Skip to main content
Shadows over Camelot box art

Shadows over Camelot

Game Info
Year
2005
Players
3-7
Age
10+
Playtime
60 min
Publisher
Collection
Ratings
Mechanic profile
Waiting on more creator content
Vibe profile
How this game feels to play
Description

Shadows over Camelot is a cooperative/semi-cooperative hand-management and deduction-based board game for 3–7 players.

Each player represents a knight of the Round Table and they must collaborate to overcome a number of quests, ranging from defeating the Black Knight to the search for the Holy Grail. Completed quests place white swords on the Round Table; failed quests add black swords and/or siege engines around Camelot. The knights are trying to build a majority of white swords on the Table before Camelot falls.

On each knight's turn, the knight takes a "heroic action", such as moving to a new quest, building his hand, or playing cards to advance the forces of good. However, he must also choose one of three evil actions, each of which will bring Camelot closer to defeat.

Moreover, one of the knights may be a traitor, pretending to be a loyal member of the party but secretly hindering his fellow knights in subtle ways, biding his time, waiting to strike at the worst possible moment...

But enough words... don your cloak, climb astride your warhorse, and gallop into the Shadows to join us in Camelot!

Description

Shadows over Camelot is a cooperative/semi-cooperative hand-management and deduction-based board game for 3–7 players.

Each player represents a knight of the Round Table and they must collaborate to overcome a number of quests, ranging from defeating the Black Knight to the search for the Holy Grail. Completed quests place white swords on the Round Table; failed quests add black swords and/or siege engines around Camelot. The knights are trying to build a majority of white swords on the Table before Camelot falls.

On each knight's turn, the knight takes a "heroic action", such as moving to a new quest, building his hand, or playing cards to advance the forces of good. However, he must also choose one of three evil actions, each of which will bring Camelot closer to defeat.

Moreover, one of the knights may be a traitor, pretending to be a loyal member of the party but secretly hindering his fellow knights in subtle ways, biding his time, waiting to strike at the worst possible moment...

But enough words... don your cloak, climb astride your warhorse, and gallop into the Shadows to join us in Camelot!

Ask a Rules Question
All mentions
Browse transcript mentions, sentiments, pros/cons, mechanics, topics, quotes, and references.
Total mentions: 60
This page: 50
Sentiment: pos 35 · mix 8 · neu 2 · neg 2
Mentions per page
Showing 1–50 of 60
Video DdpJMr_-DRQ Chairman of the Board Top List at 2:40 sentiment: mixed
Chairman of the Board - Shadows over Camelot video thumbnail
Click to watch at 2:40 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
mixed
Pros
none
Cons
  • Getting a bit dated
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Cooperative — Described as a "cooperative game."
  • hidden traitor — Features a "hidden traitor mechanic."
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • really great party style game with amazing artwork again
  • this is a very unusual kind of economic style game where you're buying and selling these containers trying to get as much profit as possible
  • which is an epic siege style euro game very a lot going on in this one but it's very cool a cool theme
  • wonderfully produced gorgeous game with worker placement quite heavy eurostar game with the magic a magicians theme which is a very cool and kind of not so popular so nice to see that a theme being used so well
  • which is a Stratego style game where you trying to get thrown into mortal or trying to a fine Frodo if you are the a shadow player
  • which is a super fun cooperative game where you're trying to play cards in chronological order but without communicating with your teammates
  • which is another cooperative real real time game so much fun very frustrating but a great time guaranteed with magic maze
  • which is a really great abstract style game where you're building planting these seeds watching your trees go and collecting points
  • so apology if I went through those quite quickly but we'd be here all day if I didn't
  • so I hope you've enjoyed my number 102 one on the number one sorry number 102 number 50 one of my greatest games of all time
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video T64KiR_f9vY Chairman of the Board Review at 0:03 sentiment: mixed
Chairman of the Board - Shadows over Camelot video thumbnail
Click to watch at 0:03 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
mixed
Pros
  • The traitor element is famous and well-utilized.
  • Thematic elements and visual representation of the medieval world are strong.
  • The game doesn't heavily favor alpha gamers.
  • Subtle traitor manipulation is engaging.
  • The balance between good and bad winning seems fair (around 50/50).
  • Negative effects are potent and make the game challenging.
  • Drop-in/drop-out play is supported by drawing a role and character card.
  • Characters have different abilities, increasing replayability.
  • Aesthetically very pleasing and a nice production quality.
  • Solid cooperative game that is fun.
  • Pioneering game in its genre.
Cons
  • Can feel like you're not doing enough on your turn, especially at higher player counts.
  • Turn structure can be slow and plodding, with long waits between actions.
  • Playing multiple cards for a mission takes many turns.
  • Gameplay feels simplistic and a bit dated.
  • Ambiguous rules regarding communication about cards in hand are problematic.
  • The playtime (around 1.5 hours) is on the longer side for its complexity.
  • Replayability is limited after a few plays as games feel similar.
  • Some rules and the slow pace can be bothersome.
Thematic elements
  • Knights completing missions
  • Arthurian legend world
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • action selection — On a turn, players must perform one 'bad' action (e.g., playing a trebuchet card, taking damage, drawing from the shadow deck) and one 'good' action (e.g., moving, playing cards for missions).
  • Hand Management — Players manage a hand of cards needed to form poker hands for mission completion.
  • Mission Completion — Players work together to complete various missions by playing cards to form poker hands before negative effects trigger.
  • Player Elimination (Conditional) — Players can die if they run out of health, and if all players die, the game is lost.
  • Set Collection — Playing cards to form specific poker hands constitutes a form of set collection for mission objectives.
  • traitor mechanic — A core element where one or two players secretly try to make the team lose without revealing their identity.
  • Variable player powers — Characters have different abilities, adding replayability.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • The traitor element of the game really famous
  • all you got to do on your turn is you do something bad and you do something good
  • it can really seem like you know when especially if you're playing at the higher play accounts when it comes back round to you that you are not doing enough on your turn
  • the Vega T to it which really doesn't quite sit well with me because the game states that you cannot actually tell other players what is in your hand
  • when you've got a rule like that people are just gonna say what they've got anyway and I think it's really kind of open to you know that rule is open to being abused by players
  • I like the I almost like the subtle ways that the traitor can kind of manipulate play in this
  • all those negative effects do feel very very potent and very strong
  • mechanism wise very simple but a bit dated in a bit too a bit too slow a bit too plodding for me
  • it did leave my collection because I just wasn't really having the urge to get it back to the table
  • it's a solid cooperative game well it's fun the traitor aspect is used very well in it
  • it does get a good verdict for me which puts it around a 7 out of 10
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video nbR7wejS2xs Chairman of the Board Unboxing at 0:47 sentiment: positive
Chairman of the Board - Shadows over Camelot video thumbnail
Click to watch at 0:47 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • facilitates up to seven players
Cons
  • traitor twist
Thematic elements
  • medieval
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • hello hello and welcome to chairman of the board
  • so let's go show you some games
  • so I'm really excited to play this
  • I absolutely loved it
  • so that's joy per my last purchase of the day was escape the cast of the temple
  • so I look forward to playing and reviewing that for you down the line
  • so I hope you've enjoyed this video it's just a quick or just a quick video showing you what I picked up at a convention which I had a great day it was really good I'd recommend you go if you have the opportunity thank you for watching and I will see you next episode where I hope to get a review out to you pretty soon so thanks a lot
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video CKUL-rh_clU Chairman of the Board Top List at 5:12 sentiment: positive
Chairman of the Board - Shadows over Camelot video thumbnail
Click to watch at 5:12 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Great cooperative game with a traitor twist
  • Simple design and mechanics
  • Supports up to 7 or 8 players
  • Traitor mechanic is subtle and clever
  • Love the medieval theme
  • Fantastic production
  • Really nice game
Cons
none
Thematic elements
  • Cooperative game with a traitor twist, players juggle quests.
  • Medieval
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • cooperative play — Players work together to juggle quests.
  • Hand Management — Building poker hands to win quests.
  • Set Collection (Quests) — Juggling a number of different quests.
  • traitor mechanic — One player may be secretly working against the others.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • I have flam Rouge now this is actually the only racing game I probably ever played but I just absolutely love the simple mechanics of this game
  • it's just predicting what other players are going to play and trying to slipstream behind them
  • just so simple really elegant and it's been a huge hit with everyone I've played with
  • this is another cooperative game where there is possibility of being a traitor
  • the theme of this game is absolutely spectacular and they've really got to that extra level through the use of those crossroads cards
  • one of those games that spot really hard to find fault with
  • real where the number 21 best game of all time so that's dead of winter
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video 722Lg6VfEeI Chairman of the Board Analysis at 0:19 sentiment: mixed
Chairman of the Board - Shadows over Camelot video thumbnail
Click to watch at 0:19 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
mixed
Pros
  • Love the theme of medieval Arthurian times
  • Love the premise and the idea
Cons
  • Turns weren't satisfying enough
  • Limited communication was frustrating
  • Game was a bit long and tedious
  • Mechanisms did not live up to the theme
Thematic elements
  • Knights of the Round Table managing missions
  • Medieval Arthurian
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Area Control — Players travel around the board to manage threats in different locations.
