Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 10 Irritating Designer Decisions

Transcript 2:12:55

n

that's better there you go mild mild little mic issue there I muted it before I put the music on forgetting that the music turns the mic off see how prepared we are for this show you can tell it's you can tell how it's uh been ages since I've done a live stream it's was about time I did more of these and get back into practice so yeah yeah he was so eager to come on the show you know he made it sound like I had to twist his arm to come on but he's the one who turned up an hour early to say I'm ready and it's um wait a minute we don't start till 7 and given my history of getting things wrong when it comes to time zones I thought I know on GMT BST have I just done that again so he made he made me panic a little bit right up to the point where my laptop decided it didn't want to switch on for a bit so it's like yeah everything was just kind of leading up to this one as almost as if the designers didn't want us to do this list but it's totally fine so yeah everybody thanks for turning up this is another top 10 live one that's been voted on by the patreons so thanks everybody who does support the patreon they basically I give a a tier of patreons the chance to vote on a list every now and again I pump them with a few ideas they can support their own but I check out the votes and see which ones gets the most and then that tends to be kind of like the order I do them in but I kind of leap frogged it a minute um on the last one because I skipped straight to sandbox games because I kind of thought well that's an easier list to do right now and I wanted to do this one live and obviously I couldn't exactly say to Mar oh yeah can we do this list

now like literally the tomorrow you know that will kind of work so that should be fine but n you know I've got Mark monk with me ninja geek games you would have seen him once on the show I can't remember which which was the list you did with me before six player games was it that does bring a bill yeah because people wanted like high player guys I mean which is kind of a weird list to do because when it's like all right I've got six players what I want to do split them up I mean what's wrong with that no no never do that but couldn't exact couldn't exactly make the list but now we were du to get more on and I say I see marigan it cons but also and this is more a twisty arm type thing come to UK games Expo I've got to sell I've got to half teach um a full game of of hegemony which I have no problems playing hegemony but it wasn't my first plan to do it the games Expo to sit in a hall and play 4H hour hemony but I think it's just my mission now that I have to play hemony at every every single convention no matter where it is although I think I might draw the line at essent I don't see myself playing it there that that' be a bit much I don't want to be in the Premier in playing hegemony that's not going to work but hegemony should be good so yeah marking is it your mates just mates of yours are just turning up for this yeah it's part of my game group yeah that that they God so yeah as long as if they got half an idea then fine we should be okay but that's not for this list so we've got top 10 irritating designer quirks decisions board game design bits we don't like I mean you can kind of phrase it however you like uh this is not to single out designers or anything

like that I'm not even going to mention any designers by name frankly it's and we'll use games as examples only you know to illustrate this even though I think pretty much everything on my list features in multiple games so this is not like a one one game fits this type but it's more that you know we play a lot of board games there'll be stuff we like and don't like in terms of the games and that but even in a good game there can still be these elements which are like oh we still putting this in games is this still a thing you know or I wish this was I wish this was taken out of this game CU it would be like near perfect otherwise and you know little things like that come up every now and again and it's just to find 10 that kind of irk me the most out of them although there wasn't tons I think I probably had like about 15 20 that I had to co down to 10 but not too bad but then it depends on how broad or narrow you go so your smile leads me to believe that it was much easier or much harder for you no I I not much irks me I'm I'm I so I found it quite difficult and then as I started I was going actually that really annoys me oh this really annoys me as well and I got worse and worse as it goes on so I say we're both from the West country so we should be able to be easily annoyed that's that shouldn't be a problem and Sor hexi be um hexi be has yeah board game nitpicks is probably another another way to put it um so that'll work on there so you be gotten a chance so we have got the hexi Beast we got Chloe Kristoff Malik right and hopefully we'll get some more I mean I can see there's a few people viewing but it always tends to build up as the uh

evening goes on so um just think is anything else you want to say about the list um no I I did start off with some components and like box designs and things but then I took those off and just did yeah we're yeah we're going to stop those like we we I only found out about the last minute but yeah I've I've stayed out of doing uh components and Aesthetics because I think that's more a publisher thing yeah um when you have a publisher do it they're the ones who say right it's going to look like this and we'll put this theme around it so those aspects I'm kind of staying away from because I don't think the designer gets a huge amount of say on it or if he does it's like I say it's a shared problem I don't think the designer is responsible for me saying that like start player marker is stupid or something like that I think that's more publish thing so it shouldn't be too bad but all right let's get on right I think we have to just get on with it get on with it yes get on with

it go for it Mark you start okay uh for me it's games that are highly competitive but or have no asymmetric factions or play that that uh so two that come to mind one was a game I played recently um called cerium which is spelled Qi perum have I now got to try and find that because that's gonna be a hard one to see Qi I know kui kui cerium yeah it was a nice little um worker placement game um well this thing where is it this is it yeah I've not heard this game no it was a nice little two-player game um but there was just no function asymmetry and I just thought that was very strange especially for jeweling card game and it just it was didn't matter how you played you were just doing the same thing over I quite liked it but I just thought asymmetric play would have made it a bit better um and I was just quite surprised and there was another one I I reviewed a long time ago which was called Tech landia and the game was pretty bad anyway but you were moving about this this um oh God that cover's that cover's horrible yeah I know um and it was oh select your character at the start and so you look through these character cards and they're all identical so it didn't really matter who you played as um and I just thought that was a really silly thing to do it really frustrated

me because I thought there's no point you know all the same it just it just ends up being luck well is it well I don't know I mean isn't it the case that if they're not any different than I mean how's that any difference to say chess yeah you know as in chess apart from who goes first yeah true No I um I just because it was I I just thought that asymmetric play would have made the game a lot better there were things they could have done to start the game differently so you end up with different objectives or goals or or starting abilities or something I thought would have made the games a lot better so I guess rather than saying highly competitive it's more of a case of um everyone's the same yeah exactly yeah everyone's the same doing the same thing hm there we go everyone's the same which would explain why you're so desperate to get a geminy learn because obviously there's yeah I mean I do like comp really competitive games I over much prefer them over cult games I had a choice I feel like I'm gonna find out about all sorts of weird games though doing this list because you get a lot of these Indie Games in or these Kickstarter ones that I've now grown out of just avoiding like anything I mean you know I get the emails for Kickstarter projects from so and so Indie designer and that and I mean 99 .9% of the time I'm going to say no or just ignore it cuz I just cannot I wouldn't be able to review them all even if I wanted to and I'm not expecting like the next the next Ticket to Ride to suddenly arise of it so but I've seen like some of the stuff you've done and not these two particular games I must admit these two have surprised me but

it's just I look at them and I go that was a Kickstarter wasn't it it had to be so but I'm curious or not if if one of these wasn't a Kickstarter then how I would have missed it I don't know okay no all right well T of mind I don't think I have a specific game example for this this one's like kind of a small irk but you get to the end of the game you've played it you've done you've been competitive you've got your you you've got your victory points and then somebody else counts up theirs and it's the same number as yours so you go back to you think like yeah you know what I want to know what the tiebreaker is and you go to the back of the book and there isn't one that gets annoying it's like I'm all up for sharing victory in something like a semi Co-op thing you know Cosmic Encounter or like you know stuff like that or Team game that's okay but you know and if I have to share the victory at the end of the day fine but this is hopefully after say about three or four different tie Breakers in which Cas we can call it an actual draw but yeah you know it's not difficult to make a tiebreaker and when you get to the end back of the book it just says if you have the same number of points you know Shar a victory or be you know enjoy your shared Victory it's like no yeah you just P you just made me do my two hour you know game of G victory points and now you tell me I've got to share it it's like no you anything most money wins most buildings made most highest up a church track I don't know is if it's a Stephan Fel game I guess

but it's it can't be that hard to come up with a tiebreaker have you ever played um blood ball team manager card game I did once I couldn't understand what I was doing the rule book's horrendous after that at the end of the game I I really like that we play that regularly in fact we have a yearly tournament and a little trophy we hand out to my game group um but they the win condition is is the one that has the most um most points at the end of the game but there are tie Breakers it's about four or five and after the fifth one it says if you are still drawing after this tie break there's obviously cheating going on nobody wins the game not necessarily I thought that's quite good yeah but it's not necessarily no cheating come on that's not right it's part of the blood bow theme not not not suggesting we've cheated that's part of the theme of the game is you're bribing there's been bribing going on you bribed the the uh by the Premier League or whatever at least that one puts a humor theme on it that's not so bad um hex's got some problems if he's getting tie Breakers in Solo games but I tied with the I tied with the AI and it's like nah the AI cheated so fine uh hello Thomas hello oh God I have VY VY I'm I swear I'm going to pronounce that wrong you want to try Mark VY yeah that's VY to me I don't know if the um accent or something on the Y like changes the pronunciation also but sorry about that but good to see you here um yeah so just come on seriously it's a small thing it's minor but for cry out loud it's not it takes you two seconds to come up with a

tiebreaker so please for the love of God do it carry on okay so for number nine for me it's any story driven game with a lot of narrative where you have to make decisions where you actually just sat on Rails and it doesn't matter what decision you make I I am so glad you ended that with that sentence because you could if you'd have full stopped after narrative within I'll be like excuse me no no no where you sat on Rails and there's the outcome's pointless so the two big games that came to me was one was Dune house Secrets oh God yes yeah I you know I was really excited to play that I thought this is going to be great I love Dune uh story driven game it's gonna be brilliant I just sat there and I just thought it's not even a game it's just like a story um and solo play for me with Destinies I I really didn't get on with I found that quite quite similar just sat on Rails almost Destiny certainly does have that problem um and do Now secrets got I mean this one is so blotted out of my memory cuz I remember just playing it and it just felt like a whole game of nothing yeah nothing a short story wasn't it that I can't even remember what the story was about it was that bland I wouldn't even necessarily call it a story as I say a story would at least try to keep me engaged but this this one didn't even make any solitary effort no it was uh yeah and Des and Destiny calls it something like

a game it says it's some type of game on the back and I was like it's not a game do Secret is not a game I'm not even sure i' called Destiny is a game I mean I was one of the few I remember like some people were just going absolute mad for um uh for Destinies at the time going oh yeah this is really cool I like no it isn't it's like you play it in a competitive game and it's just luck of which direction you went and if you play it solo the story is very Bland you know I don't think there's that many branching paths in the narrative um I got to admit I have seen this occasionally in some good games as well I mean I love the tainted Grail series and I play those i' played the death of those but I did not you do notice occasionally not often but occasionally you get a point where it says choose one of four different options it will give you a different paragraph but then it leads you to the same paragraph like afterwards and it's like well okay I get that's good from a flavor perspective but if it doesn't actually influence the story whichever one I pick then why is it a factor yeah know it's it's worse actually I think I've seen in some games where combat is almost tight to it so the combat might give you like a couple of outcomes depending on well you did but it doesn't actually matter if you did it really well or just did it a bit well just just gives you a big clap or a small clap yeah it's just like different narrative it's like I'm sorry if you're not going to give me extra XP or do give me some cool bie of loot or something then I'm not going to incentivized to do really well and put myself out and like use up all my resources if all I've got

to do is just the bare minimum but now that that does work well I thought you were literally just going to talk about like narrative games being point or something it's like games but I said they got have a point you yeah true um this one again I think we're going pretty minor on this one but I I attribute this to Lazy board game design because I think that far too many games just throw this in for the sake of it and they don't actually bother to see whether it you know you know really is necessary or there's a point to it and for me one of the laziest things you can do is add an event deck yeah cuz some some games have done it in expansion some games have done it in like their actual thing but event decks are boring they're not fun they they're just literally there to go oh wait we just need to throw in some random effects so like fine put in an event deck you know some element of Randomness that can either benefit one player or completely screw another you know they could be completely random it makes no difference and so you know why put it in the game is there like not a better way to do it I did have one example I was going to put but I've literally just thought of a better example which is age of Rome um which is good because it means I can use the other game for a different example later on but age of RAM is a half decent game um you know I got it from ESS last time it looks the absolute beans and it it's it's an interesting Little Euro game but the problem is it's one of its

