about the game, which is unique situations and just pumps a ton into that and makes it really easy to incorporate it all where you're throwing a thing out of a cup or you're, you know, you're using a dye that's a foam dye instead of a nor, you know, and just like that is so fun.
  • This game is not easy. Um and yet uh it's it's so exciting when uh when you can pull things off.
  • Um, this is a game that I've, uh, played, it looks like, five times, once in the last year.
  • Oh, that was so good. Uh, my number 23 goes to Earth.
  • Man this one just has such a great kind of a lot of great things going on.
  • It's one of the things that I like. Um, and this is a mechanism many games share where one person selects kind of you've got your four actions, I believe, and you select a main action, but then everyone else gets to trigger the secondary action of that that ability.
  • Not only that, but then run your whole engine that you're building out in front of you.
  • Every turn you're running your entire thing, which just makes engine building even more fun when you get to run the engine that many times.
  • Earth is uh I think has been a super fun one to to play and yeah, I'm I'm excited to try it a little bit more.
  • This is one that of games you have that I don't. It's near the top of ones that I would love because I've only played it once and I had a very positive play.
  • My number 23 I didn't play this year.
  • This is brass Birmingham.
  • Um actually dropped 11 spots and I think that's just cuz I haven't been playing it.
  • It is missing some of the DNA of what tends to be some of my favorite games of like big variability from game to game in like kind of like actual variable setup elements.
  • But man, does it play out interestingly.
  • And you know, definitely with your your cards and just the way that you're building these networks and looking for opportunities and reacting to what people do and like, oh, the coal market, you know, adjusted like it's actually a great time to build an ore mine or whatever so that I could offload it right away back to the market and being connected to things.
  • And then, you know, we talked about Guild of Merchanting Wars. We love this like reset that then has that too. This has that too of the one time you reset and you go into the rails era and it's like okay you can see some remnants of what we did in the canal era and now there's this very different feel cuz you can only build if you're connected to coal and so like you you re-engage with the system in this very different way. It's very satisfying.
  • It really is a brilliant system. I mean, it obviously is very well regarded in the broader hobby.
  • My number 22 uh is a game I don't need to say much about because Ryan was just singing it his praises of it.
  • This goes to Dungeon Fighter and you know, similar feelings to Ryan of you know, this is a game that also, you know, we were talking about this with uh Millennium Blades, but kind of feels like not going to ever leave the collection because what in the world is going to ever replace this cooperative dice throwing, you know, dungeon crawling experience?
  • Speaking of ruthless, uh this game can be a little ruthless.
  • My number 22 is the second highest new game to my list.
  • Um, and we both have really been enjoying [clears throat] um, our plays of this one.
  • It just feels like what we want in a epic thematic semi-ooperative game.
  • Semi-ooperative is so hard to do right and it feels like this game gets it.
  • It still has some of the crazy swinginess and there's some you know things that can happen.
  • But I think this game does a pretty good job of shifting it to where you're getting more of the good than you know the potential of those worst moments.
  • And when the bad moments happen is if everybody's gone in with the right frame of
  • Um, but man, I mean, this game it has constriction in terms of the uh placing your workers out there. Oh my gosh. Like that is a tense fighting for, you know, the the spots out there. It's got incredibly satisfying engine building.
  • When Ryan first told me about this one I was not particularly in interested and then I played it I was like my goodness this is incredible.
  • Just a deck of cards that's almost a standard deck of cards and yet it is up here beating out Nemesis Retaliation.
  • It's my favorite more traditional card game and the the interesting decisions in it and the way that every hand plays out of like it's a climbing game where you play different sets.
  • It is a fantastic one.
  • Just an absolute banger of a card game that we've been playing for like 15 years now.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video cwt6cmT4VLo Actualol Analysis at 25:09 sentiment: positive
Actualol - Brass: Birmingham video thumbnail
Click to watch at 25:09 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Is the number one game on BoardGameGeek.
