Freedom! by Phalanx - Designer Interview: Vangelis Bagiartakis | Cardboard Rhino
Transcript
Hello guys it's Cardboard Rhino and I have a to me and I think a lot other people the most Bagiartakis. Hi Vangelis how are you? Hi Eleni
well. As you guys know i'm also Greek so this to talk with Vangelis about a game that has a and it was designed by Vangelis I think a couple
Right yes yes, but it was released two in 2020 it was kickstarted one year right war game about the the siege of Messolonghi
before we go into like what the game is about like a question for you because I've seen like "Fields of Green" to "Kitchen Rush" and "Among
game is that right? Exactly. Okay, how how did you So, first of all I really like the idea of trying I mean very often some designers
They're good at it they design very good games I try to experiment and you know dip my toe into said some you know strategy games like some
even a dexterity game with a wooden board so at some point when i this idea for this game different from anything else i design, why not,
So you basically challenged yourself or something? start by saying okay i want to design a war the other way around, I mean I
i was watching a play regarding Messolonghi. It and it was a child's play and it had and while I was watching it at some point they
hero was about to help near the end of the during the Sortie the last days of the help and in my mind this sounded like
It struck me like okay you have two distinct parts, you have a very nice and I realized that this could and I mean I would see other games around other
I had seen those things and I was saying could really make a very good game and I found the guy that wrote the play who had read and he helped me with the historical part with
of reading and it was very useful for me you know all the time to do all the reading but it was very nice to have him on
so that was the initial plan but it took us yeah the the game I know it's one player plays the besieged freedom fighters
besieging imperial forces, correct? to design the game must have been of the Messolonghi, right? It played a part yes.
was very you know it was the target of this siege When the rebellion started in Greece it was so they tried to the Ottomans tried to take
that was attempted at Messolonghi, there and they didn't last long, either of them, was very angry with the fact that this the city
generals, Kioutachis, as you know and he Big incentive take the city because he knew what was on the line
easy task because when he went for the third time first two sieges the army was much smaller and the by another general but they both had brought very
between the first sieges and the third one the even better they had made some fortifications and so when Kioutachis went for the third time he
that the whole thing would be over in a matter he still couldn't take the city and that was when
who sent his son the prince Ibrahim and when the same he said like come on you can't take this And he he also thought that would be an easy task
and so this went back and forth for a few for a year I mean about six months after enter into the city by force. He tried from the which was also as you said before that it was very
fortified natural defenses a big part of the city hard for the Ottomans to get inside the city from and so near about one year after the siege had
because they had managed to blockade everything, and in the end the the city let's couldn't stand the hunger anymore They were actually starving they were dying well known as you know in Greece and to leave the
and it turned into a massacre as as they were surrender they said okay we can't take it anymore will attempt to leave during the night with
the nearby mountain but their plan was betrayed there was a lot of light and the Ottomans could a massacre very few people survived and most of the people captured ended up being
Is the the betrayal part of the game? designing the game along with my friend who one question that we would keep on you put the Sortie into the game, because it
But the problem was that essentially the Sortie can't stand any longer so it was hard to put it in
basically the game ends either with the Ottomans morale falling or the Greeks win after some time You see the the odd thing is that the lasted a couple of weeks more they would also couldn't stand it Exactly yeah it was it was a mercenary army they
feed them and their morale was also very very low trying to take this, so it was very close and that realize that this could turn into a game so it wasn't the stretch for the Greeks to win or
The irony if you like is that even though the events of the Sortie and the massacre that moved everyone in Europe very much and actually
and a lot of the grand powers in Greece in their fight for independence it actually paved the way for the independence of
yeah I think I guess the name is wars or rebellion, "freedom or death"
actually at some point one of the names that I which is actually as you know it yeah that's the name he gave to one of
people were besieged but they were yes yes exactly right we haven't really spoken about the mechanics is your favorite mechanic in the game or what was
So as as this was a siege the very first thought track of you know with the food that the people you would also have a track with the morale
and if you ever reached the end of the track was the very very first mechanic that i thought beyond that I really liked the card driven huge amount of war games game, one game that i had really enjoyed
which is about the elections in the U.S. with game and a lot of people call it a war game in so I really really loved when i was playing that
were very thematic they had actual events that the depicted event something would happen that could discard the card and use those action points
do what you wanted but it could also help you And I really love that mechanism bring the theme into the surface I mean to it was a chance to put actual events into the game
start I decided that this was how I wanted the personalities that took place during the those people, to use those events as they happened
So what has been the biggest challenge there's a lot of different moving parts really difficult for you to do I guess that consider the biggest challenges. One
