Shikoku 1889 Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Shikoku 1889
Coverage of Shikoku 1889 is limited, but the most substantive perspective comes from a long interview with a designer on Neon Gorilla. The designer admits to having played a great many 18xx titles and argues that their rules are less demanding than their reputation suggests. Once the basics are learned, the challenge shifts from remembering rules to making good decisions, which is why some of the family is described as "a little thorny" rather than impossible. The real obstacle, in this view, is length, which is harder to absorb for players whose habits are built around filler games and medium-weight evenings.
A quick sketch on Grant Lyon uses Shikoku 1889 as a punchline about new players. The bit centers on a board gamer who introduced a date to Pax Pamir and Shikoku 1889, and the laughter lands because the pick is so heavy for a first encounter with the hobby. The reviewer's underlying point is that board gamers should be more deliberate about which games they use to bring people in.
Core Mechanics That Define Shikoku 1889
Network and Route Building
Shikoku 1889 is played on a smaller map of Shikoku that is heavy with terrain, so every track a company lays carries a real cost. Companies extend their networks city by city, and because the map is shared, a placement that strengthens your railway can also block or price out a route an opponent wanted. Value comes from how well a company's network reaches the cities whose revenue grows as the game goes on, which turns route building into an ongoing negotiation with the other players rather than a solo layout exercise.
Share Dealing and Market Control
The second pillar is the stock market. Players spend cash in Share Dealing Rounds to acquire shares, and a company's operations between rounds are decided by its majority shareholder, so a stake is also a form of steering. Trains become obsolete over time while city revenue grows, which pushes players to time their purchases carefully. One voice on Neon Gorilla admits never having played an 18xx game but says the market is the draw: "I love markets in particular," adding that "the play that can be created just with market dynamics is incredible."
The Shikoku 1889 Experience
A Long Session That Rewards Patience
Reviewers describe 18xx as long rather than slow, and the designer on Neon Gorilla argues that the length is where the most rewarding moments come from. A first game of Shikoku 1889 is a three to five hour commitment, and players who learn the systems can expect that to drop toward three hours, or closer to two and a half with calculators. The experience is one of accumulating many small decisions, each of which ripples forward through the rest of the game.
Tension Built on Market Timing
The market is the main source of pressure. Because the most profitable shares must be bought at the right moment, and because trains go obsolete while city revenue climbs, a player who misjudges the timing of a share purchase can fall behind without ever seeing the mistake on the board. That sense of quiet calculation, watching a company's prospects shift round by round, is what the market-focused voices on Neon Gorilla find most compelling.
What Makes Shikoku 1889 Stand Out
Depth That Reveals Itself Over Repeated Play
The interview argues that 18xx depth is not visible on a first read. The rulebooks are not especially long, but the strategy opens up slowly as players learn which parts of the game are worth committing to in the middle stages. The designer describes the way decisions accrue and ripple through an 18xx game as something rarely found in other designs, which is why the series rewards players who keep returning to it.
A Gateway Into the 18xx Family
Shikoku 1889 belongs to a broad family of games descended from Francis Tresham's 1829. Its rules are similar to 1830: Railways and Robber Barons, but played on a smaller, terrain-heavy map, which makes it a manageable entry point into the genre. The designer's view that players who can handle Brass can handle most of the family makes this title a natural step for anyone already comfortable with the core ideas.
Potential Drawbacks
Length and a Steep First Game
The most consistent concern is time. A first game is a three to five hour adventure, and the designer concedes that the length is "harder to get around, especially for a lot of modern players" who are used to shorter sessions. Reaching the efficient version of the game requires real work, so the payoff arrives only after several sessions of learning.
A Poor Fit for Casual or Newer Groups
Grant Lyon's bit treats Shikoku 1889 as a heavy choice for someone new to tabletop games, and the reviewer's warning about picking gateway games frames the title as an advanced pick. Some 18xx rules are described as "a little thorny," so a casual group without a patient teacher may stall before the market payoff arrives.
If You Enjoy Shikoku 1889
Brass is the clearest recommendation. The designer's rule of thumb is that if you can play Brass, you can play most of the 18xx family, and Brass shares the same blend of network building and financial maneuvering that defines Shikoku 1889.
- Brass: the reference point for the whole family and the easiest on-ramp into its style of play.
- 1830: Railways and Robber Barons: the closest sibling to Shikoku 1889, since the rules are similar and the map is larger.
- Other 18xx titles: the designer keeps a shelf of them and plays many, which suggests that anyone who enjoys the market-driven, long-session style will find more to explore across the series.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"That's a three to five hour adventure. Now, once you get it down, you're going to get that down to a crisp three hours, maybe even two and a half if you're using calculators."
— Neon Gorilla
"Cuz I respected her intelligence."
— Grant Lyon
"You're actually taking often more actions per minute in a longer game than in a short game. An 18xx game has so many action points in it. There are so many little decisions that you're making, and the way they accrue and ripple through the game space is unparalleled. You don't see it in really any other type of design."
— Neon Gorilla