  • Has a manageable box size despite its complexity.
  • Is a confident, humble game.
Cons
none
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • If it looks like Monopoly, it's going to play like Monopoly.
  • And these days you can do so much better.
  • When I was 10 years old, I thought Risk was the best thing ever.
  • The games you played as a kid are not as good as you remember.
  • They're out of date.
  • Modern games are built different.
  • Don't buy a game if there's too much of it. If the box is too big, they're shouting at you from the shelf that this product has been made by idiots.
  • This box has to live in my house forever, and it uses up more oxygen than my cat.
  • Any game that comes in a box bigger than this is suffering delusions of grandeur.
  • The best, most loved games of all time don't need new content to keep them entertaining.
  • If the game has multiple modes, like you can play it cooperatively and competitively and semi-cooperatively, then steer clear. It's their game. They should know the best way to play it.
  • If you see that in a rule book, it means they've given you three mediocre games, but not one good one.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video mNE8so40SLc Banter and Boards Top List at 7:01 sentiment: positive
Banter and Boards - Brass: Birmingham video thumbnail
Click to watch at 7:01 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Worth the teach
  • Depth in decision making
  • Feels very clever when things click
  • Good resource management
Cons
  • Can look like a game for serious gamers
Thematic elements
  • Competing entrepreneurs
  • Industrial Revolution (1770-1870)
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Economic Game — Brass Birmingham is an economic strategy game
  • Resource Management — And I'll say the thing that stands out a lot to me about this game is how the resources are used throughout the game.
  • Route Building — as well as building out boats in the first era or railroads in the second.
  • Victory Points — The game is played throughout two eras, and you're trying to score the most victory points.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • So, I have 10 games I believe are worth every minute it takes to learn them.
  • Dune Imperium Uprising is a deck building worker placement game where throughout the game you will be trying to gain influence, win combat, and completing objectives to win the game.
  • And these combats can get super competitive and just really intense.
  • Andromeda's Edge is a worker placement game, but really you're going to be interacting a lot with players throughout this game.
  • Nepon Zipatu is an area majority economic game.
  • This is a fun game where you have that fun area majority, that fun efficiency puzzle. I think it really caters to all types of players.
  • In Galactic Cruise, we are all employees competing to be the next director of Galactic Cruise.
  • But the reason why this game can feel a bit intimidating is because there's quite a bit of steps that you need to do to get to point A, which is building your cruise ships, to point B, which is already having it launched.
  • this one is the one I think, at least for me, out of all the games I've recommended, is the one that's the most involved.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video O1lkJDdyb9I Board Games UnLocked Top List at 7:16 sentiment: positive
Board Games UnLocked - Brass: Birmingham video thumbnail
Click to watch at 7:16 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Very deep game.
  • Beautiful looking game on the table.
  • Good one.
  • Worth its ranking.
Cons
  • The original Brass was 'god-awful looking'.
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • action selection — Players 'get two acts' (actions) per turn, with seven different things to choose from.
  • network building — Implied by the discussion of canals and railways.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • it's also done in hadrian's wall where you are like man i only have these certain workers oh wait let me combo off and now i have 18 of these kinds of workers
  • this one just it's it's an absolute blast to play
  • garfield games typically hits the nail on the head like chef phillips i think is an excellent designer
  • the deluxe box for paladins of the west kingdom it was like a cheap insert uh and it technically holds everything but man is it not like it was not intuitive
  • what this one brings in is it flips the script and you are playing the the evil forces
  • plus it has monsters drawn by the mikko as we just just as we just uh talked about
  • it's a good one i mean it's just people that i that i hate like i don't find this or this box design is awesome but his people are also monstrosities
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video hVVP3uqEbXg The Dungeon Dive Top List at 2:56 sentiment: positive
The Dungeon Dive - Brass: Birmingham video thumbnail
Click to watch at 2:56 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • very strategic
  • very complex
Cons
  • can be frustrating
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
No quotes stored for this video.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video 8EZOrjkmTAM Banter and Boards Top List at 16:09 sentiment: positive
Banter and Boards - Brass: Birmingham video thumbnail
Click to watch at 16:09 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Changes with the players.