  • cooperative play — Described as one of the pioneers when it comes to cooperative gaming.
  • Hand Management — Players manage their hand of cards.
  • Set Collection — Players attempt to form poker hands.
  • traitor mechanic — Considered to be the first game with the potential of having a traitor in the mix.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • I hope that that gives you some insight about what process goes on in my head when I'm trying to get rid of games in my collection.
  • I have limited space, so I'm always looking forward or always looking to try and cut it down as much as I can.
  • I even try to find reasons to get rid of these games.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video KgrsIwbCCCM Chairman of the Board Top List at 11:47 sentiment: mixed
Chairman of the Board - Shadows over Camelot video thumbnail
Click to watch at 11:47 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
mixed
Pros
  • Popular and nostalgic cooperative game
  • Had a certain charm
  • Loved the theme and concept
  • Fantastic components and objectives
Cons
  • Only two actions per turn, often unsatisfying
  • Long waits between turns
  • Murkiness in communication rules leads to rule-bending/cheating
  • Never quite a keeper
Thematic elements
  • Knights of the Round Table working together to fulfill objectives.
  • Medieval Arthurian
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • cooperative play — Players work together.
  • Hand Management — Collecting cards and fulfilling objectives by building poker hands.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • I feel like there's something that it's just a little bit off and needs a little bit of a fix in order to make it amazing
  • The rule book was absolutely shocking and one of the worst rule books I've ever seen
  • And all these things just became such a burden that it really did it really hindered the gameplay
  • If there was ever a game that I wanted to like more than I actually did I think Shadows of Camelot was an example of that
  • Explaining that to someone for the first time is like talking an alien language
  • the actual work replacement board itself was a bit it seemed a bit novich like novice like it wasn't polished
  • And considering this is a it's pretty eurofied you know it does a good job of still making that theme connect with the mechanism
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video aXiwxy_ChVA Game Night Picks - Pair Of Dice Paradise Other at 10:09 sentiment: positive
Game Night Picks - Pair Of Dice Paradise - Shadows over Camelot video thumbnail
Click to watch at 10:09 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Captures the feeling of desperately juggling multiple urgent problems.
  • Includes a traitor mechanic.
  • Worth seeking out if you like the King's Gambit appeal.
Cons
  • Every turn begins with something bad happening.
  • Finding a copy can be difficult.
Thematic elements
  • Knights defending the kingdom and pursuing quests
  • Camelot
Comparison games
  • The King's Gambit
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • cooperative quests — The Knights of the Round Table work together to defend their fair kingdom by immediately splitting their forces to simultaneously pursue a whole collection of different legendary quests all over the place.
  • Simultaneous Threats — There's the Holy Grail to recover, Excalibur to claim, Saxons and Picss to fight, the Black Knight to confront, Lanclot, and a dragon to deal with. Plus, there's siege engines that are gradually gathering outside the castle walls.
  • traitor mechanic — One of your fellow knights may actually be conspiring against you.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • The Queen's Gambit, which was published way back in the year 2000, it's been out of print for literally decades. And copies of this game are notoriously difficult to find.
  • There's always, always more happening than you can comfortably keep track of.
  • This is a large deep strategic game that attempts to capture the entire War of the Rings experience rather than simply recreating a simple battle from it.
  • One of your fellow knights may actually be conspiring against you, trying to plunge a dagger deep, deep into your back.
  • It takes that wonderful sensation of everything happening all at once and packs it into a tighter package that can still deliver a cinematic finale.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video OqO9iI3BmBA Paula Deming Analysis at 20:48 sentiment: positive
Paula Deming - Shadows over Camelot video thumbnail
Click to watch at 20:48 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
Positive (Decision to keep)
Pros
  • Yes
Cons
none
Thematic elements
  • Knights, Quests, Betrayal
  • Arthurian Legend
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • hidden traitor — A common mechanic in this game, though not explicitly stated here.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • I don't think I can get rid of Catacombs and Castles.
  • I have almost 100 games in my going pile.
  • The total number of games, 540. 540. That's a lot.
  • I've been cataloged. Uh, so I have a spreadsheet where all the boxes are numbered with the games that are in them.
  • And my cool Monopoly Star Trek Collector's game that someone said I should just burn so that there's not more Monopoly in the world, but someone is going to really like this, and I don't want to deny them that.
  • Let's normalize not making add-ons and deluxe bits that don't fit in the game box.
  • I'm not going to play the fox experiment. I'm culling it.
  • So, this one's being cold.
  • This was really tough.
  • The resistance. I'm not going to play it. I have some really lovely memories of playing this with my family. I have other games, social deduction games I would pick over this.
  • I got roasted for this empty box, y'all.
  • I always play this on Board Game Arena. I really like the way the digital interface takes care of all of the scoring and the synergies that go off in the game.
  • We did it.
  • This got so much easier to do once I was categorizing things actually by like how complicated I think the game is to play.
  • Still a lot of games.
  • I was determined to get my collection into a place where I could end this series on a positive note.
  • I more than hit my goal of 100 games.
  • I am not gonna be a person who has a small game collection. Not at this point in my life.
  • And if I can't do that, then more games have to go.
  • I don't really want to do big coolls like this anymore.
  • This was deeply vulnerable and I really hope it was useful for those of you who struggle with the same thing or needed a little motivation in anything that you have that you feel like you have too much of or that is overwhelming you.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video ve3reoCCf9Y BoardGameBollocks Other at 10:58 sentiment: positive
BoardGameBollocks - Shadows over Camelot video thumbnail
Click to watch at 10:58 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
Highly Positive
Pros
  • Favorite hidden traitor game
  • Better than Battlestar Galactica
  • One of Bruno Faidutti's best games
Cons
none
Thematic elements
  • Defending Camelot from evil
  • Arthurian Legend
  • Hidden traitor
Comparison games
  • Battlestar Galactica
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Area Majority — Controlling key locations
  • Card Drafting — Players select cards from a pool
  • cooperative play — Players work together towards a common goal
  • hidden traitor — One or more players secretly work against the others
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Spartacus are going to blood and treachery this is a fantastic game for two to now I think six or seven PI were based on a TV show and there's loads of different things you can get market cast of boosted slaves up and you know go into the arena and there's all this sort of back stem and intrigue stuff and it's a little bit risque some of the cards are a little bit make my mum's or about eyebrows race our yes Barker's going blind treachery
  • so is our car Wars Steve Jackson going about this one since it was released in about 1995 I think it was so this is the deluxe edition and yeah it's a more like a role-playing game their deluxe edition rather than the little pencil case going that you did get but yeah Carl will still going strong today so yeah brilliant go
  • cross master arena this is a sort of Achebe's miniatures game sort of arena combat type thing and yeah you sort of learn it as your place as a wall book sort of staggered as a tutorial so yeah it's not too bad not too great but there you go
  • fellows of the earth one of the best eurogames ever made me love pillars in the earth we we had a thief rages but we sort of didn't really apply it for ages and then we played it before bloody hell work and we had played this for so long was it's been stuck on the shelf for so long so yeah we really love that guy
  • kefalas shadows overcame a lot and yeah this is a hidden treasure game and it's one of our favorite hidden trade games we got rid of about star Galactica so we love this one so much and yes of one of baroque attalos best games this one
  • Vlad hashmarks dungeon pets I like it nobody else will be in our gaming group likes it because it's just a bit too complex and a bit too bitty in your brain but I like it and I don't will never ever go to play again because it went down like a lead balloon when we played it last
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video kfR1OK-9OFA Board Games UnLocked Top List at 33:34 sentiment: negative
Board Games UnLocked - Shadows over Camelot video thumbnail
Click to watch at 33:34 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
negative
Pros
  • Could be fun if you like the theme
  • First hidden traitor game the reviewer played
  • Merlin expansion adds a travel card element
Cons
  • Stupidly dumb
  • Traitor mechanic is pointless
  • Doesn't do anything
  • Bad card draw mechanic
  • Merlin doesn't do much
Thematic elements
  • Knights of the Round Table, traitors
  • Arthurian legend
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Card Drafting — Players draw cards to perform actions.
  • cooperative play — Players work together against the game, with the possibility of a traitor.
  • hidden traitor — One player is secretly a traitor.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • The reason I dated the whole point you to this gentleman in that house for that we house cooler yeah that's just where if there's people in there that you roll a die and on a result of one then it would hit the person like a second it added to fire accident but then anything else we just you go for whatever you were shooting at so that made it decent
  • it was a load of [expletive]
  • people love it I mean none of it makes sense but we were sitting there and Jon's ability to tone with the dragon the judges ability to make no thematic sense of all he was able to crawl under ground and move around and blind people and then also like like he had yet like escaped after he had to wake up but he was moving around while he still needed to wake up talking yeah
  • the game components were garbage
  • the inlay like I'm not just being so really technical right now but just I'm setting like more the inlay was just that shitty plastic that holds the minis and then it's like by the way here's 10 things that pop out so good luck storing it all you [expletive]
  • it's like okay you know and here's where they don't roll anyone they don't want to play with anymore which kills automatically
  • I hate this dipping it it's just like I can't just watch my their runs review over it because that that point there's really brush in my mind
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video SD9rNPyS2iQ BoardGameBollocks Review at 0:27 sentiment: positive
BoardGameBollocks - Shadows over Camelot video thumbnail
Click to watch at 0:27 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Quality components (miniatures, artwork, card quality, insert)
  • Hidden traitor is easy to play up until the reveal, good for new players
  • Tension caused by limited opportunities and the game timer
  • Anyone can be the traitor, keeping the game tense and fresh
Cons
  • Relies on weird poker hands for some quests, which feels disconnected from the theme
  • Choices become very limited towards the end of the game
  • Some rules are fiddly and the rulebooks aren't ideal
  • New players might feel intimidated once the traitor is revealed
Thematic elements
  • Knights of the Round Table on quests with a hidden traitor
  • Camelot
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Accusation / Traitor Reveal — Players can accuse each other of being the traitor under certain conditions.
