Skip to main content
Loading video...

Can Young Children Handle Complex Board Games?

Transcript 16:07

today i'm going to be talking about complex board games for children if you're watching this you're probably familiar with the channel and you've seen a lot of my board game lists and reviews for family board games some of the stuff that i recommend is a little more challenging probably some of the most common comments i ever get are about whether or not the games are twoplex too complex for kids my kids are eight and soon to be six and so i wanted to talk a little bit about the decision making that i go through when i'm selecting games and the kinds of factors that i consider when i'm picking out a game for my children to play and i wrote down five points about more complex strategy board games for children so before i jump into that i will say today is a bit of an exceptional day this is the first time i'm doing a live uh video on my phone i am babysitting tonight and i almost didn't even do a video at all except the baby's asleep all right and uh i thought well this is kind of a great setting for a dad themed video i'm gonna i'm gonna do it i'm gonna make a live video where i am so i'm out anything could happen if i hear a little

cry i might have to end early but i thought it'd be a little bit of fun you could kind of see into my life this is what parents do for each other right parents are having fun celebrating a birthday anyway that's why the background is a little uncommon so five points about board games for kids now i did want to say that on the mobile app i don't know how easily i'll be able to follow along with messages normally i encourage comments and questions to be dropped while i'm presenting if i see them come through i'll try to respond even after the fact if you leave any comments below after the video is posted i will try to respond i really do like engaging with my viewers and responding to their questions hopefully the audio is okay too because there's a lot more balancing well whatever number one so i this concern came up with my one of my close friends uh it has to do about the objectives of a board game trying to win like are my children old enough to understand an objective and to piece together a strategy that they can follow through to the end of the game and i gotta say no that's not what i do when i'm playing with my kids my kids can't play the game and strategize yet

not at the age of six years old games at this age are still very much about the process about uh what the game is about and about the process of getting to the end so kk six or who's going to be six years old uh she'll play the game she understands that there's a winner and she'll say you know did i win and i might say yes or no or i could tell her the score but she doesn't really even have a great sense of what the scores even mean she's at the age right now where if i say you've got 28 points she'll say 28. is that a 2 and an 8 like she's still thinking about how to write those numbers this is a kindergartner so if you're watching my channel and you're hearing me talk about these complex games that i'm playing with my my eight-year-old and my five-year-old and you're thinking gosh you know my kid could never play that game my kids barely play those games they understand the rules they understand the process of the game but this is still very much a development uh activity for them and they're not fully there yet but they are having a lot of fun and i do think it challenges them and so that's why i play these more challenging games i want my kids to rise up to what those tasks demand and i'm really satisfied with the growth that i've seen but don't get me wrong my kids are not like playing teenager level games like teenager teenagers play them

so winning is not what these games are about the second point is um i've recommended some games in fact very recently i mentioned uh role player role player board game for uh best games that a dad can play with his kids and somebody brought up the complexity of that game i want to be clear i make edits to games all the time i trim them down so that they're a little bit more accessible so for example with role player this is a dice drafting game where essentially what you're trying to do is build a character by satisfying objectives you're picking dice up and you're putting them down on your board after that's over there's what's called a market phase in the market phase players use their money that they've collected during the game to buy additional cards as um supplements for their character and to get more points into the game that whole extra phase don't play it like i just trim things down what kids really do well with is repetition games that have a really clear flow like you're doing the same thing every single turn um planet is one that i've recommended before planet what you do so you take a tile you pop it onto your planet and then after everyone's put a tile on their planet you see who gets animals and you just do that over and over and over again games that have multiple phases multiple mechanics going

on they don't go over so well and normally what i do is i ask myself is this really necessary for the game and if it's not i just cut it out so the one thing i didn't mention in that last video is that for the role player cut the market phase or with five tribes i did mention this i love five tribes especially when i play with my eight-year-old but just cut the bidding mechanic don't bid for first player just play the repetitive but you know still very engaging turns and then of course another thing that the kids really don't uh cling to is any level of real abstraction um so i did a comparison very recently between a game called dinogenics and dinosaur island two very similar board games that are basically about jurassic park the game but in dinosaur island you're trading dna these uh different symbols for dinosaurs that you can build dinosaurs with so if there's like purple dna and red dna and green dna very abstract in dinogenics you're getting cards to make dinosaurs it's still dna points but every card has a picture of the dinosaur on it that you can build so if you're building a brontosaurus and it takes four brontosaurus cards to make a brontosaurus the kids get that but if it takes you know two purple and one yellow and one red in order to make a brontosaurus over here in dinosaur island the kids are like you know