biggest problems is it has an event deck uh yeah this bit up here which does it dictates how this thing moves and also gives some random effect but the effect is random as to whether it triggers but also random as to whether it's good or bad and this is only a game that I think has about four rounds in it or something like it doesn't have that many rounds so I forget how many rounds but like an X number of rounds it's short so you haven't got time to make up for a lot of these really bad things that can happen to you and also because this is a game where the thing Twirls around in the Kingdom that you are in charge of for around it's dictated by which way it turns we played a free player game of this when I was showing it off and like one of those districts does not get built up and we just had the event deck constantly go left right left right left right so this poor one person kept getting the the crappy District while two of us kept getting each other's like decent built ones on it and and so much so that even I think the designers and that themselves sort of they either put in I don't know if they put in a variant or they said like oh you could you know if you want just ignore the uh event effect and just go with the arrow and it's like well you put the event deck in the game so how can you tell me it's a not worth it all event decks you just all event decks not not crappy event decks just standard what to be honest do you know of a good event deck um yeah things like I like things like

um Arkham Horror and things like that that have event Decks that have ongoing things that you have to do like side missions almost they're pretty good the only thing I would D the only thing I would say about that is that is more they are events yes but they're narrative events I mean it's a whole narrative story that you're telling so those cards are adding to the story as you play it's almost a bit like I suppose go back to Ted gril opening not that book of Journal book and reading the paragraph when you go to a particular location it's on that similar line event decks here aren't telling the story it's literally just saying pestilence l two cubes from something you know it's it's not actually those stories being told and it happens a lot in expansions as well like you know this expansion adds this element and this element and a deck of random events because we couldn't be bothered to come up with something else it's you know occasionally they're tolerable and it's not like oh I hate the gay because it's got event decks but it always usually ends up being the weak element you know or the bit that I'm like this is cool this is cool this is we whatever you know Chuck it away and wish I didn't have to use it and if it's a variant fantastic I don't have to use it but uh you know some games it's always like the worst module of the lot do you remember a game called damn it ah what was it called Kingsburg do you remember that one yeah I remember I've not played that one I know it neon ago yeah the expansion came up with like a few modules or something and one of them was literally just an event deck yeah was like it almost just seemed like

right we've got this cool module we got this cool module uh I don't come up with something else I'm f event deck it's like stuck on the side yeah I mean I love my arc NOA game I do not want them to have an expansion where every round or every coffee break I turn up a new event card or something he's like I don't want yeah you gota you got to think about it and I mean hexi mentions that it's yeah I hate them less than Euros yeah makes sense I mean in The Narrative game like you described it actually does work although they're more like story cards as opposed to an event deck but yeah you put it in the straight up just Bland like typical Euro game it's like why I don't know but I say I think that's the last of the two really minor ones now I think they do get a bit more serious as we go on to number

eight hey Kabuki thanks for joining us it sounds like you're already going for the kill so um my my number eight is is similar to yours with event decks but mine I've titled mine stupid event decks so the card that that one card just ruins the game um so things like Mansions of Madness where you have I can't which scenarios you play the game one card depending on when you draw it that player can't speak for the rest of the game Co yeah and so my my friend said he he owns the game but he's just taking it out he just says I just don't like it it's a co-op game and it's just a stupid a stupid event I think that crazy stupid broken car sounds like a good one on there I totally you're not the only person to have seen that man the madness one though I've seen that and yeah I would gladly just rip up the card and never never look at that one again um but trying to think of other ones uh I mean you mentioned actually another another list in the list I've got the similar thing where a card pops up but I'll explain that one later ah fair enough um one that I'll mention mention actually briefly sort of give you hand with that one actually is um Arkham Horror no not Arkham Horror eldrich horror so elich horror has one card in it that is shuffled out of every single game whether it's my copy or not I don't care we're not putting it in the culu

the culu mission you know the mission cards for each um old one um kaulu um I think it's it's either one of his mission cards or it's uh no no no it's sorry it's a Mythos card it's one of the hard Mythos cards Frozen because they came out of like three different difficulty LS one of the hard Mission cards I think it either automatically does it or if you are in a certain situation it triggers off but it removes what the last progress stage thing that you did for the boss and you have to do it all again so pretty much yeah that puts you back a huge step yeah it puts you it basically undoes the like the last hour and a bit of the game and it's long game as well yeah it's stupid bits like that but although funny enough you mentioned like crazy stupid broken cards in the sense of you know okay fine you know crazy stupid mine's actually not too dissimilar because mine is stupid thing mechanic so it's it's it's stupid things from a perspective but when I say stupid things it's not necessarily I mean to be fair actually your Mansions of Madness card could fit into this category you know a dumb like don't talk but for me it's when designers just put these stupid little things in games where you are essentially acting stupid because the game tells you to you know if I play a a funny game like detective club or deception or like some other humorous game that generates a bit of

laughter the game we're doing that around the table the game is helping us do that we're not picking up a card that says you don't talk haha you know like or something like that and it gets gets on my wh when I see it I mean in games where the whole premise is being stupid it's just like I'm not interested in playing that game anyway but the worst Contender I came up with recently I mean I hate this game for more than one reason trust me about it but I don't care if everybody else loves it I can't stand feed the Kraken and the feed the Kraken on one of its spaces uh there there's this knife um space up here right you don't always land on it but it could um is it showing up yeah there you go so so there's this knife space here above the island you won't always hit it but all these other things is like oh I get to look at somebody's card or I get to you they got one for flogging which is kind of say but yeah you basically get to do something to try and figure out an identity if you go over the knife space you basically are intentially cutting out someone's tongue and that person can't speak the rest of the game I mean why stop there with st stupid mechanics I mean you know the game's not to be taken seriously I know but you've got this other stuff about you know a cult going on and Pirates versus Sailors and that and yet you've got something where in a game that's social deduction so a game where you're actively meant to talk to people here's something that stops you

talking yeah and it's just but it's just stupid you know you and you get some in some Euro games uh where I'm try remember what it was a I think it was like called it wasn't called VI magika or sonic magika it was something like that it was like a little engine builder game but it mentions like right okay Carry On like this but if you get a tiebreaker first person to shout gets it Al there was a two player that I think it was like you know that if you tie on something whoever croaks like a frog first gets in it's just for God's sake I haven't played um the magical one I've heard of and I've played it was like a small Euro one I haven't played this it's a two-player abstract game it's actually other than that stupid rule fairly serious I I haven't played it but Zar talked about it and I have I do know which game is on about but yeah when he explained that it's just like this is a two-player abstract game so we're talking chess levels of intellect here but then at random times it expects you to quro like a frog it's like come on and I'm just done with that it's like take your game seriously or if you're going to make these stupid mechanics make the game all that advertise this and then I can avoid your game a lot easier but you know we already have games like that they're called things like happy salmon right which is nothing but stupid thing mechanics but at least I know it's all stupid thing mechanics therefore I can avoid the game like the plague it's just not something I want

but yeah both of us basically on the lines of stupid stupid things crazy stupid things right uh so number seven is similar to the stupid events I mean there's one event card in the game that I take out because of it but it's if you're playing um a game with player elimination and you've got uh unavoidable or just unpredictable deaths things that you just can't do anything about you draw a cards goes you're dead and it just especially when for me it's when I'm playing Nemesis I love Nemesis you know it's a four five hour what again one that I take out the game and it's it's a fire card that just spreads everywhere yeah and so you you you half through the game you doing as much as you can and then the whole ship just blows up because of that one card um but it's not just things like that it's um if you play Forge war is that that giant box Kickstarter no this was this is an old game it was um I forget his name now we did Gloom Haven um um I forg his name um same guy did Gloom Haven did it Forge war it's um you're like making weapons for adventurers and things when you play solo you've got a list of cards that you can you like contracts that you can claim and as you can see them all sometimes you just know yeah you just I it Isaac yeah um you just know that you you can't progress any further and you think right it's just going a amount of

time now before the game's over I can't win because I can't get the resources nothing that's been drawn pointless me continuing um even though you've got a lot of the game left so and there was a game as well I can't remember what it was called but one player could just decide to Nuke the whole game and just end it oh what was that was it I can't remember it was called no it wasn't called forer it was something it was it had like it was about like saving the world wasn't it it was like globe or Global or something like that but I forget what it was end the game just go right I'm not winning I'm just going to end the game and it's basically almost like a table flip yeah yeah stupid ones there I've heard of this Forge war I think I think mates of mine have played it and I've looked at it and gone this looks a little bit big and insane is it's big it's dry but it's I I like it a lot um it's really good solo but sometimes you just get a load of cards and you just look down the line going well I'm gonna be done in three turns and you know you're halfway through the game and it's nothing that you could have done differently it's just that draw of the Card unfortunately with that one but yeah I think I just I mean I'm not massive on Gloom a so I might have avoid at that point try to think of other examples that you might have done I mean sou Nemesis is a good one yeah cuz I've had we a friend of mine wanted to teach another uh person we knew Nemesis and I thought Nemesis is very hit and miss for me either works or it or it crashes and burns so I thought all right fine I'll jump in this one three player game I swear it took like about an hour or to set the thing up and teach the rules

like it always does I think this third guy played for 10 minutes really before he got killed yeah before he got killed by aens that just happened to spawn near and there's nothing you could do and it's just like well hope you enjoyed that lecture because that's pretty much all you've done for the last hour and a half I do like Nemesis I mean I I'll play it every time someone gets it out I'll play but it's either a very short hour game which is which frustrates me or it's a long good game that you've worked out but when that that one bloody fire thing comes out and it spreads you've got no hope and it always depends when that card comes out as well uh another another one's dead of winter the frostbite die yeah yeah I'm I'm doing okay I'm doing okay frostbite dead yeah which is typically one of the things that people do hate about that one and certainly yeah one of my beefs that even at the start of the game you just might you might just constantly every time you go outside just die and you have no chance of doing anything it got work y That's right uh this one again do I have ideas for this one and not enough I don't think there's a specific game that comes to mind uh I suppose I suppose the game I can is evacuation so you know the new the recent game done by oh damn it like why am I brain farting with the designer names is like the oh yeah Vladimir sui yeah and I've got plenty enough stuff

that I like from Vladimir suji evacuation was one I kind of bounced off but this is just not because of this thing but what I do notice is that some games particularly Kickstarter games just can't stop putting variants in their games and you where you get the impression that the person didn't actually know how to design their game they kind of want the players to figure out the best way to play their game so they come up with one rule set and then they say right but here's about six seven variants on how you can change things up and it's like well how about you design one good variant how about how about you just design a good game to begin with and then we don't need these variants yeah cuz cuz you try some of the variants and they're either well I mean they range from boring to Broken to so good why is this not the thing the way we should be playing it yeah I agree um things like um is it Taff taverns of tith and Tall that has like four additional modules but you can't play the second module unless you got the first one in play and you can't play the third one unless you got the first two in play now so I more but if you weren't a fan of the first three then you've I don't think you've got a choice if you wanted to play the fourth you have to include them all yeah I mean include it all it's it's a good game with all the modules and it's gives you options for it yeah I mean yeah because evacuation has only got two I keep thinking it's got more but um I mean to be fair the the variants in in evacuation are problematic anyway because and also bearing in mind that

the game is either well actually technically it has three because it's either points or race mode so you've already got a variant for how you do that you've got the action cards which actually make the game worse you know you've you've either got fixed actions or you've got these action cards that are random when you get them range in power level and can just pretty much break somebody's game if they draw bad um but also it's got another little points variant which for some reason as you score more points if you can get stuff in diagonal lines it's like who cares but it but even then I mean evacuation is a good like you know probably actually fits this better because it was points or race mode and I think the designer wanted it in race mode all the like Euro Gamers came by saying I want it in Victory point mode cuz I love victory points and so you ended up with like two versions of a game of which you kind of try to please everybody but you don't please anybody okay and and as I say this is a milder case of it but yeah I have seen some Kickstarter games and some of the ones where you just see about five six variants at the back of the book and it's just like why you know why yeah it's it also comes down to the one I really hate from gck starter is when a a game comes out saying you can play this competitive Co-op or semi Co-op that is like a red flag to the game is going to suck because you know you haven't spent enough time developing one way of played it you've made it do all three yeah and you know inevitably