  • Hand Management — Players use cards from their hand to perform actions, progress quests, or hinder opponents.
  • hidden traitor — A core mechanic where one player is secretly working against the others.
  • Life Point Tracking — Players can lose life points, and a certain number of deaths can lead to game loss.
  • Quest Completion — Players undertake various quests, requiring specific card plays or combinations to succeed.
  • Set Collection / Poker Hands — Some quests involve playing cards that form specific poker hand combinations.
  • Timer mechanism — Siege engines act as a timer, indicating the progression towards the end of the game.
  • Variable Player Powers / Special Cards — Special white cards and Merlin cards offer unique abilities to cancel or influence game effects.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • The quality of the components really do elevate this game up to stratospheric levels.
  • The hidden traitor is really easy to play up until a certain point in the game.
  • The game relies on his weird sort of poker hands.
  • Towards the end of the game your choices become much much more limited than at the beginning of the game.
  • This game is an all-time classic.
  • It is the original intro game in my mind.
  • Shadows over Camelot is a five star game.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video NRSXrQ6kq0c BoardGameBollocks Top List at 2:32 sentiment: positive
BoardGameBollocks - Shadows over Camelot video thumbnail
Click to watch at 2:32 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Broke new ground
  • Fantastic component quality
  • Beautiful artwork
  • Laid groundwork for genre
Cons
none
Thematic elements
  • Camelot
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • cooperative play — everybody remembers that so laid the groundwork for further development in this genre
  • hidden traitor — the granddaddy of hidden traitor games
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Catan is still one of our favorite games of all time we love it
  • it's a wonderful game
  • The component quality is absolutely fantastic it's colorful it's got beautiful artwork.
  • it's a mind bending puzzle.
  • for sheer grandiose and immersive gameplay eldridge horror is really a game that you should play today.
  • this game laid the groundwork for other airing control games on curves in the old world earth blood merchandise or stuff if this if that this game hadn't been made you wouldn't see those wonderful more complex area control games that are available to you today
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video BORxbkCxHSA BoardGameBollocks Top List at 7:56 sentiment: positive
BoardGameBollocks - Shadows over Camelot video thumbnail
Click to watch at 7:56 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • preferred over Battlestar Galactica
  • play in about an hour and a half
  • one of the first hidden traitor games
  • one of the best
  • wonderful components
  • absolute classic
Cons
none
Thematic elements
  • King Arthur's Knights of the Round Table
Comparison games
  • Battlestar Galactica
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Cooperative — everyone's going to take the role of one of King Arthur's knights of the round table
  • hidden traitor — a large prospect of a hit and trader in this one
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • hello welcome back to the ball caps 4k YouTube channel
  • generally talk crap about tabletop gaming in glorious 4k resolution
  • top ten backstabbing games
  • battlestar galactica which we got rid of because it's too long and we've got other games that do similar things and probably in our opinion better than that did
  • it's a wonderful wonderful backstabbing game
  • it's a wonderful wonderful variant
  • it's a wonderful wonderful under appreciate gaming
  • everybody knows this game
  • it's a classic and it's going to be around forever
  • it's a wonderful wonderful game
  • this is the game that we preferred over Battlestar Galactica
  • it's a wonderful wonderful game it's colorful it's got wonderful components and it's an absolute classic
  • it's a wonderful wonderful game you've got these the thing that makes us going to the crossroads faster
  • this guy is absolutely fantastic in so fast backstabbing is concerned
  • this a light backstabber game this is probably the best that you can get
  • Friedrich is to saw this schizophrenic player
  • it really is a wonderful wonderful game
  • maybe it's because it's so dry I don't know maybe it's because it's so historical
  • tell us what you think about our list is there anything that we've missed though
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video b5XdqbS5RfU BoardGameBollocks Top List at 1:40 sentiment: positive
BoardGameBollocks - Shadows over Camelot video thumbnail
Click to watch at 1:40 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • One of the first and pioneering hidden traitor games.
  • Wonderful aesthetic.
  • Plays easily and is short.
Cons
  • Days of Wonder's quality has declined since being taken over by Asmodee.
Thematic elements
  • Knights of the Round Table fending off threats, completing quests, and dealing with a hidden traitor.
  • Arthurian legend.
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • action selection — Players do something good for their cause and then something nasty to hinder their cause.
  • hidden traitor — Credited as one of the first and pioneering hidden traitor games.
  • Quest Completion — Players try to solve quests to get white swords on the round table.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • this is where things start getting really exciting
  • chinatown one of the best if not the best negotiation game that you can play today
  • shadows over camelot it's got a wonderful aesthetic it plays really really easily and it's really short
  • lords of water deep is one of our favorite and we've been playing it for donkey's years
  • whilst it looks like completing that dog it's a well-oiled machine
  • concordia it's a very very simple game it's one of them games acts like a sort of a flowchart
  • this game divides opinions some people love it some people hate it we love it
  • it's credited as making it popular
  • the fact that you're getting something all the time even when it's not your turn means that you're constantly engaged
  • this is the best example of what's called a meta game
  • dogs of war is one of our favorite games of all time it just all comes together in a wildly imaginative package that is accessible at the same time
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video H8Yr9gwAjdI BoardGameBollocks Top List at 5:27 sentiment: positive
BoardGameBollocks - Shadows over Camelot video thumbnail
Click to watch at 5:27 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Plays up to seven players
  • Looks fantastic
  • Still plays really well today
  • Favorite hidden traitor game
Cons
  • Potential for traitor mechanic to be divisive (implied by regret over BSG)
Thematic elements
  • Arthurian legend, defending Camelot
  • Camelot
  • Hidden traitor
Comparison games
  • Battlestar Galactica
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • cooperative play — Players work together to achieve a common goal.
  • hidden traitor — One player may be secretly working against the group.
  • Quest Completion — Players need to achieve a certain amount of swords around Camelot and repel evil forces.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • there are some juicy tasty ball games on this list
  • Kattan is old and it's not worth playing anymore to be replaced by other games they are talking out their ass
  • a game is not just because it's old if that's the case people wouldn't be playing chess would they
  • this game is responsible for the boom in board gaming since 1995
  • anachrony is a fantastic bloody game
  • dogs of war for simplicity and the fact that's got this shifting alliances it's a fantastic euro slash war game
  • it's as close as you're gonna get to a sandbox game messiah legends of a drift system
  • it's probably our favorite hidden trailer game
  • Ave Caesar is one of our favorite racing games
  • if you can get hold of a copy fingers out print then get it it's the quintessential simple racing game mate
  • it's probably one of the most lavishly produced board games we've owned
  • Flick Fleet: one of the most original dexterity games that we've played in a long time and probably one of the best dexterity games will be played in a long time
  • Agricola's probably our favorite one of that type
  • let us know what you think whether or not you think we're talking a load of bollocks
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video NfoPBQAoFTA BoardGameBollocks Top List at 5:33 sentiment: positive
BoardGameBollocks - Shadows over Camelot video thumbnail
Click to watch at 5:33 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Still stands strong today
  • Quintessential hidden traitor game
  • Would rather play than Battlestar Galactica or Dead of Winter
Cons
  • Mini-games detract from the theme
  • Poker hands don't connect to the theme
Thematic elements
  • Arthurian legend
  • Camelot
  • Hidden traitor
Comparison games
  • Battlestar Galactica
  • Dead of Winter
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Good/Bad actions — Essentially, in this game, you will be taking a good action, and then you'll be taking a bad action. And that way, you can't really tell who the evil traitor is.
  • hidden traitor — Shadows over Camelot is a hidden traitor game.
  • Mini-games (Saxons vs Picts, Excalibur) — This game comprises of little mini games, like you've got the Saxons versus the Picts. You've got the Excalibur side board, and various other things.
  • Poker hand mechanics — basically you'll just be playing little poker hands, like four houses or straights or runs or pairs or stuff like that.
  • Set collection (swords) — You win the game if you get a certain amount of white swords on the board, and you lose the game if you've got a certain amount of black swords on the board.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • So we are absolutely honored to have Bruno Cathala join in via Zoom on this video.
  • Seven Wonders Duel does a fantastic job of re-implementing the compelling nature of the original game, but done away with the dummy player that really did sort of plague the original iteration.
  • Bruno Cathala has done an amazing job with this game, and if you haven't played it, then you are a tit.
