Solo Thoughts | Mint Knight
Transcript
foreign hello everyone welcome I'm Robert and today I want to discuss mint night I got this on a crowd sale earlier this year and it sat on my shelf till yesterday when I just felt compelled to finally try it out I will admit that I pushed it off for a while because I was um uh well I had heard that the the game was a bit tough to learn from the rules uh that uh you know you had to juggle between Reddit and Board Game Geek and the designers YouTube videos to learn the game um but uh yesterday when I decided I wanted to try the game I checked the board game geek file section and I was thinking well maybe somebody compiled all the FAQ questions so that it was uh more clear right so that it would make the learning experience uh less painful uh and as it happens when I checked this is the solve file in war game gig it is a fan made rulebook and I really want to thank um this individual this user uh their name is Hubert okay so Hubert uh took it up on uh themselves to
compile the FAQ and make a big rulebook uh it will just write a standard page a size rulebook that takes into consideration FAQ all right and I this is what I used to learn the game I did not see the designers video uh I didn't I did I barely read the rules that are included in the game I most I mostly Jose Rina and then I reference them this is what the 10 includes it's uh these rules cards uh their tiny text but the information is there but there has been a lot of FAQ you know for clarification and it's been documented in a few different places so I was really thankful to find this document so I want to really once again I really want to shout out this fella right here for making this file it made The Learning Experience uh relatively painless even as an experience uh Mage Knight player it still took me a bit to rub my head around this I have played three games so far I've lost two of them the first one I lost this last one is the end state of the This is the End support state of that third game which I lost so I won my second game but so now I I'll mention this though
um yes yesterday which is where when I started playing this game at around noon my after my afternoon my evening completely just disappeared because I got so immersed playing this game um it it does an exceptional job in um compartmentalizing the night experience into this 10 and it is just remarkable uh how how it utilizes the How it Go gets around the component limitation to try to fit the experiencing here just exceptionally exceptionally well made I completely got immersed and like four hours went by for those first two games to be fair uh a lot of that time was also wrangling with the rules uh but once we get the hang of it uh it's it's just it's just uncanny it and maybe some of you have seen my dragons of edges etching Stone um video I will make a comparison of these the tomb as far as Masonite adaptations go but um I'll more on that later but I do want to mention that in that video I brought up the fact that I I it felt like uncanny how when I learned the game like I could not believe what I was experiencing when wow I'm like playing Mason in my hand with a handful of
course I was at puzzle I I pretty much have the same experience here um is the the puzzle this is just it's just a feat that um the the designer was able to uh that the designer was able to fit that experience with these components in that box so I I want to elaborate more more of it on the uh the rules because that really is my only negative honestly I think this is an exceptional game I'll elaborate a bit more on that but as far as the rules that that really is my only negative uh even as an experienced uh Mage Knight player um there are a few things that felt a bit vague even with the fan made rules um I uh because um uh there there's a couple things that make sense like if you've played Mage Knight but even from like I'm trying to like put myself on in the shoes of what if someone who hasn't played Manish Knight plays this I think they definitely would have a bit of a hard uh difficult difficult time understanding the concepts but as I imagine I player I can definitely say that it helped uh a lot of it is the compromises as far as the components you know fundamentally change uh the rules because you know there's not the same amount of components so you kind of have to wrap your head around how the designer made changes to um made changes to adjust the game for this
scale but um that that really is my only negative the the learning it wasn't the most fun even as an experience I made a night player uh but once you do it just clicks uh it's it's great and uh the designer has a full playthrough that you can go through uh see how it plays and uh the designer is very active in answering questions on the board game geek page okay so that really is my only negative now um the let's mention the components on the art the art is not the selling point it's very um you know it gets the job done it's clear um the the only uh as far well the only thing is the font size on the rulebook but it's it's still legible but this honestly I treat this more as like a reference when I need to check uh you know when I need to when I don't want to go through the entire rulebook which uh the the designer by the way offers a PDF they offer a PDF uh with uh the the full um more flat fleshed out rules um but I still use these error now and then to look up like an ability or a specific phase of of the turn to like a memoir you know to like refresh myself on it uh rather than paging through uh the big rule book so this still is useful even though that the tax is small um but uh yeah that's the only negative I have as far as the components is just how small the taxes and this but it is still useful but all the information is
there that there's a couple of inconsistencies with the text when describing some of the card abilities but uh if you've played um Masonite like you you'll kind of infer what the uh what those ambiguities mean all right you'll know what the designer meant um but okay so I know I keep bringing up um you know uh experience mention I player and whatnot uh I don't want to deterior from from playing this game if you're not an experienced a mesh night player because as it turns out uh the uh the the person that made uh this file they're not stated that they don't have any previous experience with mesh Knight and they're big fans of the game to to the uh to the extent that they went ahead and made this file that's how much they like it okay uh so that and you know I've seen as much from reading some of the reviews uh folks have stated that even with no prior May is not experience that they still enjoy the game a lot okay um so a lot of fun to be had here and definitely this has made it to my uh this will be an evergreen game as far as portable games go um with a couple caveats because when I take games for uh you know for trips and things like that uh they have uh when and how I can play the game can depend on you know the the footprint and things like that this is a game that is not quick at least it takes me at the very minimum even with understanding the rules the way I do now I think this will
