Terrorscape: Discussion
Transcript
Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised.
Hey everyone, welcome back to Board Games Unlocked and today I'm doing a discussion over Terrorcape, uh, Terescape 1 specifically. I will do a second discussion whenever the second one gets delivered. But this is a game that for some reason I took my time on doing a uh video for cuz I have played this a lot. Uh since I got it in, I have just been playing it non-stop. And recently uh whenever I went on my non- Gen Con excursion of playing random games, uh I was also uh given a chance to play this. And at the time, you know, I'm actually glad that I waited on on this one because my my thoughts on this game has actually shifted slightly because I really I enjoy hidden movement games, but it's a genre to me that I have the staples in my collection and other other games just don't naturally they really work for me. Uh the games that are recently released, uh Sniper Elite and Mind Management, didn't really do it for me because I have other games in my collection that I just like. But then Terescape came along and it has that slasher horror vibe that I absolutely love. You know, thank Final Girl, but not Solo. And it has a unique
spin on the hidden movement element where the killer is the one that is actually revealed and all of the victims are the ones that are actually hidden. So, it's on the one player to be the one trying to figure out where everyone else is at. And on the surface, this game uh it delivers. I think it's an I I think it is still a lot of fun, especially if you can get into that vibe. I know whenever I teach people this game, of course, I play the generic butcher, but I'll set the scene and I'll play uh a revving chainsaw sound effect to get into the mood. Um, but this game actually has a really uh interest or had had an in interesting circumstance that had me thinking of what's the ratio of length of a game to randomness factor to make it enjoyable. How long essentially what I mean is how long does a game have to be before randomness is no longer fun. And this game kind of has this swingy element that I think teeters on that line of, okay, this is still really fun. Who cares? And then there are other games of this where it's okay, this is taking too long. It's no longer fun. And I've had multiple games where it goes one way or the other.
At the end of the day though, I think this is one a very unique game. I like the fact that the the people who are playing the the characters are just they're the ones that are hidden and they don't have to relay any information other than when a board state changes. You know, we're removing a a barricade noise was placed here. Um unfortunately, this is also one of those games that the players both sides have to know what they're doing. And that that's true for honestly any hidden movement game. If the person hiding and moving around makes a mistake, that throws the whole game. It's the the genre is a very finicky genre. Uh I've never claimed it to be the best genre in the world. Uh cuz I've actually had games of Fury of Dracula where I moved across the ocean and just completely blanked on telling them. And that throws everyone off.
Um, in this game you kind of need to have both sides make sure that they're do that they're playing correctly because it's on the killer side. It is pertinent to know what people are doing. Um, I think the designers of this game also tried to take in they they it seemed like they wanted to have theme be more of, you know, more prevalent than mechanisms. For example, uh there's an item that the that the survivors can find that's a glass bottle and it allows them to place a noise token in an adjacent room. Well, if you're the killer and they say, "Hey, there's a noise in the dining room." You don't you don't really know. You that's all you know is there was noise in the dining room. That can come from a glass bottle. that can come from a person's ability like uh I think it's William Hooper the uh athlete who can sprint so he can move three spaces but where he lands puts a noise token it could be there it could be a camera clicking it could be the fact that they at the end of their turn they chose a survivor who was in the dining room to do the discover action and the one of the cards they kept or discarded made noise. That's four different elements that the killer has to take into consideration uh before he even decides to go investigate.
Um so this so I I love the fact that there is a lot of theme. You can go really get into the theater of the mind with this game and it could be a lot of fun. both two two instances of um the games we had played of this was as the butcher uh there was noise in the storage room. So I moved into the storage room and searched but uh no one was there and prior to moving the character was in my space. So if I had just stayed there and searched I would have found them. But because I moved into the storage uh and search that basically miss and means he could he could run out because the the storage to uh the storage room to the garden was barricaded so they couldn't uh run that way. So if you take out the mechanisms and you go thematic where he's doing this sweaty duck dodge underneath uh this the the chainsaw of this uh butcher. That's really cool.