  • One of the main attractions of Jamaica is the way that it looks. It is a sumptuous production.
  • One criticism I do have of this game is that it doesn't last long enough.
  • it is, for me, the quintessential hidden traitor board game that you can pick up today.
  • This has been the number one game of all time on our list for the last three years.
  • It's just an all round wonderful game that everybody should play at least once.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video b3xw93K9NyQ BoardGameBollocks Top List at 6:04 sentiment: positive
BoardGameBollocks - Shadows over Camelot video thumbnail
Click to watch at 6:04 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Enjoyable
  • Quicker playtime than Battlestar Galactica
  • More simple to play than Battlestar Galactica
Cons
  • Some people prefer Battlestar Galactica
Thematic elements
  • Arthurian legend, questing, and betrayal
  • Camelot
  • Hidden traitor
Comparison games
  • Battlestar Galactica
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • cooperative with traitor — taking a role of one of the knights at a round table and you'll be trying to get white swords into camel all the while preventing black soul my thing
  • hidden traitor — one of your teammates is gonna be a hidden traitor
  • Quest Completion — trying to complete one of the multitude requests that are available like China Gold of the Holy Grail trying to get hold of lancelot's armor or trying to defeat the Black Knight
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • There's a bit of controversy surrounding this Giza last year I can't exactly remember what sort of heinous crime he is supposed to have committed but it probably has something to do with the fact that he upset the board game in Twitter Arty on Twitter anyway the only thing I'm worried about is whether or not he makes decent games and this is an example of one of his better games
  • if you're like dexterity games then this is a no-brainer and if you ain't got it then you ain't got a brain
  • if your house isn't big enough for an air hockey table then clask is the next best thing
  • the Coconuts is one of our favorite dexterity games of all time
  • credited as being the first hidden trailer game
  • Shadows at overcome a lot is still a really enjoyable game what's decade and a half after it was first published and it's one of Bruno Cafe's best games
  • whilst it's dry and doesn't really have any sort of character when you're playing this with a full complement of five players then the paths to Victory and the competition for spaces means that it really is one of them brain burning games that we enjoy a lot
  • for us blood rage is probably one of Eric Lang's best games it's just a shame that he don't make decent games anymore
  • this is a unique game we've never seen anything like it
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video yuONMf1VuVo BoardGameBollocks Top List at 10:56 sentiment: positive
BoardGameBollocks - Shadows over Camelot video thumbnail
Click to watch at 10:56 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Off the charts production quality for its age.
  • Simple rule set that provides a condensed experience of more complex games.
  • Plays up to seven players with no problems.
Cons
  • The existence of the Merlin expansion is questioned.
Thematic elements
  • Knights of the Round Table
  • Arthurian legends
Comparison games
  • Battlestar Galactica
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Card play for quests — Playing cards to create different poker hands to complete different quests.
  • Cooperative quest completion — Players work together to complete quests like defeating the Black Knight or retrieving Excalibur.
  • hidden traitor — One of the knights is secretly a traitor working against the others.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • If your favorite hidden tracker game ain't on this list then that's because I we think it's [blank] or b because we haven't played it.
  • The Resistance a classic game that we just can't stop playing.
  • Room 25 a decent game of exploration with the option of adding a hidden traitor.
  • Betrayal at House on the Hill is another tile lane game.
  • Archipelago takes a lot of mechanisms from games that were made previously and melds them all into a really really good package.
  • Police Precinct is a wonderful game.
  • It's an excellent hidden trait game very dramatic.
  • It's still a fantastic romp through the hidden traitor territory.
  • Battlestar Galactica is a classic hidden role game.
  • The difference between this and all the other hidden trailer games on this list is that you'll be drawing what's known as a crossroads card every turn.
  • Shadows over Camelot sees you take control of one of the knights of the round table from the Arthurian legends.
  • Without a doubt is the finest hidden trailer game of all time.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video 2PHNYh-apQg Top List at 22:05 sentiment: positive
Shadows over Camelot video thumbnail
Click to watch at 22:05 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
Positive
Pros
  • Highly thematic due to IP and player interaction
  • Fun and raucous time with laughter
  • Memorable due to quotes from Monty Python and the Holy Grail
Cons
  • Mechanisms are not inherently thematic
Thematic elements
  • Knights of the Round Table
  • Arthurian legend
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • cooperative play — Implied by the discussion of working together to get things done.
  • Hand Management — Players are often just getting poker hands in the right orders to do things.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Shadows Over Camelot. Now, I used to say that this is probably one of the most thematic games that I've ever played.
  • In the Hall of the Mountain King. Now, this was 97 last year and 76 the year before. So, it's hanging on.
  • Warhammer Underworlds. I probably have close to 10 to 12 different war bands that you can play with this game, but I think I probably have only I don't think I've put together like four of them.
  • Terracotta Army. Terracotta Army was my 96 last year and my 67 the year before.
  • Jackal and Hyde versus Scotland Yard. Another Vincent Dut Trade artwork game. Uh but really it's the mechanisms um that really made this one fun for me.
  • Comic Hunters is a really cool game where you are drafting all different kind of comic book covers.
  • Cities. It's really an interesting thing. And one of the cool things about it is that the game does come with a a good number of different cities.
  • Decorum. This is from Charlie and Harry Mlin and Drew Tennbomb and Floodgate Games. I really like Decorum.
  • Fury of Dracula. Now, I specifically have the uh third edition, but I think the fourth edition is the same.
  • Nar. Um, what makes Nar such a fantastic game is that it really is a race. Everything that you're doing in this is speed of getting to the 40 points and being done.
  • Criminally low. That's all I'm going to say. [referring to Nár's rank]
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video ba9qtOQ51dc Top List at 53:38 sentiment: positive
Shadows over Camelot video thumbnail
Click to watch at 53:38 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
extremely positive, bordering on evangelical
Pros
  • Excellent blend of traitor and cooperative elements
  • Hilarious limited communication mechanic
  • Rewarding cooperative gameplay
  • Punishing but exciting when things go wrong
  • Dramatic traitor reveals are possible
  • Corey is a huge fan and wants to keep it alive
Cons
  • Very out of print and hard to find
Thematic elements
  • King Arthur
  • Arthurian legend
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Hand Management — Managing cards in hand is crucial for contributing to quests and potentially for traitor actions.
  • Limited Communication — Players cannot directly state the cards in their hand, leading to coded language.
  • Semi-Cooperative — Players work together towards common goals, but one player may have opposing objectives.
  • Set Collection — Players collect specific types of cards to complete quests.
  • traitor mechanic — Features a hidden traitor who works against the semi-cooperative group.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • For my money, the best board game of all time is Dungeons and Dragons.
  • It's a board game because I say it is, and it's the best thing you can do on a tabletop with a bunch of nerds. Fight me.
  • IT'S THE BOARD GAME, ACTUALLY. LIKE, the game itself. I'm not going to just I'm not going to run this into the ground. It's freaking Wingspan. It's It's arguably the best game ever made.
  • That's a little bit funner, in my opinion, getting to go, "Oh, look at all these points."
  • And that's the worst I have to say about Wingspan.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video TCWuKD6RPmE Board to Death TV - Board Game Reviews Review at 0:16 sentiment: positive
Board to Death TV - Board Game Reviews - Shadows over Camelot video thumbnail
Click to watch at 0:16 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Game play is quick and fun
  • Player interaction is present
  • Production quality is nice
  • Comes with a decent game for about $25
  • Includes night variant and solo play variant
  • Had fun playing this game
Cons
  • Hard game to master
  • Requires a really good memory unless you're the traitor
Thematic elements
  • Defeating Morgan
  • Camelot
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Accusation — Players can accuse another player of being good or evil, with this action usable only once per game.
  • cooperative play — Players will work together to defeat Morgan.
  • Hand Management — Special cards like Merlin, Morgan, Vivien, and Mrid do special effects. Players can also use cards to switch loyalty.
  • Hidden Roles — Loyalty cards determine if a player is a Trader or not, with some players loyal to Arthur and others to Morgan.
  • questing — Players can reveal cards into a quest pile or go on a quest using those cards. Quests are separated into main and secondary quests based on card totals.
  • Set Collection — Players remember the total number for each symbol in the quest pile. Different symbols are tracked by different players.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • It's a it's a really hard game to master and you better have a really good memory unless you're the Traer than you just mess everyone up
  • we're giving 7 and 1 half loyal Knights out of 10
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video SFlNk-1gOEs Top List at 4:27 sentiment: positive
Shadows over Camelot video thumbnail
Click to watch at 4:27 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Cooperative play with a hidden traitor mechanism
  • Simple and elegant mechanisms
  • Beautiful artwork and board design
  • Engaging 'blame game' aspect
  • Enjoyable experience even when there is no traitor
Cons
  • Potential for no traitor, which some players might prefer to house rule.
Thematic elements
  • Cooperative play with a potential secret traitor in a King Arthur setting
  • King Arthur legends
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • cooperative play — The core gameplay is cooperative, with players working together towards a common goal.
  • Hidden Role / Traitor — There is a possibility of a secret traitor among the players, adding an element of suspicion.
  • Mission resolution — Players attempt to complete different missions.
