General Orders: World War II Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About General Orders: World War II
Reviewers describe General Orders: World War II as a compact two-player war game that carries more tension than its box suggests. Designed by David Thompson and Trevor Benjamin and published by Osprey Games, it pits two commanders against each other in a tug of war over a single battlefield, either the Alpine terrain of northern Italy or the islands of the Pacific. Grant, Grant's Game Rex placed it among their favorite small box games of 2023 and noted that a game takes 40 minutes or less.
The praise is consistent. Alex Radcliffe, BoardGameCo calls it a fantastic, highly recommended two-player worker placement game and gives it 4.5 out of 5. They are also candid that it no longer earns regular table time, which points to an idea that recurs in the discussion: General Orders is admired more for its design than for how often it gets played. Hosts on kovray arrive at a similar verdict after a full head-to-head match, describing each session as a close fight that rewards careful planning in a two-player format.
Core Mechanics That Define General Orders: World War II
Reviewers describe the game as area control driven by worker placement, and both halves of that description appear in nearly every explanation of how a turn unfolds.
Area Control
Holding a space requires only that you have troops in it, but scoring depends on supply. Rodney Smith, Watch It Played explains that a space counts as in Supply only when a connected chain of controlled spaces leads back to the player's headquarters. Only controlled spaces in Supply earn the victory stars tallied after the fourth round. Losing control of your headquarters ends the game at once, which means supply lines matter as much as the stars themselves. Foster the Meeple highlights the combat sequence, in which the defender rolls first and every burst removes an attacker's troop, after which both sides trade losses until one is empty. That order gives the side holding ground a real advantage. Troops are capped at five per space, so overstacking forces units back to reserve. The island side adds air zones, where planes must also trace supply and can bomb land spaces.
Worker Placement
Players alternate placing commanders onto action icons until one passes. Each icon holds only one commander, so a placement also blocks the opponent from using that action. Foster the Meeple frames this shared space as the heart of the game: taking the action you want can leave the board unprotected, so every placement is a trade-off. The available actions include Advance into an adjacent space, Paradrop behind enemy lines, Barrage a target up to three spaces away, and Reinforce, which adds troops through the support board. Plan draws operation cards, and each card carries a timing symbol that determines when it can be played. In its playthrough, kovray ran into the one-commander rule directly, finding that a planned advance was blocked because a commander already occupied the space. Cards such as Counterattack can change that rule, which makes the interaction more interesting.
The General Orders: World War II Experience
Interactive and Dynamic
The defining feel is constant back-and-forth between two players who can see each other's moves. kovray calls cutting off an opponent's supply one of the most essential aspects of the game. The Counterattack card adds bluffing, because it lets a commander enter a space already held by an enemy commander, so an opponent cannot fully read a placement. Foster the Meeple describes a match in which one player dominated the board until the opponent's card play near the end effectively won it, which shows how a position can look settled until a card changes it.
Intense
Reviewers consistently describe the game as tightly contested, with each decision carrying real weight. Rolling Dice and Taking Names notes that decisions are very tight because each player has few commanders to place, and that the game ends quickly enough that a misstep is felt. The kovray playthrough shows how fine the margins can be: a late attack that seemed to be the safer path went wrong, and the final result came down to a single space. The same channel describes every session as a close finish, which is a large part of why it holds their interest.
What Makes General Orders: World War II Stand Out
Big Game Decisions in a Small Box
The compact footprint is the most frequently praised quality. Grant describes it as a small box war game that can be played in 40 minutes or less, and says it feels much bigger than it is. Rolling Dice and Taking Names calls it a small box that takes little shelf space, is inexpensive, and can be played in about 30 minutes at most, which makes it a candidate for a quick two-player session before game night. Foster the Meeple describes it as a small box introduction to war gaming, one that gives players a reason to try larger titles.
Two Sides, Two Battlefields
The double-sided board is the second feature reviewers single out. The Alpine side keeps the game to land combat, while the island side adds air zones, planes that must trace supply through connected zones, takeoff and bombing actions, and a new set of bonus tokens. Rodney Smith, Watch It Played walks through both sides as distinct setups with their own rules. Rolling Dice and Taking Names agrees that the two sides play totally differently, and Foster the Meeple says the air layer brings another dimension to the board, so players must think about bombing runs as well as ground control.
Potential Drawbacks
Dice Swings and a Defensive Edge
Dice decide most fights, and reviewers say a single roll can reshape the board. Rolling Dice and Taking Names admits that some of their rolls were pretty extreme and that they got lucky in a match they were trying to control. Foster the Meeple points to the defender-first sequence as a built-in advantage for the side already holding a space, which can frustrate a player who prefers to attack. kovray, by contrast, describes the close margins as part of the appeal, so players who want precise control over outcomes may find the variance harder to accept.
A Light Theme and a Crowded Two-Player Shelf
Some reviewers find the theme thin. Rolling Dice and Taking Names notes that the game is a little lighter on theme, though the rulebook's historical note explains that worker placement stands in for the limited choices commanders faced rather than simulating battles. Alex Radcliffe says that even a re-theme did not win them over, and that the game loses out on regular play to other two-player titles on their shelf.
If You Enjoy General Orders: World War II
Reviewers point toward a small family of compact war games. Foster the Meeple groups General Orders with Caesar, Blitz Creek, and Dogfight, describing them as related titles in the same design lineage. Rolling Dice and Taking Names adds that Caesar and Blitz Creek use a bag of tiles drawn on each turn, while the aerial combat of Dogfight feels more direct. For a lighter two-player option with a similar area control feel, Alex Radcliffe recommends Through the Desert, an abstract game of placing camels to enclose areas that works well in a 45-minute slot.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"Every time I play it, it's amazing. The problem is I just know that over time I've come to realize certain games get pulled off the shelves, and certain games don't, regardless of how much I respect that game."
— Alex Radcliffe, BoardGameCo
"This one feels maybe like a much bigger game than it actually is to me, and the whole point of the game is to either take over your opponent's base or control the most spots for points at the end of four rounds."
— Grant, Grant's Game Rex
"It was fun, I have a lot of fun. I think every time we play this game it's like a really close head-to-head battle, which is always great in a two-player game."
— kovray