Skip to main content
Spirit Island box art

Spirit Island

Game Info
Year
2017
Players
1-4
Age
13+
Playtime
120 min
Publisher
Greater Than Games
Collection
Ratings
Expansions & Family
Horizons of Spirit Island SPIRIT ISLAND: BRANCH AND CLAW EXPANSION
Mechanic profile
Percentile rank vs. all games
Vibe profile
How this game feels to play
Description

In the most distant reaches of the world, magic still exists, embodied by spirits of the land, of the sky, and of every natural thing. As the great powers of Europe stretch their colonial empires further and further, they will inevitably lay claim to a place where spirits still hold power - and when they do, the land itself will fight back alongside the islanders who live there.

Spirit Island is a complex and thematic co-operative game about defending your island home from colonizing Invaders. Players are different spirits of the land, each with its own unique elemental powers. Every turn, players simultaneously choose which of their power cards to play, paying energy to do so. Using combinations of power cards that match a spirit's elemental affinities can grant free bonus effects. Faster powers take effect immediately, before the Invaders spread and ravage, but other magics are slower, requiring forethought and planning to use effectively. In the Spirit phase, spirits gain energy, and choose how / whether to Grow: to reclaim used power cards, to seek new power, or to spread their presence into new areas of the island.

The Invaders expand across the island map in a semi-predictable fashion. Each turn they explore into some lands (portions of the island); the next turn, they build in those lands, forming towns and cities. The turn after that, they ravage there, bringing blight to the land and attacking any native islanders present. The islanders fight back against the Invaders when attacked, and lend the spirits some other aid, but may not always do so exactly as you'd hoped. Some Powers work through the islanders, helping them, for example, to drive out the Invaders or clean the land of blight.

The game escalates as it progresses: spirits spread their presence to new parts of the island and seek out new and more potent powers, while the Invaders step up their colonization efforts. Each turn represents 1-3 years of alternate history. At game start, winning requires destroying every last explorer, town and city on the board - but as you frighten the Invaders more and more, victory becomes easier: they'll run away even if explorers or even towns and cities remain. Defeat comes if any spirit is destroyed, if the island is overrun by blight, or if the Invader deck is depleted before achieving victory.

The game includes different adversaries to fight against (eg., a Swedish Mining Colony, or a Remote British Colony). Each changes play in different ways, and offers a different path of difficulty boosts to keep the game challenging as you gain skill.

Description

In the most distant reaches of the world, magic still exists, embodied by spirits of the land, of the sky, and of every natural thing. As the great powers of Europe stretch their colonial empires further and further, they will inevitably lay claim to a place where spirits still hold power - and when they do, the land itself will fight back alongside the islanders who live there.

Spirit Island is a complex and thematic co-operative game about defending your island home from colonizing Invaders. Players are different spirits of the land, each with its own unique elemental powers. Every turn, players simultaneously choose which of their power cards to play, paying energy to do so. Using combinations of power cards that match a spirit's elemental affinities can grant free bonus effects. Faster powers take effect immediately, before the Invaders spread and ravage, but other magics are slower, requiring forethought and planning to use effectively. In the Spirit phase, spirits gain energy, and choose how / whether to Grow: to reclaim used power cards, to seek new power, or to spread their presence into new areas of the island.

The Invaders expand across the island map in a semi-predictable fashion. Each turn they explore into some lands (portions of the island); the next turn, they build in those lands, forming towns and cities. The turn after that, they ravage there, bringing blight to the land and attacking any native islanders present. The islanders fight back against the Invaders when attacked, and lend the spirits some other aid, but may not always do so exactly as you'd hoped. Some Powers work through the islanders, helping them, for example, to drive out the Invaders or clean the land of blight.

The game escalates as it progresses: spirits spread their presence to new parts of the island and seek out new and more potent powers, while the Invaders step up their colonization efforts. Each turn represents 1-3 years of alternate history. At game start, winning requires destroying every last explorer, town and city on the board - but as you frighten the Invaders more and more, victory becomes easier: they'll run away even if explorers or even towns and cities remain. Defeat comes if any spirit is destroyed, if the island is overrun by blight, or if the Invader deck is depleted before achieving victory.

The game includes different adversaries to fight against (eg., a Swedish Mining Colony, or a Remote British Colony). Each changes play in different ways, and offers a different path of difficulty boosts to keep the game challenging as you gain skill.

Ask a Rules Question
All mentions
Browse transcript mentions, sentiments, pros/cons, mechanics, topics, quotes, and references.
Total mentions: 377
This page: 50
Sentiment: pos 41 · mix 3 · neu 2 · neg 0
Mentions per page
Showing 1–50 of 377
Video 9pimwOSVUVo The Brothers Murph Top List at 1:52 sentiment: positive
The Brothers Murph - Spirit Island video thumbnail
Click to watch at 1:52 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • So revered and rightly so
  • Incredible depth
  • Each spirit plays differently
  • Cooperative puzzle
Cons
none
Thematic elements
  • spirits protecting an island and its inhabitants from colonizers
  • an island
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • action selection — Players choose between fast and slow actions that occur at different phases of the round.
  • cooperative play — Players work together as spirits to protect the island.
  • Deck Building — Players build decks with unique spirit cards and common cards.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • This is evolution. This game I like it more every time I play it.
  • There's a million things to do. Uh any of them I think can be viable.
  • Guy Project is our number one of the heavy games.
  • The expansion, the Lost Fleet expansion, absolutely incredible.
  • It's just a fun efficiency puzzle. You are trying to get as much out of every round as you can.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video -qC4DLTuXnQ Rahdo Runs Through Top List at 1:52:35 sentiment: positive
Rahdo Runs Through - Spirit Island video thumbnail
Click to watch at 1:52:35 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • solid chunky game for solo and groups
  • high replayability
Cons
  • too complicated for a starting collection according to one speaker
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
  • Clank Catacombs
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Area Control — It is an area control game.
  • Cooperative — It is a cooperative game.
  • Deck Building — It is a deck building game.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • I just think they're too complicated, right?
  • Slay the Spire as a co-op game, awesome. Super awesome.
  • I hate Ironclad. He's so boring.
  • I do think that was definitely a a gap in our list.
  • I love Ticket to Ride. I'll play it anytime, uh, any version almost any version I I love.
  • Hot Streak terrific game. And it's got that wow factor that, you know, table presence as well.
  • Station Fall is great. That's a crazy choice. That's like I this is a very heavy choice, but it's great.
  • playing with Stacy Avalon and like that's a great way to make new friends because I was like infiltrated their friend group and then I was like well you are liars
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video -qC4DLTuXnQ Rahdo Runs Through Top List at 1:53:06 sentiment: positive
Rahdo Runs Through - Spirit Island video thumbnail
Click to watch at 1:53:06 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • solid chunky game for solo and a number of people
  • get a lot in that
Cons
  • too complicated
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • I just think they're too complicated, right?
  • Slay the Spire as a co-op game, awesome. Super awesome.
  • I hate Ironclad. He's so boring.
  • I do think that was definitely a a gap in our list.
  • I love Ticket to Ride. I'll play it anytime, uh, any version almost any version I I love.
  • Hot Streak terrific game. And it's got that wow factor that, you know, table presence as well.
  • Station Fall is great. That's a crazy choice. That's like I this is a very heavy choice, but it's great.
  • playing with Stacy Avalon and like that's a great way to make new friends because I was like infiltrated their friend group and then I was like well you are liars
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video Z-QbcDRsw7s Sir Thecos Top List at 2:20 sentiment: positive
Sir Thecos - Spirit Island video thumbnail
Click to watch at 2:20 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • One of the best cooperative and solo games
  • Amazing game session
  • Managed to squeeze out a win
  • Great challenge
Cons
  • So hard
  • Got kicked around
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • The Games. Today I will be looking at the games that I played last month and rank them just like I do every month.
  • This is just my opinion. You may have a very different one and if you do, great. Put them in the comments and then we can discuss that a little bit.
  • It's possible that I will rate a game differently next month depending on how often I played, with who I played, etc.
  • Usually I play games that I like playing, that I own.
  • Grab yourself a cup of tea and let's do this.
  • Seven Wonders is a very good game.
  • Picamino Oh, this is like a push your luck game I really like. Definitely S rank for me.
  • Monstrosity. That's a weird one because I like this game. I would give this an A. It's a very fun drawing game where you have to like memorize a monster and then you have to like explain it and others have to draw it. Then you have to like figure out like who was the closest. Except for two other people, everybody hates this.
  • Kariba is a perfectly serviceable game, very easy to play.
  • So very simple. I would give this a B. It's very simple but it's it's nice to play.
  • Hunted Transylvania and also Escape from Route 52 and these two games are fine. Um I think that other games are like way superior here but also I like it more than Shred of Redemption so I will give it a B. It's just fine.
  • Flora Verse that's an A for me. That's a very very nice game like very nice set collection game with a great theme, great artwork, very simple gameplay. I really like this one.
  • Daistron Daistron is for me also an A. I really like playing it. Um I don't like the it as a duel game as much as other games but I think it's really good. I like the mechanism a lot so I need to check out Adventures at some point. I think I will like Adventures a lot.
  • Strange World also A rank for me. This is a very nice puzzle game.
  • La Quenta is shaping up to be one of my most favorite just games to pull out and play with anyone. Everybody's having fun with it. Can I give it an S? I think I can.