it won't work at at least one if not two of those jack of all trades then isn't it yeah but it's trying to please everybody and it doesn't work and you know with variance if I see that the book's got a lot of variance it just makes me think that the original base game is either a little underdeveloped or this designer has listened to too many focus groups or play testers who have all like he's come up with like he's given it to about six different play test groups Each of which has se a few people that come up with a unique idea each and he's decided that each of these ideas is great rather than saying to these people no that's stupid that's stupid or you know what this game's bloated enough as it is I don't need more yeah no I agree I agree about that but yeah just Des sign one good game one good game one good mode then when expansions come out you can throw in something like that because then if we don't think it's going to work we can avoid the expansion but if it's in the game we've now got to have all these little mini and if it's a variant to the rules it's not too bad but where like you mentioned it's modules and you're forced to to use them particularly if or like one says oh I like this I want to use this module ah but if you're using module one you can't use module three and it's for Christ sake just side a way for it to

work right number six is it yep six six so I I said I prefer competitive games but I will play co-op games um but when I play a co-op game I like to be able to talk to the other people that I'm playing with so things that irk me is when you play a game and it says it's Co-op but you can only tell people part of your actions and things and one that comes to mind is Gloom Haven so I like Gloom Haven yes play the game it says you can tell people you're going to attack but you can't tell them with how much of what it's going to do and I'm like but surely that if I was fighting someone I hang a minute I'm just going to pull out a big sword and chop their head off but you can't do that you've just got to you've got to you got to tell them how you feel about your attack I feel this is going to be a good one and that I think that's a bit that frustrates me a lot now that actually works quite well it is one beef with glueberry and I'm try to of other examples that have done that uh there are some there I can't remember what it was it was one I played the other day and it was you couldn't talk to your your teammates and I just thought um it's not Co-op then it's just kind of on your own there have been ones like that uh there was a one a while back I never played it but I know of it it was a culu based Euro game um I think it was called Witcher Salem and you know you're supposed to be closing these portals and you go in but the idea is is that when somebody is nearby that person can't tell you should I go through this door

or not you know just like well what why we're working together to get rid of these portals why can't you tell me that I should go into this one it's like I don't know you just have to try why yeah no agree yeah I just um what does that say hidden info yeah hidden info and Cults frustrates me yeah it's it's it does frustrate me a lot well because at the end of the day even something like pandemic in that don't you always have your cards out rather than having yeah on the table don't you yeah but I mean these are the cards you're on about is this initiative value yeah the that I can't tell you what value my initiative is yeah sense powerful my attack is or because because the the argument you have with it is that okay fine let's say there's two people and they've played their two characters to death or something like that if they've manage to pretty much memorize what these cards are like you know roughly oh yeah he's oh you're thinking of doing that oh that's a really high initiative card or something then you're basically just saying that if someone's got a cheat sheet it's fine of all these initiative values yeah why even have it in the first place it just I but uh I wonder if there's any other examples because I know that is not long ago and I can't remember for the life me what it was and it was only I had to go to Gloom Haven for it because I was trying to think this game it's relatively new that you come there someone in the comments get another example for us because I know there has been more like that where you can't tell something that you really should be able to in a game

all right but yeah I like that one yeah why can't I tell you um all right this one's uh Sky team isn't Sky Team a two-player game I thought Sky team was a two player and that new one that's getting a lot of accolades H I'm not sure but we'll come back to that one uh this one this again pretty broad you know so not a particular game although one game that's getting a lot of love Lately from you know Mega fans of this designer is certainly a poster child for this sort of thing but I'm a big person of theme in games I like themes to work so that's fine if you're going to make a game that doesn't go too much with a theme fine okay fine you're not going to do too much but what gets on my nerves is when I see a mechanic that is so pointless and abstracted like you know that it is in there purely for Euro gamer complexity like there's no other reason for it and biggest beef at the moment that's given me that one is the new inventions actually which I know a lot of people are going goooo Gaga for I've seen you comment on everybody's post about I'm sorry I I hate this thing I mean I like lder he's right behind me four times over okay I like his stuff but his last two games have really been a bit like stretchy stretchy with the thieves but this one is I mean this is an example there are loads of games that do this abstracted mechanic thing you

know where you put in something in a game that has no purpose being there other than the fact that it's another complex mechanic for Euro Gamers this is the one that inventions has which is these tiles you you collect them by various means during the game fine okay I've done some card flipping or whatever and stuff like that and I've got these tiles you're now expected to put them on this grid on your board in various patterns to score more points because victory points I don't know it's why is it there this is the game about inventions and this is basically telling me to make cutesy patterns with tiles why I think I think hexy Beast has got TTY hakon yeah didn't that do the trying to think if that did a similar thing I know when you built the Pyramid you had the different symbols that you had to match up which seemed a little bit like why you know not not a massive deal about that game I played it two or three times but every time I played it I thought it doesn't really matter what I do I get the same amount of victory points which dice I take or anything I just I seemed lost in the game it it could be worse on that front yeah the the evacuation game I mentioned before actually the oh actually yeah there's the I I'll go back to that game there there's one mechanic that well a couple actually evacuation has got two mechanics that are blatantly just there for Euro Gamers one is that you've got these two little satellite things that go around all the planets um and basically how far it progresses is how

much you can ter like go on the planet it's kind of weird but that's not the the most ous thing you won't be able to see it much from I don't think you'll be able to see it easily but there's there's a card here um that's laid out each round and basically when you do these actions they are numbered one to four to represent power level and if with that card there are two bonuses you can get whether you go higher than a certain number or lower than a certain number and depending which one you get you get another bonus why I mean I'm I'm playing my actions to partially like try and terraform this new planet but at the same time I'm thinking right well I've done three I'll do two as long as I don't do anything that's free or more then I can get this weird bonus it's just you know it could have been trimmed out of the game we wouldn't have missed it it would have made it cleaner and it's only in there for Euro fans there just no forward it um what's Lena got here the could the horr is building symbols do you have build symbols that one I've not played that one you've got the M shafts that you do well I suppose yeah you yeah when you're building the buildings around the different symbols that they've got give you points in various ways I mean that's fairly abstracted I was thinking maybe more the church in there the St the St Baron church I forget what it's called but the uh the church Towes that you build and they've just got r benefits When you build each section of

it again because theme I don't know question mark it's I just I don't mind if you're going to if you're going to make a dry Euro fine you know and if it's not going to be the most ftic one again you know fine I don't mind that but just some of these really pointless ones you know it's just like you when you when you first ask that question why is it in this game and they can't think of a good answer that's when you know it was just added and this is an age where I want games to be a bit more streamlined you know they can be heavy games but I would dare say that even gallerist and Coman by me are dams like more streamlined than how they can be taught and how they play compared to something like weather machine and inventions you know the two new ones so you can trim out the fat but you when you see these little abstracted mechanics it's like an aspect of ah yeah those those bits of fat that could have been trimmed you know we've we've cooked this piece of meat it's good ah here's the fatty bit got to deal with it weird an allergy but I had pork shoulder the other day

so so uh simple one here is games no food in games yeah yeah no food and drink at the table um not adjusting for player count um so I I I had the kickstarter for Dark Souls um it was a grind of a game and there's been the community have built some really good um house rules for it which I now use but initially you have you choose one of four characters they've all got the same um type of stats but they go up in different values which means that you couldn't get a you know double-handed sword for your Thief which meant they couldn't get that but if you only had one or two characters in the game the market deck stayed the same so you end you endlessly drawing cards spending your your souls to draw cards that were completely pointless because you you've got Wizard and you keep drawing armor and swords and shields which they can't use and it just really watered down the deck so they had to the community built some house rules in for that which were uh really good all that I mean Dark Souls pretty much everybody who's played it has fixed it better than the original design was yeah yeah yeah that was a frustrating it just um first couple times I played it was just because I played solo with two characters I just ended up just losing all my Souls on these wasted cards excuse the pun it was Soul destroying so yeah ideas don't come to my head off the top of my head but I mean it's a good one yeah even um think

about it I like elich horror um now when you select your players now when you select your players one to eight well you yeah I've played at eight players once actually uh we we got round once I think it took about an hour and a half and we stopped um but if you if you draw monsters or you spawn spawn monsters and and um uh portals it will say for one to two players do it here three to four players spawn this many so I'm going why don't you have two players uh don't have the one because obviously there's gonna be more monsters on the board so have two it's the same amount of monsters same with three and four players is if I'm playing um solo I'll play with four characters because there's an even amount of monsters those four rather than three gets a bit like that Ted gr definitely is harder to play true solo and they tried to scale it a bit for solo but it doesn't scale quite enough to make difficulty not kind of insane um even my I mean even my Sentinal in the Multiverse game you know you play it with three players it's a little bit harder than if you play it with four and five is almost like a cakewalk because you just got so many players going around and they do try to balance it to an extent but it doesn't quite fully work but yeah lack of there's a lot of games like that where I probably should have put this on the list actually it would certainly have belted one of the bottom two off cuz some it's not even so much like oh you know what monsters can Jo I think it's just more the time length yeah you know here's this game it's a Euro game great right so it plays what it takes about

hour and a half with two of us all right sweet okay so take about two and a half with three and then suddenly like five hours with four but it's like well okay fair enough if we have more players it's going to add more time so what have you done to mitigate this nothing oh great so you just expect me to add an extra hour because somebody else decided they want to play then why am I including them in the game yeah but that does although funny enough we had similar ones on eight with the stupid mechanics I've got a similar one for this one as well actually it's not so yours was lack of player scaling mine's a very specific player one it's not just player not scaling it's look this game's fine if you want to play it with two to four players can we s off with the fifth player I'm getting sick of this the infamous fifth player that's added to every game for one purpose only to sell more copies there's no reason because % of the time I did a funny Tik Tok about this so I I did a Tik Tok of three different people so it was me saying it's my game night I get to choose the game and someone else come in and said um it's I I'm I'm this guy I get to choose the snacks and then it said I'm the fifth player I and then it just cuts Mo because no one wants to know about we did that a couple of times so it just the fifth player just gets cut off talking each time because nobody nobody player table's got four chairs for a reason I know I've got I've got six

around this table but I mean I never have more than four of us around anyway but I hate it when I sit at a table at a game night with with five I mean and I have to feel like the jerk because there'll be say like oh if we got space in this game and it's like yeah but it's Earth you know Earth is not exactly a multiplayer game I don't want to play it with five it's like it's not enough space to the table to put a fifth player board it's Johnny's um Johnny's asked that if you had a four player game you know would you buy the fifth player expansion the fifth well I mean I hate the fifth player expansion because that's it's again it's going back to the event deck thing it's the lazy thing to put in an expansion it's like look we just want to get more people talking about a game again right we just need to put new stuff in uh easy thing new player color yeah you can play it with five now okay so how have you balanced it with five players we haven't just play it with more players why I'm not going to I mean yet some games work okay with five you know I played a of sky yesterday and we did play it with 4 in the end but I was willing to have a fifth player because it cuts off a round you know certain things get happen in order to mitigate it but the example I had where clearly it's one of those we shoved it in just simply to the cell War copies is one of my favorite games I do really love tribes of the wind but it can be played two to five players there is no reason to play this a three you know let alone five because it's all based on what your two neighbors have got in terms of their cards facing you

