Skip to main content
Loading video...

Terraforming Mars Review | Fire Up the Engine-Building!

Transcript 25:20

hey I'm Ryan this is my brother Daniel and this is rolls in the family today we are reviewing terraforming Mars a strategic engine building game about completing projects that will transform the surface of Mars to become habitable for human life and if you enjoy games with tons of unique cars that present an everchanging puzzle on how to prioritize and build your engine most efficiently terraforming Mars is one of our top recommendations and just like every video we've got a link to terraforming Mars down below if you want to check it for out for yourself after watching this video but Ryan let's hop in this ship it's time for blastoff let's jump into the review in terraforming Mars you are a giant Corporation in the 2400s that is contributing to a worldwide effort to make Mars habitable by raising its temperature oxygen level and ocean coverage you will scale your production ction to allow you to take on more and more projects that not only further this Mission but establish yourself as the most impactful Corporation in this new scientific era each generation you will have the opportunity to pay to acquire new project cards and then put your resources to work as you pay for projects and reap benefits that range from increased production for yourself to direct impact to the vital metrics for Life on Mars various projects will also allow you to establish cities greeneries oceans and other tiles on the surface of Mars as players compete over

the most lucrative positioning on the planet once all players have finished their actions in a generation your production engine will generate more resources you'll research new project cards to add to your hand and a new generation will begin Generations continue until the temperature oxygen and ocean coverage have all met the minimum requirements for Life on Mars terraforming Mars is is all about building an engine that will give you the power to make the most impact over the course of the game projects that provide resource production are very attractive in the early game as you work to scale up your efforts however impacting the requirements for habitation is also profitable as it raises your terraforming rating which not only determines the winner at the end of the game but also increases your money production which is the primary resource for playing Project cards you also want to keep a close eye on the milestones and Awards as they provide big opportunities for endgame points but are in direct competition with the other players Milestones are a race to a certain condition such as having three cities or eight building tags on cards and only three of the five Milestones can be claimed awards are player funded endgame scoring conditions where the first and second highest performing players will gain points at the end of the game funding an award it allows you to ensure the scoring is aligned with your strengths and while doing it earlier is cheaper it also gives your

opponents more information on what to pursue during the game with so many project cards and standard actions available the game is filled with tough tradeoffs this is especially evident during the research phase when you have the opportunity to acquire new cards for each card you decide to keep you must pay three credits decreasing your funds that are available to actually we play the project cards later many of the cards also have specific requirements such as the oxygen having reached a certain level which makes it tough to decide if it is worth holding on to a card even though it may not be playable for several generations and given that the game length is largely dictated by the players Collective progress on the three metrics of habitability there's an element of knowing when to push the pace more when you think you are ahead and keeping an eye on how each metric is progressing as it impacts which cards are playable and puts an expiration date on some benefits for example you may have some huge asteroid event card that would raise the temperature by three levels which equates to three points on the terraform rating track however if the temperature is already maxed out this card is way less attractive as you lose out on all the temperature raising benefit it is important that you balance the development of your own Engine with the unique dynamics of your opponent's actions we feel that three to four players is the sweet spot for terraforming Mars five players starts to introduce a lot of downtime and you don't get to do as much since there are

now five players contributing to the same habitable requirements two players can suffer from the opposite problem where the game can really drag if players are pursuing strategies that aren't pushing those metrics forward and it makes the interactive parts of the game less interesting and while I haven't been drawn back to the solo mode after using it once to learn the game it is is worth a look if you're interested in Solo play one of the strengths of terraforming Mars is how the compelling theme drives a lot of the mechanisms and flavor in the game cards have effects and prerequisites that make sense and it is cool to see the surface of Mars transform over the course of the game the efficiency puzzle of terraforming Mars is one that greatly favors skill with the caveat that there is a ton of Randomness in the cards you draw throughout the game we enjoy playing with the drafting variant that reduces this luck factor with some added play time but especially with the standard rules the luck of the draw can drastically benefit some players over others while a lot of your strategy is focusing on your own production engine there are also a lot of areas where you are affected by other players such as competition for spaces on the surface of Mars Racing for Milestones timing of funding Awards and how player strategies will affect the pace of the core habitable metrics besides the the steady flow of cards the actions of other players require you to remain tactical and ready to react setting up the game is reasonable for a game of this

