Skip to main content
Loading video...

What is difficulty? | The Arkham Horror "Podcast"

Transcript 1:09:27

Hello everybody and welcome to a podcast here for Arkham Horror the card game podcast in quotes because it is a video podcast and there are going to be relevant things on the screen that we're going to be talking about and not talking about in audio but it's the best way to call it when we talk about something for 1 hour and you brought this idea here for me dh for this video Daniel so I'm going to throw this to you uh what uh is our main talking point uh for today's Arkham podcast

I did. I've just been kind of racking my brain the last few days about kind of the difficulty in this game and how sometimes we just make it look easy and the game is just like a fun walk in the park and then sometimes you play maybe even the same campaign and you just get your teeth punched out and you're like what what happened? Why is this so different? And I think there's a lot of things to talk about here, but one of the things I like about this game is that there are so many different moving pieces. There's different investigators, different campaigns, different cards, and that makes for maybe a very different experience, but sometimes you sit back and say, what's responsible for the experience that I have? Is it uh which of these things is actually the biggest deal? And moving into this chapter 2 environment, um I've just really wanted to get to know these new cards. What is the current environment like? Cuz I wasn't around at the very beginning of this game. Um, you've played since the beginning. So, um, getting I don't know, the traditional Arkham Horror experience that y'all had is is a bit newer to me. I do think things are easier in uh, you know, like last year compared to when I came in, which was 6 years ago. But even so, I wasn't playing with a tiny card pool. I wasn't having some of these experiences that people had where you just failed a lot or maybe all the time.

And yeah, I don't know if that's what's going on here with just I've been trying a lot of new uh campaigns with uh just the chapter 2 cards and that includes some of the long campaigns from chapter 1 just running through with the chapter 2 card pool and want to see how that goes. Uh should I say more? Do you want do you have more discussion on that?

No, I think so. I think this is a very interesting uh topic for this because I do think that difficulty is something that like where does the difficulty come from in Arkham and I think the answer to that is simply put is like the the surface level answer it's this scenario right like that's the concept like the encounter deck and then the token bag those are like the like the the basic idea from that's where the game is hard. But I do think that it goes like it's like a it's like a [ __ ] onion. It goes like layer and layer and layer deeper for what actually influences the difficulty of a scenario. And when you were doing that intro, I want to get this on the screen in a way that's like good. But this is an example, a very notable example. Uh here, I'm actually just going to pause this for a second so people don't see me edit this. All right. So this is an example of when good decks can go bad.

So this is a very notable one here. That's us again. Yeah. Um this is uh from the bless run that you and I did on your channel where I was a pretty good Will Yoro deck. I wouldn't say a great deck by any means and you were a very very salt like a very good uh like Carolyn deck as well.

But this deck has a very notable experience. Um, it's this scenario, right? Depths of Yth,

the serpent from Yth.

The serpent from Yth who's there for like the entire like an entire uh agenda worth of time. And I think that's him right there. And it's just of how things can go bad from things that are outside of your control. You have this guy who took me forever to kill. Like forever. And this was a pretty solid combat deck there. Up until this point, there were there were no stressors about dealing with enemies in this campaign, right? But it went very bad. And a big part of that was the token pulls, right? But I think it sometimes goes even deeper than just like the concept of encounter deck and

Oh, culpus token. I knew it. Yep.

Yeah. Oh, there's the bless. Yeah, we can see we can see what happens here. Another bless. So that's good. Then you can automatically succeed. But like that's the thing, right? Like there's there's so much variance that comes into Arkham that can really impact a scenario. Um, and I think the Forgotten Age is a great one to talk about like this example here because it's the one that you've played you've played three you've played three times recently and currently playing three times

and they've all been very different experiences. Um, and Forgotten Age can be a very swingy campaign depending on how things go and the scenarios themselves are also quite swingy when it comes into the moment, right? We might come back to that later, but that's where we're looking at this here. But like this was a scenario where just things went bad in a way that like I can't even really think about um why, right? And then like so that's an example of like a scenario going bad. But I then there was do I still have this deck here or did I delete it? No, I still have it unfortunately.

Um then it's sometimes the deck. So here is the my Tommy deck for the initials challenge.

Challenge

and like this is where another aspect of the difficulty comes in. And you might be thinking, "Yeah, but Justin, I see a Timeworm brand, right? Like I see Michael Lee. I see like Tetsuori. These are good cards." But good cards don't make a deck good. Like a deck is like top down

from the initial idea to like the very last card. Like it's like all 30 cards in your deck in theory are working together to do something. Well, like

Yeah. It's the glue. Yeah. we look at the like the where the events where the glue usually lives and like there's not much going on here, right? It's kind of just stuff. Um, and I think this is where your concept of what you were talking about how like a limited collection is very different than playing with a full pool. This is why we do challenge runs because um it kind of adds an exciting challenge to it. it it's kind of like uh at least for Travis Burn and I chasing the days where um we had this small collection to try and get those that Arkham Struggle feeling that just doesn't really exist in Legacy into the same extent especially at three and four players. you can do like anything in Legacy of three and four players and you're going to do absolutely fine.

I mean, sometimes you can even pull off a fighter Kate deck with

even with a limited card pool. Um, but it like it's Yeah, the point of playing with the limited card pool should not just have access to all the staples, all of the the best versions of every card and even to stack all these things up. So, um, if we're going to talk about I mean some of the the TFA stuff I'm bringing up just like the noticeable things with the smaller card pool. Uh, so in the version the chapter 2 only version that I've been playing through, it's just two-player with the chapter 2 Tommy and Trish Scarboro. And the interesting thing is to compare it to this other three-player uh version that's totally legacy, although a couple of hooks there, but still a Finn Edwards has the same ability as Trish. But a Finn Edwards with two copies of Pickpocketing two

versus a chapter 2 Trish Scarbor and Lucky Cigarette case three versus a Trish Scarboro in chapter 2 who has her covert ops one copy of Sticky Fingers and you know level zero lucky cigarette case. It's a lot different.

Like just just saying that probably I mean you you perked up like yeah well there you go.

