Star Trek: Frontiers Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Star Trek: Frontiers
Reviewers almost always describe Star Trek: Frontiers through its ancestry. Designed by Vlaada Chvátil and published by WizKids in 2016, the game is widely read as a Mage Knight variant with a Star Trek theme. Board Games for One calls it a "remasking" of Mage Knight with the same designers and a different theme, and treats that lineage as the main reason to pay attention to it.
The areas of agreement center on tactical texture. The Box of Delights channel, hosted by Ricky Royal, works through the first Recon scenario and then the Solo Conquest in detail, and both videos show a game in which every decision about who joins an away mission matters. Reviewers also agree that the game asks players to think in terms of a single system, where the ship, the crew and the reputation track constantly pull against one another.
Opinions diverge on theme and complexity. TableTop Wolf struggled with Mage Knight for years and describes Frontiers as a version that fixed those frustrations with the original, yet still did not enjoy the setting or the card art. Mike of Board Games for One admits to never having played Mage Knight and expected Frontiers to be a campaign-style game, then found that each play resets. Drive Thru Games, reviewing the game as part of a look back at the 2016 anticipated list, observes that the title has largely fallen out of conversation and speculates that its complexity may have overwhelmed Star Trek fans who expected something lighter.
Core Mechanics That Define Star Trek: Frontiers
Deck Building
Deck building sits at the heart of how Star Trek: Frontiers plays, and reviewers focus on how the personal deck interacts with the crew and the ship. Ricky Royal explains that a Captain's specialization card can only be used when the Captain is part of the deck, and that the Captain must be ready and unwounded to join an away mission and use the skills attached to that Captain. TableTop Wolf, comparing the design with Mage Knight, said that deck building "seemed a little bit better and more streamlined," a change counted among the improvements that made the game work better overall.
Modular Board
The map is built from tiles as the ship explores, and each new tile can reveal a planet, a Borg cube or a reward. Mike of Board Games for One describes the result as a modular board you move around on. Ricky Royal's walkthroughs show what the tiles do in practice: a Class M planet lets a ship recruit, repair, heal and train, a Class K planet presents an enemy that must be overcome through diplomacy, and a distressed planet doubles both the enemies and the reward. Ricky says of the doubling, "everything's doubled up here I like that a lot," noting that because planet enemies are drawn fresh, "it's always a surprise who you're going to take on."
The Star Trek: Frontiers Experience
Tension Around the Away Team
Away missions are where the game feels most dangerous. In the Box of Delights walkthrough, a failed away mission leaves the Captain wounded, and a wounded Captain cannot use its skills, drops to a defense value of one, and cannot have its specialization card played. Failed away missions also cost reputation, and when no one is left to absorb the damage, the rest of the crew is lost. Ricky Royal's conclusion is that players have to think carefully before sending a team down, and that sense of calculated risk runs through the reviews.
A Space Crawler Built From the Ship Outward
Mike of Board Games for One offers the most evocative framing of the game's feel: Mage Knight is an overland fantasy, while Frontiers is "zooming out": players move their ship through the space map, level up as they go, and only then take their crew to the surface. Ricky Royal's playthroughs match that picture. A ship first fights the enemy in orbit during a space battle, and only afterward sends an away team to the surface of a ball cube, so the two halves of a single encounter feel like one escalating operation.
What Makes Star Trek: Frontiers Stand Out
A Smoother Take on Mage Knight
The most consistent praise concerns how Star Trek: Frontiers streamlines the Mage Knight formula. TableTop Wolf, who could never get into Mage Knight despite repeated attempts, found that Frontiers keeps the same basic concepts while adjusting the frustrating parts. Movement is less punishing because there is no daylight cycle, a ship can attack from an adjacent space, and the deck building feels cleaner. Ricky Royal makes a related point about combat, noting that Mage Knight's ice-against-fire matching is absent here, and that once a ship upgrades to pulse torpedo shields, the game "makes it a little simpler."
Scenarios That Reward Repeat Play
Reviewers also praise the scenario structure. Mike of Board Games for One points out that the rulebook scenarios are "not strict scripts" but guidelines that leave room for storytelling and roleplay. In a separate video, Mike describes a game for a smaller library that gets pulled out all the time. Ricky Royal shows how the difficulty can be tuned, since the ball cube levels are variable and a player who finds them too hard can simply bring them down.
Potential Drawbacks
Bookkeeping and Rules Memory
The most frequently voiced concern is the weight of the rules. Mike of Board Games for One calls Frontiers a heavy game, and says it does hardly any bookkeeping for the player, so that to play it well you have to memorize a great deal or keep referencing the rule book. Even Ricky Royal, who knows the game well enough to teach it, admits to misapplying how disruptors reduce shields and only catching the error in post-production. Drive Thru Games, speculating on why the game has faded, wonders whether it was simply too complex for the Star Trek fans who bought it.
Theme and Art Divide Opinions
Theme is the second recurring reservation. TableTop Wolf did not understand the theme or enjoy the card art, with fantasy being more of a personal preference. Mike of Board Games for One says that Frontiers is "not the prettiest game I've ever seen," and in another video judges the theme less strong than it could be, while still welcoming the Star Trek setting, which suggests that the license adds appeal for some players even as it leaves others cold.
If You Enjoy Star Trek: Frontiers
Mage Knight is the clearest recommendation because reviewers draw the connection themselves. TableTop Wolf calls Frontiers "Mage Knight Light" with the same basic concepts, and Mike describes the two as the same design with a different theme. Players who love Mage Knight's exploration and leveling loop, but want it in a space setting with smoother movement, should find Frontiers a natural next step.
Gloomhaven and Jaws of the Lion are the better comparison for players who want persistent progression. Mike of Board Games for One expected Frontiers to be a campaign-style game with a character growing across many sessions, more like Jaws of the Lion, and found that each play resets. Players who want a character to carry forward through a campaign will be better served by Gloomhaven or Jaws of the Lion.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"It's really tough once you get a wounded Captain. This is, this is what I'm saying, really. You have to think twice."
— Ricky Royal, Box of Delights
"You have a lot of bookkeeping, the game doesn't do like hardly any bookkeeping for you, so if fantastic game, don't get me wrong, but this is a game that is for like a smaller library that you pull this out all the time."
— Mike, Board Games for One
"So, Star Trek Frontiers is essentially Mage Knight Light. It has the same basic concepts and similar gameplay, but the frustrating parts of Mage Knight for me seem to be adjusted."
— TableTop Wolf