Brass: Birmingham

Video bW04QSyYqdg Bard Stupid general_discussion at 1:24 sentiment: mixed

video_pk 63241 · mention_pk 156582

Click to watch at 1:24 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

mixed

Pros

Double layer player boards are discussed as potentially improving gameplay experience
Collector's edition includes train cover and other deluxe components

Cons

Double layer boards are locked to the collector's edition and add substantial cost
Deluxe components replace content from the base game (e.g., iron clays removed from deluxe pledge)
Wooden money tiles replace iron clays in the collector's edition
Collector's edition box is full of plastic inserts and resin components
Sustainability claim (FSC wood) tied to a stretch goal raises questions about greenwashing
Base game lacks double layer boards, while deluxe adds expensive extras
Perceived shrinkflation-like pricing and removal of base game elements for deluxe tier

Thematic elements

Comparison games

Brass Birmingham
Lancasher
Lancashire
Nemesis lockdown retaliation

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

Mechanics unknown.

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

this is now the poster child for deluxification and potentially, controversial anti-consumer practices.
Double layer player boards which by their own word improve the gameplay experience are only locked to the collector's edition which in the UK will cost you £60 more at least than the normal edition.
the collector's edition box is full of plastic.
the wood is going to be FSC certified wood. So what happened in the event that they don’t achieve that, what are you going to do?
I think my overarching thought is they could have made a better compromise standard game that would have been probably a better price.

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video Ts7MeG4XZ8c Stonemaier Games playthrough at 2:49 sentiment: positive

video_pk 62639 · mention_pk 155352

Click to watch at 2:49 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

positive

Pros

Complex strategy with growth via routes and coal/industry dynamics
Flexible use of resources with river networks

Cons

Early turns can be constrained (can't connect to a one or two)
Progress can rely on tough resource/heart costs

Thematic elements

Array
Industrial England
Strategic

Comparison games

Genotype

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

Mechanics unknown.

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

Punnett square, I believe.
Genotype uses a lot of numbers, but it is a generous realm, which helps out a lot, too.
I'm glad they allowed a promo realm for the game.
Lost Ruins of Arnak would be my pick for that.

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video ylcNplo6pas Unknown Channel analysis at 1:01 sentiment: positive

video_pk 62507 · mention_pk 155140

Click to watch at 1:01 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

positive

Pros

Elegant, clean six-action rhythm across two eras
Strong shared-resource interaction that rewards collaboration and timing
Accessible teach with deep strategic payoff
Beautiful production and table presence (board art, dual eras, etc.)
Clear end-of-era scoring with meaningful long-term strategy

Cons

Can feel long in 4-player games
Rules mid-level overhead; requires careful tracking of resources and deck timing
Deck management can impact pacing if mismanaged

Thematic elements

industrial network building, resource management, and timing
England's West Midlands during the industrial revolution (1770-1870)
historical economic simulation with two eras and shared resources

Comparison games

Nucleium
Imperial Steam

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

build — Place an industry tile from your player mat onto a valid space on the map.
develop — Scrap lower-level tiles on your mat to access stronger ones faster.
Loan — Gives you £30 at the cost of dropping your income three levels.
Network — Add canal or rail links to expand connectivity.
Network/route building — Add canal or rail links to expand connectivity.
Scout — Discard a card to take the action plus two more cards from your hand (three cards total) and gain one wild industry card and one wild location card; you cannot scout if you already hold a wild card.
sell — Flip cotton mills, manufacturers, and potteries by consuming beer and using merchant tiles around the edge.
Trading — Flip cotton mills, manufacturers, and potteries by consuming beer and using merchant tiles around the edge.

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

Brass Birmingham is the elegant industrial classic with two eras and shared resources.
The rhythm is absolutely core.
Nucleium's tile system is one of its defining features.
Imperial Steam is the most overtly punishing.

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video JZL17bcpjEA general_discussion at 1:19 sentiment: negative

video_pk 62510 · mention_pk 155147

Click to watch at 1:19 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

negative

Pros

none

Cons

none

Thematic elements

Comparison games

none

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

economic engine-building — players build and optimize networks of industries and routes to gain income and victory points.
engine building — players build and optimize networks of industries and routes to gain income and victory points.

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

Trust us.
Verify everything, trust nothing.
The biggest lie board game companies tell might be the simplest. Trust us.
You're buying version 1.0 that needs patches, but there's no disclaimer saying software may require updates.
The app has potential for gamebreaking bugs, especially in stretch goal missions.

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video B5G70dA_0c0 Board Game Critique analysis at 5:43 sentiment: mixed

video_pk 62523 · mention_pk 155201

Click to watch at 5:43 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

mixed

Pros

Rich strategic depth
teaches through elegant systems

Cons

Rules polished but unforgiving when misread
punishing when mistakes are made

Thematic elements

network building and coal/industry logistics
industrial revolution in Birmingham
economic strategy with heavy planning

Comparison games

none

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

Auction / Bidding — timing and bidding influence resource availability.
Auction/market dynamics — timing and bidding influence resource availability.
network-building — players lay networks that unlock scoring opportunities.
Network/route building — players lay networks that unlock scoring opportunities.

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

It's not engagement. It's everyone doing their own puzzle in the same room.
Gorgeous production quality, but multiple simultaneous subsystems that can feel complex initially for new players.
Turn order determines a lot in this game's economy.
One wrong move with how the link network system works, and you've completely invalidated your entire strategy.
The clue giver walks a razor line between clever and intuitive that new players haven't calibrated.
Eight-hour day commitment, full group attendance, full mental energy required throughout.

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video Ycyjvv-zdKo Get into Games general_discussion at 1:06 sentiment: positive

video_pk 61696 · mention_pk 154355

Click to watch at 1:06 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

positive

Pros

Strong theme and economic engine
Engaging tension between players

Cons

Complex for new players
Longer playtime

Thematic elements

Comparison games

none

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

economic engine building — Players develop businesses to generate income and optimize supply chains.
engine building — Players develop businesses to generate income and optimize supply chains.

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

This is going to take a little while if we go through all of the 72,000 people.
The space was interesting. It felt like one big room, massive.
The best thing about our hobby is you can take somebody who's never been to the expo before and they found somebody to play a game with.
Memoir 44 looks good. Looks fun solo game.
Take Time which is absolutely beautiful.

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video _DhIh6t9W2c Allies or Enemies top_100_list at 4:49

video_pk 61162 · mention_pk 153731

Click to watch at 4:49 · YouTube ↗

Pros

none

Cons

none

Thematic elements

Array
Array
canal era, railways, and industrial growth
Array
Industrial Revolution England
Array
Array
Array
positive

Comparison games

none

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

Mechanics unknown.

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

it's just like a super easy to teach but super mean game that you can play with your family
I love games where you're involved on everyone's turn
the expansions have added a lot to it
the production value of the aliens those miniatures
this is basically alien the board game

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video Rp8vOUPx-7k Allies or Enemies top_100_list at 28:44 sentiment: positive

video_pk 61186 · mention_pk 153826

Click to watch at 28:44 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

positive

Pros

Historically rich and mechanically dense
Tight interaction and planning

Cons

Can feel heavy/dense for some players

Thematic elements

Railways, factories, and industry growth
Industrial Revolution in Birmingham, UK

Comparison games

none

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

Network/route building — Connect towns with boats and trains for resource flow.
Rail/industry network building — Connect towns with boats and trains for resource flow.
Tightly constrained resources — Resource scarcity adds strategic tension.
Tile flipping and resource management — Flip tiles to reveal scoring opportunities and adjust strategy.

