Skip to main content
Loading video...

Spirit Island Review - Colonial Boogaloo

Transcript 19:27

hi you're about to play spirit island in a wonderful evening together with your friends all that you need to do is make sure to get some wonderful spirit food so you can feed everyone and remind everyone of the joys you had as children flying in the fields and caressing the wheat to give our dish base we're going to use quinoa which is wonderful and it reminds me of my youth and how we as children is to pick a tree roots and just nibble on them a little bit destroy them you know and see what they're like to give the dish a little bit more substance we're going to have add a little bit of very nice ulti porridge which reminds me of my childhood and how we used to be naughty when my mum's made us eat porridge for breakfast and we used to sneak in chocolate and sign this one doesn't have chocolate just food finally we're going to add some red quinoa and corn bulgur now I know what you're going to say we've already added quinoa but this is red quinoa and it reminds me of my childhood and the just the different types of crayons I used to have some of them would be yellow and some of them would be red and the pictures that I used to paint so nice now we're gonna mix it all together with our hands just don't be afraid to touch it it's not going to bite you and we need to add a little bit of spice and click to this dish so we can then add

one of the best spices in the world water which reminds me of my childhood and how we used to look for wooden streams and just gorgeous elves and it's wonderful flavors it's a little bit of water to round it out mmm taste it just dip in there right with your hands and don't be afraid don't be scared remember mmm delicious now I just have to wait for my friends to come show they'll be handy woman

if you slightly newer to our hobby if you're not deeply entrenched into it if you haven't played this this or this but we'd like to give this cooperative look ago then my friends I don't recommend you watch the rest of this video in fact just go and get yourself this do you know what you will have many brilliant hours of enjoyment and surprises and wonderful things happening to you but for the rest of you if you are a little bit like me if you find yourself constantly pulling out empty baggies out of your pockets then I've got a wonderful idea to show you and I say a little bit like me I don't mean the crazy hair this one really defines me spirit island is a simple proposition in the same way that run through this motorway is a simple proposition it's not hard to execute it and it could potentially be quite fun but it requires a lot of skill and practice to make it out on the other side alive in spirit island you will be playing a spirit and not just any spirit but a fantastically named spirit if the artwork and design of spirit island is the first thing that stands out and it should then the next thing should be the naming conventions rivers surges in sunlight is perhaps my favorite board game character name ever lovingly printed onto cardboard and lost I don't expect you to feel the same way ask that you at least try and appreciate the beauty of these like in every other cooperative game you will be pitted against a system defeated and you win

simple you on up to three other spirits will be defending an island your island your home and gas water someone wants to come and take it away from you the worst kind of someone people these settlers are represented by explorers and the towns and cities that they build clear the map off of them and you get yourself a perfectly harmonious Island I also find it quite amusing that a strength one invader is a person and a strength to invader becomes a town for some reason ok move forward a bit we fall in the backwoods a little bit back with that back now we land in town and it's been said before but isn't it wonderful to have a game that approaches colonialism from a completely different angle I mean I love Mombasa but is it nice to have a heavy crunchy euro that doesn't force you to be a complete bastard don't get me wrong I am fascinated by colonialism but in the same way I'm fascinated with car crashes and don't worry there's no Cronenberg and hanky panky going on unless smooshing of game elements and spirit island has plenty of those unless I haven't made it clear yet spirit island is a crunchy nut we'll have to get to how and why in just a little bit because first I want to tell you about the challenges you're going to be facing each round the game tells you where the invaders will ravage as long as there's at least a town or two explorers on any given corresponding land they will spoil

that land causing blight if there are no more blood tokens left on your board your home is ruined then if that wasn't enough those same colonists will build more towns or cities on corresponding lands increasing their numbers finally to keep things just a bit more mysterious a new card is revealed denoting the land where more explorers will appear setting foot into even more territory that doesn't belong to them and then of course all these cars slide down meaning that the lands they've built on will be ravaged and the lands they've explored will be built on and so the cycle continues until you get rid of them it is so refreshing to have a cooperative game that doesn't just want you to prepare blindly and hedge your bets against whatever unexpected consequences it might bestow upon you you know exactly where trouble is brewing and you know what you need to do to stop it but don't for a second thing that you're getting away easy the human greed machine is an unstoppable time and you are just a spirit just an idea bestowed with incorporeal powers of nature maybe just maybe you can chase the invaders away from the lands they're about to ravage but then their bill and that'll explore and they will come in ever greater numbers you will be overwhelmed and this is where it gets complicated your powers are listed on cards and whether it's weathering crops or creating dolphins by embodying water with lightning or an actual frigging tsunami or possessing someone's dreams