  • Set Collection — Players place white swords on the round table to trigger the game end and black swords to represent failures.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • this is a party style game very much in the spirit of games like the resistance
  • clearly a puzzle it's a numeric puzzle a mathematic problem if you will
  • it's a Cooperative game that again has a secret Trader mechanism
  • it's the only game or one of the few games that you could play at really high player counts like six or seven and that does not necessarily interfere with the game length
  • a game like vid culture cannot be accused of that it really feels thematic to me
  • Players take turns being the Sheriff of Nottingham and the other players are trying to sneak in uh Goods sometimes legal Goods sometimes illegal Goods known as Contraband
  • I do remember some really cool combinations of actions taking place
  • this game is so intuitive and so easy to teach young people or new players
  • these games are both published by IDW designed by Kevin Wilson they're pretty much the same game system with different uh intellectual properties behind them
  • Batman shadow of the bat from the very start gives you that Cooperative variance
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video tx9xyd-tex8 Top List at 18:36 sentiment: positive
Shadows over Camelot video thumbnail
Click to watch at 18:36 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Made the list due to a profound life lesson learned from gameplay.
  • Can be a cooperative challenge.
Cons
  • Host doesn't own it.
  • Out of print.
  • Cooperative games are not a huge thing for the host.
  • The example provided shows a potential pitfall where too much success can lead to failure.
Thematic elements
  • Questing
  • Arthurian legend
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • hidden traitor — The game can be played with a hidden traitor, which might alter the game's dynamic.
  • Quest Completion — Players win by accomplishing quests and placing swords on the round table before the firefighting element overwhelms them.
  • Semi-Cooperative — Players work together but can have a hidden traitor, though the host only played cooperatively.
  • Set Collection — Accumulating swords on the round table is key to victory.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • It's not to say that they're bad games. It's just that if I'm going to put something in a top 100 list, I think it ought to be something that is a little bit more representative of what I do and play than just becau just a side mention that I own the game.
  • The premise is pretty much the same. Uh the the biggest difference is the the hidden roles, but uh it's fallen on my list a little bit, but uh that's simply because I'm not a huge party game person.
  • It's a game that's old, old old and it's just a game that has some really unique strategy to it, but like most abstract games, it can start falling flat because it's sy.
  • And because of that, Athell is my number 98 game.
  • The art on this is amazing. It is beautiful, beautiful art.
  • Sometimes we get discouraged on our failures, about how we're not living up to what we expect, some madeup standard that we're not achieving. But you know what? Sometimes we need to fail. Even if we tried our best to succeed, sometimes we need to fail so that we can succeed down the road so that we can learn the lessons that we need to learn to pass future tests.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video 1m9Muw0wIqs Board Games UnLocked Top List at 3:17 sentiment: negative
Board Games UnLocked - Shadows over Camelot video thumbnail
Click to watch at 3:17 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
negative
Pros
  • Theme
  • Monty Python quotes
Cons
  • Weak traitor mechanic
  • Monotonous gameplay
  • Expansion didn't improve the game
Thematic elements
  • Monty Python
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Card Play — You play cards like 'I got a straight, I win' or 'I got three sixes and twos, I did, I got more than him, I win'.
  • traitor mechanic — Praised as the best traitor mechanic game, but the reviewer disagrees because everyone does a bad thing.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • This is a list of top 10 games I hate but it's a revised edition.
  • I also rated these games at how pissed off I got while playing them.
  • Worst game I have ever played.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video fAhGiEUX-8o Board Games UnLocked Review at 0:15 sentiment: mixed
Board Games UnLocked - Shadows over Camelot video thumbnail
Click to watch at 0:15 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
mixed
Pros
  • Plays a lot of players (up to seven)
  • Can be taken and played easily
  • Painted miniatures enhance the game's appearance and theme
  • Accessible difficulty level
  • Cohesion and cooperation are encouraged
  • Innovative for its time
  • If the game is shorter, it is more enjoyable
Cons
  • Does not always like the traitor element
  • Can take forever to finish
  • Pacing issue, can slow down significantly after initial goals are met
  • Can become one-sided with certain characters
  • Difficulty in being a good traitor without experience
  • Can become too easy if the traitor is known or inexperienced
  • Luck-driven gameplay
  • Lack of ways to speed up the game
  • Gameplay mechanics are not very thematic (e.g., playing poker for quests)
  • Can be a long game (60-90 minutes estimated)
Thematic elements
  • Arthurian legend
  • Camelot
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Card Play — Cards are played to complete quests, fight enemies, or mitigate negative effects. The draw of these cards significantly impacts gameplay.
  • cooperative play — Players generally work together against the game, though the traitor mechanic adds a competitive layer.
  • hidden traitor — A core mechanic where one player works against the others. The effectiveness of this mechanic is debated among the reviewers.
  • Player elimination (traitor accusation) — A traitor can be accused and kicked out of the game, but remains active in a way that can still impact the game negatively.
  • questing — Players undertake quests to progress the game, often requiring specific card plays.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • my feelings on it is exactly the same as it was back then. I don't even remember my original feelings. I remember not caring for it and I still don't really care for this game.
  • this game has a pacing issue because once once you go after the big three, you know, the big items, the then it's like, oh, I guess we'll try to do this one for one sword.
  • I have yet to find a traitor mechanism game that does it as well as Battlestar.
  • the gameplay-wise, it's not thematic really in any way. It's like, 'Hey, let's go to battle.' And you beat them by playing a straight. Like, let's go let's go to joust the black knight. Two pair. It's very odd to me.
  • I don't think I would play this game again. I don't think it offers enough for me personally to cuz it's like it's fun at the beginning and then yeah, that that screech to like a halt to just hope that you draw the right cards just to end it one way or another.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video I34PJa2MEPk Board Games UnLocked Playthrough at 0:16 sentiment: mixed
Board Games UnLocked - Shadows over Camelot video thumbnail
Click to watch at 0:16 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
mixed
Pros
  • Special abilities for each knight can be good
  • Cooperative effort towards goals
Cons
  • Confusion regarding rules and mechanics
  • Frustration with game progression
  • Difficulty in identifying the traitor
Thematic elements
  • Saving the realm, Arthurian legend
  • Camelot
Comparison games
  • Tainted Grail
  • Avalon
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Card Drafting — Players draw white and black cards to aid or hinder their progress.
  • Hand Management — Players play cards from their hands to contribute to quests and abilities.
  • questing — Players must complete various quests to progress the game and defend Camelot.
  • special abilities — Each knight has a unique special ability that can be used once per turn.
  • traitor mechanic — One player is secretly a traitor, working against the other knights to prevent them from saving the realm. The game revolves around identifying and dealing with this traitor.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • I feel like I'm not even the traitor I'm sad I'm taking the game
  • I don't trust Cat to be honest
  • What if the king was the traitor?
  • I accused you
  • You're the traitor
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video uUNCXahr_So The Discriminating Gamer Top List at 16:12 sentiment: positive
The Discriminating Gamer - Shadows over Camelot video thumbnail
Click to watch at 16:12 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Great game
  • So much fun
  • Love hidden traitor games
Cons
  • Has fallen on the list since 2021 (from 41 to 71)
  • Haven't played it in a long time
  • Requires at least five people to play
  • Haven't played with the expansion
Thematic elements
  • King Arthur and the Knights of the Round Table completing quests
  • Camelot
  • Hidden traitor
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • action selection — Players must choose between playing a good card/completing a quest and taking an 'evil action'.
  • hidden traitor — Players work together to complete quests, but one or more may be a traitor working against the group.
  • Quest Completion — Players use cards to complete quests.
  • Set Collection — Likely involved in completing quests.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • My number 80 is a great IP game that um I haven't heard much about lately.
  • This is War Story Occupied France from Osprey Games.
  • This is Lord of the Rings Duel for Middleear.
  • This is Forbidden Stars from Fantasy Flight Games.
  • This is Halloween 2 from Trick-or-Treat Studios.
  • And I am talking about Worms Span from Stonemare Games.
  • This is from Alderac Entertainment Group. Space Base.
  • This is Cthulhu Wars from Peterson Games.
  • This is Talon. Talon is a great game.
  • This is from Days of Wonder, Shadow Over Camelot.
  • So, that is my number 80 through 71. What do you think?
  • I always want to hear what you have to say about the games on my list.
  • If you like what we do here, please check out my other channel that is Cody Carlson PhD where I talk about history, uh, books on history, sorts of all sorts of fun things like that.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video 4OHWCxS0MJk Rolling Dice & Taking Names Discussion at 1:31:12 sentiment: neutral
Rolling Dice & Taking Names - Shadows over Camelot video thumbnail
Click to watch at 1:31:12 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
neutral
Pros
none
Cons
  • Lost to Candyland in a popularity poll.