so I care about the two neighbors you could say if I've got a fourth player the person opposite me doesn't influence me but okay he's influencing the other two but then what's the fifth player doing you know I'm just adding and all it does is adds more time to the game it doesn't make any you know it doesn't do anything else extra it's just he has more time and every game now is just fifth player expansion fifth player expansion sixth player expansion you know you can now play Earth with sixth players you can now play uh Cascadia with six players it's like i' never want to got to be more examples at five players h i don't mind playing Scythe at five players I like scythe Cy's a bit better with more players in the S I mean it can go the other way because you can have uh games where you know it they put two and three on the box and clearly it's meant to be a big group game you those ones certainly um what's my got there Skull King and the crew are good at five I don't know about Skull King but crew the crew is fine at five yeah I mean it that one doesn't break at five certainly not compared to some others but I mean um I can't remember if Mystic Vil I've got here does five or maybe within the expansion it allowed you to do five but it's just no Spirit Island you can do those with five and six as a Mike mentions like I'm sorry but no I refuse to play Spirit island with more than four and even then four requires everybody to know what they're doing and then

some what about heat uh is it I can't see that one oh there it is yeah what about heat racing games are a bit different I think racing games like to have a lot of players because a lot of the times they're simultaneous anyway so something like heat or downforce for example has everybody kind of acting for the most part at the same time so that's not usually too big a deal and with a racing game you kind of want a lot of people on I think it's more the Euro games like we mentioned with the last pick you know five players rarely makes a Euro game better because most of the time it just adds more time to the game and if it's already too long with four then why the hell do I want it with five you the excuse of ah we want to be sociable with more players does not work if you're making the game sucky for everybody yeah that we can socialize fine but we can play something that's designed to have five or more players not something that you've just bolted it on to sell another copy it is all just to sell copies because they I mean well we'll get to that I don't know I'll come back to this a little bit later CU otherwise I'm going to overlap with something a bit later but uh yeah I just I just don't I don't get how it works why you would do that so ow before I start babbling let's get on to let's get on to four something

nicer so for me uh number four is this one's a prime example the thing the thing I've not played that yet um I like the game a lot but there is a massive loophole in it that you can the whole idea is that one of you is or more of you is the thing well one of you is the start as the thing and then as you meant to destroy the game a bit like you a dead of winter put cards in the wrong places and things but what I found out is that when you play you can actually win as the thing just by doing nothing just by playing normally everything you everything a human would be doing and you can win the game because nobody suspects you and and you do everything nice and everything correct and you end up getting on the helicopter and you can win the game that way just by doing nothing so it's kind of ruined the game for me now and I don't know if I play it again because that's what you can do which version of the thing is that because there's so many of them uh that's Outpost infection at Outpost 31 oh yeah this big monstrosity what yeah it's like got four or five different thing games yeah I think it's up to eight eight players is it or six I can't remember um but yeah it's it's a very simple game but it's it's really good fun but then suddenly I realized I played it once and I was the thing and I thought if I do nothing I just did nothing and played normally and put all the good cards in and we got through because you meant to go through stages by fighting the monsters and we all no one could figure out who it was because no one corrupted the game but then how does the thing win in that instance I

get on the helicopter you'll get voted on so one of oh I right so so they they don't stand out but if they get on the helicopter at the end they win because they're on the helicopter right yeah because they to go to to the mainland yeah so it was um yeah so why would you do anything yeah I know but it was not till I realized I was like oh my God this is I'm just gonna play normal um and yeah so now it's kind of ruined the game for me which is a shame because I really liked it plus how did that not come up in play testing I don't know yeah I mean there are in towards the end of the game other people can get infected but you still play normal uh they they might not get on but you can still win and only if if one thing gets on the helicopter all of the things win so yeah you just yeah you just do just keep stum yeah there's no incentive no that's what I mean is I just can't play it anymore I've got the other one by um is it pen dragon games that's a that's a lot better version that one because there are instances where you have to do that so although if that's forcing you to do it I don't I don't know if that works much better but but oh that is crazy I thought winter was bad but the whole right I can't win this game therefore I'm just going to you know I'm just going to I can't I can't hoard enough cans of beans to win therefore nobody wins I mean you mentioned it earlier with the one where you can just nuke stuff yeah but but I mean yeah is fuy of Dracula is I've not played furi of Dracula can you just I don't recall fuy of Dracula

having that problem I mean cuz one side has to kill Dracula but Dracula still has to do stuff you know he's got to do various objectives to win be less aggressive if be more aggressive yeah I guess yeah I mean I don't know how aggressive I've been with Dracula I guess I maybe I have been too aggressive with him because I'm almost like right I can't stay hidden all the time at some point I need to go Om Nom Nom but maybe like maybe doing it at the wrong time but I get well that I say it's amazing what doesn't come up in testin as hexb says I'm sorry there is no way that that thing did not come up in play testing yeah it was just so frustrating and I just I just suddenly just clicked and I went oh my God if I do nothing I'm just going to be as as a human and yeah and it went all the way through but you could read the rules and tell that that's a thing I didn't even you don't even need an explanation because other games have like hidden trailers in there but they've got to do something by the end yeah you Shadows Shadows over Camelot has a hidden traitor in it but you can't sit as the traitor and do absolutely nothing bad because then the good guys will just win so that that and I think that's what kills it with the thing is that because you make it that the endgame condition is an easy thing for the bad guys to win with like or like the bad guys can win if the game just PLS on as normal then that's what kills it because all these other games with hidden traitors will let the good guys

win if the bad guy doesn't do anything um no yeah doesn't do that you new Angeles over there there um sort of far left to the uh the Netrunner Universe like uh negotiation game I really like you've got a federalist player in there so you know six corporations they all have their own agenda to win but one of them wants the city to tank whereas the others are trying to at least keep it stable if the Federalist does nothing then the Federalist will not win period because the city I mean unless the players do so badly that the city tanks but I doubt that I doubt the city would tank unless the Federalist has tried to do something and so it does at least Force the bad player to do so but good BL me how on Earth does that work yeah yeah it was frustrating it's quite sad to find out as well all of that uh ex has got another one um was it well like in God of War there is nothing pushing you forward so you can just take as long as you need to do everything yeah I mean that that's another fade it's not so much do nothing but it's just like well there's no rush I'll just explore why not although it can go to The Other Extreme of that if you've played Lord of the Rings Journeys Earth if you don't play it on Adventure Mode then the timer is so tight that it's like oh I could explore all this stuff but no time got to get going in fact unsettled that I've been trying to play at the moment the exact same feed it's like you've got all these cool little feeds that you could explore but if you try to you'll lose because you'll just run out of time always gets it oh man that that's going to haunt me for a while that is

that thing one I can't believe that got passed so I'm going to I know some people who occasionally play that actually I've got to bring that up next time I see them on the table and just ask you know as anybody actually tried this yeah all right um am my one yes I mean this could be Campaign games certainly Campaign games I've played recently have this problem but then Euro games can have this problem particularly with regards to their solo mode um but one yeah one thing that I just don't get that designers are doing at the moment I don't know what uh sparked it is there's this Obsession now that when they create solo modes you can have levels of difficulty or like easy medium hard that kind of thing but for some reason designers have got it in their head that oh wait a minute hang on which when are we on we're on um I'm going to have to switch these two round CU I've got them in the wrong order but never mind that's an easy correction but yeah I'm kind of just sick and tired of insane difficulty levels with with with games particularly Campaign games have this problem I mean te gril is a bit too hard you have to r a little bit ISS Vanguard had a similar problem you know like way too punishing you know unsettled is a very punishing game if you try to do anything that constitutes fun you know it will punish you for doing it but even solo modes uh the one that got a lot of contention lately was the White Castle um I played that recently and got my ass handed to me yes SN enough game I think we played it did I'm not sure if the two of us

played it but we played it we play it side by side didn't we yeah cuz I was LE I was unpacking and I taught from the rule book um and yeah you I think were more angry about the size of the Box yeah because it was yeah because devier games can't give you a box big enough to pack their games but he was he was spitting teeth it was for that but it's the tety but White Castle solo mode as you know is ridiculously hard it is really hard and it doesn't feel like it's and it doesn't feel like it's fair you know it gets away with doing all those oh yeah you've got to go for all these hoops to do a b and c well I can just skip ahead to F you know not a problem and but you can have easy medium part but for some reason even that translates to a designer as hell six layer hell eighth layer of Hell or something it they're all just hell difficulties and why do they feel that they need to basically make something super hard you can have an easy solo mode and then just have it be made harder but the amount of times I pick up a book and see like right there's several difficulty modes you go on and it's either you go on the easiest mode and it kicks your ass or you have to go on the medium difficulty at of five because the bottom two are just no point like you would just Cakewalk everything there I know it's not easy to balance this kind of thing but there's got to be a better way of doing it well I one of the games I'm looking at um UK games Expo is horror on the Orient Express and

I read an article about it and they the designers have said it is hard you will lose most of the time but I don't want to I want to win sometimes you know when the challenge feels fair in a sense I mean Spirit Island's got six levels of difficulty with all their adversaries and that's assuming you even play with an adversary you could just play with uh you know with like a normal scenario and that will have its own difficulty rating I know that if I'm playing Spirit Island true solo I pretty much avoid anything that is over difficulty 4 because I just struggle to beat the game at anything more than difficulty 4 especially when playing it true solo I'll play higher difficulties when I'm playing with other people cuz jances are they'll be better at the game than I am but it's it's easier when you have more Spirits usually but at least that's got so many different levels of difficulty I can tailor it to what I want but something like White Castle is stupidly hard endol yeah when it gives you the because I played on easy and then I thought who the hell would turn the other difficulty levels and and how would you I'm not even going to try it because it' just be embarrassing but I don't mind if you have like a cakewalk difficulty in the sense but I say easy should be Cakewalk medium should be normal and then you can make it tough and put some little variants in it uh I played the Great Western Trail New Zealand's solo mode recently and that's got a pretty decent solo mode in it it's not difficult to Pilot and it produces enough of a challenge if you play it I think on the standard mode you can play it on a slightly easier mode but ideally you

want to play it on standard but there's multiple ways that you can make it harder from that point and I've got and I've got to a point where it's reached to that stage of oh actually this is an enjoyable heart you know because you have like a deck of cards for the AI and easy you've got two ways to tweak the difficulty you've got a starting point for these discs where um where they start off and accumulate so that's the better way to make it harder the other way is that it trims certain cards out the deck but the problem is when you go onto the higher difficulties what once you've trimmed out all the cards on the hardest difficulty all it leaves you with is a bunch of bland uninteresting cards that just say the AI gets to cheat basically yeah because because you can specialize in this and so can the AI and it will say like right here's a card and if they're specialized in Sailors they'll do this if not they'll do this you know they're interesting cards those get trimmed out in the higher difficulties and at that point you basically say right it doesn't matter what the AI specializes in they're just going to Hoover up the board try and beat it and I've played it on it's too hard I don't know let me win some games yeah and the argument always comes back to say like you know well you know don't you want a challenge you know you can't win all the time it's like no but I like to feel like I'm in with a Fighting Chance yeah yeah I'd like to you know win by a couple of victory points type thing or lose by a couple but when you're getting hammered every single time that's ni well even if I get hammered I don't mind if I get hammered I mean up to a point if I feel like well

there was no way I could to physically beat that and you find out only at the end you got hammered that's a bit annoying but yeah I just want like during the game let me feel like right I can do this I can do this I irk that bit right this is not going well but I still feel I can Spirit Island's great for this and so Sentinels you know you play Sentinels the Multiverse halfway through the game you could be like all right how the hell are we supposed to win this but then you put but then as you get more powerful you start building it back you get your defenses up and sudden it's like no we can actually hold out here you may still lose but once you've got that Fighting Chance you're still interested in playing G as soon as you realize there is no physical way we can win this scenario Al pandemic Legacy for example you know you could have a setup where literally there is no way you could win you know the cards will just hose you the objective you want's at the bottom of the deck you know and you're just not going to do it and that that doesn't feel fun once that realization like you know Dawns on you what's he going there similar thing to this I think the difficulty levels for Marvel Champions are getting dared yeah there's power creep you know that in ccgs term yeah because people play it so regularly they they know the game at the back of their hand than the cards in the deck so they win more regularly so they make them harder as the game goes on so new players get stumped yeah that I mean ccgs did it with power creep making cards stupidly powerful as the new sets come out the lcgs and Marvel Champions is an example but I think all of them did this to an extent Lord of the Rings and Arkham when you play the later expansions you can just tell that the

