Skip to main content
Loading video...

The legal side of creating games | Zachary Strebeck

Transcript 54:57

are you telling me that there are companies in China that make knockoffs yeah yeah or sometimes they don't even make them they just register a trademark which is crazy and then you know you you can get the trademark back a lot of times because you know you can prove that they maybe they show that we can show that they registered dozens of trademarks and never actually release any products or something like that but it costs thousands of dollars to fight it you need to go back and forth and it takes years to do it thank you all right Zachary you've been practicing law for about a decade at this point and you've worked with lots of different companies and video games and board games and just creativity in general tell me some of the common questions that these game companies these developers come to you with what are some like the main issues that you just see you know you you see people running into over the years I think one of the most common ones when designers or developers or whoever is the creative to come to me they ask you know do I need to form some sort of company or business entity before I either publish the game or start a Kickstarter or publish whatever creative work that they're doing and I mean the answer usually is yes I think a a mentor of mine told me a while ago you'd be basically committing malpractice if you told someone that no you shouldn't you shouldn't form a separate business entity to run your business the reason is that there's so many sort of entanglements that a business gets into whether it's signing contracts with people or providing a product that could

potentially be a toking Hazard or uh creating some intellectual property that could potentially be infringing on some existing intellectual property I mean there's so many ways that you could potentially accrue liability uh from third parties that having a shield against that liability is almost uh the Baseline for going into business that is to say I mean it's not a requirement you can always go into a forming a business without actually forming a company and do it as a sole proprietor I wouldn't recommend it but there are also other ways to get around it right you could get business insurance that is big enough as far as the coverage goes to cover you in case there's any any kind of issue like that uh but but the main reason people do it or the main thing that people do is to create some sort of LLC or Corporation something like that it's also a good idea because it's it's like one bucket where all of the game or creative work goes into right so if you're doing a YouTube channel that LLC is going to own all the content and that makes it easily transferable so if you were to sell you you know you wanted to you know get acquired by another company or something like that uh it's easier for them to come in buy the shares and that's it they they now own everything that the company owned so yes the limited liability is a huge part of it but there are also other other uh things that make it easy to run your business the other one will be if you have multiple

partners or owners um working on that you want to have some company documents that will describe how you make decisions how you divide up the the profit Etc all that stuff goes into making it almost a necessity to form some sort of company I I understand and with all the things we'll talk about I should say this up front uh they all cost money you know they all kind of are a barrier to entry for business and that's why I always will say you're not required to do any of this stuff uh and you're not required to hire a lawyer but it's always pretty much a good idea across the board well it's interesting how often people try to do certain things themselves when they have no experience they have no background they read an article on Google and then they go and try to do something and then they they Wonder like oh why did this cost me an absorbitant amount of money it's like well that you tried to save money but then it cost you 10x what you tried to save and so yeah I think that's that's something like if my toilet explodes I'm probably gonna hire a plumber like I'm not going to try to figure out how to fix all the pipes underneath my house because I have no idea how to do that but yet legal wise I I do this too like sometimes I'd be like I think I could just figure it out when it probably save me a lot of time and probably a lot of money to just go hire a professional so you say you read it or you you read one article on Google I mean I basically read a lot of articles on Google that's that's how you learn to be a lawyer right I mean they're books law books you take classes all that stuff but it's not like some Arcane

knowledge that no one could pick up right I mean it is you know just learning to be a lawyer and learning the specific laws and and all that the issue is like you say it's a Time versus money question do you want to spend all the time learning how to file a trademark and do a trademark clearance and understand why you would be or would not be infringing on someone else's trademark or you just want to pay someone to do it for you and handle that and forget about that and concentrate on making your game or or doing your creative project which you know I I'd like to do everything myself as well I'd like to learn how to do it you know I made my own website I do this I do that uh sometimes it's easier to just pay someone to do it for you at some point you transition into more money than time as opposed to more time than money and it's just worth it to to let someone else handle these things yeah absolutely I think it's also a matter of just information it's if you're going to do it yourself if the question becomes how many holes do you want to fall into and how many do you want to avoid because if you don't have the knowledge for instance I hired an accountant years ago and the first year that this guy did my taxes I was like how in the world did you get that much money back like I went from paying a lot of money to all of a sudden getting a huge check from the government he's like oh well you probably didn't know about this and this tax deduction and this over here and you could move money around like this and I was like you're you're a freaking wizard dude and he's like no I just know the tax code in and out right I was like and I a lot of times they have access to

software and services and things like that that will help them to do that that you as a an individual with one job don't want to pay for but for instance I have trademark clearance software and trademark docketing software that will keep track of all these deadlines and all that stuff that you know I pay a lot for but you don't need to pay for but you pay me to have access to right it's the same with with a lot of these professionals uh the knowledge the tools all that stuff just makes things better for you much smoother I think that makes a lot of sense uh let's go back and talk just for a second would you suggest someone start again if they're in the United States it might be different in Europe but would you suggest they start in LLC a limited liability company or an S corp or corporation like what do you think someone should do if they're just starting out interesting thing uh you mentioned S Corp versus LLC S Corp is what's called a tax election it's only specifically how the underlying company is taxed so you can have an LLC as the structure of your company just like you can have a partnership or a sole proprietorship or a corporation but the way that it's taxed an LLC is taxed as a as a partnership uh by default but you can have it taxed as an S corp you can have it taxed as a C Corp uh in the U.S at least which dictates how whether the entity itself pays taxes how the taxes or the income and and liabilities pass through the entity onto your personal taxes all of these things are sort of dictated by how you choose to be taxed so what do I generally recommend uh as