Yeah. it it's hard to understate how much those economy staples and I I I mean I call them staples. They're just really [clears throat] fantastic cards that make the rest of your deck do kind of whatever you want because you can find and afford them, right? Yeah.

That's just that that's playing a card game. And I think what my experience with the chapter 2 stuff is that if you don't have that and it's hard to get there, then you get back on the struggle bus a bit.

All right. So, I think that this is a nice thing. I want to actually just search um like I want to just I'm just going to put in draw here.

Sure.

And like we can just see like cards that like draw a card. So, like we're not going to look at them individually, but I'm just going to scroll through legacy with draw and then we're going to do it for current just to kind of like see like the difference between this. Right. So,

yeah. A good number of options. Of course, they're they're all like they're all specific. They all have their own things, you know. And I actually just want to even get rid of the uh uh player cards. So, sorry, the signature cards, too.

Sure.

Um but

but even something like runic axe, which has nuts stuff already, the fact that it can draw while you're also doing other things.

Yes. Yeah. So, like

pocketing is there too, right?

Yeah. We're still going. We got a bunch of a bunch of stuff here. like there's just a lot of different options and they're on powerful cards as well, right? Um

and like there are we're going to be see psychoanalysis in um current as well. But a big thing is uh another aspect of the difficulty beyond all this, another layer of the onion. So there we go. We're at the bottom here is

level two skills. O

is playing in uh is playing with uh the player count, right? Like we've said for a long time that four players is very easy Arkham. Not easy Arkham, but like much easier in comparison to two players, right? Which is then like every player you add, the more your decks are able to focus on what they're doing or alternatively have fun with what they're doing. It's like another thing is like uh an example is you and I have played a lot of Slay the Spire together and I played a lot of Slay the Spire with co-op. You can do a lot more in co-op that you can't do in single player just because there's more people to quote unquote pick up the slack so to speak for the areas that you're lacking. I'm just going to go through the draw card on current here.

But also I feel like Oh, wait. That's it.

That's it.

This just level uh one to five or level zero also. Oh, level level zero to make it. There we go. Okay. No, I want both of these, please. Yeah, level. There we go.

I mean, even so, like scroll of pharaoh's level zero isn't a draw card, but

I don't want signatures. There we go.

Um, uh, hey, how many guardian cards have we seen?

Uh, I'm counting zero. [snorts] U I guess we could add like add right because right tool for the job sort of is sort of card draw. I don't know productive s kind of right.

Yeah. All the the ad kind of comes in here. So what if it did like card as well? Um well, where does card come on this card? Discarding it. Okay, now that does make sense. Card is on there. But yeah, like basically it's coming down to in current. What we have here is the options are a lot less limited. And there was, as you saw, there's water of protection, which doesn't actually draw a card, but we were just searching and putting card in the in the game text search here. Um, but as you can see that the options are a lot more restrictive. And

while Guardians have uh some good pieces, like let's just look at Guardian stuff here. Like Guardians have some good pieces in their deck. Like the M1911 is actually just like a power crept 45 automatic. And that's not necessarily a bad thing because 45 automatic was

always just kind of okay. Um but like and it got Logan Hastings. It's it's got in um Detective Sherman who is also another very strong ally art notwithstanding, right? It got like um Police Dog, who both you and I think is a very powerful card, right?

Um it it got um Counterattack, it got bounty, like it got a lot of good pieces, but the things that it's really missing is that card draw. and um or like that consistency and other classes make up for that with like guardians in theory are supposed to kind of make up with that in their off class options, but Tommy doesn't get that. Tommy doesn't get that. So, there's just like another layer on what makes this game difficult if it goes beyond the scenario. your investigator choice, your collection, that investigator's strength and weaknesses, and that investigator's card pool strength and weaknesses. Because I think now we know what Tommy's strength is for his card pool, right? Firearms and good allies, but what are his weaknesses? Card draw.

So, let me ask you a question about the guardian class in general. Where do you get the action advantage with all of these cards? Like what what do you see here that helps you get beyond that typical three actions per turn, you know, or the equivalent, right?

Um with this card pool.

Mhm.

Um great question. Um, I think the only answer is there's not really one. So, I was gonna say the close things are like service revolver

with damage. Yeah. And then like uh

counterattack,

right?

Like these are the things that kind of let you do things that are

breaking. I think make them sing is another one that kind of gives them the extra actions, but it really is just the damage, right?

So, it's mostly on cards that are events or kind of the damage question, which I is an interesting question in itself. Like that's where it feels like, okay, I can fight better. I can deal more damage than anyone else kind of.

Um, but that's not really the way that the other classes have broken the game in Legacy, right? It's stuff like I can draw extra cards per turn with Lucky Cigarette Case. I can get extra resources every turn and not just one of them with Logan, which isn't every turn. It's it's more than that, right? Like it's stacking all these things up into this, you know, beautiful cycling through your deck multiple times thing, right?

Yeah.

And it's Yeah. So there's no safe card, right?

Yeah. That I think Yeah. That's like I think the the the big reality is that Guardian has lost um like some of their key pieces in Legacy that allow them to kind of stay competitive in their way, right? Um and I think that losing Safeguard, even though I never play safeguard, um I know the card's good, but like I know that guardians are missing it, right? Uh, another one is um stand together.

Mhm.

Which if I spell right is there um like this is uh even the level zero version is really good economy for the guardian class but also for the whole team, right? Cuz like the concept of guardian action compression has always kind of been damage and relying on compressing other people's actions as well, right? So it's like your compression is your movement in safeguard, right? Your compression here is one of the craziest economy cards in the game, right? Like everybody draws two and gain like two people draw two and gain two, right? Um but like in two players that's everybody and that's really good. You're getting what is that? Uh you're up seven actions essentially when you play this card cuz

ever vigilant.

Ever vigilant. Yeah, that's another one. Yeah,

it's a big miss. And and you could even make the argument that stick to the plan is like drawing three cards. I

Yes.

would agree with that.

And like it's it's kind of the um Hey, it's Logan Hastings again.

Yeah.