[snorts] on the other game. Uh it was against the murderer. The survivors were evading him the the entire game and uh right before they needed to convene cuz all the keys were out. Right before they needed to convene to get out the main exit, uh he happened to catch them and do an a uh encounter and the die rolls came up blank. And by that point, the butcher, not the butcher, the murderer was level five. So when an encounter starts, he's automatically damaged. And because the dice were blank that he killed him, and that's all you need for the killer to win. Now, both of these instances you can take as as they're about to run out the door, they unlock it, and they're running, and then the murderer just swoops in and like gashes uh the kid's throat, and then he bleeds out, dies.
You can really get into that, and that is fun. However, both of those examples uh of gameplay are prime examples why I actually started to have an issue with this game and why people I've played it with started to have an issue with this game. And this it's kind of twofold. A I I just do not think this game is balanced. and B, I don't think that uh I think this game has a little bit too much randomness to it. So, let's talk about the unbalanced nature of the game. Well, I think the killers and this game has a lot of expansions and at the at this time I've not played every single killer. I want to and I want to do a ranking on them. Hell, I even want to do a ranking on the survivors cuz there are two, four, six, eight. There's nine survivors and how many killers are there? There's three in the core game.
Three, four, five. No, that's So, three, four, five, six, seven, eight. Eight killers. I could lift the box up and find out, but around that around that number. Um, so I just, so if we're talking about the survivors, let's talk, uh, the survivors, some of them are just absolutely situational. I don't think that they put into much thought on on the way that the survivors uh, act and what their innate abilities are when you're comparing it to everyone else. Cuz this game, a pro to the game is that the game comes with a lot of different map boards. So, the ones you're kind of seeing, that's the base mansion. It's the standard. Nothing unique about it.
Some expansions or some uh characters do interact with this, but with all the other expansions, they came with new maps, a cave, a science lab, and all of the maps and all the killers are cross-co compatible. It's one of my favorite things. It's why Final Girl is such a hit for me is cuz you take any location, any killer, mix them up, and you're going to have a different experience. And that is true for a terror escape. So that's a positive. However, going to the unbalanced nature, there are it feels some of the expansion characters are way more restrictive. Uh one of the characters is uh he has a coin that he can use once um to either potentially heal him or to seed the deck. another character, another expansion takes up her whole turn to put an encouragement token on someone. And then you have who I think is the most busted character in this game. And I would love for someone to come in the comments and tell me that it's actually not. But I do not see how Anna Kendrick is not the most busted character in this cuz her innate abilities not something she has to activate or anything. She it is immune to sense, which is a a card that the killer plays to pick a colored room, uh, blue, red, or green, and any characters who are in those colored rooms have to say yes, this is this is who's in there. Um, Anna can just always
say no. Or if she's if she's in red and the killer senses red and she's the only one in there, oh, there's no one there. And then the other ability that she has is she does not make noise when she is searching uh key rooms, which is an action you can go out and do. And typically that's where most of the keys are going to be. And one way for the survivors to win is that uh they need to find five keys and all convene at either the hidden exit, if you have the secret map, or the main exit. Um she and and with a game that is all about the killer trying to figure out at you know try and make up some information on where they're at. I don't know how that ever got passed uh play testing. It makes absolutely no sense.
Uh because she can just sit in a room never being found unless the killer just happens to go and oh I'm in the gallery. I guess I'll just search the gallery on the off chance she's in there. Uh, and you get lucky. She just sits in a storage room and or a key location room and just spams her action. That's all she does while everyone else is [ __ ] around making noise and uh distracting the killer. [snorts] Uh, and from a thematic standpoint, yeah, that could that could kind of work thematically, but mechanically it's just because all of these hidden movement games require both sides to be able to use the information to their advantage.
And unfortunately, Terrorcape doesn't give the killer all that much info to go off of. And again, I'm going to talk about how the killers are unbalanced, too. So it it I guess they went a route of well if everything is unbalanced none of it's unbalanced. Uh so Anna Kendrick is just absolutely infuriating. It has gotten to a point that if the people the survivors the people who are playing them if someone picks Anna I take her token and I just move it off the board. Unless I'm it's it's a user error like a skill issue. I don't know how you find her ever besides getting lucky unless she's paired up with someone and you you encounter that person and she's also there.