  • Quicks is uh A B. I think it's an A rank for me. It's a very simple roll and write, but it's also always want to want to like to pull out. You can play this with anyone.
  • Insider also A. This is a very nice deduction game where you you pretty much like uh you play like Guess Who.
  • Enchanted Ivy. I've only played this a handful of times, but this is clear S rank for me. This is a really good solo game.
  • Harvest gets for me an A or B. Uh it's a very simple um card placement game where you try to pull like bad cards on the fields of your opponents, but good cards on your own.
  • Let me know in the comments which of these games you like more than me or less than me and also let me know what were you like your high and low lights from last month.
  • Thank you so much for watching. I really hope you enjoyed this video.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video xmx0t6gfLK0 Totally Tabled Top List at 33:26 sentiment: positive
Totally Tabled - Spirit Island video thumbnail
Click to watch at 33:26 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • refreshing theme
  • deep strategy
  • empowering player role
Cons
  • heavy complexity
Thematic elements
  • spirits defending an island from colonizers
  • an island
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Area Control — Defending an island from colonizers.
  • Card Play — Deep strategic card play.
  • cooperative play — Cooperative game where players work together.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • This War of Mine is the most profound board game I've ever played.
  • I'm a sucker for an epic strategy game, and Voidfall delivers that experience like no other.
  • Every horror movie fan needs to play Final Girl, a solo-only, dice-driven survival game that lets you experience whatever horror trope you desire, from classic slasher films to sci-fi and fantasy creature features and anything else you can imagine.
  • Robinson Crusoe is a timeless masterpiece, as gripping and brilliant as
  • and it is my favorite solo board game of all time.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video Pi-MkES3etM Stonemaier Games Analysis at 4:33
Stonemaier Games - Spirit Island video thumbnail
Click to watch at 4:33 · YouTube ↗
Pros
none
Cons
none
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • the tabletop power rankings. These are your picks, your picks, your votes for games that you've played recently that you are the most excited to play again in three different categories.
  • So Scythe has a bunch of different goals that you're trying to accomplish, but some of them are these objective cards that give you a way to earn a star.
  • Forest Shuffle has managed to get here at number one again as the game that people played recently and want to play again.
  • And I really like the goal system in Arknova because this public goal system because you have the option of scoring it when you only have two or three of these things, but you can get the most points if you wait until you have five of them and then choose to score.
  • I thought that was really clever in Arknova for the scoring.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video bJeOjvfKIDA Chairman of the Board Top List at 23:09 sentiment: positive
Chairman of the Board - Spirit Island video thumbnail
Click to watch at 23:09 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Massively different powers
  • Smooth cooperation, avoids quarterbacking
  • Deep card play with unique artwork
  • Complex but rewarding choices
  • Unique theme
  • Huge amount of content
Cons
  • Can be long, especially at higher player counts
  • May not change the mind of someone who dislikes cooperative games
  • Heavy
Thematic elements
  • Spirits repelling colonizing invaders
  • Island
  • Card-driven cooperative
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Area Control — Spirits try to scare invaders away.
  • Asymmetric Player Powers — Each spirit has unique abilities and powers.
  • Card Drafting — Players draft cards to their hand.
  • cooperative play — Players work together against the game.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • This is the thing that when I see it I'm like god I want to play it.
  • The Celtic mythology is something we haven't really seen in anything else.
  • Tricarion has this incredible theme that reminds me of the movie The Prestige.
  • It's extremely taxing, you feel exhausted by the end of it.
  • By the end of the game you're gonna have like four islands that you've completely filled and conquered with all your stuff, it's just so fun, so rewarding.
  • widely regarded as of the best kind of modern euro games
  • Do not build a bunch of little buildings right off the bat do not care for them right off the bat because you're going to find that you're really poor really quickly
  • the most out of print game ever
  • notorious because of its out of printedness
  • this is like gold dust this game um i've almost written it off
  • it's such a shame that good designs have to be lost because of some you know legal standpoint
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video vYh0rfs_b2M Chairman of the Board Discussion at 2:54 sentiment: positive
Chairman of the Board - Spirit Island video thumbnail
Click to watch at 2:54 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Excited to try it
  • Has a lot of hype
Cons
  • Heavy, will be a rules bear to learn
Thematic elements
  • Cooperative game where players take control of spirits to fight off colonists
  • A land being colonized
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Area Control — Taking control of spirits to fight off colonists.
  • cooperative play — A cooperative game where players work together.
  • Unique Player Powers — Using unique player powers to get colonists to leave.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • hey everybody today i'm starting a new series talking about all the games that i've acquired from month to month just to give you a heads up of what to expect in terms of content reviews etc and just the kind of things that i'm looking for
  • i really like the concept of that one again i've played it already and we'll be sharing my thoughts soon
  • i know it's got a hell of a reputation and um hopefully it's going to be as good as a lot of other connected titles because i really do enjoy violent community designs
  • it's regarded as one of the best games of all time
  • i've got some real positive things to say about tina's trial
  • this is one of the classic rhino kenichi games
  • this is a game an area control style game about being ants
  • i love talking about these style games because there's often gems here and while they often look dry and dusty and boring there's often some really fun mechanisms here
  • i like to play old games as much as i like to play new games
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video Q1nT25-p-AU BoardGameGeek Discussion at 33:08 sentiment: positive
BoardGameGeek - Spirit Island video thumbnail
Click to watch at 33:08 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • good system
  • great generative challenge
  • strategic
  • emotional experience
  • enjoy the theme
Cons
  • heavier to learn
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Cooperative Game — A cooperative game that can be played solo.
  • Spirit powers — Players control spirits with unique powers.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • "It's just great to get with people and move some meeples around, play some cards, put some tiles down, and just be present."
  • "I think that we all can make the board game community around us better, right?"
  • "Everyone's journey is different, right?"
  • "I can take some hits for you."
  • "You can literally give each other help. Or you can give them health, or you can give them supplies, just like in Pandemic, you can trade cards."
  • "I would rather work with someone than against them."
  • "Cooperative games have the ability to tell great stories, but sometimes you need to assert your dominance."
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video m7-YC4No_Sg Board Game Critique Top List at 12:56 sentiment: positive
Board Game Critique - Spirit Island video thumbnail
Click to watch at 12:56 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Playing solo highlights the specificity of your powers.
  • The invaders follow a schedule, acting like a machine to be broken.
  • The island does not need another person to be a problem.
Cons
  • Playing solo means feeling the hole in your kit.
  • The island is still ugly even when the invaders leave.
Thematic elements
  • Spirits defending an island from colonizing invaders
  • An island being colonized
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Area Control — Presence on the map, invaders exploring, building, ravaging.
  • Asymmetric powers — Each spirit grows in its own way, with unique energy, card plays, and presence on the map.
  • Card Play — Using a hand of powers.
  • Threat Escalation — Invaders explore, build, ravage. Towns become cities. Blight shows up. Fear is its own track.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • If there is a group, I am at the group. Solo is what I do when nobody can come over or when I borrowed a box and I just need to see if the thing actually works.
  • When it is just me, does this still feel like a game or does it feel like homework I am doing until my friends show up?
  • I like that it does not reset its brain every time you open the box. The dream remembers you.
  • I like how fast the threat is. There is no 20 minute setup tax before you feel the problem.
  • This one wants the gap between dinner and whatever you were going to watch, and it still has a real puzzle in it.
  • Almost no luck. You are not hoping a die saves you. You are staring at a puzzle that will happily let you ruin yourself in slow motion.
  • It is a silent argument with a system.
  • Honest and exhausting.
  • I like the no shuffle thing more than I expected. It makes the market feel like a real choice instead of a lottery ticket.
  • Most deck builders wash the sink after every hand. This one leaves the dishes out and makes you live with the pile.
  • If you have been winning, it gets meaner. If you have been drowning, it gets a little kinder.
  • It is allowed to beat you and still want you back tomorrow.
  • Borrowing a campaign is less scary when it can forget you.
  • This one makes your favorite thing leave the room.
  • It still feels like a big modern euro when nobody else is there.
  • This one sat different in my chest.
  • Winning does not feel cool. You are not a hero. You are trying to keep three tired people from breaking.
  • The stories are the thing.
  • It gives you a kettle and a neighbor and a choice you will think about while you put the bits away.
  • Not a cute spirit, a slow, angry piece of the island with a hand of powers.
  • The invaders have a schedule. They are not a dungeon. They are a machine and you are trying to break the machine before it paves the beach.
  • The board game had every reason to be a lazy cash grab and it is not.
  • It still feels like that stingy, greedy climb, not a board game wearing a hoodie with a video game logo on it.
  • I needed the table version to have teeth.
  • The horror is not only out there, you brought some of it with you.
  • This one lets last Tuesday follow you into this Tuesday, which is either delicious or rude, depending how the last scenario went.
  • The box you borrowed is a core. The hobby around it is a second job.
  • I like how loud it is for a game with nobody else at the table.
  • It does not feel like a spreadsheet.
  • It is the opposite of a quiet euro puzzle.
