Eleven - Board Game Review - Tabletop Football Manager
Transcript
thank you hi everyone I'm Luke Hector and you're watching the broken meeple this is a YouTube channel about board games where I give reviews top tens and my honest opinions regardless of the consequences we'll get on with the show in just a minute but first a quick word for my sponsor as a fellow gamer you'll understand this is unacceptable the solution head down to my new sponsor kiander.co.uk kiander stocks many of the hot new releases as well as some old hidden gems free delivery on audra's over 30 pound further discounts on bulk purchases and even five percent of your spending refunded bacteria's points to be used for further discounts down the line if you use the referral Link in the description below and sign up for a new account you'll get five percent discount on your first order over 60 pounds so let's make gaps in your collection a thing of the past get down to kinder and start saving today thank you for listening and enjoy the rest of the video get on with it so on today's show we're taking a look at 11 the new football manager board game from Portal and the weather outside is windy and Gusty that you wouldn't believe so if you hear that I apologize but I'm just gonna preface one thing here that's probably going to be more controversial than anything I mentioned in this review I don't like football most I'll do a five aside kick about for charity or something with work colleagues and that but other than that I hate Premiership football I don't care about supporting one of the man united or Arsenal teams or something they're overpaid you know overpaid Sportsmen who just get to kick a ball around for 90 minutes every now and again get paid millions of pounds whatever I got I got
no respect for the whole football thing especially when most of it is amateur Dramatics and people thinking that they can like you know cheat their way out of a game or like it's just like uh I don't like Premiership football and exactly how many times did he fall out the window so why the hell am I reviewing the board game based on it I have no idea well you know what I like different themes and the idea of running a football club sounds interesting it's different it's not it's it's been done in some smaller games but you don't hear about many of them there's a little one called super Club I keep hearing mention but I've never heard of it I think it was a like a few years old Kickstarter or something but you know a big main game by a big publisher to do with football managing that that's different and I'm always up for different themes and running a club is probably more interesting to me than like playing football itself but under the game itself so in a lemon you are managing your own club and you've got your own match sheet you've got your player board where your directors and staff will go and you've got your Stadium where you'll build upgrades and various things but what it essentially boils down to is a six round game which is done over the space of five days in each round so it's basically the week you have free action phases Tuesday to Thursday the match day which is Friday and the board meeting day which is Monday so on Monday you get production based on your various stat markers that you have on here but mainly you will get to use your board of directors so the board of directors are a bunch of cards you pre-select at the start of the game you roll a die and the board meeting card that comes out will essentially have a various effects on it
yellow blue and red you see what die results you rolled and depending on which of the colors your directors want to go for for is the outcome you do and then in this game if you ever want to mitigate die rolls you have to spend fan points you know fan counters and all that to do it but that's a very simplistic board like you know start of the round then you go into the action phases and there'll be cards laid out with you know different staff members that you can hire to go into your place and give you like special abilities and more actions you can grab sponsors which are a smorgasbord or various brand names that have been made up I think by portal there's a few sort of joke ones in here based on like certain board games but you know world's greenest grass also here's stuff like that portal cookies probably pies fly Fair Franks fruit cat food Imperium there's a lot of cool ones in here but you can basically use these to get more money and various other special effects but of course you're going to need players so you've got a mixture of players that you can hire these little cards here with different stats different abilities but they can also be trained to be even better at their jobs and some of these may even include include sorry youngsters which are basically blank faces for the while until you train them up and then there will be well who knows you don't know what the youngster is going to be that's the idea you train up the youngster they got no skill to begin with but then eventually they become a Powerhouse like the next future you know Ronaldo or something I don't know I really don't know football players that don't quote me on any of this stuff then you get to Friday with the match the match has you
