The Problem with Brass: Birmingham and Why I STILL Love It
Transcript
I can't help it I love this game why do I love this game oh why why I'm so mad at these flaws about it and I love this game normally when I do a review I start with an overview of the rules but there's already a lot of material on YouTube about this so I can give you a link in the description to something more thorough or you can check out my 62nd review in a sentence brass Birmingham is an industrial revolution game where players are building factories and networks by playing cards that's what the game is about now the elements that make the game distinct and what there is to like or dislike about it that is the subject of this video so we'll start with the big reason the one thing that really had me sort of going I don't know I don't know if I want to play this game the reason being in grass there are two eras a canal era and a rail era so during the canal era You're Building Industries and you're connecting things with canals but at the end of that era everything is scored and then all of the canals and level one Industries get removed from the board now that concept is consistent both in the original brass game and in brass Birmingham and then once the whole board is cleared you start to the second ERA
with rails where you're once again building a network this time using rails I don't like that I didn't like it when I first learned it I don't like it now it is the one thing about the game that just annoys me because it's frustrating to put in effort to build a network you get your points for it and then it just goes away taking your pieces your hard-earned pieces off the board it's it's not sad satisfying in any way it's not satisfying in any way I don't like it I still don't like it in fact I almost want to say I wish it wasn't there except I I do wish it was there here here's here's the reason why despite my distaste for it it really uh affects the game strategy because of that halfway point of scoring you can put pieces on the board and score them and then start the second round with a lot more victory points or you can take a different approach where you build things and try to get the most money and maybe you don't have a lot of points at the beginning of the second era but you have more money to buy things it really gives you a really interesting choice about how you're going to play the game second thing now this I only learned from playing brass Birmingham because you have a player board where all of your tiles every industry you can build is laid out on your player board and the
upgrade cost which is the costs of placing those tiles is displayed for each one the weird thing about brass is that there's very little meaning in what it costs to upgrade these industries and I think the best example of this is the pottery uh the pottery factories I think that's what it's called so in Pottery the first one is very very expensive ensive it's hard to get that first tile on the board and significantly you can't develop through it there's a there's a thing about development where you can kind of skip levels but you can't skip the first level in pottery and then this second level is free so the first level is expensive expensive the second level free and worth hardly any victory points at all the third level expensive expensive expensive the fourth level free like thematically explain that to me you could seriously write me a comment and explain that to me why is the second level free now mechanically I know exactly why the second level is free the second level is free because the emphasis in this industry is that it needs to take more actions to develop the higher leveled Pottery uh factories so in order to get to level three and get those victory points it's not enough that it would take one action to get it on the the board you have to take two
actions the first action is free and then the second action is actually the valuable one that's like the mechanical concept the Strategic value of making it free I understand mechanically why that influences the strategy but thematically it's just weird to me in fact I was playing with this with somebody else who's playing for the first time and my piece of advice was you have to watch and pay attention to the to the Sim symbols on your player board because it's not intuitive and you're going to find yourself making a mistake where you think something costs one thing and you find out you were wrong and I warned him and I told him to check and then sure enough during the game when somebody was doing an export and they didn't pay their beer he's like how are you not paying beer for that and we're like well because it's free he's like free like yeah look at the board he's like oh it's free you are right that's not intuitive at all hate it all right those are my two I only have two reasons I have two reasons to not like this game boom I can't help it I love this game why do I love this game oh why why I'm so mad at these flaws about it and I love this game one I always love games that have a set number of turns so in brass Birmingham you have your cards that are dealt to you you play two cards on your turn and then at the end of your turn you draw two cards cards so you always have uh eight cards in the game
and then you play through the entire deck and then once the deck Runs Out you play through all of your cards until you have no cards left and then once everyone is out of cards the era ends there's two eras so basically you go through the deck twice and that for those last several turns when you have eight cards in your hand and you know you're not going to be replacing any you know exactly like all right this is what I have I have four turns left how am I going to do it the planning in that is so compelling for me I love it and you get to do it twice because there's two eras again great argument for the two eras thing I love that the cards can be used for multiple purposes the big thing is placing Industries on the board that's like the biggest way to score victory points uh and you can place a industry on the board by either using a card that has that the name of the industry on it or the location the named location where you want to place in Industry every other action doesn't require a specific card you simply discard anything so if you want to sell you just discard anything if you want to build a connection discard anything uh if you don't like your hand you can discard a card to replace two other cards with wild cards that's cool and it's has a very difficult decision-making space where it's like okay if I discard this to build a connection I lose my chance to use the card to build the industry awesome and then thirdly because there's a set number of rounds uh the game has this really interesting ramp up between
building an income uh engine and building a victory Point engine first couple of rounds maybe you're taking some loans and then as you start to establish sources of revenue you don't have to worry about loans anymore and you can start thinking about how to get more victory points on the game I like that transition where the the strategy sort of shifts what you realize all right I'm at the point where I have enough money to pay for the things that will get me victory points the next thing I love about the game is the tension that you experience in this game there's tension on many levels one is about the rewards that you get for exporting Goods there is what in the game because exporting costs beer there is a free beer bonus for the first people that can deliver exports so there's competition to get that in then there's competition for the spaces on the board uh either for various Industries or for areas where coal and iron are available and the cost of iron and coal sometimes the cost will go up or down because there's a very Dynamic economy in this game and you need to seize the moment you know you could be planning on your turn to do one thing and then when finally it comes around to your turn you realize well I had it in my mind to do this but the cost of iron is so low right now I think I'm GNA have to develop instead because I can't I can't let this opportunity get by I love that games
where it matters it really matters what your opponents do absolutely love that about brass Birmingham so this is where I am today I have identified the things that are pitfalls about the game and I have also identified that I don't care I want to play this game again I want to see if I can get better at playing off of what my opponents do I want to see if I can improve on that on that strategy of that shift between making money and making victory points I want to play the game again because the card management the hand management is so interesting to me so ultimately brass Birmingham is indeed a great game thank you for watching and I'll see you next time bye-bye