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

it's gorgeous
everything about this game is gorgeous
it's jazz chess with insects
it's a combat game that I really like
don't be turned off by it being too pretty

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video CFxiKt9DqaM Allies or Enemies top_100_list at 24:15 sentiment: positive

video_pk 61017 · mention_pk 153408

Click to watch at 24:15 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

positive

Pros

Smart use of resources; deep economic engine
Satisfying to connect up coal and supply chains
Atmosphere and design feel thematic and polished

Cons

Gloomy theme may be off-putting to some players

Thematic elements

Array
Industrial revolution Birmingham, England
Economic strategy with resource scarcity

Comparison games

none

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

Market Pricing/Manipulation — Market forces and timing drive profit and strategic decisions
Market/ pricing tension — Market forces and timing drive profit and strategic decisions
network building — Canals and rails form networks to connect markets and optimize income
Network/route building — Canals and rails form networks to connect markets and optimize income
Resource management — Managing coal, iron, and other resources to fuel actions and development

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

My number 60 is Istanbul and I feel like this is one that flew under the radar a little bit.
There's still plenty of time to join in the Kickstarter.
I love the challenge of this game.
Istanbul big box because we waited for the big box, and it was worth it.
Jaipur is a two-player specific card game.
Unlock is an escape room in a box.
Marvel United does simplicity so so well.
Cascadia has a theme I love; I grew up near the Rockies.
Brass Birmingham is such a smart game.

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video 24CLyIMZV64 Unknown Channel game_review at 0:00 sentiment: positive

video_pk 60539 · mention_pk 152915

Click to watch at 0:00 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

positive

Pros

glare-free, high-visibility board
strong strategic depth
varied building options and upgrades

Cons

high complexity and learning curve
potentially overwhelming with many interacting systems

Thematic elements

economic engine-building with industrial expansion
Industrial Britain, Midlands during the Brass era
historical economic strategy

Comparison games

Brass Pittsburgh
Brass Birmingham

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

economic engine-building — Players create an interconnected economy to develop industries and generate income.
engine building — Players create an interconnected economy to develop industries and generate income.
Network/route building — Players connect towns and industries to optimize production and distribution.
Resource management — Balancing coal, iron, and other resources to maximize output.
route and network building — Players connect towns and industries to optimize production and distribution.

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

Brass Birmingham is literally the number one ranked board game of all time on Board GameGeeek.
There's a lot going on. It's a lot.
This might not seem like a big deal to many of you, but every board gamer has been in a convention with the harsh lights and had to like move their head all around in order to see the game.
Not with Brass Pittsburgh. Now you have no excuse when you lose.
Here is the old board from Brass Birmingham. And you can see sort of how washed out it is underneath my lights.

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video tBiaQyjq26g Brass Birmingham Stream with Ashton and Pranav playthrough at 0:00 sentiment: positive

video_pk 60661 · mention_pk 153074

Click to watch at 0:00 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

positive

Pros

Engaging two-player stream with a deep engine
Chess timer adds drama and pace
Satisfying network/link-building and engine interaction
Compact game with surprising depth

Cons

Rule clarifications and occasional confusion
Time pressure can be stressful during live play
Four-player experience can be chaotic

Thematic elements

Array
Industrial Revolution England
economic engine-building with network placement

Comparison games

Patchwork
Spirit Island
Star Wars: Rebellion
Lancaster

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

economic engine building — developing an economy via industries to generate income and points
engine building — developing an economy via industries to generate income and points
network building — placing canal and railway link tiles to connect cities and earn points
Network/route building — placing canal and railway link tiles to connect cities and earn points
Resource management — manage beer, coal, and iron as primary resources to build and score
tile placement — placing industry and link tiles to expand the network

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

Patchwork was definitely Patchwork that was good.
Star Wars Rebellion is one of those games that we literally only play with each other.
this is a very nice way of playing brass Birmingham genuinely way I enjoy more than just regular.
the chess timer would be nuts
this is a chaotic time to argue with your friends
this is a fun stream

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video 24CLyIMZV64 Unknown Channel game_review at 0:09 sentiment: positive

video_pk 60539 · mention_pk 152916

Click to watch at 0:09 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

positive

Pros

new variant features like oil drums for transport and Vanderbilt-style goods purchases

Cons

not expressly detailed in transcript; may cause confusion with base Brass Birmingham

Thematic elements

economic engine-building with variant logistics
Industrial variant in Pittsburgh
historical economic strategy variant

Comparison games

Brass Pittsburgh
Brass Birmingham

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

economic engine-building — Variant of Brass with updated logistics and production flows.
engine building — Variant of Brass with updated logistics and production flows.

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

Brass Birmingham is literally the number one ranked board game of all time on Board GameGeeek.
There's a lot going on. It's a lot.
This might not seem like a big deal to many of you, but every board gamer has been in a convention with the harsh lights and had to like move their head all around in order to see the game.
Not with Brass Pittsburgh. Now you have no excuse when you lose.
Here is the old board from Brass Birmingham. And you can see sort of how washed out it is underneath my lights.

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video yCwysOrwNos Unknown Channel playthrough at 0:21 sentiment: positive

video_pk 60670 · mention_pk 153083

Click to watch at 0:21 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

positive

Pros

Deep strategic depth and network-building
Engaging historical theme with canal economy
Promising flow with two eras (early and late game)

Cons

High learning curve and rule complexity
Iconography and token confusion can hinder beginners
Challenging to teach, especially using AI tools

Thematic elements

industrialization, networks, and economic development
Industrial Britain during the canal era (late 18th–early 19th century)
economic strategy with historical context

Comparison games

Catan
Monopoly

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

Canal network building — Construct canals to connect towns and unlock income and VP opportunities.
Development track — Progress on a development track to reduce costs and unlock capabilities.
Industry tile development — Place and flip industry tiles to increase income and points.
Loans — Money loans and income markers affect players' economies.
Loans and income markers — Money loans and income markers affect players' economies.
Network/route building — Construct canals to connect towns and unlock income and VP opportunities.
Resource management — Acquire coal/iron resources from a market to fuel actions and production.
resource/market management — Acquire coal/iron resources from a market to fuel actions and production.
Simultaneous Actions — Each player may perform two actions per turn.
Track advancement — Progress on a development track to reduce costs and unlock capabilities.
Two-actions-per-turn — Each player may perform two actions per turn.

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

Brass Birmingham the number one game on BGG right now.
it does look more of a complicated game at least more complicated than what I'm playing
the human to human connection definitely would resonate more to a person rather than talking to a tech spot
chat gbt is close to useless for teaching game as complicated as brass Birmingham
that was a really fun experiment with board game chat this spin-off of chat gbt maybe next time we'll just use chat gbt
the robots aren't coming for your jobs for a very long time
if you want to learn brass Birmingham by yourself grab that rulebook and Ronnie Smith's watch it played video
the overall amount of strategy that there is to think of
the box cover looks pretty nice it does look more of a complicated game at least more complicated than what I'm playing
not at all I mean maybe if they add some kind of interpersonality maybe add a nice voice for the chat GPT to kind of explain you a little bit more

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video BcY2NduZXrc Unknown Channel game_review at 0:41 sentiment: positive

video_pk 60722 · mention_pk 153157

Click to watch at 0:41 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

positive

Pros

Beautiful production and tactile components with a cohesive aesthetic
Strong thematic integration: theme meets gameplay in a satisfying way
Two-era progression provides meaningful structure and escalating stakes
High interactivity without being overly confrontational; opponents’ actions shape your economy
Compact footprint and elegant, legible components that stay visually clear on the board

Cons

Rulebook can be difficult to navigate; organization and indexing could be improved
Some components (VP markers) are visually too similar, which can cause minor tracking issues
Rulebook typography and layout (small font) can hinder quick onboarding
Session length often runs longer than box estimates (roughly 3 hours with 4 players)

