Kingdoms Forlorn: Dragons Devils and Kings Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Kingdoms Forlorn
Kingdoms Forlorn has polarized its early player base in ways few campaign games do. Board Games UnLocked found the game exhausting and repetitive, ultimately deciding to put the series on hold. Meet Me At The Table, by contrast, ranks it among their top five games of 2025, praising its narrative depth and mechanical sophistication. The difference is not subtle: where one channel sees a grinding slog, the other sees an immersive character-driven epic. Both perspectives are grounded in real play, and both reveal something essential about how the game works and whom it serves.
Core Mechanics That Define Kingdoms Forlorn
The Delve Phase and Exploration System
The heart of Kingdoms Forlorn is its exploration layer, where players navigate kingdoms tile by tile, deciphering ciphers, triggering events, and managing threat. Each tile reveals ciphers that unlock narrative secrets and world flavor. The delve phase controls pacing: players spend significant time traveling, resolving symbols, and making navigation choices. Board Games UnLocked notes that after multiple quest chains, the same tiles and ciphers repeat, turning what should feel like discovery into routine. Meet Me At The Table celebrates the same mechanic as a way to build familiarity with the world and notice narrative callbacks. The delve's success or failure hinges on whether the cipher and tile variation sustains interest across a full campaign.
The Clash Phase and Inverted Combat
Where the delve divides opinion, the clash phase unites it. Kingdoms Forlorn's boss fights employ an inverted combat paradigm: as the battle prolongs and damage accumulates, both the player characters and enemies grow more powerful. This creates a climactic spiral where the outcome hangs in balance until the final attack. Players roll dice, draw mortise cards (which can grant powerful boons or sudden death), and manage card cooldowns and delays. Multiple enemies can appear on the board simultaneously, each with their own card representing health and wounds. Knights gain passion as they perform well in combat, unlocking new abilities. The system rewards tactical positioning and equipment synergy while keeping tension high throughout. This mechanic is praised universally across both channels as exciting, rewarding, and genuinely fun to play.
The Kingdoms Forlorn Experience
Narrative Immersion and Character Arcs
Kingdoms Forlorn positions each playable knight as the protagonist of their own story. As players progress through their character's quest chapters, story events branch based on choices: refuse a contract and gain resilience but miss rewards; hunt a dangerous creature and reset your threat but abandon civilians. Meet Me At The Table found this structure deeply compelling. The writing in particular drew praise for character moments and meaningful consequence. Board Games UnLocked acknowledged the story was genuinely good but felt it was marred by the tedium required to reach narrative payoffs. The disconnect is real: the narrative is rich, but it is locked behind hours of delve phase gameplay.
Exhaustion and Reward Scarcity
Board Games UnLocked's primary complaint centers on the grind-to-reward ratio. A full quest cycle, from delve through clash, consumes 6+ hours and yields minimal loot: often just one piece of equipment and a small amount of gold. The delve phase features mandatory encounter encounters with monsters that drop limited rewards, and even exploring new tiles provides only the base loot. Because quests cycle through the same two kingdoms multiple times before new content arrives, players encounter the same enemies repeatedly and see identical gear drops. This creates a feeling Board Games UnLocked described as emptier than intended, made worse by the fact that new character abilities don't unlock for many hours of play, leaving characters feeling incomplete.
What Makes Kingdoms Forlorn Stand Out
Rich Branching Narrative and Living World
Kingdoms Forlorn treats the kingdom as a living space where your choices matter. Knights can interact with statues that trigger quests, encounter strangers with competing agendas, and uncover the personal histories of their peers through story branches tied to their equipment and ability unlocks. The narrative isn't a passive backdrop; it reshapes available options and boss encounters. Story cards form the core of the exploration experience, and they are crafted with genuine care. Meet Me At The Table's enthusiasm stems partly from this commitment to character and world: every quest feels personal, not generic.
Asymmetric Knight Design with Evolving Abilities
Each knight begins with a core set of cards defining their playstyle but gains unique unlockable abilities tied to their character progression. As knights level up and unlock new "flash tokens," they access powers specific to their story and persona. The game supports vastly different builds and tactical approaches, and the inverted combat system means a knight's starting weakness (low passion, limited abilities) can shift entirely as battle escalates. This creates replayability: the same encounter plays out differently if a knight arrives prepared versus underpowered.
Potential Drawbacks
Rules Complexity and Cognitive Load
The game ships with a 100+ page rulebook that explains many concepts without complete clarity. Keywords like "ethereal unity," "spectral step," and "force vault" are defined differently by each monster, forcing players to hunt between the rulebook and monster trait cards. Board Games UnLocked described the rules as word diarrhea that overwhelms without always clarifying edge cases. Example: "knock sideways" appears without specifying which direction, leaving groups to home-rule the resolution. The delve phase alone features numerous tracks, symbols, and card interactions that compound the cognitive burden of play. While Into the Unknown's design is mechanically rich, the rulebook presentation could be significantly cleaner.
Repetitive Delve Progression and Sparse Content
The core delve loop involves traveling through tiles, resolving symbols, and drawing exploration cards that describe what players discover. With only two kingdoms available at launch, players encounter the same tile layouts and cipher IDs within a few quest cycles. Board Games UnLocked noted that after the novelty wears off, the delve phase becomes a procedural grind with minimal variation. Exploration cards repeat, points of interest blur together, and the time spent exploring stops rewarding curiosity. The team acknowledged this would improve with more kingdoms, but at launch, the delve phase's pacing conflicts with its limited content variety. Sessions regularly stretch past six hours, with players actively trying to skip exploration steps to reach the story and combat they paid for.
If You Enjoy Kingdoms Forlorn
If Kingdoms Forlorn's narrative depth and boss fights resonate with you, consider Aon Trespass Odyssey (Into the Unknown's prior game using similar combat systems and campaign structure), Tainted Grail: The Fall of Avalon (branching narrative campaign with choice-driven progression), or Gloomhaven (dungeon-crawler with persistent character arcs). For pure boss-fight satisfaction, Grim Coven delivers tactical combat without the lengthy delve phases. If the knight asymmetry appeals, explore Harry Potter: The Deck Building Game for character customization, or Into the Unknown (the abstract campaign game) for pure system depth.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"It feels like we are forcing ourselves to go through it because of the sunk time element — how much we've put into it, how much we learn the rules — just to not have fun."
— Board Games UnLocked
"Kingdoms Forlorn is unique in the way that it provides you with different characters that actually have a story in themselves, and you are going to play through not only one person's story but all the character stories that you have that are going on."
— Meet Me At The Table
"The grind of this — I'm a grind guy, I'm a grindy boy — but grind needs, I need Skinner box, I need rewards. You end the whole 6-hour situation, you get one piece, assuming it's not your quest, you get one piece of gear and a handful of gold."
— Board Games UnLocked