City of Gears Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About City of Gears
City of Gears is an area control and engine-building game set in a steampunk clockwork city. It was designed by Chris Leader and Darrell Andrews and published by Grey Fox Games, with an original release in 2012 and a 2018 Kickstarter re-release. Meeple University placed it at light to medium complexity, with a wide range of options and variable setups that support replayability. Pair of Dice Paradise described a first impression that is far more intimidating than the play itself, since the tiles, gears, and bag of components look complicated until the rules have been taught.
Pair of Dice Paradise said the game is neither a high stakes heavy game nor a light filler, and placed it in a sweet spot between those for family play and game nights. Anticipation before release centered on interaction. In an Essen 2018 preview, Actualol singled out the chance to influence other players within a strategy game, along with what seemed to be a very unique mechanism. The main criticisms raised in these videos concern the physical handling of the tiles and a few unexplained icons, discussed below.
Core Mechanics That Define City of Gears
Area Control
Area control gives City of Gears its competitive structure. Nine city tiles are revealed over the course of a game. Once the last one is revealed, the game ends after a countdown, and each tile is scored by the robots and gear links players have on it. Meeple University explained that whichever player has the most controls the tile and gains its points. Gear links do double duty: they act as bridges that let workers travel across the city, and they count toward control. Pair of Dice Paradise described the race this creates. Opponents who lay their gears first can wall off a sector, since a worker can only cross gears its owner has placed, forcing a rival to spend zap resources to blow up a blocking gear or to find another route.
Resource Management
Each round begins with a roll of three dice showing zap, cog, and steam, which are combined with resources from the player's existing engine. Meeple University stressed that stockpiling is limited: at the end of a turn a player may store only four leftover resources and discards the rest. Players must therefore build a resource-producing engine to take actions in each round, and the economy rewards planning ahead rather than hoarding. Resources are spent on basic actions such as drawing and placing development gears, placing gear links, moving robots, and attacking opponents.
The City of Gears Experience
Interactive and Dynamic
Pair of Dice Paradise describes a board that changes beneath the players. The reviewer did not notice until about three quarters of the way through the first game that rivals could block a sector, because a worker can only cross gear links its owner has placed. Once that became clear, gears became something to contest rather than merely something to place, and the reviewer found the game had far more strategic depth than expected. Every turn then carries a need to watch what others are doing, since a rival's next gear can cut off a route you had planned to use.
Confrontational, on a Dial
Conflict in City of Gears is present but adjustable. Players can destroy a rival's gear links, and Meeple University summarized attacks as returning opponents' robots to their home base or destroying their gear links entirely. Pair of Dice Paradise noted that the table layout itself sets the level of conflict: the rulebook includes an alternate arrangement that adds an extra tile around the outer edge of the board and produces a much less confrontational game. Hostility is therefore partly decided during setup and then sustained by the choices players make on their turns.
What Makes City of Gears Stand Out
Modular Cities With Real Replay
Pair of Dice Paradise praised the modular tile system. The box contains 21 unique city tiles, of which only nine are used in any game, producing at least a dozen combinations before counting layout variations. The bag holds 40 gears, and each factory uses five per game, so a four-player group can go about two full games before seeing the same gear twice. Layouts are not limited to a strict 3x3 grid. A 4x4 board, a mix of rectangular sections, and asymmetrical designs are all valid, giving groups control over how crowded the city feels.
Accessible Depth After the First Game
Pair of Dice Paradise found the rules easy to take in. The group did not consult the rulebook any more than for other games of similar size, and the game moves at a brisk pace while still offering enough decisions to feel substantial. Meeple University's rules video reinforces this structure by presenting each round as four clear phases: produce resources, activate city tiles, perform actions, and spoil overages.
Potential Drawbacks
Fiddly Tiles and a Missing Frame
The most pointed complaint concerns handling the tiles. Pair of Dice Paradise described the die-cut city tiles as possibly the most fiddly components the reviewer has used, since flipping one face up often disturbs its neighbors and forces the grid to be repositioned. The reviewer admitted that part of the problem was their own habit of straightening tiles, and noted that each tile is flipped only once per game. Still, every player in the group independently suggested a board underlay or frame to hold the tiles in place, while the reviewer doubted the added production cost would be worth it.
Unexplained Icons and a Heavy-Looking First Session
Pair of Dice Paradise reported a few icons that appeared during play without a full description in the rulebook, so the group had to guess how they worked until an instructional video clarified them. Because the game looks intimidating on the table, new players may expect more complexity than the rules deliver, so teaching the game before play helps set expectations for the first session.
If You Enjoy City of Gears
Pair of Dice Paradise compared the game to Forbidden Island and Downforce, two of the reviewer's favorite gateway games, and said City of Gears is a little more than a typical gateway game. Players who enjoy those titles and want more decisions per turn will find City of Gears a natural next step, particularly for the way its area control and resource engine reward planning. Players drawn to its gear-link contests, where one rival's placement can reshape the board for everyone, will appreciate the shared table tension it creates.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"Well it opened up a whole new layer of strategy, a whole new layer of interest in the game, and it was really not something I was expecting to experience. I wasn't thinking that this game would actually have that much potential bite to it."
— Chaz Muller, Pair of Dice Paradise
"What attracted to me about this was that it was a strategy game but with some interaction stuff where you can actually influence the other players and with what seems to be some very unique mechanism so I'm intrigued by this one."
— John Backus, Actualol
"Players then evaluate each tile for the total number of robots and gear links present on each. And whichever player has the most controls that tile and gains its points."
— Meeple University