Forbidden Sky Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Forbidden Sky
Forbidden Sky is Matt Leacock's cooperative tile-laying game and the third entry in the Forbidden series after Forbidden Island and Forbidden Desert. Reviewers are warm toward it, with clear reservations. Actualol calls it "my favorite of the trilogy," and Pounds and Inches say it "might be my favorite" in the series, though they wonder whether the novelty of a ship that lights up is part of the appeal. Board Games UnLocked covers the game across several videos, from a full playthrough to a post-game discussion, and its verdict is mostly positive even while it criticizes the luck.
The praise comes with friction. The Dice Tower says the rocket "doesn't quite work every time," and 3 Minute Board Games played it once, did not think much of it, and called it a giant gimmick. Across the channels, reviewers point to the same weak spots: the luck of the tile draws and the fiddly wiring. Pounds and Inches report that they have not yet won a single game on the normal difficulty, which they describe as the second tier.
Core Mechanics That Define Forbidden Sky
Tile Placement
Players draw tiles and spend actions to place them, and the shape of the platform decides where the lightning rods and other components can go. Board Games UnLocked points out that, unlike the earlier Forbidden games, players build the board, so placement becomes the main route to victory. The draws make that difficult. Pounds and Inches say players are at the mercy of the draw, and that they sometimes have to use actions to make room for the tiles they need. Actualol notes that a tile which protects a player from an electric shock is useful, but that the gale-force wind can blow the team right back into danger.
Cooperative Play
Forbidden Sky is cooperative, so the team wins or loses together. Actualol stresses that "if anyone dies you all lose," which makes every end-of-turn position a shared risk. The storm also escalates as the game goes on. Early on players face one storm card per turn, but later they flip three or four. Actualol credits Matt Leacock as "the master of the genre" and says the game reminds them of Leacock's earlier work on Pandemic, which they call the definitive co-op board game.
The Forbidden Sky Experience
Relentless Storm Tension
Reviewers describe a game that rarely lets the pressure drop. Board Games UnLocked calls it "just non-stop," with wind and lightning hitting the team every turn, and says it likes that intensity. Actualol enjoys how the wind blows players back into range of a lightning rod just after they thought they were safe, and says the storm's "unrelenting chaos" feels cinematic, like the climax of an action film.
Team Dynamics
The difficulty also works as a social experience. Actualol describes the build as "a logistical nightmare" that "makes for a great team discussion because everyone has different ideas on what to do." Board Games UnLocked recalls a group where everyone had a role to play and an early game that felt like a dream team, but says the lack of a way to move later in the game hurt the team the most.
What Makes Forbidden Sky Stand Out
The Light-Up Rocket
The rocket is the feature reviewers praise most. Pounds and Inches say the light-up ship "isn't just a simple gimmick" because it is "actually functional as well," and that lighting it up takes real work. Board Games UnLocked calls the ship "awesome" and the favorite part of the game. Actualol says powering up the rocket "feels amazing," and that the lights and noises are the reward for building a working circuit.
Physical Components and Threats
Reviewers also single out the physical components. Pounds and Inches are impressed that Matt Leacock "took a stack of tiles and made yet a third game system out of it." Actualol adds that the lightning and wind mechanisms "make your struggle feel real," which ties the threats directly to the board the players are building.
Potential Drawbacks
Luck in the Tile Draws
The most common complaint is randomness. Board Games UnLocked says that "it just comes down to luck on how the deck comes out," and that players can plan ahead but cannot change what is coming. Pounds and Inches say a player may have "lost the game before you even started without knowing it" because of how the tiles were shuffled. The storm offers little protection either, since its one buffer is a card that stops drawing, which Board Games UnLocked finds a weak safety net.
Fiddly Wiring and Plain Tile Art
The wiring that makes the game special also causes friction. Pounds and Inches note that the components with wire connectors "aren't quite perfect" on the tiles, and that it can be hard to get them "exactly lined up perfectly." The Dice Tower says the rocket "doesn't quite work every time." On the art, Board Games UnLocked says the tiles "look like garbage" next to the glowing wires and ship, and before release it noted that some viewers found the tiles bland.
If You Enjoy Forbidden Sky
Reviewers place Forbidden Sky alongside Forbidden Desert, Forbidden Island, Pandemic, and Pandemic Legacy. Board Games UnLocked says that when a plan works, the game feels "almost like a Pandemic strategy," and it notes that Pandemic Legacy also "did come down to luck" at times. If you like the tile-building and want a different threat, Forbidden Desert is the natural next step. If you want to start at the beginning of the trilogy, Forbidden Island is the first game that Forbidden Sky builds on. Forbidden Sky suits groups who enjoy planning around threats and a physical payoff, and who accept a few bad draws as part of the challenge.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"Forbidden Sky is a stunning achievement. It's such a complete package. First and foremost, it's a fun nail-biting game with a delicious puzzle to solve."
— Actualol
"Unlike the other Forbidden games, this one you actually build the board, so tile placement is very very important because that's ultimately how we will win this game."
— Board Games UnLocked
"But it just doesn't quite work every time."
— The Dice Tower