Between Two Castles of Mad King Ludwig: Secrets & Soirees Expansion Review
Transcript
opulence granger secret passageways that lead from kitten rooms all the way to pits of despair that is what between two castles has always been about and it helps that it's a damn good tile placement game too which honestly i think is better than either of its respective parents and now we have secrets and soirees an expansion that includes a whole bunch of new doodads to add to your castley goodness and blessedly introduces new solo modes so let's take a look first and foremost this expansion introduces some new hardware to the mix most important of which are the two new basic room types in the box secret rooms become doppelgangers of the room they're pointing to copying the room type scoring effect and even the special little torchy sortie wall hanging symbol making for some really interesting and creative plays not least of which is that they can be used to make copies of copies of copies or for obtaining third and fifth room bonuses for the room type they become activity rooms on the other hand scored points for all tiles adjacent unless a specific type of room is anywhere surrounding it rendering the activity room to just one point after all it's just cruel to put a food room right next to a climbing room how you gonna get your workout done and of course the activity rooms have to come with a bonus for getting three so the game introduces ballrooms a special room type that scores points for specific room types in neighboring castles which can lead to some tricky opportunities in a drafting game
especially when you have a hand in building one of those neighboring castles these new rooms are just another layer on the cake that is this game new puzzles and possibilities that also make for some great whimsical thematic connotations as you explain how visitors navigate your precious little castle that said shuffling in a whopping 61 tiles into the existing set is no joke extravagance and being super extra does come at a certain cost and yeah that's 61 new tiles because on top of the secret rooms and activity rooms there are supplemental rooms of the original type that key off the new rooms the utility bonus cards in a throne room and even another castle allowing play for up to eight players fortunately to house it all the expansion totes another beautiful insert which fits magically in the original box ensuring everything is safe and snug but hardware isn't enough this expansion includes a new multiplayer variant and two solo modes the multiplayer variant allows you to skip well more or less exactly the thing that makes this game so unique in the first place participating in the building of two neighboring castle tiles nope in this you are in charge of one and only one castle but the hitches you still pick two tiles at a time putting one in your castle and inflicting the other upon your neighbor for the most part i'm not the biggest fan i love the tension and collaboration of this game as originally designed but i think this mode is great for two-player as an alternative to the dummy castle making this a bit more of a head-to-head
duel and in the end more options more better but solo solo is great yes it's a table hog yes it's pretty cerebral but it does facilitate the best parts of the game while changing up your thought process quite a bit in the basic and my favorite of the solo variants you build a castle with two automated opponents drafting out of a face-up hand of tiles on each of their turns you signal to the automa what you think would be best to the remaining tiles for your shared castle then flip the priority card which will evaluate which of those tiles they'll take to the ottoma's shared castle and which of the signal tiles you'll get to place then on your turn you just draft one for each of your shared castles eventually working her way through the numerous hands the autumna's shared castle is scored uniquely based purely on room types and amounts of acquisition numbers and you score your shared castles as normal it's challenging smart as a whip plays in under an hour and the design shows creativity and cleverness of all involved the also quite good but simpler and more rudimentary introvert variant mode has you managing one castle against an automated opponent which similarly prioritizes acquisitions out of a smaller handed tiles really it just becomes a basic two-player drafting game of who can build the better thing which is fun and puzzly but i prefer the elaborate and closer to the spirit of the original multiplayer game basic solo variant so to put it simply secrets and soirees is one of my
favorite expansions to come from stonemaier in a while it adds more of the best parts of an under-recognized game in their catalog and it also introduces a bunch of new ways to play even extending the player count all the way from solo to a big fat whopping eight players and yes it's a lot of tiles and no it's not like the base game was exactly lacking for content except for a solo mode in which case this is a pretty big deal but it capitalizes on the puzzly and thematic aspects that make the game so fun and serves them up in a way that feels right at home in the base game box so i'm betting that if you like between two castles mag king ludwig there's no way you're not gonna like secrets and soirees and that's our review thank you so much for watching i've been jack for the cardboard herald if you enjoyed this video we have all kinds of other reviews interviews and recommendations via writing podcasts and video here on our channel and website cardboardherald.com our content is audience supported so if you want to show your support please visit our patreon thank you so much for watching this has been the cardboard herald