Skip to main content
Loading video...

Attack on Titan: Deckbuilding Game - Discussion

Transcript 18:28

Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised.

Hey everyone, welcome back to Board Games online and today I'm doing a discussion over the Attack on Titan deck building game for season 1. Now, this is actually kind of an interesting game mainly because uh I thought like I was getting ads for this game and I thought it came out this year. Well, I mean I technically it did but apparently this is a re-implementation of the same deck building game that came out 10 years ago. Um cuz I had to look up some forums. I'm like, "What do you mean this is why am I getting ads from a 10-year-old game?" Well, from what I was reading in the forums that this is a much better version of that game although I don't know the specifics of what they did in that old game cuz this is not a game I normally would ever entertain. IP driven games just don't really tend to do it for me for a lot of of reasons mainly because I don't know. I I [clears throat] don't know. I I just it always feels like a cash grab.

Well, I ended up picking up this game because A Attack on Titan is my girlfriend's favorite anime and B I have just recently finished the entire animated series because um my girlfriend and we're going to go see a live orchestra perform the soundtrack. So I was like, "Well, I should probably know what the show is about." And I'd only ever seen season 1 funny enough and then I binge watched all the other seasons and yeah, it's it's I mean I don't know if it would be in my top 10 but I could imagine it might be. All that being said, how does it work as a deck building game? And I would say pretty well. I actually thought this was surprisingly good.

Again, I don't know what they had in the original game, but in this one it does a pretty solid job. Now, capturing season 1 is purely in theme alone. None of the mechanics of the game I don't know how they would ever implement that. And it also seems to bode that they're going to make seasons 2, 3, and 4, which again I would just imagine is going to be based off of the theming and what you're seeing in the art. And but it would be cool if they did kind kind of a what was it again? The Hogwarts not Legacy Hogwarts Battle for Hogwarts Harry Potter the Harry Potter deck-building game where you went through each of the books.

And the characters' abilities kind of got improved over that. It'd be cool if they did something like that here. But I think that this one was surprisingly solid. It has some pacing issues, but it overall works. It's it's different in how it utilizes its market. So, you know in a lot of deck-building games there's a market that you can buy cards from and then you play your cards and so on and so forth. Sometimes you are fighting enemies, other times you are just straight deck-building. The way that Attack on Titan does it is you have these five districts, which again they're just these these wall tokens. And over at the beginning of the every round you will bring in new stuff from the castle, which is your deck. And it goes off of which district has the least amount of cards. And sometimes I'll bring titans out. Most of the time it's going to be bringing out cards that you can buy.

But you kind of will seed where those cards are going to be coming in cuz I like I said, it goes to the the district that has the least amount of cards. So, if you have a bunch of players in one district that has the least amount of cards, chances are a titan might show up. And those titans have ambush abilities that you will affect all the all the players in that district. Uh but, that's also going to be if if you're just getting overwhelmed in a certain area, you can kind of start buying cards for another location, and just, you know, start making making cards go to that district. Uh I guess thematically that kind of works if you're making it to where all the heroes are congregating in one area, well, that's where titans are going to show up. I think that's really cool. I should also preface this as I can't imagine anyone who is watching this video is not an Attack on Titan fan.

Uh otherwise, what would be the point of buying the game unless you just really like deck builders. But, I think that the way that the market uh comes in is pretty unique and different from a lot of other games that I've seen. However, this is kind of a double-edged sword because of the way that the board works out. So, the the districts separate one half. It's uh there's the inside the castle, then outside the castle, where outside is where all the enemies show up. Uh but, because you don't have enough power to just constantly be buying cards, mechanically, there are certain districts that just get flooded with cards, and it's just awkward. It reminds me of the way Seven Wonders used to do stuff, where you had to splay cards out diagonally. I guess you don't have to, you could just put them where you see the titles, but the problem with that is is you don't see the abilities of the cards, and you don't see the power cost of the cards. So, you kind of are it organizing in such a way that again, it's going at a splay diagonal that starts to bleed into other districts.

So, it's just very a little fiddly. I guess what you could do is you could You don't have to have the districts touching each other. You could have some space in between them. And that would work probably perfectly fine. Uh but then again, you're just making arbitrary large table space uh just to accommodate the weird market seating or district seating. Uh so, I mean, that was my only main issue with that. I actually liked the way that the uh again, that the way the Titan showed up. But that also kind of goes into the pacing issue. Where there would be times where you would just have uh you know, Titans a bunch of Titans show up and you can't really do anything about them because you don't have the power to kill them.

