Skip to main content
Loading video...

Audience HOT Takes: First Player Tokens = WASTE!!

Transcript 1:30:57

Good morning everybody. Welcome to the Dice Tower Arm Chair Vassal.

I'm Zee Garcia.

I'm Joey Evans.

I'm Mike Delisio.

I'm Chris Yee.

Alrighty, well, hey, it's Wednesday and it's been a month and a half so it's time for some more hot takes.

Hot takes?

Yep.

Nelly.

What?

No, I don't think so.

Hot takes?

Nelly?

Doesn't he say that?

Yeah.

Are you talking about the hot in takes?

Hot in here?

Hot in takes.

Didn't he say something like that?

I don't know, maybe not. Maybe it's not Nelly.

Are you thinking of Jim Gaffigan?

He's not a rapper.

Hot pockets.

Okay, yeah, I always think of Jim Gaffigan.

Yum, mhm.

Fine.

[sighs]

Okay, so we want to say thank you to all you for watching. We also want to point out Dice Tower West coming this coming in just a few months.

February.

Coming around the corner.

But also we just opened yesterday registration for Dice Tower Cruise in Alaska next September. Want to come join us? It's a once-in-a-lifetime cruise. Likely will be. We're not doing this every year. dicetowercruise.com check it out. Come see bears.

And meese.

Of the polar variety.

Mhm. The the toughest bears.

Actually, I don't think so. I think you see a lot of

Grizzly bears.

Or the brown bear.

Kodiak, maybe.

I would love to see a Kodiak.

Oh my gosh, I don't know.

Fairly

Gummy gummy bears.

That's what I want to see.

That's my favorite kind of bear, for sure, the gummy bears. Yes, yes. Good friends with the gummy worms. I've heard tell they're quite ferocious.

Also, apparently we'll see many baby moose. Woo! It's a baby moose.

Best song ever.

So, we're doing hot takes here today. These are your hot takes that you sent. You can send me new hot takes at tom@dicetower.com.

[clears throat]

I went through I think we had uh there was 206 and we're doing 24 today.

It's 206. They're not all going to be winners. You also curate what you pick, right? I mean

I do curate. There's a possibility that some hot takes will be slight variations of what we've seen in the past. You've written these hot takes. Some people write them very inflammatory. We will treat them thus, but we're also It's all in good fun. It's all in good fun.

Are people actually getting upset about hot takes?

In good fun. I think that's like the very purpose of some people's hot takes.

What are we on the internet?

You can vote on these hot takes. We're going to open it up in just a minute. There's a link in the description of this video and I'm sure it will show up in the comments, too. So, we have 24 hot takes. We're going to start with the first one from Sergio. Sergio says, "Having a community to share and discuss your hobby is great, but most people in the board games don't know BGG, BoardGameGeek, exists nor do they care nor would they care if they did. Not everyone runs to BGG to get an opinion, so the people that are active on BGG represent only a small part of the community. I've heard several hot takes about BGG and the answer to a lot of them is don't take BGG that seriously."

I agree with that.

I agree with this, too. Clearly, most people who play board games do not even know BoardGameGeek exist. 1,000%.

yeah. In [clears throat] fact, 2,000%.

is now live.

Uh

When I the first website that I got into board game related was dominionstrategy.wiki or something like that. And it was just about Dominion cards and like news about the new sets coming out. I was like, "This is really cool. A website about a board game I love." You know what I mean?

No.

Yeah.

That's really far down the rabbit hole.

Yeah, it's a dark web. Yeah, yeah.

But there's also very specific websites that are not BoardGameGeek. People go to Facebook to talk about games in different groups.

Sure.

There's Instagram.

Discord, Instagram, Reddit.

Altavista

After your dog pile.

Mhm. That's Cape Navigator.

I will say this, though. If you are a small publisher and do strategic games, I do disagree on that part. You need BoardGameGeek. That is where That is where your fans are. That is where they're going to come to buy things.

If it's a If it's a hobby game,

Yes. you got to utilize that tool. I think you need to be active on BoardGameGeek. You certainly should be there to answer questions, to kind of Yeah. Yeah, if you're it's You know, that's that's the disconnect is that people think what is the hottest game of the year? And they'll be like, "Oh, Drillers." And I'm like, very few people in the world

Right.

know about Drillers versus like the latest Monopoly release is everywhere. Whatever that may be. You know what I mean?

Monopoly uh deep K-pop demon hunter.

Yeah, exactly. Like

K-pop demon drillers is going to outsell

Right.

factor of 10 to 1, I'm sure.

The fact that you can look up its rules clarifications is probably my main pull for BGG.

Sure, but most people will never do that.

They'll just house rule it and say, "I Let's try it this

Or they put the game back on the shelf and

Yeah, that's the other thing.

Yeah, BGG has just become a much broader thing. I mean, it really started out as a database, essentially, of board games. And that sense it's become curated by its members, by people that go to BoardGameGeek and interact with it. And it's become this huge you know, repository of reviews and lists and opinions and jokes.

Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Of the booty.

You didn't like that word?

I didn't say that. I The funny thing is, I think you must have sensed that I almost said suppository instead of repository, but [snorts] I corrected myself.

Proud of you.

say I was at my cousin's. They love board games.

Oh, here we go. This is a heck of a segue, okay. So, he says suppository immediately. Like, I was at my cousin's.

No, no, because they were like, "We have a game we can't figure out in the closet." And we need some medicine.

Up. Camel Up. Camel Up.

just never really looked it up. It is just funny how they are not into BGG at all, but they love games. I think

Go Go ahead.

No, I'm just thinking percentage-wise, how many people just love games but aren't really into that ecosystem.

I would bet that a lot of people, the first time they come across BGG is because they've written just in Google a question and the first

That's

is BGG.

absolutely.

That's what I was thinking. I wonder how far it is if you not write the name of a game down where BGG is there.

Pretty near the top, I think.

Yeah, usually. And this is not to bash BGG cuz I use it daily and it's a very important. But I think for a lot of people that click on it for the first time, its user interface is going to be very off-putting to them.

That's a good point. Yeah.

To the pointed.

I don't know if you guys if it was [clears throat] your experience or not, but I used BGG occasionally to find like rules answers and stuff and then that was it and I clicked away and didn't make a an account. I didn't participate in forums and answer and and type in threads and all of that stuff for years, I think.

It's still hard to navigate. I mean, if I'm looking for something I can't remember how to get back there.

Yeah.

Well, I mean, I don't do that with most things. I mean, I again, I'm on BoardGameGeek all the time. I think it's I really it's a useful site. But I like movies and I very rarely go to IMDb. Very rarely.

Rotten Tomatoes?

I go there a lot. A few times, right? But I don't go farther into these sites. I might just go look at

Letterboxd is really good.

go look at a few things on these websites, but I don't I don't go there every day. I don't go see what the newest stuff is. I just don't do that. BoardGameGeek is the only one I do that with, really.

Yeah, like we do literally use it every single day to the point if they're ever doing maintenance during work hours,

Yeah.

it slows

Tower shuts down.

Yeah, our productivity is hampered by

true. It's like, what are you doing?

It's definitely true.

Yeah, I don't you know?

Where am I supposed to get my opinion if not BoardGameGeek?

All right. Irwin N says, [clears throat] "Expansion boxes should be larger than the base game instead of smaller. The base game box can have minimal empty space enough so it's not a challenge to get everything back in and take up less space on a shelf without having to predict what is needed to fit future content. When the expansion comes out with a different player count and play time, the new box should have the new information on the cover, player count and play time, and enough space to fit the base game with the expansion content." I would love to go to a friend's house and see on the shelf that they have the same game but with a a bigger box with different artwork and printed on the cover that it goes to five players that are four and know immediately that they have something different that I might want to try. I understand there's a cost associated with this.

Oh, good. Oh, good. I was concerned for a moment.

expansion packaging, but the people who are buying expansions already love the game and are willing to invest money for more content.

It's not about the people buying it. It's about the company making it.

I know a lot of big box versions of games exist, but I would love to see this done on more games that have just one or two expansions. By the way, the last one everyone mildly agreed with the person about board game boxes.

Yeah, okay. Okay. Yeah. This is Yeah, this is why all over

[cough]

again. Expansions are going to sell a fraction of what whatever of whatever the game is sold. And if they have to now make if now making that is more expensive than the board game was then we're going to all say goodbye to expansions.

Yeah, this has been done. I'm trying to remember

Yeah, it's crowd surfing generally cuz then you know what your costs are up front.

what I'm trying to think of a game where the expansion was bigger than the base box. A counting

to hold them both. I It's done it at least once or twice.

It's usually like with a big box.

Right. It'll usually be a big box.

Yeah, go ahead. Pick and choose the expansions you want, but then it's like, oh, I'm sorry. You need every single one. Like Catacombs has like two. One What if I skip one? I'm like

I'll do it now.

Can you imagine

Right, this is what happens. They have to include the second and then the second and first or are they both

By the time you got Can you imagine the latest Carcassonne expansion? It'd be like a coffin sized box.

Oh, Dominion wouldn't exist.

Yeah.

Yeah, spend just say Yeah, spend in the check. Can you imagine each Dominion box just

Oh, coming in a crate.

It This is a I think this is not a terrible idea for a very specific line of games or something like that, right? Something where you have uh oh, Arcs. Arcs is the game that does that, right? The expansion box is

Yeah, it's bigger.

Cuz it's a campaign, too. Yeah.

No, they came out at the same time.

Yes, right.

Oh, yeah, that's

That's right.

Choose whichever one you want.

Yeah.

Oh, that's fine.

Super rookie just said it.

Just said it, yeah. Ours did it.

The expansion is also the Their expansion is mega.

Sure.

Even if they had made it the same size as that to fit the base game, it would still be bigger than the base game.

I think it's also essentially because the game was designed as the big thing and they said, "Hey, let's make a more approachable product for people to to to enter into."

This person probably lose their mind on booster packs and like sea salt and pepper or whatever.

What I was going to say was that what's funnier to me about this take is not the essential argument because sure, you can make that argument. I would disagree with it, but um it's that he then goes on and is graphic designing these boxes and telling you exactly what should be on there, what information should be on there. This isn't a one-size-fits-all thing. You're not going to get a bunch of publishers to, you know, agree to something like this.

What if it What if they did the Thunder Road thing where you just put the extender on the box over and over

and over.

and over and over.