difficulty curve is going up and it's like look good for them I still play it casually I don't want you know Ronin the accuser to absolutely bludging my head with a sledgehammer every time I look at him you know and it is getting annoying but there's so there easy fixes you know if you just had the difficulties about the same throughout the whole thing you know you might make a boss character at the end of The Campaign harder fine they can play those ones but because something like Marvel Champions has those modular sets that you throw in you know they did it in one the recent one Age of Apocalypse up there there they released like a new standard modular set cuz normally the the basic standards quite basic so they just thrown in a harder version well why can't you do that why can't you just throw in harder versions of those ones that they can use in those decks we don't have to use them but now we have to play a campaign of something like Age of Apocalypse and I don't know how difficult the heroes are in that one yet but for example the what was it uh oh God yeah the Guardians of the Galaxy one it's like you get to a point in that where the B the fights you've got are just so stupidly hard it isn't fun anymore you know and I just want a chance just give me a chance what's so wrong with

that go for it um this one the game did Rectify with an expansion but this game's out of print now I I used play it a lot um and it's a long game uh it's run Wars from FY games cool that's going back a bit yeah and I I love the game it was brilliant but the thing is is what happened is you'd plan your turns your strategy you'd play really well for you know four five hours and then there'd be someone just goes right I've won and that would because you there's no scoring system or anything in there all the runes that they have to collect are hidden so it's all hidden information so somebody you don't know who's winning at any one time um and it's a great game but it's like my other one that's it game over um the expansion then put in um so what's spec so what's it specifically then is it like abrupt endings yeah abrupt endings yeah things that you and you you don't know when they yeah you don't know when they're coming up so um I think Fallout was the same the original before the expansion I haven't played it but I've seen um I've seen a lot of comments on Fallout doing the same thing and yeah cuz that one's that one's mostly like quite random and how it works but yeah it does eventually just get to a point where it's like game over win see I I Love A Game of Thrones and that has a sudden ending but you can see the victory point you can see the how many castles people have got so you know who's winning at any one time and the likelihood of so you know who to attack and who not to and um but with run Wars it just that was the only Downer for the game the expansion I said

has stopped that because they they let you play extra turns after someone has reached the goal um but then does that but I mean how many extra turns I mean does that I think you play the end of the year so it's another yeah another four actions which could have someone else win um but yeah before it was just suddenly someone just says right I win and then it was just a bit of a a letd down really yeah I'm just think heast put the original version of Fallout would run out before you have time to finish Atomic B I thought it was also someone would just suddenly just win you planned ahead and then someone just go I've won it could have that one I'm trying to think of the other examples where it's hidden to that extent I mean like some games finish abruptly when you kind of know they're getting to that point but it can still feel a little bit anti-climatic but certainly a hidden part it's that's okay in a short game I think you know Celestia has that yes Celestia is short hour game yeah not not in a long game Celestia is short you play it for 45 minutes somebody reveals I've got 50 or more points that's the end you win great but it it was quick you know it's it's a race from the get- go but to have yeah to play two three hour Euro and then somebody the just do that I'm not sure I can think of any specific other like game one but uh you it doesn't bother Kabuki kid so yeah but I'm curious as to whether a lot of people have problems with this because I've heard it mentioned more often that

some people do have problems with you know anti-climatic endings and for a year game it would be it's it's usually better when it is is like oh we're progressing up to a point you know all the rounds are starting to tick over you know now it's getting to the end as opposed to right we're carrying on carrying on almost like you're playing Bingo and you know you're there crossing off numbers until eventually somebody does just come out of nowhere and say I've won it's like no yeah yeah exactly but yeah I'm curious on now want to be curious to know if there's any more examples of games wise okay so three I had to swap my three and four around but to be honest they were pretty similar anyway and I suppose it does space it out because I mentioned on my um fifth player one that I was going to in danger of overlapping with this particular pick you know and I've said like you know I'm sick and tired of five players being added to a game just for the sake of having five players that also works on the Other Extreme where you're put in a Solo mode for the sake of having a solo mode in it I like you know I like solo modes I I play a lot of games solo I'm kind of forced to do it but you just with the way my living situation but it is getting a little bit annoying that when you look at a game and it says one to four players and especially depending on what the game is you have to just wonder to yourself okay how much F went into that solo mode is this literally just there again to please a crowd who won't shut up when a game doesn't have solo modes in it it's yeah it's always the most commented

thing on the Kickstart a project you know where's the solo mode this ain't worth it it's like well I place other solo games or get some more friends I don't know but you find a way around it it it it's a painful one and the most recent review I did where I commented on this one now technically there is a solo mode that does work with this but not the one that's in the book which was the moon Breakers one moonbreakers has this like digital one called luminar I've not tried it that's apparently the best way to play solo but okay but you have to get it on you have to download it on Steam it's free or whatever and work through this app I will try it I do want to try it it sounds pretty cool that but the solo mode in the book is literally just right here's put a few cards out face up this is what you can play with during the turn try and complete some projects now that doesn't sound too bad but but the thing is is that the game is a negotiation game where most of this game is about talking with the other players trying to get people on your side and all that who asked for a solo mode in a negotiation game it kind of just sort of defeats the point really doesn't it yeah and and most of the time a lot of these solo modes are that not quite as blatant as this example I mean this example had to be said just for how stupid it is that a solo mode was put in this you the digital one is supposedly a better thing you know the idea that you play with these events that turn up and a little

bit of a story in there and it's like okay cool you know but I'll give it a shot and I'll let you know but yeah just even just like some games where it's beat your own score and it's just like right you can play this game with two to four players but if you want to play it solo then fine just uh flip this tiny deck of cards over one at a time it will take something out of the display see what score you can beat and it is just tacked on there's no thought that went into it it was just pleasing the solo mode and most of the time they're in the game but nobody's suddenly crying out oh yeah this was a fantastic solo mode I'm so glad I played this solo it's like no I've got amount of games I can play solo that you know I either true Solo or can be played with groups that are better with solo but I don't need every single rotten game to have a solo mode in it so cut it out especially when it then combines with the obscene difficulty levels and stuff like that you know so we didn't really take time to develop the solo mode we just put it in to please you can you win it no but who cares do you play a lot of games solo I do yeah I do yeah I do play a lot of games solo um I I've got Moon rakers and I I admit that I it was what it was beat your own score as well wasn't it after a certain amount of rounds or something yeah I just after playing it five players which I thought was great playing it solo was a disappoint bit of a disappointment I think even just played it at any of the player accounts three to five I mean five takes a while I prefer four but three is still good

but yeah the two players why you negotia with one other player and then just the idea that the solo the negotiation game had a solo mode doesn't make any sense and I can't think of many other I can't think of any under negotiation game that does that Cosmic Encounter didn't new Angeles doesn't you know I think most other people got it in their heads that the whole point of a group discussion game is that you play it as a group what he got it worst thing of when you put the mode in thinking no one gonna play solo anyway but yeah that's probably the thought process it's like oh God these people on my Kickstarter page won't shut the hell up fine I'll put a solo mode in you almost like have to come up with one in advance now and V James would be as number one yeah play solo modes a lot but some just seem tacked on and it it is cuz it paints a bad picture for solo players because it's covering up with all these different ways to play solo that just aren't that fun but I can't play every single game in my collection if it was solo it's not going to happen I've got solo games that I want want to play more often and I simply can't just because of time you know I don't need any more so I'm more interested to sort of go right these games I'm not going to touch solo ever again and focus on these other ones why yeah just fifth player for the sake of it solo for the sake of it it's same sort of thing it's just a lot of these things that I come up with are and I just realized that said number four yeah it was meant to be number three whatever people know how to count it's

free but it yeah come on just don't do it you for two left two so this this one really irked me only because I got given a copy of the game to look at and and my head just imploded as why have you done this so again I've gone back to steam forged gam so dark souls it's get a lot of punishment yeah so they um they created they did a an updated version they two two big box Standalone games um and basically what they had done in each box was um take out the enemies putting some other ones and literally split the main box the first game in half so it actually two halfes of a game um right isn't that more of a publisher thing though uh well it's the rules as well um and the um so they they had one of the rules in the in the original was that if you were being attacked if you were a tank you would you could choose to Def defend or evade but you would obviously defend using your armor if you were sort like a thief or something you would look to evade but the thing is is that it was um it was risky because evading meant if you did it correctly you would take no damage at all if you if you failed you evade you would get hit with everything whereas if you defended with your armor the likelihood is You' take a little bit of

damage but not too much so you had to risk what you were going to do in the um the new version they changed the rules that you roll all the dice for evade and defend look at the result and then choose what you wanted but so what exactly is this point then I'm just trying to doing a new uh a new version of a game but making the rules worse so what like re-implementations that don't work I'm sort of like trying to summarize it in one because I thought it was splitting up your game but that doesn't quite work no no that's it it was just changing the rules changing the rules for a game that was already quite broken anyway but um yes they made them they made them a lot worse and I yeah and it just it was it was quite frustra the thing they did as well that was really frustrating is that they've um they don't tell you that these two new games aren't compatible with everything else they've done so a newcomer would grab everything they're 100 pound a game um and you've got no idea that the 50 Quid expansions are not compatible with these that was um that was a big big mistake I think love that I like the fact that like some of the comments are like going on about you know could number two just be steam Forge game well I did just put Dark Souls there as a joke so this game has I like the game but I really don't like the the new new versions I think they've completely spam the rules I don't think you like any version of the game that's done by the designer though I think you fan variant yeah and they and they were great and

then they went actually what these fans have done for the past five years we're going to ignore and make up another rule set that's week so yeah I mean this is I mean this is a going back to the solo video I don't know if I understand as wanting no solo instead of a bad one can you not ignore it but the thing with that is though is that development time is limited on a game you know somebody had to put time to like right I'm going to write this extra bit of the rules or do this solo mode because I want to ask to the time they spend doing that is time they could have spent refining the element that does work and there you they can be and it can even be more costly to do that because somebody might go right well I can't think of a solo mode so let's get tury or somebody else to just make a solo mode for me and then that cost money takes time gets put in and this is time that could have been spent doing other stuff so that's where I'd go with that but what other game has ever changing rules or I suppose is it a Kickstarter thing because I don't do a lot of that anymore or is it just Dark Souls there is a game actually where they're all books online and it gets updated all the time which one's that oh I mean that could work for something like the lcgs yeah where you've got like a rata list and taboo list that always gets my nerves I can't remember which one it was I can't remember but with um with making you um updated versions as well so I used to play Warhammer underworlds um little small box um two

faction shade spire and all that wasn't it yeah so I tournaments and I was doing all right and I really enjoyed it but what they were doing the tournaments is every time every time Games Workshop released a new expansion the the oldest one become Obsolete and so you all your cards and and things just were completely Obsolete and it was just you had to keep buying I bought it thinking Warhammer in a 30 quid box brilliant and then you end up spending loads of money if you want to compete that does happen with a few of the the ccg ones as well where the The Meta changes so much that a lot of your earlier stuff is just kind of obsolete it's like well hang on this was fine now but I don't know if I want it like that yeah that's old one yeah but hopefully his number one's not to do with dark souls because I on one specific game I've tried to spread the love with the games that I'm using as examples but I swear like is is just targeted what all right this one um I mean name any splotter game and this would work but I swear there's probably a lot of other games where this would happen and fact I mean stuff like blood on the Clock Tower actually suffers from this now and again uh but you know splotter Euro games have this issue it's it's worse in Long games um but I mentioned with like solo modes now you want to feel like you've got a fighting chance throughout the game um you know cuz otherwise if you're just there for 4 hours playing Through the Motions whereas the fun the term which I don't know who near it or say but it's called