So, I just I have absolutely given up on ever trying to find her and I focus on on the other two. And you might think, well, all the killer has to do is kill one person. If it's level if he levels up enough, then he'll eventually just naturally do it. And that's true. I have beaten survivors who have Anna on their team. She is not one of the ones I've ever found. It's always funny enough, it's always the fat mechanic. Um, but yeah, so she's I just think she's broken. The doctor is also kind of busted uh because he can keep pulling his adrenaline from the discard pile. It takes his turn to do it, but it's an extra action to use that. and the adrenaline gives you an extra move. And that's frustrating because again, the way noise works in this game, it's you can essentially make noise in one room, you know, pass along the adrenaline to someone, have them use it to move out of the room they just made noise in, and then the doctor can just, oh, I got it right back. And I think is the doctor core game? I think the doctor is core game. It it definitely just feels like the core game monsters and survivors are just well I overpowered and then expansions are almost underpowered.
Um although I will say the expansion that I did play most recently felt a lot more balanced than it was I think it was their newest one, the one with the mummified queen in the cave. That felt a lot more balanced than than doing the base game mansion. Uh, so the survivors I think are just all over the place. Someone can be incredibly useful. Um, and it's funny, uh, whenever we, uh, the last game we played against the murderer, I specifically I was playing on the survivor side and and we lost, but it was funny cuz I specifically did not choose Anna. Uh, me and the other person we were playing I was playing with, we went uh, William. uh Olivia, which or uh Olivia, the one who can do encourage tokens, and then the uh guy with the the coin who can search in the graveyard. Um and it was actually working out extremely well. And it's funny because we did end up losing and I'm like, it's cuz we didn't have Anna.
She's she's easy mode for the survivors. Uh, so it's uh it's just it it it just it's really unfun honestly in hidden movement games like this where there's almost a character who is designed to go against the rules or to go against the hidden movement element. So the survivors I feel are unbalanced. The killers are also radically unbalanced. I think I don't know because they say in the rule book that the butcher is the purest form of terrorcape. [snorts] I do not know how you do well with the butcher cuz his whole stick is that he has high strength so that if you um if you go to an encounter with him, you have to roll extremely high to be able to uh not take damage from him. But the problem is is he has no movement and his whole gimmick is that he barricades locations, but the barricades I mean you have to get I mean you can find a hatchet gets rid of barricades and yeah those are one time use items but all of his cards just are so expensive to play besides obviously the quick ones. but he has one. It's even a level up uh ability for the butcher where his revving chainsaw is now a quick action. Well, the problem with that is it requires two cards to be able to um to be able to
use. So, yeah, it doesn't take up your turn. You could still play the revving chainsaw and that fears all survivors within one range. and fear can be useful if you do find anyone. And then you're allowed to move zero to one and just outright damage all uh survivors in your location. So that's powerful except it still costs two cards to do. And then his big one, which is kind of funny now with obsession coming out, the stay is uh it cost four [ __ ] cards. It's that's your whole turn is uh blocking all doors in your location. And it'd be different if the survivor could move through them and still keep them up. Um but he can't if he can move through them, but then he removes it. And that's also part of the butcher's ability, his brutal rage cost a card, and he can move one to two spaces and search, but if no one was found and he moved through a block token, he gets to do it again.
So to get any sense of control of the map as the butcher, you have to constantly be putting up barricades um and hope that you can even find someone because he doesn't have any innate way to actually um to actually find someone. And he barely does any fear. And if he does with uh revving chainsaw, then he well I hope I moved into one space that you're in and I just damaged you. Uh, so the butcher definitely definitely feels the worst to play. But then as if you're talking about unbal like the unbalanced nature, the what is it? The wraith. The wraith is disgustingly OP. She is basically easy mode for the killers because she's actually a good counter against Anna because hey, I don't need to sense you. I just need to move. She has ways to move through you.
