Empire's End Roundtable Review - Friendly Ties Podcast
Transcript
hello there and welcome back to Friendly ties today we're going to be talking about a interesting board game we're going to be talking about Empire's end so Empire's end guys do you like your Empire this is a weird game yeah and what a title though like I actually you know a credit to that I kind of like this is like this game so if there's anything to know about this game it's about the end of an Empire um which is what Nick told me when I asked him what it was but it it really it really says it all um it's just if you feel a sense of Doom when you hear that that is that is that is what you will feel as you uh embark on this journey the theme drew me to the game yeah Nick you're the reason we played it like I think for the last like a month and a half every time we got together to play a game you're like well we could play Empire's end and that's actually unusual for Nick like usually Nick just plays you know whatever Anastasia and I voiced upon him so yeah first of all I'm running a DND campaign with the theme of an Empire's end and so like there's a very personal connection with it sure but that being said I like a negative Victory point game and I had a suspicion that it was kind of like a negative victory point game it's not but that's what I thought it might be at the at the beginning when I kind of grabbed onto the idea of it yeah so this is like a inverse Tableau Builder like
you start with like 11 happy little cards in front of you and they make you stuff and then as the game goes on it just all burns like literally yeah like okay so the idea right is that you have you have we each have our own Empire represented by those 12 cards right and then I and then it's uh yeah yeah it's like slowly destroyed like your role is not necessarily to prevent the destruction of your Empire but to like slow down the destruction of your Empire but also prevent it I don't know how do you guys feel about that and like the schema thing what do you think we're doing like like who are we what is our role I do think the like yeah right because at the end of the game it's no one's no one's Tableau or 11 cards or Empire or however like thematic or literally you want to get with it is completely wiped out right like you are stemming the bleeding as much as you can and you do get some benefits Powers along the way that you can use to modify what you still have left uh so you're you're trying to make the best of things that are are falling apart right the game is it comes from a a negative space in terms of like the actions and I think one way that that really came out in our games the two of you constantly were like I'm so stressed I like yes I can't I can't have this thing coming my way so I don't think I had the same the same
like emotional reaction but it's I think it's that's probably to me kind of the like Flagship unique thing that this game had with was this idea of just like the sense of loss um which I enjoyed but I think and I think the two of you enjoyed it too but also there were times where you're like oh that's a lot yeah I mean there's definitely a concept in gaming I forget the name of it exactly of you know it if I was to give you 25 victory points or I was to take away 25 victory points from you they're they're functionally the same but they feel different like losing the 25 points feels way worse than getting like if you start with 25 and you go to zero it's way yeah anyway and this game leans so hard into that emotion uh like this is probably one of the more emotion uh sparking Euro games I played in a long time you know not just like oh I want to win but just like Dread and Terror about what's about to come next and I think that's because you know as I said it's like a tableau Destroyer but it it's also a tableau Builder like you have these 11 cards and over the course of the game you're going to be adding little customized powers to the bottom of these cards and you get to activate them at various times and you you I don't I I get an affinity to those cards like you make combos like oh this card over here is going to give me extra resources as long as it's next to a road so I put a Road next to it but now my road is maybe going to burn and then my combo goes away and I like my combo I put that together and how do I defend
this and you know like I just and you know that combo's worth 17 points just on the card itself it like all these things kind of compound into uh well until the way I played it so when we play this game twice and what I noticed over these two plays is the three of us had kind of different uh strategies or maybe not even strategy but like emotional reactions to it and uh and mechanical reactions like I played both of these games trying to keep my Empire unburnt as possible so in this game if you're familiar with the game no thanks um it's a similar kind of thing where like destruction is coming on the third card and now we all have a auction to see who gets hit and essentially you pay resources to not have your third card destroyed and then whoever you know ends up having the third card destroyed gets all the resources everybody paid so maybe it was worth it um and I spent both of these games uh barely burning anything and and running like having almost no money no resources behind my screen it's just terrified I think that's why I was so scared because I I was so close to the precipice every single round because I kept paying you two to have your Empires burn and mine wasn't burning but I was just it was you know I was in a really fragile uh uh game State through much of it I think that there's something so key to like what you said to about this idea of that you're like you're like you you're building your Tableau you're building your engine if you will it is an engine Nick right I wouldn't agree but that's