pseudo knockout and it's essentially like saying you know you're not eliminated from the game but you're might as well have been because at this point you have no physical chance to win you will never pull it back it's not going to happen it's but you are there you know good luck you better keep joining in and I mentioned Blood on the clock tower because that's got the idea that you know if you die early you can't just get up and walk away you you're stuck there still doing stuff and it's like on I died you know I don't want to like stick around for a bit but splotter games especially this one the bane of my freaking life this horrible game I know it's got its fans but five players as well yeah five players who plays this with five oh dear God it's already like a 4H hour game I we look at that 120 to 240 I've never seen a game of this take less than 3 hours but with with fuch mag and I've suffered from this cuz I've tried to give it a chance and it fails miserably I mean I already have to get past these Aesthetics but the the game their design standpoint is if you can't lose on the first term what's the point of a first term I don't get what they were smoking when they came up with that because it does not work it but this one this game has that problem in Spades where if you don't start in a particular way like you've got maybe one or two ways that you must start this game if you try to deviate from that you will lose like you're never going to pull it

back your income will be too low you won't get a decent enough like setup or anything but you can't leave and this game won't end for another four hours so you I already know as I play this that I've done something wrong at the start and now my start is so bad I'll never pick it back up but I can't get out you know I have to just go through the motions like what do I do do I help this player do I King make this one am I trying to beat my own score I don't know you lose all incentive to carry on as well as you lose any sense of an objective cuz you know your normal objective is to win or at least do well but that's not going to happen anymore you know a decent game should have the idea that as I say you have a fighting chance throughout yeah you might fall back so maybe you think you're not going to win but you never know something could happen that could pull you back and you know I mean you'll notice this with you know hegemony that can have that effect at times but even you know games where you've got the scoring at the end I mean Earth's a good example um if you play Earth the scoring is so vast when you get to the end that you know you you'd be surprised how close the scores could be or where somebody wins and you didn't realize it that's good because then you find out at the end when that happens but and I must admit I'm not seeing this happen as often as I used to I think there was a phase when I played some of these splotter games and some of these bigger Euros like power grids another one like you know if you do badly in power grid like a couple of auctions or something then good night sweep prints you ain't going to pull it back ever again and I just got sick and

tired of this mechanic being a Forefront of the game but I don't see it too often in modern designs I think that maybe designers have got wise to it now or done better at hiding it that's what I would to think I mean have you come across this um no not not really not in the games I play the only time I have players that are left behind and struggling is because one of my friends we just literally have to carry through most of the games we play because he just doesn't get any of the rules that we play but that's on him not the game yeah and there are occasions when it can be you know I mean I mentioned the Germany doesn't often have that problem we did have one game of it where somebody was a capitalist was doing so badly that there was no chance they could win like no no chance but granted they were playing stupendously badly like I've never seen anybody play the capitalist class that bad even players who have not played the game before you know we'll see yeah depend who plays that but I don't think you could do worse in this player I swear you got something like 20 something points that is quite an achievement to have that low a score right because everything someone's asked a question that I was going to ask how do you feel about um the catch-up mechanics end of the round if you're losing you get x amount of money or or or points or something I don't mind that as long as it doesn't negate a reason for winning um because in fact good example of that I brought out Isle of Sky last night um

at the game club I said on my last uh uh keep Co one sorry that I wanted to get this one out and I'm glad I did because I realize just how solid it is and it will stick around but is of Sky's got a catch-up mechanic with the money income if I can find the a picture of the player board I'll show you but or sorry the central board but but essentially is that good enough you can only barely see it but at the top there these little money values on the round um when you get your income for every player marker that's ahead of you on the score track you get a certain amount of money back and that's a decent catch-up mechanic but we had that in the game the people who were at the back a lot didn't win they still came third and fourth despite the fact that they were getting this money but at least they had something to do they didn't feel like they were getting punished too badly and I mean the person who was ahead on the score track more often like for most of the game still won it only by a few points I was only like about four five six points behind him but I was like second maybe third occasionally on the track but most of the time I wasn't getting a huge amount of money from it and so it's a catch-up mechanic in a sense like it gives you a chance to do something you've still got to make use of it but this one doesn't feel overpowering now there are some cases where you know Lin as a as a point yeah the catchup mechanic can be so powerful that you like I forget like some card games I've seen where like the person in last place gets a particular card like a dragon card in a trick takey game or something like that but that dragon card might be

so Ultra powerful it's like everybody wants that card so why are you trying to win at that stage and yeah I mean that can be just as bad although I mean I've seen way more examples of pseudo knockout than I have catchup mechanics period let alone catchup mechanics that overpower the need to win I certainly wouldn't say no to an um an example of that to sort of prove me wrong but yeah I mean I haven't seen I can't think of a case of it not something for yours no I can't think of any or do catch up mechanics have no effect on you I don't is that I'm doing I'm doing badly that I'm doing badly that's it it's just like we know we've accepted Our Fate there is no catchup mechanic that can help but I'm just curious as I look at I don't I'm trying to think can't think a one no the catcher mechanics do not uh advertise themselves as much anymore you know I don't I used to see them occasionally but now I think a lot of the designers are just probably because they're going down this route of everything's got to be harder or more punishing in their games it's like now they just say look if you're losing you're losing deal with it you know crime a river it does seem to be that way all right well what can possibly be any worse than what we just said

right so does it end in Souls no no um but pick to this you are playing a long competitive game for five or six hours you've done everything right you've you've conquered land you've got loads of resources you are sure you're Victorious and then hidden Victory Point tokens get revealed and some lucky bug all the highest randomly picked the highest so my it was It was a second on oh God I hate that game but yes I know exactly what you mean yeah and I I did everything right I was I had loads of territory I'd taken the center and I was sure of Victory and this this and um all my battles have been really difficult as well so I kind of really earned them um but then this other guy just flipped over his victory point he was getting fours fours fours and I was just like there's only a few in the game how come we've got them all and I lost I lost because of that and it was just it was random that's what frustrated me I I just other games do it as well and it's it's totally with you yeah that is I mean to be fair I could come up with a long list of stuff I hate in Eclipse but that is there's a lot of RNG elements in Eclipse that do bug me and there's a lot of random elements in it that included and it is kind of crazy like that cuz other games have it and I don't mind it too much in a short game you play something like jaur you can get those hid you can get those Point tokens and they range from like seven to n four to six or whatever yeah yeah that's a luck

Factor but it's Jer it's a simple tiny little two-player game they could have done it better they could have just made it fixed but you know what the hell it's a tiny one but yeah I've seen these in some of these bigger games and why would you include a random element like that yeah that's what I mean is the whole I mean I know the guy the game has has dice but they are based on your um your choice of of of weapon um the bloodb team manager has them as well but I don't mind it in that game is chaotic anyway it's it's a chaotic um random fun game but when you spend hours playing and you lose just by someone picked a random token um that than you it was it was yeah quite frustrating that was it makes sense on that one yeah CU yeah I've seen because this one is not like if it said oh yeah this is meant to be a little silly fun space game it's not it's a super serious Euro game about balancing your checkbook in space it's not you know meant to be a silly stupid things so why these RNG mechanics are thrown in there stuff even not just victory Point tokens like random expiration tokens have that problem as well where Twilight and pyramid I think it's got like this one could blow up your ship this one could give you extra resources well there's a bit of a disparity between the two and you get given them at random but I try to think of other hidden VP ones I mean there's I'm sure there's tons of examples I have seen this crop up and yeah it rarely it rarely gets anybody going oh yeah I'm excited to see what your hidden random

tokens do yeah I mean if they were revealed you could you could gauge who's winning and you know who to kind of like hunt down but because it's random I was I was getting um attached just because I had more more um area than anybody else or more locations and the central location and I just thought that's fair because I'm winning and then when they revealed the tokens I was like how is that possible is f there you know the fact that I'm forgetting some of these games as examples as that because they're just not coming to the top of my head but yeah the random Victory Point tokens yeah I'm sure there's other examples maybe the commenters can hurt but yeah that's other things as well not just it's not just the random ones it's things like games that have so many ways you can get victory points at the end of the game you lose complete track of them during the game so at the end you've got like a list of 20 points um nine worlds does that quite well where they've got a huge list how you got victory points and you can never keep up with that in the game you could never look at anyone and think who's winning well I mean that's not necessarily A too bad of thing because then do you have you played Earth yet no oh right okay that's interesting because because Earth's got like about 10 different things you end up scoring for and scores can be anywhere between like 150 to 300 or something on typical games so they do vary quite a lot and technically you don't I mean technically you don't see what you're scoring until the end you know you've got an idea you can see somebody's got a lot of trees or a lot of sprout cubes or what and go oh yeah that's worth a decent amount of points but because there's so many different

elements you would not be able to necessarily go oh yeah that person's definitely W but when scoring up I've never felt I don't get that feeling you get from Eclipse with it to say oh that was just random points it's like well it wasn't random you earned every point on that list but obviously you didn't necessarily know that they had 40 more points than you until you actually started adding things up but varied in Earth then can you get quite a vary the oh good yeah I mean the points can vary quite a bit because it is like a sort of bit of a point sad at the end of the day but nothing is hidden score rate I mean you know if you wanted to you could go to somebody's player board unwrap it all and see right you've got this many points at the moment but obviously you wouldn't there's no need but you you don't get a random token in Earth that says X points you know if you got 20 points from an objective card it's because you have exactly what is Neary to get those that's fine yeah as you said those hidden random ones that doesn't matter you both do the same thing it's just whoever picked that one at the bag I forgot that game had it as soon as you mentioned it it's like oh God yeah I'll add it to the list such a strange thing such a such a heavy complex and and sort of like um you know long game to have that silly random element in all these people are like oh yeah look at my super strategic Eclipse game and it's like yeah the amount of Randomness in that game I mean I'm surprised most Euro gamers are opposed to luck and even I'm like in Long games I don't want loads of luck in my long games um which I must

admit uh I suppose my number one is actually not too dissimilar to that actually we'll carry on this conversation because you actually actually despite actually be the equivalent of a crossover yours is very specific you're talking about hidden sort of random victory points in that mine is similar I'm just broadening it up a bit I'm just talking about random elements in the long game and it's not so much the victory point scoring it's more that you've got this Euro game that's clearly meant to be a serious Euro game it's it's got complexity it's going to take a good three plus hours to play you know it's clearly not a silly fun lucky game but then one aspect of it has to have some push your luck mechanic or some random element that is so snny in its nature that it pretty much does decide what happens with other players septe is probably the worst contender I've had for this lately I like that because of that troll mechanic and and I say I played it with three mates of mine we love mine clash games well sort of their recent stuff not so much but we love like cheran and arony you know we've got those two high up and list but I showed them septeber CU I wanted to get it played all of us bounced off it that particular game but one one person in particular hated the TR mechanic so much it pretty much killed the game for her ever wanting to play it again like she could not say anything else apart from just how bad this was but it it had that thing cuz it's push your luck you spend this whole game trying to be strategic with what you do and what your witches

at but there's only four rounds or something like that or like not five you know there's very few rounds in the game yeah and these and getting these witches are is essential because you need them to score the points off your big divination card hard to get the witches isn't it yeah you've got spaces for four of them but trying to get any it is an absolute nightmare um but to have this thing where and in that same game you know cuz this is pushy luck it's draw stuff out of a bag and see what happens blatantly she had more stuff in the bag than I did like I wasn't caring about the Witch and that I still beat her on the first witch and then the second time when clearly it should have been her because I would have lost those characters somehow we just drew in such a way that I still won it like I won two witches in a row and I clearly should not have done but even though she had more stuff stuff in there like she'd prep spent all that time prepping for it she gets nothing from it and this is like a 3our OD like Euro game you know and your eclipse is a similar thing you know because it's not just the victory points in that doesn't it have like technology you get randomly and sort bits like that I forget yeah oh yeah if you um well when you draw your tiles you can get some really good tiles so you can you can like earn a piece of technology from a tile in Eclipse whereas someone else draws a tile and they'll get two bad guys always a apparently there's a variant for the trial possibly but again this goes back to why is well I'm not aware of what this variant is maybe it was a official one on there but it's just like well if

