In the Ashes Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About In the Ashes
Reviewers who have played In the Ashes, the solo action RPG adventure by Pablo Aguilera published by Devir Games, respond with clear enthusiasm and a few practical reservations. Crimsonboardgames first met the game at Spiel and described it as something they had never seen before, encouraging solo players and tabletop roleplaying fans to seek it out. Watch It Played was similarly warm, praising the branching storylines and the steady stream of puzzles and encounters. Our Family Plays Games treated it as an intriguing find, with one household member keen to try it during lunch breaks.
The more measured view comes from One Stop Co-op Shop, which played through the full campaign and found it enjoyable, but did not rate it as a strong recommendation next to other narrative games. The Dice Tower offered a brief take, describing it as a tactical game played through a book and singling out the book itself as a pleasure to use. Taken together, the consensus is that In the Ashes delivers a surprisingly full RPG experience in a very portable package, with trade-offs that stem from its book-based design.
Core Mechanics That Define In the Ashes
Narrative Choice
Story is the engine that drives the game, and reviewers consistently point to how well it draws them in. Crimsonboardgames followed the protagonist Vestar after a comet strikes near a village and an expedition sets out to find the wreckage in the mountains. The reviewer became invested in Vestar early, feeling sympathy for a character who has suffered hard times before the adventure begins. Watch It Played described the game as a journey through branching storylines, and One Stop Co-op Shop summed up the core structure by calling it a choose your own adventure book in which combat is drawn directly on the page. Choices also shape the character itself. Crimsonboardgames noted that the career paths and specializations a player picks determine how their fights unfold, which gives each playthrough a distinct character.
Dice Rolling
Randomness in In the Ashes is handled in a way that Crimsonboardgames found especially clever. Rather than rolling dice for every check, players flip to a random page, and the dice results printed in the book's margins decide the outcome. The reviewer noted that a set of dice is optional, since the book supplies everything needed. Combat adds another layer of variance and planning. Each turn, a player chooses three actions from the columns of the combat grid, with the restriction that no two picks may come from the same column or row, and the enemy's moves are visible in advance. Crimsonboardgames called the game definitely more strategic than many others, because the enemy's moves are laid out in advance for planning. Watch It Played called the combat "more puzzly than anything else," treating each fight as a problem to solve.
The In the Ashes Experience
Immersive Book-Based Storytelling
The defining feeling reviewers describe is immersion. Because the entire campaign lives inside a single book, the act of reading becomes the act of playing. Crimsonboardgames praised the way the narrative is worked out, saying the story immerses the player from the first pages and makes them want the protagonist to succeed. Watch It Played emphasized the sense of discovery, describing the game as a dark story with branching paths and a slow, deliberate pace. The reviewer said they were playing slowly so they could savor the experience, which captures how the book rewards unhurried reading.
Portable, Low-Setup Play
Portability is the other feeling that comes through strongly. Crimsonboardgames explained that the only thing truly required is a pencil, so a session can start from a couch with no table, no miniatures, and no board to assemble. The reviewer said that even half an hour is enough to play part of a chapter and one fight, which makes In the Ashes a natural fit for short breaks. That same low-friction setup is what made Our Family Plays Games willing to consider it for a quick lunchtime session.
What Makes In the Ashes Stand Out
Artwork and Page Layout
Presentation is one of the features reviewers praise most often. Crimsonboardgames called the artwork gorgeous and the descriptions beautiful, while Watch It Played called the game beautiful and a cool, dark story. The reviewer also admired the way each fight is laid out across two pages of the book, which keeps the combat grid, the enemy's moves, and the player's action choices clear and organized on the page. The Dice Tower similarly commented on how nice the book is to use.
A Gentle Introduction to the Rules
Accessibility for newcomers is another point of praise. Crimsonboardgames argued that the opening chapters introduce the rules slowly, easing the player in with the early story before layering on the mechanics that the strategic combat requires. The reviewer called this a remarkable way to teach a game of this depth and said that almost anyone could get into it. For players who are new to solo roleplaying, that gradual onboarding lowers the barrier to starting a campaign.
Potential Drawbacks
Limited Replay Without Workarounds
The most concrete concern is that the book format restricts how many times the campaign can be played as written. One Stop Co-op Shop noted that because combat is drawn directly in the book, the game limits itself to two or three plays unless players adopt a workaround, such as placing a see-through sheet over the page. The reviewer also suggested checking the comments on their original playthrough for further ideas. The Dice Tower handled the same issue by writing notes on a separate sheet of paper rather than in the book. Crimsonboardgames took a more optimistic view, arguing that the branching career paths and the choice between carrying a new weapon or keeping the current one give each run enough variety to justify returning to the game.
Combat Dominates and Does Not Stand Out Against Other Narrative Games
A second reservation is that much of the play is combat, which some players may find repetitive. Watch It Played described the game as involving a lot of combat, and One Stop Co-op Shop, while enjoying the adventure, stopped short of a strong recommendation when comparing it to other narrative games. The reviewer found the experience a good time but not one that clearly outshines the competition in its genre. Players who want a story-first experience with less emphasis on tactical fights should weigh that trade-off before committing.
If You Enjoy In the Ashes
Watch It Played made the most direct comparison, noting that the game reminded them of Gloomhaven because of its cards, although the reviewer added that the resemblance was only a general feeling. Players who appreciate the card-driven tactical combat of Gloomhaven will recognize some of the same satisfaction in the grid-based fights of In the Ashes, though the book-based format offers a far more compact and portable experience. Players who enjoy the feel of a branching adventure told in a physical book, and who are comfortable drawing directly on the page or using a workaround, are likely to find In the Ashes a rewarding next step.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"The wonderful thing about this game is the only thing you truly need is a pencil and optionally dice."
— Crimsonboardgames
"This is a phenomenal game that plays throughout branching storylines and lots of puzzles and encounters. I'm playing this one slowly so I can savor the experience."
— Watch It Played
"If you hate drawing in the book there are workarounds like go check the comments in my original playthrough."
— One Stop Co-op Shop