  • Euro game with interaction.
  • Unique in its own way.
  • Player interaction is involved.
  • Deep and strategic.
  • Stringing up tiles and selling feels good and satisfying.
  • Great game, absolutely loved.
  • Strong impression on players.
  • Balance of working on own puzzle and piggybacking off others.
  • Not punishing to the degree of taking things/resources.
  • Rewarded for others using your tiles.
Cons
  • Host got last place in a previous play.
  • Hardest thing is wrapping head around networks.
Thematic elements
  • Economic strategy where players are entrepreneurs.
  • Birmingham during the industrial revolution
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • economic strategy — Brass Birmingham is an economic strategy game
  • network building — how the networks work in general.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • My taste in board games are still evolving and I still consider myself pretty new to the hobby.
  • This has to be a good idea.
  • So, we'll see how it goes.
  • It's not that I'm not interested in playing it. It's in that weird spot where I'm interested, but I'm not that interested to learn it and teach it.
  • I think there's a lot to explore here, but for myself, I'm giving this a solid A.
  • I felt a little bit intimidated to play. I I don't know why, but when I see a lot of board games that have like a lot of icons, I just feel much more intimidated.
  • This has been a game I've scheduled out two months in advance. It's this one and Twilight Imperium, which that in its own self is another beast in its own, and I'm very nervous about that game, but more on that later.
  • It's going to be a very long night if not everyone read the rules or watched the how to plays.
  • This game does not really hold your hand or give you any form of catch-up mechanism to get back in the game once you're out.
  • I do appreciate that Hegemony gives you the opportunity to have a bit of a closed economy and you're essentially creating the rules as you go within the policies that you make throughout the rounds, which I think is really cool.
  • Brass: Lancashire, excellent game.
  • However, Brass: Lancashire I I don't know. I think I might like this more.
  • My totally not premature ranking for Brass: Lancashire is S tier.
  • Cosmic Encounter is a game unlike anything he's ever played before.
  • I could see this game going sour very quickly, but who knows, maybe we'll have a really good time with this one.
  • With Cosmic Encounters, I can definitely tell the game is interesting because of the alien abilities that you have. If it weren't for those abilities, I I kind of personally think the game's a bit stale.
  • For my totally not premature ranking for this one, I'm giving this one a C. I think it's okay. I think it's fine.
  • This is easily an S tier. This has worker placement elements that I really enjoy, but keeps it fun and interactive, too, but not to a point where it's so much where I can't work on my own puzzle.
  • So, the day is finally upon us.
  • Um, but I just feel like this is the game that once I play it, I am officially a board gamer.
  • And what a game this was.
  • To my surprise, she picked this up very quickly and she enjoyed this game quite a bit.
  • The game itself is not as hard as I thought it would be.
  • I was very surprised Melissa gave this one an S tier. Totally did not expect that.
  • And so the more I've chewed on this and have thought about it, I'm giving this one a B. And I'm giving this one actually a B minus.
  • If you're someone who loves high player interaction and you want to just wheel and deal and just really play the table, I think you're going to have an amazing time with this game.
  • This actually took about close to 4 months to do.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video Mtz386BxJ_c JestaThaRogue Analysis at 2:20 sentiment: neutral
JestaThaRogue - Brass: Birmingham video thumbnail
Click to watch at 2:20 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
neutral
Pros
none
Cons
none
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • 81% of the top 100 does not line up with the community opinion.
  • Almost every game on the most respected board game ranking in the world asterisk has a gap between what the box says and what thousands of players actually think.
  • The box time is more accurate than the player count, but it assumes you know what you're doing.
  • First play is almost always longer than the box suggests.
  • The box minimum time appears to be collaborating for two players, not solo.