going up against one of the other teams in the division now this deck is huge because it covers all the teams in every division with multiple versions of each one but before the game starts you'll effectively have six of these for the game based on what division you're doing so for example I've got division one here Port East has a little Scout report which gives you a little bit of a blurb on what they do as well as their formation and then on the back it has the actual formation you do you will then use your match board to place your various jerseys all over it in the various different sections and zones in order to prepare for the match you're kind of guessing what the opponent's going to do in terms of their attacking and defending forces Shields and footballs and so what happens is once you've prepared you've played your tactic cards and various other things you're right okay I'm sorted for the match you then flip over the respective Scout report and then based on where your jerseys are on this grid you will assess in pairs whether you are able to get your shots past those pairs so basically if it's a football it's attacking if it's a defense it's defending they've got strength values you compare the strengths highest goes through if it's attacking it'll score a goal if it's defending it blocks it and so on so forth most of the players work in a similar fashion the goalkeeper has one or two extra rules about saving but that's essentially the deal once you've assessed the five different zones both wings and the three Central ones you check to see who's won the match you roll a die on some consequences to see if you get injuries or some extra strength for maybe somebody gets trained up in them in the match and then you rinse repeat for another five rounds you
do another board meeting and then you get more Stadium bonuses you get more players you find more staff you you know you get more sponsors you do whatever it is you need to do but you've only got the free actions plus any bonus ones that you might pay for with specific markers so actions are quite tight and then of course you've got to play another five matches at the end of all those matches you find out by our victory points from stuff you've built players you've hired players that have gone into matches and scored goals as well as your final league position in the table compared to all the other teams total up the points and of course the woman the most of course so I get a preface right now I am coming into this solely as a solo player right that I am this is a solo review I'm just going to explain why now multiplayer is pointless this is a multiplayer solitaire game in every definition of the word the only thing that another player does to you is you'll have a display of the staff cards of the players and of the sponsors okay and you can only choose from certain ones in the display they rinse they rinse and repeat so if one gets taken they slide down another one comes out other players might take the card you want that's literally it that is all the multiplayer is all the matches are simultaneous and everybody plays their own match the board meeting simultaneous everybody rolls their own die has their own board directors and decides what it is they want to do the match consequences are there beef you know the stadium is there beef you can't do anything with the other players so this game is entirely pretty much multiplayer
Solitaire or a solo game so if you think of the buying this to play with your three or four player group I honestly don't particularly recommend that this is a solo game it felt like a solo game when I played it multiplayer and it's just like yeah you know what solo all the way so here we go with that said going forward let's talk about components rise now this insert is not in the game okay I've forgotten the name I think it's nudruko or something but basically they were selling these Essen it's an MDF insert I'll put the name on the screen if I can find a web link I'll let you know but basically this was an MDF insert that I bought at the time to house the card and it does a pretty good job of actually containing everything in a nice neat setup in the main box the only downside is if you want to mix and match the various sponsors and director cards the copy holds don't allow for that very easily so you've got to split them across multiple compartments it's kind of assumes that you're going to separate all the expansion stuff every game which is kind of stupid but you know it's doing well for me so that is what these are but the rest of the components are all portal and to be honest they're fine actually this is the retail copy of the game and I don't know what all the deluxe kickstarter's meant stuff is meant to be or what was on game round I'm not interested this is the retail copy okay the card's pretty decent they're stiff cards I don't think you ever need to sleeve these I think these are pretty sturdy cards they're not going to scuff they're very they're fairly thick cardstock you know good quality you know these are not going to be a problem to leave unsleeped I quite like the player mats as well I mean yeah
they are you know flimsy in in that sense but I like the feel of them they've got this kind of glossy almost linen finish cover on them with slightly different feel for where you would actually put tiles so that they stick a little bit more another thing I quite like this I mean it just feels nice yes I would like an actual board if it you know all things considered but if it keeps the price down you know what I'd settle for this these don't slide around on the table especially not on something like this surface and you know the artwork is you know decent enough it certainly portrays that theme of being a football manager and the rest of the game kind of does that as well but more on that in a minute and honestly the other other ideas I mean you've got you know pretty thick cardboard sort of cardboard so you pick wooden tokens for the various resources I mean would you like proper looking resources yes but honestly I'll take thick wooden counters as a side thing tiles tiles for the stadium increases they're fine you've got a bunch more tokens that you can have in the box and yeah honestly I'm fine with the component quality in this there was nothing in here that I felt detracted from the experience I've heard reports of some issues with some of the game found stuff but that's not my concern my concern is what could you buy in the box if you went to the shop and bought it direct and honestly I think the stuff you get in the retail box is pretty comprehensive the theme does come out quite strong yes you're just mainly acquiring cards and doing a whole push of luck thing with the match isn't that but if you want to play this thinking this is going to be a like football manager it's not far off