I never realized that, but he's here again. Um the the big thing is that um Guardian has always been like the fair class, right? To their benefit and to their detriment. And I think that when you go to a smaller pool, that detriment really starts to show itself. I don't think it's the only class that has weaknesses in this small card pool. But I think that if you look at the full big picture, right, where we also now start looking at investigators,

I think that this is when we start seeing the weaknesses of Tommy Maldun as an investigator, right? Uh you and I just recorded a video where um it's compared to Carolyn Fern, her ability is kind of just free. Like, yeah, you have to have horror, but there's cards that enable horror, right? Tommy Maldoon's ability, like the discarding an al firearms as you control is a very good way to have that ability come across, right?

But the action uh to spend a resource is already really tough when they're not really able to compress their resources as efficiently as some of the other classes. They do have bounty, which is a very strong uh economy card, but like they're lacking um where is bounty? You got to get to the events.

They can't really find it.

Yeah, like that's the thing. Yeah, like the card draw is also really tough for this kind of thing. And this is where um we're gonna kind of look at like uh your Tommy deck that you're playing in Forgotten Age and Brin's current Tommy deck in Feast of Hemlock Veil. and he has that perk of playing in three players where he is able to take time to draw cards because his he's not as required to be all in on solving an enemy problem when he's when it comes up because I'm playing a Marie Lambo that is also able to kill enemies very efficiently.

Yeah. Yeah. It it's just you just sort of notice these things. Like you said, drawing cards is not something you plan on doing, right? You'd rather have cards that give you that passive card draw. Um so you just sit back and say, "Well, I I can't use the cards in my hand. I need to draw some more." And yeah, I mean, the fighting act the fighting actually hasn't been bad. Like the passing the fights generally hasn't been a problem. Although the Brotherhood cultists in in uh Threads of Fate were a big problem, that's just there's not a good solution for those in the the card pool. Um the small card pool, it just becomes you fight them two or three times and the doom escalates and if it goes bad, then it goes bad. Like there's there's no um I don't know, string of curses, right?

Like it just feels like the back in the old days when people rightly um said that Brotherhood cultists were the scariest enemy in in the game just because there isn't

like I mean you only have one vicious blow also like how else am I dealing the extra damage so it's tough.

I actually also do legitimately think because the other investigator you have is Trish Scarboro, right?

Yeah.

I want to just get her pool up here. I actually do legitimately think uh and people might say I'm crazy for this, but I do actually think uh this seeker rogue pool is not great for um compression right now.

Not what it was.

Yeah, I think a big thing is that the um it's it's really good for card draw, right? like and it's really good for evading, but I think that there's a lot of pieces that kind of just fall into this where uh there's like a big difference between like um a clover Carolyn Fern in chapter 2 uh versus a clover Trish um because Trish she doesn't have that she doesn't have compression anymore, right? She just like her ability used to be great compression and the evade action, the free evade action is really good, but there's a big reason why in legacy Trish outpaced Finn and it's because of that compression on the investigator card.

Like anytime you can get some sort of like ways to get more clues, the investigators end up being really strong because of that.

Yeah. you're just taking, you know, lockpicks or these kit actions and that's fine. Like you pass the test generally except for when you don't.

And yeah, fingerprint kit is is there too. And there's the upgraded deductions. Like it's not it's hard to say like it's been a problem. It's just not exceeding kind of the pace that we say is the baseline,

right? Like imagine if you throw just as simply as an ally like Lola Santiago, right? there there is no I mean that's such a nuts ally because of the compression. You finish scenarios so much more quickly because all you need to do is is throw in some money and when you're already getting money off of pickpocketing and you can have multiple in play it compounds, right? Yeah.

And there's just nothing

not It's not that these cards are bad, it's just that they're I think the sum of all of them is worse than looking at them individually.

Yeah. And like Olivia Bishop is does a good job of giving Trish like compression I assume is is Olivier the ally of choice that the Trish is playing. Yeah.

Um and that does like really good. But the the stark reality and the next layer of difficulty that we're going to that kind of just poke at here is getting so like a good deck is always ahead, right?

Mhm. But a good deck is also able to stabilize when it's behind.

Yes.

And uh that ability to stabilize is something that is really felt with smaller collections. Olivia Bishop, you might be thinking is this is your compression, right? Like this is where you're saving on actions. And it's true when you're ahead, but what if you start to fall behind? What does that free movement action actually give you each turn? Right. nothing. Maybe you get away from the enemies further, but that doesn't actually progress the scenario, you know,

and like

it's kicking the count down the road. It's it's not that good.

And like and that's why like these effects like I'm not saying Olivia Bishop's a bad card. He's our top rated ally in our video, right? But when it looks at these kind of things is like when you get to a smaller collection and like when you're even looking at like why are things why am I losing a scenario you have to ask yourself like is my deck designed to all like to win like to win or is it designed for like winning more right and at a certain case cards like Olivier kind of become like win more if you're behind right like he doesn't do anything for that um and that's why like clue compression or free clues become very very powerful. Um and like it's it's a big change like even just going like um from like from pickpocketing to sticky fingers, right?

Sticking finger sticky fingers like the resources you gain from these those aren't going to help you win, right? Like card draw helps you win. And that's why like pickpocketing is better and why pickpocketing two is so good because it gives you cards and resources, right? Like arguably potentially a little bit too good in the right deck. But like if you're following the same side of principle where it's like, oh, I'm playing pickpocketing, so I'm going to be good with go with sticky fingers. It doesn't really actually do the same thing for helping you get ahead when you start to fall behind. Cuz like if we look at it, uh I mean like there are some issues with the rogue investigator deck. Like we've talked about that on the past where like these weird events kind of just like don't do too much. Like we look at this, it it does deal three damage like backstab did, but the enemy has to be evaded, which is not bad for Trish, right? But already it's like you're not really getting ahead with this card, right? It's still two actions for most rogue investigators to get four damage on an enemy, which is generally two actions, right? Um

cleanage.

It's only three damage.

Wow. Okay.

Two, right?