  • The box time, were accurate at all, is based on experienced players playing with the optimum player count.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video Zvu2uGZteIs Board Game Critique Top List at 8:38 sentiment: positive
Board Game Critique - Brass: Birmingham video thumbnail
Click to watch at 8:38 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Ruthless efficiency and interaction
  • Deep production chaining puzzle
  • Constant strategic tension from timing actions
  • Hand management adds another layer of strategy
  • Competition for space creates meaningful interaction
  • Rewards experience, improving with repeated plays
  • Elegantly designed heavy economic game
  • Satisfying feeling of outmaneuvering others
  • Tight interaction and deep decision space
Cons
  • Lacks the loud social energy of other top games
Thematic elements
  • building industries and transportation networks during the Industrial Revolution
  • Industrial Revolution in England's heartland
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • economic strategy — Players build industries and manage resources in the Industrial Revolution.
  • Hand Management — Players try to play cards at the optimal moment while managing network connections.
  • network building — Players develop transportation networks, including canals and railways.
  • production chaining — Players create production chains like coal, iron, beer, and cotton.
  • Worker Placement — Limited action spaces mean players' actions directly affect others.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • We built this list around what we both value most at the table. High player interaction, meaningful decisions that affect others, tension that builds through negotiation or coordination, and experiences that create stories worth retelling long after the game ends.
  • We don't chase pure optimization or solo puzzle solving as much as we once did. We want games where the people around us matter.
  • Root is one of the most unique and brilliant designs in modern board gaming for us.
  • Blood on the Clock Tower is a social deduction game set in a foggy English village plagued by evil forces.
  • It earns the number one spot on our list because it generates the highest level of interaction and memorable moments of any game we play.
  • For us, who value high interaction social gaming above almost everything else, this is the pinnacle.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video Mtz386BxJ_c JestaThaRogue Analysis at 8:56 sentiment: neutral
JestaThaRogue - Brass: Birmingham video thumbnail
Click to watch at 8:56 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
neutral
Pros
none
Cons
none
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Route Building — Both brasses are there, too. Three to four for Birmingham
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • 81% of the top 100 does not line up with the community opinion.
  • Almost every game on the most respected board game ranking in the world asterisk has a gap between what the box says and what thousands of players actually think.
  • The box time is more accurate than the player count, but it assumes you know what you're doing.
  • First play is almost always longer than the box suggests.
  • The box minimum time appears to be collaborating for two players, not solo.
  • The box time, were accurate at all, is based on experienced players playing with the optimum player count.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video kmWIJIguXTg Banter and Boards Top List at 0:19
Banter and Boards - Brass: Birmingham video thumbnail
Click to watch at 0:19 · YouTube ↗
Pros
none
Cons
none
Thematic elements
  • economic
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Some games can look incredibly intimidating.
  • So, I have 10 games I believe are worth every minute it takes to learn them.
  • Are there any other games that you think that are hard to learn, but worth to teach? Comment down below. I'd love to hear it.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video UpGoy3jenCQ Bower's Game Corner Analysis at 3:26 sentiment: positive
Bower's Game Corner - Brass: Birmingham video thumbnail
Click to watch at 3:26 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Clever stretch goal system that encourages continued engagement.
  • Good job showcasing components and game play.
  • The game is a spiritual successor to a beloved game and is associated with awards.
  • Positive aspect of Gamefound getting another company.
  • Deluxified components and trays are exciting.
  • Stretch goals make the game more appealing.
Cons
  • The Kickstarter video was lengthy and redundant in parts.
  • The main image for the campaign is considered trash.
  • The base price of $125 feels high, and with optional add-ons like coins, the cost can become $185 or $225.
  • No rule booklet was provided.
  • The game doesn't feel good at its price point without add-ons.
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
  • Brass Pittsburgh
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • I'm not a fan of how long it was and how redundant it was at certain parts, but I understand.
  • That looks hot. That gets me excited for your 125 bucks.