  • Too many bones, which is the correct amount of bones.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video 7cEWZa9yTL0 Board Game Sanctuary Analysis at 22:47 sentiment: positive
Board Game Sanctuary - Spirit Island video thumbnail
Click to watch at 22:47 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
Positive
Pros
none
Cons
none
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • I had a really interesting thought I thought what if I rated my entire board game collection by sight
  • 4 out of four would be like a really fantastic game that really does well in what it sets out to do
  • Empires of the Void still yet to dive into that probably a 2 out of four for me at this point
  • um not much of a fan of agricola unfortunately
  • forcing myself to do that was probably therapeutic in itself
  • it kind of made me my mind think okay really love these are my top t one games and these games are kind of like on the CP for
  • I do all of this uh on the lowest of budgets
  • it's just purely out of passion that I do this and it brings me so much enjoyment
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video QAMSgIW5BUk Board Games UnLocked Top List at 37:33 sentiment: positive
Board Games UnLocked - Spirit Island video thumbnail
Click to watch at 37:33 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Genius mechanics
  • Great art
  • Good cooperation
  • High replayability
Cons
  • Too dense and complex for the reviewer's solo play preference
  • Never hits the table often
  • Board art is basic and can muddy iconography
Thematic elements
  • Spirits defending an island from invaders
  • Players tell stories through their spirit's actions and combinations.
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Area Control — Spirits push back invaders from the island.
  • Asymmetric powers — Each spirit has unique abilities and playstyles.
  • Cooperative — Players work together against the game system.
  • Deck Building — Spirits gain new power cards to add to their deck.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • man every single time i have played this game like and i've always played it as the 4v4
  • The real-time aspect of the game just is so atmospheric and and a blast to play
  • The reason why i don't own this you need eight people
  • six to eight people never happening i i will never have six to eight people where this is the game that i would pick
  • it is my favorite game on this list okay um but i will never own it because it would be very very sad playing this game solo because nobody else would ever play it with me
  • so unlike let's say you talked about um oh the space alert oh yes like that's like 10 minutes of intense like real time stuff that you're going this is two minutes okay let's sit down and figure out what's going on now
  • if i had to pick my favorite off of this list probably would be hadrian's wall
  • this game's extremely solid like i actually just played it not too long ago and had a blast
  • surprisingly not um as bloated as simon usually goes
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video NfpJquPivEI JestaThaRogue Top List at 0:29 sentiment: positive
JestaThaRogue - Spirit Island video thumbnail
Click to watch at 0:29 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
Positive
Pros
  • Deeply strategic and challenging
  • Highly asymmetric spirit powers
  • Satisfying cooperative puzzle
  • Strong thematic integration
Cons
  • Steep learning curve
  • Can be overwhelming
  • Analysis paralysis potential
Thematic elements
  • Asymmetric Spirits vs. Invaders
  • Island
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Area Control — Spirits aim to control sections of the island and push back invaders.
  • Asymmetric powers — Each spirit has a unique set of powers and a distinct playstyle.
  • Card Play — Players play power cards to affect the board and defeat invaders.
  • cooperative play — Players work together as spirits against an automated invader force.
  • Hand Management — Managing the hand of cards and when to play them is crucial.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Brass Birmingham, a truly monumental game, a 9.5 out of 10, coming in at number three on my list.
  • Spirit Island, 9.4 out of 10, number four.
  • If you want a deep, strategic, cooperative game, this is it.
  • Nemesis, number five, a 9.3 out of 10.
  • Concordia, a 9.3 out of 10, number six.
  • The card play is so elegant.
  • Terraforming Mars, 9.2 out of 10, number seven.
  • It's just a really satisfying engine builder.
  • Hadrian's Wall, a 9.1 out of 10, number eight.
  • Ark Nova, number nine, 9.1 out of 10.
  • Gloomhaven, number 10, a 9 out of 10.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video NfpJquPivEI JestaThaRogue Top List at 0:37 sentiment: positive
JestaThaRogue - Spirit Island video thumbnail
Click to watch at 0:37 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Deeply strategic and rewarding cooperative experience
  • High replayability due to unique spirits and variable setup
  • Strong thematic integration
  • Challenging puzzle-like gameplay
Cons
  • Can be very complex and have a steep learning curve
  • Analysis paralysis can be an issue
Thematic elements
  • Cooperative, nature spirits fighting off invaders
  • Fantasy island, defending against colonizers
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Area Control — Spirits aim to control or defend areas of the island.
  • cooperative play — Players work together against the game system.
  • Deck Building — Players add cards to their deck as the game progresses.
  • Hand Management — Managing spirit powers and growth cards.
  • Modular Board — The island is composed of modular tiles.
  • Variable player powers — Each spirit has unique abilities.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Brass Birmingham, a truly monumental game, a 9.5 out of 10, coming in at number three on my list.
  • Spirit Island, 9.4 out of 10, number four.
  • If you want a deep, strategic, cooperative game, this is it.
  • Nemesis, number five, a 9.3 out of 10.
  • Concordia, a 9.3 out of 10, number six.
  • The card play is so elegant.
  • Terraforming Mars, 9.2 out of 10, number seven.
  • It's just a really satisfying engine builder.
  • Hadrian's Wall, a 9.1 out of 10, number eight.
  • Ark Nova, number nine, 9.1 out of 10.
  • Gloomhaven, number 10, a 9 out of 10.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video 0zG2hh71XQo Board Games UnLocked Top List at 1:11:56 sentiment: positive
Board Games UnLocked - Spirit Island video thumbnail
Click to watch at 1:11:56 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
Highly Positive
Pros
  • Excellent cooperative strategy game
  • Strong thematic integration
  • High replayability with many spirits and expansions
  • Satisfying player synergy and coordination
  • Clear and understandable iconography once learned
Cons
  • Can be heavy with rules and requires significant learning.
  • Rulebook consultation is frequent for new players.
  • Not ideal for solo play for one host.
  • Art is functional rather than visually stunning.
Thematic elements
  • Nature spirits defending an island from colonizers
  • Fantasy island
Comparison games
  • Horizons of Spirit Island
  • Gloomhaven
  • Jaws of the Lion
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • action selection — Abilities are categorized as 'fast' (before invaders) or 'slow' (after invaders).
  • Area Control — Spirits aim to remove invaders from the island.
  • cooperative play — Players work together against the game system.
  • Hand Management — Players manage cards representing spirit abilities.
  • threat management — Players must deal with the invaders' actions of ravaging, building, and exploring.
  • Variable player powers — Each spirit has unique abilities and playstyles.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • the Tea Ceremony where it's built around negotiation
  • I'll give you 10 gold to break your alliance with him and I'm like deal
  • to say there's no negotiation is that's that's a group problem not a game problem
  • this game does have literally an action you can use to betray someone but what's really cool is one you know that that's available and so there are actions you can take to like make it to where that's not the possibility but even if you are betrayed your game's not over
  • this one's just so much better you know that from the art to the smoothness of play
  • it's not as clunky
  • this is one of the ones I know it's been done before but in my mind this is kind of the best of the whole deck building worker placement uh deal
  • the people who hate on it it just feels like well you hate it you hate it because the internet told you to hate it
  • it's very frustrating when it's like I just need to go to one space to do literally anything and I'm going last so I'm not going to get to do anything right I don't like that that type of gameplay
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video mwCE87vwq88 Board Games UnLocked Top List at 7:48 sentiment: positive
Board Games UnLocked - Spirit Island video thumbnail
Click to watch at 7:48 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Deep cooperative play
  • Thematic storytelling
  • Favorite cooperative game
  • Difficulty level printed on box
Cons
  • Hard to get to the table
  • A lot to take in
  • Complex
  • Hard
Thematic elements
  • cooperative spirits defending against settlers
  • an island
  • storytelling through gameplay
Comparison games
  • Settlers of Catan
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Area Control — Spirits defend the island from settlers.
  • cooperative play — Players work together against the game system.
  • Hand Management — Players manage cards representing spirit powers.
  • Variable player powers — Each spirit has unique abilities and powers.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • but that is escape plan Bitola sorry this escape plan
  • this game is just super [cool]
  • this was actually the very first vidalus rd game I ever played
  • this is the simplest game now that's not to say that it's like oh Gateway know his games really have like the mechanics and everything is easy to understand but they all tie in in some somatic mechanic like game mechanics way
  • and the skate plan is about hice your your your your group of like people that were on a heist but then like you hid money throughout and you're trying to escape the city because the cops are on on you
  • This theme is his seems are always so cool and like never touch I don't know another heist a big score is that's kind of like yeah it's a lot it's cooler than nothing like this but his other games are just so awesomely themed
  • escape playing charlot illest if because of how how integrated and how everything just makes sense I don't know how he does it like his name put on anything I'm gonna be like ooh
  • and it's Blood Bowl team manager
  • Fantasy football it's the card version of the actual Blood Bowl the miniatures game that you can play but you are you picking a team you're playing to try to win fans are fans as your victory points
  • So it's kind of a deck building Oh kind of like deck building with it
  • there's been a couple of expansions there's a cheating mechanic every time you cheat you have to draw with these little skulls
  • but um but anyway it's gone it'll probably hover right around here because it's a it's a great game
  • probably if you like football enough right right I just have to go in there with that like kale sounds fun
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video CrsIQJBvOs0 Board Games UnLocked Top List at 42:24 sentiment: positive
Board Games UnLocked - Spirit Island video thumbnail
Click to watch at 42:24 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Works on all levels as a cooperative game.
  • Powers have distinct slow and fast timings that interact with opponent actions.
  • High variety with many spirits and adversaries.
  • Clear iconography aids strategy.
Cons
  • Powers drawn might not synergize thematically with the spirit.
  • Not a 'looker' but functional.