it's a variant why don't you design your game to be better without the variant in it CU surely in play testing that must have come up as like a potential thing but I swear people are just very accepting of these random parts and card draw luck can be a problem as well cuz I mean I love art NOA I'm not like oblivious to the fact that there is an element of card draw luck but I'd argue that I have won more games of OVA than I've lost so even with some of that bad luck I am still able to do something with what cards I get you know it's like right I was hunting monkeys well monkeys have all dried up now well you know what that's still a good card there that's still something there you know what I can try something else it may not work but at least there's an option but uh some of other long ones uh Wonderland was it not what's the word Wonderland's War another one yeah it's basically a longer version of um uh quacks of quber you you're just drawing stuff out the bag that's not a short game this game takes a good two hours plus to finish like two and a half hours to get people to finish here and the whole game is basically push your luck you know like R to the bag so you're just play two and a half hours of luck Talisman yeah who remembers that like old that old game yeah it's just roll and move but you play it for six hours so why am I playing it for for six hours odd I'm trying to think of um I know there was like some other better examples that had lady oh actually Dune Imperium is another one of those you know Dune Imperium is not a short game by any means particularly when you play it with you know four players or with

expansions but dun Imperium is at its heart a deck building game and deck building is already quite a luck based mechanic but then you play something like Dominion Star Realms or you know stuff of that it's a short game L ruins of arac is a longer game but I feel like you can do a bit more with your deck or you see more of it do an Imperium you don't go for your deck that many times you only buy so many cards because you've only got so many points you grab but because you know when you buy a card you might not see it appear for that that long D imperium's also got very critical turns like I know somebody's going to block me out of this or screw me out of this combat or screw me out of this faction token I need to go to this spot draw my five cards oh I've got none of those triangle spaces I can't physically go to those spaces I can't do anything to stop you and you know after a three-hour game of doing Imperium to have like critical turns at the end just messed up because of a bad luck draw yeah no I mean I like I like Dune Imperium but yeah it's frustrating when you're because normally the games we play and quite closely but you draw a deck hand of cards and you've got not one of where you need to go maybe you need to go up the you know um to get that token off the side faction tracks yeah and you just don't have those because they're quite Limited anyway have it is frustrating because like even with some of the ones that are you know if you don't get the best cards there's usually something you can do with other bits and in rnac your worker placement is not tied to the cards in

your hand other than just the boot or car symbol but there's still good places for you to go regardless or there's stuff that doesn't even require you to T your dudes out dude Imperium has to have you put your agents out and it's critical what cards you get on there I like the face kuki says six hours of Talis yeah granted that's a underestimate it does go much longer than six hours particularly when you throw every in but that is just kind of insane uh what we got so yeah I mean AR over terrify M of ail huge deck of cards which makes them reactive in a sense yeah you have to adapt with what comes out of the deck and that's why I kind of not so much terraforming mods but I warmed up more to it everel similar but you know AR yes there is an element of draw luck but if it was just luck of the draw I wouldn't be winning most of my games of AR NOA you know there clearly has to be an element of what you do with what you what you're given that works with it even Earth has that you know you burn through a ton of cards in Earth but the the idea isn't that you know you might draw a really good card it can happen but the game's an hour long you know an hour 10 hour 20 minutes whatever but at the end of the day you burn through so many cards the idea of being good at Earth is that you can take a hand of 10 cards and immediately sort of go right those are good that's good that's better than that those four are trash right they get composted I'm going to keep these and being able to separate your hand like that it's not that oh I've drawn 10 fantastic cards you only play 16 so you can't have everything you got

to pick your battles so yeah I mean there's a million examples of these ones that doesn't necessarily mean that if you remove all the the randomness from the game it's now brilliant because then you get stuff like food chain magnate which still sucks but it's it's not removing all the luck doesn't automatically make the game fantastic but you know it's got to if you are going to for a random element in a long game it's got to be mitigable or not so swinny you know make it a small bet like a price Market a price Market that doesn't swing ridiculously yeah you know it's going to adjust every round something will be high something will be low it might suck but at least it's not a case off right next round I'd rather that wood wasn't expensive and then a roll of a die happens and suddenly W wood is like twice as much you know you don't want it to be a crazy swing you just want it to be a little bit of a nuisance um you know something that you could prepare for you can't really prepare in septe for example for having such a bad draw on a trial that you just don't get any witches yeah yeah especially when you've sent played all your actions to get those mles into that area yeah word there so yeah I don't like you know I like some Randomness just you know in the right stayed uh wasn't there a game ages ago where you would you would roll a die to see how many actions you took that turn I don't D12 or D20 or something I don't know the game you're on about but in Old Dice Tower top 10 list Z mentions

this game a few times and yes it you you rolled a d a d10 or something I don't know and that was how many actions you got yeah I think it was a d10 but even then rolling a d10 for actions is a stupid thing but I think that's quite an old game or at least maybe an old indie game so nobody no designer these days would be stupid enough to ATT another game I played where you had a set amount of actions and you rolled a d D6 but it become a D3 to add actions I can't remember what it was I'm sure I can't I have to think I'll look back through my stats and see which game I I'm sure you added yeah you old D and you added actions to your your standard you had four to start with and you R die to had a few more I'll have a think TR think on that one right uh right before wrapping this up because those ones did go on there right everyone in the comments come on I want to hear some I want to hear some of your quirks I some of your annoying designer quirks because we've done 10 each we crossed over slightly you know unofficially on those but I swear there's more there was certainly more on I think the short list on there I mean I suppose like while they get their brains in GE did you have a couple extra like 11 and 12 I'm just having a look now at my list I think I might have yeah one of them was trading card games as a whole that's not Designer qu that's just you hate a genre now C cried Fowler making things overly complex I think was one I took off the list uh because I don't mind a

complex game having again and again but somebody mentioned like David tury earlier and it's like David tur's a nice bloke and I swear he puts up with a lot of crap for me and does very well he's a very tolerant person but the you know a lot of his solo modes are very complex and I get to the point where it's a bit too much but even some games you know like unrelated to unrelated to David you know there are some games that come out and it's just like everything in their kitchen sink I mean revive was one of those revive was okay but it had its problems but man does it just throw everything in there that it physically could does that just Chuck every single mechanical every single it feels like it's got like a bit of everything it's like a a mixture of All Sorts because it's bone dry there's no real theme in it at all but you know you've got the tracks around the board and you've got like a card a little deck build thing then you've got the action slots then you've got you know tokens that you can grab and then you've got a map that you move around and build stuff on it's like Jesus Christ it is a kitchen sink worth of stuff uh don't think there's many El too long in general yeah I mean I'm I don't mind long games I mean I we played Game of Thrones for 12 hours once and I'd do it again I'd do it again no I'd rather I I'd rather watch season eight no you a I would I no I'd rather watch season 8 than play 12 hours of a game any game no game is 12 hours worthy you know even though hegemony one is meant to be four you know okay so I doing that for 12 uh but yeah there

wasn't much else on the short list right what else have we got uh um oh the played the going back to that Old Point yeah I think Destiny is the bad game yeah well well I think I I gave it a six out of 10 when I first reviewed it but I think I was being a bit lenient then and this was before I solidified what my rating system was so six then probably might have translated to four now um but yeah I was not a fan there saw one there from Kristoff it's trying to play Europa un universalis now I have that unpunched um I bought at last UK games Expo Mark has it I would like to play it but I am so not buying it and learning it myself it's like true it's like like like 15 hour games or something or is it played over scenarios or I think it's like how big you make the game I'm not sure but like I say it looks way too much for anybody normal to sort of jump into but it's it seems like one of those games I should try I'm just going in order here so what we got uh so misses on dice I prefer the street Masters idea with the misses are re that's a good point actually um too many bones kind of done does this but I think the I don't think there is good in too many bones Street Masters has a cool thing that you are running around you're trying to hit people with Streets of Rage miniature style really good but if you do miss you effectively get a charge icon that charges up your super move so so it's all well and good it's like you know I'm punching the bad guy and it's like all I've had a couple of Misses I'm taking a bit of damage but because I've taken the

damage I'm charging myself up to suddenly do spinny flurry kick or whatever you know like yeah I mean it's it's they're like Street Fighter stuff so it's like partially Fantastical street fighting type thing but but then at least missing is not the end of the world in that um but it is uh what sorry we played strongholds is that the two-player game where you got seizure Castle I've not I don't get two players to the table very often no that that has a really good hit and miss mechanic for their catapult so you have a big deck of cards thr for each individual machine um and a lot of them at the start of the game are misses and as you draw a card if it's a hit you do your damage and you put the hit card back in if it's a miss you don't do anything but the Miss card disappears so you gradually out I think that's a really good mechanic for for the like you're getting your aim in almost version before that that's the newer version I think yeah that's Undead there was a second edition one it was the first one I clicked on but yeah I mean I it's a game I I would try but it's two player only so they're ones I don't tend to go for unless they're short and quick like seven oners duel but I that for atically works I thought that was really really nice uh really nice mechanic for the um for the action but yeah I mean Imperial assault Gloom Haven a lot of these ones will have misses on cards and yeah I mean you could just draw really badly and get you know I played Imperial assault and what I found is it doesn't matter where you were on the board you always got hit by something you couldn't

hide behind terrain it just seemed that the way the terrain was brought out you always got hit the terrain made no difference because it was so easy to hit things like line of sight too many steps for a bot I hate to say the name again but yeah tury um so um if you've ever you ever want to have too many steps for a bot play uh what was that three hour Point salad Euro the one that had the anime feel aoku um he ads he admits he admits it's not his best solo mode which is fine but you know he makes complex solo modes it's gonna happen but but yeah you want yeah but go Blobby yeah you want to you want to play this game and talk about too many steps for a bot the thing's got about like 10 12 steps on a giant flowchart or something I could not fathom it to save my life I tried to play it solo and I just felt like I was going to have to spend an hour a turn just understanding what this wretched bot did it's just like that went way too far uh we got overly complex endgame goals uh what ones in particular I mean can you think of anything like that over the complex I mean what would be complex I mean are we talking are we talking like where you get like a set of endgame objectives that you got to do and there's like one that's you know get four tiles and the other one requires you to get like four tiles two dreadnots three you know spheres of whatever and like you know

and a million pound or something you know like the're way too disparaged who knows uh uh 12 hour yeah Kabuki car believe you played game of fro 12 to be fair I don't know how you played that 12 hours player as well eight player did everyone know the game yes yeah still 12 hours oh God yeah we are we are very tactical when it comes to that game yeah lot of table talk at least of I watch season 8 I get some good acting something to keep me engaged even if the story sucked um what we got uh yeah I've played shorter diplomacy games oh God yeah that is true uh what else have we got do we got any more uh caving into popular commercial demand and not sticking to your design idea I mean I suppose that links with the one you talked about earlier where the rules kept changing yeah um but also I suppose it links to a couple I've done where I said like you know we put in a fifth player or solo player for the sake of it because everybody keeps crying for one and I can't think of examples but I know I have seen the occasional Kickstarter project where the designer has come out and said I know you're all asking for it but I'm not putting in a four a fifth play or a solo mode you I have decided that it doesn't work I can't think of a good one maybe in the future but for now we're not putting it in the game fair play to you you're willing to like come out and just state that and stick to your guns that get a brownie point that game I said with the the living rule book was it was it Soul Forge that was online it you no I didn't oh wait so oh Soul so so