Every expansion Let's do this. Let's Let's find a middle ground here. Every expansion should come with a sticker for the base game that you slap over the player information and the game length count.

I love it.

How about that? And then when you go to your friends, you just have to check every box to see if it has that sticker on it.

doesn't

then you know that the base game

Your very base.

Yes.

[clears throat]

The last thing I'll say is to the opposite point of this, I really like that more expansions are doing the tearaway packet fit it in the base box.

I agree.

I really like that rather than selling a whole box that you go, "What would I do with this now?" It's going in the garbage.

Well, this was indeed a hot take. 29 votes, folks. You can vote the link in the description. Um [clears throat] uh 29 votes, but 25 disagreed and there was only four mild agrees and all right.

All right, Joey, this next one's for you.

Oh.

Alex S says,

Oh, no.

"If you're printing out grids for Carcassonne or Hive, you need a time out from the 3D printer."

Preach.

Joey.

I HAVE

DONE

THIS. THIS is your wife, MAN.

GOOD POINT.

I SHOULD HAVE JUST PUT ALEX WITHOUT THE S AT THE END.

Alex Sevens. Schmevens.

But they look really cool, though.

You printed this out for real?

didn't. I thought about them.

This is stupid. I'm sorry.

I haven't done it. No, I'm not going to.

it for

Definitely won't tell you, by the way, I did.

I get it for like a game

like Catan. And in fact, they eventually did it themselves where they give you that sort of cardboard grid on the outside or whatever, a fence on the outside. But for Carcassonne, for Hive, for any sort of visual, you know, hex grid or square grid, come on. Come on. Now you're just printing crap for the sake of printing crap.

honestly

Who would do that?

Okay, that's it really where it is.

ever printed out a statue? IF I IF I SIT THERE AND MY PRINTER'S not working for a while, I'm like, I got to get doing something while I sleep.

And I'll find something like this and be like, well, I guess I'm getting a grid for Hive.

I think that's one of the bad things about 3D printers. In fact, we don't do that with a [clears throat] my paper printer. I'm like, I guess we should just print a book out.

I'm meant to ask you, was were those prints of the legs, was that real or was that like a fake photo?

Oh, it was real. It was a 3-ft alien. Did you see the finished one?

No.

Again, it sat there for a while. I'm like, guess I'm printing an alien.

What?

You know what? You guys are going to You guys are going to love your Christmas presents, by the way.

Yeah.

Is it a 3D printer?

Yeah, no. Printer.

And your 3D printer can print a 3D printer.

Teach a man to print.

Yes.

Uh yeah, any game that is intentionally amorphous, you know what I mean? Like Catan board

it's a positive?

Yes, thank you. Like the Catan board doesn't grow partway through the game. And we're like, oh, look at all this stuff over here. No, that's the point of like Carcassonne and Hive.

Right. It grows.

There are magnet parts that you can stick on, so it can grow with it.

Can you 3D print a magnet? I'm asking a serious question.

No, you're not.

It's a

A unserious question.

I do love the voting at this one. So, the vast So, there's 31 votes. 19 agrees out of that. But, on the disagrees, there's seven hard disagrees.

THERE WE GO.

YOU ARE MY PEOPLE.

I OWN several bamboo hats.

All righty.

[clears throat]

Next Next one from Shawn says, "Board games have their own Call of Duty, FIFA, Madden issues. It feels like a new Everdell comes out every year, for example. It feels like there are quite a few games that aren't even that old that are re-released as a new version. Do Imperium and Uprising, for example."

For example. For example.

Why do we keep buying the same games from companies that only have minor tweaks? It's even worse than Madden and Call of Duty, though, because you don't need the latest version of Everdell to play with your friends.

Do you think they should go full

actually understand that. That part I don't get.

They should do full

Can't you friends? Is it because your friends moved on and you didn't get the latest? Is that I I must be it.

I think it's worse for video games cuz you do need the

To play online, you need the new one.

Right. Right.

So, they should go full Grand Theft Auto and be like, "You know what? You get one 40 years later or give us the next one."

Like George R. R. Martin novels.

Oh, did you see that yesterday they announced the name for the next Elder Scrolls. This big announcement. It's called Sentinels. This whole thing and people are like, "So, we got the name after 16 years." So, 16 years,

maybe they'll tell us how the game plays now.

it called?

It's called Patience. Sentinel or Sentinels.

So, it's called The Elder Scrolls 6 Sentinels? It's a terrible title. Really? It's not as good as Oblivion. Fantasy location.

They only had 16 years. They

That's wild, right? Morrowind, Daggerfall, Skyrim. Are you kidding? These are amazing. Oblivion. Sentinels? I'm going to write a strong letter.

getting a hot take right here. Goodness gracious.

Is it singular? Cuz that might be a cool name for a place. Sentinels.

to buy it, though. We'll see.

I could see that being all right.

He's already pre-ordered it.

He's He's got

Yeah, it looks like it It like it's singular. Just Sentinel. And it is one of the nine major kingdoms of the province of Hammerfell.

face, Hammer man. Hammerfell, that's cool.

Should have called it Hammerfell.

Would have been a better name.

Is there not a Hammerfell already? No, I don't think so.

I would tell you that you're getting to this, which we haven't addressed even a little bit.

I think that there's a bit of truth to this, but I will also say that when instead of trying to put out a kind of a redone edition, when an errata pack is pushed put out put out, often times board gamers flip out and hate the idea of an errata pack. They'd [clears throat] rather buy a whole new game than take an errata pack and put it in their board game.

I guess that's where

I think I agree with you. Um, and there's a bunch of reasons for that. The reason being a lot of any kind of secondary edition to a game might not match one to one, and that really bothers me. Like if you buy an expansion to a game, you take that game home, you're excited, you shuffle in the cards and realize they don't match, that sucks.

Right.

I have a tendency to keep those like Dominion. I bought the upgraded cards, you know, second and put them in there, but then I still have my first edition. I don't know why, just in case. I almost just rather buy a second.

I think it's a psychol- I for what you're saying, of course that's a thing to to be like, yeah, this isn't cool. You're not really fixing it if now you're I've got a mismatch game.

Right. Now I have a new issue to solve.

Right. Exactly. But I think it's more than that. I think board gamers No, I just think board gamers often times have this weird thing where it's like, I don't want an errata pack because I don't know what the because is, but it I think it's something that's more specific to board games than to video games.

It does but think though I think it's some reason.

I don't think this is this will this will not stop, but and why should it? It's comfort food, you know, the movie franchises, the the next Fast and Furious is going to come out cuz people like Fast and Furious. So if you make Everdell, you'd be a fool not to make more of it. How many Munchkins are there? I mean, it's again, if you have a game that sells like crazy, why would I not want to make another copy of it? I want to make money, and that's not me being greedy. Or even if I'm being greedy, it just makes sense. I I don't I don't fault people for that.

The The day that an that Everdell 22 comes out, uh you know, flying to the moon and back or whatever, then and and it sells 40 copies, then that'll stop.

Right.

Right.

You know, but it's it's

It's definitely a market to you know, will yeah, yeah, drive this.

This is definitely a split one. There's eight neutral, 20 agrees, and 10 disagrees. Um yeah. All right. This next one's for Kenny, from Shawn A. People need to stop treating board games as investments.

I can always tell a Kickstarter has fulfilled because I see copies of sale for double the pledge price on Facebook Marketplace. You're telling me you spent $200 to $500 years ago to try and make a few hundred bucks? That's a horrible investment strategy. You can do so much better things with than with your money than that. I get there are also people trying to buy two copies to try and cover the cost of theirs by selling the other, but it's insane.

Strong agree.

Can you combine into this people that see them at discount places and say, "Oh, this is a $40 game for $5. I'm going to hold on to it for a couple years until I can sell the Marketplace."

I don't know. That becomes a big investment thing.

want to see the best uh

Like board game

Barnes & Noble stuff.

The best proof of this thing being an actual issue is go to any any board game flea market where people are trying to sell their 4-year-old copies of games at retail. It's like people have such an inflated idea of what their board games are worth because they have personal investment into You got to get It's an entertainment, right? It's a form of entertainment. And that's why in many ways I think it's a you know, you talk about movies, that's great. You see it and you have that experience. And and and that could live with you for the right, you [clears throat] know, and you you may not ever see it again, but a board game, you can have multiple great experiences for, you know, a relatively reasonable price usually. And I just I think people are too precious.

I'm guilty of it sometimes, but

You also have to take into account, board games take space.

They do take up

It's not like investing money in the bank. You know, that doesn't take Board games, if you have a garage full of board games that you're probably going to sell,

Mhm.

that's a an issue. Most board games don't go up in value.

Right.

The very In fact, very few do and we know this because we were just at Essen and

[clears throat]

that amazing was one of my top games, the space game from Peter um

Andromeda's Edge?

Andromeda's Edge was selling for 15 euros.

Yeah.

15.

That's insane. Is it

And Kenny bought it.

Unbelievable.

Yep. Uh

I mean that to me is

It is.

The value of games drops so much and everyone every time you say it, someone will point to something, but what about this game? But that's like one out of 500.

And even those games, Battlestar Galactica, I would say check the check the price history speaking of BGG on Battlestar Galactica, you're going to see a huge drop, right? If you are holding on to that waiting for someone to pay you 250 bucks, it ain't happening now.

No.

Yeah. Yeah, that's that that's done. That's one of those things too. If you are trying to speculate on the market like that and then a reprint gets announced, you're done and that's fully out of your control.

Yep.

But what do you think about the Target, Barnes & Noble people that get these for $5

Just say Kenny, we know what you mean.

Well, no, I mean even Target's a big one though.

you can do that. That's fine if it's a hobby, but I don't think it's

I don't think you should do it to like make money. I think

Yeah.

I've done it, but it's because

I want to try it out.

psychological things where I'm like well, it's only $3. I I need it. Even if I never would have considered this game at full price or even, you know, with a normal discount.

You're looking like I'd buy it for that price.

Yeah, it's probably folly to do so because if you never even would have considered that game, then no amount of money should make you grab that game.

In Kenny's defense, I think he does it cuz he just finds fun in doing it.

Oh, he absolutely is opening booster packs in his mind. That's what happens.

Sure, yeah, yeah.

Or he'll buy stuff and give it to people.

Yeah, yeah, he loves to do it. He gets

If there's anybody that's interested in an insta in shrink copy of Yamatai, we've got your hookup.

Okay, now this is first time this happened in a while. 49 votes here, zero disagrees.