Thematic elements
  • Spirits defending their island from colonizers
  • Island
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • area majority / area influence — Spirits influence different regions of the island.
  • asymmetrical information — Players have different knowledge and abilities based on their spirit.
  • cooperative play — Players work together as spirits to defend the island.
  • Hand Management — Players manage a hand of power cards.
  • Variable player powers — Each spirit has unique abilities and playstyles.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • it has to be probably the best gaming experience
  • the sandbox nature the culmination of everything that he's it feels like he's just led up to this
  • the combat system in this game being a puzzle instead of just rolling you know rolling dice or whatever to see what happens
  • you are given a general direction and whenever you're reading it and you go in that general direction you're kind of like okay well they mentioned the door or like a doorway this kind of looks like a doorway i think that might be it
  • you just keep going and it has a finite end
  • it's a sandbox in a bite-sized chunk to where you can't do everything you cannot see everything
  • this one was easily my number one kickstarter game whenever we were making this list
  • this one is is my favorite i mean just because it's pure pure um ameritrash
  • you choose your characters you um choose what episode you want to play and then you choose what boss i mean so you have a lot of replayability here
  • the obvious complaint with this is the tiles are small
  • what happens in this game is it has that that follow me uh minion mechanic
  • you have to find this balance of leveling up
  • this is one of my favorite things you talk pretty much about everything on it but my favorite thing about is the fact that the characters are unique
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video AtOfFMRUqfw Board Games UnLocked Top List at 46:59 sentiment: positive
Board Games UnLocked - Spirit Island video thumbnail
Click to watch at 46:59 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Innovative and unique
Cons
  • Niche appeal, requires intellect to understand
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Out the artwork that had theme that was a like a mellow euro with with combat
  • It was another game that was actually the first solo game I ever played that I was like man I can do this too it just fires on all cylinders
  • Scythe has been one that was this big grandiose game that was based
  • It was phenomenal and I mean it was just I think with the Kickstarter hype of it that that's kind of what set it apart from from the others
  • My game of the decade also mine was Or Leone's
  • Because of the bag building because I'm really surprised
  • If we did an underrated list they would probably do actually have one roommate
  • Fireteam Zero would have to be on that list
  • 2016 was was such a good year for gaming that every whenever you were talking about yours why'd you pick for it again for 2016
  • Like, it's just like can you stuck can you give us a break give us a shitty game
  • There are stellar games that came out years ago that deserve some love
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video 3dKNv4QhVvA Board Games UnLocked Top List at 1:27:51 sentiment: positive
Board Games UnLocked - Spirit Island video thumbnail
Click to watch at 1:27:51 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
Extremely Positive
Pros
  • Incredibly deep cooperative strategy
  • Highly thematic and unique spirit powers
  • Challenging and rewarding gameplay
  • Excellent artwork for spirits and spells
Cons
  • Components are generally considered poor quality
Thematic elements
  • Nature Spirits vs. Colonizers
  • Island
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Area Control — you're trying to work together to to cause fear
  • Asymmetric powers — every spirit is different all their cards are different
  • Card Drafting — you play you know the two cards one is you do a top villain and bomb ability
  • cooperative play — co-op spirit island is my favorite game
  • Hand Management — some of the cards your spirit powers are one extremely thematic
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • you got the spookiness you got a trailer mechanics when it comes down to it but you don't know who it's gonna be
  • it's a very very solid deck builder and the reason it's so high just because of the sheer strategy that you have to have on it
  • it's dice rolling it's brutal
  • it's 100% nostalgia
  • Gloom Haven is like the epitome of board game RPG
  • the deck mechanic how your character has them deck that has pertains to him
  • the ambiance of having the music going and and the app support
  • spirit island is my number one
  • it just oozes theme
  • it's like playing an RPG only yeah right on the table in front of you
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video Hwm2ydzRQas Rahdo Runs Through Analysis at 36:59 sentiment: positive
Rahdo Runs Through - Spirit Island video thumbnail
Click to watch at 36:59 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
Positive, but strongly prefers two players.
Pros
  • Great interplay between players at two
  • Unique spirits with distinct strengths and weaknesses
  • Engaging puzzle of improving spirits and collaborating
  • Works well solo
Cons
  • Complexity increases significantly with more players
  • Downtime becomes a major issue with three or more players
Thematic elements
  • Spirits of nature protecting an island from invaders
  • Island
Comparison games
  • Horizon Spirit Island
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Area Control — Players focus on controlling or defending areas of the island from invaders.
  • cooperative play — Players work together as spirits to defend the island from invaders.
  • Hand Management — Players manage their spirit's abilities and actions.
  • Simultaneous Play — Players generally perform their actions at the same time, though coordination can lead to pauses.
  • Variable player powers — Each spirit has unique strengths and weaknesses that influence gameplay.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Maybe I'm just stupid.
  • I FIND THIS I THIS UNPLAYABLE BEYOND TWO PLAYERS.
  • This game to me is a couple's game.
  • I find it an absolute nightmare above two players.
  • it goes so long. It's such a long game.
  • So I think there's so much more to discover when you're playing it, too.
  • So, with that and also the time issue for me, I think two is the only way to play it.
  • the same game but longer.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video JrGV9IUwVp0 Board Games UnLocked Top List at 26:58 sentiment: positive
Board Games UnLocked - Spirit Island video thumbnail
Click to watch at 26:58 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
highly positive
Pros
  • One of the best co-op games ever played.
  • Every spirit plays differently, requiring coordination.
  • Strategic element with fast and slow powers.
  • Great rulebook for teaching.
Cons
  • Very hard.
  • The invaders' turn can sometimes negate awesome player actions.
Thematic elements
  • Spirits fighting off invaders
  • Island
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Action timing — Your powers have fast and slow reaction time and the way the turn order works is you all choose your cards and pay energy for them and then you choose and then fast powers activate, then everyone and you do them in any order really you want, then that happens, then the invaders go, then the slow powers go.
  • Asymmetric Player Powers — Every spirit plays different and you need everyone to coordinate well because 'I can do a lot of fear and scare them, but I can't do any damage.'
  • Card Play — You have power cards, you're trying to do to be able to effectively work together.
  • cooperative play — One of the best co-op games I've ever played.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Anachrony is a fantastic or it's my favorite worker placement game I think because oh man it's so great burning I love brain burning games I'm just like I love that like constant you know just my just trying to think of every possible way to be efficient
  • Anachrony is a very very heavy game probably the heaviest games I actually own two to play but it's not one of those games where it's like so how does all this work you know like a fiddly rule book everything just ties in together so smoothly to where what you are is your faction that's trying to not prevent the end of the world but you know what's coming
  • my number 2 is unfair no way I really enjoy that game well I mean it's I've ever had an experience with that game as many times as I've played it bad I like the I like the screw screw you type deal and then take that element
  • my number one was gloom Haven
  • Gloomhaven has that open or kind of half folklore was with giving you a field gloom ham and has the exact same thing
  • I love the way that each scenario has played out so far I love the the fact that you feel powerful from the get-go but also it's just like oh my god so I each scenario has already been different and the story aspect of it feels like if it's D&D the board game and like it really is
  • dinosaur island oh good that came out the country long ago especially especially the deluxe edition
  • it's broken down into four really structured phases so it's easy to teach just teaching a phase at a time
  • so it's Jurassic Park yes those would say but they don't eat the hooligans so well of course these are good at hiding so good they for the other people and writing some you lose patrons you lose a victory point per patron they get sequel
  • it is is definitely the hot one right now everyone is trying to get their copy of dinosaur island
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video K5rXb93AiYk Board Games UnLocked Top List at 4:20
Board Games UnLocked - Spirit Island video thumbnail
Click to watch at 4:20 · YouTube ↗
Pros
none
Cons
none
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • even though was your list depressing
  • my orange is it's the exact same spot green isn't moved up yellow it's a new game and then red it moved down there's a lot of red alumni have a lot of red
  • I used a ranking system online ranking system from pub meatball mmm
  • mine was like 700 like options because I they include everything
  • I felt like my index card system was more accurate
  • the way I do my index card system is I'm like okay here's vindication versus blood rage and I'm blood vindication so that's just a complete example but it's like first blood rage okay I don't like it as much as that boom Albert or okay no and I go down the list I compare the one game to every other game until I find one that I like so I feel like instead of one verse one it's one verse a bunch once
  • I double-checked everything
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video 1ZZtuLlh6XM Board Games UnLocked Top List at 6:28 sentiment: positive
Board Games UnLocked - Spirit Island video thumbnail
Click to watch at 6:28 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Cool theme
  • Spirits play uniquely
  • Mechanics play well to the theme
  • Unique role as defenders
  • Cooperative play where weaknesses are strengths
Cons
none
Thematic elements
  • Players take on the role of island spirits defending the island from colonizers.
  • An island being colonized by Europeans.
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • asymmetric spirits — Each spirit plays very differently, reflecting their unique nature.