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
  • Candyland
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • it's a popularity contest
  • those are your gateway games that will eventually lead to the pandemics
  • I'm not gonna begrudge anybody to sit and play Monopoly that that's all they know man
  • if you like monopoly you might like and then suggest something else
  • I will play Monopoly with you anytime as long as we play by the rules
  • there's the problem everybody has a slight what do you play with this particular rule no there's no house rules play by the real rules
  • I think that's a natural step and I think people could easily go from monopoly to ticket to ride
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video YBXqAiCyVPc Watch It Played Discussion at 2:31
Watch It Played - Shadows over Camelot video thumbnail
Click to watch at 2:31 · YouTube ↗
Pros
none
Cons
  • Group does not speak in character
Thematic elements
  • Camelot
  • Speaking in character as rules suggest
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Once you've bought the game it's yours to do with as you see fit there aren't any rules police that are going to come knocking at the door if you don't abide by the rule book
  • At the end of the day if there's a rule that's just getting in the way of you being able to enjoy that game that you spent your money on then why not change it and get on with enjoying the game
  • I realized that I started this video in the original table talk episode being a little more staunchly against house rules and as this discussion went on and you guys provide these different responses I had to reconsider my position I think I actually am a little more open to host rules than I first imagined myself being
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video hwpSQbHxK7o 3 Minute Board Games Top List at 11:43 sentiment: mixed
3 Minute Board Games - Shadows over Camelot video thumbnail
Click to watch at 11:43 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
mixed
Pros
  • Pretty damn good game
  • First hidden traitor game played
Cons
  • Has been sitting on the shelf gathering dust
  • Groups prefer Battle Star Galactica for the hidden traitor experience
  • Occupied much of the same space as Battle Star Galactica
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
  • Battle Star Galactica
  • Dead of Winter
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • hello and welcome to games that left my collection in 2018 this is a list of 10 games I've gotten rid of over the last year or so
  • not every game needs to stay in your collection especially not if you found a game that does much the same thing only a lot better for you
  • I don't have to be the one that owns everything I don't have to be the person in the group that owns every single game other people can own games and I can borrow them off them that's fine that's great
  • it's actually quite neat for other people in your group to go actually this is the game I want to own I want to add this to my shelf and for you to go cool you you get that one that's awesome I don't need every single game
  • the app absolutely killed my interest in playing this as a solo on the tabletop or as a multiplayer game
  • all I could think was this is an improved version of Arkham Horror wow I must be totally out of line with what everyone else is thinking because I'm not enjoying this at all
  • it really bugs me when the optimal way to play someone is so utterly boring
  • one thing that drove me up the wall was when a character would be at one location discover a clue but then anyone could act on it so if you were on the opposite side of the map you could go and complete that assignment and it just didn't make any sense to me
  • Foreclosed is just rubbish
  • you either have to play down so people can learn the game or you play your ability and people just get stomped
  • it's just because the groups I play with if they want that hidden Trader experience they're going to play Battle Star Galactica and shadows of Camelot just occupied much of the same space
  • no game is for everyone and Through the Ages is not for me
  • it's just such a time consumer there's so much fiddling around with cubes and the game just has a heck of a lot of downtime when it's someone else's turn
  • my only real regret with this one is that I got rid of it just before I started the channel because despite my reservations with the game I think it's one that would do quite well as a 3-minute recap
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video UKko5RbQQPM BoardGameBollocks Top List at 1:45 sentiment: positive
BoardGameBollocks - Shadows over Camelot video thumbnail
Click to watch at 1:45 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Original hidden traitor game
  • Fantastic production quality
  • Still looks awesome
Cons
  • Out of print
  • Goes for stupid money
Thematic elements
  • Arthurian legend, betrayal
  • The court of King Arthur
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • cooperative play — you're going to be taken on the role of one of the members of the Arthurian Court
  • hidden traitor — Shadows over Camelot is the original hidden traitor game.
  • Set Collection — you'll be trying to get a certain number of white swords onto the round table whilst avoiding getting any black swords on the round table.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • I hope you [__] are interally grateful to me for causing myself this much pain and suffering
  • Panic on Wall Street is way out of print so I'm not like dangling carrots or anything but if you can find it and you can afford to buy the vacant Epstein Island then Panic on Wall Street is a fantastic investment
  • Shadows over Camelot is the original hidden traitor game maybe it laid the groundwork for other games like Battle Star Galactica and smaller games like the resistance and all that [__]
  • the combat system does leave the other players just sitting there toling their thumbs quite a bit there's a little bit of downtime on this and it is a really long game
  • Picture Perfect is a Zen like experience for me and it allows me that sort of breathing space to go back to kicking all you [__] heads in when I lose or rag
  • it's huge it's vast it's confusing and we love it
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video lFAO5TFZn-8 BoardGameBollocks Top List at 9:33 sentiment: positive
BoardGameBollocks - Shadows over Camelot video thumbnail
Click to watch at 9:33 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
Positive
Pros
  • One of the first hidden traitor games
  • Lighter, easier, and quicker than comparable games
  • Fantastic component quality
  • Still reasonably affordable if picked up second-hand
Cons
  • Expansion (Merlin's Company) is nearly impossible to get hold of
  • Second-hand copies go for stupid money
Thematic elements
  • Knights of the Round Table
  • Camelot
Comparison games
  • Battlestar Galactica
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Card Play — Players use cards to play poker-style hands.
  • cooperative play — Players work together to achieve a common goal.
  • hidden traitor — One player might be a traitor working against the group.
  • roll and move — Implied by the context of playing cards and completing quests, though not explicitly detailed as the primary movement mechanic.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • it's Shadows over Camelot yeah
  • one of you may be a dirty filthy traitor and you'll be working against the other players trying to make bad [__] happen without getting caught
  • credited as being one of the first hidden traitor games
  • it's lighter and easier to play and quicker than games like battar Galactica
  • the component quality is fantastic this comes from an era when desel Wonder actually made quality games
  • this is Memoir 44
  • the reason I was Al and earin but sticking this on the list is because I own almost everything that's been produced for this game
  • the only problem I've got with Memoir 44 it's getting to the point now where it looks as stuffy as a geriatrics [__]
  • if it was made sort of compatible with the existing stuff you sort of edge your way into it you know sort of wean yourself off of the old stuff and gradually buy the new stuff as it come along then maybe they could make this game feel like more modern have updated components
  • something like 20 years old it's about time that we all admitted to ourselves that there needs to be a reprint of this a refresh it needs to be brought up to date with the current fantastic high quality standards of modern board games
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video s7BkpEBpHyw Chairman of the Board Top List at 18:58 sentiment: positive
Chairman of the Board - Shadows over Camelot video thumbnail
Click to watch at 18:58 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
Positive
Pros
  • An oldie but a goodie
Cons
none
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Cooperative games are actually not my forte I don't play too many of them and when I do play them and the ones I enjoy tend to be on the lighter end of the spectrum
  • if you're looking for the highly and heavily involved complex Cooperative games then you're probably not going to find many of those kind of games on this list these are a lot breezier because that's what I tend to enjoy when working with others
  • I didn't realize how much I enjoyed Real Time games until kind of going back through this uh list
  • Sometimes that is not always necessary and for me these are two perfect examples of that where game play Just trumps everything
  • Such a cool concept it works beautifully and I can't create ize the game at all I think it is that much fun and a true game that anybody can play drop in and out of it's just a blast
  • And yeah there is good as party games get and as good as coopertive games get in my opinion
  • Now I understand they're not heavy complex involved games with lots of strategy but sometimes that is not always necessary and for me these are two perfect examples of that where game play Just trumps everything
  • Spirit Island a fantastic heavy Euro game that didn't quite work for me in terms of being a bit overwhelming and I was so bad at it but gameplay wise it is um pretty magnificent
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video pkI25DaHAWo BoardGameBollocks Top List at 5:09 sentiment: positive
BoardGameBollocks - Shadows over Camelot video thumbnail
Click to watch at 5:09 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • One of the best hidden traitor games
Cons
  • Out of print
Thematic elements
  • King Arthur's court
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • action selection — On your turn you'll choose something good to happen and then you'll have to choose something bad to happen.
  • Area Majority — You win if at the end of the game you got more white swords on the board that and black s.
