Medieval Madness - Kickstarter Critique Review
Transcript
Ohoy there YouTube. I'm back again today for another Kickstarter critique where I take a look at a different Kickstarter tabletop game project every weekday at 1:30 p.m. Eastern Standard Time. Give my honest thoughts when the project is being ran. And today I am legitimately very excited to check it out. Medieval Madness. It's got two days left. It's the 24th most popular project in all the games. And I'm immediately loving the main image. Trick taking deck builder. Like that that enough that is enough for a lot of people. Like I'm like okay. I'm immediately intrigued. I see €9 down here. I wish you could print the currencies. The majority of people probably going to back this from the United States of America even though I imagine the shipping's not going to be great if you're you're spot like that. Um, but I'd like to see more like the artwork here. Meh. Uh, what else could you show me? Does it look cool set up? Does it have some table presents? Have we stretch goals? Anything else aside from just your artwork here? But $9 trick taking deck builder. I feel like it's still a solid main image. A trick taking deck building card game set.
Medieval world. I got that blending madness and strategy. Meh. Very meh. Feel like that's a big fumble. Like, tell me more. Tell me more. I need to know more. I want to know more. I should say I don't need. You've told me a lot, but I want more. All right. 1100 $1,179 goal. Let's raise 13,000 bucks from Cow. Have I covered this? I haven't covered this, have I? I feel like I've seen this before. I was like cow Poland. No way. I'm gonna feel like a real dummy. Uh, okay. No, I've not covered. I just wanted to cover. Okay. I was going to be like, "Wow, that was going to be wild if I cover this before." Uh, it looks Oh, there's no video. Oh, why? That's disappointing. Okay.
Mint Panda, first grade, one backed. Mid Panda is a small publishing house from Poland based in the royal city of KA. And we're excited to see where this road leads. Okay. Bringing out our first game. It's neat. It's a trick taking deck builder €9. It's happening. 10 times the funding goal. 11,000 bucks for your first small box games. Congrats, by the way. That's like, let's take it back. 13K. That's a big success. Like, I know we look at the hundreds of thousands all the time, but if this is your first game and it's a small box card game and you were asking for,00 bucks and you get 13,000, that is a massively larger print run consideration than you were thinking, right? all of a sudden it goes from 500 to a,000 to500 to 5,000 to 10,000 where it's like okay maybe we do consider making 10,000 because the price goes down so insanely low and we can sell them in the back end like you have some very fun conversations at that point behind every great medieval story are unseen hand shaping yeah theme it's a deck builder and a trick taker I don't think I am not expecting theme here 48 medieval cards divided into four suits 20 madness cards and four order cards okay unlock stretch goals love the fact these are here I put that on the main image. Honestly, the tally of deeds, a score sheet designed to make tracking points clearer and more convenient through the game. So, immediately this $9 value is getting better, and this is how we do it. Like this, this is why we put it up high. Uh, four new cards that shake up the trick taking, adding unexpected turns, legacy cards. Wow. 12 12 legacy cards that help you gather the right icons for scoring while enhancing the depth of trick taking. So, that's 16
more cards. Fresh pages. 20 more cards. 26 more cards. 32 36 40 44 56 more cards unlocked. Oh, it's 44. What? Oh, 44 plus the 12. I think it's 56. Maybe I counted wrong. Either way, great, great, great, great, great. That's how we spotlight stretch goals. I'd do it on your main image. Witches cauldron unlock stretch goals will be gathered into a single box under the Witches Cauldron title. We hope you'll enjoy the goodies bubbling inside this cauldron. We keep tossing in more surprises as the magic grows. So pretty much this was probably already something that existed and that just we had stretch goals. We have a bunch of stretch goals. We hit them. Cool. Setup. Shuffle the middle of the cards and deal 12 to each player. I would love a video just briefly talking over this. Madness phase. Reveal three cards from the madness. The trick phase. Okay, looks good. Great. Show me the rule booklet.