  • I really like how they handled the stretch goals for a couple reasons.
  • Final Grade Brass Birmingham by Roxley Games. Do I want it? Yes, I do.
  • Main image sucks. I definitely feel like this main image is trash, but do I want it? Yes.
  • So, all of a sudden that 125 is now a 185 or 225 if you want to get the coins, which they're really selling hard.
  • No rule booklet pushes me to B plus but I gave them a third of a point to bump up. I'll go to A minus.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video 0k1BiUNy_f8 Top List at 11:08 sentiment: positive
Brass: Birmingham video thumbnail
Click to watch at 11:08 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Fantastic thinky game
  • Great Eurogame
  • Beautiful game
  • Great app
Cons
  • Can feel like work (to one speaker)
  • Slipped in rank from previous years
Thematic elements
  • Industrial Revolution, trade
  • Birmingham
Comparison games
  • Brass Pittsburgh
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • economic engine — You're putting out iron mines and coal mines and then you're putting out goods and resources or putting out goods and pottery barns, whatever else and you're trying to sell those goods.
  • Hand Management — You have a hand of cards, you're going to play down two of those cards.
  • Loan System — This is a game where you can take loans, which you will have to do cuz you are spending money.
  • network building — but to sell those goods you have to create pathways, you have to create, you know, routes to get to the selling places.
  • Two Eras — There's two different eras. Some of your buildings when you're playing the first area, you're doing canals and everything else. Then when you switch to the second area, you're making railroads.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Marvel Dice Throne is one of the games that as a spiritual crossover?
  • This is a really fun This is a game that any my kids any one of my kids will take take it and ask for it at game night.
  • Champions of Midgard is a fantastic game.
  • This is the game that encapsulates what I think the zombie apocalypse would be if it were to happen.
  • It's so thematically rich.
  • The mechanics are just so clean and smooth.
  • Blood Rage? Blood Rage is my number 11.
  • It's a hard way It's a hard game to teach new people how to play. And have them enjoy it.
  • Oathsworn is an amazing game where you take on your characters. You go through this campaign story that's It's riveting from the first beginning until you're going through town.
  • And then the second half is a boss battler and that boss battler is top notch.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video y8zxARCqgiI Top List at 26:50 sentiment: positive
Brass: Birmingham video thumbnail
Click to watch at 26:50 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
highly positive
Pros
  • High level of positive player interaction
  • Deep strategic gameplay
  • Beautiful production quality
  • Satisfying progression through two eras
Cons
  • Can be challenging to teach initially
  • Tempting to bling out with upgrades
Thematic elements
  • Industrial Revolution, commerce, and trade
  • West Midlands, England
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • action selection — Players take actions such as building industries, taking loans, developing, or scouting.
  • network building — Players build routes (canals then railways) to connect industries and ship goods.
  • player interaction — Relies on shared resources and routes, encouraging interaction without being fully cooperative.
  • Resource Management — Managing the production and consumption of resources like coal and iron is crucial.
  • Set Collection — Shipping off goods to markets can grant points based on sets or types.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • my top 10 games of all time
  • Thanks to everyone who have liked and commented uh on these videos
  • I wanted this to be a community focused Channel
  • I'm pretty happy with my old tasty minstral deluxified Edition
  • The way the card play works in this game is that players will have a hand of the same 15 character cards and you'll choose a hand of cards at the beginning of the round – five cards – and if you play a card on your turn that no one else has played, you get to take both the abilities on that card; but if anyone else has chosen the same card for that round, they will get to play that card on your turn and you'll each only get to take one of the card actions.
  • These resource wheels are essentially large dials and instead of taking tokens to represent your available resources, you're going to move them around this wheel. The catch is that whenever resources move away from the arms of the dial, the dial will move to, meaning that you will automatically spend resources to produce one of the premium goods either brick or glass.