And this is I mean, luckily early on in the game, they don't show up a whole lot. But that was kind of an issue where you don't because the way your opening deck is is you have you have courage and thrust. You have your currency and you have your movement. Cuz in this game, you can actually move around from inside the castle from district to district. Um that it it it it definitely had some moments of lulls where okay, we have a bunch of power, but we have no Titans to kill. And so, I guess we'll just go buy cards. And then, oh, cool. Now, we have a bunch bunch of Titans to kill, but we now we don't have any power. So, we can't really do anything. Cuz while moving from district to district is crucial and cool, sometimes you just either don't have the movement.

You have all the power in the world, but you for some reason just can't move one district or one one space. Or you have all the movement, but you only really need to move one space. So, it does kind of create this weird element of I mean, why can't I just naturally move somewhere I if I don't have the movement. I I don't know. I mean, I guess I had to have some way of implementing the 3D gear system and I mean, luckily that is almost readily available every time. That's the only card in the market that is readily available. And chances are you're going to have the two power to buy it. And then comes the the wall system. So, every district has these wall tokens that represent the health and Titans will do a certain amount of damage to the wall.

I almost immediately it feels like you could just have sections of the wall like the districts get destroyed. So, you're incentivized to run to a location if you can and you take wounds. So, you your heroes they don't have health or anything, but they can take wound cards that prevent damage to the walls and you're that's kind of your innate way of defending. And the wounds don't necessarily do a whole lot except that if you play one and you happen to gain another one, then your character dies. And luckily that's not it's not player elimination or anything. You just had grab a new character, but you and it depending on the the number of players, you can only have so many characters die before you lose.

I don't necessarily hate this system. I just don't really it's just kind of odd. The wound system ended up being relatively simple to work around which I guess is nice because there's a lot of ambush cards that just give you a wound unless you can fulfill a gain a wound unless you can get rid of an equipment. Oh, I don't have an equipment so I gain a wound. So, things like that. It it's fine. I guess they had to throw in some way of how characters can can die in this, but yeah. So, that's that's kind of that's that's the weird balance of this game. I guess when you're trying to be unique and different from other just deck builders, cuz I appreciate the fact that they have the wall. It it definitely feels like season 1.

And I'm glad they went this route instead of just a standard deck builder that happens to have Attack on Titan arts. And with Cryptozoic being the ones that make this game, that almost feels like a lot of their games is that it's the same game just with a different screen grab on them. And they also have their way of being able to implement this into all their other games, which would just be weird. I don't know anyone who would have fun doing that, but maybe there are those people. So, then you go to the way you actually win. And that's through the Arch-Enemy Titans, the bigger named ones. And in this season 1, they have your standard ones that you get. You have the Armor Titan, the Colossal Titan, uh the Female Titan, and then uh there's a few others like that aren't the the big three in the uh you know, in basically the whole show.

Um The Arch-Enemy Titans, I think are actually really cool. They I like that they're kind of a pseudo mini boss throughout the course of the game. And they're uh uh seated throughout the castle deck, similar to the way the Pandemic the epidemic cards are in Pandemic, except not random. Uh you basically, when you're shuffling the entire castle deck, you break it up into four 20 uh card stacks, and then you put the Arch-Enemy three on the top of one, the Arch-Enemy two on top of the other, and the Arch-Enemy one on the third one, so that every 20 cards, you're going to have an enemy titan an Arch-Enemy Titan show up. I like this system. It feels that you have enough time between Arch Enemy Titans and you can kind of guess when they're going to show up.

Uh so, I like that. And the Arch Enemy Titans, they have a pretty interesting way of defeating them because they actually have health and and a power system. So, when you're killing regular Titans, they have a power system or power cost just like the cards that you buy, except you use power to kill them. The Arch Enemy Titans have uh health that you have to completely remove, and then they you use power to try and do a final blow. But, they do another neat little twist in that there's this Titans on Attack deck. And um these are kind of the unpredictable nature of these Titans that could increase their power cost or cause an effect that you have to do uh when trying to kill them.