Um so yeah. So sorry, I guess I say when I meant to say three, I meant killing the three health enemy in two. Oh yes, thank you. Uh it's the same sort of thing, right? Where it's like your two actions to kill a three health enemy is still two actions and it's why like backstab is good because it does that three health enemy in one action. It's expensive, right? And you have to work for it, but you're able to kind of like compound that with other things and like a sudden fall. Imagine a world like just imagine if you will if instead of sticky fingers these were pickpocketing zero and pickpocketing two. Suddenly now to set up your sudden fall you're drawing a card and gaining a resource or god forbid you have two and you're drawing two and gaining two. Right? Like

it's a big difference. Yeah. That's kind of like where like the smaller pool can really come in in ways that don't seem particularly obvious for like that kind of thing. Um, and it's why actually the card that impressed me has impressed me the most has been right under their noses cuz it's like one of the few ways to actually like compress clues in actions that you would otherwise like this allows you to start getting ahead. So like in the forgotten age of like you're you're stuck with an enemy, you can evade that enemy, grab two clues if and then be like, "Okay, now I can leave, right?" Like I can and I'm set up for this next location that has there.

But even this, you actually see that in chapter 2, they've changed the value of clue uh of these burst clues where you're not getting two from your location, you're getting one from your location and one from a connecting location. So already this card is also actually even weaker than stuff we would have seen in the past which I think is also very interesting. Yeah,

which I think is also a very interesting kind of thing to see in action.

So um yeah, ultimately in this run which just has us not getting very much XP and you know you get behind you kind of stay behind um on that sort of tracker. The biggest problem has been on the treachery front

where if you look at the I mean look the two investigators aren't the most optimal for going through the forgotten age. Um if you look at I mean Trish should be good but granted the uh willpower for her is tough. And for Tommy he's got three which is not horrible. It's just not enough to do much with after that. like his uh agility is only two, so he's actually pretty weak to the mythos phase, I would say.

And what do you usually do to protect yourself from the mythos phase? Like what what kinds of cards are you looking for um from a legacy card pool? Like for for someone with Tommy's statline, like what kinds of things do you do you think about? My true answer for legacy is efficiency, is compression, is winning the game, drawing five less cards,

right? So, you finish before that kind of catches up to you.

Yeah. Yeah. And you can't really do that on smaller pools.

That's harder to do. But even if you get like something in the first few mythos phases that become a problem or you need to solve some random tests that show up, like what do you do? There there's some things like if it's damage or horror, you can soak those kinds of things, right? You you play your out some assets that have good, you know, uh good value for that, right? Take the initiative that there's a good skill card for for passing tests, right? Um this was a staple for a long time. Want to look at all the skills in Guardian

in chapter two?

Chapter two. Mhm.

It's going to be dark, isn't it? We're going to have a dark day here. Give me just guardian, please.

Yeah.

Yeah.

Yeah.

So, run unexpected courage. Run uh guts. And now we're starting to eat into the rest of the deck that needs to be focused on guns and supporting the gun lifestyle. And that's tough because none of these skills, you know, replenish or or anything like that. Uh armed to the teeth is is fine. Um, but again, the willpower icon here only works. I mean, it's only one, but it's only going to get you extra if you're going to commit to uh something on one of your items. Adapt and overcome you can only use on attacks or evasions. You can't use it on your snake bite.

Yeah.

Indomitable. Uh,

I mean, it's the Yeah. Like the thing is during the mythos phase, it's just an unexpected courage or a guts that doesn't replenish itself, right? Yeah,

like this is a card you're using to fight boss monsters in the scenario, right? Like

Yep.

That's why this card is here. Um Yeah. And like I think a big thing is let's just do a a quick thing. Let's just pivot to the mystic class.

Right.

Right. Cuz like the mystic class is this I think in the best position after this apart from maybe survivor. Survivor is really up there as well. Um, but this mystic class the like just even these two cards like giving yourself seven wild icons uh over two cards in your deck, right? So that means you have 14 wild icons for just four cards in your deck.

Yep.

Like so when you ask a question like what do you do to beat the to beat the encounter deck and the answer is for me is compression. win quicker. But the other answer is just run two copies of a multi- wild icon card, right? Because uh that will beat the two encounter cards that you're scared of when they show up and then everything else you'll be able to either tank through or win before, right? And mystics have that

already. Yeah.

Right. But like guardians, they don't have that. Like I think take the initiative probably should have been like would have been a good healthy reprint, right? Um, like you could definitely see that they there there I think there was a definite conscious effort to weaken guardian on the skill card tree of things.

Um, because I mean if we look at everything else, right? Like the skills in the other classes

and they're not that good other than survivor either.

I mean well mystic. Mystic's good, right? Mystic.

I mean other than mystic. Yeah. Yeah. Um, but I mean like rogues got like imagine if like a a guardian equivalent is just like deal one damage to an enemy when you commit it to a card, right? Like like a front-loaded vicious blow. And that might sound like why would they have uh a front-loaded vicious blow when there's a backloated vicious blow? Why would they have a front-loaded uh out the door when there's a backloaded out the door in the form of watch this? Right? like it's like

like this redund like that's the next thing that in the smaller card pool is that you're also lacking redundancy, right? And

that's something that I think is really really coming into play here as well, right? And I think that's just the the the consequence of a small card pool, right? But uh realistically, this is the smallest chapter 2 is ever going to be, right?

That's true. So, I don't think we're gonna really get because it's every two years of product or is it the last three? How

I be three?

Is it on the rules here?

Probably

in the grimoire formats. See if we can find that in here. Say current. Oh my god. Uh there we go. Uh so the current environment is the two most recently released and then the two most so the deck building and investigator expansions.

Okay.

So we're not going to get our full slice of the core pool. We get like four more products in the pool to really get an idea of what that's going to look like.

Right. So this basically means I mean to what you're saying here is that what I'm experiencing is maybe unfair to the product because the design should have potentially twice as many cards in playing in current.