Not really what I want to see here, but it's nice. Legends. Cool. Why back now? by backing medieval madness for helping a small dream become reality. So you're making people read that like that. Okay. Not a fan of that. Hopefully there's a preview a game. Like it's just there are hundreds of games on on on right now. So to make people force people to have to read paragraphs upon paragraphs to learn your game, not a great idea, right? It's just that's why there's previews are so popular. That's why people have videos. That's why people have, you know, hey, here's the gameplay flow. By backing Medieval Madness, you're helping a small dream team. Okay, so nine bucks, we get the game with the expansion. What's a puppet master? One copy of Medieval Madness along with all my stretch goals, including the Wilder Tale, a five to six player expansion, the folk deck, a standard deck of playing cards themed around Medieval Madness. Ick on the the the playing cards first and foremost.
Just very ick there. And then this one, five and six player expansion. Feel like he had sprung this on me. Also, I'd mentioned that that it goes up to six players, right? Two to six players, 3 to six players, whatever. What was the player count? You showed me it. Have you? Hopefully, right? Common sense. It's on the side of every single box pretty much. Don't you think it'd be nice to tell me the player count somewhere in here? Maybe that video. Maybe on the front. Nah. Really? Is this Is this going to have to be an FAQ question? Is it two? Is it three? How many players is it? I don't know. Maybe we'll find out. Do we have to read through all this to get there? Do we have to? Wow. Yeah. I hate I hate I hate this Kickstarter.
I love the main image. I love the price. I hate that puppet master pledge. I've designed a stretch goal to make medieval madness even richer and more strategic. And so here's the stuff we unlocked. The stretch goal introduces a score sheet. Yeah, it's a banger. Legacy cards. Neat. So, this is more of a description of all the stuff. Social goals. So, I don't care about your artwork, right? Like this artwork here. That feels like a really bad choice. Like, I would get rid of that dumb artwork and put not dumb, but like nonfunctional artwork and put the functional, hey, here's the cards you unlocked. Here's the score sheet you unlocked instead of here's an imposing bad guy. you know, like, oh yeah, I'd rather see this princess AI thing instead of madness cards, right? Because I think that's what they're getting to.
Also, the only thing you have here is risks of use of AI. Use the left spot. It looks lazy if you don't do it right. Like two years ago when it was first introduced, three years ago, it didn't look lazy. Now it just looks lazy cuz it makes it so I have to go through your story at the exact flow that you made it. And I don't think it's a good flow at all instead of just being like, "All right, what's the price? What are the stretch goals? What's this?" Yeah, this is a poor choice. We prepared two social stretch goals for you. Unlike regular stretch goals, these aren't tied to funding. Uh 100% Dominion. to help unlock the stretch goal. Follow our Facebook profile and go to on the the page on Board Game Dee and the add-ons the Wilder Tale the card the deck of cards another copy shipping. Wow, that's a great price. $12.
I I was I'm shocked honestly. I would That's fantastic. How much is it is rock solid. I don't feel like you sold the deluxe version well at all. Even though I still want it to get up to five to six players, but not with that stinking deck of cards. But your add-on section is not too bad either. Like I could be like, "All right, I don't want this deck of cards." A lot of good stuff on here. A lot of bad stuff, I feel like, personally. But a lot of good stuff, too. Uh, our artwork begins with the AI generated concepts. I don't care. Some people do, but I mean, it's it looks very AI, but that doesn't like Okay, we're in and out 12 minutes. That's quick as it should be for a $9 game, but not converting the currency. Let's see. So, how many people got the game? 148 people got the game. 600 people.
Cool. You convinced 600 people? Yeah, I guess it's only a $7 price jump now that I think about it, right? Like, as much as I don't want to buy your stupid deck of cards, and I'm going to call that that. Like, I'll call that a spade a spade. I'm not buying a board game to get a deck of cards. Just not doing it. Like I'm playing board games cuz I don't cuz cards don't whatever. Whatever. Get off my soap box. So yeah, $7 price jump. Not bad at all. It makes sense. I still don't feel like you sold it well though. But for $7, you don't really have to. How much is it so great? Let's check out the FAQ updates, comments. The creator hasn't listened any questions. I have a question. How many How many players does this play? Uh, do you have a gameplay video? Do you have a quote from anyone? They have a BGG page, which yeah, would would essentially mean that, you know.