There you go.

There's one neutral, but there's 32 hard agrees.

Yeah, all right, good.

Yeah, okay, okay.

I'm glad.

the opposite of one we just had from Kevin Q who says, "Publishers should release their games in a box that fits just the game. Don't drop in wells for possible future expansions or Kickstarter content that most buyers are not ever going to be able to purchase. Then, when they publish a substantial expansion, that expansion should come with a box with space for all the original releases' content." So, it's very similar in some ways. But what do you think?

This guy just marked it down.

Forget the second part of it cuz we already talked about that. But the part here where he's saying

[clears throat]

we don't want that extra space. Does it bother you when you buy a game and there's a well for a Kickstarter piece

A little bit.

get?

A little bit, sure.

No, because I can then 3D print A NICE INSERT.

I'M TELLING YOU.

TO SPEND MONEY TO DO THAT, THOUGH.

Ring the rail.

You have to spend money and time to do that, 3D

Well, there's also, you know, getting into another potential hot take, you know, you you a lot of times I don't particularly like it if I'm not going to sleeve a game and now I've got an empty card well. You know what I mean? So, you know, and I do sleeve some, but I don't sleeve most. And so yeah, now you've got this empty well and you're like, "Ah, I can split the cards in half and now they look like they're half empty."

That being said,

I would do that every time. I think the more problematic thing here is the psychological feeling of getting a game that has spots for things that aren't in there.

Mhm.

And that game then psychologically you always feel like, "Hmm, [clears throat] this game's incomplete."

Yes.

Cuz you're being reminded of it incessantly. Every time you open that game up, you feel like you don't have everything. Oh, that sucks. That's So, the card well thing I'm not as bothered by because cards go here. It's a really dumb deep well. Okay, but cards go there. This one spot that will always be empty and has the shape of a guy holding a sword, a guy I don't own, I Why is my game not complete?

3D print the sword.

I was going to compound on that. Mike Mike Howard brought up Heat. Heat had the two extra card spots. I would say like Lords of

Waterdeep, I did an insert for this and at the end there is something I'm like, I thought I had everything and now I don't. I don't even know what it is, but there's other things for Lords of Waterdeep. I'm like, I need that.

Do you?

The game is fine. I don't miss it until You're right. When you open it, but the instruction booklet does that too.

What are you missing?

That's true. Yes. Yes. That's true.

you missing in Lords of Waterdeep?

know. I still don't know, but there's a spot that upgraded little guys and stuff. I'm like,

Oh, you don't have the upgraded little guys? Joey and stuff that he's missing in Sentinels of the Multiverse would be hilarious.

Thank you. That'd be great.

I I don't know. I I just kind of mentally chalk that up to like in my mind I think I justify it as it's a misprint. You know what I mean? Like, oh, there there's a part of the well that or like there's something there that's uh didn't need to be there and then I can try to like uh compartmentalize that away. But, I also know that we don't keep a lot of inserts. So, I think that's part of it too that that'll fix it. You're like, "I don't have something."

Blip.

Yeah.

Well, I don't love the DeVir model of there's room in the game for the the box for the game and nothing else and you better

There's not even room for air. You have to Tetris

Yeah, I don't like that as much, I'll say. I like a little breathing room.

I I How many game nights you see people struggle like this is not going to fit back in?

Yeah, it's That's wild. If after I punch your game, I can't quite get it back in, my gosh, then you you got to give me a little breathing room in there.

Immediate lid lift.

Yeah, that's wild. No, so I'll take the opposite. This whole it just barely fits, No.

All right. Well, most people actually did disagree with this take. There's a This was kind of spread out.

Yeah.

All right. Next we have something from Jason M. He says, "Five and six player expansions for games are only bought for extra colors and characters and rarely used actually play at those player counts."

We're not saying this. I'm reminding people watching, this is not what we're saying. Your five player game group loves the five player expansion and that's fantastic. This is a weird take because I don't

I agree with it.

You agree with it?

too.

I don't I think that there are What does it say? Does it say only bought for? Obviously, that's not true.

Well, obviously, I don't think it's objectively, but I think

Jason's hyperbolic.

Yeah, yeah. Jason's also likely in the UK.

What do you mean he wrote colors?

The extraneous U in colors.

Oh, extraneous.

Oh, now we got the hot take coming.

Sorry, the U That's for uh listeners of of my podcast. That yeah, we I I always give grief to the extra U's over there. But yes, I I How popular are five player and six player expansions

I think people buy them with the intent of playing with more players and then it doesn't happen.

If your game group is five people, it You know what I mean? Like my Vegas game group back in the day was often five.

Right.

And we're like, all right, fine. We're playing Broom Service again. We're playing Castles of Burgundy again. And uh with people like, "Hey, I have the five tribes with the fifth player expansion." Or whatever. Didn't didn't want to Not a thing. Shoot. I don't remember which game I'm thinking of. Had the extra player expansion. Okay. You know what I mean? Like we would pull that out occasionally. It's not ideal. Most of those five player expansions are not ideal.

I was going to say that's my hotter take is that most five and six player expansions are making a game worse.

But they usually

But they fit a group.

Yeah.

And it's almost like reverse engineering.

People buy them They already love the game being a slightly worse version of something that you're very comfortable with.

Mhm.

It's still comfort food.

People buy this for two me. I mean

Who Okay, go.

Well, completionist. Completionist, but then also free shipping.

Okay, free shipping.

Really? I need to get free shipping. I'm like

That is such a You have the wildest hot takes today. 3D print everything and get crap for free shipping. Oh, okay. Not everyone at this table has done it, right? When you're right next to free shipping, you add something.

No.

Plenty of people

Have you?

Plenty of people do it.

You have to compare the pricing, but it's usually a bad That's what it's for. It's always like 38 cents.

I'd rather spend 20 bucks and get They don't sell dental floss at Target.

What game store you going to that does not sell dental floss?

M- The five to six player expansions are mostly a thing of the past. The big ones were Catan added. Nowadays, expansions add something and then it's like, "Also, a fifth player."

Yeah.

And people have gotten wise to that.

Yes.

Yes.

That's why they're doing it cuz they got wise to that whole five and six player expansions on their own aren't selling well enough. So, we got to like give them a five and six player expansion and this card that you only get in this

But usually it's not that blatant. It usually is like, "Here's a whole section. Also, it's a fifth player." And I And then I will complain and be like, "Why did I want the fifth player? Now I got to pay for that extra part of that expansion." But also, that's another player color. And so, I I've done that before, but I I can't speak for everybody. But I I I know they don't sell well. for most games.

I feel like this is

Except for Cosmic Encounter, which you should

I don't know if I would agree with this because I would say if it's a five or six player expansion and that's all it offers, I think very few people would just buy that just for the color. But if it is part of something else, then yeah, certainly that's not going to be a deciding factor. And you treat it as like, "Oh, an extra color."

Oh, cool. I have orange now.

Yeah.

Like I didn't like the the Heat expansions, I want the map.

Mhm.

It comes with orange, cool.

Yeah.

Right. Right.

And I think the better way to do this is make that extra thing something different. Thunderroad, right? The the big rig and

Yeah, right.

motorcycles. People play that five and six player. They treat it like a five six player expansion.

Right, right, right.

But it's also new content that's meaningful for fewer than four people.

I think that more companies need to go the route that uh the Suburbia big box did and just have the entire Pantone playbook in every game.

colors.

Have 20 colors in every game.

All right.

Uh this one was definitely split right down the middle. Almost almost evenly slight tilt towards agree.

Wow.

All right. People will likely not agree with Mark L who says, "Roll and write {slash} flip and write is not a genre of games."

Right.

Every roll and write could be played with physical components like a board and tokens that replace a pad and pencil.

Correct.

We don't call games cardboard token game. It has nothing to do with mechanisms at all. If I have a bunch of number tokens and circles and X tokens, I could play Welcome To without a pencil. Anyway, I don't really care about this at all, but it is time to make a shot at Mark when it is just a component alternative. Then he sent me another email

Oh, boy.

that said, "Now that I've had five minutes to reflect, I guess I mean it's not a mechanism. I guess genre is okay, but it's definitely not a mechanism. Doesn't change gameplay at Oh, in any way. I'd love to hear the argument Z."

OH!

WOW, YOU'RE CALLED OUT.

YOU'RE CALLED OUT.

YOU DON'T SPEAK FOR ROLL AND WRITE.

I'M BLAST.

I know, I'm on blast. I'm in the hot seat. Um I don't disagree that that he's right that it's kind of a componentry thing that we are associating with this kind of game. But you also have to admit that they feel very similar to each other often times and it's not just because of the sort of uh the delivery method. It's not just that. I don't know what I would call that, but it is this idea of like you're given a piece of information and then you are filling in a board, filling in a grid, creating a pattern.

I don't know what a genre is.

Yeah, they they feel similar to each other.

Right. And I agree that yes, many times you're like, "Well, this could just be tile. I put tiles in the squares instead of writing a little, you know, drawing a little tree or whatever. 100% [clears throat] and in fact there were games like that before

Let's make a bus route became the on board

Get on board which is not a roll and write anymore technically flip and write.

Cartographers it's like they have those pieces that you can instead of drawing you put the pieces on there.

I mean rather dice game. Which came out many years ago rather dice game could be a roll and write.

Today it would be probably although they reprinted it but yeah very much good.

Feels like a roll and write before roll and write were a thing because you were taking cubes and putting them in a grid.

Yeah.

That's it. I mean you could do this with anything right? Um But what else would you call that?

Yeah, I mean I think technically maybe he's right.

Yeah, the mechanism it's definitely a genre like he I mean he corrected himself there.

I think it's a mechanism because it you might it might be incorrectly named but you are rolling or flipping and doing something whether it's writing or putting a tile on it's that that's a mechanism of a game whether you call it bingo or Yahtzee or whatever.

Yeah, tile laying games could just be cube placement games right? You replace everything with a tile you just have cubes of different colors or it could just be a drawing game but it's still a tile laying game.

Right.

I think he's arguing almost a little bit to the point of is it a mechanism or is it like an ergonomic interface?

And

And therefore why should it be called after that?

I should think they should be called ergonomic interface games.

Mhm.

I like that EIG that rolls right off the tongue.

A lot of games are about that.

Um

No, I don't disagree with this at all. I don't I don't appreciate being put on blast the way I was. Man, properly attached.

Speaking for all roll and write.

