Schadenfreude Review: Gone in 41 Seconds
Transcript
Hey there everybody. I'm Mike Delisio.
I'm Chris Yee.
And today we're going to be taking a look at Schotten Totten. This is a trick-taking game that had been originally released in a smaller print run from Studio Turbine and now Office Dog has done this new fancier edition of the game.
The designer goes by the pen name the pseudonym CTR and the artist goes by the name Weberson Santiago.
Yes.
Fantastic artist that I love a lot of the stuff he does. So
They have the name of the designer here, too.
Oh, okay. Yeah, and on BoardGameGeek it's CTR. It's
Yoshiharu Nakahara.
Yes.
So I had only seen CTR. This is the first time I saw the name in the rulebook. So
Choose the right.
Yes. Trick-taking game with a couple of little hooks that I'll be happy to show you in this overview and then we will come back and let you know what we think. Here we see Schotten Totten set up for a five-player game and you'll see the distribution of the cards and this will change depending on upon player count, but in a four-and five-player game you'll see that there are four suits that have this distribution of numbers. Obviously, you can see there are negative numbers in there with the mostly positive numbers and then in the whole deck there are two of these jester cards. One with a value of zero, one with a value of 10 and they count as a wild card. They will be the card of whatever the lead color is when they're played. You're never forced to play a jester card and if you lead with a jester card, the next player will determine what the lead suit is. So in a must-follow trick-taking game, the first player can play a card of any suit that they want, any value they want into the trick. The following players in a clockwise order will have to follow the lead suit if they are able. If they do not have any cards of the lead suit, then they can play any card they want.
So, let's say that this is the first player. They lead out with a red seven. All the other players must follow with a red card if they have one. Let's play that say this player uh follows with a red two. This player doesn't have any red, so they follow with a red negative or blue negative three. This player plays with a red six. Now, one of the big hooks in Schadenfreude, 1 2 3 4, oops, sorry. This player comes in oh, with a negative two red. Okay. Um one of the hooks of Schadenfreude is that unlike most trick-taking games where the highest card of the lead suit will win, in this game, the second highest card of the lead suit will win. So, in this case, the yellow player who played the red six has the second highest card of the lead suit, which was red, so they're going to win the trick.
When you win a trick, you'll take the card that you won with and put it in your scoring pile. Also, any cards that were off suit will also come into your scoring pile. So, in this case, the yellow player took this six and this negative three. The remaining cards would be discarded. Now, the winner of the trick will lead out the next trick, so that would be the yellow player. Let's say that they lead out this green five. Following players, if they have a green card, must play them. They play a green one. The blue player doesn't have any green. They play this yellow negative two. Green player plays a red five. Purple player plays a red nine. So, in this case, the lead suit was green, the second highest card of the lead suit was is the winner, and that is yellow again.
So, in this case, they will take this green five, and they will take any other cards off suit. Well, in that case, that is this five and this negative two. The second big hook in Schadenfreude is that if you have any duplicate cards in your scoring area, either when you win the trick or at a later point, those get discarded. So, these fives go away and now they're left with the six, the negative three, and the negative two in their scoring pile. So, those are the two big hooks is that the second highest card of the lead suit wins and you're going to be collecting these cards that you're going to be scoring points on on this point tracker, but any duplicate values will get wiped out. You'll never be able to have more than one of each value in your score pile. I mentioned the Jokers before and I said that if a player were to lead with a Joker, then the following players in clockwise order would set the lead suit. So, in this case, blue would technically be the lead suit and this would be a zero of blue. All right?
That's the general idea. After all the tricks have been played out, that ends the round and players are going to tally up the score that they have in their scoring piles and move up the tracker accordingly. Say it's something like this and this player actually never won any. You're going to continue to play, reshuffling, and redealing until one player goes over this 40. So, maybe this player had one and had enough in their score pile, they went over 40 40, they perish, they fell off of the tower into the crocodile-infested waters down here. This player is ineligible to win the game and then what you do is you determine who is the closest to 40 without going off the tower. In this case, that would be pink. They would be the winner. Now, what happens in a situation like this where you've got a tie for the lead. In that case, both of these players cancel out and the second highest would win. In this situation, orange would win. That's the general idea of Schadenfreude. Let's head back and talk thoughts.
All right, so as I mentioned earlier, this is a re-implementation of a game that was you know, smaller print run game and a perfectly nice game, but wow, this new production, my goodness.
And when you say re-implementation, there's no I don't think there's any changes. If anyone's played the previous version.
Yeah, I don't think they changed any of the rules to the game.