fine okay fine you're building your Tableau here but when John talks about this idea of you know you have these cards that give you these little abilities the part you left out John is that you only get those cards not only but you probably barely get those cards from destroying parts of your Empire so you know it the basic function of this game is we each have our Tableau of uh I see it's 11 cards our table of 11 cards and then there's a like a main board and that board is just a track it's a set track you play the same track every game and I would say there's three types of spots but primarily there are destruction spots and that's that plays out with what John described which is basically a card comes out it's a slot of one of those 11 and that spot is what is threatened and one of you is going to destroy that spot and so that's what the auction is is essentially are you willing to lose that spot of your Empire and in exchange you get these resources which I think to your point John makes for such an interesting dynamic in the game because they're like well am I willing to destroy my number two area you know and every spot is worth points so you're like okay am I willing to destroy it and maybe I can rebuild it but I'm gonna get all these resources and you need those resources to then bid defense against the next one yeah and there's like 20 of people's coming in or something I can't even find the language it's like you're both bidding you're bidding on
defending from taking the thing but then when you take these cards that or when you destroy these slots then you get a special ability that you can put on another area so that's that's like what makes for such a weird emotional and stressful dynamic in this game and it kind of you know to what Nick was saying it's just it it could be really fun because you could sort of it is fun because you're like okay fine I'll destroy I'll destroy this side of my town and I don't need that road but man I'm gonna make this other spot really great but then suddenly that other spot is being threatened and you're like I can't possibly lose this so I need to like I have to bid as high as possible and then I'm giving all these resources away so it's just it's it's fascinating because in our first game I I thought the goal of the game was like not the goal but I thought everyone's Empire was just gonna be ruined by the end and so I like let my entire Empire Burn yeah Nick's like No One's Gonna Empire is gonna entirely burnt like I think it could yeah yeah like by the end I was like burning sections just to stay alive with like like it was I was encroaching from both sides and it's the second game I played a lot more defensively but I think it is true that Jon was much more attack like he did not want to let parts of his world and yeah yeah because you do you get kind of attached to it so there's a lot of really interesting little Dynamics kind of brought even in this game yeah one thing that I want to talk a little bit I mean John you mentioned no thanks and Anastasia you mentioned
bid and auction I actually think that rulebook even does call it an auction or bidding or something I don't know and one thing that I find really interesting is when I hear auction I generally think about like what happens in most real life auctions right where it's like I'll pay more I'll pay more I'll pay more until someone's like I'll pay the hundred and fifty thousand dollars and then they pay that amount of money and no one else pays anything uh but that's not what happens in this game really what happens as we go around is like would you like to pay one for something bad to not happen to you and the answer is yes pretty much always yeah until the point where you're like well if I say that I don't want to pay one then I'm gonna take all of the resources that everybody else paid one for before this including yourself and you're kind of getting that including yourself yeah right it just kind of accumulates over the the course of the round is everyone's saying no I'll pay one no I'll pay one and then those things kind of accrue until the point where someone says all right well I'll take the bad thing but I also get all these resources along with that which is which is really just the no thanks mechanism if you have played no thanks this game is is a complicated no thanks right it just it takes that same core Loop and and adds a couple aspects to it which is pretty neat I actually I haven't seen that uh particular mechanism being used in other games and I think that it is well executed in this game thematically I don't really know that it makes a ton of sense that it also doesn't really matter like the idea that I'm just like waiting until like oh yeah there's a ton
of food for me to take if I allow this pestilence to come in yeah or it's like is it like a meteor that we're all like hot potatoing around with our like magic or something I don't I don't know I I actually I did one of those like things where you like you really stretch the theme in your mind where I was like well no because if this area is getting destroyed then all the people in resources from this region had to move over to this region and so that's why these other regions get skill sets or these other reasons get these things or people were sending Aid because I was destroyed like in my mind I was like found myself being surprisingly thematic but I think part of that is the ownership that I did feel over my 11 slot town right like understanding that you know it wasn't going to survive unscathed particularly in our in the second game we played um which after the first game I think this one of those games it takes a play or two to kind of understand the pacing uh because in it's a long track there's a lot of Destruction I mean you kind of going along it and you're like Okay cool so we have three more destructions nope actually four more distractions and then maybe we'll get a little bit of resources back but by that point everything's basically destroyed so we're really not getting much like so it's been a majority part of the game did we figure out how many auctions take place it depends on the player count it's a lot it's a lot it's like you know a couple dozen or something like that yeah yeah so you you do feel this like I guess I felt this like ownership over my