If anyone is associated with roll and write slash flip and write it's Z Garcia.

say the voters though did disagree very strongly. There was only seven people agreed and 33 disagreed and 17 of those were hard disagrees.

Okay, the bigger question is ratchet. Is that a genre of games?

All right, that's not what I'm talking about.

Uh if you want to vote, link in the description of the video. All right, this next one's an interesting take from Joseph S, who says Full art sleeves are always a mistake. He said this is directed more publishers. I don't blame people for not knowing how often art stickers come off after the first couple shuffles. I But even if that doesn't happen, there will never be enough spares for when splitting. Sleeves protect fancy hard to replace items. They shouldn't be fancy and hard to replace.

Yes. Yes, I agree, too. And they'll become faded. Your new ones won't match up perfectly. It's Yeah, I

You think they should be clear always?

Well, or

No, they can be standard colored, but he's talking about the ones that have a printed image.

Full art, yeah.

Full art are are are glued, heat pressed, whatever it is, onto then just a normal sleeve. And you shuffle

Shuffle that enough, they'll they'll they'll start to

they'll peel off.

Most libraries like most games in our DiceTower library that have that like it comes standard in it. And sometimes not even standard, but like mechanically, I think like Slay the Spire you have to use like solid sleeves and stuff. Those things get destroyed. They're played a few times at a convention. I mean if you say a few, maybe 20. Right? They're messed up by the end of one convention.

And then it is hard to replace it. Like that's

I do like the idea that like what he said there at the end where it's like, you know, the pieces are fancy. The sleeves just protecting the fancy pieces don't need to be fancy. I like that. I like that. I like good feeling sleeves. I don't want fancy sleeves, either. Cuz then they're not doing the job.

Now, I will say for my GameGenic games, for for Star Wars Unlimited, I buy I'm sorry, I buy GameGenic sleeves that have the pictures on the back of them. But those don't bother me mostly because they come in a pack of 60 sleeves, and the the game has 50. So I I 10 spares. So if something if one of them does split, I have one to take its place. And if more than 10 split, well, then I'll get a new set of sleeves. It's not the end of the world.

My issue with this is more that clear sleeves. I I really like sleeves. I like seeing and testing new sleeves. I've reviewed sleeves on the channel before, and I end up then with a deck of that I sleeved with something, and then I want to grow that deck because I want to put in a couple of cards or whatever, and it's going to be wild trying to figure out this Aladdin sleeve. I'll find others and be like, "Oh, I don't think this is the same sleeve." And I Was it a Gamegenic sleeve? No, Gamegenic tends to be taller. Was it Oh my gosh, that's the That's the hard part.

when sleeves have that little marker that tells you what kind of sleeve it is.

Pro dot. I hate that crap.

You just said you want TO KNOW WHAT SLEEVE it is. If Ultra

but I don't want to have to spend having to deal with the Ultra Pro dot.

That dot annoys me cuz I've been PUTTING

I'VE BEEN PUTTING it on the back.

It's a new hot tag.

And half You put it on the back or the front?

Hate the dot. I hate it when people are like, "I don't care if it goes on the back. If I don't care."

It does go on the back.

I put it on the back. You have to put it on the front normally cuz you can mark a card otherwise.

But the agents of chaos don't care.

If it's your own deck, you can mark the backs.

No, that's the same deck.

No one's on that side.

NO, NO, NO.

NO, that's a roll and write. You're talking about roll and write now. No.

I've never seen that.

Those people, they're not around anymore. They don't know about BGG.

Uh Renee said that Slay the Spire I didn't mean to call them out. I'm not like putting them on blast, but they fixed it later, which I, you know, kudos to that cuz that first edition didn't have it.

an errata pack, and I refuse to participate.

Well, the sleeves came in a box that can hold everything.

No, okay. Okay.

All right. Well, most people agreed with this one. It was 35 agreed, 13 disagreed.

No, it's good. That's a good one.

Yeah.

Yeah.

All righty. Matt S says, "When people cite their main reason for disliking Wingspan as, 'I just don't care about birds,' their real reason for disliking it is that it is a popular game."

So, anyone that doesn't like it doesn't like it cuz it's popular.

No, no. He's saying if they say it's because I don't care about birds, but they really mean

They might They might dislike it just cuz they don't like the mechanism but if what they're saying is I just don't care about birds, then I guess it's because it's popular. I mean, that's

Yeah, my issue is this is what you're making way too absolute a statement for something that probably applies to several people but not every or even the majority.

Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Everyone who likes Wingspan should play different games is what you're saying.

I think Yeah, I think birds are are fine but I can say that I think Wingspan is a good game whether or not I like birds or not.

The thing is, the funny thing about this kind of statement and I've heard it is that I bet if you looked at those people's favorite games, they're probably not particularly with thematic games.

Right.

And I bet they don't care about those topics.

they're like, "Well, it's zombies and stuff." I've seen this happen and I'll be like, "I don't really like that horror theme." And they'll be like,

[snorts]

"Oh, you baby." I'm like, "Yeah."

I just don't like it.

don't It doesn't mean that I'm not like I just don't like it. You said you don't like birds. Is that okay?

Yeah.

He hates dragons. Don't get him started on dragons.

Who doesn't like dragons?

dragons.

That's true.

I I'm fine with Wait. You mean dragons or do you mean wharms?

He's a rabid anti-wharm. I hate wharms. Um no, I I agree with this and I feel like it's the people that say this kind of crap are either the zombie people, horror, whatever, miniatures, or the heavy heavy Euro gamers that definitely do not care about the theme.

Right.

You don't want to run a fast food restaurant that bad. That theme does not like excite you. Calm down. You like it because of what the game does and the way it's respected.

Yeah.

But on the flip side, how can you say like how can people like Tom say, "I don't like the theme so I'm not like this game."

Okay.

But then But then if somebody says, "I don't like birds." Hold on. You can't just not like it because you don't like the bird theme. Everyone loves the bird theme. It's okay if you don't like the horror theme, right? But you can't say you don't like birds. That's impossible. Like I don't not dislike birds. I don't just

I know, I know, I think you're right. Yeah, yeah, yeah. I think you're very I think you're very right as well. It's okay to not be interested because it's wall-to-wall birds.

And and it has become okay to go after people for just being like, "I really don't like the theme."

I still catch strays. I just saw it this past week with someone because I because I did not like the fact that that Chaos in the Old World board was a human skin board.

Yeah, the only thing is the lost edition the lost edition was human stretched human skin, but the basic edition was just cardboard.

Yeah, it looked like

stretched human skin, right.

But then they had the extra spot if you got the cardboard one for the human skin board. And I'm like, I needed that.

All the butcher hooks.

All right. You could just 3D print it.

Uh this one was was was actually split down the middle.

That's interesting.

A few people disagreeing. All right. Well, Bill is about to get pulled the doors down here. Bill says, "I should be able to talk about my kids playing board games without you getting weird about it. I'm sorry that your 15-year-old still can't understand shooting

Oh my goodness.

Stop bragging for parents to be honest when talking about what games their kids like. No, I don't force my daughter to play complicated games. She can choose whichever game she would wants to play and she would enjoy beating you up in Dune Imperium: Uprising. Just because your child inherited your awful board game skills doesn't mean all kids are incapable of playing strategy games.

I think he's not wrong, but I will say it is bragging Bill when we're talking about the weather and you go, "Yeah, I think it will rain today." Just like my daughter can play CO2 and smoke your butt. LIKE, WHAT? I WILL SAY [screaming] NOBODY WAS TALKING about your daughter, Bill.

Your kid might be an anomaly, but I know it's pretty much split down the middle on the ones that brag and don't have that right to brag because there's a kid in our game group who can't play anything, right? But there's also like people like, "Oh, my kid just loves Nucleum." I'm like, "Awesome." After we trade or I sit there and play it. You're playing through that kid, man. That kid would rather be out there on his tablet.

I'm sorry.

So, I've seen that, too. So, I've seen

seen that a lot. People do that more than the than the than the Einsteins.

People get weird about it because they are reacting to something that actually happens a lot in this hobby, which is parents being weird about their kids playing Lacerta games at 7 years old. I'm sorry. It's a reaction to a thing that actually happens often enough that people are annoyed with it. Bill, your child might be a great game player and it may not be an issue, but I'm sorry, this is a thing and that's why people are reacting to it and they're getting weird. I don't think the people reacting are getting weird are being weird. I think it's a response to a weird thing that happens in the board game world.

There's also the fact that often times, if I go to a place and I go to a conven- whatever, I want to sit down at the table and play a game for adults for all intents and purposes because of what it demands of people, I don't necessarily want to be playing next to a 12-year-old I don't know. I don't really want to hang out with children that I don't know. I barely want to hang out with the ones I do know.

This is the biggest thing right here. I don't care if your kid can play Lacerta with us. I would like to spend some time with other adults because not only the game, it's the the conversation we're going to have, everything to spend time with a It does not matter if your kid wants to play it. I

The fact that they can handle the mental load does not make them an adult.

Right. Sweet. Play with them at home, but I may want to spend time with adults.

Yeah, that's kind of my bigger thing is that

the feeling of being with other grown-ups and maybe somebody will go talk about their work. Somebody will talk about something adult related, you know what I mean? And then I don't have to be like, "Oh, that we're boring the kid." Or "We shouldn't talk about that in front of the kid." Yeah, that's a little weird to me.

Yes, I agree. Uh, and I like kids outside of games.

Yeah, it's not the mental load of them handling it. That's fine. It's the it's the maturity at the table.

Right.

Yeah, and I've definitely found there to be a direct correlation with how much you brag about your kids being good at those games and how good they actually are. This past Friday, I had a a bunch of school kids come in with their parents and I said it was it's four fourth grade and higher cuz I just didn't want to deal with the little kids in the same and one one teacher was like, "This kid can't come unless their sister comes with them and she's in second grade." And I was like, "Fine. Whatever." And so she showed up and we played a game and I my mouth kept dropping as we played this game cuz this second grader was clearly better than every other person in that room. You know, and I was really surprised and I mentioned it to her dad and he was just like very reserved like, "Yeah, yeah, she's you know." But he didn't make a big deal about it.

Yeah.

And I appreciate that. I noticed it.

Right.

He didn't come up and be like,

She can handle it.

Because I didn't even realize it when they first sat down to play a game, I was like, "Well, she should be on someone's team." That's what I always say, right?