for oh God game yeah I got I got so much stick for that from Fanboys that was I wish I never reviewed that game um the game itself was okay I wasn't that bold by I mean it's basically just another magic clone with some extra tweaks but the had an online rule book that was forever changing because I remember I I I sold my copy and someone complained it was no rule book and I was like oh my God and I forgot I was like oh no no it's online there isn't one yeah and I was thinking about that you open it and it's got like a crappy paper mat bunch of cards but no rule book and you and I tried to read it on my phone um my tablet was charging so that you cannot do it on your phone but it's just like I'm sorry there's no excuse for putting a rotten rule book in your game people and people were giving me sticks saying like you know it's fine it's online it's like what everybody's okay with this I printed it I needed a paper coffee yeah but it's like for CED out loud the basic rule book well Magic's got this problem cuz magic the Gathering doesn't put a rule book in it starter decks anymore it expects you to go online and find it or be taught it you know by OS by osmosis or something it's it just doesn't work but it's almost I don't want games to go the way of computer games cuz do you remember like in the back of the days you actually felt really good when you opened up a physical disc and you got a little booklet inside yeah and then you got the rule book and then it got to a point where you didn't get the booklet but you at least had some rules or it was just a disc now you're luy enough to get the

disc and now it's all digital so Rule books don't exist in a computer game I don't you know it expects you to go into the game and learn it through a tutorial or something I do not want board games to start making us go to online sources because casual people don't do online stuff all the time you know if I buy a game for my parents they're not going to go online and read a rule book you know in their 70s it's not going to happen um making a roll and right version of every game oh I mean preaching to the choir I just don't know if that's a designer or a publisher thing I suppose it's a designer because they've got to come up with the rules for it but I wonder if it's also egging by a publisher you know is there a is does somebody make a game and they go oh your alhamra game was fantastic mate um we want to sell more we just want to sell more stuff and make money though can you turn it into a Rolland right and make it one that doesn't work very well but yeah I must admit I'm sick and tired of these R right tlight one Twilight Imperium one you played that rolling right

can't get out what did you it's stuck in there with my Marvel Champion stuff yeah Twilight description yeah it's as ideas go it's crazy like it really shouldn't work or like I do have to wonder what you were smoking when you thought let's turn Twilight Imperium into a Rolland right but to be honest I actually kind of enjoy it I've still got it it there's a lot to learn I certainly would never play it with more than three players and honestly I just don't think I would play it more than solo cuz I think the solo works fine in it but as Rolland Wes go it gives you a lot to do a lot of choices and it's it looks cool it's well produced in that so yeah probably a dumb crazy idea but I actually still enjoyed it it's one of my more preferred rolling writes I think it did it did end up on my top 10 list but called blamy I know the feeling like turning everything into a roll and right especially I don't mind sometimes uh cuz um long shot um long shot the dice game is you know such a really cool game nobody has played long shot for ages I'd never played the original I mean the original long shot came out in 2003 and then maybe again in 2009 or something so it's not like it was the hotness and all of a sudden it got a Rolland wri but this Rolland wri is a really good one but it's just when you do get like a you know Isle of cats has done it Dinosaur Island have done it you know these games have not been out that long and all all of a sudden you've now got Roar and right and the uh you know whatever the AR of cats one was and

they're always stff names as well you like doing puns and things like that that always does my head in because again when it happens so soon after a game gets released the cascadia's now doing it the two roll and rights for that I couldn't care less Cascadia is one of the best Gateway Games there is I don't need a roll and right version of it you know just to and it just feels like oh we these games won't be that good they're not going to be great roll and right but it's got the word Cascadia on it therefore you'll buy it won't you that's kind of how it works uh too many different ways to win the game five different ways to win the game just makes it too overwhelming um I mean five is a bit extreme but um this I played a game recently it's it's a finished game it's it's designed published everything but well but it's going to Kickstarter for its delivery um it's called Winds of new M you you play some obscure games you really yeah really good card game really good card game of Waring factions um but there are four ways to win the game but you have to it's the first person to get to two of them which I didn't mind so how many what do you call Wings of I mean there's wings of everything here wind a wind of wind of num why stop there at that point just make up words I mean I don't it may not even be on here or like it might be too old or something no no no it's um it's goes to Kickstarter next month but the game's been made so it's just going to be sort of like the kickstarter is going to be

like a delivery rather than a a funding right okay maybe it's just not BG or perhaps I just don't know how to spell it I mean that's I mean there another thing for Publishers name your game something that people can find on Board Game Geek but yeah and I don't mind this one too much yeah gred having too many ways to win could be a problematic but I'm not I don't can't think of a game where it's got five but I like a game where it comes up with two or three different ways 7even wonders duel has three you either win by points you win by science or you win by military all three of those are perfectly legit ways to win I like it even in a euro game if that long Euro game if that happens if I know that there's two ways I can win and it's like well I'm not doing too well at this aspect I should do the other bit and there's equal chances I'm cool with that but five five does seem like a lot I'm curious what game example that will be um the worst every may be I love the five and six on D6 well basically just yeah successes is one in three chance rathered than one and two well if you if you start the game playing as um Rex the reporter he's cursed you start the game rolling sixes which just kills you yeah just like no good uh perseverance yeah multi-step solo mode again it's like not like those ones um was this I bed T say about about it and he said he tried to solve the issue with void fall no he did not void fall solo mod I I guess it doesn't have a million steps but the game has a million rules so that kind of

makes up for it got a million steps void Fall's got so many rules it's ridiculous um it's a big game this one actually is I quite yeah I got to admit this one irks me in Arkham Horror because as much as I do like the game I haven't played it in a while and sometimes when I do get frustrated during my plays this is the thing that's frustrating me the fact that when you draw the tokens out of the bag there is an eldrich token that Auto Fails yes so no matter how well you've done yeah always at the worst bloody tie but you pull out that tentacle token it is as well yeah but it's I get the idea that thematically you could do what you could be totally prepared and you could still lose I mean any Star Trek fan knows Bard's quote of it's you you you can was it it's possible to commit no mistake and still lose such a great quote but but the fact is this tentacle token is pulled out at random so I might not see it the entire game I might pull it three times in a row yeah um what was it uh vo for lacks Touch of Randomness in combat yeah deterministic combat some there that chaos tokens why I like Lord of the Rings better yeah I suppose it does have that uh what else we got um Soul Forge solge games released without proper lawn testing I mean that Designer publisher I mean it's hard to tell the thing yeah the thing well I mean this could be anything but the problem is that as much as I rag on the thing for

saying look how the hell did this get past play testing we don't know how much play testing happens with a game so we can cry fou and say that there's no way this should have got past the testing but we don't actually know how often they play tested it although to be honest I would argue that pretty much most stonem games don't go through much play testing but because because if they did you wouldn't have games like tapestry so uh toight description yeah the oh yeah yeah the political voting part of the game yeah there's a mini little voty thing in Twilight in description that's kind of weak but that's a minor thing and even then if you're playing it solo it's not a big deal uh let's see like obscure games everybody's agreeing with the autof fail token so yeah yeah that that is probably a good one anyway two arrows five I think we'll wrap things up there so cheers everyone for joining in hopefully this will get some views not a ton of people on tonight but uh it is the summer so I guess everybody's just out enjoying what left there is of the sun before the storms start hitting and it is a weird topic cuz some people are sort of worried that like oh you just hear a ragon designers like no we do honestly love board games we do love board game design games I mentioned I I do like you know um yeah these games sorry Eclipse again I'll play that again but it's just that little bit that hurts me well that's the thing is because what the examples Moon rakers gave a good radient still in my collection I want to play luminar it was a tribes of the wind love that one White

Castle that's a solid game yeah love that yeah although actually now that I come to think of it feed the Kraken inventions splutters septe ah okay maybe maybe my list focused more on I suppose if I had to say I hated the rule I needed to give an example of a game that irked me more in I guess but I did mention good games as well no but yeah come to think of it I think my list actually did focus more on games I didn't like whereas yours are actually more games you did like or at least had that so that would have had that problem but still let say we're not bragging on designers and saying that like this game sucks therefore I hate this designer I like no you know every designer can put out a bad game and even my favorite games can have things that aren't great in it you know a great example Abyss Abyss love the game Bruna cfala one of my fav designers for like games the monster track though in the Bas game sucks as a mechanic it was not a good mechanic it got fixed in expansion so now it's an auto include but I still really liked Abyss for a long time before that happened even though that aspect of the game was a bad mechanic so you know there's always uh like I say these are irritating quirks not necessarily irritating games period maybe with the exception of one or two but we'll see um but now so hopefully if anybody at the UK games Expo we'll both see you there next week uh you're there the whole time Thursday to Sunday Thursday to Sunday yeah yeah I'll be there as well yeah press show and add but I mean we've got a geminy game on

Friday evening so that's going to be interesting uh we'll have to try and get try and find a table at the gaming rules section or something um tables wise we have to I don't know it'll be in one of the gaming Halls um I think they have a few tables like cloths wise or sorry but try and find one there we like getting it I don't know try and be somewhere I can find you cuz I've got to come straight from a world order demo um to that one so get me on my phone I'll tell you where we are keep it on the phone there but yeah so yeah we'll be at the games Expo if you want to say hi just by all means just come up not a problem I have got drinks for people that say hello to him what's that I said you buying drinks for people that say hello to you no not quite but I mean Essen it's hard to get hold of me sometimes because there's too many like interviews and that you got to do like all speaking to people I don't do a lot of that the games Expo because most of the games are not that desperate to try and I have got a few demos booked but that's it you know like a few hours a day you know not much um uh well World Order I'm definitely playing that one because I'm looking forward to that one the new same people as to gmany their followup so that's definitely given um I want to try and get in on that new like seven wonders Jewels spin-off Lord of the Rings one but I'm still like tempering expectations that up for ages for that w't you probably uh Yonder I think a 30 minute demo for that one um I have sources that are getting me into a black forest uh demo the the one that looks

like a sequel to Glass road that looks pretty sweet um but saying now one or two of the games I'm playing aren't technically there properly I mean I'm meeting up with Sarah sh you know b games in a minute and she's going to teach me inventors of the South Tigress so it's like that won't be at the games Expo but hell yeah I'm going to try that game so it's kind of a mix of a mix of everything but you know it's a lot easier to get hold of me at the Expo so just say hi same for Mark go say hi to him after you subscribe to his channel so and we've already established that he plays a lot of obscure Kickstarter games that I would probably never touch with a bar ball so by by all means if you want somebody who's going to actually plays some of the crowdfunding stuff around he's GNA berate me on next Friday aren't you no no it's because a lot of people will still you get the same old people previewing like the hit Kickstarter stuff you know like oh this is the million pound razor or something like that you're playing a lot of kickstarters that are less heard of but some of them still make it into your collection or still end up as good games so a minute yeah I have no idea what that game is never heard of it waken Realms it's the new one but that's the say you say you'll get a lot of these crowd funny games that are less heard of that could still be solid games I won't touch them so somebody's got to you know it's better that some you not because I think they're bad but it's just I've got time you know I've tried to pull back from Kickstarter on a big deal you know unsettled probably the last thing I got in the post that was a big Kickstarter one and even then I forgot about it CU

it like two years or something or stupidly Lana was waiting for that and it's kind of like another one of those Nails in the coffin to say yeah why did we buy the whole lot why did we not just get like a base set and see what it was like first so it has that commented about Utopia um I did a Kickstarter preview for that and a solo playthrough and they made me a card in the game oh sweet looks just like me is say what happens to said card though Wonder there is is it a hated card is it a traitor card is it does the character die at any point it's called the monk the monk that works yeah actually that would work I could see like a almost like a sort of medieval narrative G so where you're basically the F tuck character with the beard and everything I've got a big robe and a staff and I've got my big beard that would be great cool but yeah cheers for joining in guys let us know your thoughts in the comments certainly put up some ideas of quirks you don't like we've had a few already but I want to read some more because they're always good fun we'll see you on the next time I do one of these live streams this one was a little bit haphazard but that's because I'm out of practice so hopefully future ones will be a bit more smooth but now ways you know cheers Mark for coming on we'll get we'll certainly repeat this and of course yeah we he needs to go away and do some hegemony homework now so I do yes I have been looking I've got my rules out and I've been watching videos just the basics we do I don't

need every class specific because we don't know who's playing what yet but that's that's going to be fun looking forward to it so yep take care everybody we'll see you next time it's only a game regardless of whether how many designer quirks are in it so see you later guys byebye bye

Progress saved