far as how you're taxed I recommend you have some sort of Tax Advisor like you said you you found a CPA to help you with that and because everyone's situation is going to be different I'm not an expert on taxes so I would recommend that you you find someone who is to to tell you and it's a simple election you file one form with the with the IRS and send it in uh and and you can change how you're being taxed as far as the underlying company generally there's a there's there's two situations one is if you're just going to kind of run the company yourself you're not getting outside investment uh you're essentially just running a business where you put out a product you get paid for a product you pay yourself those profits right that's usually an LLC and that's sufficient for for that purpose it's a flexible structure to work with you can kind of dictate how you want things to be run as opposed to a corporation which is a little more rigid and structured and requires things like annual meetings uh and that's more geared toward if you're going to get outside investment and this is usually more on the video game side than the board game side because you're not seeing a lot of that on at least on the hobby board game side of things so you know for most board game or small creatives like if you run a YouTube channel or something like that an LLC is probably fine I mean you'll see lots of big companies Sony uh Sony's uh you know PlayStation company here in the US is an LLC right I mean it's it's just a limited liability company and you can kind of dictate how it runs internally with your operating agreement so no problems there gotcha now another thing

you mentioned was like if you have a partnership making sure you've got some contracts in place between the partners figure stuff out because I've seen quite a few people unfortunately that ran into a situation where one person was done and they want to get out and it's like well how do we do that do I do I buy you like they didn't have any stipulations I had no agreements and another thing I'm thinking about is I think it was a big time real estate guy was talking about this one time he said yeah I don't call them agreements I call them disagreements because the only time we look at them is when we disagree about something I was like that's a good way to look at it but as far as you know Partnerships what are some of the common things you just make sure you want to make sure you have the common language the common pieces in there that way if someone does want to leave or let's say someone uh you know does something terrible and they you know go to prison they're like you know there's all sorts of scenarios that can play out that you want to kind of make sure you're protected and protecting yourself what are what are some of those things what what are the things I need to make sure I have as far as Partnerships right inside your operating agreement or your partnership agreement or whatever sort of company agreement you have you're going to want to have things about a process for transferring ownership you know whether you someone wants to sell their ownership to some third party right you don't necessarily want one of your partners to sell their half the company to someone that you don't like right so you want to have a right a first refusal to buy that back first maybe you want to have something like a morals Clause where you say if they do something that brings harm you know reputational harm to the company or their you know they commit a felony or something like that um you were able maybe to buy back their

interest uh one big thing we do with almost every LLC is when you're first starting a business everyone's happy everyone's excited to you know and they're in it for the long haul but maybe three months later one of the partners gets a full-time job and they just don't have time to work on well now you've given them half your company and they're not going to be working on anything anymore and you can't really go back I mean you could offer to buy it back but they don't necessarily have to sell it to you and so what we do is use what's called vesting where uh you have the ability to buy back their ownership if they leave after a certain amount of time or their ownership will only sort of accrue in in chunks over time so that you can ensure that they're going to stay on you know for three years or four years or however long you sort of expect your initial project or your first chunk of work to go until they've really earned the full ownership and and not being able to pull it back and so those vesting Agreements are super important they're really common for startups but a lot of companies smaller companies that come to me don't have that they are just granting everyone the ownership and that runs into issues if someone just stops working or or is not interested in the company anymore yeah that makes a lot of sense all right another thing I've had several people ask me about that I wasn't entirely sure is non-disclosure agreements ndas when do you need one when should you sign one when should you not sign one what are your thoughts you know the blanket answer would be you

should probably always sign them because if you have something secret that you're sharing with someone else you want to have some protection or at least some you know a contract is only as good as the paper it's printed on right so I mean you can have a contract that says you owe me a million dollars if you disclose this uh to someone else but if they don't have a million dollars then there's no way you're going to get that from them and if they have an LLC with no money in it or something like that there's no way you're gonna get that money so I mean it does serve as a deterrent and it is helpful in that way but uh you know just be aware of the circumstances and not just what the agreement says right so be selective about who you share your confidential information with uh and and only share as much as you need to to share but you know it's generally a good idea when you're doing entering into any sort of negotiation to get into a bigger agreement with another business or with a maybe you have a contractor that you want to hire to do some art for your game and you're going to share with them all the you know the secrets about the game get an NDA in place that's good a couple situations where people always want ndas but they're not really practical would be maybe with uh you're sending copies of your game or product out to be play tested right you know you you can ask them for an NDA signature but a lot of times it's kind of it's asking a lot right I mean you're often asking them to do it for free and so you know you're saying Hey I want you to play this game for free and give me feedback for free and also take on this potential legal liability if you talk

