Skip to main content
Loading video...

10 Board Games Ranked - Episode 26

Transcript 18:49

hey everybody and welcome to another episode of 10 board games ranked so I make a video like this every now and then whenever I play 10 new to me games and I rank them for my least favorite up to my most favorite now before I get into the 10 games I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor keyienda dot Co dot UK who are my go to online retailer when it comes to purchasing board games and if you use the link in my show notes or the QR code then you can get five percent off your first order at number 10 I have abandoned all artichokes so this is a deck deconstruction game where you want to be the first player to abandon all of your artichokes so you're doing that by um shedding at these artichoke cars by playing other cards essentially and you can do that in a bunch of different ways sometimes it's just a matter of top decking or some cards will synergize with each other where you can play one card that will help another card that will give you a bit more predictability and more accuracy about what's going to happen and how to get rid of those cards or the artichoke cards more efficiently and there's a little bit of back and forth as well where you can maybe give your artichoke cards to other players and back and forth that kind of thing um but for me the game was pretty it was pretty flat I didn't really have much depth on where you could go with this now there were a couple of little tricks and synergies with the cards but once you've used and explored those couple of Tricks there really wasn't anything else to unravel or to discover so I think after a play or two you've pretty much

seen everything here it's um there's a lot of luck and I think some cards are significantly better than other cards even though there's no cost um disparity so it's a little bit imbalanced in that respect too but it's a very light game it's very quick bit of silly fun and I still think that deck deconstruction mechanism could be explored so much further but I don't think Abandon All artichokes is the one to really showcase that mechanism at number nine I have Beast so this is a brand new hidden movement game where one player plays a mythological Beast I'm trying to achieve different missions on the board while the other players are trying to track them down and ultimately kill them now hidden movement games are a strange one for me because although I like the concept of them and the concept of them on paper in actuality I find them quite frustrating now something I have to say about Beast is that I think it did a good job of being able to you know once you've tracked the Beast down you can kind of get into a bit of a skirmish and keep tracing their path rather than maybe restarting again each time so it does have that kind of cat and mouse effect a bit stronger than some other um hidden movement games but ultimately the game was a little bit too tactical um for me because it is card driven and you the way you wrote um take these cards is through a passing draft and sometimes the cards will be like Attack cards or movement cards sometimes it means that you don't have a good balance of the two so even though I might know where you are I've got nothing in my toolbox to hurt you and then that can

add some more um frustration a lovely production there's some different different game modes and different beasts you can play with I have only played this stuff once and I will certainly give it another go because it didn't take too long Deputy didn't outstage welcome um and there were some really cool Concepts here as well you know you could have these little helpers going around and helping the Beast out and you've got to kind of spin quite a few plates and defend different areas and there's even like these spotlights and things where you can find the beasts footsteps so some good ideas here I think this might be a matter of personal tastes rather than objective criticism of the game as to why it ranked so low but you know as for now I'm not really feeling it but that could change with more plays and with those different beasts we shall see at number eight I have Coral now this is an abstract strategy game as you are fitting these kind of L-shaped blocks together and the idea is you're trying to have the most of your symbols exposed from a bird's eye view and inevitably you are going to start overlapping other players symbols they're going to do the same to you and it's all about How It Ends by the time the game ends so another game that's pretty tactical there are some placement restrictions that can make it a bit more puzzly and it is the lightning quick um but a bit like Beast this one felt a little bit too Tactical for me and if you're playing with say three players if two players get in a bit of a um a bit of a feud and start overlapping each other then that third player is probably going to naturally benefit because they're being untouched and could just lay things without any competition so it

does have that kind of third player Advantage if you want to phrase it that way um but it's not bad I think it's another example that you know abstract strategy games generally aren't my jam I don't find the the Tactical nature of them or that short-term thinking overly satisfying and it doesn't really pay off for me um and that's probably why I was lukewarm at best on Coral at number seven I have gallonus so this is no doubt a big disappointment for me um gallanus is a a game that I've been looking forward to for quite a long time it's a worker placement game but there was one thing about it that really did intrigue me and that was the idea that you can switch from placing your workers into resolving your actions whenever you like so it's gonna go around and turn order as any other game would but some people might still be placing their worker on by the time you're resolving your actions and because there is a priority and a definitely a need to go quicker and resolve your actions because there's a scarcity of the resources and things on the board then that's actually quite an interesting decision to make unfortunately I don't think that mechanism was enough to save the generic gameplay here because essentially all you're doing is you're leveling up this track and then trying to heal as much of these disease cubes on the board as possible and it just becomes a bit of a spamming mechanism where I charge up clean as many cubes as you can and repeat and repeat and repeat now they did have quite an interesting resource mechanism all these different kind of um tracks you're climbing up which would affect each other but there was some