Thematic elements

Array
Industrial Revolution Britain
Historical economic simulation with enthusiastic, experiential commentary

Comparison games

Food Chain Magnate
Manchester Madness

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

Card-driven actions — Players use a hand of cards to perform actions at various locations and on the board.
end game bonuses — End-of-era scoring and a public VP track determine the winner as the board resets between eras.
Endgame scoring / VP track — End-of-era scoring and a public VP track determine the winner as the board resets between eras.
Loans — Players can take loans to boost cash temporarily, enabling flexible planning.
Loans / financial options — Players can take loans to boost cash temporarily, enabling flexible planning.
market / supply and demand — Resource cubes can be bought and sold in a market; prices shift with supply and demand dynamics.
Network building / linking — Players create connections between cities to unlock points and enable resource flows.
Network/route building — Players create connections between cities to unlock points and enable resource flows.
Resource management — Managing coal, iron, beer, and other resources across the evolving network drives decisions.
Resource management / production economy — Managing coal, iron, beer, and other resources across the evolving network drives decisions.
tile placement — Tiles are placed on the board and flipped face-up as costs are paid or conditions met, revealing benefits.
Tile placement and flipping — Tiles are placed on the board and flipped face-up as costs are paid or conditions met, revealing benefits.
Tile upgrades / income ramp — Industries upgrade to higher-tier tiles that boost income and sometimes provide more capabilities.
Track advancement — The game progresses through two eras (canal era and railroad era) with era-specific tiles and scoring shifts.
Two-era progression — The game progresses through two eras (canal era and railroad era) with era-specific tiles and scoring shifts.

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

this countryside board is going to get wrapped up with the change of the industrial revolution as you build all these tiles and then you're utilizing shipping lanes and you're even paying your workers
the theme meets the gameplay amazingly
the board ends up feeling like this growing flower or growing smaller flowers as the opportunities just keep rising up
loans ... you can basically buy anything now
the VP marker ... doesn't really move until end of eras

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video Vi3RGk5DoH4 Unknown Channel analysis at 0:45 sentiment: mixed

video_pk 60660 · mention_pk 153064

Click to watch at 0:45 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

mixed

Pros

Deep economic planning
Engaging with timer across two eras

Cons

Two eras increase complexity for timer
Money denominations can slow interaction

Thematic elements

Array
industrial revolution

Comparison games

Monolith Arena
Coup
Patchwork

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

economic engine — players manage income and industries to build networks
Turn-based sequencing — turns and phases across two eras with pause between actions

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

I love playing with the chess timer
it's addicting
my final say is to at least try using a chest timer for one of your two player games
we could finish brass Birmingham under 75 minutes
this chest timer is My Little Secret Weapon to use with a handful of friends to get through our favorite games faster
I definitely think we could do it more games less time

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video u5Z4xzJZ4Fs Power Media playthrough at 3:06 sentiment: mixed

video_pk 60669 · mention_pk 153082

Click to watch at 3:06 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

mixed

Pros

Noted as a highly regarded title in the video (described as 'the number one board game right now' by the presenter).
The gameplay is framed around close competition and strategic decision-making.

Cons

The video mentions production/footage issues rather than game flaws; there is limited direct critique of Brass: Birmingham mechanics.
No explicit rating or verdict is given in the transcript, leaving takeaway vague.

Thematic elements

Array
England during the Industrial Revolution
Competitive/strategic commentary

Comparison games

none

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

Economic/Victory Point Scoring — Income generation and strategic placement convert into victory points, driving competition for market opportunities.
engine building — Players build up an internal engine of actions and opportunities by acquiring industries and linking them with networks, enabling higher income and more options over the course of the game.
hidden victory points — Income generation and strategic placement convert into victory points, driving competition for market opportunities.
Network/route building — Players lay down canals and rail connections to connect towns, enabling goods movement and scoring opportunities as the board develops.
Resource management — Players manage basic resources (coal, iron) to build and upgrade industries, balancing scarcity and demand as the market evolves.

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

"brass Birmingham the number one board game right now allegedly"
"I played it recently and it was a close game"
"turn by turn breakdown I really want to show you guys"
"we have brass Birmingham the number one board game right now allegedly"
"it's just a board game"
"I love all board games"
"I'll show them how it really went"
"this is real Power Media is real"

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video qEFx0l-JpPg Unknown Channel general_discussion at 4:07 sentiment: positive

video_pk 60717 · mention_pk 153151

Click to watch at 4:07 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

positive

Pros

Engaging engine-building strategy
Interlocking systems create deep planning

Cons

High weight and complexity may be intimidating for new players

Thematic elements

Array
Industrial England during the Industrial Revolution
Euro-style, minimal narrative

Comparison games

none

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

engine building — Players develop an interconnected economic engine to generate points/resources over the game.
Network/route building — Players connect industries through networks to optimize production and shipments.

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

ameritrash games are just incredibly inefficient
euro games are just objectively better than ameritrash games
I'm a board gamer not a doll painter
Remember time is money so if you're gonna spend two hours learning a game it better be worth it
why would we bother with such a degenerate gambling tool in this modern society
there is something exceedingly satisfying about building something up and watching a strong robust engine grow

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video b4CDtK5NcUg game_review at 4:56 sentiment: neutral

video_pk 60668 · mention_pk 153080

Click to watch at 4:56 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

neutral

Pros

Impressive look and presence in a room
Large table with ample space
Topper adds surface area
Sturdy construction (as described)

Cons

No direct discussion of gameplay mechanics
Weight and assembly issues discussed in terms of the table, not the game

Thematic elements

Array
Industrial Revolution England

Comparison games

Catan

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

Mechanics unknown.

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

here's a table in all of its glory and man it is an impressive looking piece of furniture
this is definitely the biggest board game table I've ever owned
seriously the origins is a cool table looks wise it's very impressive

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video qf8mEKZCnqc Game House playthrough at 0:00 sentiment: positive

video_pk 60182 · mention_pk 152628

Click to watch at 0:00 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

positive

Pros

Brass DNA retained with a Pittsburgh-inspired theme that adds oil and crown jewel industries
Solid three-player balance with meaningful decisions on networks and tiles
Strong thematic flavor tied to Pittsburgh's industrial history (steel, oil, rails)
Encourages long-term strategic planning and end-game scoring opportunities

Cons

Steep learning curve for new Brass players
Prototype/ao balance tweaks noted during the session (stickers, adjustments)
Turn order and market mechanics can be punishing for some players in early eras

Thematic elements

industrial growth, resource extraction, rail networks, and urban development
Eastern United States during the industrial revolution, focusing on the steel belt and the development of crown jewel industries
historical-economic simulation with competitive network-building

Comparison games

Brass: Birmingham
Brass: Lancashire

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

card drafting — players draft and use cards to perform actions
Compound Scoring — periods end with scoring and map progression; end-game determined by total points
crown jewel investments — Powerful developments that significantly affect scoring and strategy
era-based scoring — periods end with scoring and map progression; end-game determined by total points
Loans — Loans provide immediate funds but push players toward negative income if misused
loans / financial risk — Loans provide immediate funds but push players toward negative income if misused
network building — connect rail links to expand markets and routes
Network/route building — connect rail links to expand markets and routes
resource tiles — owning tiles yields resources (iron, coal, oil) and rewards when emptied

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

Brass Pittsburgh is a follow-up to the prior brass games and now offers players new ways to explore the renowned mechanisms from the previous games.
Oil, steel belt, the Pittsburgh Penguins. Boom. That's all I know.
End of era. So Mikey, nine points on the flip—it's big.
The big themes and stuff should not be changing.
Pittsburgh, baby. Let's go.