about my game um especially for a lot of small games you don't necessarily want people to not talk about it right you you kind of want them to be talking about your game and generating some excitement so I it doesn't actually always work in your favor and another one would be if you're sort of approaching Publishers to potentially publish your game a publisher is not going to sign an NDA with you they don't know who you are unless you really have a reputation and or someone that they they know they want to sign that NDA with they don't want to take on liability in case maybe they have their own game that's very similar to yours or something like that I mean they are not going to agree to that so don't even bother it's going to make you look unprofessional I think if you try to approach a publisher with an NDA if you don't have already kind of accrued a reputation and and that professionalism already unfortunately yeah I completely agree on that one of the main places I've seen them especially in the hobby game Space they're not as not as privileged I think in the hobby board game spaces video games and other places unless you're talking about licensed games if you're working with Marvel BC Disney something like that that's the main place or main time that I've seen those come into play and or in those situations is that really coming from Marvel is that the main person that's kind of making sure that's in India or is it the company that's doing the game or something like that yeah most likely the licensor who is Marvel or whoever owns the the the IP that's the subject to license they're

the one that's going to dictate anyone that you talk to about this game is going to have an NDA in place only because they they don't want the terms of their agreement to come out they don't want the fact that you're making the product to come out a lot of times and they don't want any of their kind of confidential information maybe they have you know maybe you're doing a game based on a movie that's not coming out for three years or something like that it's gonna be very important for them that you don't disclose this to anyone who's not under NDA already and that potentially they could go after if they did disclose this so yeah super big deal with with us the bigger the company the more the more strict they're going to be about about these kinds of things for sure yeah yeah that makes a lot of sense all right so let's switch gears a little bit let's talk about copyright and trademark that's another thing that I've had so many people ask me about or just ask in the community online that I run and I feel like there's a lot of misconceptions about copyright and trademarks and they get people you know people get those things confused and they miss they think one is the other and whatever so first of all what exactly is a trademark versus a copyright and then what are some of the main things that people just to they just need to be aware of copyright uh is the exclusive right to essentially to make copies of your original creative works so to make copies to distribute to publicly perform to create derivative works from so if you make one game to be able to make any kind of sequel or or um you know derivatives of that work that's your exclusive right as the copyright owner and that I know others

are not allowed to do that with your work and it has to be an original creative work uh it can't be anything that's functional or factual within the work it can't be anything that's sort of like an underlying game mechanic uh it needs to be like an actual creative thing like text the text of your rules or the or the graphic design and the artwork of the game or uh things like that things that are creative in nature and not necessarily now obviously game designers would probably say that there's a lot of creativity in the game design itself but unfortunately the law doesn't see it that way and um you can visit my blog I have blog posts about this some of the cases about this uh what is sort of protected by copyright in a game and unfortunately the design and the mechanics and you know characters powers and things like that are not going to be protected by copyright so next is trademark and trademark protects something totally different trademark actually protects consumers from being confused about the source of the goods that they buy so imagine you walk into a store and you see a bottle that says Coca-Cola on the label right but it's made by some guy down the street in his bathtub but he's just slapping the label of Coca-Cola on it uh you don't know where that you don't know if there wasn't trademark law and if they weren't allowed to stop other people from doing that and give those exclusive rights to a trademark owner you wouldn't know where your products are coming from so that's what they try to accomplish with trademark law and it's going to protect your your brand names like your game name or your company name and then your logos your uh

maybe the trade dress you know one famous one is a the shape of a coke bottle is very distinctive and they can protect that because that's that's that gained so much distinctiveness with consumers that the law wants to protect that so again so you can't walk into a store and see the same exact bottle shape and think that it's made by Coke and then there's patents patents protect Innovations and inventions and improvements to other inventions things that are not obvious to other practitioners in the field um and those are maybe less common in board games and video games but they're still there I mean there's still lots of them uh for sure I don't know and then there's something called Trade Secrets which is the fourth type of intellectual property and that's basically any kind of secret that you have that has some value in uh in the industry that you're in a big one again going back to Coke is would be the formula for Coke the recipe for Coke right that's something that a recipe because it's just functional it's a list of items uh is not copyrightable but it is something that you would have to keep secret and you know the Catch-22 of protecting intellectual property is that you have to register it in order to protect it so if you have something secret you can't register it so you basically have to just keep it keep it inside only share it with people that are under ndas and all of that and that's maybe one of the reasons why uh everyone wants ndas especially from the big companies because these are not copyrightable things maybe they're ideas or plans or something like that but they want to keep them secret gotcha first of all knockoff Coke made in a bathtub I

think is the origin story of Pepsi at least Dr Pepper yeah um all right so let's talk about copyrights just for a second how how do I do I have to file a copyright or as soon as I put it out into the world is it automatically legally binding copyrighted like how does that work from a legal standpoint from the standpoint from a legal standpoint as soon as you they call it fixation as soon as you fix something in a tangible medium of expression you have copyright rights that means when you write something down when you save a digital file on your computer when you record a video or take a photo of something copyrightable you have rights underlying copyrights in that thing the issue is at least in the U.S you can't actually do anything with those rights you can't file a lawsuit against someone unless you've registered that copyright so and it used to be that you just had to have filed for the registration because when you file it it can take three months it can take a year to get the actual registration depending on how quickly the copyright office is moving Supreme Court a few years ago ruled that it needs to actually have been registered before you can sue someone so what's happened sometimes is I will have a client and we want to send a demand letter to someone that says hey you're infringing on my copyright uh you need to stop and they'll come back and say well where's your registration because they basically know that we can't do anything without that registration now fortunately they do offer you an option graciously allowing you to pay eight hundred dollars extra to you to get a an