town knowing that these things are gonna happen and so I don't know I think that that lends itself to like kind of digging a little deeper into the theme if you want to but it is it I don't want to I don't want to oversell it it is it's a Euro with a with a theme yeah pasted on there one thing I really liked about it was which does exist in uh no thanks as well is the asymmetric incentives um that happen in this game you know all of our Empires start out identical at the very beginning but as soon as like literally one turn happens and you know one person has something get burned things start to get asymmetric they you know they don't care about one spot anymore because it burned already to a certain extent um well I guess the burning can kind of spread but they also got some asymmetric benefit and then there's also ways that you may move your slots around and there are ways that you may be forced to move your slots around and that just jostles everything and when you're forced to move your slots around it's like you know take your your second best uh slot and move it to the the third slot or something like that and my second best might be different than Nick's second best because you know his best got destroyed already or something like that so by surprisingly quickly you get to the point after just a few actions where you know a thing comes out and it's threatening spot five and spot five is worth 25 points to me and it's only worth seven points to Anastasia and it's worth 14 points to Nick and not even considering the potential bonuses we have put underneath those and combos that might be reacting to other things and so now you know in in that situation
um I super care like I don't want to lose my whatever 25 points in Anastasia is like I don't mind losing three points at all I will take this mountain of resources that John is terrified to like to take because it's such an asymmetric um incentive structure and and because of that maybe Anastasia keeps pushing her luck hoping she can squeeze just one more thing out of me but then what if she pushes too far and I can't afford it well well then I guess I lose 25 points so she's not too unhappy and you know there's a huge Silver Lining um usually when you uh you know have the destruction hit your town and that is that you you get a bunch of stuff yeah and you're like I think I think that the way this game does that executes the the asymmetry that's built out is is very well implemented um I especially notice when we were playing in our four player game that there were often times where it was like two of us had changed from the bass thing but two of us had very similar to kind of like what the starting setup was yeah and that is really neat that the game has enough points of contact to say hey you're going to switch the locations of these cards or you'll have innovated or upgraded these cards um to be a little bit better over here and so that matters more to you than it does to another player but it doesn't do it so chaotically that it's exhausting or annoying um it also doesn't do it so chaotically that you are always in a situation where everyone's circumstances look totally different and so that requires you to pay attention that's the interaction
component of the game is paying attention to other folks and saying hey what is important here yeah but one thing that does lend itself to is analysis and Analysis can lead itself towards paralysis to a certain extent and um we played this game twice and I think one was a three player game one was a four both of them came in between 60 and 90 minutes so it was not maybe closer to 90. I think the four player game was was 90. um so it wasn't a terribly long game but as one of the resident analysis paralysis people I can say that there were many times in this game in these games where I just sat there staring at my resources and I'm like do I spend a week here and I'm just sitting there and I'm thinking like okay if I do that I lose this amount of points and if I don't then it says I might take it and she gets that amount of points and this and that the other thing and kind of bounce around and ultimately I generally you know the the fear of of Destruction won out and I would spend the week even if it was my last wheat and then I'd be just terrified it might come back around to me but fortunately Anastasia usually uh took the bullets out of those I do want to know Anastasia came dead last in the first game and crushed Us in the second game using similar ish Vibes like you still definitely caught a lot of bullets in that second play which was interesting but this is just like especially near the end of the game because there's a lot of end game scoring on these cards as well um in that second play um my best slot I think it's like 32 points or something like that had two end game Victory Point things stacked up underneath it that just made like one of
my resources worth a ton of points and so that's one of the reasons I was sweating bullets is because that one slot made or broke the entire game for me like like half of my points probably were baked into this one slot whereas in a city you were more spread out but you also just had so many more end game points and that's also something to keep in mind like okay you know if if I don't take this maybe Anastasia is forced to take it and it'll knock out that thing which gives her points for her wheat but I don't know how much wheat she has and ah like to a certain extent like there's so much you can analyze that I tried to to come back to emotions and be like well I don't want my Empire to burn so I'm going to spend the wheat and be unhappy in about 45 seconds when it comes back around to me um but sometimes it took me a long time to to end up going with my gut instinct if that makes sense yeah yeah no I mean that makes a lot of sense and I think that goes and goes back to what we've been talking about like this idea that this game is very emotionally stimulating uh so to speak I I think like and I think that you know what I was saying earlier too about like the pacing of that game and also I think how we can all kind of bring different play styles to it you know I think that that when I was playing that first game with the three of us I was playing in front of John and it was interesting because I didn't quite understand the pacing and I was I think trying to exert a little bit more control over my city I actually ended up Bernie or Empire going to town and see it's an Empire it's an Empire yes um