  • Glenmore 2 I just added so many cool new ideas with all of the Chronicles that you can swap in and out of the game that will change up the game sometimes in subtle ways sometimes in really big ways.
  • but holy crap did I fall immediately in love with this game.
  • one of my favorite things that he does is take a relatively simple action selection mechanism and gives you a lot of interesting decisions to make.
  • The special edition from awaken Realms which is absolutely gorgeous. It's got beautiful art amazing Castle pieces and even includes a new Vineyards expansion which gives you even more options to score points.
  • This game gives you a lot of opportunities for some major combo turns which are all super satisfying and make you feel like a board game genius even when you are definitely not.
  • The first player rolls dice twice the number of players plus one then players take turns drafting those dice and depending on the number on those D on the die that you choose you're going to be taking an action associated with that number.
  • The biggest reason I love this game so much is all of the positive player interaction. It's very difficult to do well in this game just being off on your own on your own little corner of the map doing your own thing.
  • The production of this game is in my opinion absolutely beautiful. Whether you use the day or night side of the board.
  • brass Birmingham is my favorite game for another year although L granha might be coming for it
  • well we made it that's 100 of my favorite games
  • stay tuned for that and until next time let's get another round for the table
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video d7BQYYPuQK0 Top List at 4:04 sentiment: mixed
Brass: Birmingham video thumbnail
Click to watch at 4:04 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
mixed
Pros
  • Good game
  • Rewarding once understood
Cons
  • Confusing
  • Incredibly heavy
  • Not a business game
  • Hard to define
Thematic elements
  • Business/Connections
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • action selection — Making sure every single turn is valid.
  • network building — It's a game where you just make connections, you make roads.
  • Resource Management — You don't really sell cuz you can't sell the beer. You sell the beer as a means to sell something else.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • This is nature. Another game that was sent to me by Outset Games. Thank you so much, Outset. Um, I like this a lot.
  • by nature it's a very simplified version of evolution where like it doesn't hurt nearly as much. Doesn't take nearly as long.
  • it's the best version of Evolution I've seen so far.
  • Now, this is one of the only games I know that's a fully fleshed out polyamino board game.
  • once you have your board fully completed. It's so difficult and so rewarding.
  • This is Tokyo Ghoul the card game. And Tokyo Ghoul the card game. It is a very unique deck building system to it.
  • It's kind of like an auto battler cuz the character cards will flip out in front of you to act as your defenders and attackers.
  • Apparently the board game's not that good, but the card game is amazing.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video 5xe5HoMAG6w Shelfside Analysis at 2:08
Shelfside - Brass: Birmingham video thumbnail
Click to watch at 2:08 · YouTube ↗
Pros
none
Cons
none
Thematic elements
  • Uses sidebars for flavor text.
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • I HATE IT. I hate it. I hate it. Hate it. I hate it when I can't play game. I want to play a game, but I can't play a game because the rulebook is in the way.
  • Like yeah, it kind of does feel like I need a bachelor of arts degrees and Google Board Game Geek to play the game. Like why is it so much work to play the game?
  • But games shouldn't have a required solo session before gaming.
  • So, your game is pretty big, right? You spent many years making it. There's a lot of components. There's a lot of terms. There's a lot of cool mechanics that go together well, and yeah, why why is there no index or glossary?
  • There's a big difference between something being a good reference book and being a good tutorial book.
  • So, the rulebook is trying to be more like an almanac or like an encyclopedia of being so comprehensive, but there's a big difference between something being a good reference book and being a good tutorial book.
  • Like rule book reading actually reminds me of being forced to read in college for classes and just being kind of burned out of reading.
  • And now I know why people hate reading cuz yeah, a lot of reading is just boring. Like technical writing by its nature is not fun for most people. So, why make people go through that?
  • A picture tells a thousand words. That is just how it is.
  • You just want to play games as quickly as possible and a lot of rule books unfortunately just don't facilitate that.