  • hidden traitor — Credited for being the first hidden traitor game. A hidden traitor can choose something bad deliberately.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • if your top 100 ball games aren't on this list that's because a we haven't played them B we think they complete dog [ __ ]
  • You could accuse Eric M Lang of copying a lot of ideas from his other games and just reimplementing them in Rising Sun but it's different enough from another couple of games that he's done for us to pick it up and keep playing it
  • ordinarily I hate roll and move you must know that by now but like a lot of these games I can make exceptions for formula D
  • it does tell one of the most hilarious and memorable stories that you likely to get in a board game
  • This is one of those rare occasions where the theme isn't pasted on and it actually attaches itself to the mechanics of the game in a kind of sort of expert manner
  • You win if at the end of the game you got more white swords on the board that and black s
  • It's like a two- tiered mechanical system going on here
  • It can be a little bit hairy bit like my knck sack if I run out of Lady Shavers
  • The fact that you're going to be getting stuff on other people's turns and the game moves really really quickly means that there is basically zero downtime in this game here
  • Eldj horror ended up with more [ __ ] babies than alucino at 86
  • it's another one of those Amor trash storytelling games where sometimes you just want to sit back put your feet up and let the dice do the talking and have a good old rump around the world and not give a flying [ __ ] about what is going on around you
  • If you're not really that good at fondling people's sacks then Eclipse may not be for you
  • have you decided to jump off a Motorway Bridge without a trampoline I hope not
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video GS-SsFY2RuU UndeadVikingVideos Discussion at 25:57 sentiment: positive
UndeadVikingVideos - Shadows over Camelot video thumbnail
Click to watch at 25:57 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Good for introducing the traitor mechanic to new players
Cons
  • Needs to be reprinted
  • Out of print and expensive
Thematic elements
  • Camelot
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • traitor mechanic — Introduces the concept of a traitor within the group.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Playing without Val I mean like the moment you play with Valhalla that's the moment you realize I will never not play with balla
  • it is now I believe in my top 30 games of all time
  • it's not a looker I mean it's just cards a board
  • worst demo of any game ever with that ascendency game
  • the rakugan game that's B based in uh the l5r universe
  • Roller ball is an incoherent mess a jumble of footage in search of plot meaning Rhythm and sense
  • I'm this close to a North American cable deal
  • Roller ball has a scene where they they have to all her night vision goggles yeah but but it's like but for you know but for whatever Reon I forget the exact reason is but then the camera goes into the night vision look you know so you can see where the night vision but then they take off their night vision goggles but you continue in the night vision look
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video NBrVGXOlT9I Board Game Critique Top 8 List at 2:11 sentiment: positive
Board Game Critique - Shadows over Camelot video thumbnail
Click to watch at 2:11 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Tense atmosphere and meaningful choices
  • Strong group dynamics at larger player counts
Cons
  • Can stall with long deliberations
  • Less satisfying at very low player counts
Thematic elements
  • paranoia and betrayal within a cooperative quest
  • Camelot, with quests and a round table
  • mythic questing with potential traitor sabotage
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Cooperative Game — Players work together to complete quests for the realm.
  • cooperative questing — Players work together to complete quests for the realm.
  • hidden traitor mechanic — There may be a traitor among players who sabotages quests.
  • Multi-Use Cards — Cards influence quest outcomes and can pressure accusations.
  • Public and black cards — Cards influence quest outcomes and can pressure accusations.
  • Traitor Game — There may be a traitor among players who sabotages quests.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Massive social deduction in a cursed village.
  • The storyteller moderates, keeps balance, and adds drama.
  • Every game forms a new narrative.
  • One Night Ultimate Werewolf: Lightning fast. Social deduction.
  • The traitor subtly tanks quests, plays black cards, or pressures the table into false accusations.
  • Carl became the traitor before his character even got to move.
  • We spent the rest of the game running and screaming, 'Carl!'
  • It's the best feeling for the traitor and the worst for everyone else.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video KLWi8e6FtPg The Dice Tower Top 100 List at 0:54 sentiment: mixed
The Dice Tower - Shadows over Camelot video thumbnail
Click to watch at 0:54 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
mixed
Pros
  • Strong thematic hook and betrayal element; good for groups
Cons
  • Flaws become more apparent with age; game balance can be uneven
Thematic elements
  • cooperation under suspicion, loyalty, and subterfuge
  • Arthurian Camelot; cooperative questing with a traitor mechanic
  • mythic/legendary quests with a traitor twist
Comparison games
  • The Lord of the Rings (Knizia)
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • cooperative gameplay with traitor mechanic — Players work together to complete quests while one player may secretly betray the group.
  • group decision making and suspicion — Deductions and mistrust influence choices and outcomes.
  • quest cards / narrative-driven objectives — Quests provide thematic goals that drive player actions.
  • Traitor Game — Players work together to complete quests while one player may secretly betray the group.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • this was the game that put cooperative games on the map because I played this I played Lord of the Rings from Knizia, but this was the game that did it and also added that traitor aspect which was so interesting.
  • I really enjoyed playing it.
  • the cleanest version of Carcassonne I think
  • Mystery of the Abbey is fantastic.
  • It's a game of pure logic until it's not.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video uM4ULThB-q0 Neon Gorilla Analysis at 0:36
Neon Gorilla - Shadows over Camelot video thumbnail
Click to watch at 0:36 · YouTube ↗
Pros
none
Cons
none
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • traitor element — The game has a traitor element, which could appear or is always there.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • after playing it, uh, the the the reaction that I saw when that first epidemic hit where people got out of their seats
  • Oh, really?
  • out where the epi- Yeah, when the when they find out, "Oh my god, where is the epidemic going to hit?" Uh, and I looked I went, "Yeah, I'm doing this game."
  • Was there much co-op back then?
  • No. So, there there were only a few co-op games and they all and they all had except for maybe one, they all had a traitor element to it, which could appear or is always there. Like Shadows over Camelot, I believe. Uh, that was the big one back the the the modern one back then.
  • Uh, I believe there was one full co-op game and I want to say it was a Hobbit game.
  • Uh, you know, a a Lord of the Rings Hobbit type game where it was a full co-op. Uh, but yeah, there were really not
  • Nothing. No hits.
  • It wasn't a culture at all.
  • Yeah, and people tried to talk me out of it.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video EXgFlIBdqzE Rules Teach at 0:35 sentiment: positive
Shadows over Camelot video thumbnail
Click to watch at 0:35 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Still a good game
  • Engaging cooperative gameplay
  • Tense traitor mechanic
  • Unique communication rules
  • Variety of quests
  • Special abilities for each knight
Cons
  • Can be lost if traitor goes undetected
  • Accusations can be bad for morale if wrong
  • Potential for Camelot to fall under siege engines or too many black swords
Thematic elements
  • Arthurian quests and battling forces of evil, potentially with a traitor among the Knights of the Round Table.
  • Camelot
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Accusation — A heroic action allows players to accuse another of being the traitor, with specific consequences for both loyal and traitorous revealed players.
  • Combat — Certain quests involve playing fight cards to overcome black fight cards or battle against siege engines.
  • cooperative play — Players team up to battle evil and complete quests, with a shared win/loss condition for loyal knights.
  • Hand Management — Players must keep their hands secret and make vague allusions to their cards.
  • Push Your Luck — Players can spend life points to perform an additional action, risking their health for more progress.
  • questing — Players work to complete various Arthurian quests, which add white swords for success and black swords for failure to the Round Table.
  • Set Collection — Discarding three identical cards can be used to gain one life.
  • traitor mechanic — One player may secretly be a traitor aiming for the loyal knights to lose.
  • Variable player powers — Each knight has a special ability, such as King Arthur's ability to swap a white card or Sir Galahad's ability to play special white cards for free.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Shadows over Camelot was one of the first modern Cooperative board games and it's still a good one
  • keep your hand secret no talking about what cards you have instead you'll make vague illusions to the contents of your hand
  • The Traer only wins if all the other players lose
  • Shadows over Camelot the group project simulator
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video QcvzJ0BZ2qE Discussion at 1:18:50 sentiment: neutral
Shadows over Camelot video thumbnail
Click to watch at 1:18:50 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
neutral
Pros
none
Cons
none
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • I'm not a businessman. Uh, I am not jack business Eddie.
  • If you build it, they'll come.
  • The cult of new is so strong that I feel like having a lot of content saying older games are also still really great. Um, yeah, can also counteract that.
  • The entire Carboard Herald experiment, uh, has been about a dialogue, uh, between the people hosting it and an audience about sharing enthusiastic love for tabletop gaming and the people who make it.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video l7OEGDl_6rY Top List at 4:01 sentiment: positive
Shadows over Camelot video thumbnail
Click to watch at 4:01 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
Positive
Pros
  • Considered a classic hidden traitor game.
  • Definitively on both hosts' lists.
Cons
none
Thematic elements
  • Knights saving Camelot, potential traitor
  • Camelot
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • cooperative play — Loyal Knights unite to save Camelot
  • hidden traitor — old school hidden Trader Trad
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • so we have a list of every single game that was released in 2005 and we're going to go through all of them in a three-hour episode absolutely not
  • we have a potential pool of 25 board games but only 10 can be inducted into our newly minted Hall of Fame that's the rules that's the rules only 10 we made them up that's the rules
  • you could argue with us in the comments and tell us why we're wrong you could do that always an option
  • I'm going to be real honest with everyone that this list of games from 2005 there are a bunch on here I don't know
  • that is like the oldest of old school hidden Trader Trad
  • it spawned so many other games right we have a ton of games in this Arkham Horror World which is obviously the world of HP Lovecraft
  • I think wits and wagers is a is a classic
  • it is on my list it's one of the very early like kind of worker placement kind of mean Euro dry Euro kind of game that I played
  • this is like a grill game for people
  • wow we didn't even rehearse that
  • it sounds like if your jam is hidden rolls or social deduction style games and you haven't played Shadow hunters and you see it out in the wild maybe pick KCK it maybe give it a whirl you might like it
  • if this isn't a classic game I don't know what it is
  • it is ubiquitous when it comes to board games not just the theme but sooner or later if you're talking about board games eventually Arkham Horror is going to hit the table
  • many aboard gamer covet this
  • people still talk about I mean any game that you're still it's 20 years old and you're like I should play that sometimes
  • I may have my Nostalgia goggles on and uh you know be looking at it through those rosecolor glasses
  • it's a game 100% you can play with your kids
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video doJoJsXRsw8 Analysis at 43:16 sentiment: positive
Shadows over Camelot video thumbnail
Click to watch at 43:16 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
Positive, with reservations
Pros
  • Good game
  • Influential in spawning other games
Cons
  • Potential flaw with cards
  • Not currently in print
Thematic elements
  • Arthurian Legend
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • traitor mechanic — Mentioned as a key mechanic that influenced later games in the genre.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • I think from my perspective based on what I've seen of the games that they inducted the original 25 uh I just wanted to speculate on what the next 25 would be
  • there's some interesting gaps in the 25 list that's out there now
  • Shadows over Camelot out really started that whole thing
  • it influences things that you wouldn't necessarily think that it did influence that kind of thing
  • it really took the world over for several years
  • it's like too big I mean the shadows of Brimstone which isn't on this list and I would never suggest to be in the Hall of Fame is like its own thing
  • it is such um a force or a presence in the board gaming world that it just has to be in there
  • it's almost like the quintessential board game in in a way
  • it is really the predecessor of all of these board games that have been a big part of the board game geek hobby
  • maybe eventually this is my opinion here I think they should stick to the games for a few years and then you know later on they can start thinking about like putting ryer kitsi in or stefen Feld or Christian Peterson or Corey kesa Cole Worley Richard Borg
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video q2KGiUTpY3E The Dice Tower Discussion at 4:49 sentiment: positive
The Dice Tower - Shadows over Camelot video thumbnail
Click to watch at 4:49 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • classic cooperative experience
  • tension around trader mechanics
Cons
  • some fiddly rules
  • trader balance can be tricky
Thematic elements
  • medieval fantasy cooperative game with potential trader elements
  • Camelot; Arthurian legend
Comparison games
  • Descent
  • Battlestar Galactica
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Cooperative Game — Players work together to achieve objectives against the game, with potential betrayal elements.
