City of Remnants Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About City of Remnants
Reviewers agree on what City of Remnants is trying to do, but they disagree sharply on whether it pulls it off. Plaid Hat Games published this gang-warfare design in 2013, and the premise is grim: refugees from conquered worlds are held in a Yugai-run prison city, and they form gangs to fight over scraps. Players bid for recruits, build a deck, claim districts and battle rivals, and the reviewers who enjoyed it describe a sprawling, interlocking strategy game rather than a simple skirmish.
The enthusiasts are the most positive voices in the group. Board to Death TV played the game many times and scored it an eight out of ten, but its praise is conditional on player count. The reviewers found the game most satisfying at four players, where battles and bidding wars fill the table, and they felt it was merely acceptable with two.
The skeptics are blunter. The Watch Review channel argued that the systems work on their own but turn into a mess when combined, and it noted that the developers reissued the design as Neon Gods, a version it said still falls short. Board Games UnLocked placed the game at number ten on a list of games its host dislikes, while conceding that it is not a terrible game. Tom Vasel of The Dice Tower recalled it fondly as "pretty nifty," though Vasel had not played it in a while. The split is real: the praise comes from players who wanted a crowded, interactive city, and the frustration comes from players who found the table quiet or the rules tangled.
Core Mechanics That Define City of Remnants
Area Control Across the City
The board is the heart of the game. Board to Death TV describes a city arranged in rings, with the Slums on the fringe, Midtown and the Center around the middle, and Uptown at the very center, where the most lucrative developments can be built. Gangs hold districts, and those districts produce goods and Renown, the victory currency. Watch It Played's walkthrough makes the same point, noting that development tiles yield Renown only while a gang controls them, so holding ground is the core objective.
Contested spaces are where the area control becomes combat. When a figure moves onto an enemy, the mover becomes the attacker, both sides commit gang cards, and each side rolls battle dice matched to the figures in and around the space. Board to Death TV explains that this repeats for every contested space, which makes deployment a real decision. Board Games UnLocked, however, found that a non-competitive table could avoid fighting almost entirely, which weakens that tension.
Bidding for Gang Members and Deck Building
Recruitment is where City of Remnants borrows most visibly from auction games. Watch It Played describes players trying to outbid one another for gang members who are for sale, and Board to Death TV explains that the recruit action opens a bid on a gang member card that moves clockwise until players pass. Recruited members join the deck and also add a figure to the gang's pool on the player mat, so the auction feeds both the fighting force and the growth of the gang.
Deck building ties these layers together. Gang members who are killed leave the game, so players must keep recruiting, and black market cards offer another purchase channel for special abilities. The Watch Review channel had expected auctions, bidding, area control and deck building to reinforce one another, which is exactly the combination reviewers credit with the game's ambition.
The City of Remnants Experience
A Constant Tug of War Over Every Card
Reviewers repeatedly describe a hand of cards that must be spent three ways at once. The Board to Death TV host lays out the choice: cards can power a fight, generate cash for buying troops, or supply influence. Influence is the central stat, since it governs hand size, how many figures can move, and how many cards can be committed to a battle. The strongest turns come when a player has to decide which of those three uses matters most this round, and the reviewers describe that balancing act as the source of the game's tension.
Gritty Underworld Tension
The setting pushes toward a gritty, criminal atmosphere, and the most memorable moments are the ones where that atmosphere breaks through. Board Games UnLocked singled out the Yugai police units that drop into the city and kick down doors as the only truly exciting part of its experience. Board to Death TV also describes the Yugai patrols, which place tokens on coordinates and force gangs into battle unless they pay to bribe them off. Board Games UnLocked had hoped for an open underground market where rival gangs tore into each other, and found that the game rarely delivered that brawl unless players went out of their way to start it.
What Makes City of Remnants Stand Out
Four Asymmetric Gangs
Reviewers consistently praise the asymmetry. The Board to Death TV host described four gangs, each with its own abilities, and stressed that the gangs are very different from one another. Watch It Played noted that the figures come in four colors and four races, although the races have no effect on play and only colors matter. The result is that each player begins with a distinct identity and a different way to win, which gives repeat plays a different flavor.
Production Values and Component Density
Board to Death TV praised the art and production quality, and Watch It Played went through the box in detail. Its walkthrough covered a fully illustrated 19-page rulebook with roughly eight pages of core rules, four player mats with turn and influence trackers, two-sided boards for different player counts, and a large pile of plastic gang figures. The reviewer stressed that the card art is not tied to specific miniatures, so players do not need to match faces to models. That level of detail is a major reason reviewers describe the box as an event rather than a filler game.
Potential Drawbacks
Fights That Fizzle or Dominate by Player Count
Board to Death TV found the game most fun with four players, but at three players the reviewers ran into trouble. Two gangs would fight each other, and then the third gang would arrive to destroy both weakened rivals. Their concern extended to group dynamics: with a non-competitive table, a full game could pass without a single battle, which left the experience feeling solitary. Board Games UnLocked made a related point, noting that players had to go out of their way to start fights and that a player could simply hole up in a corner.
Systems That Do Not Add Up
The most serious complaint is that the parts do not cohere. Watch Review described the individual mechanisms as well designed but said that combined they produce a game that is messy and fails to deliver on its promise of an intricate gang-building area control experience. Board to Death TV agreed that the variety in items and mercs is limited, though it noted that some players will enjoy learning the cards by heart. Board Games UnLocked complained that gang members were only useful while their leader survived, which left some cards effectively dead weight. The same channel found the game boring with certain groups, even though it stopped short of calling it bad.
If You Enjoy City of Remnants
The Dice Tower's Tom Vasel and Watch Review both point to Neon Gods as the streamlined version of this design. Vasel noted that City of Remnants was later re-implemented as Neon Gods in 2018, a version Vasel had never personally played. Watch Review took a more pointed view, saying the developers reissued the game in a streamlined form that is still not very good. For players who like the bidding, district control and gang building of City of Remnants but want a tighter ruleset, Neon Gods is the logical next step to test. Players who found the original sprawling should expect that complaint to carry over, so trying it before committing to a purchase is the safer path.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"Two gangs would duke it out and then the third gang would come in and destroy the two weakened gangs."
— Board to Death TV
"Individually these systems seem really well but you put them all together and it's just a mess."
— Watch Review
"It is very boring and the fact that my gaming group kind of does that at times depending on the game it was it just wasn't for us."
— Board Games UnLocked