complexity it's mostly getting the various Supply piles set up shuffling all of the cards and dealing each player their initial options there is a lot going on here for a new player but it is somewhat alleviated by the Simplicity of all project cars requiring credits it is logical that producing more money will let you play more cards but it can be difficult for new players to grasp a lot of the tangential considerations such as when to use standard projects how to pursue milestones and awards effectively the tradeoffs between buying or passing on cards in the research phase Etc the variability in terraforming Mars is huge primarily driven by the giant deck of unique cards the beginning of the game has each player picking from two corporations and paying to keep projects from a selection of 10 cards and if players happen to be itching for more variety expansion like Prelude which adds additional randomized start game options and helis and elisium which adds two more unique Maps will be sure to satisfy so much of what you do in terraforming Mars is about increasing your production each round as the game progresses it is exciting to have more and more resources at your disposal to strategically deploy to keep the snowball rolling and besides raw production playing blue active cards will give you ongoing abilities or once per generation AC that can be foundational to your strategic Direction and part of the reason building that engine is so fun is because there is such Variety in the project cards that

your production can be used for with a steady flow of four new cards you could acquire each research phase every game plays out differently and the strategy remains fluid as you process New Opportunities this also leads to Great diversity and strategies one game you might be hammering the surface of Mars with cities and greeneries but another game you might have some crazy micro engine that is mostly about generating points on your own cards that core decision in the research phrase do I pay three credits to keep this card or not is always grueling because you are spending the same resource that you ultimately need to play the project cards sometimes you need to pass on a card you love simply because it is more important that you keep the three credits to ensure you can complete certain actions this round the decision is made even more interesting is you weigh the value of production cards based on how many generations you think are left in the game as well as strong cards that have prerequisites such as 10% oxygen that won't be playable for a while and if the steady flow of cards was not enough to keep you on your strategic toes the actions of other players can be very impactful as well in the early game you want to be very aware of Milestones as each can only be claimed by one player and only three Milestones can be claimed in total but there are other times that an opportunity presents itself that you weren't considering for example a player builds a second Greenery that leaves an empty space with two adjacent greeneries

cities score for every adjacent Greenery at the end of the game so maybe it is worth completely pivoting to grab that attractive spot before someone else can build a city there the game strikes a great balance between the satisfaction of working on your own thing while still interacting meaningfully with other players that said not all of the interaction feels great specifically there are a number of cards often asteroids or some other kind of catastrophic event that allow you to destroy plants of another player the impact can range from insignificant to quite brutal but it is even more the fact that 95% of the game doesn't have that kind of negative interaction that makes it feel out of place well it can be a mechanism for targeting the leader to even the playing field often times it boils down to which player just happens to have the resource that is being targeted in our experience both the attacking player and the targeted player end up feeling bad while we can see some of the design justification for these attacks both mechanically and thematically we can't help feeling the game might just be more fun without them the giant deck of unique cards and terraforming Mars is a double-edged sword it is what powers the variability and dynamic strategic decisions that we have praised but the side effect is that players can find themselves at the mercy of Randomness you might have great titanium production and never draw space

cards that let you utilize it you might be close to the building tag Milestone only to not draw a building tag for several Generations you could draw cards that are literally unplayable because their minimum environmental thresholds have already been passed it is inevitable with this kind of card variety but that doesn't change the fact that it doesn't feel awesome when that Randomness clearly impacts the outcome of the game and now let's get to our personal ratings for terraforming Mars well terraforming Mars I think for both Ryan and I is in the upper echelon of gam we just love talking about echelons especially the upper ones what even is an Echelon that's a question I don't know you don't you don't never hear people saying like the lower echelons right yeah or just or just an Echelon on its own anyways vocab word for the week Echelon uh but but terrifying March truly is in that top tier for me of when I think of just games that deliver some of my favorite alltime uh experiences this is right up there with it and that's why I'm going to be coming in with a 9.5 for terraforming Mars um it just delivers every time for me like I very rarely have a game of terraforming Mars that like I might play bad but in terms of the game delivering it is so consistent on just delivering a wonderful experience and I think the thing that maybe separates