game so each side has different actions ,has so when designing an asymmetrical game it's you know at the perfect point, because one player may play one of the sides may be
it helps if you know the cards so during play playing the game again and trying the game for the first time and you know, the exact balance where is the point that you say entirely up to them and how well they play uh in
part and it's also I mean every now and then much better than the other one and claiming the other thing maybe the opposite and for people that have played a lot of games
they have an equal number of wins if either side game was how much do I put into the game many things do I transfer into the game and
let's say simulation of what actually happened in the game when I started designing and that at while interesting and true to historical accuracy
For example around the walls there was water some parts weren't and initially that perform an action to fill the moat with water The ottomans could also perform an action
so you had these kind of things that in a way they were interesting but they they usually trying to find the interesting versus too complex you don't want
make it too simple and lose interest so that And how long did it take you from starting you said okay now it's good to go? Or I don't
think all the time you'll find something that designing and development part last? so the idea came in like 2010 I think
but we actually started working on the game The game was in my mind but you know not here and there so on 2014 along with Alexander our ideas down on paper and it took roughly a
But we weren't a meeting every day but it took about a year with that rate yeah the development came afterwards you know with
you probably need to change it okay let's change or okay let's see so how many cards do I have that other side that was the development part that came
specific period of time because as I was while we were waiting for the publisher Phalanx decided to publish it I did some more play
after that point was you know effort I was just wondering have you ever kids? I think they're very young now, right?
all of them have shown interest because they've I think most of them you know the older one could probably play it but with the Hopefully as soon as the Greek version goes
There's gonna be a greek version? as you may know Phalanx has a pre-ordering for the english version and there are also plans greek version, german one, polish and spanish and
pre-orders are made for the game the production made there we're probably going to see a great Great yeah I'll have the link to the to the anyone who wants to check it out and it would be
this kind of game would actually secondary schools and stuff more excited they learn it at school is not that much exciting get them really you know excited about board
One of the very you know exciting you actually feel like the people involved So initially you see the the Ottoman player you feel very confident you feel like i have all and the the greek layer, the insurgents, they are
As a few rounds will go by the the good player it so his confidence goes up while the imperial have a lot of forces so it actually seemed like
At that point it's where Ibrahim comes in and he brings on better cannon operators and so he start suddenly to become harder for the for the
that due to the fact that the city was holding a the city to protect themselves but this meant that Right, there's a trade-off. to become really hard for the greek players to
may at that point they may have very few units to player at some point also has his morale for supplies and for salaries for these units
both sides they are both feeling like helpless how are we going to survive and both are trying to can get, try to hold longer.
you actually learn a lot of things about Again so as i said it's a perfect tool Yes, yes definitely. I don't know expansions maybe or not yet? So this was not exactly an expansion
a solo version for the Ottomans I mean right are being played by an AI there is actually this well because you know the insurgents they're more
it's easy to to have an AI control the the What some players have asked for is a solo this I haven't worked on it yet but it is in the to work on that too. I also have a question it's not so much
in general because I think most gamers they are into game design and like a big so I'd like to ask you if you have any
that they can like they should avoid or That's really a bigger discussion but you know So i would start the I think the very first thing
would be to play a lot of games the more because playing a lot of games lets you see how things into mechanics, like okay this guy did
salaries or the resource gathering whatever Exactly you see if you play just five games you're going to be based on those five games you have played for example just Monopoly and when
design a game, they design a Monopoly clone what they've seen, it makes perfect sense. then he has a much larger pool to Somebody having played at 1000 the more games you played the easier it's
and the other thing that you should know is I don't want to say this in a you is in every art in every craft like the first fail or you're not going to do it so well that's You're taking out of your system basically. new designers is try to design your get them out of the way so that they can Right so yeah play a lot of games and design
don't hold on to an idea of yours And I guess try to do the Yeah another keyword phrase that it's used a play test it okay a lot of things won't
try again ,okay some things will fail you'll process like you keep doing this, you think you play test it you change you play just And you should probably find get feedback from, not anybody
you have it's very easy to fall into another for example and usually they're going to say oh they're doing it on purpose they're happy for
and the best thing is to have somebody with the game because she will give you blunt feedback and tell you "hey your baby is ugly" It hurts a lot but you learned that you realize at
order for you to improve the game because if you going to hear it after the game comes out and to hear it early on and do changes to your game Okay all right! your advice, for your time, for everything. If anyone wants to check out the game you also see a lot of footage of the game,
Thank you so much Vangelis and I hope to have more the nitty-gritty of game I'll be happy.