The Princes of Florence Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About The Princes of Florence
The Princes of Florence, designed by Wolfgang Kramer and Richard Ulrich and first published in 2000, is set in the Golden Age of the Renaissance. Each player leads an Italian aristocratic dynasty and tries to become the most prestigious family in Florence over seven rounds. Reviewers who return to it tend to describe a design that still feels sharp, while disagreeing about how much its card luck and its dated look matter.
Praise centers on the way the game joins bidding with spatial building. Rolling Dice and Taking Names described the recent reprint as a game that did not feel its age, and highlighted how quickly it moved at a three-player table with little downtime because every turn offers two actions and no one can block them.
Before You Play focused on the scoring decision at the end of each work. Players can take their earnings as money or convert some of them into Prestige, and that choice shapes the next auction. The same channel also showed how punishing a rich-get-richer dynamic can be, with one reviewer admitting that cashing everything out as money early on was a mistake.
Criticism is mostly directed at variance. Chairman of the Board found that the design held up well, but said that the draws from the profession deck could swing a player's position sharply, and that some of those swings felt close to game breaking. That reviewer also said the game was a close relative of Coliseum, preferred Coliseum for its more family-friendly charm, and set The Princes of Florence beside Siliconia as a hybrid of auction and polyomino placement. Several reviewers also noted that the older box and artwork look dated next to modern releases.
Core Mechanics That Define The Princes of Florence
Auction Bidding and the Item Stacks
Each round opens with an auction phase. The starting player picks one of the stacks, which hold landscape tiles such as forests, lakes, and parks, along with Prestige cards, Builders, Jesters, and Recruiting cards. Bidding starts at 200 Florins and climbs in exact steps of 100, and each player either raises or passes. Once a player wins an item, they sit out the remaining auctions that round, and the last player without an item can buy whatever remains for the minimum price.
Reviewers consistently treat this as the heart of the game. Chairman of the Board singled it out as the element that kept the game interesting, and Getting Games demonstrated how a single early win can shape the rest of a player's round. Builders are the most consequential auction prize. The first one lowers the cost of buildings from 700 to 300 Florins, the second allows buildings to touch each other, and the third makes buildings free, though a player can never hold more than three.
Work Value and Matching Professions
Profession cards are the scoring engine. Each one names specific requirements in the form of a landscape, a freedom, a building, and gestures from Jesters, and it earns work value for every requirement met. Every profession also counts the cards in a player's hand and on the table, which rewards players who keep a varied collection. Work value must meet a minimum that rises each round, which Getting Games noted starts at 9 and climbs steadily, so late-game works demand a well-planned palazzo.
Completed work converts into money at a rate of 100 Florins per work value point, and players may spend that money to buy Prestige at 200 Florins per point. The decision to cash out as money or Prestige is made immediately and cannot be revisited, a point Watch It Played stressed when explaining the rules. The player whose single best work is highest in the round earns a bonus of three Prestige, which encourages players to chase one big work rather than several small ones.
The Princes of Florence Experience
Tension at the Auction Table
Play feels deliberate and tight. Every auction forces players to decide what a landscape or Builder is worth to them, and to weigh that against the money they will need for buildings later. Reviewers describe moments where players deliberately bid up an item they do not want, just to drain an opponent's cash. That push and pull is the appeal for players who enjoy reading the table, and it keeps even quiet players involved because each round offers several openings.
Variance, Pacing, and Hindsight
The experience is not without frustration. The profession deck can produce a card that matches a player's buildings perfectly, or one that matches nothing, and reviewers found that luck could decide a game in a few turns. Players who learn the rules quickly tend to have an easier time managing this, because they plan around the minimum work value and keep Builders and Jesters in mind when bidding. Reviewers who enjoyed it also appreciated that the game ends in seven rounds and runs at a steady pace, with Rolling Dice and Taking Names reporting a table that finished in about an hour with three players.
What Makes The Princes of Florence Stand Out
An Auction That Never Stalls
Rolling Dice and Taking Names singled out how little downtime the auction phase creates, since every turn offers two actions that nobody can block. Reviewers consistently treat the auction as the strongest part of the design precisely because it keeps every player engaged even when it is not their turn to bid.
A Scoring Decision With Real Teeth
The irreversible choice between cashing out work as money or converting it into Prestige gives every completed project weight. Before You Play highlighted how punishing it is to misjudge that decision, which reviewers treat as a sign the game's economy has genuine stakes rather than an obvious optimal play.
Potential Drawbacks
Profession Card Variance Can Decide the Game
Chairman of the Board was direct that the draws from the profession deck can swing a player's position sharply enough to feel close to game breaking. A card that matches nothing a player has built leaves little room to recover, which reviewers flagged as the design's biggest weakness.
A Dated Look Next to Modern Releases
Several reviewers noted that the older box and artwork look dated compared to current Euro releases, even in the recent reprint. Chairman of the Board's preference for Coliseum's more family-friendly charm reflects the same concern about presentation rather than mechanics.
If You Enjoy The Princes of Florence
The Princes of Florence suits players who enjoy auction games with a lot of tension, and who want an engine-building Euro with a clear end-of-round rhythm. It is a strong fit for groups of three to five, since reviewers found bidding is more interesting with more participants, and it rewards players who like planning several rounds ahead. Those who enjoy Siliconia or Tennis Trail, and who like deciding when to convert points into money, will find familiar ground here. It is less suited to players who dislike variance from card draws, or who want a family game that is quick to teach and lighter to play; Coliseum may serve those players better. Groups with a strong preference for modern artwork and components should also know that the older presentation can feel dated. For everyone else, the game remains a sharp and respected example of how a classic Euro can still hold a table's attention.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"it went quick with three people hardly any downtime"
— Rolling Dice & Taking Names
"I got crushed in this game but I really liked it"
— Before You Play
"I love the tension of the auction"
— Chairman of the Board