expedited copyright registration which actually takes about a day which is great but it's additional cost that you don't want to have to pay if you had just filed it the day that you created the thing right you publish your board game and you file a copyright registration that day which is the probably the best time to do it uh and then as far as trademark goes at least in the U.S when you use a trademark in Commerce which is say you actually sell a game with the name that you want to trademark you have trademark rights and you have something called common law trademark rights which is you know uh unregistered but you do have the ability to protect that it's not as good as the registered trademark which allows you to sue someone for trademark infringement in federal court but really that what I find to be the most useful benefit of a trademark registration isn't the protection you get later on but it's the protection you can get from the beginning so with games specifically most of the time a developer or designer will come up with a game name let's say today but they're not actually going to get that game into consumers hands for another couple years right so in the time between today when you've decided on the name and the time when your common law trademark writes accrue that's a couple years that other people could have been coming up with the same name and actually releasing products so you're not going to have those exclusive rights and that other party is going to have the right set name so you may have wasted months or years advertising a

game under a certain name and then you have to change it at the end right because you haven't filed any kind of trademark registration now if you filed a trademark application today you could file it as what's called an intent to use application that then gives you rights dated as of the day you file it even though you don't actually use it until later on which is I think the most important part of trademark registration and the reason to do it for especially board game and video game uh developers because you don't want to waste that time marketing your game when you don't even really have the uh the rights in that name that makes sense sometimes it really can get confusing the intent to use and all that all the dates and all the craziness but you know trust me when I say it has happened more than a few times with clients of mine where we're lucky that we have filed that trademark application and you know sometimes it can be we send a demand letter and say hey we filed this application you can't use this name maybe they run a Kickstarter and then we can contact Kickstarter potentially I mean the technicality of it is that even though you do have those rights going back to that day until you've actually finally and fully registered your trademark you don't actually have those rights so you kind of need to register it first and then come back and say anyone that that used it in that period of time is infringing but we can certainly send a letter to warn them and say hey this is going to happen if you don't stop using this and a lot of times they will they will stop nobody wants a letter from a lawyer unfortunately I'm a nice guy but you know nobody wants to hear from me unfortunately which is good for you if

you're the client but uh you know bad for me and maybe personal relationships or whatever but yeah it's it's definitely useful uh and it it has happened I can tell you from Real World Experience we've had to do that and had to stop other people and sometimes you can even sell the trademark to someone else right if they you know you've you've spent a thousand dollars getting this trademark but maybe a Big Brand comes in and starts using it you know you may be able to sell that for a lot more you know maybe it's 50 000 right that you sell it for which is uh you know a good deal if you're a small small game designer yeah that makes a lot of sense I've also seen going back to like the whole idea of of preemptive thinking ahead like really thinking about what you're going to do long term I can't remember what company it was this is a video game company a few years ago they were so excited about this game they were working on and they put out a trailer and then but they hadn't gotten the domain the URL or like the website and so some random dude on the internet saw the trigger I was like oh okay and he went on GoDaddy or whatever and it's like oh this URL is for sale and he he registered it and then sold it to the company sure later it's so you know that that does happen in fact it's something I'm sort of dealing with right now um it does happen a lot and you know we there are companies that are out there that are just watching new trademark registrations and and seeing if they can get the domain names uh there are procedures in place to help deal with that if someone registers a domain in bad faith uh then you could potentially do what's called a udrp proceeding to

get I can which is the the domain name Authority you can get them to basically give you the domain name back uh if it's been done in bad faith and you can prove the average registration uh it's a little tougher though if you only have an application and you haven't actually started using it before that person registered the domain so yes the lesson is get your domain names uh registered along with your trademark registration once you decide on your name for sure now I've seen a lot of board game Publishers I think it's a little different video games because the the ceiling for the amount of money you can make is so much different in the video game space board game space margins are kind of low so it's hard to make a lot of money you're probably only selling a couple thousand copies you know if you're an indie publisher so with that being the case is it is it always worth it to go through all these processes and spend all the money that it goes into to file the trademarks on or are you really just putting yourself more in the hole especially if you're just you know registering a game title or something like that I'm nodding my head but the answer is no it's not always worth it and a lot of times what people will do is wait until they see that something is a hit put it up on Kickstarter if it starts to get some attention then you file the trademark for it and you know the things I talked about are risks you know other people using your name or what have you they're risks but they're probably low risks so if you're okay with sort of accepting that business risk and maybe you have some flexibility you can change the name or sort of deal with whatever problems come

