Calico Review - Brutal Cat Carcassone
Transcript
cats we love them they hate us as a cat owner myself i know exactly what they like being dressed up in various costumes but the designer of calico kevin russ would have us believe that they love quilts as well and that making a quilt for your feline would be a fun thing to do i was willing to have a nice pleasant time with cats never has there ever been a board game that made me think you know what f cats i'm never making a quilt for those ungrateful again they can sleep outside from now on like all the other parasitic animals when you open up calico you are immediately presented with a lie and i don't mean that in the hyperbolic sense i mean this game is straight up lying to you at first you're like oh cool chunky dual layer player boards let's analyze the visual language here bright colors pleasing patterns gorgeous illustrations by beth sobel tokens for buttons i mean have you ever seen anything anything more relaxed and chill of course the correct answer is yes any given sloth in a nature documentary but aside from that this is the next most relaxed and chill thing in the world except it isn't the objective of calico
is to build a quilt that will please not one not two but three cats which is a ridiculous number of cats to please one is already difficult enough i guess this should have tipped me off about the hardcore nature of this game each cat wants a matching set of patterns you'll compose out of hexagonal tiles on your player board tibbett is happy four tiles of the same pattern are next to each other but only if it's one of tibbett's two preferred patterns techalot wants four tiles of the same pattern but in a straight line and luna oh my god luna can gtf oh i am not doing that if you manage to arrange tiles according to the cat's whims then you will get a token which is kind of like a badge that says i'm okay with what you've done here human for the next week i won't hurt you also you score some points technically you don't have to get all three types of cat token you could just keep making lines of four earning endless adoration from tech a lot but that would leave you with two very upset cats and i'm sorry i'm just not doing that i value my life too much similarly there's buttons because if there's one cool thing about quilts is the seemingly random distribution of completely needless buttons anywho once you create an area of three tiles of the same color you get a button and place it on your
quilt each button is worth three points and is different based on what color spawned it and if you collect all of them you'll get a cool special rainbow button which is objectively the best button and the best color so obviously you have to do all of that as well at which point you might ask me but efka how do you get tiles and how do you place them oo well that part is simple at the start of the game you will get two tiles each time your turn comes along you can place any one of your two tiles anywhere on the quilt and then after you placed your tile you can take a new tile from a choice of three which you then immediately refill from the bag see simple what possible complexity what sheer devilry could you extract from such a basic gentle system let's do some quilt science there are exactly 25 spaces on this board to get the coveted rainbow button 18 of those 25 spaces are spoken for which does not leave you with a lot of wiggle room wiggle wiggle now consider that you also want cat tokens and that means filling spaces with patterns as well with each cat token requiring at least three and sometimes even five spaces on your quilt the good news here is that you can use the same tile for both buttons and cats and crucially the pre-printed tiles on the side of the board also count for
both cats and buttons which rounds this out as a clever yet not insurmountable puzzle and that's that yeah you wish enter design goals truly just the most punishing system devised by humans right in the center of the board right where you want the space to play around with patterns and colors loom free blocked spaces reducing your total allotment from 25 to 22 and also they impose on you more restrictions and even though those restrictions are not exactly mandatory much like a human to a cat you will bend to their will let's take a look at an example this is the aabb cc design goal if it is on your player board it either wants you to have three pairs of patterns so something like this could work all three pairs of colors just like in this example but if you manage to do the nearly impossible which is to have both free pairs of colors and three pairs of patterns on these six spaces surrounding this one tile you will score a bit more points and there's three of these design goals on your player board taking up 18 of the 22 available spaces are you beginning to see the problem the beauty of calico is that it doesn't force you to do
anything you could feasibly just lay tiles wherever you like you'll score zero points and you'll end up having a very nice time because you made your own patterns and you had fun except nobody wants to score zero points we want to score all of the points if there are points we want to score them and i'll let you in on a little secret it's impossible let me drop the pretense calico is genius it's a phenomenal game that manages to achieve the most with some of the simplest rules out there and despite it being a really challenging puzzle it still conforms to its aesthetic it's difficult but it's the welcoming kind of difficult so many times i've tried to achieve all three design goals scoring both colors and patterns and it just it never happened am i bitter no no no i'm i'm not bitter i just resent things a little bit at the start of each game i would sit down examine my goals examine my tiles and then i would start to formulate a plan okay this color it could go here and this pattern that could potentially go here and let's not forget i can only ever have a choice of two tiles and after i play one i must take another one from only a selection of free free tiles then in all likelihood i want nothing to do with if i've got a good
tile great i'll stick it in the middle and if it's a space where it's surrounding two design goals i have to be very careful about that because it will have to match colors and patterns for both and if i'm forced to take something that has no business being anywhere on my quilt i can shove it somewhere in the edges hopefully pleasing a cat or making a button as spaces dwindle the plan solidifies it takes concrete shape and ultimately will be my downfall because restriction breeds creativity switches to restriction just breeds more restriction until there's only like two spaces left and one wrong move could topple the entire thing it's beautiful it's also nonsense because this is nothing i made nothing here over the course of this discussion this is not going to score me any points keen observers might notice a fatal flaw in calico systems if there's only ever three tiles to choose from and the only circulation is players taking one tile a turn then eventually you'll end up with something that nobody wants elsewhere this would be called bad game design whereas here it's not a bug it's a feature calico wants to make you feel uncomfortable it's the opposite of a cozy quilt eventually you'll just end up having to take tiles you don't want need and can i have something else instead please this isn't useful and that's the trick calico aggressively shoves you lemons
and your ability to make lemonade is what tests your metal what's joyous is that everyone at the table is in the same lemon boat and sharing the game's frugality brings a sense of unity calico takeoffs so much that when it gives you feel elation even though the person it giveth to is not you although you do hate them just a little bit because calico didn't choose you and that's what i call a conflicted feeling for that reason i am particularly fond of the two-player less variance variant where there's only two copies of each possible tile in this bag if you see a tile you absolutely need the one that will make your plan work and another player snatches it i can't describe how crushing that feels you know there's only one of that tile left in the bag and it might not even come out so you wait and you anticipate and then you draw and you draw and you draw and then you look at your player board and oh you've already placed that tile somewhere else calico is a rare breed of fun it's light as a feather but with the gravity turned upside down it's a dichotomy of pleasure and crunch a promise that never manifests only for you to find out that that promise was there all along it's just great this video
is sponsored by skillshare the online learning community that offers thousands of classes on various subjects gardening cooking writing photography caring for cats even board game design skillshare is your opportunity to become a little bit better at almost anything so i've been editing with adobe premiere pro for seven years whenever i needed to i read a tutorial here and there i landed on the fly and i thought i was doing fine i was but trust me taking a structured course in something you might think you know well fills in so many gaps you never even knew you had i was genuinely astounded by how useful a course like advanced video editing with adobe premiere pro 2020 by jodi vanderpud was and now i can do stuff like this ooh spooky it's not spooky i've got more great news for you skillshare is less than ten dollars a month with an annual subscription and the first 000 of you to click the link in the description will get a trial of skillshare premium so you can start your creativity today all of our videos are powered by our patreon supporters if you'd like to join this wonderful selection of people you can find the link in the description and you'll get other perks like my ongoing series on my top 97 games to roll you out here's some chill footage of a cat lounging in the garden
do
you