honestly you've got the teams doing what they do you've got other teams winning and drawing and losing matches at random more on that later in the tournament you've got unexpected consequences you've got the board directors having to come up with some quandary you know like you know are we gonna like sponsor this or not and you're hoping to not have to spend all your money yeah are you going to get more players you're gonna get more stuff that theme came out quite strong and for someone like me who's not even interested in football to the most extent that's pretty impressive
now we're starting to get into mixed bag opinions because that was all good up to that point however firstly the rule book the rule book is not as bad as portal games rulebooks have been in the past it's not it's decent enough it's big and thick yes but most of it is because there's a lot of pictures in here and the text is relatively big you know they're not wasting the space on just like Bland the white space and text there's a lot going on here I mean there's tons of pages just for the setup which is a quite a lengthy setup it must be said but the issues with the rule book are mainly to do with the ordering and the matches I found that this book was pretty useful from a player 8 perspective I found it was very good at teaching me what to do with the various cards and what to do in the the board director's phase and the action phases but they then like put these additional rules at the very end of the book after you've done the end of the game and these are important additional rules like maintenance that you have to pay every round uh enjoy series objective cars match effects this year in a bit tactic cards even you need to know how tactic cards work before the match why is it in additional rules these things should have just there shouldn't be an additional rule section this should be in the bulk of the main rule book but on top of that the matches as much as they do do as a good job of sorry a good attempt of trying to explain how the matches work I did find that that was a little bit tricky to get
my head around because it's not explained as well as it could have been and you certainly are going to have problems with this game if you're left and right to have problems because you are playing like forward Midfield and back your scout report goes here right and it's obviously from the same perspective but you have to like ascertain these pairs based on their right wing attacking your left wing because obviously it's you know obviously my perspective is different from the opponent's perspective but when you try to translate that to a board game it gets a little bit weird you're thinking Ah that's blocking that and that's blocking oh wait hang on I'm supposed to be associating that zone against that zone all right then that zone against that zone is like all right just takes a little bit extra to kind of go hmm you know so the the matches I found to not be quite as streamlined as I would like and they're gonna take you a bit longer to get used to in fact I mean I wouldn't be surprised if someone told me I was playing in Ron at one point yeah it's gonna be one of those things that's like uh could have been better but they have seen much worse Rule books so honestly it's not that bad overall I would rate it a c plus okay not great but here's one big problem I have and this is not this is this is going to be exacerbated if you play this multiplayer this is another reason why this is a solo game and nothing else the luck factor in this game is a bit much this game does outstay its welcome I think with six rounds every time I've played this whether it's multiplayer or well actually a specially multiplayer but when I played it solo it's I feel like when I get to the end of round four I feel like I'm done you've already had
a decent amount of time in the game because you're planning what you're going to do with those free actions it's not like you can just go through the round in five minutes and do well because it's not gonna happen and the matches usually take a bit to get through but by the time gets around five and six I feel like I'm done so five and six just like ah they feel bolted on I wish it was just a little bit shorter and a bit more condensed not to mention that it's very rinse repeat every round plays out exactly the same the only difference is that you will have slightly better players some bigger stats or maybe I don't know it depends how badly you did earlier but uh you know you're gonna have a bit more stuff built which means that the turns are going to take a bit longer because you've got more stuff to play with but again it's rinse repeat there's no sense of a real Crescendo in this game it's not like when you get to the match six it's like right this is the final against the best team ever or anything it's like well no it's another team out of the random selection of six and it will be exactly the same as before it's just your players are hopefully a little bit better not a lot of differentiation with each round and so by the time I get around four I'm kind of done but the luck Factor really hurts because there are some aspects of luck in this game which you can argue quite thematic that they work for the game yes they're fanatic but mechanically I don't think they work the board of directors meetings these cards it's a cool idea and I like the concept but some of these effects are pretty bad and some of these are particularly good so there is definitely a swing in how good