Yeah, but the so, the box is about twice as big as it was in the previous printing, which a lot of times when you take a tiny little card game and you blow it up, I sit there and think, well, it would be so nice if it still the small box size. But, I think that this board is way more functional. I think that the original used a few cards as like the score track.
Correct, yeah.
So, nice big score track, way easier to use. And a lot of people haven't played the original, so I don't really need to keep comparing it.
Yeah.
But, no, I think that this looks great. It displays some of Webern's artwork
Yes.
on that score track very well. And it also visually I think has this great touch where it explains the end game condition very well.
Yeah. And it adds some visual drama. You know, you're going up this tower and if you go over 40 points, down you go into the crocodile infested waters. So, yeah, beautiful production, incredible artwork as always by Webern Santiago and nice wooden pieces that you know, again, they add a nice more luxurious feel without going crazy with the box size. It's it's a kind of a non-standard box size, so you have that, but I like this production a lot.
It's the office dog trick taking box size of the Lord of the Rings trick takers and stuff. So, I don't I'm fine if they continue to do it cuz it still fits well on shelves, portable well and everything.
Yes.
So, yeah, production, no notes, no further notes, fantastic.
Fantastic. And I've done a several lists and such regarding trick taking games on this channel, and I have mentioned Schotten Totten many times. It's been on top 10 lists of mine over the years. It is in my top 10 trick-taking games of all time. And now you're taking a game I love, absolutely love, and have shown people over the years, but always felt slightly bad because it was not easy to get a hold of it. And now you're taking that game, improving the production, and making it more accessible to a larger group, which I think is very good because I think this game will appeal to a wide group of people. I I'm thrilled that this edition exists.
Well, cuz gameplay-wise, it's pretty simple. You explain the second highest is best. And that's kind of the the overriding principle in in all regards, right? With the end game scoring, with who's going to win each trick and everything. So, and I like that there's that little like continuity thread in explaining. Like, okay, so who wins? Player with the second most points.
Right.
That's great, right? Because it ties into how the card play works. Four-suit trick-taking game, very simple. Nice player aid because depending on the player count, the cards in play are a little different. And so, you can look right in front of you and say, "Okay, this version goes -1 or -3, 1, 2, etc."
Right, right, right. And that does change based on player count, but as you were saying, the player aid kind of accounts for that, shows you the card distribution no matter what player count you are playing. It also plays well at the different player counts. It's a slightly different experience at three than it is at five, but they're both compelling, they're both good. And that also is something that I think is an important factor to consider when you're talking about trick-taking games is that sometimes the experience is is markedly better or worse at a particular player count. I don't think that's the case here. I probably prefer playing it with five just because I want more people to potentially hose over, which is really one of the hallmarks of this game, and it's right there in the name. You can be very mean to each other, but it also is a very compelling game at three.
I I agree. I was pleasantly surprised. Now, there's this fun little tiebreaker element that isn't there in three players with four or five. If one person goes over the edge and two people are I have you know are tied for the second most points, they're skipped.
Yeah .
And it goes to the next person back. So, that's more likely to happen in a five-player game. Happens sometimes in a four-player. I've seen it. It's one of those funny rules that's not just like it's just there, but because everyone is chasing points, but not too many points,
Mhm.
people do end up tying in that 35 to 40 range.
Yes.
The incentives are are there. And so, instead of having this weirdly weird tiebreaker,
Yeah.
it just skips the ties and goes to the the you know further back person. I I and I think that plays into how funny and how much personality this game has.
Yes. Yeah, it it's one of those things where I say it's mean, but and it and it oftentimes is targeted, too. Like, and those usually are like really feel bad moments. For some reason, because of the tone of the game and you know that everybody is equally uh susceptible to getting that that just bad run. It could happen to anybody, but it's not arbitrary. That's another important thing to note is that it's not arbitrary, right? You're not going to usually get stuck with negative points just because of vagaries of how the card came down. No, you're getting negative points because people are sticking you with negative points and you're going to you're trying to do the exact thing to them. Um it doesn't lead to feel bad moments for me and I've played this game dozens of times, right?
There have been games where I've just done very poorly, but it's it's funny. I'm telling you there's just there's a spirit of humor to this. You know, black humor, but humor.
Dark humor. Just that Yeah, it's it's so funny because for a trick-taking game, which tend to be kind of you know cerebral or maybe even passive experience. You play red, guess I got to play a red card. Uh it it is amazing because the the incentives are aligned with the mechanisms
Mhm.
perfectly in this. When you play a card off suit, you're not just sloughing a card and it goes away into the ether.