Oh, so these are people who backed a Kickstarter. We got some force. So, nobody's played this except for this guy from Denmark. Uh, that's not a great sign. Are there any videos? Nothing. Post rules. Do we have rules? I didn't see any rules either. There's really post for this game, especially the two and three player setup. Okay, so it does go to two players. There's a solo mode. Wow. Uh yes, it'll be stretch goals. Then put one to six players on the everywhere, right? That's Come on. I SHOULDN'T HAVE to go to BGG to look that up. Gross AR. Who I I mean I shouldn't say who cares. A lot of people care. Uh any play test revis? Yeah, I'm thinking about bagging this Kickstarter. I'm just wondering.
There's nothing. Nothing. There's no preview video. There's no gameplay video. There's no ah ick full point grade bumpdown for just just that. No rule booklet. Yeah. No, that's because it's a big deal. No rule booklet, no gameplay, no preview. You're going to read this. This is what we're going to do. You are going to read this and if you don't read this, you're not going to have a dang idea what this game is like as I am right now. And that's piss poor job. Like that is a piss poor job. I'm not gonna be nice about it. Like your job is to convey to people that they want your game AND THE MOST ESSENTIAL THING is gonna be to let me know how to play the game. How do I contact you for consultation with my Kickstarter page of promotions? I have a Fiverr link down below. Thanks for uh thanks for asking, Gecko. Uh yeah, so updates comments. Give this one a great 11 updates. They're being active. The Lone Knight arrives and the M. These are just prepackaged ones with you hitting stretch goals that you made in advance.
Okay. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So, these are just the prepackaged ones, which I hate even more. This is a Sean trope because what it means is if you hit a whole bunch of stretch goals really early on, you just blast people with email after email after email after email when it's like, dude, I I paid $9 for your deck building game. I don't care. Um, Legacy. Yeah. Okay. So, let's check out the most engaging one where people actually said something because right now we see some hearts. Two. Is it two? Two is bad. That's pretty bad. Six. Yes, there we go. Solitude mode on the horizon. That's people excited. What people say most engaging one. I have social I love social stretch goals. I love the idea of the social set of goals. Adds a fun goal for the community to build hype. Any idea something? Okay, moving on.
Comments. We are 56 hours to go and I do not see a rule booklet, a video with the gameplay, and even the cards. Is this just a virtual project without any protonic? I don't know what that word is. Uh can you please confirm it to us? Yeah. Yeah. Like the ooey gets it. Like I know it's a small amount of money, right? Relatively speaking to other Kickstarter projects 16 which how much is that dollars too? What are we like 22 or something? 11 19 or like 30-ish bucks. It's still like there's so little information and it's so inexcusable. Like not even a just a video like this is what a video could do. Personal touch. Hey, this is my card game. Working on it for a long time. We got some really awesome stretch goals planned uh that we're going to be putting in there. It it it takes this really interesting aspect of deck building. Kind of familiar if you're familiar with this game. Like like anything anything is better than what you have, which is nothing. I'd like to confirm. If I take only the base game plus the five six player expansion, what will be the delivery fee? The same as in the older pledge or I pay uh how do I get a second deck?
Getting some chapter 3 vibes from this one. Looking forward to try it. Great. Okay. Is there essence pickup? I think it will be possible. Please check upcoming updates. Upcoming updates. Okay. Well, you're done in 52 hours. All right. I want to see how many new backers this are. I'm curious. 17. Okay. And yeah, look at there. Lookie lookie who gets a cookie. Like I said, the most popular country is the one that you couldn't be bothered to convert the currency to. 344 to 74. Like, god, golly. So, final grade for this one. Do I want it? I do. I do want it. I love trick taking games. I love deck building games. They are two of my favorite mechanisms. I don't give a hoot about AI artwork. AI artwork. And I'm not saying that in like uh in any other way to say that that doesn't bug me. So I am the target market for this game. I like cheap games. I like small games. This fits every bill. I like games that have the potential to go to higher player counts. EVEN THOUGH I'M PROBABLY NEVER GOING TO PLAY WITH THAT. I AM THE PERSON WHO wants this game AND YOU STILL DID A TERRIBLE JOB selling it to me.