and bad they are somebody rolling like a good one versus somebody who rolls a bad one has a massive leg up and it's purely luck if you've got the red tokens to mitigate it possibly but that just allows you to re-roll the die I don't know if you know my dice luck but I can re-roll the die I'm doing them at times and still get bad results if I try so it's not like you spend the marker and adjust the die value by one or two because that would actually probably work better but the fact you have to re-roll it just means it's more luck at the end of the day and it's pretty punishing to sort of go right well I just had to spend two money because of this board meeting but oh you got to train an entire player it's a bit of a leg up all based on a die roll in Solo mode you put up with it in multiplayer mode it hurts a lot on top of that what other luck factors you've got well you've got the match itself the Scout reports yeah they give you a little report on them like I mean you know they are the current champion of the lead they rarely score but almost never lose goals either they're motivated and they press on both Wings they play 4-4-2 okay how do I interpret that now the last bit they press on both wings okay so I expect the wings to have a lot of players or a lot of strength and lo and behold there's a strength five player here a strength three Defender and a strength three there but there's also string fours at the back there's also a string three at the front it a lot of these Scout reports are pretty vague you don't feel like you've like oh yeah I've sussed out there team right this is the perfect layout I'm gonna do it it's push your luck at the end of the day and you sometimes feel that you lost a match
purely because you got unlucky like I'll put a player on left wing or right wing I don't know it's the same player it's left wing or white wing there's nothing in the Scout report about it all right I'll put it on the left and then you find the left has got a massive Defender and it's screw whereas if you put it on the right you would have got lucky and scored a goal and again you can argue that football is a bit like that when you watch it being played but in a board game in a euro game that's this long it says 90 minutes on the box good yeah good luck with that yeah you're talking to arrows plus it's I don't know that that does hurt a bit and bear in mind this is something that wants you to get victory points or achieve certain scenarios so something like that happening which just screws you over in a long game does get a little bit grating and then you've got the Matched consequences at the end win draw or lose you roll a six-sided die and you see what happens you could win every single game in the league and you could still roll bad enough to injure all your players and getting rid of injuries isn't that easy or cheap whereas you could lose every single game and still get like extra strength added to your players for the future it it's another random element and as much as you might think well don't what if you just get a bunch of these red counters the red counters also go on your ad stands and provide revenue for people coming to your club and if you don't get that Revenue good luck paying your maintenance because money is tight you don't have a lot of money to go around and it even wants you to upgrade your office in this game which is just generic track up great for victory points but I'm like yeah I'm glad you've got all the money in the world I don't know where everybody else is getting all
the money in the world to upgrade their office I mean you could probably upgrade your office if you don't mind your Stadium being consisting of nothing interesting or important hey yeah money is quite tight I want my red counters for that not for die rolls and if somebody isn't spending them on die rolls they're getting more money Rich get richer you see where I'm going with this but the variety is pretty decent you've got a lot of players you've got a lot of sponsors I mean a ton of sponsors and yes this does include a few from the mini expansion but you would still have quite a fair bit after that would have liked a few more board directors there's not a huge amount of variety in here there's not a huge amount of different ones but you know what it is there's a decent amount of skull um skull Scout report skull report that'd be interesting um objectives are kind of normal but where I think this game lacks a lot on variety is the staff because we'll ignore this set because this came from an expand tension so these are your starter ones this is your deck of staff this is it that's another staff although hang on a minute surely there's more staff than that Luke oh there is there's this chunk of Staff but why am I not using it because it's three and four player only if you play this with one or two players these are all the staff you have that is purely for three or four players and they are not particularly varied um you know varied abilities mostly it's set collection for victory points which I don't get thematically how that's
supposed to work in the game in the game of football but you know needs to the must but that means I'm literally seeing the same stuff about every single game and they're not that interesting in terms of abilities so this for some reason I mean you've got all these sponsors and you've only got this many stabs that just seemed like a bit of a little waste and the stadium upgrades aren't particularly buried either I mean there's two sets here because one's a mini expansion but in the base set you just get four generic ones that increase your markers stands and uh and was it and your billboard that's it there's not particularly much Variety in Stadium upgrades nor are they by themselves that interesting so you get good variety in some places and bad in others but if you are playing Just solo you do at least get some decent scenarios so if you're multiplayer you're playing normal rules but solo you've got six scenarios this is double-sided which much like in the Robinson Crusoe vein basically touch up the rules give you set up changes new ideas and gotta admit that played all six but they are pretty varied I mean you've got one where you're investigating a corrupt Club one where you're in a rubbish team and you've got to try not to get relegated you've got uh you know friendly matches with trying to get to the highest uh managerial position you've got going up against a rival you've got a guy who's like obsessed with money and having like not wasting money on stuff these are pretty varied and as I say this is why I'm reviewing it mostly for a solo perspective because you get these and this is more variety than the multiplayer is this is why Superman works alone so recommending 11 kind of