  • cooperative play — Players work together to achieve objectives against the game, with potential betrayal elements.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • It's going to change the industry whether we like it or not.
  • Time heals wounds. It really does.
  • If we're always traveling, we're not doing content.
  • Everyone is welcome at my cons except jerks.
  • The best way to find out if a game is out of print? Try to buy it.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video adKwQ9pCc78 Board Stupid Top List at 8:13 sentiment: positive
Board Stupid - Shadows over Camelot video thumbnail
Click to watch at 8:13 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • strong thematic feel and memorable components
  • simple core mechanics with deep emergent play
  • great for a group that enjoys social interaction and suspicion
Cons
  • rules can be opaque and setup lengthy
  • group-dependent experience; some sessions can stall
Thematic elements
  • Betrayal within a fellowship, chivalry, questing
  • Arthurian legend-inspired knights quest
  • Semi-cooperative with a hidden traitor (Black Knight) optional
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Hand Management — Players manage cards to undertake quests and advance the board state
  • Narrative Choice — Quest outcomes and events shape the ongoing narrative
  • story-driven quests — Quest outcomes and events shape the ongoing narrative
  • Traitor Game — One or more players may secretly be traitors working against the group
  • traitor mechanic — One or more players may secretly be traitors working against the group
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • the two Hitler and the fascist players are going to try to demolish democracy and take over the power
  • it plays with giving everyone bad information
  • it's a pretty decent social deduction game
  • it's a backstabbing traitor Black Knight
  • it's such a cool theme and it's such a cool game
  • the game is like go kill player three oh damn okay that's the game from now on
  • you need to lean into those secret things with 100% conviction
  • the role playing in the game is essential
  • it's all of these games but just cranked up to 11
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video hpMw99KFqMw Game Night Picks - Pair Of Dice Paradise Top List at 5:36 sentiment: positive
Game Night Picks - Pair Of Dice Paradise - Shadows over Camelot video thumbnail
Click to watch at 5:36 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Nostalgia and Arthurian theming
  • Solid core mechanics and social interaction
  • Strong art and component quality
Cons
  • Older design may feel clunky to new players
  • Trait or mechanic can be polarizing
Thematic elements
  • Cooperative quests with a hidden traitor element
  • Camelot, Arthurian legend
  • Semi-cooperative, thematic collaborative play with social deduction
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Card management / hand management — Managing cards to progress on quests.
  • Cooperative play with hidden traitor — Players work together on quests while one may secretly oppose them.
  • Quest cards / scenarios — Players undertake quests that require coordination and planning.
  • Role-based / traitor dynamics — Possible traitor reveals and suspicion among players.
  • Traitor Game — Possible traitor reveals and suspicion among players.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Power Grid. I'm never getting rid of my copy of Power Grid.
  • I want to play Power Grid.
  • Power Grid to be online somewhere to play.
  • If you see me out in the wild... the answer is yes.
  • Shadows Over Camelot is a great game. I would say yes.
  • We should play Shadows Over Camelot.
  • I love King Arthur and Camelot.
  • Dixit is one of the games that got me into board games.
  • Dixit comes with a lot of these abstract kind of esoterically beautiful artwork cards.
  • It was the first game to have these beautiful abstract artwork cards on it.
  • I really like the game Detective Club.
  • Mysterium, Obscurio, Detective Club were inspired by Dixit.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video F1wpHvQMvcc Game Night Picks - Pair Of Dice Paradise Discussion at 13:07 sentiment: positive
Game Night Picks - Pair Of Dice Paradise - Shadows over Camelot video thumbnail
Click to watch at 13:07 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • strong thematic flavor
  • great group dynamics when the group is engaged
Cons
  • execution can be fragile if pacing slips
Thematic elements
  • co-op with potential traitor mechanic
  • Arthurian mythic quest
  • story-driven collaborative play with twists
Comparison games
  • Battlestar Galactica
  • Shadows over Camelot
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • cooperative play with betrayal — players cooperate but a hidden traitor may undermine the group
  • story-based quests — each quest unfolds with set-up and conditions to win
  • Traitor Game — players cooperate but a hidden traitor may undermine the group
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • I had an amazing time but that's a game that you're super engaged with the players and the game for three to four hours so the time kind of flew
  • the time kind of flew
  • it's funny you say that because I have a built-in clock even if a game is long if there's some element that eventually will wind down and the game will end I love that
  • Scheduling in advance is really the way to go
  • I rarely actually rarely get to play a three plus hour game
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video vwNcT48viZI The Dice Tower Discussion at 5:03
The Dice Tower - Shadows over Camelot video thumbnail
Click to watch at 5:03 · YouTube ↗
Pros
none
Cons
none
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • We added them together. That was the incorrect usage there.
  • Blast some imps. Do it.
  • Tea fatigue is what I'm calling it.
  • We’re going to show you 200 through 101 and talk about them.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video WoyWR9aLmd4 The Broken Meeple Top List sentiment: positive
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • hidden traitor forced to act
Cons
none
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • it's not even a game it's just like a story
  • why is it there this is the game about inventions and this is basically telling me to make cutesy patterns with tiles
  • the bane of my freaking life this horrible game
  • I just want to feel like right I can do this I can do this
  • just design one good game one good game one good mode
  • why can't I tell you
  • they just made them a lot worse
  • it's a red flag to the game is going to suck
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video vqVopDUaDVI The Cardboard Herald Interview at 31:20 sentiment: positive
The Cardboard Herald - Shadows over Camelot video thumbnail
Click to watch at 31:20 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Strong thematic fit with Arthurian legend
  • Solid cooperative experience with tension from traitor
Cons
  • Trust dynamics can be divisive at times
Thematic elements
  • cooperative questing with a hidden traitor
  • Camelot/Arthurian legends
  • mythic, heroic adventure
Comparison games
  • Track 12
  • Five Tribes
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • dice-driven quests — Actions resolved through dice and quest cards
  • semi-cooperative with traitor mechanic — Players work together but one may be secretly undermining the group
  • Traitor Game — Players work together but one may be secretly undermining the group
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • gaming is social relations
  • solo variants are house rules
  • my games are my games
  • it's not a competition with myself
  • i'm designing the games i want to play myself
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video xbibw-ZdCko Board Game Spotlight Review at 9:49 sentiment: positive
Board Game Spotlight - Shadows over Camelot video thumbnail
Click to watch at 9:49 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Still fun despite age
  • Plays up to seven players
  • Cool traitor mechanic
  • Pioneering mechanic for its time
Cons
  • Newer games have built upon the concept
  • Better versions exist now
Thematic elements
  • Cooperative fantasy with traitor mechanic
  • King Arthur's Camelot
  • Narrative-driven with hidden roles
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • cooperative gameplay — Work together against darkness
  • Team vs traitor — Hidden role reveals later in game
  • traitor mechanic — One player may be a traitor trying to sabotage
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Agricola is one of those games that you just got to have in your collection if you like euro style games
  • Porta is one of my favorite underrated games
  • Broom service I absolutely love food service one of the coolest mechanics in board games 100 percent recommend this game it is a hoot
  • Barron Park is my favorite polyomino Tetris in a board game game
  • Orleans is a top 5 game for me period just one of my favorite games to play ever
  • Power grid this was the game that got me into board gaming y'all
  • Seven wonders this is a modern-day classic
  • Betrayal at house on the hill every game is different
  • King of Tokyo one of those games that you have to have in your collection
  • If you like board games one or percent recommend this game
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Transcript Navigation
Showing 1–50 of 60
Game Deep Dive