and giving them ideas of fear I kid you not you can do it the only question is when you can do it you have the invader face that we just described before where the baddies do the damage and your powers activate before and after the invader face now naturally you want to do it before the invader face you want to get your sausage roll now before you're late for work and skip the cube but the game isn't designed that way most powers that do damage have a turtle which is an iconographic way of saying they are slow no powers normally pretty good but the problem is that they happen after the invader phase after most of the damage to the island has already been done or some powers give you a bird which is an iconographic way of saying they're fast however they rarely affect the state of the board such as giving you a defense value defense value simply you choose a land and it has defense now meaning it shrugs up some of the damage but doesn't actually do anything to the invaders now of course exceptions exist but they normally cost a lot of energy which is yet another precious resource that he's used to cast cards or sometimes your powers are affected by range most powers related to presence which are these bits that you put onto certain territories on the board or sacred sites which is just a fancy way of saying that Alan has to piece and with so many variables fast or slow and energy and elements which we haven't even mentioned yet and range you could get so overwhelmed just choosing a

couple of cars that you come to play we found ourselves so bamboozled by what cards we were going to play we didn't even have time to look at what the other player was doing a great way to eliminate the ever-present alpha gamma syndrome in cooperative games choosing which card you're going to play five minutes of that can seem like an hour has whooshed and then once you actually decide and show the other player what you're going to do you realize that if you execute your plan together then you probably lose the game so you go back to the drawing board and it's like having a developmental business meeting in your company and put the first brainstorming ideas in your own individual department and having that meeting to discuss those ideas realize it would bankrupt the company and then just order some pizza in iterate until you have something that doesn't end in total catastrophe this complexity is compounded by a word that makes my crotch just a Schrage wet with excitement by symmetry no matter which spirit you settle on playing you will have a different experience than other players lightning swifting strike is pretty simple your slope hours can become fast per hours and of course because you're learning you blast everything all you can choose to play something a little bit more esoteric like oceans hungry grass which is incredibly strong at the outskirts of the board by where the oceans are but not very influential in the center god I love a symmetry but I am also terrified of asymmetry because it can make the

game feel very and different each time you play or we can make it feel stale and boring as people settle onto an idea of what they should be doing and this is good and this is good and you should be doing that or that and you shouldn't be doing that this is boring poor amongst gaming people known as meta being a cooperative game however spirit island touches all of that so what if you find a really potentially strong combination of characters the game has more levels of difficulty than an average student has unwashed socks emitting an odor that is an altogether different kind of spirit team spirit but even at its most basic difficulty the game will be rough going because on your first play for all you'll be doing is just focusing on the lands that are about to get ravaged and trying to stop that from happening belonging to everything else that's going on and overwhelmed by the myriad of options and your poor little brain will melt into a puddle but then as you play the game more you start to realize that you need to plan and just like a teenager let some things like maybe it's okay to let a certain land be blighted and just lose one of these pips and prepare for what's coming next utilize your slow powers to actually affect things on the next round anyway Fiat which is yet another resource in the game anytime you destroy a town or a city you get to move some fear on this fear track but more

importantly you have powers that generate fear but don't necessarily have a lot of impact on the board adding more bits onto here and once you add all the bits you get to put the next fear cart down onto the board and crucially you don't know what it does but when it does resolve itself it will often do something that's quite useful and nasty to the invaders and it's just like an extra little bit of icing on the cake and so many times the fear cards have surprised us and how much useful they felt but more importantly once you move more fear cards down you terrorize the people so much that you have to actually do less to win the game removing all the white pieces from the board can seem like a monumental in accomplishable task but with the assistance of fear you don't have to do as much anymore you just have to show the invaders some financial projections of their business venture and they're there like now we'd better leave this not worth sticking around him this is where the game comes together for me where it comes alive not just this fear mechanism but how it all blends together into a dream that you might just achieve it's too chaotic to compute too unwieldy to take control so all you can do is have an idea a vision and hope that that vision pans out and was for most of the game you'll be too busy focusing on your side of the island hoping that the other players take care of this you will have to find those crucial moments of cooperation to make sure you succeed and isn't that just