If if she moved through you, you gain a fear. If um and her whole thing is she stacks a [ __ ] ton of fear because if you encounter her, she has two strength. So you'd have to roll complete blanks to uh to, you know, get damage from her. But her big thing is once you get a third fear stacked on you, you make a noise in your location and you have to say where you're at. So her big thing is she just ramps you with fear and at a certain level once you if you max out on fear, you're just damaged. So the way that and she's also able to sneak uh which sneak is huge in this game. Murderer can also sneak. I'll talk about the murderer in a sec, but I think the siren out of all the ones I've played is I mean it's over before it began.
And then the murderer is kind of a a happy medium between the two, but his big thing is his uh his ultimate card that allows him to stealth and when he reappears, he eliminates anyone that is within zero or one space of him. So yeah, the the strategy is okay, he has to use his death blossom. Hey, I'm using my death blossom. And then you know where he was at and if you can everyone scatters as far away as they cuz he can only move I think 0 to two too. And to be fair against the murderer that's not even how we lost. Um there was a moment though that was it was basically he had to move in the opposite direction. Uh otherwise no matter what we did someone was going to get caught. So we did our best possible move but it wouldn't matter.
Um, so he had moved and I think I've seen a lot of people house rule that as it damages people within 0ero to one because straight up eliminates that's not a fun that's not a fun uh mechanism. So all three of the core game uh killers just they're all over the place. And like I said, this game, you have to ask yourself, how long is too long before this the unbalanced nature before you can no longer do theater of the mind and you're now hyper aware you're playing an unbalanced board game is no longer fun. And then we go to the other systems of randomness that I started to have an issue with on both sides. So, I've had multiple games of this where people found keys like that and I've had people never find keys. Uh, the key system just I think ultimately is going to determine whether or not you're going to win as the survivors. If you can find the if all the keys happen to be at the top of the the deck. Oh, key. Yeah, it gives you a noise, but you're you're finding locate you're finding items all over the place, and the the killer still has to go out and find you. Even if you're making noise, it's hey, I made a noise in the main hall. Okay, well, he's not anywhere near it. So, who gives a [ __ ] that you made noise there? So, I've had games where
people found the keys immediately. Nothing the killer can do. Okay, you just now have to meet either in the main hall or hope that they don't have the uh the secret the the map and get out of the the hidden exit. But I've also been in games where the keys are at the [ __ ] bottom of the deck and there's nothing you can do because yeah, you can repair the radio, but then you have to survive five rounds before they even show up. it. Uh oh, and also the deck of discovery is your timer until the um the cops are on their way, then you can't lose that way. But it uh so the key system is very frustrating for both for both sides, honestly. If the keys aren't pulling for you as the survivors, okay, great. I guess we have to go make a [ __ ] ton of noise in the living room. or if they're showing up for the survivors as the killer, it's like, okay, well, I have no [ __ ] clue where anyone's at. And I here's here's the problem is I don't know of a way to fix any of that. Um, I think a lot of it is it kind of boils down to the fact that the survivors don't ever ever have to say when they're using items. The killer does. If I'm saying, "Hey, I'm using my revving chainsaw. I have to show my card and play it." The survivors don't have to do that. They can just say, "Oh, removed a barricade. Noise was placed over here." Not, "We used a glass bottle. We're using this." And yeah,
that would probably ruin the game, too, if they kept saying what items they had to use. Um cuz in all the other games of Hidden Movement, at least the ones that I still have in my collection, Leathers from White Chapel, um you as the game goes on, if the well, we're assuming that the investigators or the many are competent, uh they'll eventually ga gather your your clues and eventually hone in on an area on where your um where your hideout is. Uh because you at least from White Chapel, you always have to make it back to your hideout. And you also you do have ways to evade them, but you're limited on those. So if they can really box in the his hideout is here, number five, for example, and they have all the policemen surrounding it and you can't pass them, you're going to run out of time. Fury of Dracula has uh the investigators abilities. Uh Mina, for example, if she's in a location with another investigator, uh she can just, hey, this whole region, are you in here?