kind of counter-intuitive ways that that worked and I've gone in a little bit more detail when um when I've reviewed it because I have actually reviewed this game but I've obviously not launched it yet so I'm keeping an eye out for that upload but yeah this one very generic um I don't think there's really any needs to play it amongst the Sea of other great worker placement games out there despite that mechanism being very cool and this game just did not kind of exploit that enough to make it a real keeper so gallonus yeah fell rather flat for me and I was hoping for quite a lot more at number six I have downforce so I'm quite ashamed to say that I've never actually played down Force until uh this month it's a Wolfgang Kramer I think it might be Michael keisling as well a racing game but you're racing these kind of go-karts around a track and it's considered to be one of the great racing games and after playing it I can see why it is so revered because it is so smooth it's so simple it does have quite a nice charm to it and it has another layer of um kind of decision space here as well because you're not only trying to race your carts to um obviously finish on a Podium place but you can actually bet on other um carts winning even if it doesn't belong to you or if it's not your turn so I do like the way that that works you have kind of two pools of winning the game here now the actual nature of the car play is very basic and it's all about trying to capitalize on the board position and utilize these kind of Choke points on the track in order to waste other carts movement because um you know

generally speaking every car moves at the same pace and it's all about trying to again waste that movement where the carts are stuck and can't go any further so I did quite like the way that that worked another game that is lightning quick I was actually very surprised that you could get this plate in about 15 minutes so um I think that definitely works in a favor and I would play this one again um if somebody wanted to it's not my favorite racing game but it probably would you know be up there in my top 10 top 20. um it was quite a nice one and I generally do like Wolfgang creamer games and this game actually did a good job of introducing these uh individual player Powers they're all very interesting so I did like the way that that worked as well so that is downforce considered a bit of a classic and I'm quite glad I got to play it now at number five I have a union Stockyards so this is a game that I've been quite excited for for quite some time because this game came out of the blue already and it was launched on Kickstarter a kind of an economic worker placement game with a very unique theme you know this is all about running your own Stockyard you know slaughtering livestock for the most profit as you can and it does have some very cool mechanisms but sadly much like gallonus I don't think the unique mechanisms here were strong enough or they didn't play out the way I wanted them to because this game does have a small spatial puzzle with it where you're placing these buildings down which will make you better at doing things and help you climb tracks and increase your profit margins but ultimately I thought that would um well I thought it was going to be a very interactive mechanism where you could you kind of get income by people

building on your land and stuff when in actuality it became a matter of I bought this bit of land and I build my buildings on it and it seemed like every player would do that and there really wasn't that much of an incentive to do anything else so I think another another mechanism that didn't quite reach its potential the rest of it is fairly generic there is a little bit of supply and demand which I tend to like but I think this game is going to struggle for its audience because it is way lighter than I thought it was going to be in terms of its complexity and because of that Niche theme I don't think that the generic or maybe Gateway audience of board gamers are going to be interested in it and anybody who is interested in this team is probably going to want something a bit more complex richer and something that's going to have that longevity um because you know generally I kind of I think I've noticed over the years is that the more weird a theme is well the more specific a theme is the heavier the game is this one is not going to have that broad appeal and it's not got the the depth of gameplay to satisfy those more Niche Gamers so a bit of a mismatch in terms of what this is going for I feel and I think that's going to hurt it but the game is fine um I would say give it a go if you see a copy out there because you know it's a solid well-rounded game but it just wasn't quite what I was looking for at number four we're going all the way back to the year 2000 with the princes of Florence another Wolfgang uh Kramer game now this is considered one of the kind of the

classic Euros I suppose it's one of the original polyomino style games as you're building these or your own little Province I suppose to these little buildings little Gardens and it's a very restrictive little board you have to build on and you do actually have to invest in auctions in order to break some restrictions and give you more flexibility and I did like that urgency and that pressure to get everything you needed in these auctions now if you're familiar with a game called Coliseum Coliseum was directly inspired by the princess of Florence and because I like the um Coliseum so much but I did get a bit fatigued with it because I played it so much I wanted to go back and try this one you know I found it a very cheap price many years ago um and I did like it you know I like it a lot it's my fourth favorite game out of the 10 here but I do feel and I really see this about Wolfgang chroma games I do feel that this game is slightly aged I could do with a few tweaks in terms of the mechanisms because I thought this game did rely quite heavily on the luck of the draw sometimes when it came to drawing these cards because essentially you're collecting these um tetramino tiles in order to fulfill these contracts but you're drawing these contracts by top decking them and sometimes you're going to top deck these cards and they're going to match perfectly what you've already built sometimes that's not going to happen so it did have that big swings of black now you do have some mitigation because you can you can even draw from people's discard piles and you can draw five cards at a time and keep one but I've experienced firsthand that um you know drawing the wrong card or the right card at the right time is going to determine the winner and that's