  • the whole premise, the whole the whole state of it is just sad even from decades of modern board gaming.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video cgNuMiPOUqs Board Games UnLocked Review at 0:15 sentiment: mixed
Board Games UnLocked - Brass: Birmingham video thumbnail
Click to watch at 0:15 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
mixed
Pros
  • Solid Euro game
  • Has a nice flow and thematic elements
  • Player interaction where resources can be used by others
  • Interesting turn order mechanic based on spending
  • Ability to buy and sell excess resources
  • Tried and true game with a long history
Cons
  • Not particularly liked by the host, despite acknowledging its solidity
  • Lack of standout 'wow' factor
  • End game can be repetitive, focused on simply scoring points
  • Randomness of card draws and tiles can dictate early game success/failure
  • Hard reset between eras feels like a significant loss
  • Hesitancy due to fear of players taking resources/spots
  • Can feel like wasted turns or steps backward
  • Lack of variety compared to other games
  • The BGG ranking system drama detracted from wanting to try it
Thematic elements
  • Industrial Revolution
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Deck Building — The opening hand of cards is discussed as influencing strategy, and the ability to draw 'wild' cards by burning others is noted.
  • Development — The development action, which seems less utilized, is discussed as a potentially powerful way to flip tiles and gain access to higher-level buildings.
  • Income tracking — The increase in income level throughout the game is a key progression mechanic.
  • Market manipulation — Buying and selling resources like coal and iron at market rates is a mechanic discussed.
  • network building — The placement of rails and connections is a key part of the game, with discussions on how connections are used and affect other players.
  • Resource Management — Managing coal, iron, and beer is crucial, with discussions on their availability and strategic use.
  • Set Collection — Implicitly present in building sets of buildings for points and income.
  • Worker Placement — Mentioned in comparison to other games, with a discussion about the 'one worker per spot' rule and its implications.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • There is no best game of all time because time isn't out yet.
  • The inherent flaw in caring what other people think and that inherent flaw of the BGG ranking system.
  • The BGG top 10 is definitely the top 10 Board Game Geek is petty.
  • Do I feel like being an asshole? I just kind of want to do my strategy and oh cool you built in front of the water thing. Yay.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video MqSsu71e_YA Board Games UnLocked Playthrough at 0:16 sentiment: positive
Board Games UnLocked - Brass: Birmingham video thumbnail
Click to watch at 0:16 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Considered the number one game on BoardGameGeek.
  • Offers deep strategic gameplay with interconnected systems.
  • High replayability due to variable setup and player choices.
Cons
  • Complex rules and a challenging learning curve.
  • Can be frustrating if planning goes awry or resources are scarce.
Thematic elements
  • Building industries and infrastructure during the Industrial Revolution
  • Industrial Revolution era England
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Development — Players can develop industries, removing lower-tier buildings to unlock access to higher-tier ones.
  • Hand Management — Players use cards from their hand to perform actions, build industries, and establish connections.
  • Income Track — Players gain income based on their level on the income track, which can be increased by selling goods.
  • Loans — Players can take loans to gain money, but this typically reduces their income.
  • network building — Players build connections (links and rails) between locations to transport goods and expand their reach.
  • Resource Management — Players manage various resources like coal, iron, and beer, which are needed for building and selling.
  • scoring — Points are awarded at the end of each era for network links and flipped industries.
  • Selling — Players can sell built industries, which earns them income and points.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • the best game ever made brass Birmingham
  • number one number one game
  • this is number one on board game Geeks therefore every other game is inferior
  • I hate this game and everything about it anyone who likes it is um an [__]
  • this game gives me cancer
  • it's a lot of cold burning
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video DR5mhcjhkuY Board Games UnLocked Discussion at 1:07
Board Games UnLocked - Brass: Birmingham video thumbnail
Click to watch at 1:07 · YouTube ↗
Pros
none
Cons
none
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • So, 10 seconds. Uh, three points for the game title, one point for the designer.
  • What do all these have in common? They're designed by Uve Rosenberg.
