Il Vecchio Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Il Vecchio
Il Vecchio is a Rüdiger Dorn Euro set in 15th century Tuscany, where players guide Florentine noble families toward power by moving workers into cities and claiming provinces. Reviewers agree that the mechanisms are stronger than the packaging suggests. Chairman of the Board, in a dedicated review, calls it a "really nice entry-level Euro game" and says that "it's not revolutionary" but that it "just feels very enjoyable." The same channel's later "games I've got rid of" episode is more measured. It describes the game as having the usual trappings of a dry, beige Euro, while conceding that its mechanisms are surprisingly good. That reviewer ultimately parted with their copy and says they would rather keep Istanbul, which they find the juicier design.
The jnit games channel came to the game from a different angle. A friend of the host had backed it on Kickstarter, and the group played it for the first time as a two-player match. The verdict was enthusiastic, with the reviewer calling it a "really tight neat experience" and wanting to play it again with more people. Both channels describe a game whose appeal comes from its systems rather than its presentation. Where they differ is in the emphasis: Chairman of the Board is most impressed by how smoothly the turns flow, while jnit games was more struck by how a single engine tile can decide a match.
Core Mechanics That Define Il Vecchio
Moving Middlemen and Activation Tokens
The defining system in Il Vecchio is the middleman. Only the matching spot that currently holds a middleman token is active. When a player uses it, their worker is exhausted by being laid down, and the token then travels clockwise to the next matching spot on the board. Because the resource always shifts, a player cannot simply repeat the same city over and over. Chairman of the Board describes the appeal directly, saying they love how the moving middlemen force a player to think about both their own positioning and what they are handing an opponent in the process. Knowing where the token will land next lets a player line up a sequence of profitable moves, and it also means that a good action can hand an opponent a free move on the next turn.
The bishop and cart tokens soften this system without removing it. A bishop lets a player act even when the middleman is absent, and it avoids exhausting the worker, though it does not move the middleman, so the same spot can be used again. Cart tokens remove the road fee, letting a player teleport across the map. The reviewer notes that these are "quite a luxury thing to have," so knowing when to spend them is a real decision.
One Action Per Turn and Worker Exhaustion
Designer Rüdiger Dorn structures each turn around a single action, which jnit games singled out as a favorite feature of Euro design, preferring the discipline of one clean choice per turn over the sprawling multi-action turns that can drag other Euros out. The available actions are simple. A player can take resources at a middleman spot, cash followers into a province, roll dice to place a new worker, or stand up all exhausted workers, which also pays a little money. Movement costs coins per road, and money scales up as the game goes on, so entering cities quickly is cheaper. Chairman of the Board also notes that once a Medici spot is claimed, a penalty hits every player, such as losing money or a token. That penalty is not crippling, but it can throw a spanner in the works.
The Il Vecchio Experience
Interactive and Dynamic
Il Vecchio feels most alive when players are reacting to each other's moves. Because the middleman tokens are shared, each action is also a decision about where an opponent will end up. Chairman of the Board notes that a player who benefits from a move feels rewarded because the action lands right where they wanted it, and that the rising cost of cities creates a tension about getting there early. The reviewer sums up the experience by saying that decisions "aren't meaningless," since each choice about which token to spend and when to spend it can give a real edge.
Satisfying Engine
Each player starts with one engine tile from a stack of three draws, and additional tiles can be bought during play. These tiles change the rules of the player's own turns, such as doing one action twice or gaining money from a specific token. jnit games describes how its opponent Evan took a money tile and was "always drowning in money," while the reviewer, who grabbed more engine tiles, had to scramble for cash but still won by a reasonable margin. Chairman of the Board describes the same progression, saying that players gain "more powerful turns" as they acquire tiles. The Florence track adds more of this, letting players earn powers that no one else can have.
What Makes Il Vecchio Stand Out
Smooth Flow in About an Hour
Chairman of the Board repeatedly praises the pacing. The game takes about an hour, a length the reviewer considers still a niche for Eurogames, and calls the time investment "great." Downtime is low because a player can claim a city, choose tokens, and let the other players keep going. Setup and teardown are quick, and the iconography is easy to learn, which gives the game a comfortable entry point for newer players. The reviewer places it at a "medium light weighting" that is easier to jump on than many of its peers.
Scalability and Interlocking Systems
Chairman of the Board says Il Vecchio "works well at each of those player counts" from two through four players, and that the game "is not going to suffer from playing at a certain player count." jnit games also praised how the parts fit together, saying "the mechanics all worked well together" and that the game was "just a really tight neat experience." The reviewers value that the middleman movement, money scaling, and engine tiles all reinforce one another rather than competing for attention.
Potential Drawbacks
A Dry Look and Generic Feel
Even the reviewers who like the game concede that it is plain. Chairman of the Board says the theme is "very dry" and that the game is "pretty dry to look at, but I think it works well." jnit games called it a "very dry boring looking Euro game," and the Chairman of the Board episode on rejected games describes the board as very beige. The later reviewer also found it "a bit generic" in comparison with more modern Dorn designs, though they stress that everything it does, it does smoothly. For players who want theme or visual flair, these reviews suggest Il Vecchio will be a hard sell.
Engine Snowballs and Limited Replayability
The engine tiles that make the game satisfying can also create a runaway leader. In the jnit games two-player match, Evan's money tile let Evan move freely around the board, and the host felt "like I was just getting farther and farther behind" while scrambling for money. The host did win in the end, but the imbalance was a clear point of frustration. Chairman of the Board also flags replayability as only "so-so." The token supply is limited, and the same tokens keep showing up in the same cities, so once players know the options, the variety thins out. The reviewer does note that the Florence track gives a little more freedom because a player can pick from several tiles.
If You Enjoy Il Vecchio
Chairman of the Board places Il Vecchio alongside Rüdiger Dorn's Istanbul, Caruba, and Runestone, praising Dorn for making solid games. Players who enjoy Il Vecchio's moving middleman mechanic will find similar satisfaction in Istanbul, which the reviewer on the rejected-games episode considers "a little bit more juicy" and a better fit for the same play time. Players who appreciate the one-action turn structure and the sense of lining up future moves are a natural audience for Caruba and Runestone, the other Dorn designs the reviewer names as examples of Dorn's strong design work.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"The base thing that you're doing in the game is you just take one action a turn and then it's the next player's turn, which is my favorite kind of Euro game action structure. I hate it when it's like here's three or four actions and you do this or you could do this and you do this into this into that, turns can get so long. I just love to just do one thing, move on style gameplay and this has that."
— jnit games
"I love the idea of the way the different middlemen move around the board. Not only to line up yourself, but you've also got to bear in mind what you're giving your opponents as well because if I use this action and my opponent is stood in the next closest spot, then I know he can take that action next turn without having to travel to do so."
— Chairman of the Board
"I like the kind of dynamism of the board as these kind of moving pawns would go around and they would visit your different people depending on where you were stood, and you could really kind of line up a few moves."
— Chairman of the Board