She's with him and then I was watching him play and she was telling the dad what the good moves were.

Mhm.

Something I've seen in this area.

Yeah. The dad was an idiot.

I didn't say that.

But her brother was there and she was also better than him.

So the brother was also It sounds like a family of idiots.

Who are these people, Tom?

No, but but again, I think it's the same way like I think it's good to be proud of your kids. That's that's fine.

I think so, too. Yeah.

I don't mind that, but it's the same thing as when someone comes up and then every day they're like, "Look at this. My kid got a all A's." You're like, "That's great."

Mhm.

Now I feel worse though cuz my kid's a C student. You know, I'm glad that your kid's doing so great, but calm down a bit.

Yeah.

never be ashamed that my kids like kids games.

Right.

I agree.

Or may not like games at all.

That's what's crazy. It's like cuz my daughter's not a prodigy by any stretch. She'll play some of the games that are more, but she will likes the kids games. And there are times you want to play those. You know, let me be a kid, too.

And I'm sorry. I I'm

It's not gatekeeping.

It's not gatekeeping and no one's advocating driving kids out of the hobby. I just think that there's a uh there needs to be a recognition that this has been something that has been in this board gaming space for years.

Because board games necessitate other players at the table. There is that drive for Uber gamers to drag their kids into their hobby early. This is not solely about board games. Anybody who's into anything like the dad's got the kid out there playing catch. Be like you will like baseball.

Yes.

Do it. They're barely able to hang on to please you. Recognize that. Let the kid be a kid. And if they want to be a gamer, great.

Right.

If not, let them find their own things.

That's exactly it.

Okay. This reminds me of my friend my poor friend who is not left-handed

[clears throat]

but does everything in life left-handed because his dad raised him and said, "Well, I want one of my kids to be a lefty because they have an advantage in baseball and in several sports." So, he trained my friend to be a left-handed

Yes. Yes. Get him in here now.

So, now who is [clears throat] not athletic self-describedly and fairly uncoordinated

Can't drive. Can't eat.

Cuz he cannot because he hadn't have like a whole lifetime of practicing doing things with his ACTUAL DOMINANT HAND.

SAD STUFF, CHRIS.

This is terrible. Way to bring down the room.

Wow.

Call him out. I thought Danny was going to be ambidextrous. He's just he

He's neither dextrous.

Neither dextrous.

He's non-dextrous.

So.

That's better.

Correlating this to there are too many parents who are overbearing in whatever thing. That my friend's dad a little overbearing on the sports side of things. You know, and so Yes, that is crazy. But also [clears throat] keep in mind are you doing that to your kids? Bill, you're probably not. Your kid is probably enjoying their games and everything. That's fine. But just make sure that they at the end are the ones driving the interest instead of you saying like

exactly it. I'll say Bill called I'm saying stupid so I'm not feeling too bad.

They asked to play a game because they want to spend time with you or whatever.

Yes.

No, no, no.

Sometimes that's

And also I mean there there people have been mentioning in the comments too but it it you may not be as a parent you may not be as aware that while your child may be a wonderful human being a fantastic game player. I'm I'm not this isn't leading to it. I'm being serious. It will likely change the tenor and you were kind of alluding to this of the table, right?

Right, right, right.

People may not be as comfortable I'm not talking about profanity or anything like that.

that.

It will often times change the whole makeup of the table, the conversation because you're going to have again different interests, you know, you're you're not going to be able to just speak freely often times.

Adults get so little time to spend with other adults. That's just the way society is now. And I think games provide you that. But when you put a kid in there, you will just subconsciously cater the conversation to something the kid will get because it's not it's rude to do otherwise. You know? But if you can't, you will talk about work. You will talk about things that matter to adults. And that's okay.

And I and and no one here is saying don't bring your kid up to us at a convention right? Like but I think that there is you should just be aware that that is a little bit more of an ask if you're going to say would you like to play this hour like a three hour affair with me? That is that is a little different of an ask.

[cough]

I agree. I [clears throat] agree.

It doesn't bother me as much but also I've I don't know that I've sat in and played a Lacerda with a 12 year old, you know, or 12 is again pretty decent age.

His daughter would smoke you at Lacerda. Yes. Yes, she would.

Francis has sent in a bunch of [clears throat] uh hot takes here and so I combined two of them

Okay, Francis.

So this first one he said stop demonizing [clears throat] tryhards.

not.

To me when you label someone as a tryhard, you're just saying that they're a competitive person who who's extremely familiar with the game they're playing and is playing to win. Obviously anything can be taken to it extreme can become toxic and obnoxious, but calling someone a try-hard simply for becoming engrossed in a deeper strategy and then beating everyone because of it seems pretty lame. Maybe try asking for tips instead. He also said, "Playing games to win and or prioritizing the competition in the game experience is okay. If you are playing a game with one winner, then competition is inherent to that experience and if that makes you uncomfortable for whatever reason, then communicating that is on you."

I think the second point is the easier one to sort of deal with. It's certainly don't play a competitive game without trying to win.

If you're not trying to win, you are not playing the game correctly and I strive to play games correctly. Um I also know it's a game.

Mhm.

I also know that it is there are levels of of effort. I know at the end of the night, if I lose, I'm not going to be beaten or not go to dinner, you know, go to bed with on an empty stomach. So, there are levels there. I'm trying to win because the game, this activity that we are all engaging in for fun, mind you, um demands that. I will certainly try that.

You're also aware that there are people on the table.

There's a line between the importance that that separates this being an actual important, you know, thing and then a toy, a game, an activity we're doing for for kicks. That's when you cross that line, that's when I guess we could call somebody a try-hard.

Yeah, because I don't like playing a game with all don't like playing if someone doesn't care about winning.

Oh, it's horrible. It's much worse, actually. I would I would much rather try with somebody who is taking things way too seriously than the person who is just going, "I'm going to play my cards randomly and see what happens."

That's just That ruins it for us. That's the worst.

But if your entire enjoyment is tied on whether or not you win, that's also a problem, you know? Cuz like I I I had somebody like Jake message me he played Kingdom Come: Deliverance and he's like, "I loved it. I got crushed, but I loved it." And that's cool. To actually enjoy the game no matter if you win or lose.

I just I think that that this is kind of a a false kind of a equivalency here because they're saying stop demonizing tryhards and then gives their own definition of a tryhard that almost none of us would agree with.

Correct. Yeah, I think I agree. Someone mentioned in the comments that it the attitude uh matters behind this and we've all played with someone and we're like, "Listen, buddy. Calm down."

Yeah.

You know, that you're this is not the end of the world that this is this tryhard nature often causes people to play very slowly, to get angry when they lose. A lot of the negative stereotypes that we come come from this thing where your your identity is whether you win or not. That's exactly it. And yes, then we're calling you a tryhard. But someone who's trying hard to win doesn't make you a tryhard.

I agree 100%. That's it. You you hit the nail on the head. And it's not even the playing slowly for me specifically, if you're playing slowly because you're taking your time, because you're having a harder time parsing what's happening, I don't mind that at all.

Mhm. It's very

other thing you said. It's that whole you're getting angry as the game goes on because you're lagging in points, you're you're physically and actively upset at the end of the game because you lost. We are not playing games anymore. It's a game.

Yeah.

I didn't do anything to you. Nobody here assaulted you for real, took anything of yours for real. Like that's wild, man.

Go check your car.

Yeah. Yeah.

I took everything during your turn.

If you make a sub-optimal turn like a turn ago and you're like, "Ah, that's the reason I lost." I love the people who are like, "Ah, that sucked. Next time I won't."

Mhm. Yeah.

But some people are like, "Man, mhm [clears throat] I just wish" and just

recover, right? If you don't recover, that's also that that can be difficult, yeah.

Right. And it's about bringing down as as some people said in the chat, like the mood of the table, the experience for everybody else. That's what we're saying a tryhard is. Like a tryhard is someone that them Everyone should try genuinely hard to win the game.

Yeah.

Exactly. But if you then broach into that territory of ruining the mood for everybody else because of it. That's a try-hard. You And And Francis himself said, "Don't demonize try-hards." Yeah, there are people who take it to a toxic level.

Yeah, that's who we're talking about.

what we're talking about.

That's what we're talking about. If your need to win is more important than the experience of the other people at the table,

That's good to

it's a problem. Yes.

It's Is it a little weird if someone comes and says, "Oh, you know, Chris, you know, we played Brass Birmingham 2 months ago. We're going to play it again. I've read up on a bunch of strategy and all of this and I'm going to crush you blah blah blah." That's That's not a great attitude. That makes me feel kind of dumb, you know, now to be playing with someone who's

targeted, right? I mean, he's a He's He's targeting you. He's kind of coming for you.

Right. That That kind of breaches past that like, "I'm going to try hard to win this game."

Yeah. I also thought that the the bit about "Don't demonize these people. If you suck, ask him for tips instead."

That's wild.

Yeah.

That's a wild take to be like, "You're so Oh, you are really difficult to play games with because you're you're visibly getting upset as you lose

Mhm.

or as like you made a mistake and you're not recovering. Could I get some tips instead from you though?

your way.

Yeah, I'm like, "No."

Okay, weird side thing on this. How is it different than like if you play Mortal Kombat get crushed, then you go home and you're like, "I'm going to learn those moves to do that."

Mhm.

You know, and then go try to play it again.

I think that's fine. I don't

Yeah.

No, no, I think it's

You can do that.

Yeah.

But you're not also you're not tied to

Yeah.

It's not It's when you lose Mortal Kombat and you get a handful of quarters and throw them at the guy's face. That's a problem.

It's It's the reason I've never played it again.

But yes, I

I got your quarter. Yeah, I got your quarter.

And most people disagreed with this one. Jay.

Oh, and somebody says, "Why then why is it okay in chess?" Chess people are toxic.

It's not okay in chess. People who do that are jerks.

Yes. Yes. The The The

And also world champions

Magnus Carlsen

Magnus Carlsen

Magnus Carlsen, whenever I see a video of him, I think

He's a jerk.

He stops me from ever wanting to play chess. The fact that he comes up, shakes the hand, doesn't look at the person, is rude, hits the table when he loses, walks away. If someone beats him, he acts like it And when he wins, he's very cocky. I hate everything about that.

Chess and Donkey Kong have a world championship.

thing for the chess hobby.

Right.

Yeah.

I will never play competitive chess because of competitive chess players.

I would rather play that than yeah.