I think I took auctions too low John wasn't taking auctions per se uh Nick was was grabbing auctions as soon yeah and he was so if I did pass John would put in food John would put in a resource and then and then Nick would take it so it wouldn't even get back to me so it's an interesting Dynamic how the kind of the the the personality Porter yeah and personalities kind of playing because in the follow-up game it was a four player uh with our friend NJ and there was a different dynamic because I was sitting behind John and so John's sort of strategy of just constantly putting things in meant by the time it got to me the pots were really attractive and I also learned from that first game to wait even if I knew I could take something and I was like oh I don't care if this spot Burns I was like well great that means I should wait this out as long as possible and see how much benefit I can get for it I think I even had a rule where I was like not four player game now I should we should add this caveat in in four players there's just more resources right there are more auctions but there's also just more resources inherently so if it does come back around to you just the the value add is just so much higher which also I think I I'm sure we'll touch on this more but I think I really enjoyed four player and I think that might be the best player count I can only say that having played three and four but I just so enjoyed that just the gain I was getting for the burning it actually made the burning of my Empire uh better but
my point is to say that like you would get these huge piles of resources and so that it became very attractive and there was even a point at one point in the game where I think by the nature of what we could see it seemed like John was winning he had the least amount of his Empire burned right and so in each of those slots we talked about are worth points some of them are huge amounts of points and that can be very I don't want to say deceptive but it can be a it's a very strong consideration or you know I early on particularly when you're like okay do I want to lose 25 points for this and so Nick said to me no I think I think we I think you need to let John take like you weren't supposed to take that right like I took the auction because it was just covered in resources Yeah Eddie was like he was like this was our chance to like burn John's
and it was like the heart of his engine and and I was like yeah but Nick there's just so much stuff here it's so good for me it was like I just it was so good for me like yes it was an opportunity so it creates also an interesting Dynamic at the table because I think there is an element it's it's not a take that and I want to be very careful to describe that because I don't want people to think this is a particularly mean game because it's not a mean game it's sort of like it's a fringe of that I think well the game can be means like have moments to be a little bit mean but it's yeah but not directly because you don't know how many resources people has you don't know if I can defend again or not and if I can't you don't you know you didn't know that you didn't know that and also like if even if John had taken it right like if we had destroyed it he would have then gotten this massive pile of resources and so it's not necessarily always bad for him because then he could have maybe done something differently with those and you know to drop back to your point John and with all of those resources I had all sorts of cards that not all sorts but I had created a tableau that really benefited me for having the food at the end of the game oh four points at the end of the game for every food you had and you took like 12 food it was insane I had like 20 food yeah so like at the end so like yeah and so for me I was like yeah sure I could I could lose all these points but this is like you know 48 points of food for me like I'm
I'm taking it yeah and when winning scores seem to be in the high 100s like you know 180 to 200 or so that's a lot that's a lot exactly so just again really really interesting Dynamics at the table amongst both each other and and and you know your own interaction with your Tableau yeah yeah John made a comment I think quite along the same lines of that Anastasia at the end of our first play that um it felt reminded him a lot of the modern art Dynamic where it was a game that really cares about the metagame of the players at the table and you largely want to be in sync with the the group think of your table and you know you could be really good at this game at your table and go sit down in another table and the way that they play the game you know maybe they don't let resources a pile in the same way or they you know the opposite right they really really just pile everything on there and it might be that the way you play this game uh is actually quite disastrous for their strategy and that's I think that's very good right that the game has um has has a a flexibility uh in strategy based on the world around you it means that you need to like pay attention to what's going on with the like table Vibe is it's just as important in this game to like say hmm do I think that you're gonna put more resources on there if I pass right now uh because you brought that up earlier yeah yeah exactly you're you were like okay this isn't bad I'll take this but
really the question you're asking yourself is this isn't bad but are you two not gonna take it because I would like to really puff this piggy bank full if I can exactly yeah and you know every resource we spend into that is less defense we have against the future as well exactly exactly and I think that I you know we've said this multiple times I I don't build my sand castle I don't want anyone to kick it over and if anyone's going to kick it over then I want to kick it over right and I I think I've also said though that if we go into a game where I have zero control I often you know bring up Grand Austria hotel as my like kind of trademark example for this you know that the inherent luck of the dice means that I'm going to have very little control I'm gonna do my best to build the best thing I can despite that right and I think that's how I ended up going into the second play of this which is I was like cool not all of this Empire is going to survive but how am I going to mitigate that like what is going to be the most important to me and then what am I going to lose right and so like I was like very careful to be like cool the only thing I want to keep is like these two or three areas and and then I prioritize them you know I was like this is the most important and this is the least and then you know and then I I told myself I have to be malleable as things happen because I make it in a situation where I don't have enough resources and I'm gonna have to lose a spot but I was very careful in
