First Empires Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About First Empires
First Empires is a light civilization game from Sandcastle Games, designed by Eric B. Vogel, who also made Katara. Reviewers tend to place it between heavier civilization games and simple area control. Meeple University gave it a special mention in its year-end coverage and called it one of the better Gateway level games of that style out there, noting that it simplifies a lot of the civilization formula while still rewarding planning.
Opinions split most sharply on luck. All You Can Board previewed the game and said that although the dice component is large, it did not sound like it would be too luck based. Board Games UnLocked took the opposite view. The host called the game totally luck based on dice and said mitigation was limited. The host of Rolling Dice & Taking Names landed in the middle, describing the dice as cleverly frustrating or frustratingly clever. Reviewers agree on the table presence. Our Family Plays Games enjoyed a four-player game at a festival and praised the art, which it compared to the look of Days of Wonder.
Core Mechanics That Define First Empires
Dice Rolling
Each turn opens with dice. The number of dice you roll is set by your position on the orange track, and you can then re-roll based on your position on the blue track. Meeple University walked through the sequence and noted that the roll is the foundation for everything else in the turn. The symbols you roll decide whether you can move, conquer, or advance a track. If a die shows a symbol that matches a region you control, you can advance on that track, and each region and die pairing counts only once.
The game gives you some control over the dice through achievement cards. Discarding a card lets you reset a die to another face, including a sword, and you can repeat this as long as you have cards to spend. Each card also carries an objective that can be completed for points, so a card you cannot reach can still be useful as a die modifier.
Area Control
Movement comes from your purple track plus the swords you rolled. Each movement point lets one explorer cross one border, and sea movement requires enough points to reach land. Conquest works by bringing more explorers than the defender, or an equal or smaller number backed by enough swords. Swords are not consumed, so they can power several conquests in one turn. Meeple University pointed out that a conquered player retreats to another territory where they already have an explorer, so no player can wipe out another's last territory. Cities captured this way are kept face down and scored at the end.
The First Empires Experience
A Breezy Gateway Session
Setup and teaching are both quick. Rolling Dice & Taking Names described the game as a breeze to set up, with the box insert and player board insets keeping cubes and discs in place. Sessions are typically reported at around 45 to 60 minutes, which places it firmly in a Gateway slot. Our Family Plays Games said the rules were easy and the group had a great time at the festival table. Rolling Dice & Taking Names said the game is one it can pull out and play any time.
Chaotic Swings in the Middle Game
Once players are conquering each other's territory, the board changes quickly. Because a conquered player never leaves the game, a losing position stays playable, and the table can swing a lot from turn to turn. Our Family Plays Games emphasized that you always keep one land area and can keep conquering from there. The result is a game where the lead can change hands several times before the final scoring.
What Makes First Empires Stand Out
Hidden Cities and Achievement Cards
Captured cities are a quiet but satisfying part of the design. Each city tile carries a victory point value that stays hidden until the end of the game, so the final reveal can change the result. Rolling Dice & Taking Names highlighted the way a card can be turned in to convert a die into a sword, which turns an unmet goal into a tactical advantage.
Multiple Paths to Victory
Meeple University listed three ways to score: advancing your cubes on the five tracks, completing achievement cards, and capturing cities while defending your own. Ties go to the player with the most cards left in hand, then to combined city and card points. The tracks reward players who commit to one tree, since the highest position on each track is worth points on its own.
Potential Drawbacks
Dice Luck Can Stall a Turn
The most serious criticism comes from Board Games UnLocked. The host said that if you cannot roll a movement symbol, you cannot move your meeples, and that rolling for a conquest without swords means you cannot take the territory. The host pointed to Roll Through the Ages as a comparison point and gave the game a weight of 1.73, describing it as a very light game. Rolling Dice & Taking Names recalled a first game where one player could not roll the yellow die needed to grow their population, which made it hard to move forward.
Lower Counts and the Tech Tree Learning Curve
Player count matters. Rolling Dice & Taking Names said the game needs four players, because the map is smaller at three and the game is less fun with less territory to contest. The tech trees also take time to appreciate. Each empire starts differently and each track is worth different points, so players who do not understand their own trees early can feel stuck. Rolling Dice & Taking Names advised teaching that value clearly so new players are not frustrated in the opening turns.
If You Enjoy First Empires
Players who like the civilization track and dice mix may enjoy Roll Through the Ages: The Bronze Age, which Board Games UnLocked used as its comparison point. Catan offers a familiar board and resource-driven expansion for groups who want a gentler introduction to area control. Quadropolis and Res Arcana suit players who enjoy building an engine over several rounds and want a different kind of planning.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"everything in this game is totally luck based on dice"
— Board Games UnLocked
"but you never get knocked out of the game no no you don't get nothing which is cool"
— Our Family Plays Games
"one of the better Gateway level games of that style out there"
— Meeple University