Marco Polo II: In the Service of the Khan Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Marco Polo II: In the Service of the Khan
Reviewers present Marco Polo II: In the Service of the Khan as a follow-up to The Voyages of Marco Polo that moves the journey from Beijing back toward the West. Meeple University describes it as a standalone game of soft medium complexity for two to four players, one that new players can learn without owning the original. The overall reaction is favorable. Reviewers tend to treat the sequel as a streamlined version of the same engine rather than a reskin, and the most enthusiastic voices describe a game that rewards careful planning.
The strongest endorsement came from The Cardboard Herald, which placed the game seventh on its worker placement top 10. That reviewer had panned the original on release and approached the sequel expecting to dislike it, then came away describing it as a shift from frustration to empowerment. Board Gaming Ramblings placed it seventh on its revisited 2019 list and kept both games on the shelf because they could not decide which was better.
Core Mechanics That Define Marco Polo II: In the Service of the Khan
Dice Placement
Dice placement is the mechanic reviewers return to most when describing how the game feels. Each player begins a round by rolling five dice, then assigns dice one at a time to spaces on the main board, where the pip value determines how strong the resulting action is. Meeple University frames this as rolling worker placement, and The Cardboard Herald describes the challenge as working out how to use dice "that feel like they're always at odds" with what a player really needs. Reviewers note that low rolls are softened by dice mitigation options, including extra dice given as compensation, so the tension comes from choice rather than from a roll alone.
Resource Management
The second mechanic reviewers discuss is resource management, built around goods that must be gathered, converted, and delivered to the right places. Board Gaming Ramblings describes a game in which players are always scraping by for points, coins, and resources. Meeple University lists goods, money, gilt seals, and contract cards as the currency players juggle, and it points to rare Chinese jade as the new good introduced in this sequel. Reviewers describe the appeal as planning a chain of purchases and trades, where one acquisition sets up several later actions.
The Marco Polo II: In the Service of the Khan Experience
Asymmetric
Asymmetry is the vibe reviewers praise most consistently. Each player receives a character power at the start of the game, and Meeple University calls these powers quite powerful, saying they give players strategy and something specific to focus on. Board Gaming Ramblings argues that the game has some of the best asymmetric player powers in its class, in which everyone feels uniquely powerful in ways that are impressive yet balanced. The result is that each table develops a distinct set of plans rather than one shared path to victory.
Economic
The game is also economic at its core. Travel, trading posts, goods, and contracts combine into a commerce loop. Meeple University observes that travel is now cheaper than in the original, although players still pay goods and road costs on some paths. Gilt seals serve a dual role, since they are required to pass certain roads and can later be upgraded to produce income. Scoring rewards players for collecting different banner types in cities where they hold trading posts, so the experience is one of building a trade network across the map.
What Makes Marco Polo II: In the Service of the Khan Stand Out
A Sequel That Answers the Original's Complaints
What separates the sequel for many reviewers is how it treats the original's weaknesses. The Cardboard Herald contrasts the first game's frustrating, dwindling capabilities with the sequel's sense of empowerment, while still acknowledging that the decisions are hard. Meeple University notes that goods are easier and cheaper to obtain, and that the lower cost of travel encourages players to move more often. The reviewer's conclusion is that the sequel is more streamlined, which suits players who usually roll lower pip values. Reviewers see the reward for good planning as a sense that you can bend the dice to your purpose, with the tools to see an ambitious goal through.
Two-Player Strength
In a discussion of two-player design, The Cardboard Herald names Marco Polo II as a worker placement game that works especially well with two. The reviewers say they simply like these games at two players because it provides the right amount of opposition. Their broader argument is that two-player designs keep the decision space focused, so each choice creates direct tension with the single other player. That focus makes the sequel's ambitious planning feel more personal than it can at a crowded table.
Potential Drawbacks
Overlap With the Original
Meeple University argues that the core mechanics of the two games are similar, so the sequel's changes concentrate in travel cost, goods, gilt seals, and the new jade good. Getting Games reviewed the game from pre-release information and described it as essentially the original with some tweaks, including a different map and possibly different characters. Players who already own one edition may therefore not feel a strong need for the other, a concern that Board Gaming Ramblings partly confirmed when it kept both copies.
Fragile Sequencing and Dice Pressure
Because success depends on lining up a sequence of trades, a single missed roll or blocked space can disrupt the whole chain. The Cardboard Herald describes this planning as a series of trades that "works beautifully when everything just sings in concert," which implies that the plan is only as strong as its weakest link. Meeple University also notes that gilt seals are needed to pass certain roads, a hard constraint that can stall a route. Players who dislike tight planning or long dependency chains may find the pressure more demanding than they expect.
If You Enjoy Marco Polo II: In the Service of the Khan
Reviewers consistently point to The Voyages of Marco Polo as the natural starting point. Meeple University compares the two directly and concludes that the sequel is more streamlined, so players who valued the original's dice-driven planning but wanted cheaper travel will likely prefer the follow-up. Players drawn to dice-driven worker placement should also look at Lords of Waterdeep and Agricola, both of which The Cardboard Herald places in its worker placement canon. The reviewer calls Lords of Waterdeep "pure worker placement" built around sending warriors on quests, and praises Agricola for making players work for the payoff of a strong food engine. Both reward the same planning rhythm that draws players to Marco Polo II.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"I went to Marco Polo 2 fully expecting to dislike it. But it was just everything that I wanted the first one to be instead of being a game of frustrating dwindling capabilities. It became a game of empowerment."
— The Cardboard Herald
"It seems like they encourage players to more travel in Marco Polo - as it's low in cost and more in benefits. I personally think that Marco Polo - is more streamlined with better gameplays helps it better when I usually roll lower dice pips."
— Meeple University
"They're both really good. I think the dice mechanism is really solid and the way that you're scraping by for both points and sorry uh coins and also resources to try to deliver the right things to the right places is really I just want to play it again."
— Board Gaming Ramblings