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video sxSIJt-K6MQ Gamebound game_review at 0:00 sentiment: positive

video_pk 60232 · mention_pk 152663

Click to watch at 0:00 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

positive

Pros

none

Cons

none

Thematic elements

Industrialization, oil, railroads, and steel production shaping cities and economies
Late 19th-century American steel belt during industrial expansion
Historical-industrial simulation with macroeconomic strategy

Comparison games

Brass Birmingham

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

oil_and_pipelines — Oil fields and pipelines are central to Brass Pittsburgh's resource strategy, representing one of the key sectors that drive city-building and connectivity. Players must tap into oil sources to fuel growth and use pipelines to transport resources between industrial hubs. The pipeline network not only fuels production but also creates a spatial strategy element, as players decide where to lay rails and pipes to maximize efficiency while contesting routes with rivals. The interplay between oil extraction, pipeline routing, and the placement of steel mills is designed to create a web of interdependent decisions, where location, timing, and market demand determine who secures the most valuable routes.
premium_deals — Premium deals are a new economic mechanism introduced in Brass Pittsburgh that provide players with powerful, high-value actions or resources in exchange for strategic commitments. These deals function as cards or tiles that players can purchase or activate, creating a dynamic market where the timing of acquisition matters. The mechanic creates tension between immediate gains and long-term positioning, since choosing to take a premium deal can unlock strong synergy with your evolving network (factories, towns, and routes) while potentially depriving opponents of similar opportunities. The design encourages players to weigh the relative value of premium actions against the baseline engine-building options available in a given turn, and it rewards careful resource management and timing as the market shifts with each new round. In practice, premium deals can catalyze dramatic shifts in momentum, as a single well-timed premium can accelerate growth or unlock critical links between industries.
whiskey_wildcard — The whiskey wildcard system introduces a thematic risk element into the economic engine. Whiskey acts as a wildcard resource that can substitute for various commodities or unlock unusual combinations of actions. The unpredictability of whiskey availability injects volatility into planning, forcing players to adapt their short-term tactics to capitalizing on whiskey when it becomes accessible. This mechanic interacts with the core engine in ways that can disrupt an otherwise stable growth curve, creating opportunities for clever players to pivot their strategy mid-game and potentially surprise opponents who cornered a different path. The wildcard nature also encourages diversification in production, distribution, and network-building, as players hedge against the possibility that a crucial commodity may be out of reach when the turn comes around.

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

the whiskey wildcard system adds a touch of unpredictability
Will you rise to power in this industrial revolution or be overtaken by the competition?

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video tkCnIR9TW6c Before You Play playthrough at 0:05 sentiment: positive

video_pk 60184 · mention_pk 152629

Click to watch at 0:05 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

positive

Pros

deep strategic depth for a two-player engine
new resources and mechanics (steel, coke, oil) that diversify strategy
premium deals and skyscraper options add high-end scoring
two-era structure with meaningful end-of-era scoring

Cons

prototype copy means values and components can change in final release
heavy rule complexity; steep learning curve for new players
two-player map can constrict choices relative to higher player counts

Thematic elements

Industrial expansion, resource networks, and economic competition
Gilded Age United States
Array

Comparison games

Brass Lancasher
Brass Birmingham
Brass Lancaster

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

Card-driven action selection — players discard cards to take two actions; the discard drives which actions are available
network/rail and pipeline building — build out rail links and oil pipelines; connections determine resource flow and selling options
Network/route building — build out rail links and oil pipelines; connections determine resource flow and selling options
oil pipelines and sell actions — oil is consumed via pipelines during sells; pipelines grant route-based income bonuses
premium deals and whiskey — premium deal tiles offer large, race-type bonuses; whiskey provides flexibility and star boosting for premium thresholds
Resource management — markets provide resources; you can also buy from Vanderbilt; costs scale with market availability
resource markets and purchasing — markets provide resources; you can also buy from Vanderbilt; costs scale with market availability
tile flipping and end-game scoring — flipped tiles yield ongoing bonuses and end-of-era points; crown jewel tiles have special scoring rules

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

This is actually the third sort of installment in the brass series.
There are new mechanisms. There are new industries as well as new resources including coke, steel, and now oil.
Whiskey... this is Brass Pittsburgh's way of allowing you to have flexibility.
This is prototype copy of the game.
Arrow one, you can make mistakes early in this game, but not late.

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video wuQ4on6Gcbw Unknown Channel game_review at 0:24 sentiment: positive

video_pk 60289 · mention_pk 152719

Click to watch at 0:24 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

positive

Pros

Expanded network types (heavy trains and pipelines) add depth
Persistent networks across eras reduce resets and increase planning
Tighter two-player experience with a refined board
Whiskey and premium deals create tension and reward timing

Cons

Increased decision density may raise complexity
Resource scarcity and Vanderbilt pricing can impact balance
Prototype balancing may change in final version

Thematic elements

Industrial-era networks, resource flow, and economic development
Pittsburgh, North America during the Gilded Age industrial expansion
Historical industrial empire-building with personal resource management

Comparison games

Brass

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

Card-driven turns — players play cards to take turns and plan actions
Era Progression — two eras with persistent networks that influence decisions across eras
network building — connect heavy trains, light trains, and pipelines to move resources and unlock bonuses
Network/route building — connect heavy trains, light trains, and pipelines to move resources and unlock bonuses
pipeline and oil mechanics — pipelines stay from era 1 to era 2; oil fields yield bonuses and future income
Premium deals — sale goals that grant points and bonuses when meeting conditions, often requiring whiskey or timing
Resource management — manage coal, iron, steel, coke, oil, and whiskey with entry of six resource-like elements
whiskey wildcard and stockpiling — whiskey can be used as wild cards or stockpiled for selling actions

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

It's one of those risk things that you have to decide if you wait another turn and you can manage to reach one of these premium deals, is it going to be worth it or is somebody going to steal those resources from you so you no longer can do those actions?
I will absolutely steal those resources from you, just so you know.
We're in Pittsburgh now. We're in North America.
some of the new industries we'll see are kerosene and coke refineries
Definitely lots of decisions.
this brass Pittsburgh game comes with a more refined two-player board.
two-player playthrough next week upon the launch of the campaign.

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video X2NEgvUmw_U Unknown Channel game_review at 0:57 sentiment: positive

video_pk 60173 · mention_pk 152613

Click to watch at 0:57 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

positive

Pros

Deep engine-building core with timing-driven decisions
New oil/pipeline mechanics add fresh strategic layers
Expanded bonuses and cell actions increase player interaction
The thematic flavor is strong, with historical context and humor
Clear linkage between rail/trade networks and scoring progression

Cons

High complexity and a steep learning curve for new players
Potentially long play sessions with intricate bookkeeping
Debt and bankruptcy mechanics can feel punishing if mismanaged
Connectivity and pipeline rules may require careful setup and planning

Thematic elements

Industrialization, railroads, oil capitalism, and urban megastructure growth
Late 19th-century Pittsburgh during a burgeoning industrial era
economic engine-building with timing, negotiation, and risk

Comparison games

Brass: Birmingham
Brass: Lancashire

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

action selection — On each turn, players choose up to two actions (except the first turn uses one) and execute them for various costs and effects, with timing shaping outcomes.
Debt and bankruptcy mechanics — Loans can be taken for strategic payoff, but failure to meet obligations can lead to bankruptcy and penalties.
Economy and income timing — Income levels determine turn order next round; managing cash and timing is crucial to staying ahead.
Loans — Loans can be taken for strategic payoff, but failure to meet obligations can lead to bankruptcy and penalties.
Network/route building — Connecting infrastructure via rail links is essential to access markets and move resources; trains and links drive accessibility.
Oil, pipelines, and energy management — Oil becomes a central resource with its own pipeline system and field actions, introducing new chokepoints and connectivity rules.
Premium deals and tile bonuses — Flip cell bonuses to gain extra rewards; whiskey can supplement to meet premium metrics for higher bonuses.
Rail/railway network connectivity — Connecting infrastructure via rail links is essential to access markets and move resources; trains and links drive accessibility.
Resource management — Resources are consumed and moved via rails; players interact with markets and tile-based bonuses as rewards or costs accrue.
Resource management and markets — Resources are consumed and moved via rails; players interact with markets and tile-based bonuses as rewards or costs accrue.
tile placement — Players place industry tiles to build into cities, discarding matching location or industry cards to enable builds on board spaces.
tile placement and building — Players place industry tiles to build into cities, discarding matching location or industry cards to enable builds on board spaces.
Wild card and whiskey mechanic — Whiskey tools act as wildcards in certain card actions, adding flexibility and a thematic flavor to gameplay decisions.