I'd rather chow when they when you mix them together. Have you seen the world champion Donkey Kong play chess?

Okay. Jay says,

up the rules like that.

"People who don't like playing games, but still come to game night to hang out, should sit out on the games. Forcing yourself to join a game where you actively struggle to learn because you have no interest or taking chaotic turns because that's more fun for you spoils the game for everyone else." So, how big

this.

How big of a problem is this though?

I don't know. I mean, for Jay it happens every time.

No, but this happens I know for a lot of people they'll invite someone over to come play games. And that person will bring their significant other or often the person they're dating at this point in time. They barely know this person.

Or their pool guy.

And they'll be like, "Oh, they want to play games too." And the person is like, "I don't really care about games." And they'll go, "Come on, join us in this game." And that person comes and you're like, and that person doesn't really get games. They don't even want to play.

Yeah.

Usually, they're not the ones, in my experience, who insist that they play. It's the person who brought them like, "Come on." And I'm like,

But they're new. I mean, I remember when I first was like, "The board game disciples, everyone's going to love board games. They just have to find the right one."

You just need to say, "Yeah, like you don't have to play games. Just give them a cat toy or something. They'll keep themselves occupied and you play your game. Put a movie on."

Yeah, no, I guess maybe in some groups this is an issue. I I haven't had too much of this, but yeah. I mean, it wouldn't be

But you also cultivate your game nights, right?

Oh, I cultivate

It's like you know the ones that are coming. You love farming games.

It's Yeah, I don't I don't think I disagree with this really. There's it's just kind of

it's a yeah, it's very good.

If someone doesn't want to be It's kind of like

[clears throat]

don't I'm not trying to sound inflammatory. Don't invite me to your crochet circle because I will not be able to participate in any meaningful way.

[snorts]

I wouldn't mind learning how to crochet.

If somebody's falling behind in the crocheting and they get visibly angry, I'll be like, "Could I have some tips on how you"

Knit one, purl Come on! MADE A MISTAKE.

ALSO, GAME NIGHT SORRY, but game night for me are more like I'm going to invite these three people over cuz I want to get these games played. It's not like you can also invite someone.

Yeah.

Party are different, but this is

That's happened to me. If I invite you and you invite the people I wasn't accounting for, that's a little weird.

It's not Yeah, don't

Bring a friend.

I've had it happen though. Like I'm playing a four-player game, invite three people, one of those person brings someone.

Yeah.

And I'm like, they're like, "Oh, can they play too?"

Well, I guess we're playing the game.

Guess who's not invited to the next one.

Right.

Get the five-player expansion so I can have a worse version of the game.

Right.

It comes full circle.

My eight-year-old was smoking me in

problems with the voting stuff here briefly. Let's see if this fixes it.

Voting page is stuck.

Yeah, the voting page I don't know what's going on with it. Um okay. The next one is the main appeal for says Mark S. For solo games modes is that players can cheat without consequences.

THIS IS

SO IGNORANT. THIS IS SO IGNORANT.

I almost can't even believe this is a good faith argument. The main appeal for solo games is that players can cheat without consequences? I'm I'm so confused by this.

silly.

No, this this shows a fundamental misunderstanding of I think why most people play solo games. And that I'm being charitable with that.

Yeah, yeah, I was going to say not a misunderstanding, just a a willful

Yeah.

ignorance to the fact that someone could possibly enjoy a medium or a piece of art differently than you. The only reason why people like watching XYZ type of movies is because they are inferior to me.

Yeah, I don't get this at all. That's Are you trying to allude to the fact that these people really, really want to win and they'll cheat in order to win? Then you can just say, "Okay, I I you're alone."

Yeah.

You just say like, "I pull the game off the shelf, put it on the table, and go."

I've triumphed, and then put it back on the shelf.

Yeah. Like, I don't understand this at all.

again, this is very silly.

This is There there's 45 votes. It's

Mike says that Mark is full of crap.

Okay. I

Let's go to our title topic.

much more diplomatic way.

Our title topic from Craig P says, "We do not need a first player token. We are adults, and I'm pretty sure we can figure it out."

But, that's where they get to be creative.

Um What? Sure, many times it's fairly unnecessary.

Sure.

But, sometimes it matters.

Sometimes it's hugely important.

But, it just

It's the same argument as like, "We don't need a scoring pad. We can just figure it out." Yes, but it's helpful, probably. There's a reason they included it. If the first player token is important, it's in there. There's a There's a slippery slope here. You can start taking things away.

You don't need to include dice. Everyone has dice.

And just like, "Oh, you don't need a worker placement. You don't need all the meeples. The last worker you put out, you'll just take it back right right away. So, you can actually just give me one fewer worker, and I'll just say, 'My last one's here. We good? We good. I'm taking them all back.' You don't need the last guy. No, man. Slippery slope.

There's

I just think this is silly.

In a 30-minute game, you can remember who went first. But, if someone in a 4-hour game, you're like, "Uh I think we started with you, right?"

If it's important to remember who went first,

Right.

give me a token.

So many times that you get to the end of the game, you're like, "And so, we all get one final round starting with the start player."

Who was it?

I think it was you. The first player marker is like, it was you. As dumb as it is, it often matters.

I agree.

It doesn't need to be a you know, a a giant sword.

Oh, there are

You could have made a very different hot take here that I think [clears throat] we all would have agreed with. Not this one.

I I like when there's one player board that has the little symbol printed on it, or it's a slightly different color. You know what I mean? If you don't want to make a whole another punch out token or something. Cool, man. Like that's

the exploding kittens little cone. Things like that.

The cone is subtle. Subtle goes a long way. I agree with you, Joey.

All right. Well, this one was highly disagreed with by the people watching. Craig has another one. He says, "If your 12-year-old brought to an adult game group can't handle not going first, even if he has eaten the most marshmallows this week, then he shouldn't be here. If you find it offensive, YOU SHOULDN'T BE THERE."

WOW.

IT'S ALL ABOUT THE marshmallow test.

Okay. I will say this. I think

Good stuff.

We talked about the kids earlier.

Yeah. Yeah.

Um and bringing them how we'd always want to bring them.

about the same child?

Well, maybe. But I do think you need to be mindful of your child. I was really thinking about this because a couple weeks ago, me, Mike, and Jimmy played a game. And the whole time I was like, "All right. Jimmy, calm down here." Cuz he just he just was like wide open. I don't know how he was

a child, right?

And it it was like he was being very age appropriate. But you know what? It was my responsibility. I definitely didn't be like, "Here's Jimmy, Mike. You got this?"

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. No.

Which I hate. But also, yeah, you need to teach your kids. When I When I see my kids Every single one of my kids has gotten angry about something in a board game. And I deal with that right away cuz I don't want that to be when they're 20.

You also asked me if I was okay with it, which you absolutely didn't need to do, but it was it was a very, you know, like a considerate thing to do. You right?

Yes, but I also always think about the fact that you sometimes will come up and be like, "Are you okay with them joining?" And like, "Well, you've given me no other option."

Yeah. That's That's true.

You got to be very cautious.

No. That's not really a That was a polite thing to say, but he

Yes.

In that scenario, you're not really being asked. Like if somebody comes up with the kid and they're like, "Yeah, I'm going to just write Say right to their face, I really don't want them here." No, you're not going to do that. That's a fake choice.

Also, it was very much a game that was appropriate to be playing with someone Jimmy's age.

Yeah.

Mhm.

I think it's also good as a as a gamer to teach your kid to be a good gamer if If going to get him into that.

No. We're not talking about winning and losing or being good at the strategy either, okay? Those things are important, but

Social skills.

Yes.

Also, as a magician, the biggest thing is I see other magicians that have their kids be horrible spectators on stage.

When did that happen? Never seen it.

Oh, you were there for that.

Oh, it's Yes. So, that's one of the things that's like at the game or the same way. It's like if your kid's a jerk for gamer, you got to nip that or don't let him play.

Absolutely.

That's your Be a parent.

Yeah, you know.

those lessons, especially it's your job is that your responsibility as the parent, right? They're not just another player. They are actually your responsibility, right? So,

They reflect on you.

Right. They yeah, keeps them at home, teaching them good habits and all this stuff, and then yeah, it's

Unless you dump them off at a table playing Everdell and then you go play Food Chain Magnet, then it's fine.

I've seen that done before and I don't like Yes.

It's not ideal, no. And it's funny because his example here, I don't know if he means uh uh not going first.

Yeah, I think he does mean that.

kid cried cuz they didn't go first.

Cuz they didn't go first.

That's the thing. Yeah.

They had though eaten the most marshmallows that week. Let's just put that out there.

But I do agree with this last sentence here. He says, "If you find that offensive, you shouldn't either." And Chris said your kid reflects on you. If you bring your kid to an event and that kid's a pain in the neck and I'm running that event, then you are going to miss the next invite to the event. You are. And that's even if it's not a kid. If you bring an annoying spouse, friend with you, and they're a pain in the neck, and we have to babysit that person, then you're not invited.

Yeah, it's not about kids because I've had a lot of kids act a lot better than adults. So,

Yes. Yeah, exactly. Yeah, if you if you bring someone in to an event and you don't help them and make sure that they're comfortable, that they're good, and also the other way around, that they're acting a appropriate for the event, then yeah, that it's on you.

Well, not a hot take, everyone agreed. All right. Here's one for us. Matt S says, "When it comes to top 10 list, 10 to 5 is way more interesting than 4 to 1. The top of the list is typically a rapturous and repetitive veneration of sacred cows and flavors OF THE

OH, THE BIG WORDS.

OH, the big words.

That big word again. Slowly and distinctly.

to hear about how much you love Ticket to Ride again. The bottom of the list is the island of misfit toys and this really tells me who you are as a gamer.

I agree with this.

I kind of agree.

Me, too.

A lot of times, in fact, I think every time we do a top 10 list it should just be 10 10 through 5 and then the rest were like, you know,

You know.

We'll turn it off.

Mhm.

Thanks Matt for this. Click.

Yeah. Yeah, I mean

I agree.

I agree cuz a lot of times the top of our list are games that we've talked about in other lists.

You know what [snorts] I mean? It's just the bottom line.

Yeah. You can't just not

Right.

include them because

Exactly.

You not every Not every person has watched the hundreds of other Dicebreaker videos.

it. That's what it is. That's it.

But I will say Matt, very eloquent.

Yeah.

Mhm.

Yeah, very eloquent.

suppositive.

The S stands for thesaurus.