Yeah,

that's fair. It's still it's still interesting to to go through it. Um let me go back to the the the soak question. Um for guardian we can leave it here. Um so you would think there's a lot of soak and guardian because that's the other way to deal with these. You just tank them. And I think it's true, but it's concentrated in the ally slot

in in a way that is like not there's a charisma tax associated that or you have to turn through and there's not a lot of support for that in this card pool in the Tommy deck for

having multiple of these in play or benefits for them going out of play. The resilience, I guess, is another possibility. Um, but I've acreded like a lot of trauma in the Tommy deck. And I think I have three in three in one and that's without in the thick of it or anything just from either getting defeated or I don't know just having to take the the no blankets thing. And it's not that that's bad. Um, but it's sort of indicative of you draw a pitfall and you say, I don't know. I guess I'm taking three damage.

Yeah. which just feels so different from the legacy uh versions of this where you say, "Yeah, I'll try to pass a test." Like we either have multiple people to commit or you're holding back lysies or you have crazy amounts of soak like I had in in Carson with you know the bracelet and the star like other things that compound like synergize together with the the play style here. It's just kind of guess I'll die.

Yeah. Yeah. I know you're really kind of just like I don't have a unexpected courage like here. I should like this uh let's uh let's look at this Tommy deck. Let's give it a quick little peek here.

And maybe I'm just built a bad deck. I mean that could be it too, but there's not much to work with. Uh, but also like there's a there's a big thing to be said about um why the first scenario is so important to get right because it kind of sets you off on the place to go and why I think Arkham has kind of lost some of its um wonderful balance in terms of failing forward, right?

Where like it requires you to do good. But fun fact, if you play House always wins and lose by agenda, you get two experience. Like you get one experience for uh getting crushed and you get two for Dr. Henry Armadage not being in your deck, right?

Um and like we don't get that kind of stuff anymore. If you lose a scenario, they're just like, "Dang, too bad you suck." And I think that that big shift came because players wanted to win more because players like winning games, right? But I feel like

winning games.

Um, that's another thing that's like what makes it harder is the fact that you guys in this TFA run have not been able to get the snowball effect that they kind of just expect you to have. Right.

Right. Right. And TFA is not a new like not an old like not a new scenario like new campaign, but they did go out of the fail forward pretty quickly.

Yeah. Like there's some good cards here. I've had a I I thought they did the thing,

but the problem was the thing wasn't enough to actually deal with what the scenario wanted you to do, which was to get ahead. Uh the I mean I needed to keep my I can't get rid of the skill cards. They're they're good. Like the guts was like the only way for the team to pass some tests. And that said, it wasn't a very good shot cuz we're going at five to whatever the test is. Usually three. What else am I committing?

Yep.

The the on the beats are are helpful, right? They can be committed.

Yeah. to be real. Uh what the this actually sounds like a very like old school Arkham when it just came out where you're just like

I'm going to be up too and you're just like that's all I can do. But the thing is like um when you don't know what it's like on the other side when you could do more, it doesn't feel as bad, right?

Um because like I was going to ask in retrospect, do you think that your deck would have been better if this arm to the teeth was the manual was manual dexterities instead? or unexpected courage probably.

And like it's one of those things that Yeah. Like I feel like uh an example is when when Travis Brit and I were playing back in the day, we would pray like on average three different two of each of the of the neutral skills in our decks just because like you kind of had to. And honestly, like being up two on a a Roger Remains usually meant you were only taking one horror worse like when things go wrong, which you're kind of were just like, I'm happy about that. But on the other side, now that that happens, I'm like, what? I'm not happy about that. What the heck? You know, but

I mean honestly that's it feels like the riding remains design is better for that. But then when they throw things at you that are test three willpower if you fail you know nothing happens but you also don't progress something. You don't

parlay with parl. You don't uh you know talk to the custodian. You don't do these things that you don't get rid of the uh conspiracy of blood. These are things that you actually have to pass the test. And once you spent your your guts or your unexpected courage or your bullet as you will on those tests and you fail, whether it's an auto fail, which though they hurt so much more in limited card pool, or just a, you know, minus five or minus three or you're poisoned and you draw some other token that says you just automatically fail instead. Or maybe you I mean a lot of those if you fail writers on the chaos tokens, you almost ignore them in legacy because you're not going to fail. Y

and now you're taking these tests that say uh now you take a [ __ ] cuz you failed. Now you place a doom on an enemy because you failed. Now you discard a card at random because you failed and it hurts so much more. Anyway, you spend your guts, you fail a test, and now you say that was what I had. I don't have assets that boost me more. I don't have I mean I hate to say physical training but there's like the level four physical training from the Nathaniel Cho deck does so much for the guardian to protect themselves from the mythos.

Yes.

And you get endurance which is not nothing but it doesn't have the same payout. And it's it's why it's very hard for the designers to like design for like the people who like the the players who are like I want the game to be harder but I want to play with my full card pool.

Mhm.

And really the answer there's no way to do that because if the games became harder um people are going to play with a limited card pool, right? And I think that I think it's about like finding the balance as best they can with that. Um, but that's that's tough. But it is a very interesting idea of like the difference between for each point you fail by effects versus if you fail effects and the number of them because the um the threads of fake conspiracy look hard. That probably was just brutal for your team comp.

Yep. like that was there's there's no other way to beat that,

right? And you get used to having something for that, right? Either you're I don't know. I mean, when we just played with the Silus and Carson team, and that was uh I mean, I think we did just well anyway, but we had ways of dealing with that. Like Carson could draw cards and and commit them to tests. You have a million different ways to retroactively pass the test. Mhm.

There just wasn't a problem. Um I mean, okay, so back to like the the difficulty question. We should have said this up front, but like clearly you can play on a higher or lower difficulty level. like that is part of what that the intention is for those and probably playing full legacy and I hate to say the word abusing but to know that the card draw uh combinations you know playing what you and I both agree to be the strongest card in the game lucky cigarette case three

I think that allows you to push the difficulty up a little bit more on on something like that and maybe I could have played easy on this and it would have been a more comparable time because the chaos tokens would have given us a better shot because we just didn't have, you know, cuz like is it the failing of the deck? Is it the failing of the investigator, the piloting? Or is it truly that you just don't have the stuff in every single deck? And if you want the same Arkham Horror experience, you either have to live with it being more difficult on you or you play at a lower difficulty level. Yeah.