why so i when i see a game that has a lot of abstraction like that i sort of steered clear of it okay one thing i really love i've mentioned this on my top 10 family board meetings the kids really do well or rather i think a game is really educational and the kids really do well when it involves choices with numbers so a fantastic example of this is mountain goats in mountain goats players roll dice and then from the resulting die each player has to select a pair of die in order to perform uh the action that they're going to do on their turn so the actual or i guess they're sucking two pairs of dice so they've got to add up the different numbers if you add up a three and a four that makes seven and i can do this or i could add up a six and a four and that makes little like very very small adding and then choice that comes down to it or another game uh pebble rock delivery service in this game there are two sets of die a fast and dangerous die and a slow and safe uh pair of dice and so the children have to select or all the players not just the children but they have to select which pair of dice they want to use for their turn do they want to take a risk and move faster do they want to move slow and be safer so and every player decides that for each turn i really like it when choice is

involved and those choices involve numbers i think that kind of gets their gears turning in a way that's very realistic for them it means elementary school kids but it's also you know it's fun for adults too but i think that's what they find most challenging and those are the kinds of games that i'm most satisfied as a father and as a former math teacher i don't really talk about that a lot in this channel but i used to teach high school math i have a goal that i'm working towards i really want to develop my kids problem solving skills and that's why i do these board games with them um choices with numbers have always been excellent oh another one um rescue animals that's the one where you're trying to get patterns from dice more choices with numbers so point four is uh yeah i i've mentioned this so many times before but i wanted to include it on this list of things to consider when you're getting complex board games for children um it's simultaneous game play so here's the thing especially with young kids when i'm playing a game like a game for example that i really love is russian railroads don't play without my kids by the way but one of the things that i find so engaging about that is the tension as i'm waiting for what i want to do next i see my my next move and i have to wait for everybody's turn the whole time i'm thinking oh come on come on you know i hope this is available

when my next turn comes or if it's not available what can i do instead so i got my plan and my plan b that is engaging that keeps my attention for the kids those stakes are not reached kk is not thinking about what she's going to do on her next turn for her the game only happens during her turn she could care less what other people are doing unless it's a combative game like evolution for example so um with that in consideration in order to keep things interesting for everybody simultaneous gameplay has had a huge impact on like the kinds of games that we like to play most it just keeps things moving and honestly it's less interesting for the adults too when the kids are bored waiting for their turns but when we played karuba when we played my city everyone was active the entire time i love games that do that and i found that when a game utilizes simultaneous gameplay there's a much better handling of the complexity of the game then lastly the most important thing of all probably is that these board games i'm making memories with my kids the attitude i take into it and that elona takes into it when we're playing together is most important of all um i mentioned single things gameplay and how it can be boring when we're waiting

for people to take turns for those that are turn-based games when people do get impatient when when you know kids are asking lots of questions if that ever becomes taxing or if that ever starts to become a burden it's better just stop as soon as a game becomes about teaching a lesson like if you're using a game in order to teach something the kids pick that up if they feel like you're not trying to have fun with them but you're trying to get something out of it like you wanna you wanna see them perform by doing arithmetic or you wanna see them pay attention and recognize when their turn is or you wanna um you know you want to see them be more strategic as soon as you're playing a game with expectation instead of just for the joy of the game that's a big turn off for the kids so whether you're playing even if you're playing something easy uh the thing is you play a harder game and you go into it as a parent thinking okay this is a challenging one i really hope my kids do well i really want to see them embrace this and like try to solve some puzzles and you have this hope and if they're not doing that and that comes across the way you're you know talking with them suddenly they think the game sucks and they don't want to stop and they just stop having fun if you're gonna play a complex game with kids something that's a little bit higher on the box than is their age level and you've got to go into it the same way as if you're playing candyland

just have fun who cares as long as you know especially if there's a story like i can even play dinosaur island the one with the abstract gene genes and if i'm if i act like i'm interested in what they're doing oh wow you know you could do this and that that's cool wow that's a clever idea like regardless of the idea is actually you know really under anything just having fun that's what matters that's what keeps the kids interested and you know challenges them more and it makes them want to take it out again which i think is really what reinforces their understanding of these complex rules and you know helps them develop the sense of strategy so that is what i consider when i'm or those are some of the things that i've learned from these more complex board games that i played with my kids um if you were dropping comments during the video on this device i was not able to see them coming up so i apologize i wasn't ignoring you i just couldn't see um but next week i want to talk about the mechanics of board games that i find most interesting what is it that drives my hobby you know what is it that i identify in a game that makes a game perfect at least for me i want to share that with you that'd be interested to

talk about um what it is that you find in board games that makes the hobby addictive and most enjoyable for you one of the things what are the things that make you need to buy a board game i'm not sure what i'll call yet something like that um i did recently do a video with my daughter we did a board game showcase we're gonna be editing that so that'll be the first time i post a review that we did together be on the lookout it'll have some sort of thumbnail to help you recognize that she's featured that's all for now thank you for watching and for joining me today i'm sorry i wasn't able to see the comments during the feed i am working to do a live video every monday at about 8 p.m uh hope you come back for more take care i'll see you next time bye

Progress saved