  • cooperative play — Players work together as spirits to defend the island.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • it's a more realistic one yeah like than the oh wow it's jason voorhees going after this or this is this badass
  • such a unique theme because it's a it's arthurian legend but it has kind of that dark souls-esque where darkness or what they call weirdness is enveloping the land
  • the art's crazy in this game too
  • the depressing reality to to this game is that like if you're incorporating it into real world circumstances is that we might already it like it has already hit the fan
  • this one's straight cooperative
  • unfortunately realistic type of theme that i actually can can empathize with
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video ScFqdKbarVM Board Games UnLocked Top List at 14:54 sentiment: positive
Board Games UnLocked - Spirit Island video thumbnail
Click to watch at 14:54 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Unique theme and gameplay
  • Makes cooperative nature feel the best
  • Unique powers and abilities
  • Challenging puzzle
  • Cool powers make the game sing
Cons
  • Component quality is 'garbage'
  • Difficult to teach
  • Random level one and two power decks could feel less thematic
  • Can be complicated
Thematic elements
  • Spirits fighting off colonizers
  • An island
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Area Control — Players spread their presence across the island to fight off invaders.
  • Asymmetric powers — Everyone has unique powers and abilities that are integrated in a slow-fast mechanic.
  • cooperative play — A completely unique cooperative game where players play as spirits fighting off invaders.
  • Hand Management — Players use power cards in a cohesive way with their faction's abilities.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Scythe is just like the perfect game for me in all aspects.
  • It's easy to learn but not easy to master.
  • A portal could pop up if you decide to go through the portal, it throws you into these other worlds that they have a ton of different ones.
  • The Rise of Fenris expansion, without spoiling anything, that story was really really cool.
  • This game introduced me more and more or less to bag building.
  • Scythe base game would not be my number one, like right, it probably still be top 10 but not number one but with all three expansions.
  • The player interaction like even though there's hardly any, like it's not a combat war game, but you can become you can be combative, is streamlined and simple.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video D7AagsYY0WM Board Games UnLocked Top List at 54:08 sentiment: positive
Board Games UnLocked - Spirit Island video thumbnail
Click to watch at 54:08 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
Positive
Pros
  • Utilizes teamwork more than any other coop game
  • Unique theme where players are spirits defending the island
  • Amazing artwork on cards and spirits
  • Clear visual representation of board areas
  • Strategic planning is facilitated by predictable enemy actions
  • Scalable complexity with advanced options and expansions
Cons
  • Component quality for the island map is poor
  • Artwork for the island board is not as strong as the cards
Thematic elements
  • Nature spirits defending an island from invaders
  • Fantasy island
  • Thematic descriptions of spirit actions and their impact on invaders.
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Area Control — Players focus on specific areas of the island to defend against invader expansion and presence.
  • Asymmetric powers — Each spirit has unique powers and abilities, with some being more complex than others.
  • Card Drafting — Players play cards representing spirit powers, with some powers having 'fast' and 'slow' triggers that affect the turn order relative to invaders.
  • cooperative play — Players work together to defend the island from invaders, requiring significant teamwork and coordination.
  • threat management — Players manage the threat posed by invaders and their actions, such as building and exploring.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Gloomhaven is a phenomenal game, rightly at number one for BoardGameGeek just because it doesn't have the state like it is it hasn't been out long enough to deserve to be the best game in the [ __ ] in all of time but for me at number two it hits on all cylinders
  • This game has been I think it was number one that might when we did the top ten of all time that first time we did a top ten with that all those other guys yeah it was number one it was number two last year in order to this year
  • SCYTHE is the only game on this entire list that stayed the same
  • I have no complaints with SCYTHE
  • this game is just awesome
  • it's a bag building game you start off with a certain number of deals and you pull them out you'll set them on your deal then everybody at the same time you place them on your board
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video NBdVcQKOoE8 Board Games UnLocked Top List at 1:14:16 sentiment: positive
Board Games UnLocked - Spirit Island video thumbnail
Click to watch at 1:14:16 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
Highly Positive
Pros
  • Considered one of the best cooperative games.
  • Strong and unique theme.
  • Highly customizable difficulty.
  • Vast variety of spirits with unique powers.
  • Excellent cooperative synergy between players.
  • Intense strategic gameplay with visible invader actions.
  • Engaging fear mechanic.
  • Creative and thematic spirit designs.
Cons
  • Complex to manage when playing solo with multiple spirits.
Thematic elements
  • Nature spirits defending against invaders
  • An island being colonized
  • Asymmetric cooperative strategy
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Area Control — Players spread their presence across the island.
  • Asymmetric powers — Each spirit has unique powers, abilities, and ways of leveling up.
  • Card Play — Players use cards representing powers (fast and slow) to take actions.
  • cooperative play — Players work together as spirits to defend the island from invaders.
  • Fear generation — Players generate fear, which can lead to beneficial fear cards and ultimately win the game.
  • Invader deck — An invader deck dictates the actions of the colonizing forces (build, explore, blight).
  • Spirit growth — Spirits can level up and gain access to more powerful minor and major powers.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • this is our top 10 games of all time
  • if our house was on fire we'd probably run in and omit uh wife kids and and pets just to grab these games
  • this one i think is the best overall
  • So Bluehaven supports a masterpiece in in gaming
  • this is my favorite lcg at this point
  • this is by far my favorite arkham horror game
  • Scythe is my number one game of all time
  • it's bag building which is what i love bag building stuff
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video TQlk41PiBr0 Board Games UnLocked Top List sentiment: positive
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Deeply strategic and rewarding
  • Excellent cooperative experience
  • High replayability with different spirits and adversaries
Cons
  • Can be very punishing and difficult
  • Steep learning curve
Thematic elements
  • spirit defense
  • island
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Area Control — Spirits defend the island from invaders spreading across it.
  • cooperative play — Players must work together to defeat the invaders.
  • Hand Management — Players manage a hand of cards representing spirit powers.
  • Variable player powers — Each spirit has unique powers and abilities.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • This segment is 20 through 11, so this is where the cream is.
  • Root at number 15 on our top 100 games of all time list.
  • Spirit Island at number 14.
  • Terraforming Mars at number 13.
  • Gloomhaven at number 12.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video hnaMWA7bQlE Board Stupid Top List at 30:51 sentiment: mixed
Board Stupid - Spirit Island video thumbnail
Click to watch at 30:51 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
Mixed
Pros
  • Unique cooperative experience.
  • High player engagement due to complexity.
Cons
  • Can be too complicated for some players.
  • Potential for players to play cards wrong without others noticing.
Thematic elements
  • Nature Spirits vs. Colonizers
  • Island
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Area Control — Trying to kick out the colonizers.
  • Card Play — Combos and various things and effects.
  • cooperative play — It's a cooperative game.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • At number two, wow.
  • I find the game very bloated
  • I've never really been a fan of Arnova. Shoot me. I don't care.
  • I'm not having enough fun.
  • Brass Birmingham is my favorite game.
  • It is a tremendous game.
  • It is the number one game on BGG.
  • For me, this is 100% st game.
  • It has lots of amazing um interaction.
  • brutal uncompromising unforgiving nature of the game.
  • If you screw up that very much is going to cost you the game.
  • punishing in a good way. In an interesting way, in a stressful way.
  • I absolutely love Brass Birmingham.
  • It's an S tier game.
  • It's top 10 for my taste.
  • It's not the number one,
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video EDnU4Y4NPXg BoardGameBollocks Rules Teach at 0:52 sentiment: mixed
BoardGameBollocks - Spirit Island video thumbnail
Click to watch at 0:52 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
mixed
Pros
  • Asymmetrical spirit abilities offer unique play experiences.
  • Cooperative nature encourages discussion and teamwork.
  • Mechanics are well-integrated with the thematic elements.
Cons
  • High complexity and steep learning curve.
  • Can be difficult to coordinate strategies with multiple players.
  • The game escalates quickly, leading to potential overwhelm.
  • Perceived difficulty can be high, especially for new players.
Thematic elements
  • spirits defending an island from invaders
  • island
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • area influence — Players influence different regions on the island map by placing presence markers.
  • Card Drafting — Players draw power cards (minor and major) and choose which ones to add to their hand.
  • cooperative play — Players work together towards a common goal of defending the island.
  • event cards — Invader cards dictate actions like building, ravaging, and exploring, driving the game's progression.
  • Hand Management — Players draw and play power cards from their hand, managing energy costs and card speeds.
  • Modular Board — The island map is divided into different regions with various terrain types.
  • Resource Management — Players manage energy to play cards and activate abilities.
  • territory building — Invaders build towns and cities on the island, which players must counter.
  • Variable player powers — Each spirit has unique asymmetrical abilities and powers.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • it's just annoying because you've got to wait forever and there's always these exclusives and it's just pain and bomb
  • the kickstarter goes now 100 pounds just for a basic game i swear it's pushing up the price of normal games
  • rather than settling and building you're trying to get those settlers off the island
  • blight is bad
  • the more fear the more you can scare the invaders the easier the game gets
  • the game should be encouraging to be playing cool combos
  • this is really hard to I don't know how you can do this
  • the trouble with this game is you've all got to be really talking to each other but we don't know the game so we don't know what cards to help us out or don't
  • most people play this solo
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video I0FSsYR76rY Board Game Sanctuary Discussion at 24:35 sentiment: positive
Board Game Sanctuary - Spirit Island video thumbnail
Click to watch at 24:35 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
Highly Positive
Pros
  • Beautiful artwork
  • Strategic gameplay
  • Highly variable
  • Lots of replayability with different powers and scenarios
  • Encourages player discussion and coordination
Cons
none
Thematic elements
  • Spirits defending against settlers
  • An island
  • Reverse Catan
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Action Point Allowance — Players use abilities and actions on their turn.
  • Asymmetric powers — Players take on the role of spirits that have their own special deck of cards and special abilities.
  • cooperative play — Players work together to ward off settlers.
