Tides of Madness Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Tides of Madness
Reviewers present Tides of Madness as a two-player card drafting game designed by Christian Krill and published by Portal Games, and they consistently treat it as a sequel to Tides of Time rather than a separate design. Rodney Smith of Watch It Played frames the premise as a race to discover the secrets of the ancient ones while avoiding certain madness. The Getting Games playthrough goes further, describing the sequel as mechanically identical to its predecessor except for the addition of Madness.
Board Game Sanctuary offers the most direct comparison, arguing that the two games play almost the same at their core and differ mainly in the new madness rules and a few swapped cards. That reviewer ultimately leans toward Tides of Madness, because the madness tokens add a tension the original lacks, while still advising that newcomers learn Tides of Time first. The Getting Games host admitted to overconfidence in the middle of their playthrough, and the final score of 80 to 79 showed how tight the contest stayed from start to finish.
Enthusiasm runs highest among players who already enjoy the drafting engine. Some reviewers, however, question whether the two titles deserve shelf space side by side, which is a recurring theme when discussing a sequel that keeps so much of its predecessor intact.
Core Mechanics That Define Tides of Madness
Simultaneous Drafting and Passing
Each round begins with five cards in hand. Players secretly select one card, reveal their choices together, and pass the remaining cards across the table, repeating until each player has built a row of five cards in front of them. Every card carries one of five suits and a scoring effect in its upper corner, so each pick is both a scoring decision and a denial decision. Reviewers stress reading the opponent closely. The Getting Games host spends much of the playthrough taking cards the opponent needs, and at one point weighs whether a card with a wild suit is worth handing over. Board Game Sanctuary highlights synergy as well, pointing to the Great Library, whose value depends on assembling a set of matching cards later, so early picks are often chosen for what they enable down the line. Majority scoring adds another layer, since holding the most of a suit earns bonus points, but a tie scores nothing for either player.
The Madness Track
Madness is the defining addition to the formula. Each card with tentacles on its side gives its owner a madness token at the end of the round. The player with the most madness either gains four victory points or discards a token to heal, and a tie for the lead awards nothing to either side. Reaching nine or more madness ends the game immediately, which is why the track shapes every decision. Certain cards interact with it directly: the Dreamlands can take a token from the opponent, while the Necronomicon awards a point for each madness the player holds. The Getting Games host describes the central skill as wringing every possible point out of madness without crossing the threshold, noting that ending the game with eight madness on the table is the way to squeeze the most value from the Necronomicon. Board Game Sanctuary agrees that the track is the heart of the design, since a player who has collected many tokens may find the final round dictated by madness rather than by the cards they want to play.
The Tides of Madness Experience
A Tightrope Walk Toward Insanity
The dominant feeling in these videos is a constant balancing act. Every strong card tempts a player to accept more tokens, and every token brings the player closer to the nine-token limit. In the Getting Games playthrough, both players approached the final round with madness levels that forced careful planning, and the host deliberately fed madness to the opponent in an attempt to push them toward losing outright. The tension builds gradually rather than arriving in a single decisive moment, so the last round often feels like a reckoning for every earlier choice.
Lovecraftian Dread Meets Strategic Calm
The theme arrives through the cards themselves. Board Game Sanctuary notes that the game draws on the world of H.P. Lovecraft and on some of H.P. Lovecraft's very well-known pieces of writing, and the Getting Games host openly jokes about butchering the Mythos names printed on the cards. Each card reads like a small piece of the Cthulhu mythology, from Great Old Ones and Outer Gods to Manuscripts and the Mountains of Madness. The mood is less about jump scares than about an unsettling sense of cosmic bookkeeping, where the scoring text becomes the story: a Deep Ones card rewards sets of Great Old Ones and Manuscripts, while a location card can crown whoever controls the Elder Gods majority. The strategic calm of counting suits and tokens sits in sharp contrast to the horror the names suggest.
What Makes Tides of Madness Stand Out
Deck Order Keeps Every Game Different
Watch It Played points out that all 18 cards are used during a game, which means the order in which cards reach each player shapes every session. Because the deck runs out completely by the third round, no two plays unfold the same way, and the choices a player faces depend heavily on what the opponent passed along earlier. Reviewers praise this structure because the variety comes from the card flow itself rather than from dice or hidden information, so the game rewards careful reading of what has already been drafted and what remains.
Art and Component Quality
Board Game Sanctuary praises the artwork across both games, describing it as nothing short of amazing. In Tides of Madness the illustrations run all the way to the edge of each card, making the most of every inch of space. The reviewer also calls the madness tokens very large, durable, and functional, with clear iconography that makes suits easy to read at a glance during a busy scoring phase.
Potential Drawbacks
Dominant Cards and Lopsided Swings
Board Game Sanctuary argues that the King's Nest, a card that wins ties for the points, is slightly overpowered. Taking it and using it well can skew the entire game in one direction, and the reviewer suggests that players must work hard to keep the balance feeling fair. The Dreamlands creates a similar dynamic, since a card that can take a madness token from the opponent can tip the track in a single move. Reviewers acknowledge that these powerful cards add excitement, but they also suggest that a single well-timed pick can overshadow the careful planning that came before it.
Limited Novelty for Tides of Time Players
Because the core loop is inherited so directly, the sequel can feel like a modest update to players who already know its predecessor. Board Game Sanctuary characterizes the changes as small rule additions and notes that a Tides of Time player will find Tides of Madness much easier to pick up. The Getting Games vlog, which covered a copy the host already owned alongside the original, reported uncertainty about keeping both titles, reasoning that the sequel is a variation on the first game rather than a fresh experience.
If You Enjoy Tides of Madness
- Tides of Time: The predecessor delivers the same simultaneous drafting and suit-based scoring without the madness track. Board Game Sanctuary argues that Tides of Time excels at maximizing combinations between cards, since synergy is the main route to victory points, and recommends learning it first so the sequel's additions feel like a natural extension rather than a steep jump.
Players who relish the denial drafting and the careful reading of an opponent's needs will find Tides of Time a natural companion. Those who want the extra tension of managing tokens and timing their risks should move on to Tides of Madness once the drafting rhythm feels comfortable.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"I think the madness tokens really levels out the playing field and really tries to make you work on your timing strategies, timing when the best time to garner madness tokens is, and timing when to use certain cards as well."
Board Game Sanctuary
"Ending the game with eight Madness while you have that card is the way to do it. You're going to squeeze the most points for that Madness that you possibly can without tipping over the threshold and just flat out losing the game entirely."
Getting Games
"The order in which players receive those cards means that every time you play, you'll end up with different choices to make."
Watch It Played