doing that to to kind of pay attention to my resource counts and to kind of know that I was always kind of prepared to protect what I needed I felt I needed to protect but there was a good portion of my Empire I was willing to lose in order to do that and so it's sort of like I don't know if this is the right use of this term but like diminishing returns like at different points in this game you're gonna have a number of points and then you're going you're just going to kind of constantly be losing them and then trying to get them back and so it's like I guess I was always kind of looking at it as like cool as long if I have these five slots then I'm gonna get a ton of points but if I only have these three I'll still get a bunch it's just kind of like what am I willing to lose does that make sense and there are ways to rebuild your Empire we haven't mentioned that but like there are a few emphasis on few moments that you can spend one of the resources to unburn one of your spots so that is also a consideration there were there were a couple times uh where I was like really really worried about a thing you know I kept paying to not take a thing and then like I saw Anastasia take it and then we immediately went into an Empire Building thing and she just rebuilt it and I'm like oh I guess I could have finally done that too I mean again asymmetric uh incentives maybe hers was cheaper to rebuild than mine but like I was so terrified of destroying anything that I I kind of forgot that you know well you can repair these things so I mean to a certain extent I mean it takes a lot of resources to repair the really lucrative ones but you can get a lot of resources off of your opponents from these
auctions so it's interesting yeah one thing that we um since we were talking about points that I do want to bring up is that mostly in this game your points are going to be the parts of your Tableau that haven't burned but there are a handful of the innovations that you can get that give you end game scoring and it's mostly for having XYZ leftover resources at the end of the game and I was very pleasantly surprised in this in the the most recent game that we played the four player game um because I had the the quote unquote best Tableau right the least burned Empire at the end of the round and I came up I came in third place and I actually thought that was a really cool aspect of the game I think after our first game game it felt like it was just going to be don't let your stuff burn and make sure you like do the auctions in such a way that you have enough resources to not let the important things burn and that's how you're going to win and then after this second play it's like oh no no like actually like paying attention to those other end game scoring conditions um does help does matter does change the way that you're going to evaluate certain piles and I just I like that because I thought it was going to be a little bit more straightforward of the scoring and I think it it it expands the the Strategic approach in a game that is largely very very tactical yeah yeah a lot of sense and I don't think you can undersell that really like that this really is like it's a it's a good quality Euro underneath there there is a lot of different little elements to think about whether it is you know your Tableau or how you are managing those auctions or what you're burning or to
John's Point what you're rebuilding I mean there was this kind of pivotal point at the end of our of that four player game where it was like do I take this massive pile of resources and I actually um because it's something we do we you know we do a lot of table talk I was actually Nick and I were kind of evaluating it because it was like it was gonna burn one of my 25 points areas and it's the last turn of the game and so Nick was like is that good for you and I was like well I have enough resources to immediately rebuild it and I was then going to get a bunch of food and I've mentioned that you know food was worth you know a whole bunch of points to me at the end of the game so I was like there's actually a world here where I can burn this rebuild it and still come out on top and very much so that is I think to go back to what you were saying John about like AP I'm sure I could have sat there and like taken a Nick's board and seeing how valuable it was to him which I didn't realize in the moment so it really was the right decision he told me that later or I could have tried to consider how negative is it for John if he has to take it or is this good for you know NJ like there was these elements at play and I think that there is a dynamic to this game where you want you you have the ability to to see all these different like layers playing out and I I agree with you Nick that it's like really fun to kind of be like cool how can I make these cards work or how can I make these different Dynamics work but there also is like um kind of a nice I don't want to say it's not pacing or like it's not really Breezy but like there there kind of comes a point where
you like you were saying John you kind of just have to get into the emotion of it we're like yeah I don't know this like big pile it seems like this is better for me if I do this and then I can burn and rebuild and like let's do it and then you do that and if you can calculate all of the benefits of that in the moment that's fantastic and that is what is provided for you there but I think it's also a game that you can and just kind of like take that in and then move on to the next thing you can make more of a heuristic decision I think as is that what you're kind of like getting yeah you could play the game a little bit more by feel or a little bit more by math and in the example that you brought up it was like the end of the game it was like the final auction or whatever which is like where you're gonna default to leaning a little bit more on math yeah um but you did mention Breezy in there you said not Breezy and that made me want to bring up the thing that was my that's my biggest issue with this game and that is the um John mentioned AP earlier about like thinking about like do I want to spend another week and I actually in playing this game never once was annoyed or bored while someone was thinking about what did they want to pay on a certain bid because I could think to myself well I'm next and so if they pay one then I'm gonna be doing this on my turn like I still could be engaged in those moments or I think Anastasia is going to take it before me so I really don't even think about it anyway but the thing that really bothered me was at the end of any disaster you claim the card and then you take take the Innovation and slide it under another one of your cards and the game cannot continue until you have done that and that was the part