terraforming Mars from just other you know there's so me and you we both love so many of these kind of this this is like our Prime window of games like these like heavy kind of you know heavier strategic two this is where our top games typically are found and I think what's fun about this one is it has this like beautiful balance between such an addicting personal engine building of you know you've got this you're just you're building this engine you feel it as it's just growing and growing and and that's a ton of fun but then it also has the interaction on the shared player board and navigating like those two things kind of together I find is really interesting um in this game and sometimes even challenging like you know often times when I'm teaching this game game I specifically say to new players like don't forget about the you know Milestone like pick a milestone and just go for it because uh you know if you miss out on all of those you still could win but it's going to be challenging harder on yourself and and and likewise you know with the the shared player board especially if someone's going like a Greenery route you really need to be you just need to be at least be aware of like where can you where can you capitalize oh someone just they they have two greeneries by each other oh I could drop a city right there and whatnot um and so I just find the interplay between that like personal engine building and the shared player

board kind of I don't know Blends really well um yeah and most of the interaction is like positive interaction or at least not like really negative interaction you know you're kind of getting each other's way and changing things but you know when you're playing a game that's so much building your own thing sometimes it can feel really and we actually talked about as a negative here is there are a few cards that are a little bit more pointed attacks yeah um and you know it just can be hard if you're not prepared for that to go from I'm building my own thing to oh there go my plants yeah and actually and and really and this is honestly probably like my one negative of the game is is that those do just feel out of place and and specifically just those moments where like someone plays one and they like the leader like it's one thing to like go after the leader and it's like okay you know everyone even the leader is like okay I'm I'm in first place there finally got up to six plants yeah I'm in like last place over here and I finally get enough to get a Greenery and I'm the only one with plants it's like I'm so sorry Daniel you know that's not fun and just like we mentioned just feels kind a little bit out of the out of the spirit of the game um but that aside it is so much fun I mean I think both of us really love the mechanic of in any game where you're draw you're getting cards and you know card drafting but deciding

kind of which ones to keep and which ones to you know get rid of to essentially have more money you know it's almost a little bit kind of like what we love about race for the Galaxy right it's the what to keep what to use for resources and this game that tension is so hard because you you're getting every round you're getting these cards and you're like oh my gosh that's amazing oh my gosh but that's so good and you're so but you can't keep it all and and that if you keep all four that's 12 credits out the door and like very rarely is that like worth it to do all four because you're really strapping you know what you're going to be able to play that round yeah and we've obviously found that the card drafting is has really helped with balancing out just the like oh that person just got dealt really lucky and I didn't um it makes the research phase even more grueling though cuz now you're starting to consider oh I can't pass this to him like like they've got all these Jian things and I've got a jovian scoring one or like you just see that it's really good for them and so now you're like do I keep this one that's so we we do really enjoy playing with the drafting it's one that you know you probably only want to be playing with more experienced players and it is adding a little bit of time but I mean it has become our preferred way of for sure for sure yeah and I'd say the other really interesting thing about this game is the pacing of it because you have those three kind of

things that all need to happen to end the game in terms of temperature hitting a rating uh all the ocean tiles going out and the oxygen hitting you know the the max level and what's interesting is every game those like the pace of that can be different and that changes how you play so like if someone early in the game you know maybe plays some asteroids and stuff and the temperature just flies up well now suddenly one cards that you play you can play cards maybe earlier that needed a certain temperature but then it's also challenging because if for half the game temperature's already been maxed well now you don't really have that much incentive to be you know building up a lot of heat in fact heat can you can get a like have do this but then instead you know if it was oy that that changes things and so I find that's really interesting is you're trying to kind of read the the pacing of the game and then fit your strategy kind of around that you know as you're you're yeah and if you're being you know very strategic about like paying attention to what other players are doing you know if I see you over there man Daniel's got an amazing heat engine like you're just producing heat I might want to at least be doing some stuff on temperature because if I let it just slow play you're going to just power all of it yeah and so you know that adaptability I yeah I think is really interesting um without being like a neg like that doesn't feel that negative like I'm directly hurting you but it is definitely affecting how I'm approaching

things yeah so I'd say the game actually does have a decent amount of you needing to be aware of what your opponents are doing there's a lot of of you you got to be okay you know that's kind of sometimes the hard thing is you're so focused on this personal engine you need to be looking at what other people are doing for milestones for awards if someone's playing tons of greeneries you got you can't just let them you know go rampant with that you gotta just you know throw in some cities you know and then car drafting you're looking at you know if you're doing that variant you're looking at what that there's a lot of kind of managing what are other people doing and I enjoy that but but if you know someone doesn't doesn't enjoy that interaction you know that can that can be a downside but yeah so there's I mean gosh terraforming Mars is again one of those we have quite a few expansions for it I mean I think both of us would say Prelude is like just an absolute must I was going to mention that that like you know our ratings have definitely settled on like we typically use drafting we love using Prelude we'll sometimes use colonies which we find one we enjoy um so that all plays into our personal ratings um yeah that said like if I had the opportunity to throw down on base game ter Mar be a happy happy man Happy Camp if you like yeah yeah if you like terf Mars though it pray becomes like almost a no-brainer yeah and prel Prelude to we're waiting on Prelude too so I waffled on this one I went back and forth mean you know look it up so I was