up then I totally understand not wanting to pay a thousand dollars to register a trademark and I will tell any client this you know I'm not I'm I'm not like you must do this I mean I think it's a good thing to do and I think it's very helpful for the reasons I talked about but I totally understand that it is not uh cost effective unless until until it becomes a problem right and then you will have wished that you did it but you know if you're okay and you're flexible enough that you're you're okay changing the name you know there have been uh things where you know someone's put a game up on Kickstarter and then they've gotten a trademark takedown and they've had to take down the whole campaign and it kind of messes with the campaign have they done a clearance search and maybe file their trademark application beforehand they could have avoided that uh they could have come back to Kickstarter and said hey actually I have a registration for this or or what have you um you know it's it's all risk it's all risk assessment and you know seeing what you can accept and that's fine that's a lot of business right this is the name of the game am I remembering correctly that a trademark only works for the country that you file it in so if I file a trademark in the U.S then you know a company in Canada they don't care they can do whatever they want is that right correct yeah yeah they're territorial uh so and again you want to talk about costs yes you can file in the US and then you can take that U.S application and file it in the EU and Australia and Japan and uh you know all over the world uh but the costs get kind of astronomical if you wanted to do every country in the world you're

going to pay tens of thousands of dollars right so most like it's not worth it so what you want to do is figure out your uh your biggest markets potentially and then maybe file in those but again it's a cost benefit analysis I mean the the problem is outside of the US it's generally a first to file jurisdiction so what we'll have a lot of times is a game gets popular in the US and then in China or in the EU someone else is going to file an application for that because they're getting in before you and they then take those rights and maybe they want to you know extract money from you or they want to you know do their own product with the you know that's a knockoff of yours or something like that but that can be a real problem so again I mean I hate to say it but I mean it costs money to protect all this stuff and you know you're going to pay 600 US dollars to just get into that International System and then each country then has their own fees after that so I mean it gets real pricey you're gonna pay thousands of dollars to get in the EU and Canada and in the US and everywhere but you know if it becomes a problem you're gonna wish you had done it it's the unfortunate sort of reality about this stuff you know protecting yourself legally costs money unfortunately right are you telling me that there are companies in China that make knockoffs yeah yeah or sometimes they don't even make them they just register a trademark which is crazy and then you know you you can get the trademark back a lot of

times because you know you can prove that they maybe they show that we can show that they register dozens of trademarks and never actually release any products or something like that but it costs thousands of dollars to fight it you need to go back and forth and it takes years to do it and it's just a huge pain so you know if you can get it in there beforehand that would be uh way way better but again it costs it's gonna cost you another 600 bucks or so to file a trademark in China unfortunately that's where you have to sell another thousand games or 500 or 100 games to to make up that money you know unfortunately all right so let's keep traveling down this road of just being aware of things that are going to cost money but also some things that are maybe waste of money and things to be aware of because anytime you're doing what I found anytime you're dealing with legal things there's always somebody out there trying to hustle you there's always someone being like Oh you need to pay me this to do that and the other when you could have probably done it for free easily right I'm reminded of my roommate back in college and I was chatting with him one day and he was at his computer working on something and he pulled out his debit card and I was like oh are you are you buying something he goes yeah I'm filing for FAFSA and I was like do fast you don't have to pay for that like what do you what do you need your debit card and he was on fafsa.com not fafsa.gov and so there was this company that was basically charging like 25 or 50 bucks or something like that and they would file it for you even though you could go on the government website and do it for free it's the

exact same process and so are there any things like that that come to mind that people end up getting hustled and end up getting kind of scammed out of their money as far as legal stuff one of the big ones is since since all the trademark filings are public right there are companies that you know scrape all that information from the trademark database and as soon as you file something new they will send you these official looking letters that say Hey you need to register for the global trademark database or something crazy like that it's just some made up thing I don't even know if it even exists but they want to charge you 800 to do it um and I always tell clients it's in all of my form emails that I send when I you know when we file them that there are going to be scams and they're going to send them to you and you should at the very least send me a photo of it uh you know all sort of notifications about payments and things like that will go through me as your lawyer but if you're doing it yourself you're going to have no idea that these things are fake you don't know what fees you need to pay and what you don't need to pay and all that I'm it's just crazy yeah and and they look official um you know sometimes they talk about like you need to register you know I I don't know it's all these like fake Registries and and things like that same with when you form a company you'll start getting all these kind of scam emails because your business address is online and there are companies that just you know they scrape all this information and just send these letters out and they must get I mean they must get enough people paying them that that it makes it worthwhile it's sad yeah it's it's kind of like all the emails that we get nowadays right and sure right they don't look ridiculous they're

not for Viagra pills or whatever you know they are for like things that look official unfortunately yeah and that's that's the road man it's like it really because I've got some of these things I registered trademark a while back and all of a sudden yeah I started getting all these emails all these things in the mail and I had to like really look at it and be like what is this thing because it sounds official and they're using all the right jargon and all the right words and it's like I and a lot of times I'll just look it up I'll just go to Google and be like okay what is this thing it's like oh okay that's a scam cool good to know anytime you receive something right write the name of it and then scam and Google and it will tell you is this a scam or not appreciate it yeah absolutely any other things that come to mind as far as hustles scams waste of money that's a good question I don't know in my business not really I mean you'll have I mean there's there's Kickstarter scammers and people like that that are maybe they're selling some sort of marketing services or something like that I have clients that come back to me and say hey I paid this guy thousands of dollars to do a bunch of social media videos for me and and get me followers and all that and you know nothing comes of it and you know unfortunately what I tell them is look you're gonna either pay me more than you paid them and more than you're ever going to get back from them to you know send them a letter or something like that I mean it doesn't make sense to try to go after them if if it's just a couple thousand dollars but I mean they that's how they get you they they get you for just enough where you pay them and you know they make money and don't need to deliver and it's really not worth going after them either uh so they can get away with this stuff