how these games play out for me so that's left a little bit of a sour taste in my mouth to the point where I think maybe the time for princess of Florence is gone I didn't really feel the need to own it anymore because I've got so many great auction games in my own collection um but um but hey there we go a good one holds up okay but it could have done a few more tweaks to make it great and I know there is going to be a um a new edition coming out this year so it'd be interesting to see it interesting to see if those things are addressed so that is the princess of Florence at number four at number three I have Lewis and Clark the Expedition so this is a deck building racing game which is very Euro in its approach now you are collecting these cards you're playing them some cars will activate other cards and it's all about resource conversion you know you're converting one type of resource into another resource and then converting those resources into moving down a river or through mountains now the resource conversion and the Hand management part of this game I thought was fantastic some great puzzly moments here trying to map things out in the right order I love that you have workers not only to collect resources on the weight main board but you can also use those workers to activate your cards but if you run short of the workers you can use some cars to activate the other cards and it's all about trying to optimize how you play them and have as little wastage as possible because if you say over spill um on resources or if you don't manage that hand of cards correctly and have just stray cards laying out there then you actually get

hit by these punishment tokens which can slow you down significantly now I do like the idea of that but another one where in practice it did become quite frustrating and it does make the game drag on and considering this is a racing game I thought the sense of urgency was lacking here it didn't feel like a tense race it was a long marathon and I think the game sadly outstayed its welcome you know this game should take around 60 to 90 minutes you're talking around two and a half to three hours to pay this which I think is not on the money for me you know this was probably the prime example of a game that could benefit from shaving an hour off you know I can normally forgive maybe staying 20 minutes half an hour beyond the desired length but going an hour at least over the what I would like to like the game to take is kind of unforgivable so the gameplay itself is so good and so much fun but I can't warrant getting to this to the table because it simply does not warrant how long it takes so a very near miss me I'll say you know if you if you're intrigued by this one and you're not so bothered about games dragging on then give this one a look because the gameplay is great but sadly that's something that I do look for and I don't like it when games take too long so that is Lewis and Clark the Expedition so only two recommendations uh this time and the first of which and my number two out of these ten is your Vic so another one for Stefan Feld here and this is a game that goes back to 2016 and one that I haven't played so um you know generally speaking I love stuff and fall games and I really enjoyed this

bidding game and I don't think I've played a bidding Stephenville game so far so it might be his only one I'm not sure maybe I'm forgetting one but this is um one where you're placing these meeples on the main board in order to collect these cards and these cards score your points in tons of different ways such as contract fulfillment where you're collecting the contracts and the resources for the contract separately but I love the way that these auctions are resolved by placing these meeples next to the card once everybody's run out then you are going to go and priority order saying who's placed their people first against this card is going to get the first option to buy it but they're going to have to pay the price for everybody else who's placed it on that card and they can abuse to buy it or pass and if they pass they're gonna remove their meeple making it one coin cheaper for the next player in the queue so it's got that kind of sudden death mechanism there and that is the definitive mechanism here and I think it's definitely enough to keep me intrigued and keep me coming back to this one I did like the breadth of the different ways you can score it does come with a kind of a basic mode and an advanced mode and I think you can dive straight in to the advanced mode because it's not terribly complex there's tons of things you can go for some great decisions and it's really interesting when um you think I really want this card but this player knows I want it they're gonna they put their workers there just to make me pay more for it if I don't take it then he's going to get it for a bargain so you've got to really consider all these decisions done that's what I love about Euro games and stefenfeld is just the master so I really enjoyed this one a pleasant surprise because I I know

a lot of stuff and fall fans don't rate this one terribly high but I think it is Rock Solid and I enjoyed it thoroughly so that is jorvik app number two and finally at number one I have revive so revive is a game that I've been eagerly anticipating um because it's taking a bit of time to get over here to uh England but it's definitely been worth the wait because I love the gameplay here this is such a great card driven Euro with tons of engine building tons of unique powers you can use and building up a bunch of powers that only you can exploit but I also like the way that this game is somewhat sandboxy and I was wasn't quite expecting that going into the game because each player is going to have their own private objectives or secret objectives that they are trying to maximize but they could be things such as you know for every I mean if every step of this track you're going to get a point or for every one of these tiles you're on you get a point these style of things but it all has a great sense of Discovery as you're flipping over tiles or really new Spots I'm racing to get to these best spots to increase your engine and climb tracks get new technologies I'm just a great forward momentum and you're constantly getting stronger and stronger and stronger and taking these big Grand used turns that feel immensely um satisfying so I definitely think this one has legs I think it's going to have longevity people are still going to be talking about this one in five years time and the potential to expand this one is huge because you could just add um you know a little module here and there new powers new factions and um I'm actually quite excited to do that to do to see that as long as they don't kind

of differ from that core mechanism too much because it is so simple and pure in the way that it plays just like playing cards or kind of resetting your cards I suppose and it just it comes together so harmoniously and I was very very impressed by it and um yeah one of the best games from 2022 No Doubt so there we have it that's another 10 games there hopefully you have found this video useful if you have please be sure to hit like And subscribe to my channel and check out my other content too but for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye

Progress saved