what all good cooperative games are about let me show you what I mean in one of the games we were completely overwhelmed most of the land was blighted we were actually running out of physical components to put on the board and it was clear that we were not going to survive the next invader phase I was playing a spirit called shadows flicker in flames which largely closes fear and pushes the invaders around rather than removing them where's Alain was putting vital strength of the earth which defends the land but doesn't really remove any of the invaders meaning that our gameplay was largely revolving at preventing bad things from happening but the invaders kept coming and coming and coming and overwhelming us but that was fine we had a game plan and we were gonna stick to it on the up side however we caused a lot of fear we were at our level 3 meaning we were in the invaders heads and all we had to do was remove the five cities doesn't matter how many white pieces there are on the board as long as we can remove the five cities we win the game but it was only our fast actions that mattered because as soon as the invader face hits we lose the game and five cities is a lot sometimes on a turn you're happy you can remove one so it was a tall order but then I played my card wins of thrust and Anthropy that replaced cities with towns and because of its special ability I could repeat it again and because of the line and lanes character special ability I could repeat that card again meaning three of the

cities were gone and then aligned by the card that said well a fourth city was destroyed and we were one city short so all I had to do was dip into this new card deck from draw fool cards for all and find a fast power that destroyed a city if one was in here we would win the game and I'm not gonna tell you whether we did or not because that's not what matters what matters is the feeling of anticipation you get when you draw those cards spirit Island is a dream a wonderful dream of a complex cooperative game but the thing about dreams is well they only feel real when we're in them it's only when we wake up that we realize that something is actually strange it's easy to see why spirit is exciting with isometric powers very complex and gripping moments but it does have its weak points this box contains massive contribution of eight different artists and some of the artwork on the cards will seriously make some competitive card games feel jealous of just how astoundingly beautiful it is but the problem is not the artwork itself but the formatting of the cards which is just also 2005 I mean most of it is just brown and the all work itself is hidden in this tiny little box I get that full art cards are a little bit more expensive to produce but if you went through the effort of hiring a

different artists for the game showcase their work the other problem however is a little bit more yeah and what I mean by that is that some players will love it and some players will hate it and it's the fact that as a system as an adversarial system as the thing you're meant to defeat in spirit island well it's just almost this nine penetrable giant ice ball and unlike other games like pandemic where you're giving clear directions as what do to what you're meant to do to defeat it yeah you're just given hundreds of cards or the equivalent of a hundred tiny little like specs and you're meant to claw your way inside and somehow just break that giant ball it's less elegant and less cohesive and you kind of meant to find your own way around and you can imagine that for some people that will be absolutely what draws them into this game and makes them feel invested in or others it's just gonna be a straight no go and honestly at times spirit island can feel a bit bogged down repeatedly churning through cycles of its own systems advancing ever so slowly sometimes heightened by a poor selection of spirits was the game recommend you starting spirits in a two-player game with no one to guide you you could easily end up with the selection that just doesn't complement each other very well and a four-player game that is just be all chaos and I wish the best of luck even to the best strategists untangling that particular white plastic piece puzzle yeah these

are minor blemishes in a box that continuously invites you to challenge yourself and explore its depths explore ironically because you playing against explorers will shadows flicking flame stack wealth of oceans hungry grasp will one of them work better on the thematic side of the ward which by the way doesn't just look different it plays different and when is finally the time to break out the expansion that offers to nourish spirits and a variety of different ways to play the game and in a no pun included first it's a core game from a Kickstarter campaign that feels like it is a cool game not missing in expansion but already has an expansion that feels like an expansion spirit island is a dream it's an idea of a deep complex cooperative car driven mishmash and do you know what even if it is dream then excuse me while I stay in this dream for just a little bit longer because I'm really enjoying myself

if you enjoyed this video you don't have to eat red quinoa to enjoy spirit island but what you do have to do is subscribe to know but included where we do videos every week we try doing them on first this doesn't always work but we've got some wonderful stuff coming up and if you really really liked us and want us to support us until our next Kickstarter goes live next year you can always purchase our digital blue haven adventure promo which was popular kickstarter last year but is purchasable on this button right here you can click it but if you don't want to do any of that just you know say hi say hello in the comments below say what you think about spirit island do you think it's a cool game or maybe not or maybe you're excited about something else let us know who knows maybe we'll cover it

Progress saved