that really bothered me for a game that felt like the gameplay is pretty smooth flipped This Disaster resolve let's flip the next disaster you know that's the tempo that I want to play this game at but the problem was we would bid and then now hmm do I want to put this over here underneath my seven because it's next to the road or do I want to put it over here underneath my nine because the resources there match a little bit better and what's coming up next on the track oh it's the the swords thing next so I don't know if I quite want that one and then I would be sitting there waiting and this is gonna sound really uh small and Petty but like 10 or 15 seconds while someone is doing that um and in a game where you're doing 30 40 auctions over the course of the game that really adds up to a point that like instead of being a breezy smooth playing game there were just like starts and stops that that got in the way of my enjoyment a bit yeah that does make sense and part of that too is is actually a neat part of the game and that is that frequently especially in a four player game you have double disasters where everybody is is fending off at the start two disasters at the same time and you could potentially have one disaster hit you take those resources and then use one of those resources to immediately pay off the other one which is a cool tactical decision and a really good way to bake a bunch of these uh auctions into the game but if I take one of them to have resources to pay off the other one I I paused the entire other auction to make
that decision as well um that definitely felt like a situation like where maybe those should have been slotted in like after all of the auctions are done it seemed like the biggest offenders were the first out of two in those double auctions at least as far as like you know hitting the the potential breeziness of the game yeah and it's funny because I really like the control that that gives you we talked a lot about like how do you kind of mitigate like you know what's happening and is this tactical is it strategic is this so I like the control that you get by getting to choose where this goes in your Empire the upgrade and I like the the upgrade the Innovation and I but I also I like some of the other elements we talked about which is opportunities to move different slots in your Empire around and different things that kind of come up over the course of the game but I will say that just from a like a stress or an emotion or this is such an emotional game from like a bad feeling place I think what adds a lot to that AP is the fear that you're gonna pick the wrong spot that you're not going to be able to move it um even though there are some exceptions where maybe you can but like for the most part you're not going to be able to or that you didn't consider that this was about to get destroyed or that this could get destroyed or that you like it it just it adds a uh like a stress load I think to that decision that makes it into 10 15 30 seconds a minute you know just trying to figure out like what is the right thing what is going to be destroyed how's that
going to be straight and so I I like that that element of control that it adds but I but I also think that's something it is like a little bit of a stressor point in in the game as well and you're thinking about the emotional space that this this game can kind of take up but I don't know if you guys feel this way I think with more plays that would lessen right you get used to kind of the cards and you get used to the things that you're seeing and that thought process may or may not lessen or on the flip side it could also increase because as you become more aware of the different strategies in the game you might be more cognizant of like what you're trying to do I think that depends kind of on the type of player you are yeah I think it would smooth out largely yeah I want to bring up one other kind of negative or kind of con that that I out with the game and and I would say overall like I actually I really really enjoyed this game I really like the dynamic and the elements and it was really fun to play I mean the the stress side of it is is a factor and I think that this is not going to be a game for everyone because of that um and if you find ways to mitigate that even like I did like just embracing like okay well as long as I can save this that's that's as good as I'm gonna get but I felt a lack of variability in the game and I I know that I brought it up and you guys both said to me well the Tableau is what's variable because you know these 11 slots the starting locations if you will they change every game they just come out randomly you all
have the same setup but it's going to be different and and the slots do different things and so there's an element of that but the the track the fact that the track doesn't change and I'm I know that it's I'm sure that it's like perfectly fine-tuned so exactly the right amount of disasters come out and the pacing but it's I think that there's a uh I just felt like a little bit like I wanted that track to be a little bit different or offer something a little bit new or even with a couple different spots but like we've talked about I think like two-thirds of the track we need 70 of the track is just disasters so like there can be a little bit of repetition too and that like a lot of this game is Just auctioning off those disasters and then in addition to that it does almost feel like a little long too for how many of those seem to come out it just seems like I I guess I just I I like that I was like building up something but there there was like a little bit of I don't know I don't say sameness I I don't want to overemphasize this because this game does feel like it has a lot of replayability and and I definitely see that and I could see myself playing it a bunch of times it's just there is just something like I I think I just wanted that track to be able to be a little bit different or to offer something a little bit different I just kind of found myself sort of being like okay we're doing kind of just doing the same thing over and over I don't know if you guys felt any of that