and it sucks you know there's lots of scammers so you want to make sure that any of these Services you're working with have a good reputation uh another thing is like uh you know and I have nothing against uh developers and other countries but one thing that I often deal with is a client in the US will hire a company in another country that's cheaper to develop a game or to develop some software and they will start paying them a lot of times they will pay them despite not approving the Milestones that they're supposed to be approving uh you know that they're supposed to be getting these deliverables and they're saying well okay I'll pay you because they're asking for more money but they're not actually getting what they promised and so they'll pay them lunch and then at some point they'll realize that they're not getting what they wanted and maybe they have no backup of all the code and they basically just sent their money into a black hole for months and you know it sucks but and then there's really no way to do it after go after a lot of these companies just because the cost of going to another country and filing lawsuits and going after the company and maybe they don't even have the money to get out of them in the first place you know it's just more than than it costs more than you would get back and it doesn't make sense and you know they're all whether it was a scam intentionally or it was just a company that went under uh if you're not getting copies of everything you're doing I mean even if you hire an individual contractor to do artwork for you you want to make sure that you're getting backups of all their you know Photoshop files or whatever you know that that sort of underlying materials you want the rough sketches you want all that you want everything you're paying

for on a regular basis uh before you pay them right because you don't want them to disappear uh even within your country they can disappear and again it may not be worth going going after them just because it costs so much to file a lawsuit it's crazy yeah so just be smart when you're working with people right and it's unfortunate it it happens you know I've worked with artists that have disappeared and and luckily I hadn't paid them everything and you just have to write it off be like well I gotta go find somebody else and that's just over in the Lost column but um let's switch gears a little bit let's talk about the other side of it let's say I'm working on a project and I receive a c send assist letter right where someone is saying that I am cop you know I'm infringing on their trademarks or their copyright or something like that what do I do in that situation call me and we can talk about it I think that would be the first of all don't call me email me I don't like taking calls is why I work on the internet the yeah I mean the first step is to read the letter see what they're claiming to have rights to and then see if there's an actual case there A lot of times there isn't you have to understand what a cease and desist letter is right it's basically the cheapest possible way they can get you to stop doing something that they don't like so even if they don't really have the rights or it's kind of vague you know I do it myself you know I'm guilty of it too we'll send a letter that says hey you need to stop doing this and you know it costs them a few hundred bucks to do that whereas it would cost them you know ten thousand

dollars to file a complaint in court right and to really sue you and so this is them getting away with it cheaply right and so in that in that case it's kind of low low risk High reward for them because if they if if they scare you with a letter that looks scary sounds scary says they're gonna sue you and all this stuff then you know that's a win for them so a lot of times you know the claims are nonsense I mean you know a lot of times they're they're right on right on point because a lot of times people do sort of over estimate the amount of money or the amount of intellectual property they can take from someone else or what a parody is or or you know all these things that that people think are fine and they're not actually fine so that's sort of where that first analysis comes in and then once we do that analysis we can push back a lot of times once you push back they'll just go away right because they they weren't expecting any pushback from a small game developer or designer um but when you push back and they see that you've hired a lawyer and and that it's serious you know they may think twice about actually suing you but you never know I mean you know they they may sue you and in that case you sort of have to deal with it so again it's always risk uh you know is the risk of potentially being sued greater than the detriment to you for just you know stopping using you know complying with whatever they're asking you to do and if so then maybe it's best to avoid the problem altogether on that note though I would say there are certain companies that you want to make sure you avoid any kind of borrowing of anything Nintendo seems to like they don't bear the big one like

they'll shut down somebody with three followers three YouTube subscribers they don't care they will like come in and strike your channel so any other companies you've seen like that just come down with the hammer and like we'll spin yeah the funny one is well there's there's two it's in the trademark context if you ever put the word monster in your trademark or you ever put the word Apple in your trademark they will uh even if the examiner allows it through and says that it's okay you will most likely get them either filing an opposition or contacting you that you need to you know get rid of your registration uh or else they're gonna they're gonna oppose your trademark and they have enough money to do it right and so you can negotiate with them and try to get them to maybe you can change your trademark application or do something to it um but yeah monster is notorious for filing oppositions against anything uh even though they don't I know to my knowledge they don't make games but they may have toys and things like that and they are really kind of litigious about their their trademarks so definitely uh something to watch out for uh yeah and Nintendo is the other one big one I mean they especially for fan games and things like that they are notorious for taking that stuff down even though you know from a practical perspective it probably doesn't really hurt them at all but they are notorious for controlling their IP I mean they shut down like a Pokemon theme party one time at E3 or GBC or something like that and people were just having fun and you know I don't know if they sent the police or whatever but they they definitely sent a cease and desist letter to get this party shut down so I