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

Brass Pittsburgh plays two to four players with mechanics such as hand management, income, and market. The game is of heavy complexity.
The goal is to score the most victory points by the end of era 2.
In Pittsburgh, you are an ambitious industrial titan in late 19th century America.
This is economic engine building, network expansion and resource capitalism served with a side of regretting your play three turns ago.
Everything to trigger your rifles to say, 'H, I was going to do that.'
Congratulations, you've monopolized the market and are the greatest magnate in all of the steel belt.

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video AIVQHPNHfRo Tantrum House game_overview at 1:04 sentiment: positive

video_pk 60233 · mention_pk 152664

Click to watch at 1:04 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

positive

Pros

New oil fields and pipelines add a layered timing and competition
Premium deals introduce timing and efficiency
Whiskey wildcard provides flexible card use
Remains faithful to Brass DNA while evolving the system
Two-era structure with a refined end-game scoring

Cons

Increased complexity compared to Lancaster/Birmingham
Learning curve due to new mechanics like oil/pipeline layering
Potentially longer playtime with extra mechanics

Thematic elements

Industrial expansion, oil, steel, rail and pipeline infrastructure
American Gilded Age, 1865-1913, Pittsburgh steel belt
Economic simulation of industrial empire-building with resource logistics

Comparison games

Lancaster
Birmingham

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

Card discard resource actions — Actions require discarding matching location and industry cards (or whiskey as wild).
Develop action to upgrade tiles — Remove lower-level tiles for higher-level industries; costs iron/steel.
Loans — Discard a card to gain $30; reduce income; cannot drop below -10; no repayment.
Oil fields and competition — Oil fields flip on first connection and provide immediate rewards; oil timing creates race elements.
Premium deals — Premium deal tiles grant bonuses when selling industries matching deal requirements.
Resource infrastructure: trains and pipelines — Networks include light/heavy trains and pipelines; pipelines used for oil.
scoring phases — End of era scoring based on train links and flipped industries; level one tiles are removed in era two; pipelines stay.
Tile/Map Shifting — Remove lower-level tiles for higher-level industries; costs iron/steel.
Turn order by spending — Money spent on a turn is tracked and order is determined by total spent at end of round.
Two-action turns — Era one starts with one action per player; later turns grant two actions per turn after discarding a card.
Whiskey wildcard system — Whiskey acts as wild card for building to substitute for either card type.

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

This whiskey [snorts] system replaces Birmingham's scout action.
Oil fields introduce this like race element. When a player connects to an oil field for the first time, that oil field actually flips and provides immediate rewards.
Premium deals are a notable new addition here.
The core structure remains the same, but the industrial chains and the infrastructure feel different from both earlier titles.
Pittsburgh is going to lean heavily into oil, steel, and large-scale infrastructure dominance.
The theme is actually, if you've played these games, it's not just cosmetic. It influences how the systems interact with each other while you play.

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video R106o4Qo33Y Unknown Channel top_10_list at 2:24 sentiment: positive

video_pk 59407 · mention_pk 151964

Click to watch at 2:24 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

positive

Pros

Stays true to Brass themes and elegance while introducing Pittsburgh-specific twists
New map and two-player variant introduce fresh strategic options
Strong thematic alignment with the industrial era and whiskey as a resource

Cons

none

Thematic elements

Industrialization, market networks, and regional specialization
Industrial-era Pittsburgh, late 19th century
Eurogame-like economic simulation with historical theming

Comparison games

none

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

engine building — Players develop an economic engine by building industries and connecting markets, optimizing supply and demand across a railroad/network layout.
engine_building — Players develop an economic engine by building industries and connecting markets, optimizing supply and demand across a railroad/network layout.
network_and_market — Players lay down networks and interact with a decentralized market system that influences resource availability and scoring opportunities.

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

From what I can see, I'm excited to hear uh about the experience that play testers have had with Pittsburgh.
I'm excited to see the new map, the variations they were making to various buildings.
And so I'm super excited for Pittsburgh this year.

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video 28XkKDV6XO0 top_10_list at 16:19 sentiment: positive

video_pk 59482 · mention_pk 152033

Click to watch at 16:19 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

positive

Pros

More approachable Brass experience
Excellent balance of depth and accessibility

Cons

Similar flavor to Brass; may feel familiar to fans

Thematic elements

Economic engine-building and network expansion
Industrial revolution in Birmingham with refined networks
Accessible yet deep reuse of Brass mechanics

Comparison games

Brass
Power Grid
Concordia

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

engine building — Build an efficient industrial network via cards and tiles
engine-building — Build an efficient industrial network via cards and tiles
network integration — Integration of tiles and actions to maximize revenue

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

it's a wonderful starter game for nearly anyone.
how have I not played dominion
when I played Dominion I just felt like an absolute idiot
the quintessential racing game out there
it's an absolutely brilliant game
the best network builder of all time

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video OY_vbD9bYyY general_discussion at 17:17

video_pk 59451 · mention_pk 152005

Click to watch at 17:17 · YouTube ↗

Pros

none

Cons

none

Thematic elements

economic development, industry, and trade
industrial-era Birmingham, England, during the industrial revolution
historical realism with economic strategy

Comparison games

Gaia Project
Concordia
Food Chain Magnate

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

economic engine-building — players develop a network of industries to generate income and points
engine building — players develop a network of industries to generate income and points
Network/route building — connecting industries to maximize production and efficiency
route-building/connection — connecting industries to maximize production and efficiency

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

I'm definitely into Dragon Eclipse right now
I just have to bribe my youngest son to play 12 games with me on that
Primal The Awakening I actually have here on my desk I'm playing it right this second
I've never taken money for a preview
if you're not consistent you're never going to get seen

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video P4eHtwCKkko Board of It top_10_list at 14:59 sentiment: positive

video_pk 42357 · mention_pk 128538

Click to watch at 14:59 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

positive

Pros

Very balanced, highly regarded in the board game community
Tightly designed economic engine with strong theme

Cons

Can require careful planning to avoid bottlenecks
Some players find the starter experience challenging

Thematic elements

industrialization, canal/rail networks, and economic competition
Industrial England, Midlands from 1770 to 1870
historical and strategic with a strong thematic core

Comparison games

none

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

Market and route optimization — Move goods and optimize production to maximize income and victory points.
Network/route building — Move goods and optimize production to maximize income and victory points.
tile placement — Lay tiles representing industry and connect them with canals and railways.
Tile placement & network building — Lay tiles representing industry and connect them with canals and railways.