Uh and then but Dracula has abilities to be able to figure that uh you know, to weasle out of certain situations. So it uh this game just does not have enough ways for the killer to kind of pinpoint where they're at or certain killers. Like I said, the Wraith, who [ __ ] cares? I'll just fear you to death and you'll constantly be it's like a ping like, "Hey, ping. I'm here. I'm here. I'm here. Oh, you're feared and now you're injured. Cool. I know exactly where you're at. It's my turn still. I'm going to go find you." Um, and then the last bit of randomness that Terescape has is its dice. And it the dice I think are inherently bad design. Um cuz it just becomes extremely frustrating like in in the situation that that I was in whenever we lost as the survivors. Like I said, we he was all the way at level five, which takes a decent amount of time to shuffle through the the deck to be able to have them level up.
Um the cops were on their way. We had all five keys. We're all getting ready to go out the main exit. and he goes to the main exit and does an encounter. One person passes the uh the check and the other person I think it was he did an attack card that his strength was by plus one and I think it was I had a sword that gives you plus three to your defense and rolled two blanks cuz we it was we were feared but two blanks nothing to be done about that. So the dice and it's like, okay, well, you're level five. I get it. That's kind of the timer of the game, but it it gets real frustrating when you've played for an hour and a half eluding the killer the entire time. I don't think there was a single maybe there was like one or two encounters that we had that entire game, but for the most part, he just had no clue where we were at or how we were moving. We evaded his death blossom multiple times. uh had the cops and the keys. Everything was in our favor. One turn away and oh, rolled blanks. Okay. I don't know anyone who would be like, "Oh, wow. That was so much fun." There's no way. Again, that's because we played for an hour and a half.
And it's just so frustrating. And I've seen this game happen where even against the wraith whose whole point is to fear you and and then potentially go and attack you. And for all for all intents and purposes, you should not lose to a two strength uh killer. And even with two dice, I'm going to roll and blanks. Okay, we just lost. That That's not satisfying. That's not anti that's just completely antilimactic in I mean if you were watching a slasher film and the final girl or or the final person was trying to get away and it was just like oh the okay and then credits you know like it'd be like what the [ __ ] just happened it it just always leaves a sour taste in the mouth of anyone who's dying because of die rolls.
Um, so yeah, I think and I know in Terescape 2 they have done they have a third way that the killer and the um that the survivors can win. It's like an allout. We're going to try and gather info on the killer, which is a risk to do, but if it pays off now we have an an advantage against him and they can try and work together to try and go kill the killer. And if they succeed, they win. And if they fail, they lose. And I think the biggest issue with the dice in this one is there's zero mitigation. There's no it's an all or nothing system. And that just feels incredibly archaic. Uh any game nowadays that it that has dice has to have some way to mitigate it. [snorts] Unless it's a 30 minute game, which this game definitely can be. It could be a 30-minute game. It could be an hour and a half long game. And the games of this that I've played where it is the most fun has been right in that middle at about an hour, win or lose, it has a solid sweet spot. Um, but if it goes over that hour, then the charm of the game wears off. It's not fun for the killer who can't [ __ ] find anyone because then he's scrambling. And that's the problem with hidden movement games is that if you just can't find the per the people that are hidden in your scrambling, it's just not a fun system.
So there's a balance that happens that does happen in this game for sure. And that's whenever this game sings is when there's that cat and mouse of, okay, I think I know where they're at. I know what I'm doing. But in every game but this one, there is information that the killer can gleam uh can gleam from it. Uh yeah, so it's I don't know. It is this game is still a lot of fun and I do like it. I just think that potentially they tried to fix all their issues with their expansions and the core game stuff, the core game characters and the core game killers are kind of all over the [ __ ] place. And that leaves a pretty unsatisfying taste in a lot of people's mouths whenever they're playing this one.
Um, like I said, it's still fun, but I think now after all the plays of this, the the cracks have definitely started to to show, and I don't know if Terescape 2, of which I backed everything for. I don't know cuz I I mean they're not rebalancing the game. So, I don't know if it's been rectified or if this is just one of those games that you don't play all the time or Yeah, I don't know cuz I would now I'm hesitant to play it on the off chance that it's going to take forever. Um cuz then it's just not it's not fun on on either side. So yeah, it it is interesting of the way that this game has kind of morphed into something that I was thinking, man, this might be my favorite hidden movement game to it just doesn't quite hit, you know, as as it once did.