  • And man, 10 seconds. That really puts it on you.
  • All right. So, that's five points.
  • So, I'm at 14 points.
  • So, I got 17.
  • So, I got 21.
  • So, 24.
  • Okay. Hey, I'll take four points.
  • Okay, 35.
  • So that's four points there. So I'm at 73.
  • Okay. I am at 76.
  • That is uh 76. That is how well I did.
  • So if there were how many questions were there at the very 20 20 total questions.
  • So not bad. I I definitely don't think that was too terrible.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video nzd8yz8hcp4 Board Gaymes James Discussion at 4:48 sentiment: negative
Board Gaymes James - Brass: Birmingham video thumbnail
Click to watch at 4:48 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
negative
Pros
  • Beautiful artwork
  • Beautiful production
Cons
  • Added a ton of weight and issues to transporting
  • Didn't really need the added complexity over Lancashire
  • Mathematical mismatch in setup
  • Discarding/playing one card mechanic issues
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Card Mechanics — The reviewer needed the card mechanics to make sure rounds are right.
  • Discarding — Still had an issue with discarding one and playing one card.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Sometimes you get a game and it just doesn't click or it sits on your shelf for a while and some of these games cost quite a lot of money.
  • buy with intent.
  • It's an okay game. Um I don't mind it, but I don't feel like I need to own it after playing it on BGA and that's kind of a consensus that might be happening with a lot of more games that I have lately is that I have been selling some games that I'm like, okay, this is easier to play in a digital version than it is in the board game version cuz there's too much setup or it's too physically heavy to take with me places, um or the game is too short that um it's quicker to play the game than it is to set up the game.
  • Those are 10 different games that I kind of regret buying. My collection is constantly recycling, too, so don't take any of these as a you shouldn't get them, but that you need to buy with intent. You should think about, am I going to get this to the table? Is this the types of mechanics I like? Is this the types of themes I like?
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video kBLJRyFWSIo Board Game Sanctuary Discussion at 13:57 sentiment: positive
Board Game Sanctuary - Brass: Birmingham video thumbnail
Click to watch at 13:57 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Plays a lot better at three or four players.
  • More options for different connections and scoring opportunities with more players.
Cons
none
Thematic elements
  • Route connection, industry, and economic development
  • Industrial Revolution England
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • network building — Players build connections to utilize resources and manufacture goods.
  • Resource Management — Players utilize coal, iron, and beer.
  • Route Building — Players connect locations to form routes.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • player count is really crucial for determining what sort of games get to hit the table
  • the conflict has been split you can either go against one player and use the support of the third player or the other two players can kind of go against you that kind of split interaction means you're you feel less like the target essentially
  • the fact that there is a different social Dynamic and a different level of strategy that you might engaging when you play a game at three plays
  • playing Team based games at an odd player number can feel a little bit off balance
  • the downside of that that is that you don't actually get to play I get to miss out I just kind of watch I get to ref the game
  • the freedom to be able to own your own uh moves uh contribute to the discussion equally and to be able to contribute in your own way just makes those sorts of games far more fun when you do have an uneven number of players
  • because you've got odd numbers there's always going to be at least one player who might disagree against the majority
  • Betray often feels really left out feels very isolating
  • when you introduce that third player or even fourth or fifth player all of a sudden everything becomes constricted the board becomes limited the choices become far more tense
  • games feel vastly different sometimes depending on how many people are playing
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video zJujvq8yi6I Board Game Sanctuary Discussion at 0:28
Board Game Sanctuary - Brass: Birmingham video thumbnail
Click to watch at 0:28 · YouTube ↗
Pros
none
Cons
none
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • this is the best board game I've ever played
  • I've decided that we'll do a 10x10 challenge where we pick 10 board games play them 10 times throughout the year
  • I've signed you up without even asking you without even your knowledge they'll be doing the challenge together
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Transcript Navigation
Showing 1–50 of 285
Game Deep Dive