  • Variable player powers — Each spirit has unique abilities and play styles.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Quirky Circuits time to plug this game into your nearest outlet because this is a cooperative game that is inspired by the mind
  • So if you ever played The Mind where you're playing cards out in numerical order but you can't actually talk this game does it but it does it in terms of a programming level
  • The Quacks of Quedlinburg basically you are going to be drawing little elements out of the bag then you're going to be trying to avoid triggering an explosion buying other elements and putting them in your bag so that in the following round you can gain more points move along the track a little bit further
  • So it is a bag building game so just like in a deck building game where you decide what cards go in your deck as you play through them this is all about putting chips in a bag drawing them out it's almost like lottery except each time you're pulling something out you've decided what has gone in the bag so you know that in your bag you have a certain composition of different colors and different elements
  • I create these videos all on my own script them edit them write the music etc and it would mean the world to me if more people could really access just how wonderful board games truly are
  • Goodbye now it's time to bust out Curious Cargo
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video QwDQ9HbUhws Board Games UnLocked Other at 17:27 sentiment: positive
Board Games UnLocked - Spirit Island video thumbnail
Click to watch at 17:27 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Neat tutorial system for Spirit Island.
  • Compatible with existing Spirit Island components.
  • Improved board layout.
Cons
none
Thematic elements
  • Spirit Island
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Cooperative — A cooperative game, similar to Spirit Island.
  • Spirit Play — Adds five new spirits to play.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • this is meadow downstream this is a must-have because i think meadow is a beautifully gorgeous game
  • meadow is just whoever the artist is this artist right here that's only done meadow is so good
  • this is a must-have it's ryan lockett although this looks completely i mean i know all of his games are supposed to take place in the same universe
  • this is supposed to be a boss battler like kdm vagrant song but narrative driven
  • i absolutely love narrative driven campaign style games and if you can have any like innovative and involved boss fights then i am totally down
  • this one by smirk and dagger behext i believe i backed this on kickstarter
  • i love dueling magicians i love dueling wizards or sorcerers or anything like that i love deck builders i love deck constructors
  • despise the name of this game australia is the dumbest [ __ ] title for a game that i can think of because it's a capital z and it immediately makes you think zombies but it's about cthulhu
  • but i've heard the base game is actually really good it's surprisingly good
  • this one i grabbed just because it looks pretty cool
  • it does look like a video game that art it looks like clash of clans a little bit
  • then actually played timpani parks the other day and it was really good
  • vincent de trait he's one of those artists i couldn't i couldn't get over the art in this game
  • timpani parks is a really awesome unique polyamino game which i like i just said is i love polyamino games and this had a very interesting twist to that that was just enough
  • so those are the games that i am excited for uh for gen con 20 22
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video 06n1swGih3I Board Games UnLocked Top List at 1:22:48 sentiment: positive
Board Games UnLocked - Spirit Island video thumbnail
Click to watch at 1:22:48 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
Positive
Pros
  • Deeply strategic and complex gameplay
  • Unique theme with players as nature spirits
  • High synergy between unique player spirits
  • Adjustable difficulty
  • Great replayability
Cons
  • High complexity can be a barrier to entry.
  • Artwork style is unconventional and may not appeal to all.
  • Can be overwhelming in solo play.
  • Winning is very difficult.
Thematic elements
  • Nature spirits defending an island from colonizers
  • Island
  • Asymmetrical
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Area Control — The settlers inhabit specific regions so it's just easier to be able to immediately see what they're doing.
  • asymmetrical powers — Everyone is playing as a unique spirit that has a unique way to play special abilities and unique powers.
  • Card Play — Players use cards representing powers and abilities.
  • cooperative play — This is my favorite cooperative game.
  • Threat Generation — Your whole goal is to generate fear.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • This is the perfect entry point into the big Gloomhaven slash Frosthaven when it comes to.
  • This tutorial is easily the best in any game.
  • There's so many options and avenues to victory which is a huge thing for me whenever I want to play games.
  • This one does not have that. There's multiple ways to get victory points, multiple ways to build your civilization.
  • It's a cooperative game but I'm making it my solo pick.
  • This one has an easy point of entry. I mean, you can just buy what you want and play.
  • This is still kind of gateway, a little higher than that.
  • Cooperative games lend itself to be more inviting than competitive, but that's just me.
  • My number one essential game: Pandemic.
  • This was kind of the in my mind because I know there were some before this, but this was kind of the card drafting game that really got that mechanic going.
  • The ebb and flow of how this game works, of the roller coaster kind of feel, just works so well.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video agxBHNzbDeo Board Games UnLocked Top List at 8:14 sentiment: positive
Board Games UnLocked - Spirit Island video thumbnail
Click to watch at 8:14 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Each spirit plays differently, which is amazing.
  • Requires significant synergy between players.
  • Everyone contributes, and no one can be everywhere.
  • Horizons of Spirit Island is a great jumping-off point for new players.
Cons
  • High learning curve for spirits and their synergies.
  • Can be a hindrance if players don't understand their spirit.
  • A heavier cooperative game that requires a lot of understanding.
Thematic elements
  • Cooperative nature defense
Comparison games
  • Root
  • Horizons of Spirit Island
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Area Control — Players defend against invaders.
  • Asymmetric Player Powers — Players control spirits with distinct abilities and playstyles.
  • Cooperative — A cooperative game where players work together.
  • Hand Management — Managing cards and powers is crucial.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • It's like they're in our top 10 for a reason. And it's hard to find flaw type things for them, but I was able to make it make it work.
  • We are doing the flaws with our top 10 games of all time.
  • It seems to be most people's issue if they have an issue with this is just that that aspect.
  • So, the boss fights, which you do a fair amount of in this, can be completely can be very, very swingy.
  • The game is insanely expensive.
  • And my my flaw is probably the most common talked about flaw with this game, and that is just the the steep learning curve of each character.
  • Chip Theory kills it with their social media.
  • They really streamlined a lot of fiddliness from Too Many Bones in with Elder Scrolls.
  • It's like, man, you guys came a long way.
  • I think a lot of people the reason why I wanted to do this one was there are so many people out there that just are in denial or have buyer remorse or whatever it might be that they just like no my game these games are perfect.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video ARjKWqgdXGM Board Games UnLocked Top List at 52:34 sentiment: positive
Board Games UnLocked - Spirit Island video thumbnail
Click to watch at 52:34 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
Very Positive
Pros
  • Deeply thematic
  • Highly asymmetric spirits
  • Excellent cooperative experience
  • High modularity with invaders and scenarios
  • Fast and slow power system creates interesting turns
Cons
  • Heavy and complex
  • Not as engaging for solo play for one of the hosts
Thematic elements
  • Nature spirits defending their island from colonizers
  • An island being invaded
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Area Control — Spirits try to control or reclaim parts of the island from invaders.
  • Card Drafting — Players acquire new power cards to add to their hand.
  • cooperative play — Players work together against the game's mechanics.
  • Hand Management — Players manage a hand of power cards to use for their spirit.
  • Variable player powers — Each spirit has unique abilities and playstyles.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Black Rose Wars was uh is kind of like my favorite dueling Mages game like that there's not a lot of I mean there are a lot of games about you know out that do that theme but black rose Wars I think does it best with just the magic picking different schools of magic to fight against other Mages who are picking different schools of magic
  • it has so much content it's by a company that does they do a good job like they're not like dog like Mythic games but they're not at the top like some others uh but they you know they they make they make games with a ton of content
  • Black Rose Wars Duel is hot poop
  • if you're looking for an awesome super fun dueling Mages game I highly recommend Black Rose Wars
  • this one is so much prettier looking
  • just the better game in my opinion I know a lot of people don't agree but um the options that this gives you especially when the expansions came out giving you the the extra um adventures and the extra um research tracks and all that stuff is has been those are really smart to get those out because that was one of the complaints the base box was that the the research track was you know deterministic pretty well but they right they uh adding the new stuff with that been really cool
  • this is one of those hybrid games um it's a worker placement deck builder um and you also it kind of gives me that that feeling that you get a little bit in everell where you only have you know two workers and you have to maximize what you what you do you know it's like you can get a lot done but you have to play it right or you could kind of screw yourself out and and stuff
  • the components are nice you know all the the the chits and the arrowheads and the tablets and all that stuff are really cool
  • the deck building aspects really neat because you're using it for different travel purposes as well you can use them for that to get you your adventurers to different locations
  • the solo of this is really nice
  • I just like this one a lot and yet both expansions are are super super good
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video tABQltbzzz4 Stonemaier Games Top List at 0:34 sentiment: positive
Stonemaier Games - Spirit Island video thumbnail
Click to watch at 0:34 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
none
Cons
none
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • These are the games that you have played recently that you are the most excited to play again and this is entirely based on your votes and your nominations.
  • Castles of Burgundy, which has been at number one for a long time now, dropped down to number two.
  • At number one, we have Ark Nova.
  • I really like that organic nature of the uh the non- rigid round structure and the end of the game in Arc Nova.
  • Cascadia number three, harmonies, number two, and Forest Shuffle at number one.
  • Scythe retains its spot at number one.
  • Well, that's it for this month. I hope you uh I appreciate if you voted on last month. And if you want to take a look at this month's poll, it's a quick survey.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video mPRcsbqdNGs Stonemaier Games Top List at 4:28
Stonemaier Games - Spirit Island video thumbnail
Click to watch at 4:28 · YouTube ↗
Pros
none
Cons
none
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • What amazes me about this that it keeps showing up is that if people are responding to the survey honestly, it means that they are playing Castles of Burgundy in the recent past, in the last few weeks, and they still anticipate or are very excited to play it again.
