Make your players feel CLEVER
Transcript
Some people don't enjoy board games. It's hard to believe, I know. I think one of the main reasons is a fear of not understanding the rules, of not playing well, and being made to look foolish. As a designer of multiple published games, my goal is always to offer a positive experience. One of the best ways of achieving this is making the players feel good about themselves. An excellent question to ask during play testing is, "What moments in the game made you feel clever?" If a player says that they felt clever playing your game, it means you offered up interesting decisions, a challenging puzzle, or an opportunity for them to be creative. These are excellent ways of engaging an audience. Gathering feedback about such moments will help you to pinpoint the precise game mechanisms and scenarios which made the players feel this way. You can then refine these elements and work to amplify their sense of achievement.
Distribute these moments evenly throughout the game to create a consistently rewarding experience. Alternatively, ask if there are any elements of the game which made the player feel stupid or foolish. This is potentially even more valuable information for you as a designer because it's not an experience that anybody wishes for their players, but you might find players are worried about answering this question honestly. So, it's essential that you watch your testers as they play your game. Don't just rely on their verbal or written feedback. Body language can tell you a lot about how your players are feeling. For hundreds more play testing questions like this one and a rationale for each of them, pick up my book, Adam and Wales Play Testing, available on Amazon.