And I I kind of like that system. I like the fact that they have health, so you have to go and and whoop on them a little bit before you can try to to kill them. Uh but, they also will regenerate a certain amount of health depending on number of players and depending on the effects of the Titans. But, they also will start destroying the walls. And what's cool about destroying the section the different districts, A, cards aren't going to go there anymore. And B, that's going to start pushing the Titans towards the castle. And when Titans uh are completely attacking the castle if they're in District 1, they might just start eating cards from the top of the deck, and you lose when the castle deck runs out. So, I think that that's a pretty neat system, too, of the Titans are devouring, so they're removing your options of cards to buy.

And the only a kind of slightly annoying thing about the healing system of the Arch Enemy Titans is that if you So, if you just don't have an absorbent amount of power to outright kill them, they since they regenerate you always have to almost do the amount of players plus the power uh to kill them every time you're trying to kill them because unless one of the players can come in and get their get their health down to zero and then the other player or players can come in and then try and finish them off in that same turn the next round you're going to have to do a little bit uh just a little bit more damage to be able to kill them. But I thought that the the health pool and the power system was scaled really well. It it never felt that whenever we were coming into an Arch Enemy Titan that we were so under leveled.

Um so yeah, I think the Arch Enemy Titans is a really cool little system there. And they have a decent variety. They also have a decent variety of characters. I think the characters are okay power-wise. They work and they have a a system around them like Levi needs if you play two or more maneuvers you get plus two power. It feels like a lot of the characters have that where oh if you play two or more allies, if you play two or more equipment do that. But I don't know. I like the card effects. I thought that they worked. Uh they weren't the most you know, exciting uh cards you could buy but they had they seated enough in there that were really high cost cards that were were really good to have. You could get a synergy of deck building going.

So overall, yeah, I'm I'm pleasantly surprised with how this this game uh ended up being. So and it also helps that you could just listen to the Attack on Titan soundtrack and it's going to be amazing. But uh oh and one other thing I thought was kind of a cool element is instead of cards you could just purchase they had locations that could come out that had that went on the districts and they had special abilities you could use when you went there. I thought that was a cool little element. So, yeah. I mean, if you're a fan of Attack on Titan, I think this game is going to do wonders for you. Hell, even if you're a fan of deck building, it does a pretty good job. It's standard deck building rules. You play your entire hand out. Um, shuffle when you clean up your your shitty cards to get the good ones out. But, I think that even though there were some pacing issues of the way your decks can come out so where you have a bunch of power because I've had plenty of instances where I killed the Titan and I was on the outside of the wall. My next hand had a ton of power and there was no Titans to kill and I couldn't even move to go spend that power. So, you just can have dead turns, which kind of sucks.

But, the game works relatively quickly. So, it's like, "Okay, yeah. You know, that was amazing hand, but whatever." It still works. Uh, so, I I I am excited to see what they do for seasons 2, 3, and and 4. Uh, I imagine call me crazy. I have a feeling it's just going to be the Titans from those seasons, which actually wouldn't really be that versatile. Um, they I mean, I can think of some that they would add, but that the heroes they might add a little bit more heroes, but I just hope that they kind of I I basically I I I wouldn't hate the same game. Just more complex. Okay, we're in season 4. Things have gotten pretty crazy at this point. Here's the final enemies. Here's the final boss. I mean, well, in that case we would know who the final boss is, but I don't want to spoil this for anyone who hasn't watched Attack on Titan.

Uh, but but now we have really badass powers or something and the cards are crazy. I think season 1 this is good foundation. I would like to see them get more involved in creative as the seasons go on, but only time will tell. Yeah, pleasantly surprised. On a scale of 1 to 10, I'm going to give the Attack on Titan deck-building game a 7. I think this is good. I will be keeping it in my collection cuz again, it's quick to just bring out to the table and has enough variety to play. I don't think this game would have the legs to as of right now to just keep playing all the time, but that's most base game deck builders. But I could see this being once all the seasons are out having just an really fun Attack on Titan just kind of gauntlet of playing through all the seasons.

That would be really neat. Hell, it'd be kind of cool if they Well, no, then I'm wrong. I was going to say it's kind of cool if they could carry characters from one game to the next, but that's just what they're naturally going to do. And yeah, so that's it. That's my thoughts on the Attack on Titan deck-building game. Let me know what you think of the game in the comments below. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you.

Progress saved