And it feels a little better. And I mean like the the real answer is it's like a perfect storm, right? Where um like I don't think like you look at the cards and you're like, "Yeah, these cards are like these are all like legit cards, right? Like they all get the job done, right?" Like there's there's nothing here that you're just like, "What the heck is this doing here?" But it's like the small things afterwards where you're like again, it's like, "What if this was something else, right? Like what if this like cuz you the arms of the teeth is not a bad card for a deck that's using items to fight with, right?

Yeah.

But like in retrospect, you're like what if this was something else? Or like when something bad happens in the scenario, you get the auto fail and you know your deck is incapable of getting ahead of it. Are you making the right decisions in that moment to try to salvage it? Like that's hard to know until the scenario is done, right? Um,

then there's also just like the turn to turn stuff where um you played the wrong asset without even realizing it, right? Like that's there or the game can just flex on you in a way that it doesn't where you play Logan Hastings and then he gets frozen to death in a crypt chill, right? Like these are things that uh if that doesn't happen, that pushes you into an entirely different space than if it does happen, right? Like there's a lot of different moving pieces that establish the difficulty of a of a scenario.

You know that it's funny because the game got me the other way around where I didn't play Logan because I was afraid of the crypt kill and instead I drew my weakness which is um loose cannon which made me lose all my resources to begin with.

And you might say well why didn't you have any firearms out? You know what scenario I was playing. Ah, that sounds like a City of Archives. Can't play items type situation. Yeah.

Yeah. And you can't play Becky either because she's unique.

Yeah.

She's out of the deck entirely.

Yeah. The Atheians are like, "What's this thing? I need to hold this."

Right. Oh man. I mean, it it worked out like Okay. And that's part of also you get so used to like crushing scenarios that um I agree with your earlier idea of like failing forward probably should be more of the game but also as players we get used to anything but the best is failure and that's not true either.

Yep. That's that was a big thing for when I was trying to figure out what winning meant to me in Arkham and I ultimately came down to like I mean individually does the deck do what it's supposed to do? Uh but beyond that any result in a scenario if you get to that if you don't get the resolution that's on the agenda unless it's like meant to be that res that resolution right

that's a win that's that's a one scenario right and

that's right

if you can feel bad to get a result that's like oh imagine if I got all this XP or like the last time I played this this was so it went so much better but your deck still won right like it might have struggled. But again, some investigators like not going to point fingers at you, Mr. Tommy Maldun, but like are just like this is what I like when I talk about in my tier list where um it's the amount of effort you need to put in to get a great result. And like Tommy just due to the nature of his ability

and his stat line is gonna require a tiny bit more effort because he needs pieces to get set up. He has a stat line that you want to enhance, right? And he doesn't have any sort of built-in compression. And those are things that just make one investigator better than another investigator, right? Mark Harrian is before Tommy and probably after Tommy is the most played firearm investigator and that's because he draws cards on his ability and he has five fist. So already your guns are better. Um, so it's just like another piece of the puzzle of what makes a scenario difficult beyond just scenario difficulty.

And it's interesting because I I like the ability. I liked having more ammo. I felt like the firearms like they didn't run out, but I don't think that was enough. That's not

I don't feel like that's as big of a pressure point of the card game design as this ability makes it seem like, right? It's just it's it's kind of like when you play um you know, Jim or other investigators that their ability is just to pass skill tests better. It's like well I was already working to do that. Like every investigator has to pass skill tests better. So, like what more are you bringing to the table? And that's harder to find, I think, just with the chapter 2 stuff here. Um, now I will say that for City of Archives, like we did fine. We got through with 10 XP, which is a lot. In fact, it almost doubled the amount of XP in the deck already. Uh, but it it wasn't as enjoyable, you know?

Mhm.

It wasn't like a great time. It was really kind of like I guess we'll pull a token and see what happens. And sometimes that's great. Sometimes it's really stressful. You start to notice other parts of the design as well, like the Yetian enemies that make you discard cards when they attack you, you're like, "Well,

oh, usually they're dead before that happens in Legacy."

Um, but on the other hand, when I played the Let's set aside the Silus Carson for a second, but the other one with the three-player one where I felt like I didn't have to do anything. I was just sitting back because the other decks again, especially the Finn one, just does so much,

like more than it probably should. And I'm not going to say that's an enjoyable time either because it feels a little, you know, a little boring.

Yeah. It feels like you're above curve,

right? Yeah. So, it's like that's that's less fun, too. So, I don't want to to say that like having the bad deck, it's not a bad deck. that have the undertuned deck is um maybe that's more the point, right? That that is that's okay too instead of just sort of sitting back. Remember when we played um once where you were playing a Wilson in a four player deaths of Yoth and you didn't you you signed up to be the clover and didn't get a clue for like six rounds or something.

Yeah. Yeah.

Cuz it was four player, right? You just didn't really need to do anything. It just kind of it worked out fine at the end. But that was kind of one of the times you've you've cited as being you can do anything in four player, but this is also kind of pointing out how important it is in two-player that everything goes

as goes well.

Yeah, it's one of those things where you can kind of change your deck because of that to adapt to the player count. Um I wanted to look at the Brin deck for chapter 2, Tommy here. uh not to like be like, "Oh, this Brenn did differently. Maybe this worked better." Because it is apples and oranges, right? It's a three-player game through Feast of Hemlock Veil. They're very different experiences

with Caroline and Marie.

Yeah. So, that's a big thing. Um, but kind of like curious to see even like the differences because the I really like watching Brin play because Brinn does a lot of things that I would view crazy or unconventional and he makes it work which is uh is I think Brin's think ability here. Um, but we can actually see that there's like a lot of similarities. Um, I mean in weapon choice they're practically the same thing. Brin went into the shotgun, which you do have more time with in um three player because again Carolyn kill sorry uh Marie kills the small stuff, right? Um I I was actually like Brin uh played the resilience quite a bit. Um, which I'm kind of curious from like the soak standpoint if it actually is like just good enough to get there because um it's something that Brinn does a lot where he like he really values soak even if it's all it does. The two cards, something worth fighting for and True Grit I believe they're called. He played those way past the time I would have, but he always made them work really well, which I think maybe is like the thing is that they actually are okay forms of just mythos management, right? Uh, and I'm very curious to see that in further play. Um,

yeah, I actually like that card too reasonably well. It just always feels tough to fit it into the deck cuz it doesn't do anything.