Yeah.
It's going to the person who's winning the trick, the second highest card of the lead suit, which is great.
And so you're sitting there going, well, I'm going to feed him an eight. Which is so great. It's such a good ex-until they already have an eight in front of them and you say, well, actually I well, if they get two of the same number card, they go away, so I don't want to feed him an eight. I'm going to Well, my next highest is a five. I'll give him a five. And the next player goes, well, I was going to feed him a five. And now I don't want him to to not get those points either. And the fact that points are both a penalty, but also the goal of the game is just brilliant.
It is. And and I'm glad, cuz that was that was the next place I was going to go: is that even if it looks like you're in a very precarious position with the number of cards in front of you, you can also cleverly play in such a way that you know you're going to win a trick that cancels out one of yours, or you're very likely to.
Yeah.
Um just there there are so many compelling decisions without weird edge cases, s-hooks that are really meaningful, but not hard to internalize. It's just this game has so many things going for it. It does so many things right. And now a top-notch production to go with it.
Yeah, hands down.
Uh
I think one of the last things I I I want to say before we kind of close up thoughts here is that the game has this little sense of progression. It kind of has this little bit of an arc that's different for players depending on their standing on that tower.
Yes.
So, played a three-player game of it where at the end of the second round the scores were 36, 35, 34. So, the three of us are looking at each other going, okay, so are we going to try are people going to try to be avoiding points and just shoving one person off? And so now I'm at 35. I think I'll try to get to 39 and stay right on the edge without falling off, but also brilliantly, if everyone falls off the tower, then the winner is the player who gets the most points.
Right.
And it turns that incentives on it all of a sudden on its head. Instead of sticking other people, you're like, well, I would like to get the points cuz I'm sure all of us are falling off the tower now.
Right. Right. Right.
And it feels perfectly in line with the game instead of like a "Oops, what do we do now?" staple on an extra rule.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Um I'll go into final thoughts uh cuz I think, you know, we we both clearly uh like the game a lot. Um this before, in the original edition, was a game I really, really loved, and I I'm going to have to give it a slightly higher rating because this this production is incredible, and more people can get a hold of it. That's great. It doesn't affect my rating. I'm just happy about that. I'm giving it a nine. I I It's one of my favorite trick-taking games. Um made even better with a lovely production that's not so over the top that, you know, you're you're paying you know, 50, 60 dollars for a trick-taking game. Um a classic. I I really mean a classic trick-taking game. It's been out for may quite a few years.
Eight, nine years, I think, right?
Um and it still feels both classic and fresh at the same time. I do think that it's probably well, not probably it is a little more complex than, you know, like your your entry-level trick-taking games; but it's not so out there and wacky and cerebral that you couldn't play this with people that have played a couple of trick-taking games in their lifetime. It does everything right. Nine for me. Um yeah, I'm just so happy more people are going to get a chance to play this.
I'm going to preface this. So, this was not We recently did our top 10 trick-taking games list, and this one was like number 11. It didn't quite make my top 10, and I was very happy when you mentioned it. Having played this a lot more now since we've been able to play this new edition of it, this is comfortably in my top 10. This is so good. I'm also giving this one a 9 out of 10 because the tension and the excitement that you get from getting a lot of points, but not too many. Oh, no, I got a few more than I thought I was going to. I can save it. You constantly have that feeling of I can fix it. I can work with this. It gives you the control to be able to to overcome the fact that people are, as you said, kind of hunting for you. And so, mix that with the fact that it's gorgeous, mix that with the fact that I've been able to play it so much, and it's smooth. I love trick-taking games that have wrinkles to them, and sometimes that's in the form of like when you play this card, there's a special ability you have to remember, remember to split the None of that. It's just pure incentives mixed with simple mechanisms that come together and and it lives up to its name, Schadenfreude. When you stick someone with eight points and you just laugh at them as they plunge off the tower, man, that that theme comes to life. The the or the the name of it, the whole idea of it, it's there, as you said. So, yeah, 9 out of 10. I love this one.
All right. Well, I think Chris and I have made our point abundantly clear. This is one of the best trick-taking games on the market right now, and we both think you should check it out. Beautiful production, as well. I'm Mike.
And I'm Chris.
And uh have fun sticking it to your friends.
Excellent.
Hey, everybody. Thanks for watching this video. If you liked this review or whatever you just watched, wasn't it amazing? Uh check out our channel, Dice Tower. Uh we have all kinds of things. We review games, we do top 10s, we play games live. It's all about board games, but especially the people who play them. Check out Dice Tower YouTube channel.