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

this is a really solid euro game by one of our favorite designers Alexander Pfister and one of our favorite publishers Capstone Games
the reason we're not drinking this right now is because this is actually a friend's bottle
it's elevated if you have a glass of wine to go with it
it's an excellent euro game and alexander definitely has a very distinct style
it's a very very funny game and also the RPG elements
this is a really great game to play and you should check it out
it's a lovely little cocktail try it out
it's a very popular game

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video gZwgWtMjWOQ analysis at 1:43 sentiment: neutral

video_pk 41854 · mention_pk 152542

Click to watch at 1:43 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

neutral

Pros

none

Cons

none

Thematic elements

Economic engine-building and network development
Industrial England during the Industrial Revolution
Economic-simulation flavor focused on production, routes, and connectivity

Comparison games

none

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

economic competition / resource management — Optimize resources like coal, iron, money to maximize scoring opportunities.
engine building — Players develop an economic engine through production and connections.
engine-building — Players develop an economic engine through production and connections.
hand management — Cards determine available actions; players manage a hand to optimize turns.
hand-management / card-driven actions — Cards determine available actions; players manage a hand to optimize turns.
Network/route building — Players build networks of canals and railways to improve income.
Resource management — Optimize resources like coal, iron, money to maximize scoring opportunities.
route-building — Players build networks of canals and railways to improve income.

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

AI is in board games now.
AI is just another tool. It's not some evil force descending from the heavens to personally ruin your copy of brass Birmingham.
Yes, AI in board games, yes, absolutely.
I'm much more interested in whether the final game is good or not than in every single step of the creative process.
AI should be viewed as part of a toolkit like you would when you're creating anything.
Is AI the next useful step in the board gaming industry, or do you think the hobby should treat it like you're holding a dog ended barge pole?
That whole video was made with AI.

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video fyKid_dkx1c top_20_list at 49:25 sentiment: positive

video_pk 41076 · mention_pk 148189

Click to watch at 49:25 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

positive

Pros

tight sandbox with rich interaction
clear yet deep scoring structure

Cons

complex to teach; strategic depth can overwhelm casual players

Thematic elements

Comparison games

Maracaibo
Terra Mystica

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

economy and scoring through linking buildings — points come from how well your links and buildings perform.
network-building — players build a network of industry connections in a evolving map.
Network/route building — players build a network of industry connections in a evolving map.
Point Salad — points come from how well your links and buildings perform.

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

the central mechanic of pulling chips and push your luck is so much fun
it's a brain burner because everything is connected
the dice mechanism... it's tight and open information
the narrative tension of Final Girl keeps delivering memorable moments
the balance of speed versus efficiency in Great Western Trail is brilliant
Race for the Galaxy remains a fantastic quick puzzle with a strong core system

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video NPT9wBZ0WfE Board Gaming Doctor top_10_list at 11:54 sentiment: positive

video_pk 40219 · mention_pk 121642

Click to watch at 11:54 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

positive

Pros

Masterful design with deep strategic depth
High replayability and variability with different setups

Cons

Steep learning curve
Digital implementation could improve accessibility

Thematic elements

Economic development, industry, and market dynamics
Industrial England during the brass era
Array

Comparison games

none

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

Competition & blocking — Block and utilize spaces to gain advantage.
economic engine building — Construct networks and industries to power growth.
engine building — Construct networks and industries to power growth.
Supply chains / city interactions — Coordinate coal, buildings, and markets for scoring.

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

This is all an effort to rerank my collection
here are the honorable mentions there are 29 games unique games that start with the letter b
Brass Birmingham is the number one game of all time as according to Board Game Geek

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video aWUxb2mGibU Unknown Channel general_discussion at 5:33 sentiment: positive

video_pk 38510 · mention_pk 152120

Click to watch at 5:33 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

positive

Pros

Beloved by many gamers
deep engine-building and strategic planning

Cons

Complex rules for new players
heavy weight may deter casual players

Thematic elements

Industrial revolution, economic engine-building
Industrial England during the canal era and the rail era
historical economic simulation, procedural progression

Comparison games

none

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

engine building — Players develop and optimize an economic engine to produce goods and score points.
engine-building — Players develop and optimize an economic engine to produce goods and score points.
network_building — Connecting canals/rail routes to maximize production and transport.
Network/route building — Connecting canals/rail routes to maximize production and transport.
Resource management — Managing coal, iron, and other resources to build industries.
resource_management — Managing coal, iron, and other resources to build industries.

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

That was clearly and obviously Brass Birmingham.
Ticket to Ride Europe.
King Domino.
Brass Birmingham is a game much beloved by many.
It couldn't have been clearer. That was quite obviously Great Western Trail.
Sky Team.

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video vpTOE23Ji8Q Board Sh top_40_list at 6:32 sentiment: positive

video_pk 35607 · mention_pk 106391

Click to watch at 6:32 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

positive

Pros

robust economic engine and tight player interaction
strong production and thematic weight
deep, satisfying strategic choices

Cons

production and component familiarity can be intimidating for newcomers

Thematic elements

economic development, network building, and industry
Industrial revolution-era Britain
historical economic simulation with strategic depth

Comparison games

Brass: Birmingham vs Brass: Lancashire

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

economic engine building — players develop networks of industries and transport links to maximize income and score
engine building — players develop networks of industries and transport links to maximize income and score

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

"tile placement and open market..., it's a smooth and perfect tile placement game"
"Cascadia is a fantastic game that you can play with everyone"
"endless winter paleo Americans is wide and thinky; a big, ambitious euro"
"mind management is the best sort of one game you can buy"
"production is insane—deluxe, beautiful components"
"unsettled is a giant puzzle with every planet different"
"Iki is a tremendous Euro game I absolutely love"

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video 25x2uxxY83w Unknown Channel general_discussion at 14:07 sentiment: positive

video_pk 35515 · mention_pk 149917

Click to watch at 14:07 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

positive

Pros

Deep economic engine with high interaction
Polished design and modern classic status

Cons

Steep learning curve and heavy rules
Longer playtime

Thematic elements

Economic engine-building and network development
Industrial revolution in Birmingham
Dense economic strategy with tight interaction

Comparison games

Lancashire
Lancashire

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

hand management — Manage cards to perform actions and build networks
Network/route building — Create networks and connect cities for points
Route Building — Create networks and connect cities for points

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

"Bonanza does a great job of putting that negotiation forward and creating more of a social interactive experience that I feel like Katan offers as a Euro game that is somewhat unique amongst Euro games today"
"Katan by creating that social interaction the fluidity and the kind of non-scripted approach to that"
"Sleeping Gods is an amazing experience very reminiscent of an open world game"
"This is definitely a step up in complexity"

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video CRQrwr8CIrw Unknown Channel game_review at 0:00 sentiment: mixed

video_pk 34114 · mention_pk 101579

Click to watch at 0:00 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

mixed

Pros

Tight planning and scheduling due to the deck structure and two-era arc
High tension and meaningful competition for key spaces and exports
Card versatility provides multiple strategic angles and responses
The two eras offer a satisfying long-term strategic arc and replayability

Cons

The canal-to-rail transition can feel unrewarding as existing networks may be removed
Pottery upgrade costs and the notion of a free second level can be confounding
The Sim symbols on the player board can be non-intuitive and easy to misread

Thematic elements

industrial development, network-building, market dynamics, and regional growth
Industrial revolution-era Midlands England, canal era transitioning to rail era
analytical with passionate advocacy; candid critique woven into a personal journey through the game’s systems

Comparison games

Brass (original)
Brass Birmingham (this title) – comparison within the Brass family