don't know yeah they're notorious for that stuff that's funny wow people just trying to enjoy your your IP like you'd be happy about that right yeah exactly that's a positive thing good good good PR for your brand but no do you camera with bad PR which I think is crazy well there's uh famously uh what Wizards of the Coast just what do they send a SWAT team or something to someone for having an early copy of some magic cards uh this I think just happened in the last week crazy stuff oh man that is kind of crazy it also it makes me have to pause and really think through I've got this Farm project that I was going to call it you know the monster Apple Farm but maybe I just need to rethink the name well if it's a farm you may get away from it although monster has uh food and beverage related trademarks so they probably would come after you Apple maybe not so much all right give me some like horror stories tell me about some projects some companies you've worked on or just seen or know about that you're like wow that's that's next level because I feel like you know it's one thing to sit here we kind of talk through little things in Nintendo and hahaha you know but like give me some real life on the ground stuff that people ran into that they probably could have avoided had they not done things themselves or had they hired a lawyer tell me about it all the worst stories are clients that come to me with a publishing agreement that they signed that has basically no responsibilities on the publisher side and then no way out of it right so essentially what

you're doing is signing over your game to them and saying you know please publish this game and you know do a good job I hope right there's no no way to keep them on on track no minimum amount of marketing spend or marketing activities no minimum amount of money you're getting for it or anything like that I mean and it will go on in perpetuity and you know they don't necessarily even need to run the kickstarter or necessarily even sell the game so you and a lot of times these these contracts maybe don't even give you any money any minimum guarantee of money or anything like that so you're essentially taking your game giving to these people and it goes into a black hole and never sees the light of day that's really unfortunate and that happens way too much I mean there are you know some companies that are or were notorious for this kind of thing um but then you have others that sort of just act in bad faith or we'll we'll go to them and say hey you know you want this game forever but you're not actually promising that you'll keep it available or anything like that so we added all these things to your termination Clause to make sure we can get out and they will act appalled like how dare you how dare you uh say that you know why wouldn't we you know publish this game and all that well I've seen it before and that's why we're adding it because this is something that happens all the time unfortunately you know and yeah the the saddest ones are when when clients come to me and they have a publishing agreement that's just awful for them and there really is no way out of it right the best we can do is kind of you know hope for the best and reach out to the other party and say look you're not even selling this thing

why do you want this anymore please give it back maybe we can do a buyout or pay some portion of Revenue or something like that some way to get it back but yeah it's a sad story and could it be avoided yes by coming to me in the beginning and having me review the agreements I'm working on one where the contract was one page long and is basically extremely vague about everything and it's just caused nothing but problems right trying to interpret what this sentence meant when two sentences probably could have explained it completely but just to keep it on one page they they didn't include all these terms and yeah it sucks you gotta you gotta there's I have a list of things basically a checklist of things that we need to address in all these publishing agreements and if it's not there then we need to add it and you know a lot of these bad agreements don't even talk about this stuff and it becomes vague and you can again this always goes back to the the issue of you know suing someone or taking any kind of legal action costs more money more and more and more right if you want to actually have a lawsuit against someone it's going to cost you hundreds of thousands of dollars in the U.S and if you could avoid that in the first place by having a good contract and spending you know an hour or two of billable time with a with an attorney in the beginning uh I think that's a good a good win but I'm the lawyer so of course I would say that but yeah I I definitely think it can help well you bring up a good point though because I've seen so many desires especially brand new designers that this is their first game that they've ever gotten signed and they're so excited they're so happy and

they they're just willing to sign whatever and they don't even necessarily read it I think they you know they'll read through it but they don't understand it and so many contracts are written almost purposefully vague almost purposefully hard to understand and using phrases and words and sentence structure that's odd and so it just makes sense to have somebody that can read it can understand it and go oh actually this is what this means oh you thought it was the opposite of that no no this is what it means and I know it's written like Yoda talking but it's you know it's almost like a puzzle you have to figure out the riddle and so just you know finding someone who understands uh it makes a lot of sense because so many people they do get in a situation where they're kind of Trapped they're kind of stuck you know I was in a contract that I didn't fully understand at one point and you know luckily I was with working with someone that you know it was great and they you know they were like oh and once they realized that there was some confusion and misunderstanding like we kind of worked through it and figured some things out but had they not done that had they not been a really great person to work with they didn't have to fix that like I signed something I didn't fully comprehend because I was super new into the whole you know publishing space and getting game side and so you know I can't imagine how many people run into a scenario where now they're stuck now they're trapped and now now what do you do for a lot of designers if it's your first time sometimes you don't really care about this being the big Fair contract that's gonna you know last you forever and all that sometimes you really just want to get your name out there which I think is okay and that's that's fine you know a lot of times you don't really want to go back and forth too much and spend a lot of money with the publisher you just

want them to publish the game and sort of get the bare minimum of protection for yourself and I totally understand that you know if it's not your one and only game that you're ever going to publish hopefully uh then then maybe it's okay to sort of take a worse deal in the beginning just to sort of get your name out there and all that and I do have clients that are sort of you know this is not their dream game that they're making this is something that they you know designed and they found someone to publish and they just want to get a name out there for for something that's totally fine totally respectable but just be aware of the issues with these contracts and a lot of times you know when I draft them for the Publishers I draft them for the publisher right I don't draft them because I want the developer or the designer to you know be it for it to be totally fair to them you know I obviously are dropped you know representing my client and trying to get things better for them so there's always going to be things to push back on for sure negotiate I think is negotiation is something I feel like a lot of new people they just feel like they can't they feel like they're like I don't know I don't want to say something and then they call off the whole deal and it's like I know we're in the the business of fun and games but it's yeah it's business it's still business yeah and it especially as the money increases and you know people change and things what I what I always tell people is look they want to publish your game so you you have value right you are not just like begging them to publish for you right you you they want to work with you so you can push back on