Okay, let's move on.

And people get that.

Adam C says,

Wait. Wait. Wait.

Playing a digital implementation of a solo game is the worst of both worlds.

cheat, Mike.

YOU LOSE THE

YOU LOSE THE TACTILE FEEL AND THE OVERVIEW of the mechanics while sticking with the limited complexity afforded by an analog game. Just go play Belatro.

No, I think this is the best because I don't want to set up a solo game.

It's the only way to play solo.

It is so funny like how many people are like deeply offended that solo games exist.

Is that a weird thing cuz it really doesn't affect you at all. It's

Yeah. It's a perfect encapsulation of you do you, boo.

Right, cuz you're not affecting me.

The only only argument against solo gaming that I give any credence to really is when Tom mentions that it can make the cost of the game go up. Sure, that that's an actual thing.

Don't side with this guy.

Right.

No, you are basically Adam.

Most of the people that are complaining about solo games just don't play them. Why do you got to get upset that other people like to play solo games?

I kind of like playing it on the app a little better cuz I don't have to pull out the game and set up all the

That's my point. Nobody said that yet.

Mhm.

That's why I'm doing it.

I just Yeah, I don't get that.

It's It's insane to me to say that it is a flaw that something has limited complexity because of its analog form. Like, yes, that is true if you are trying to make uh Elder Scrolls Sentinel, the board game.

Don't even get me STARTED ON THAT.

YEAH, IT'S IT'S GOING TO BE MORE restrictive than playing an immersive massive open world game. But also, games are made to be what they are, and I like that experience. I like interacting with that system at its level of complexity. I don't need to say like, "What's the most complex video game out there?"

Yeah, I was going to say the same thing.

Balatro, huh, how about quad latro where you're playing four balatros at once?

Yeah, I might not I kind of like playing Wordle with 10 Wordles at one time.

Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

I know you like that. Is that still going?

I haven't done it in a while.

Oh, we got to get back into Wordle, y'all.

Um No, but Wordle's definitely still going. My family every day argues about it.

Anyway, I don't Yeah, I don't know about this. I It's one of those flavor things. Pick your the flavor you like. I I don't know. Yeah, I I I There's some games I really enjoy a digital implementation for. Some I don't.

Mhm.

Some I think are better solo, but it's only per game basis, the way that game makes me feel, maybe the game has dice and I want to physically roll dice. Some something silly like that.

Yeah.

Mhm.

Onirim, fantastic I don't have to shuffle all the time. But also, sometimes You want to shuffle the cards out.

Right, right.

Marvel Champions had a good solo app. Would you play that a lot?

Yeah, I There's There's a couple of online implementations. I've been able to get one to work, and I've played on there a couple times. It's fine. Yeah.

Do you like a tactile or you like actually playing it, too?

More. Yeah, yeah, yeah, right.

Okay. He has another take which I think is a much more

[clears throat]

might be slightly more divisive cuz this one people mildly disagreed. A lot of people aren't even bothering to vote at this point, but you

My opponent is atrocious.

Go ahead.

Adam says, "Playing cooperative games with people you don't know is stupid. If I want to save the world or something, I want a close-knit group of people who I can trust and whose skill I know. It's different with competitive games since there's a lot of joy in beating DOWN ON RANDOS."

WOW, I hate everything about this take.

Can I Somebody saying, "Can I play this with you?" I don't know you.

It's like

THAT'S MY FIRST NO, I DON'T KNOW YOU.

WHAT KIND OF game is it? Competitive? Sit down, rando. I'M GOING TO WHALE on you.

It's like the first part of it I was like, "Oh, this is terrible." And I'm like, "Oh, it gets worse."

This is amazing.

This is is the best.

terrible This is a terrible take in every sense.

You know You know

You know that movie trope where only the closest-knit group of friends comes together to save the world? You never have to work out things in a in a setting with people you don't know.

Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Never has have people been foisted into situations with unknown randos.

There's no drama in that. Oh, wait. That's the only way you get any sort of exciting spark.

Han Solo, my old childhood friend, let's go blow up yon Death Star.

so this guy's getting beat up everywhere and which way, but I will say I I would say I do agree that I think a cooperative game with people you know is more fun

Yes.

than with people you don't know.

Most games are

usually, but more most games are more fun.

Yeah, yeah, I think that there are some especially like um word games or things that yeah, it really is a much different experience with people you know. Or how well do you know the people around the table? I mean, there are cooperative games where that's the game. And it's like, well, yeah, with people you don't know, it's not going to be a terrific experience, right?

I find myself

Yeah, yeah, yeah.

I find myself in a in competitive games, I can be more aggressive with people I know cuz I know no one's going to get offended. And I'm like Yeah, see?

I would never I I would not have played that way against a stranger.

That's true. I appreciate

100%. Yeah, right. It's cuz I you know, I didn't realize I would cause quite so much trauma.

outside the family.

But yeah, no, I don't know. I I almost feel like

like I think his first take there is very inflammatory, but it's not like Thomas saying something crazy. Saying it's stupid, come on. But saying it's different, totally different, yeah, sure.

Yeah.

The second part is the really wild part. It's like, "Oh, it's like almost like a PS, I love beating on Rando."

I almost feel like I'm going to, you know, give a little grace to Adam and I'll say the one thing here is that he definitely understood the assignment. This is a hot take.

And I think it was done to create this type of a response.

He does have three hard agrees, but

Oh my goodness.

But there are 41 disagrees, so

I love it.

All right. Arthur G says, "You can't see the rule book if you're going to fold it. Use two hands."

Wait, what?

when someone asks to see the rule book during a game and begins to bend the spine of the rule book, holding the front COVER OVER THE

PREACH, ARTHUR. PREACH.

and Boeing the pages.

Thoughts, Tom?

Here's my thoughts. If it's my game, I'll do what I want, Michael.

Okay.

Yeah, if it's Arthur's game, you don't Yes, treat other people's property

You are right, Tom.

with a nicer assumption than then you treat yours.

You wouldn't do that to my game.

Well, no, but I might I remember when I went to BGG for the thing and I was teaching games at their hot games room and they they kept coming to me like, "Please don't bend the rule book backward." I'm like, "Oh, I'm sorry." And I would then I'd start doing cuz I They're too big. It ain't my fault. Publishers make books that I can hold in one hand. Every other book I don't need two hands to read.

It ain't my fault.

I don't I think

12-year-old that wants to go first. Almost every book I read is two-handed.

You can read a paperback with one hand. What are you talking about?

but it's uncomfortable to read a paperback one-handed.

I agree with that, Tom. You've been reading on a phone

Yeah, you've got 10 years you've been reading on your

You don't even own any rule books.

But But again,

when you read on your phone, it goes like this.

The reason I fold them back isn't even that, it's that it's blocking It's blocking the view of the game board.

I 100%

agree that often times rule books are larger than need to be. Even speaking of someone that that doesn't see that great. But I don't I don't know. It's just to me it's a thing like bending cards. Like I I don't it just It's it's an Look, at the end of the day again I I think though that it is your rule book and

You're right. You're right.

It's the same as riffle shuffling. If I'm going to riffle shuffle cards, I better check and make sure it's okay with you.

No, I agree with that. I agree.

I got that.

I agree.

The main thing about having a rule book is that you can't cheat.

Right.

And you can hit randos with it.

Roll it up like a newspaper.

Beat him with a stick.

Like now in a cooperative game. Don't make that move. No.

Okay. All right. Sean says, "I hate when reviewers By the way,

OH, HEY.

I HATE WHEN REVIEWERS SAY, 'IT'S GREAT TO throw in a backpack or play in a park bench or take out to eat. It's not a selling point. No one would ever take their games to such places and if they did, THEY SHOULD BE ASHAMED.'"

NO ONE.

I LOVE THESE LIKE absolute statements are the best.

say though there's a slight bit of truth to you like, "Oh, it's a game you throw in a backpack. Take it to the beach." And like, but how often do you do that? You know, I agree. You probably do that less than you say in your head.

Yes. Yes.

Like I've never actually taken a game to the beach. I don't think ever.

Out to eat I think at lunch time and things I think you could do that.

often have you done it?

In my mind?

I

[snorts]

For me it's happened at banquets before where I'm like stuck at a big table and I'm like, "Oh, I have a small game to [clears throat] play."

I have another question. You got into a banquet where I'm assuming you dressed up with a backpack during the groom's speech. He looks over and tells over there to play.

You haven't been to many teacher events then cuz they are boring as all get out.

They are. I just don't sneak games in there.

I don't like to sneak it in. I

Suitcase pocket also.

I will do it. Okay.

I will do any games we play outside.

I I would agree I would agree with a portion of the idea that I think that reviewers in general, and I can even speak for myself, probably make it a bigger selling point that it is the portability of a game.

Yes.

I probably, you know, it's probably not that big of a deal for most people. You know what I mean?

I mean, you but the portability whether you then just took it and went inside someone's house and played there.

Right.

The portability still applies. We are alluding to it being very easy to take with.

Yeah, exactly.

You can say that for most card games, you know.

Play wherever you are.

Yeah, I've definitely done loads of this.

Yes.

But my go-to is Starbucks.

Yeah.

It's been traditionally Starbucks anyway. I haven't done it in a while, but this idea of like, I like this game because I can play it on a Starbucks table, which are kind of small.

Right.

With a coffee nearby.

Spilled onto the cards.

Sometimes, yeah.

Notebook bent backwards.

Heck, yes.

Doused in latte.

I can cheat like crazy. The barista is not going to come after me.

She's a random.

SHE'S A RANDO.

WHAT'S FUNNY BECAUSE I USE YOU SAID the I can throw it in my backpack is like such a different thing because I bring my backpack to my family's house and to friends' places.

I carry it with me. It's it's

You know what I

mean, it's not like a a shocking thing to say, "Oh, I brought a card game to play with my brother when I go visit him."

Yeah, I agree. It's in my backpack.

We would definitely do this kind of thing. Maybe not the beach, but

Right.

Yeah, I've played um Hive

in the ocean.

outdoor settings. Maybe not the beach, but like a pool setting, you know what I mean? So, yeah, it'd happen.

at a whole park or take out to eat.

So, steady, how was your day?

Yeah, right.

I'm like, okay.

So, yeah, I think reviewers should probably only say things that they actually do. Like, I have never once said, "This is a This is a beach game." Cuz guess who hates going to the beach? It's me, right?

And me.