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

Card-driven tile placement — Players place industries on the board using industry-named cards or generic actions, with cards offering multiple placement options and trade-offs.
Compound Scoring — The canal era ends with scoring and removal of canal networks and level-1 industries; the rail era then begins with renewed opportunities and scoring.
Economy ramps and timing pressure — The game increments pressure as you balance loans, income, and VP potential, with increasing strategic tension between fast VP gains and steady income growth.
engine building — Early rounds emphasize building income; later rounds shift focus toward converting revenue into victory points, driving strategic pivots.
Exporting with beer costs and competition for board spaces — Exporting goods incurs beer costs; the first exporters get a beer bonus, and competition for spaces and materials creates tense decisions.
Flow between income engine and victory-point engine — Early rounds emphasize building income; later rounds shift focus toward converting revenue into victory points, driving strategic pivots.
hand management — Each turn you play two cards, then draw back up to a fixed hand; the deck is exhausted and reshuffled over two eras, shaping planning and timing.
hand management and deck cycling — Each turn you play two cards, then draw back up to a fixed hand; the deck is exhausted and reshuffled over two eras, shaping planning and timing.
Loans — The game increments pressure as you balance loans, income, and VP potential, with increasing strategic tension between fast VP gains and steady income growth.
Player Board | Main Board — Each industry’s upgrade costs and Sim symbols require careful attention; misreading costs can lead to costly mistakes, increasing cognitive load.
Sim symbols and explicit cost tracking on player boards — Each industry’s upgrade costs and Sim symbols require careful attention; misreading costs can lead to costly mistakes, increasing cognitive load.
Staged development with unusual cost structure (Pottery example) — Industries require multiple upgrade actions; some levels are free yet require more actions to reach higher tiers, producing a counterintuitive but strategic dynamic.
tile placement — Players place industries on the board using industry-named cards or generic actions, with cards offering multiple placement options and trade-offs.
Two-era structure with end-of-era scoring — The canal era ends with scoring and removal of canal networks and level-1 industries; the rail era then begins with renewed opportunities and scoring.

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

I can't help it I love this game
I don't like it
it's not sad satisfying in any way
the planning in that is so compelling for me I love it
I love the tension that you experience in this game
these two eras really matter for strategy

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video cOi7zeHcfaw War Game Garden top_10_list at 11:59 sentiment: positive

video_pk 33928 · mention_pk 101058

Click to watch at 11:59 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

positive

Pros

deep, crunchy gameplay
unique economic loop

Cons

heavier to learn and table time

Thematic elements

Comparison games

none

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

economic engine-building — heavy network building and income sequencing
engine building — heavy network building and income sequencing

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

Castles of Burgundy oh my goodness I love this game so much
Cascadia is definitely one of the lighter of the bunch
I would freaking love in the future to compete in this

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video 90H8HHsJmw8 Board Stupid general_discussion at 23:41 sentiment: positive

video_pk 32757 · mention_pk 97060

Click to watch at 23:41 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

positive

Pros

Deep, satisfying Euro mechanics
Strong thematic immersion
Solid for groups who enjoy economic strategy

Cons

Steep learning curve
Can be lengthy to play

Thematic elements

Merchants building networks and industries
Industrial-era economic simulation
Historical economic progression

Comparison games

Hansa Teutonica
Castles of Burgundy

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

engine building — Players develop an economic network of industries to generate income.
engine-building — Players develop an economic network of industries to generate income.
Network/route building — Players connect cities and resources to optimize production and deliveries.
route/network building — Players connect cities and resources to optimize production and deliveries.

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

the library I've had to look is freaking awesome
the board gamer community is one of the finest community of all the obbies it is
99.999% people are nice and just want to play games and have fun
wash your hands wash your hands damn it
probably don't plan too much
it's four days long
airon is known as the friendly and inclusive gaming space

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video riFmwc3vYsE Unknown Channel top_10_list at 17:26 sentiment: positive

video_pk 31416 · mention_pk 92547

Click to watch at 17:26 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

positive

Pros

Deep, interlocking strategy
High player interaction

Cons

Long playtime; can be heavy for casual games

Thematic elements

economic development and network construction
Industrial Revolution, Birmingham region

Comparison games

Lancashire

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

Card-driven action selection — Cards influence actions and can unlock bonuses
engine building — Build networks, develop industries, and score via multiple tracks
engine-building/economic development — Build networks, develop industries, and score via multiple tracks

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

My number five is a game called Foxy.
The way you score is so seamless.
It's so cozy.
I've really enjoyed the two-player mode.
There are a ton of different ways to score in this game
I cannot wait to dive into it
I understand the hype.
I will rank Birmingham high after playing more.

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video -xihR3ePRSY Unknown Channel rules teach at 0:00 sentiment: positive

video_pk 30952 · mention_pk 91257

Click to watch at 0:00 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

positive

Pros

Approachable card-driven complexity
High strategic depth
Thematic immersion through historic details
Dynamic market that reacts to supply and demand
Two eras add depth and progression

Cons

none

Thematic elements

Network building and economic development driven by canals transitioning to rail
Industrial England during the canal and rail eras of the Industrial Revolution
Historical realism with eurogame abstraction

Comparison games

none

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

Build / route network — Construct industries and connections within a growing network.
card drafting — Play two cards per turn to execute actions; discarding cards to access market or build routes.
card play / drafting — Play two cards per turn to execute actions; discarding cards to access market or build routes.
closed economy — A communal pool of resources with supply and demand driving the economy.
Era Progression — Two distinct eras (canal era and rail era) with canal routes replaced by rail routes.
hand management — Players manage a hand of cards to build industries or take actions; discarding cards for other actions.
market economy — A communal pool of resources with supply and demand driving the economy.
Network/route building — Construct industries and connections within a growing network.
Resource management — Balancing scarce resources and cash to expand the network.

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

The cardplay mechanic makes for approachable complexity while maintaining a high level of strategic depth.
Brass Birmingham is enriched with historic details to make it feel more thematically immersive.

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video bzNMsAvgaLk Board Game Biographies analysis at 13:20 sentiment: positive

video_pk 29187 · mention_pk 85798

Click to watch at 13:20 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

positive

Pros

Beautiful art and strong thematic fidelity to industrial Midlands
Clear representation of the era’s infrastructure challenges and opportunities
Biographies add historical flavor and accessibility

Cons

Thematic heaviness and historical brutality can be off-putting
Can be complex and lengthy for new players

Thematic elements

Industrialization, coal/iron/brass economy
Midlands, Birmingham and surrounding towns, Victorian era
Grim realism

Comparison games

Arkwright
Stevenson's Rocket

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

Compound Scoring — Players score prestige based on network reach and efficiency, with interactions and shared infrastructure.
Market and scoring — Players score prestige based on network reach and efficiency, with interactions and shared infrastructure.
Network/route building — Players construct a regional network; the quality of transport depends on network strength and efficiency.
Network/track building — Players construct a regional network; the quality of transport depends on network strength and efficiency.
Resource management — Coal, iron, and brass drive production and onward movement of goods.