I think you hit the nail on the head I think that it is replayable but not variable um I think the fact that in a four player game you will go through all 66 disaster cards but is a little weird right like I don't feel like I should have control or knowledge over impending disasters yeah you're right you could you could account for all yeah yeah yeah I mean it doesn't really matter if you know like what type of disaster is coming out but it does matter what the Innovations are and so I might at a certain point be like ah there are six End Game Innovations that pay you for food and I have collected such and such and I don't see these other ones in play so there's still some in the deck and that control uh does feel a little odd for the idea of like barbarians are coming and burning your lands on on this schedule at three o'clock we'll see you at nine o'clock we'll give you a break so that you can you know till the wheat and all that stuff no Nick they only attack During certain seasons yeah I mean they could have done like a you know a random card deck to reveal you know what's happening now oh it's a disaster what's happening now oh it's a economy phase but I could also see that like that could be more thematically make sense but also could also be frustrating like yeah there's definitely a part of this game like planning ahead like one of the events that happens is uh this kind of Sword showing contest
where you like count up the swords yeah more or you're all being destroyed but you still need to go to work we still need to fight each other and uh and it's a it's a one-time blind auction of a ax resource plus some static things over there and there were it seemed like a strange amount of times where the final disaster before one of these cost axes and so that was a big factor in the incentives as well it's like okay well there's six axes if I take this disaster I get six axes back and literally the moment after we do that we're we're going to be doing a blind auction for axes and the person who does the better in that is going to get the you know more points in one on and so like that was also a consideration whereas if the the next War Phase or whatever was was a bunch of you know turns away that incentive would be different I guess and that's just random like the disaster needing axes right before the war was random it just seemed like that happened several times I guess there are only three main resources so it's not too unlikely yeah no but it definitely is a factor and that kind of goes back to why I'm so sort of like torn on making this point because it's like there are a lot of ways I love how you said that Nick about how it's like it's very replayable but not super variable but there and yet they're I think one could definitely argue that there is a lot of variety in these like kind of subtle little ways the Innovations primarily yeah the Innovations or just the dynamic of the things we've talked about the dynamic of
the play table the dynamic of the player order the dynamic of your Empire the dynamic of the different resources being required when so there are those elements and and yet you know I I think I still felt that but I also don't know that I would change that because part of what makes this game also I can say that it feels like a like a finely tuned Euro game with a lot of tactical and strategic decisions is because of what I imagined was I you know highly play tested board that that does make for a you know a uh a game that is long enough for you to be able to build up enough tablet points in your Tableau that there are multiple paths to Victory it does allow for a certain amount of disaster and then other things that happen it does let you plan ahead you you do know what's coming and you are able to know not where it's coming but you do know how many disasters you're going to have to survive you know so it's like for as much as I think I wish it had I can sit here and say like oh I wish it had more of like a pandemic style you know uh you know event deck if you will uh that you know I I kind of know how many epidemics are coming but I don't know when that would completely tear apart the strategy the strategy yeah so and you know I imagine in success this game could have multiple boards or multiple kind of ways of
playing could be a little bit like um Concordia potentially where there could be other Maps if you will um that could play differently and I'm I I don't know where it's headed but I think that might be fun to see yeah so one thing I think both of you have hit to that is uh the game being maybe slightly longer than you wanted expected something like that and I mentioned earlier that like our four player game was you know 90-ish minutes maybe it was 100 minutes but not terribly long like when you count the seconds but from an emotional perspective where I land with it is it is a fatiguing game uh like like mentally fatiguing game and we play this twice and I think both times at about the three-quarter Mark I just remember sitting here being like I kind of wish the game was about to end right now not because I wasn't having fun not because you know I was like oh you can only hang on for so long yeah I was just like oh my gosh eight more it talks how to burn I've got one ax I have two food I've got two coins there's eight auctions it's just like you know that like stress anxiety and whatnot like it it seemed like both times we played if it had ended at the the 75 Mark instead of the 100 Mark I would have been okay with that but again I think that was mostly because then I could just like take a breath and be like okay cool this is my final score this is how I did and I think that says a lot to like the theming that like a Euro can can spark