take me at least an hour I think an hour and a half is more what it will take me because I really like analyzing the board and figuring out the puzzle of the combat so hour to hour and a half the designer in uh his playthrough it took him 45 minutes and I think that after like maybe 10 more plays I might reduce the play time to I might reduce the play time to an hour but you know depending on where you're gonna take this game with you maybe you're not gonna have an hour to an hour and a half to play it but um I I really like how the designer used the double-sided cards here so double-sided tiles I like how uh the there's an enemy reference so every time that you draw a tile you randomly draw one of these colored boxes okay and and then depending on the colored uh boxes colored cubes and the colored Cube will determine the type of anime that you're gonna encounter so you reference this okay so I I like the way that the designer implemented that making sure that each map tile could have three different possibilities for enemies depending on the color of the cube that you draw um I like the double-sided um the double-sided uh ability cards okay well done throughout the game you'll get to upgrade three of them all right and they're W so you you use them on their starting side every round and then you flip them to their uh waning side before they're discarded for good so
essentially you get to use each card twice um so what I'm saying is I just really like the the way that with the component limitation the way that the designer figured out to get the best out of them uh I did add a couple things on my own so you might notice here that I'm using black cubes where you're supposed to use the gold cubes I just prefer using these gold cubes for uh these called cubes for uh when when you produce gold Mana I just like using these cubes for that instead uh these are a lot of the Ring tokens okay that I use for when I um when I succeed in a battle in a location I just prefer that over the Black Cube and it fits back in the Box no problem uh a nice ice lift the all the tiny cards with mini Euro I did have to trim them uh I did have to trim them a couple millimeters so that it didn't have that access uh above them uh this this and I think that next to dragons of etching Stone let's get into the comparisons now okay I'll be more in depth with that so the biggest advantage that dragons of etching Stone have in my opinion is The Learning Experience uh when I read the rulebook for that game I did not have to consult anybody I didn't have to go ask any questions everything was in there and that was it I think there was one minor Errata but other than that you know like I didn't have to ask any questions for this uh they have to go on Board Game Geek a couple times and check the previous rules rules questions but even with the uh the FAQ and the fan made version like there's
still a couple things that might feel fussy but as far as the rules but I I think I I have a pretty good hang of the game by by this third play that I I made uh that I just had so that's the biggest Advantage um I do like um I do like the the graphic design and drivers of etching Stone a bit more although I'll say I like the pixel the pixel characters here I prefer the pixel art of the characters uh I prefer this over the um like the low poly um character artwork from uh dragons of action Stone I preferred a little tiny pixelated characters uh in this case um but uh so yeah rules graphic design and play time okay so dragons of a tombstone once you learn the rules you should constantly be able to play dragons of action Stone in 30 minutes whereas here for midnight uh like I mentioned earlier it's a longer game and also dragons of register you can play it anywhere in your hand even on a table in a very very small space midnight will require a bit definitely some um some table more footprint but there's nothing terrible it's actually all things considered it really doesn't occupy that much space all right that that's your comparison there um midnight is more expensive it's about twice the price so there's that too but 100 worth it and I really want to thank uh the designer for uh making this
because like it's just a it's just a a fit like being able to uh cram the entire amazement experience with these few components one other Advantage versus dragons of etching Stone I really like the tactile experience here more I like that that there's more cards there's tokens I appreciate that since this has more components it has a bit more of a tactile experience but yeah thank you so much I really want to thank the designer this this is such a cool cool game and as an amazing night fan I'm really happy that I finally got to try this and it has become a Evergreen game for uh travel and as far as portable games go yeah so that is my solo thoughts on midnight amazing game really worthwhile and it makes me glad that a platform that uh a platform like um uh like game crafter access for people to create something like this it's just I I love that this exists so much but uh let me show you now how all of it fits back in the box all right so now I just want to show you how it all fits back in here I did add a couple extra tokens and other tidbits and I sleeve the small cart and it all fits back in there just fine so here are the larger cards uh this doesn't really need to be sleeved honestly of course I would love to but it's all right they don't need to be sleeved they don't get shuffled all that much and they're and they have really rounded Corners so it wouldn't work anywhere and it wouldn't
fit back in there so yeah these are the large cards I do have this little uh I like I cut these bags or it acts as like a sleeve so that I'm able to remove it easily how you just saw there okay so I'm able to just uh do this and it all comes out like that so I have the I have the uh many cards here and um but they I have this tiny bag that I cut so that they all are stuck together like that and yeah these are Mayday sleeves we've made a soft sleeves by the way a Euro sized and I already mentioned why I added these I I liked and I wanted to have more by the way because I just wanted to cover uh in the game you're gonna beat the fitting areas even though it's not necessary three cubes the game includes three cubes for you to cover the enemies that you defeat and that's fine I just wanted to have more so I'm using this Lord of the Rings tokens and I added a couple of very tiny I think these are four millimeter dies for uh tracking Mana okay on the and I added exactly and they're very they're very very limited space here so I was able to add exactly these four and that's it I you can't add anything else after this it's it's packed completely in there uh I did um I didn't mention why I added this so this is for um uh this chart for the enemies uh I wanna uh
you know because this board is very visually busy and the text is so tiny I just like using this for when I'm in a certain region and a region has a specific color Cube I can just point here uh to one enemy I'm supposed to be facing so because this whole board is so it's so visually busy that it was like really distracting me so just using this helped that definitely helped me a lot so that I know you know every time I glance over to this card I know which anime I'm facing and I don't have to like refer to this every time
all right and as you can see as you can see it all fits back in there but yeah so it's midnight and I want to thank you so much for watching if you enjoy this content please make sure to like And subscribe if you have any comments questions feedback put them in the comment section and I'll see you in the next one