Arkham Horror Evergreen Investigators
Transcript
Today I'm ranking all five the brand new investigator decks from Arkham Horror [snorts] the card game, but there's an important catch here. I'm still pretty new to Arkham Horror.
Welcome to Tangent House Studio D. I'm Kevin Delp. So, this video is not coming from the perspective of some hardcore or better room player who has built 50 custom decks and played every campaign 10 times. This is coming from the perspective of someone newer to the game who is asking questions like which decks are the most fun right out of the box? Which ones are the easiest to understand? Which ones make me excited to keep playing Arkham Horror? You'll need to have a campaign box of some sort in order to play these new characters like the new one that recently came out. You can check Melissa and my full review of this new chapter in Arkham Horror. Honestly, I think there are probably a lot of viewers that think Arkham Horror can feel intimidating when you first jump in. There are tons of cards, tons of mechanics, and deck building can feel a little overwhelming. That's why these investigator decks are such a cool idea.
Each one comes pre-built and ready to play, but they also give you upgrade options as you continue throughout a campaign. So, if you're newer to Arkham like me, these feel like a really approachable way to experience different play styles without needing to become a deck construction expert overnight. Now, before I jump into the rankings, let me know in the comments which investigator deck you're most interested in because I'm really curious where a long time Arkham players and newer players differ on these. All right, let's start with number five. At number five for me is Miguel Dela Cruz. And this one honestly feels like the advanced player deck of the group. Miguel deck is for players who already understand Arkham Horror really well and want to do clever, efficient things with their actions and card interactions. When I first started looking through this deck, I could tell there was a lot of depth here and a lot to unlock. Experienced players are probably going to do some crazy stuff with this.
That doesn't make it bad at all. In fact, I think long-time Arkham players may end up loving this deck. But for the perspective of a newer player, this was the deck that felt the least approachable to me. Many of the cards had a lot of text on them. I think if you're the type of player who enjoys mastering systems and finding smart combos, Miguel could absolutely become your favorite. But for me, this was the hardest deck to immediately connect with. At number four is the Tommy Muldoon deck. Now, Tommy is very combat-focused. If you want to fight monsters and protect the team, this deck absolutely delivers on that. And honestly, as a newer Arkham player, there's something refreshing about that clarity. You kind of know what your job is. Monster show up, Tommy handles them.
The deck also leans into taking damage and surviving punishment, which fits the theme really well. You feel sturdy. You feel dependable. You feel like the investigator standing between your team and complete disaster. But the reason I have Tommy at number four instead of higher is that the gameplay felt maybe a little too narrow for me personally compared to some of the other decks. This one felt really specialized. And depending on the campaign scenario, you may or may not need a fighter. But if your group needs a dedicated fighter, I could absolutely see this deck becoming a favorite. It just wasn't the one that made me most excited as a newer player to explore the possibilities of the Arkham Horror game. At number three is Carolyn Fern. Carolyn is built around healing horror, supporting teammates, and helping keep the group functioning when things start going badly. And if you're newer to Arkham Horror, trust me, things go badly a lot. At first, I assumed this would be a less exciting support style deck, but it's pretty interesting. Carolyn doesn't just heal people. Uh, the deck feels like it's constantly stabilizing the table and helping everyone stay in the game. What I found really interesting is that this deck is very different from a typical fighter or clue finder. It's more about managing the chaos of Arkham Horror itself. You're helping the team survive mentally while still contributing clues and support. I do
think this deck probably shines brightest in multiplayer. If you mostly play solo, I'm not sure it would be uh, ranked as high as it is for me. But as someone newer to Arkham, I appreciated how unique this deck felt compared to the others. At number two is Andre Patel. Uh, this deck was a nice surprise for me, and Andre felt stylish, flexible, and just really fun to play. The deck seems built around efficiency, extra actions, clever plays, and adapting on the fly. And as a newer player, this was one of the decks that made me feel smart without making me feel overwhelmed. It's a tough balance to pull off. Some decks feel simple, but maybe a little repetitive. Other decks feel incredibly deep, but intimidating. Andre landed right in that sweet spot for me. There were turns where I felt like I was pulling off some really cinematic moments, getting extra value, chaining actions together, finding ways out of difficult situations. The whole deck it just has this cool momentum to it. I also think this might be one of the best gateway decks for newer players who want to start seeing some of the deeper strategy Arkham Horror offers without getting completely buried in complexity.
But, my number one pick is the Marie Lambeau investigator deck. I just had the most fun with this one. Marie is the mystic deck, so you're using spells, manipulating weird supernatural powers, and basically dancing right on the edge of disaster the entire game. And to me, that feels like Arkham Horror. Uh there's this constant tension with mystic gameplay where you feel incredibly powerful one moment and completely terrified the next. And honestly, that's what makes the gameplay memorable. Uh this deck created moments where I was leaning forward in my chair wondering if everything was about to work perfectly or completely collapse. I also think the theme comes through incredibly strongly with Marie. The spells, uh the supernatural stuff going on, uh the risky play, it's all really immersive.
As a newer player, this was the deck that made me most excited to keep exploring the game because it felt dramatic, thematic, and a little unpredictable in all the best ways. Now, I'm sure long-time Arkham players could completely disagree with this ranking. And honestly, that's kind of part of the fun. Uh these investigators decks really do appeal to different kinds of players. If you love straightforward combat, Tommy might be your number one. If you love support play, Carolyn could absolutely be your favorite. If you enjoy deep combo gameplay, then you want Miguel. It might be the strongest deck in the group. But, from the perspective of someone still newer to Arkham Horror, these are the decks as I would rank them.
Thank so much for watching everyone. If you enjoyed this video, make sure to subscribe. Let me know what kind of video content you'd like to see on our channel. And let me know your rankings down in the comments. I'd love to hear where you agree and where you think I'm completely wrong.