  • I really like that there is a gap between gaining tiles and placing tiles.
  • I think that gap is really helpful in this game because you when you gain a tile, you may not always be ready to place it. It gives you a little bit of time to evaluate exactly where you want to place it or where is the best place to put that tile.
  • So, I really like that when you gain tiles, they kind of go off to the side for a little bit and then you get to place them later on your board.
  • I think that's a a really neat and especially since the game uses the randomness of dice to to determine which tiles you could select and where you can place those tiles.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video HAhm8EmTLc8 Board Game Critique Top List at 7:19 sentiment: positive
Board Game Critique - Spirit Island video thumbnail
Click to watch at 7:19 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Spirits have completely unique approaches
  • Cooperation against invaders
  • One spirit grows slow then hits hard
  • Another is fast disruption and fear
Cons
none
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • asymmetry — The way each spirit approaches the problem is completely unique.
  • Variable player powers — The spirits themselves. One spirit grows slowly and then hits like a truck in the late game. Another is all about fast disruption and fear.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • This was honestly one of the hardest videos I've ever had to make. I mean that.
  • I love so many of these mechanics so deeply that trying to rank them felt almost unfair.
  • The top five especially are ridiculously close. I rearranged them like five different times before settling on this order.
  • It's the mechanic that makes me think about the game for days afterward.
  • That's my personal top 10 right now. The order could easily shift next month, especially that top five. But this is where my head is at today.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video bwVE3c9h5M4 Board Games UnLocked Top List at 24:07 sentiment: positive
Board Games UnLocked - Spirit Island video thumbnail
Click to watch at 24:07 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Excellent cooperative gameplay
  • High replayability due to unique spirits
  • Strong thematic integration
  • Strategic depth
Cons
  • Component quality for invaders and buildings could be better
  • Power cards are not spirit-specific, wish they were
  • Solo play can be challenging with two spirits
  • Travel between locations can be slow
Thematic elements
  • spirits defending against colonizers
  • Island
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Area Control — Spirits defend different areas of the island from invaders.
  • Asymmetric powers — Each spirit has unique abilities and starting decks.
  • cooperative play — Players work together as spirits to fight off invaders.
  • Hand Management — Players manage a deck of power cards for their spirit.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • um I love worker placement youve played this because you borrowed it
  • this is actually what people call like granddaddy Stone AG uh worker placement game
  • Imperial settlers is a phenomenal uh would you call this a SI building game I would yeah yeah so a phenomenal Sil building game
  • it's just a lot more streamlined of version of the big thieves game
  • Alchemist is a phenomenal game one of the first games I played that had an app
  • it's just so much fun
  • this theme is fantastic it will most likely be higher on your list
  • the worst thing about this game is their dumbass Health VA V and power trackers
  • if you want a game that is like D and D without the DM at this point this is probably your closest game
  • I hate that game I hate it I hate it so much
  • God I was seething like I was actually I was very mad throughout that whole game
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video NQ8DC3VuICw Board Games UnLocked Top List at 14:33 sentiment: positive
Board Games UnLocked - Spirit Island video thumbnail
Click to watch at 14:33 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Unique theme and gameplay.
  • Highly differentiated spirits.
  • Requires deep cooperation and strategy.
  • Tons of content available.
  • Nails the cooperative aspect.
Cons
  • Not the most intuitive game to hop into.
  • Not the most pretty game in the world.
Thematic elements
  • Spirits defending an island from invaders.
  • An island being defended by spirits.
  • Action cards represent spirit abilities and actions.
Comparison games
  • Horizons on Spirit Island
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Area Control/Defense — Spirits defend the island from invaders trying to build and explore.
  • Asymmetric Player Powers — Every spirit plays differently with unique abilities and starting actions.
  • Card Play — Uses action cards, with fast and slow cards that trigger at different times.
  • cooperative play — A cooperative game where players work together to defend the island.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • It's Elder Scrolls in a box. It is everything about that universe
  • My entire character's build has no magic, has no melee, has no armor. He could only talk.
  • Every combat always feels like a puzzle.
  • Easily Chip Theory's best game in my opinion.
  • This to me is what I I think other campaign games should achieve to be
  • The writing of this game is easily the best. In my opinion, it's the best in the industry for campaign games.
  • I think it does the combat way better.
  • It has been consistently my number one game since it came out.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video hVVP3uqEbXg The Dungeon Dive Top List at 2:27 sentiment: positive
The Dungeon Dive - Spirit Island video thumbnail
Click to watch at 2:27 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • very strategic
  • very complex
  • unique theme
  • cooperative
Cons
  • can be frustrating
Thematic elements
  • nature spirits defending against colonizers
  • island
  • emergent narrative
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Area Control — controlling regions on the board
  • cooperative play — players win or lose together
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
No quotes stored for this video.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video 4B3lgwpAAVM Sir Thecos Top List at 3:54 sentiment: positive
Sir Thecos - Spirit Island video thumbnail
Click to watch at 3:54 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • One of the best cooperative games ever
  • Amazing theme
  • Amazing gameplay
  • Always fun
  • Great game
Cons
  • A lot of text (on physical German version)
Thematic elements
  • Amazing theme
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • cooperative play — Highlighted as one of the best cooperative games.
  • Events — Events are mentioned as a feature that enhances the fun.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • This is just my opinion. Your opinion may very well differ and if it does, great.
  • Bullet, it's one of the best games in my in my in my collection.
  • it's such an amazing game and that I haven't shown it off on the channel yet is a crime.
  • Both really amazing hidden movement games.
  • this game does everything I want in a farming game.
  • This is a game I'm currently reviewing, so I don't really like to rank that before yet.
  • This is a deduction game where you try to guess like the five numbers that are on your board like in your in a row.
  • Really weird. It's like a card placement game where you like build like a tableau like a weird manor and if you manage to fulfill specific conditions, then you can play review cards in there that's like extra guests that give you points, and it's like really weird. But I like it.
  • man, this is good.
  • This is a very cute game of you just turning over card, like drawing cards, and trying to have like a you you put like groups of the same animal uh together here, and if you have like the same number of cards for one animal, the opponent does, then you can like switch both groups.
  • Wow. Uh this is amazing.
  • This by Tim Fowers, who also did the Burgle Bros series, and this is a really good two-player game.
  • Descent always gets an A for me.
  • it does a few things like really well, but there are also a few things holding it back, so that's why it's only an A and not an S.
  • Want to play a simpler version of Wingspan that feels still feels like the game, it only plays in half an half an hour? This is it.
  • It is so luck-based.
  • I'm really conflicted here. I like this game.
  • Oh man, I'm so conflicted here.
  • I really like the idea of Doomtown. I like what it tries to do. I like the theme.
  • Tomb Raider is clear as rank, very clear as rank.
  • This is such a good game.
  • These are all the games that I played. Not as many as as some as in some other months, but like there were like some a lot of time intensive games here.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video Pij2wDf270c Board Game Sanctuary Analysis at 6:47 sentiment: positive
Board Game Sanctuary - Spirit Island video thumbnail
Click to watch at 6:47 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Retains the heart of the original game.
  • Makes the game accessible to families and casual gamers.
  • Makes sense to make a light edition for those who want a taste or sample of the game.
Cons
  • Watered down so much that it doesn't feel like a game anymore.
  • Rarely would someone own the original game as well as a light version.
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Rule simplification — Rules and map setup were simplified for a broader audience.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • then spawned uh Curious cargo a two-player Style game which also involved transporting fulfilling Goods VI pipes and then Trailblazers which is basically a route building game that kind of has the same kind of configuration as pipeline but instead you're kind of circuiting trails looping them around as much as you can
  • what do you think of reimplemented and spin-off versions of some of your favorite games do you think it's a little bit of a crh grab or do you think it has a place in our board gaming Hobbies as well as our board game collections
  • Please let me know your thoughts share your opinions your stories and your experiences in the comment section below this is a safe space to chat and I'd love to start a conversation with you
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video Mtz386BxJ_c JestaThaRogue Analysis at 2:09 sentiment: neutral
JestaThaRogue - Spirit Island video thumbnail
Click to watch at 2:09 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
neutral
Pros
none
Cons
none
Thematic elements
  • spirit themed
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • 81% of the top 100 does not line up with the community opinion.
  • Almost every game on the most respected board game ranking in the world asterisk has a gap between what the box says and what thousands of players actually think.
  • The box time is more accurate than the player count, but it assumes you know what you're doing.
  • First play is almost always longer than the box suggests.
  • The box minimum time appears to be collaborating for two players, not solo.
  • The box time, were accurate at all, is based on experienced players playing with the optimum player count.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video Zvu2uGZteIs Board Game Critique Top List at 2:56 sentiment: positive
Board Game Critique - Spirit Island video thumbnail
Click to watch at 2:56 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Maintains meaningful collaboration and tension
  • Delivers shared problem-solving and coordination
  • Strategically deep
  • Table comes alive with discussion and joint planning
  • Everyone stays alive and engaged during play
Cons
none
Thematic elements
  • ancient island spirits defending home from colonizing invaders
  • ancient island home
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • area influence
  • Asymmetric powers — Each spirit has completely unique powers and growth paths.