depends on how you're going to play this you need to have your expectations solid if you're coming into this as a multiplayer experience I just don't recommend it honestly I don't think it's worth it you could have four players with this massive table Hulk table and the other three players do almost nothing to get in your way apart from by the occasional staff card you wanted that's literally it it's not worth it solo is the way to play this game now from a solo perspective is the game still good yes and no there's certainly a good amount of strong theme here you know it definitely felt like I was running a football club that bit is definitely done well thumbs up the rulebook could have been better at explaining the matches and ordering certain rules around but for the most part it didn't take me too long to get into the game and just get going and that's pretty impressive in Portal's standpoint there's a decent amount of variety in some of the players that you can have and the different sponsors that you can have but then the variety drops with things like the staff car it's been cut in half if you want to play this solo and they're not being that many interesting Stadium upgrades or you know that many directors to speak of unless you buy some of the other expansions and as I say the expansions are nice to have but I gotta give this rating based on the box that you just buy on its own These are nice additions this is what you're buying up front first the component quality is fine you know the cards are decent quality the wooden counter isn't that a decent yeah there's no Miniatures who cares I'm not interested what are the game found um extras and Deluxe stuff like I don't
know not my concern I'm on about the review I'm reviewing a retail copy here but that luck factor and the length of the game is a big deal you know this game is already taking you a good 90 minutes to two hours to play possibly even solo because you're not playing it at super speed you're looking at the different things you can do and going right well let me plan out my whole week well I probably should do that first but then should I pay to do this current action on top if I do that will I have enough money to then buy the stadium upgrade maybe but then I'll have to get a sponsor which sponsor do I want and and certainly it'll get your brain ticking but it means that the game's gonna drag on a bit and the matches take a while to do assuming that you read the rules where I can understand how to do them because you'll constantly be thinking all right hang on left versus right and this one goes against this one and that one goes against that ah you know and not to mention that the game is I didn't mention before but the game's also pretty hard you know this is a hard game to win this game will punch you in the face on a regular basis and some of that is just the game being naturally difficult but some of it is also just the randomness of the consequences of the match the board director meetings and the match Scout reports themselves that feel very disconnected getting in the way and if this was a 60 Minute game tops probably wouldn't have too much trouble with that and then I play empires in the north so low and you know that's a short game I'm done in 60 minutes is there luck of the draw yeah but it's 60 minutes it's the shortest game this is like twice as long that you're going to be investing in setting up getting it out playing through six rounds which really should have ideally been four rounds and yet you've got to pull up with those aspects now for some of you you're not gonna care you're
gonna love that and if you do you're gonna like this and think this is really really good especially with six scenarios in here and potentially more if you buy the extra expansion for me though this is it does things right but a lot of other things it just kind of falls on so I think my final rating for this is probably going to be a strong but still capped at six out of ten it's not quite enough to get the endorsement rating up front I just think that some of the the downsides that they're in this game are quite a big deal for me I don't want to play six rounds of this rinse repeat rinse repeat even know the scenarios are quite cool but then they also just don't want the luck factor to come in that bad I mean the board meetings are fun to read the little blur but just to do a die roll and hope for the best as that is interesting the Scout reports again I feel like I'm literally just going and I'll just put me jerseys here here and here and then flip it and then see what happens again that's not as fun either so it does some stuff right and I think it's going to be it's gonna work well with fans particularly those who are big football fans but bearing in mind another football fan I'm coming into this as somebody who doesn't like football but that hasn't influenced my opinion if anything I think the fact that I like the theme of this game despite not liking football was quite an achievement but it's a strong six out of ten it's just not quite up to that level and you know I feel like maybe a little bit more development time maybe just streamlining certain aspects getting those matches done really well or shortening the game
a little bit I think would have just brought it up to that seven and eight category for me because it could have been but it's a six out of 10 for me here so that's it for me on this episode if you like what you see then please if you can share the video on social media thumb up the video on YouTube and also on Board Game Geek as well it will pop up there I'd be grateful if you could thumb it up in there as well because it then appears in the hotness but also I'd like you to check out more content on the channel including the latest reviews I've done for Starship captains as well as Ottawa from UE Rosenberg so take care and remember regardless of how crummy your Club is it's still only a game bye for now