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

you start the game with 50 pounds and two factories
the cheaper you sell for the more appealing they are
in this game you win by being the best at doing the trains
like in stevenson's rocket you'll be transporting goods using tracks
the board implies a grottiness that a lot of people felt at the time
two sides of the board in brass a day and a night side
the more beer you drink the more successful you'll be

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video sz5Dmz7xpbw Chairman of the Board general_discussion at 6:02 sentiment: positive

video_pk 13314 · mention_pk 83073

Click to watch at 6:02 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

positive

Pros

one of the designer's strongest titles
tight economic tension and great pacing

Cons

heavy and long for casual nights

Thematic elements

economic development with network building
Industrial England
dense economic simulation

Comparison games

Power Grid
Railways of the World

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

bag building — hidden information via draw from a bag
bag_building — hidden information via draw from a bag
economic_simulation — build an industrial network and manage markets

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

probably my favorite tire placement game of all time
this one is like a companion game to el grande
Arc Nova certainly the hotness at the moment

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video i3GXGJ-OUjI playthrough at 0:00 sentiment: positive

video_pk 13060 · mention_pk 38165

Click to watch at 0:00 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

positive

Pros

Strategic depth
Complex economic interactions
Dynamic gameplay

Cons

Complex for new players
Requires careful planning

Thematic elements

Economic Development
Industrial Revolution England
Competitive Economic Simulation

Comparison games

none

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

economic engine building — Developing businesses and infrastructure
engine building — Developing businesses and infrastructure
network building — Connecting cities and industries
Network/route building — Connecting cities and industries

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

I felt like I was being reactionary getting the booze and iron built along with Pottery but it all seemed to work out well

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video i5S9ODHse9o Three Minute Board Games top_10_list at 5:23 sentiment: positive

video_pk 12851 · mention_pk 94642

Click to watch at 5:23 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

positive

Pros

Highly interconnected and dynamic economy
Opportunistic play that rewards tactful trading

Cons

Potential for analysis paralysis in tight games
Requires careful negotiation to maximize synergy

Thematic elements

economic interdependence and network-building
Industrial era in England
strategic economic engine with player interdependence

Comparison games

Traditionally themed economic/area-control strategy games

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

Interconnected networks — Players’ actions ripple through the map, creating dynamic opportunities and rivalries.
Network/route building — Players’ actions ripple through the map, creating dynamic opportunities and rivalries.
Resource exchange with other players — Spending other players' resources can flip their buildings and provide XP/points.

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

Clues are used to seal gates in the game which is one of the main ways of winning
one at a time after any skill check failed or not each spent clue token allows the player to roll one additional die and the result is a success
the Provost can be moved up and down the board
it's a fantastic atmosphere at the table
the greatness in games is that they're fun and enjoyable
you trick yourself into spending your important resource Clues into passing a check out of desperation
trades are binding and you can't lie
success is harder to move forward from than failure

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video dfCcLi9vSC0 Secret Cabal general_discussion at 57:41 sentiment: positive

video_pk 12722 · mention_pk 37115

Click to watch at 57:41 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

positive

Pros

Rich economic depth and strategic choices
Beautiful production values

Cons

Heavy rules and long play time
Can be punishing for newcomers

Thematic elements

economic development and railway expansion
Industrial revolution in Birmingham
dense economic strategy with economic engine

Comparison games

Brass: Birmingham vs Brass: Lancashire
Power Grid (economic engine comparison)

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

Economic engine / network building — Players grow networks and industries through rail and markets.

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

Artwork does have a big impact on my interest in playing the game.
I bought games just for artwork that I've never played.
Santorini doesn't turn me off, and Arcadia Quest doesn't turn me off exactly but I would prefer it to be more realistic in general.
I think games with Xavier Colette his kind of artwork he did the a lot of the dixit stuff.
I love getting up and coming down here and shooting a video and editing a podcast and developing content for the next show.
quit drinking soda it's poison.
Feast for Odin is a Viking-era title that rewards careful planning.

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video QtdDZNz_beQ Rolls in the Family top_3_list at 17:03 sentiment: positive

video_pk 12564 · mention_pk 126453

Click to watch at 17:03 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

positive

Pros

Fascinating board-state growth and tactical decision points
High interaction and strategic depth; satisfying engine dynamics
Strong reception and status in the hobby (BGG #1 at the time)

Cons

Very heavy and lengthy; not for casual gamers
Learning curve can be steep for new players

Thematic elements

Industrialization, market strategy, and network expansion
Industrial England during the Birmingham era; coal, iron, and rail
Heavy economic strategy with evolving board state as the game progresses

Comparison games

Yellow and Yangtze
Cascadia
Hive

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

card-driven system — Cards guide actions and shape orchestration of the play area each turn.
economic engine-building — Players develop networks and production to flip tiles and score through shipments.
engine building — Players develop networks and production to flip tiles and score through shipments.
tile/market interaction — Market demand and coal/oil/iron resources drive decision-making and value.

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

it's such a great combination of satisfying engine building and tight worker placement
this is the number one game on Board Game Geek
it's a hot game right now
the module variability is great; eight standalone maps
it's such an interesting combination of mechanisms here
one of my favorite games to introduce to people

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video t5Tv1XSteGA Board Game Ango top_10_list at 5:45 sentiment: positive

video_pk 12294 · mention_pk 35872

Click to watch at 5:45 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

very positive

Pros

Interactive gameplay
Economic ecosystem

Cons

none

Thematic elements

Industrial development
Industrial Birmingham
Economic interaction

Comparison games

none

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

Resource management — Building industries and delivering resources

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

we put in the time and effort to play the best Euro AKA Resource Management games
each game will feel completely because you will have completely different cards

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video u0wDdQWJ5EQ Unknown game_review at 29:13 sentiment: positive

video_pk 11872 · mention_pk 34772

Click to watch at 29:13 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

positive

Pros

Intense strategic decision-making
Tight action selection
Blend of long-term strategy and tactical decisions

Cons

none

Thematic elements

Economic development
Industrial Revolution England

Comparison games

none

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

card-based action selection — Players use cards to build railways and industries

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

Take this as just my opinion, it's my gut feelings on a game
If I say I don't like a game that you enjoy don't let that take away from the fact that you enjoy the game

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video rNdlbJ19hO8 board_game_discussion at 0:33 sentiment: positive

video_pk 11406 · mention_pk 33527

Click to watch at 0:33 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

positive

Pros

Complex Euro game
Innovative design

Cons

none

Thematic elements

Economic development

Comparison games

Gloomhaven
Puerto Rico
Twilight Struggle

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

Mechanics unknown.

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

the number one game is kind of like the face of the hobby
I can push and pull and do whatever I freaking want to do based on my mood
there's not really a good concrete objective objective

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video EZNG-YXgO7E Foster the Meatballer general_discussion at 2:25 sentiment: positive

video_pk 11377 · mention_pk 33445

Click to watch at 2:25 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

positive

Pros

tight, interlocking engine with multiple viable paths
high replay value and strategic depth

Cons

lesson to play can be steep; long first session
player interaction can be limited in some variants

Thematic elements

industrial growth, mining, and rail expansion
Industrial Revolution era in Birmingham, England
economic strategy with network building

Comparison games

Agricola
Railways of the World

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

hand management — select actions from a personal card hand to develop industry
Network/link-building — connect coal, iron, and cloth markets through a network to maximize income

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

this is the a to z board game challenge
we love to challenge ourselves and each other
there's no timer this isn't speed round because there's going to be some where it's going to be harder
you should definitely do this at home it was super fun
that is not easy that is so much harder than you would think

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video Jn5N-8aXoxU Not Specified game_guessing_game at 0:21 sentiment: neutral

video_pk 10513 · mention_pk 30928

Click to watch at 0:21 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

neutral

Pros

none

Cons

none

Thematic elements

Industrial Development
Industrial Era England

Comparison games

none

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

Canal building — Involves constructing canal networks
Train Routes — Involves building train connections

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

You have 10 seconds to figure out which board game is hiding underneath this blanket

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Have you heard of Brass: Pittsburgh?

Brass: Pittsburgh - Teach & Playthrough

Brass unboxing with Board Game Coffee

Brass: Birmingham

Have you heard of Brass: Pittsburgh?

Brass: Pittsburgh - Teach & Playthrough

Brass unboxing with Board Game Coffee

Welcome Friend

Create a New Guild