So it uh yeah, I don't know how you fix it. I don't know how you fix the keys, the key system. Uh, the dice system could be fixed with any sense of mitigation of of trying to get a roll out of it, giving yourself I don't know what you would what you could do to counteract it. Cuz if you always got to roll the dice, then the killer would never get to damage them outside of, you know, their level five abilities or a death blossom card that can just auto wipe someone. So you it'd have to be in some way that you couldn't constantly mitigate the die rolls, but you could you need some way to be able to do so because a a a die roll during an encounter coming up blank is it's just not fun. It's even not even satisfying for the killer. Uh because you could see the frustration in the other player's face of oh wow blanks okay damaged. Yay.
Yeah, it uh it it is unfortunate. And then yeah, with the killers or not the killers, the survivors that players pick, it it could be demoralizing to see who they picked and it's like great. I mean, to be fair, there is a cool element that I discovered whenever I was last playing this in that depending on the killer you're facing, you're going to prioritize certain items more. And that's a cool thing. Now, the problem is the discovery deck is the same deck every single time. But it I mean against the butcher, you're going to prioritize the hatchet. Against the murderer, you're probably going to prioritize um adrenaline because that lets you move faster as an extra action so you can evade his death blossom. And against the siren, you're probably going to uh prioritize what is it? Pills? I can't remember the item, but the one that wipes your fear away. So that is a cool element. And again, I do really love the fact that all the killers and locations and maps can be mixed and matched because you will get a different scenario. You can take the butcher and put him in the science lab and the way he's going to play and the way that the survivors are going to play are going to be different because those actually have unique rules. It's really neat. A lot of the main issues that I have actually come to see, funny enough, do come with the core stuff.
Uh so yeah, it it is unfortunate. We'll see how Terrorcape 2 if it if it changes anything at all besides the fact that now there's a way to try and kill the killer to win. Uh but but yeah, it it has definitely softened on on me. So, on a scale of 1 to 10, I'm going to give Terascape. Originally, I had it as a nine. I had this ranked, it was ready to go. Um, and after having played it more, um, and seeing the the issues with it, [sighs] you know, it's funny. Yeah. losing in the way that that I did with just rolling blanks.
That definitely I mean that was that was a a ways back. And even thinking about that still is [ __ ] annoying cuz normally it's okay. Yeah, whatever. That was [ __ ] that was obnoxious. And then you move on. You play something else or you move on with life. And just even thinking about losing that way still is frustrating. Uh, so originally I was going to bump this down to an eight, but I think as I'm doing this discussion, I think the issues that I have with, again, I haven't tried every single killer. Maybe it literally is just the unbalance of the core uh the core box and all the expansion stuff is a lot more fine-tuned. I don't know yet.
Um, but even then, let's say someone goes in the comments and says, "Oh, all the expansions, the killers are more balanced. They're not as OP, and the survivors aren't as OP, the maps aren't as OP, whatever it might be." That would still mean that there are there's a chunk of the game that is your core system that is unbalanced and virt, you know, virtually unusable. And if you do use it, you have to go in with a grain of salt and just know it's going to be a [ __ ] [ __ ] show. So I think I man but there is something about this one. Again I love the fact that the the killer is hidden but stealth is I mean some some characters don't have stealth and stealth is huge because that gives you an element of hidden movement. Um I think I'm going to go with a 7.5.
I was thinking a seven, but this game still is a lot of fun. Uh, you just have to go in knowing that it's kind of a complete random cluster [ __ ] Uh, but it is unfortunate that the the the nine I gave it has not held up um over the course of time. But I also do know that Terescape 2 stuff is compatible with this. So that just increases the the customization even more. And who knows, let me I mean in the comments, let me know if you guys have found a way to try and balance out some of these uh like characters like the butcher or Anna or the doctor or uh dice mitigation. I would love to know.
This g this is a game that I would actually kind of homebrew. Uh because it is a simple game to learn and to teach and it is a lot of fun. Uh but if there's ways to kind of fix it, then I would love to do so. Anyway, that's it. That's my thoughts on Terrorcape. Let me know what you think of the game in the comments below. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe, and have a wonderful whatever the time of day it is for you.