those kind of emotions but also at the same time you know if I'm going to sit down to play this game uh which I do hope to play more in the future I I also know that I'm gonna have to be in a mental space for it uh even it's not a crunchy game but it's a fatiguing one for me yeah and another thing and I think this is uh this is kind of what happened to Anastasia in the first game is that uh it's a game where you can fall into a little bit of a trap if you're if you let yourself go broke like totally broke yeah uh then you can be stuck taking cards or bids or auctions or whatever you want to call them with very few resources on them which does not give you a lot of rope to survive the succeeding events and so all the way at the beginning Anastasia said it might take you a player two to get the tempo of this game and I think that like hey going to zero is a very very scary place to be yeah um
you're playing this game I will say though like to go back to like the emotional aspect you know I did that in our first play right and and and I remember at the time like equating it to again to be on the sun which I often bring up as my example of a game where I played the first time and I was like I just I I really enjoyed the experience and at the end I was like so frustrated because I didn't understand the tempo and the points and what I was trying to do and that's basically how I felt at the end of the first game of this where I was basically like great I thought I was doing all of these things and then suddenly my whole empire has burned and I don't like I have nothing to show for it and not only that Nick and John have double my points like it was a it was a sad showing yeah you were surprised you know I yeah and but the reason I made that comparison is because when I I love beyond the sun it's one of my favorite games now and and I I've done you know uh in in subsequent plays when I understood the game it really clicked for me and that's I think what happened here with Empire's end as well is just that element of sure you can burn your Empire you just need to kind of know what you're doing when you do it so make sure it's working exactly exactly and understanding better of where the points could come from I noticed very quickly that food seemed to be the resource you needed most which thematically makes sense right for the
auctions yeah yeah for the auctions and so I had in that first game kind of focused on like axes and Military thinking that I would like pay out like no it didn't like you needed food and having lots of food was really beneficial and so I kind of focused on that and then I I tried to take disasters to get benefits for that and then that ended up working out you know I think at the end of my game I had I I had like 92 points in in points I got from resources and when you think about how many points here Tableau is worth the beginning I don't know off top of my head but you know it that's a significant amount of points that was my total score I think was in the two or three or something like that yeah and I think it's yeah it was 216 and that was a significant portion of that score and so that was from building the Tableau and you know something that I saw our friend NJ do is he like he was like three cards deep on each of his parts of his Empire like he went full hog on Tableau and even though it was his first game in that four player game that we played he still had a really respectable score because of that and I can see like there's just a lot of different ways to play like watching him do that I was like oh how interesting like I want to go deeper on a couple of areas next time too so it's like just a lot of Dynamics in this game that um that I think would come out of multiple plays and I do think it's a game that I kind of really wants that from you well speaking of
playing this game I do want to mention that it doesn't exist yet uh I think I should probably mention that like it just went up on Kickstarter it ended like a month ago or so I backed the campaign but before we actually played it and so I'm glad that I enjoyed it but um but yeah it's kind of an interesting situation where like this won't physically exist I don't know for a year or something I'm not sure what their timetable is but um it is one that uh We've we've been playing you know obviously on tabletop simulator and and I'm quite curious to see what it's going to be like in person you know with the resources and everything you know because all the resources are hidden and you know the ability to lean across the table and look and see what somebody's Tableau looks like is going to be a little bit different than when you're essentially playing a video game and you could just you know look over there and zoom in um it's an interesting consideration anyway yeah I think it's uh I think this is a really cool game I I have to admit like I really enjoyed myself I haven't seen any mechanics quite like this I never played no thanks now yeah we should totally play the things yeah like I um but so I guess the closest I'd gotten to this is high society has a similar kind of like I don't want that so I'm gonna kind of bid bid to get that off of me sure that's a good I like that comparison quite a lot actually yeah um and so I like that I really enjoy seeing elements of that at play I liked once I kind of it clicked for me I just
there's just like just a lot of facets of this that I liked I do think that that emotional space that stress is not going to be for everyone it is stressful there is a tension that makes it fun it's like a scary movie like you like can't look away uh but that also is a factor I know that this is a game that my partner would not enjoy at all this would just not be fun for us so it's probably not a game that like I am gonna run out and get but if I was over at John's or I someone had this like I would absolutely play this particularly of four players I just think that for for some seasoned Euro Gamers that would enjoy a kind of destructiony evening like this I think you know even for the kind of faults I I said about like sort of the length and some of the variability I just think it's for 90 minutes that for me is a sweet spot for a game and I just think that it's it's a good time for especially if you're like a backwards auction situation I I would very happily play this anytime that it's it's put in front of me yeah I agree yeah for sure all right well I think that's going to wrap up everything we have to say on this one uh as John mentioned it was uh recently a Kickstarter campaign so if you want to go check that out I don't know if they're doing late pledges or if by the time you're listening to this the game is out but you know if you're interested you can go find that I will put a link to that in the description and until next time happy gaming bye
wow