things now you may push too far and that's something that I'm always aware of over lawyering it or or pushing back too hard on sort of crazy things or maybe like uh you know sticking on one thing when really it's like a one percent chance of happening and so it's not worth holding out the whole deal over but you know realize that you have value and that your product has value that you're making and you know just don't don't accept a bad deal just because you're afraid to ask for anything right very rarely will they come back and say I can't believe you changed it I think one time I had a company where they were like you would think I I don't know I did it insulted their mothers or something like that right I mean the way they came back they were like I can't believe you we I thought we had a deal and I thought that I said you're crazy this is a totally normal business stuff to push back on on these onerous Clauses that you have in your in your contract so don't be afraid have some confidence what are some of those onerous Clauses what are some things you mentioned earlier of making sure there's a way to get the game rights back making sure there's some minimums in there that a company can't just have the thing in you know for Infinity uh but what are some of the other things that designers need to just be on the lookout for just be aware of make sure that their contracts have have these things or or things that they want to avoid a couple things all right number one yeah the big one is being able to get out of it if things are not going well right if the publisher is not holding up their end of the bargain you need to have a way to

get out right and then maybe some certain minimum standards of things that they're doing that basically they're earning the right to continue publishing this game that's number one number two is the scope of the rights that you're giving them so maybe you are you just have one game you're giving them that they probably have a right of first refusal to publish like add-ons and expansions and sequels that's nice sometimes they want a last match so that if they refuse it in the beginning you can then go and you know find another company to potentially publish it and then they want to be able to match that offer right and if you don't like working with them then you don't necessarily want them to have that right a lot of companies will want like TV rights and movie rights and all this crazy stuff and you look at their history and they've never done a TV show and they've never done movies they you know I why am I giving you these rights to make a TV series out of my game when you've never done it before it doesn't make any sense so we'll push back on that a lot um the royalty Provisions are another one where you know sometimes they you know they receive the money and then they have like 30 days to send you a report and then you need to send them an invoice and then they have like 60 days to pay the invoice and they just have these like extremely long timelines for paying you the money that you're owed and you know sometimes there's no requirement that they send a statement that shows like the number of units they sold and the the price of the units and the territory they sold it in so it's just like a black box like you don't they're just sending you a royalty check

and you have no idea how many they sold or what they you know where they sold them another one is approvals so a lot of times you need to submit materials for them to approve uh and they will basically get like 30 days to approve it and then if they don't approve it in that 30 days it's deemed to be disapproved so then you're just like left after a month you know wondering is it wrong do you you know do I need to change something and there's really no uh requirement on their end that they actually communicate that so you want to make sure that you know there's a time limit that maybe if they don't respond in that time then it's automatically approved or something like that something to sort of light a fire under them and get them to approve your stuff because a lot of times especially in the video game context you know you're waiting on approvals to continue creating things and if they have like a month to approve things then that's a month that could potentially be wasted you know where you could have been working on the approved thing so you know we try to shrink that time period down as much as possible and try to try to get some sort of uh penalties for them not approving things on time so those are some of the big things you know there's other things like making sure that they promise they're gonna follow the law when they publish your game and they're not gonna you know incorporate infringing intellectual property into the game and you know promising to defend you in case you get sued because of something they did a lot of times those Clauses are really one-sided so just sort of turning those things it's called indemnification and warranties or representations making

them uh Mutual uh and having some some sort of promises on their end is another good one gotcha there's there's a good two-thirds of the agreement that probably makes no sense to most people that is where a lot of these like sort of you know devil in the details kind of things happen and a lot of one-sided stuff is going to be so a lot of times they allow themselves to assign their rights to another company without your consent and so that means you could you know you give your game to one publisher and then they have the right to go and send it to another publisher or maybe they like create a new brand under it and that Brand's Never released anything and you know you don't know who they are and then they assign it over to them and now you're working with a whole new team and they're not approving what you thought they had approved before I mean it could be a huge mess so you maybe want to get some uh some right over consent uh of those assignments things like that so lots of I mean there's a million things you could change in a contract but those are some of the highlights I think that I usually deal with exactly this has been awesome and so many things to be aware of so many things just to think about and to research and talk to a professional about and so thank you so much for just sharing you can learn all this stuff on your own but it seems a little more cost effective to just work with someone like me to to help you out since I've already done the uh the learning yeah exactly where can people find you online if they want to hire you or send you a contract they're working on where can people check you out easiest way is a game lawyerblog.com that'll take you right to my blog but there's you know uh price list there's a contact form there all

that stuff you can set up a consultation all that right on the website so game lawyerblog.com we'll take you right there I don't tweet I don't do any of that stuff so the website is the place to be to to contact me awesome Zach really appreciate your time thanks for joining me on the show my pleasure all right

Progress saved