  • Cooperative — Players work together to defend their island from invaders.
  • Engine Building — Player abilities become more powerful each round.
  • Escalating difficulty
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • We built this list around what we both value most at the table. High player interaction, meaningful decisions that affect others, tension that builds through negotiation or coordination, and experiences that create stories worth retelling long after the game ends.
  • We don't chase pure optimization or solo puzzle solving as much as we once did. We want games where the people around us matter.
  • Root is one of the most unique and brilliant designs in modern board gaming for us.
  • Blood on the Clock Tower is a social deduction game set in a foggy English village plagued by evil forces.
  • It earns the number one spot on our list because it generates the highest level of interaction and memorable moments of any game we play.
  • For us, who value high interaction social gaming above almost everything else, this is the pinnacle.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video X1a5KUD-V2U Stonemaier Games Top List at 4:15
Stonemaier Games - Spirit Island video thumbnail
Click to watch at 4:15 · YouTube ↗
Pros
none
Cons
none
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Castles of Burgundy again, number one.
  • Hats off to how replayable this game is.
  • People keep coming back to it and declaring it their number one game that they've played, that they also want to play again.
  • I really appreciate... the vast variety of um of buildings that you can place in your tableau.
  • The game has a lot of replayability replayability built into it from the dice, the different tiles, to the different asymmetric mats, but also a big part of the replayability comes from the order in which the buildings uh become available on the board, and each building does something different.
  • They feel really good to get into your into your display. They they make the game feel different from time to time and depending on when you get these tiles, that can also make the game feel different.
  • It's just a little bit tough if you come back to the game after not playing it for a while.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video Mtz386BxJ_c JestaThaRogue Analysis at 13:45 sentiment: neutral
JestaThaRogue - Spirit Island video thumbnail
Click to watch at 13:45 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
neutral
Pros
none
Cons
none
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Mechanics unknown.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • 81% of the top 100 does not line up with the community opinion.
  • Almost every game on the most respected board game ranking in the world asterisk has a gap between what the box says and what thousands of players actually think.
  • The box time is more accurate than the player count, but it assumes you know what you're doing.
  • First play is almost always longer than the box suggests.
  • The box minimum time appears to be collaborating for two players, not solo.
  • The box time, were accurate at all, is based on experienced players playing with the optimum player count.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video BYXv4owfEGs BoardGameGeek Discussion at 37:31 sentiment: positive
BoardGameGeek - Spirit Island video thumbnail
Click to watch at 37:31 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Great game with an appealing theme.
  • Challenging and rewarding gameplay.
  • Works well solo.
  • The spirits have cute mushroom-like tokens.
Cons
  • Can be difficult to learn from the rulebook.
  • Alpha gamer syndrome can be an issue in cooperative games.
Thematic elements
  • Spirits defending their island from colonizers
  • Spirit Island
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Area Control — Spirits control areas of the island against invaders.
  • Asymmetric Player Powers — Each spirit has unique abilities and playstyles.
  • Card Play — Players play cards to activate spirit abilities.
  • cooperative play — Players work together against the game.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • I have been to over 30 BGG events between the spring and the fall convention and some some of the cruises.
  • So, there are many many many years that we did not get to play any games at all.
  • You know, I start 6 weeks early and I'm sending out weekly emails with a little bit of information in each email so that I'm not overwhelming them with all of it at once, but they get a weekly email that they need to read and review.
  • So, when you're dealing with large team of volunteers, we have some set things that you have to have done. You have to have been to the convention before cuz we want you to see we want to know that you understand the culture before that you jump into this.
  • We have anywhere from 8,500 to 9,000 titles at any given time at 60 rolling shelves.
  • So, when you're dealing with volunteers, we try to give them the end goal
  • Again, just that whole all the different mechanisms coming to together and the cards, you know, you you sit down and you you're terraforming Mars or making it habitable.
  • Every time it's something new and different. You don't go in with a strategy of I always do the plants or I always do the volcano, whatever. You you just you have to figure it out based on the cards that are in front of you. So, it keeps it new and fresh.
  • It's it's like I said, you know, it's it's for me it's one that has a lot of replayability which again, I don't get to do very often, but when I find one that I really like that I can play again and again and it's a little bit different each time. I enjoy that.
  • This one is definitely one of those games where you are comboing.
  • It's one of those classic Euros that's really fun to do, but it has that extra theme of it.
  • Everyone raves about Season 1 and really I think this game is the one that really pushed a lot of legacy games afterwards. So, it really kind of kicked off the great legacy series that we have now.
  • My funny story in all of this, which is my positive thing, is that people that I met at BGG over the years, we became close enough friends with them that 4 years ago my husband and I left Oklahoma, which I had lived in in almost my entire life, and moved to Colorado and now live in Colorado Springs and get to game with people that we met through the board gaming community and continue to expand the number of people that we know up here in the board gaming community.
  • And as y'all know, I am part of the OFPG Voices team. And so, it was They put on a great first con. I think it's I've only been to a couple of them, but they they did a absolutely wonderful job.
  • Yeah, people are like saying, "Wait, it's already sold out?"
  • As somebody who spends a lot of nights in hotel beds, you cannot underestimate a good hotel bed.
  • Yeah, it was absolutely amazing and it was really great to talk to and meet people. It's just It was 200 people so it was small enough that you can meet someone and play games with them and kind of work the con too because I helped teach Layers from KTBG in the mornings and then I got to play games with both my friends and the new people that came up to me be like, "We enjoy the BGG podcast."
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video BVYvXIkyRoY Top List sentiment: positive
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Deeply strategic and thoughtful gameplay.
  • Unique and engaging theme.
  • High replayability due to asymmetric spirits.
Cons
  • Can be very complex and challenging.
  • High learning curve.
Thematic elements
  • nature spirits defending against colonizers
  • island
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Area management — Darien describes 'defending your island from the invaders.'
  • Asymmetric powers — Caleb mentions 'each of the spirits has a very different feel, a different power set.'
  • Card Play — Caleb states 'you're playing cards to utilize your spirit powers.'
  • cooperative play — Darien explains 'It's a cooperative game, so you're playing against the game.'
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • It's so tense. It's so tense that it's like, oh, my gosh, it's gonna be a problem.
  • I thought the final moments of this game were absolutely amazing.
  • an epic, epic game.
  • If you love Lord of the Rings, this is the game for you.
  • a very complex game.
  • It's a tough game to win.
  • an engine builder.
  • It feels really good when you start seeing your engine come together and you're just producing tons of resources.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video fskNbkHhdo0 Top List at 1:38 sentiment: mixed
Spirit Island video thumbnail
Click to watch at 1:38 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
mixed
Pros
  • Had so much fun
  • Improved experience upon revisit
Cons
  • Did not climb into one host's top 50
  • Initial experience was not great
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Card Drafting — Players draft cards to achieve patterns matching drafted cards.
  • tile drafting — Players draft tiles to achieve patterns matching drafted cards.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • It got a resurgence.
  • It's one of it's well, maybe the best app-driven game that we have.
  • Now that again, with the caveat being I wish that it had more content that came with it.
  • We've had a blast. If you've been watching our content, you know we've just really enjoyed Flip Tunes.
  • It is. It is. Basically a deck builder. But you have to mitigate what cards you have cuz some are going to be higher as you buy them from the market, but you need to really strategically get rid of your lower point cards.
  • My number 33 wasn't on the list last year, but it's Paladins of the West Kingdom.
  • It's my favorite of the West Kingdom games.
  • I know this one is probably going to go down probably year after year just because you do not enjoy Paladins.
  • My number 32 was number 12 last year.
  • It's Marvel Champions: The Card Game.
  • This is another one of those games that you were not as interested in at first, but now it's really kind of grown on you.
  • This is the only West Kingdom game that I really like. Yeah, and it's my least favorite of all of them.
  • That's my favorite part of that game is the way that your cards slide and you use the resources on the cards. That's how you take your actions and I think that's really interesting.
  • This is another one of those games that you were not as interested in at first, but now it's really kind of grown on you and we've been playing it a ton and I am loving it every single play.
  • Yeah, this is so surprising to me because I haven't had this one on my list yet.
  • I love the going around the rondel of the board.
  • That's my favorite part of that game is the way that your cards slide and you use the resources on the cards. That's how you take your actions and I think that's really interesting and then it kind of slides off and so that's really good.
  • Yeah, it it's a really good game and it's one that I didn't enjoy at first.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video 6xeIDzS-QnI Top List at 9:09 sentiment: positive
Spirit Island video thumbnail
Click to watch at 9:09 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
Positive
Pros
  • Deeply strategic
  • Highly thematic
  • Excellent cooperative experience
  • High replayability due to different spirits and adversaries
Cons
  • Steep learning curve
  • Can be prone to analysis paralysis
Thematic elements
  • Indigenous Spirits
  • Island
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Area Control — Players exert control over different areas of the island.
  • Asymmetric powers — Each spirit has unique abilities.
  • cooperative play — Players work together against the game.
  • Hand Management — Players manage a hand of power cards.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • This is probably my favorite co-op game on the planet.
  • It's a beast of a game, it's really complex, it has a steep learning curve.
  • The components are absolutely massive and beautiful.
  • It's a game that feels huge on the table.
  • This is a fantastic game, it combines deck building and worker placement.
  • I love the feeling of exploring and discovering new things on the island.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Transcript Navigation
Showing 1–50 of 377
Game Deep Dive