Y

right on it.

And it's expensive. Yeah.

And it's expensive. And like that's the thing like in three players you have that space to be like I'm going to gain a resource and then play resilience and in two players you have a lot less of that space to do that.

Um the protective vest actually also has been very impressive. It has pretty good soak when it comes to it. But again, we're seeing again this like in this Tommy deck that you have here. Um like the bounty and the emergency cash are really good, but I feel like we're still missing like another resource generation card in the guardian class in some way, right? or alternatively good card draw that allows them to like draw their second copy of Bounty or their second copy of Emergency Cash, right? I feel like they're missing that.

The other part is that the money has to get spent, at least in in my deck, into Endurance sometimes because I need to beat minus five tokens.

Yeah.

And it's hard to do that.

It just Yeah. I mean

Yeah. Yeah. economy is the same. We're looking at like the custom grip is a fantastic card.

And like this is I think like um an example of some like compression in the guardian class, right? And it's a very very good form of compression. I think that Tommy,

let's just talk about Tommy for a second again. I think that Tommy

uh his ability could have been a lightning bolt

and I think he would

No, no. I think like his uh is it's a lightning bolt during your turn. Spend one resource to discard a firearm asset to play one.

I think he should have been able

I think it's should be a reaction so he could use it with with that card.

Oh, when you play like that. Yeah, that could be cool.

Yeah, when you play a firearm.

I think it would be on custom grip. Like I think he should be able to I don't think it would have been bad if he had some action compression where his ability was a lightning bolt.

Okay. Just have a free play while you spend money for it. Yeah. Yeah.

Yeah. Yeah. I think that like this is an example of the difference of what I view as what other classes would have got. I 100% convinced if this was a rogue, he would have got a lightning bolt ability to do this. Right.

Right.

Um but it's like that guardian fairness. The guardian are always just kind of dragged back a bit because they're the fair class and that's not great. Guardians should be a little bit unfair in some ways.

Yeah, they can have their niche. Like that's Yeah. So, going back to his events, the other big difference here is that this deck isn't getting any clues, which is

it's three player. You don't need to.

Yep.

And I don't necessarily need to either that much. Uh, but the on the beats are there not necessarily for investigating, but for the um the scenario tests like the parlaying in threads of fate

or in in City of Archives and honestly just the icons, it it seems bad, but

but it's taking up deck space that I otherwise

would love to put in some other like bigger weapons or or something else, but with the little XP at the beginning, it felt necessary to get. And I think they're they're fine. like plus three actually is a very good number for the whole phase.

Uh yeah, it's it's

yeah,

it feels a little

uh and then on the uh events here very similar to sorry to the skills very similar to your pool like incredibly similar which makes sense. Um I think he just put the indomitable in after the longest night. Um

so I think that that's uh what what that was there for. But as you can see, yeah, like pretty one to one for that kind of thing, which makes sense because you are so limited in this.

Um,

but you don't need gut in this deck, right? Cuz Marie and Carolyn can probably handle all of that.

Yeah. And then he just like tanks the horror is like his philosophy.

Um, so I do think that Yeah, because also we have a Carolyn who heals horror, right? We have that as well, right? So the horror is a little bit less scary. Um to close out this video uh and the podcast here, let's look at this Marie deck that I'm playing just to show like the difference between these card pools and then also what this ability means for uh an investigator with a limited card pool because I I definitely see and understand the struggles that you're going through with this current Tommy deck, but it's kind of crazy cuz with this Marie deck. I feel I feel like I'm playing Legacy. Um, and a big reason for that is just this these these two lines here that are so seemingly inconsequential, but they are absolutely nutter for like just making sure that you are consistent and are able to win. And this goes to what we were saying about consistency.

And it's to the point where I'm able to because of this

just play decks for cards for fun

to see if these are actually like good cards. Like I'm doing what I would do in Legacy where I'd be like I want to try this card out because my deck is popping off so much, right? Um and this is not a good card for my deck. But you have that privilege because two-player sorry three players the two-player because of action efficiency through my economy like my compression is really good right and these are just like it's like the perfect storm of everything coming together cuz we have our ability that draws a card we have gym so I now whenever I take damage I get a draw a card and then look at two and draw a card right I have offering bowl which lets me draw three draw two cards and and then gain two resources, right? Like that's ins and this is all lightning bolt speed, right?

Um,

and like [clears throat] there are costs associated with this. Like I I need to have a way to heal this damage,

but like in the same like environment that this Tommy Maldune deck is, they got a counter punch that like heals [snorts] the damage that you're taking. It doesn't damage the enemy, right? But like like this is already so much like ability and compression that's like coming into just these small pieces, right?

I mean, you have one of those too. Retribution.

Yeah.

And also that does damage back and those are both fast, right? That's that's huge.

Yeah. And then like I'm running the like what is it? The 14 wild icons in my skill and then like healing while I'm taking a test.

Clue compression, right? like the mystic class like this is just like it's a it's a notable night and day difference in comparison to what the guardian pool has offered to them because the guardians have good allies right but they don't have a motivational speech-like effect and I think that guardian could feasibly this might be a controversial controversial thing to mention here but I think that I would have been in a better place If charisma wasn't printed as a neutral card and Guardians got a better charisma in their pool,

I think that that would be better. I'm going to go as far to say I think Guardians should have been able to do it at like level zero. Like maybe not permanent, but a card in their deck that they could play, right? I think that it's part of the class and the guardians need to start having some broken identity to uh to take advantage of to keep up with some of the other classes in a way.