That's why this is going to be a negative grade because honestly the best thing in this entire page in my opinion is the main image which once again I think could be substantially better. And that's because it lets me know this is a dirt cheap game and it combines trick taking and deck building. Like you have the peanut butter and the chocolate and I don't care how you mix them together. IT'S PROBABLY GOING TO TASTE GOOD. OH, YOU THROW A PICKLE IN THERE. WHATEVER. I'll still enjoy it. So, do I want it? Yeah, I do. But mostly not because of you. You know what? They got me covered. So, do I want it? Yeah, I'll go there. I do want it. How much is it? Great price. Very Kickstarter reasonable in and out the door. 32 bucks with the expansion. You don't want to get the expansion? It's like 30 something 25. Totally fine. They got some banger stretch goals here um that that unleash, you know, different modes and legacy modes and all this other stuff. Cool. But can you do it there? There in lies the biggest problem because there are so many red flags on this campaign that if you were looking at this campaign in a year and a half and you're like ah crap force call it. Yeah. Like this one looks like if they just ran off the cash, which I don't think they're going to do because I just don't want to assume that that's where we are in the Kickstarter process where people are just like making these and then just having no plan at all of shipping them. I'm sure that happens from time to time and I'm sure it's but
ah I don't want to I don't want to believe that. I want to believe that they were just incredibly ignorant about the what's the word uh I use the word all the time the Kickstarter like what what's expected like what people expect from you and you it's not hard to fi figure it out you just need to go look at like five to 10 other projects I say this all the time just look at five to 10 other projects that are popular right now that are games and see what things happen very consistently and they're like, "Okay, the industry standard." Yeah. Like they'd feel like they're just totally ignorant about the industry standard for so many things and it's just there's no quotes, there's no nothing, there's nothing like they got a BG page at least, but it's just ick there's and so for that how it's being ran, I feel like this is a huge fumble.
I feel like you have chocolate, you have you have a great price, you have mechanisms people love, you have, you know, you got expansions, you got a dirt cheap expansion that everybody's going to go for. Nobody's going to bat an eye pretty much when they say, "Oh, it's just seven extra euros." If you did the rest of your job competently, but you didn't. Instead, it was, "Hey, we're going to post what looks like the rule booklet right here and force you to read that. That is the only way you will have knowledge of this game. There will be no content creators. There will be no preview. There will be no main video. There will be no quotes. There will be no board game s like arena. There's nothing. And that's just ick. Uh that being said, I still didn't want to play the game. Final grade is a hard one.
Cus, right? Like this this could easily be I think an A. It could easily be an A with just a personal video just showcasing the prototype. Here's some pictures from a convention that we took it to. Here's some HERE'S SOME FAKE QUOTES THAT I MADE UP ABOUT FROM fake people about loving the game. There even be real quotes. THEY COULD BE TOTALLY FAKE QUOTES. JUST there is so little meat on this Kickstarter page that it's I I can't even on principle. I don't want to give it the plus. I'm just going to go with a C. A C. The only thing saving this is that right there, that main image, trick taking, deck building, dirt cheap, and great shipping price, I would say, for shipping for Poland, right? Because it's such a small game. But everything else just complete and utter fumble. And it's just look at the room around you and all the other projects. Even the smaller box projects, go look at 10 OF THOSE. FIVE OF THOSE wear the bathroom.
Just ick. I'm gonna go with a C. But this one's got a lot of red flags. But the bottom line is you can't get it after like and then it's the other thing. They got you bent over the barrel. You're not getting this at retail after the fact. They're going to pick like so it's either now. All right. Yeah. I'm going to go with C. Let me know in the comments below what's your final grade for medieval madness or trick taking the game set in medieval world blending madness and strategy. And if you happen to read the rules, did they sound fun? let me know because they couldn't be bothered to convey it in any other way. Have yourself a great one. Bye-bye.