very close to giving this a 10 but I also settled at a 9.5 and it's hard for me to know if it's if it's like some of the negatives you know we talked about like the direct attacking and some of it or maybe just like the highs of it that maybe don't feel like a 10 or if it's the fact that other games other game singular that I rate a 10es hard to put another in that category if there still feels like there's a gap yeah but man it's a high 9.5 for me it's a n it really yes we won't get more granular than our 05 system okay but um yeah so many great experiences one that I mean I think I'm up around almost 30 plays or so um and that's spread over the last what seven eight years or something yeah and it's just been consistent it's just like you know there's some games that enter the collection and kind of become like a new staple like there's some games that like get pulled out every once in a while whatever but there's ones that fit in more of this C category of like this is kind of just a staple for this type of game like it just often gets to the table when it we're looking for that type of strategic experience um and you know I've had good games anywhere like really from three to five players I know five players we said kind of gets a little bit long um and like you don't get to do as much um and oftentimes it can feel a little weird because it's like oh my gosh everything's going up so fast and I've hardly done anything um

but yeah and you know mix in the we have the helis and elisium board expansion so like I'll rotate between which boards which is actually like a pretty big difference with it completely changes the milestones and awards um so as someone who loves terraforming Mars there's a lot of fun content to explore I don't think I recommend exploring all of it I've never had an interest in like the uh what is the turmoil expansion that adds like a whole political like yeah you know and we weren't fans of the we weren't really fans of the Venus um yes I have Venus next and I basically weave out almost all of the Venus stuff I keep a few of the cards yeah you know it's like certain stuff Colony like walks the line just right for me of like it's added on but it feels good and you can integrate your strategies pretty directly yeah um instead of like Venus it was like well there's one person like doing a Venus strategy and like nobody else cares and it just it felt a little more disconnected right um but yeah great stuff one that I see you know there's oftentimes Games come out that people are like oo this you know a newer game that is similar to this that could for certain people replace it you know I just don't see terraforming Mars getting replaced by a game for me I know Aries Expedition came out some people basically said they'd never play terf Mars again because now this Aries Expedition is faster whatever you know in everything I've looked into it it's like man I'd be losing a lot of what I love about tering Mars and I'm okay with some of the extra length to get that out

of it yeah you know well I was just GNA last thing I was going to say is that you know it's interesting I've been we tal you know you talk about in the board game World Gateway games but I almost have started thinking about like what are the Gateway games for like you know we we rate the categories you know the weight of games but what are kind of the Gateway Games to a category and that's kind of what I feel like this is is oft times if people are looking for a game to kind of their first experience of kind of this heavier weight of games this is often the first one I I'll look at cuz it just it's consistent you can have a good you can have I find it's uh even though it's really strategic new players can do you know DEC even if you lose by quite a bit like you feel like you did a lot like so I think there's a little bit of like the satisfaction doing things I think it also the game strikes that nice balance of working on your own thing but also interaction so no matter how a person feels about whether they prefer more interaction or more working on their own they're getting a little bit of it from this so it's a little safer um as a strategic experience um yeah yeah so it's it's really kind of I think it's solidified itself as kind of that um perfect spot uh for me where I would agree with you it's uh it is a lock as of right now in the in the collection and uh one that we enjoy thoroughly so but would you enjoy it thoroughly that is the question dear

viewer that is the question that we also want to answer for you if you are bothered by card Randomness don't enjoy doing a lot of mental math to allocate resources or really prefer there to be no direct attacks in games where you are building up your own thing and terraforming Mars might not be for you but if you want an engine building game that has a steady flow of tough decisions huge Variety in card effects and a meaningful level of player interaction then terraforming Mars is one of our personal favorites and one that we can definitely recommend hey thanks for watching as you can tell Ryan and I clearly love terraforming Mars and if you find yourself in that same camp uh you can actually go check it out we got a link down below if you want to uh purchase it for yourself it also supports the channel so we always appreciate that and we've got a couple more videos here and we will see you in the next one

Progress saved