So, let me also say I agree with you. Uh they're the the ally synergy is just missing here. They're just they're here, but they don't they need something extra for that because every other class gets that. And we'll come back to the Mystic as the example for sure um in a sec, but I've played so yeah, I should have said this beginning, but I've played chapter 2 only decks. I've played a lot of Brethren of Ash and three scenarios is usually fine. Uh but I played Marie through all of of Dunge Legacy and you might think that drawing a lot of cards in her is a little bit dangerous, but you know what? It's still fun and you still do very well even though it's a little bit interesting. Um, but that went, like you said, like Legacy cuz everything in her card pool just seems to mesh together so well that it's covering the weaknesses and turning them into strengths even of the previous version of Mystics that we saw.

Mhm.

And let her see everything that she needs to do. Even if there's not like redundancy in the spells, like we don't have an Azure Flame on top of a shriveling, but we don't need them cuz you'll find these things relatively quickly.

Yeah.

Um and I've also played a, you know, kind of a little different, but I played uh a SkidS original Skids Oul through Drown City with just chapter 2 cards, and that also worked well because I think his card pool and his ability kind of circumvent some of the other issues we were talking about.

Mhm. Uh, but yeah, I think the to comes down to there's something missing for the Guardians and the Tommy deck or Tommy Investigator that's just not I'm just not vibing with with that play style.

I mean, I I think the big thing is that um it's the mono class, right? Cuz like you said, Skids worked well. I think if Katami could do anything to just find some sort of compression, he'd probably be feeling a lot happier.

But because he isn't he doesn't have that like other way like he doesn't he has to deal with just these cards, right? Like I think in Legacy Tommy is probably pretty good, right? Um, but when you're looking at just this pool of cards, Tommy is definitely being like watching the other even the other mono class investigators and being like, why can't I do that? Like, why why can't I do that thing that they're doing, right? And that's actually I I feel like Marie, while she's very very good, I don't think she's abusing some of these legacy type of interactions that we've, you know, come to enjoy and have a lot of fun with. Uh partly because I think all the cards kind of I think she's very good. She all the cards kind of come together at the same cost, right? Like the damage isn't nothing. Even though you want to do this, the card draw is very good. Jim is very good. Um, but it doesn't feel like you're getting I don't know like the the the stack string alongs and pickpocketing type of and lucky cigarette case 3's type of value, right? It's it's still a little bit more limited than than that.

Yeah. Yeah. And like the I want to just say as well for everyone watching this

Mhm. I do think that this guardian pool, the specifically the firearms is impactful in legacy, right? Like I think that these are cards like bounty bounty [clears throat] uh counterattack custom grip, right? These are make him sing. I'm a big proponent of this card. These are all cards that are relevant in Legacy. It's just that when you're looking at a very compressed pool, uh it's hard to see the value of these because you're missing like everything else around it to really make them like have a home.

That's like the scratching head part where I'm like, I know these cards are all good and they have all done things good on their own. They're missing the secret sauce and maybe the secret sauce is the investigator card. So, I probably need to take Dianiela through a campaign and just see how different that is. She has uh similar stats on the defensive end and she doesn't give it to get as much sanity, but she can rely on the the survivor stuff to make up some of the difference.

Yeah. I think the big thing that the secret sauce that I think that is truly missing is just good card draw.

Yeah.

Like I think your deck would have been imagine if your deck had overpowered two, right?

Yes. Yes. Yes. Oh my god. like just like that would be that would have been huge to just give you like a little bit more juice to really make it work,

man. Just going back to that search of draw and there's nothing.

Yeah. Yeah. But, uh, as we said here, uh, this is the smallest it's ever going to be, right? So, things are going to get interesting. I'm hoping that they do some I'm hoping they're very focused in how they do rotation that they try things out that might be too strong, but the idea is that current is the official format. So then they can be like, "Yeah, but it'll eventually leave." So we're happy to give like Guardian this crazy like card for this thing and then Legacy is just already busted, right? So what are they going to do? Make it more busted? I mean, yes, that is what's going to happen to Legacy, but that's okay. That's why it exists.

Yeah, we're already there. It doesn't I don't think it's going to change people's perspective on playing it or not. I think if you've already determined that's the way you want to play the game, that's fine.

Yeah, I have a hard time getting to 30 cards as is, right? Like getting down to 30. Um, [clears throat] so being able to uh more cards in that pool is not going to make that harder [clears throat] because it's already already very hard. All right. Uh, any closing thoughts about all this?

I miss Gerish.

I get it. Uh, my big closing thought here is that if you're um if you find yourself like losing Arkham scenarios, try to ask yourself like every aspect of the onion of difficulty if that was the reason that you think was was part of this because I think that's a good thing. It's like was it the scenario cards? Was it the token I pulled? Was it my deck? Was it my or was my card pool? Was it my deck? Was it the choices I made? Am I able to get ahead if I'm behind? Like, there's all these little pieces that I think are really good to analyze when you're going with it, when you're playing at home to all you awesome viewers there. And I think there's a lot to discover and learn about how you can be like, what would I do differently if I'm if I'm uh if I'm playing this again? And even though this took me a while to learn, I had this revelation while I was playing this that initials Tommy deck where if you draw a card and you're not happy that you drew it, why is that card in your deck? Right? So that's a good way to look at as well. If you draw a card and you're just like, oh, this does nothing, then maybe that's a that's a sign that, hey, what else could this have been that I would have been happy to see drawing here?

I guess I'll close also by saying like don't be too hard on yourself. The game does have a lot of random elements.

Sometimes you draw a bad token when you put a lot into it and now you just don't have anything to back that up. That's not necessarily your fault. That's okay. Just keep playing. I think it's hard to evaluate until you've played through multiple scenarios with a particular deck. Then you can diagnose a little bit better. like truly could have been bad things happen and that's that's part of what makes the game interesting. Um so don't like overreact to anything any one thing either.

Yep. 100%. All right. Well, thanks for watching everybody. I hope you enjoyed this Arkham podcast. We'll be back for another one of these sometime in the future. But in the meantime, have a good one. If you want to support the channel, like, comment, subscribe, or if you want to go above and beyond, you can join all these patrons over here or YouTube membership. We have that going now as well. Thanks for watching. Have a good one.

Progress saved