But

I love the beach.

Well, yeah. If someone says something, I I generally take it in good faith that like that doesn't apply to me. It might apply to someone who actually likes going to the beach. Right.

Mhm.

I won't ever play a game outside. I mean, last studio we had a lanai. Played once out there, and I was like, I will I will never do that again.

Right. You didn't like it.

You could just feel those cards really just going

Maybe it's a Florida thing.

Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

The hive tiles start bending.

Mhm.

Yeah, I mean, I figured they wouldn't.

When we were in Miami, we used to play on the at the university there, and the one guy came and opened up the building for us to play games. And if he didn't show up, which could happen, then we were like, "Well, I guess we'll play outside on these tables." It was terrible.

Oh, yeah, yeah.

It's rough.

Sean has another hot take though. By the way, the uh most people disagree with him on this one. Sean's other hot take is, if you roll dice and mess up the board state, you should immediately LOSE THE GAME.

MAN.

[screaming]

OH, SEAN deals in absolutes.

Okay. There's one way There's one way

You TOTALLY REDEEMED YOURSELF.

THERE'S one way I can I would hard agree with this, and that would be to add the word intentionally after you say state. Yeah.

Like, I mean, I've done this several times, and yeah, I feel terrible about it.

We've all done it.

Right.

when you do it the fourth time in the same game?

Yeah, that's That's the problem. Then get out of here.

Everybody gets one pass, right?

Right, right, right.

There's someone I really enjoy playing games WITH WHO SITS BRO! IT'S LIKE, "WHAT ARE YOU DOING?"

OH MY GOODNESS. The crowd I have I have talked to people about that. Like, where they they they're like being reckless with what they're doing. I'm like, "Whoa. I mean, we we can have stuff that we're going to get knocked around here. We have to be a little more reasonable."

to teach Jimmy like, he'll sit there and be like I'm like, "You know, shaking it more

It doesn't do anything.

change anything." But he's like doing this. This is like, "JUST THROW THE DIE." AND THEN EVERY KID There's like a skill I've had to teach every kid. How to roll a die so it stays on on

Yeah.

Every time it's like, there it goes off the table under the couch.

Yes, yes.

Does this annoy you more than the person saying, "I'm sorry. I thought I've yet been yellow the past couple turns." And you're like,

Wait, why are we comparing these two things?

I don't know. These two things annoy me more.

Yeah, messing up the board state. It's like, I don't know how far back you Okay.

At that point you might as well write it off.

Is this Arshan? Okay, yeah.

The theme usually disagrees with my hot take.

Oh, is this Arshan?

Oh, well.

Nice, Arshan. You got us talking.

And not invited anymore to game night.

Also, I am going to be paying close attention every time you roll a die.

Yeah, from now on you're under a microscope.

Strong scrutiny.

I do really like this take though. I with the the forgiveness of like once, right? You roll the dice, you didn't realize these ones clearly clack on this table and you mess up the stuff.

In fact, I think publishers should, besides a start player token, include a token per player that says, "You get one free pass, buddy."

And then you cash it in if you mess something up. If you mess up again, you have to leave.

I will say in Zombicide there's one person I did not want to have the chainsaw because they get six dice, we're going to lose the game.

Oh, boy. Yeah.

Yeah, it's like it's no.

That's all.

All right. I guess it's a different show.

Most people actually Well, this was split actually. All righty. Two hot takes left. Eddie K says, "The use of the word cozy in bo- I spelled that wrong. In board game marketing is completely out of control. It needs to stop. It's bandied around with complete abandon at best whenever a game is rules light or has cute artwork and at worst when a game is half-baked. But let's be honest, the word cozy can never actually apply to a board game. By definition, cozy means giving a feeling of comfort, warmth, and relaxation. But a board game, even the most rules light whimsical game on the market, must have stakes. If it doesn't have stakes, it's not a game. If there are stakes, the experience cannot be entirely relaxing. He started off so well. Furthermore, a cardboard box full of punch boards and components cannot physically make you warm or COMFORTABLE UNLESS YOU SET FIRE to it.

I love this guy.

to call out this lazy marketing buzzword. So, except for that couple paragraphs in the mail, I do agree

I think he should have stopped right there. That I I I'd be much more in board with that because then when I mean, I think he hurt his argument by reading the definition of cozy because I do think that those are feelings that a board game can

can evoke quite well.

Right, right.

Yeah, I agree.

But just because your game involves your collection of books doesn't mean it's cozy.

But I do agree.

I agree and some games do throw it around way too freely.

use it they're talking about the theme. [clears throat]

Right.

And they call the game those cozy and I'm like, this game is cutthroat. But it has cute animals.

I agree. That's the issue. The games are have a cozy theme trappings but don't feel that way. That seems to be the bigger problem. But like board games have been calling themselves this is a horror board game. I've never been scared at a board game in my life, okay? But cozy? Yeah, some games do give you that sort of feeling of yeah, familiarity leads to that. The low stakes, no not no stakes but low stakes.

Yeah, sure.

But I think I think the bigger issue is what the actual statement there is is that I agree that it's become lazy marketing and it's overused.

Yes.

We're just like using anthropomorphic animals that are cute in watercolor. That's become lazy. It's become the easy thing. I don't know what else to put a to put as a theme on this. Anthropomorphic cute watercolor animals. That'll sell.

Yep.

Mhm.

Right.

It at one point it was a selling point.

Yeah, right. The first time you saw Root and Everdell and some of these games.

Sure, sure.

It was kind of inventive, it was kind of fun. And at this point it's just become so commonplace that I'm I'm curious what the next thing will be that people say, "Oh." Right now it's the word dino, by the way.

Mhm.

Tons of games come out with the word dino in the title.

in a big way also. Racing dino games.

Some point.

Yes, there's a few of those.

Yeah, and in in a year there's going to be five more dinosaur racing games and people are going to say, "All right, like this is feels kind of lazy."

Yeah, right, right, right.

It's the hard thing about the industry where games come out 3 years after they're signed and like the, you know, designed and everything. And so, you kind of get this delayed run-on effect of what people are like, "This is what people are into right now." Right. Guess what they're not going to be into in 3 years.

Trick-taking games.

Trick-taking games. Cozy anthropomorphic animal trick-taking games.

been done?

Cozy anthropomorphic trick-taking games? Yeah, sure.

Name six.

Okay.

Uh Trick Takers.

I The idea like someone in the comments said, "I've been scared in board games many times. Every time someone leans on the edge of the table and cards ARE NEARBY."

FAIR. VERY TRUE. That is a terrifying moment, isn't it? That whole like they they do this and they're like, "What's that saying?" I'm like,

"I'll read it to you." That's very true. Very true.

All right, this one was it another split? A lot of seven heart disagrees and 11 heart agrees. All right, final one. Jason B says, "We don't have the right language to describe board game weight. Board game weight should be broken into two categories. How hard it is to learn and how deep is the strategy. War Chest is the perfect example of a game that's easy [clears throat] to learn, but the strategy is incredibly deep to master. We need language to describe the depth of strategy a board game has."

I like this take. I like this take a lot. Yeah, because yeah, we we tend to think of weight in difficulty to learn, to to pick up, the learning curve when strategy would be a better one. And I've made this argument many times with the Reiner Knizia's that a lot of his games I think are very deep strategy with a two-page rulebook.

Sure.

Right.

thought you were like I thought you were saying you've made it with him. I'm like,

No, no, no, I'm just I've made the argument.

Listen, buddy.

I've made this argument, you know, about complexity versus depth. You know what I mean? You know, complexity is just like, you know, if you have mechanism after mechanism after mechanism and chaining this this this and this. Yeah, it can be a heavy game, it could be a complex game, but so could a game like Go, which has how many rules, right? So.

You have a lot of those C style games that are like really like Santorini. So easy, but then there's like a lot of strategy to it.

Sure, and it's all I mean and often it'll be that way, right? It's the rules light game.

Yes.

was trying to think of a lot of depth. The opposite is sucks.

I was trying to think of any game that is the opposite.

and they're terrible out of the gate. Any game that you like have to learn a bunch of rules and then realize there's no juice there worth the squeeze. You're like, well.

Yeah.

That's a dud.

I love that phrase, lift with your brain, not your back.

Mhm.

That's a good That's a good quote for a board game box.

Yeah.

Yeah, I mean onboarding, right? Is maybe like the term for that first thing, like what is the onboarding experience of a game, right? That's where I think Galactic Cruise is which is a game I I champion a lot. It has a very good onboarding experience. Is it a lot of rules to learn up front? Yeah. But is it made in a way that the onboarding is not so hard? Also, yeah.

That's a different thing though. The The sort of like the onboarding versus the entirety of the rules that you're going to have to be dealing with are two different things.

As soon as I said I was like, I think

Yeah.

Like I think onboarding is an important It could even be like a third factor of this concept, but the amount of rules you're going to have to deal with is the sort of how many balls you have to keep up up in the air as you're juggling all of the rules. Um you're right that the language is not perfect, it's not quite there yet. And so we try to when we review things, mention them, describe them, that you know, this is a rules light game. Or it belies the size of the box with how much is in there, mental, you know, that kind of thing. You'll hear those things.

Sure, yeah. No, this is a good take. I agree with this.

Strategic weight versus learning curve.

Mhm.

Yeah, it's not, you know, that's two decent framings I think for that kind of concept.

Yeah.

Mhm.

All right, that is it, folks. If you have hot takes, send them to me at Tom at Dice Tower dot com and we'll mention them possibly in a future episode. Maybe even in 2028. Um but no, I do take old ones and new ones. I jump around. So, don't feel like you will take will take forever to get there. But, it also could. Um we'll be back later today for crowd surfing at 2:00. That's a few hours from now. So, we'll talk to you about some games that are on Kickstarter Game Found.

Yep.

Until then, I'm Tom.

I'm Zee.

I'm Joey.

I'm Mike.

I'm Chris.

We're going to beat the randos.

Hey, uh thanks for watching another video here on the Dice Tower. Uh we really appreciate you stopping by and checking our things out. Thanks so much for joining us today. And hey, if you really like what we're doing here at the Dice Tower, then there are different ways to support the Dice Tower. One of those ways is through Patreon. We have links in the description to this video. We have links to lots of other things we do down there. So, definitely check it out. But, either way, we're glad you watched. Just tell your friends about the Dice Tower. Until next time though, I'm Tom Vasel and I hope you enjoyed this video.

Progress saved