Papyria Review - Me So Potamia
Transcript
Hey everybody, Z Garcia here. Today I'm taking a look at the latest from Iron Games. This is Papiria or Papyia. I'm not sure how you pronounce that. Uh it is going to be a Euro style game in which you'll be moving around with your boat and your wanderers uh on the rivers Tigris and Euphrates. You are going to be collecting resources. You're going to be building up your landscape and you're going to be scoring, triggering scoring uh for various things, trying to of course come out on top at the end. Let me show you what the game looks like. I'll give you a quick overview of the mechanisms and then we'll come on back and I'll tell you what I think of it. Here we're taking a look at a game for three players already a few rounds into uh the game. We've started from this player over here and a player is represented by this board right here.
They put tokens above that, possibly some tokens here beneath that. And then an area of tiles that they are building. Uh we've got this player here, the yellow player, and then we've got the red player over here. It's red to play next. In the first few rounds, uh, based on the player count, you are going to be deploying either one of your wanderers or one of your ships, one of these right here, to a spot and taking some actions. Uh, the boats are going to go on this inner track right here. And then the wanderers go on the outside track out here that go all goes all the way around the board. So, you deploy your piece and then you take the associated actions. If you deploy a ship, you are going to take this score multiplier that is in the spot where you deploy. Say I deploy here with a ship, I take that. Uh and then you get one of the two actions on the outside. If you deploy with a wanderer, you get these two actions on the outside. So ship one and one, the wanderer, these two out here. So it's red to play. They are going to play to one of these locations. And uh perhaps they are going to play here to that spot right there. Uh they are going to then take one of these two in whatever order they want to. They'll take this one first. It's a tile. They have to place that tile next to their priest out here.
So this is going to be built. You do not have to match sides. I could play this like this if I want to. Uh but you do benefit from having a longer river. So you might want to do it. I'm going to indeed do this. And then after you place a tile, the priest will move to that tile. And then the second action out here is making income, making lapis, which is one of the two currencies, the other one being papyrus. So I am going to check how many mountains I have, how many of these mines. I have one, two, three. And then if I have any of the special abilities that give me more, I do not. So I get one, two, and three of these. And I will put that right here with my other two like so. So that is my turn. Now we go to the next player, which is the green player. They have their priest right here. Uh but all their pieces are already in play. So they are going to move one of their pieces. And really, this is the majority of the game. You only deploy and take an action during the first three, four rounds, depending on the player count. From now on, you will select one of your pieces, one of your ships or one of your wanderers, and move that piece clockwise uh one or two spaces, though you can pay lapis to move uh farther than that. And so the green player is going to select one of their pieces. And they could, for example, select this one and go one and go two because you do not count occupied
spaces. Okay. Uh, and same thing for these ships. You can also boot someone out of the location. If I really wanted that spot, I could go one and I could go two in there, pay a lapis, and have that player kind of scoot over to the next open space so that I could take this action. Now, if when you move, you land across from another player, say green goes, they land there, and I'm across from the other player, meaning I just move my ship and they have a wanderer there, or vice versa, then I may pay them one lapis to gain one papyrus from the uh supply here. Okay. And after I've moved uh then I may, of course, take my two actions. If I land across from my own piece, then I may take my priest and put them anywhere I want to in my board so that I can build next to that spot.
That's the only place I'm allowed to build. And then the priest moves to that location. Okay, so that is what's going on. And and green is going to be taking a turn. So what are the various things we can take out here? Well, there is production, which I already showed you. There is taking new tiles. I do need to uh reveal that which I've already shown you. Taking new tiles. You get multipliers on the inside. They're all really the same, but they multiply different scoring opportunities. We'll come back to that. You'll see here you begin with some and then more and more of those you can stack above those uh spots. And then the other things out here that you can do are you can build you can build these temples. They are going to go and you have a there's player aids on the table here. You can build one of those temples on one of these statues. Okay, the first one's going to be one lapis. The second one you build is two and so on. And then you can build one of these on your forests.
And again, one, two for the second and so on. So you can take those here, you can take them here, right? These different locations. You can also then gain income from the uh over here you get papyrus and the uh this income. I've already talked about the papyrus. You'll see in some locations they show you one or two. The starting tile shows two there. Some other tiles will show a further one like right here. And then lastly, scoring. These are going to be scoring tiles. When you choose to take that, you are going to be triggering scoring for some that that thing denotes. So, let's go ahead and take a turn for green here. Green's going to go there. They land across from red. They are going to pay them a lapis to take a papyrus because they can do that. They are then going to take this action where they get one of these and put it on one of their mountains. Cover that up. it will increase their uh income when they choose to do that and then they are going to trigger this scoring right here. Okay. The very first thing you do is increase this token on the bottom here. This track is sort of limits. It's your knowledge and it limits the amount of victory points you can make. So it goes up by two for green. Green's gonna go right there. So they have seven.
Okay, everybody begins at five. And then it shows you uh a symbol there that they are going to be triggering scoring for that symbol and various things are going to score differently. Let me show you that. Here we have all of the different kinds of scoring. Okay? And so you've got mountain scoring. You're going to be checking the largest group you have of contiguous mountains. That's the stone and the peaks that we're putting out. those blue peaks, the biggest group of those with the peaks counting as two, and you multiply that by your mountain scoring, this one right here. Okay? Then you've got river scoring, your longest river, uh, one a piece, times the river scoring, which is this one right here.
This player already has an extra one. So for them, if this player was scoring river right now, it would be 1 2 3 4 5* 2 is 10 points. But if their limiter is only at five, their knowledge, it could only make five victory points across the top and so on. There's different kinds. The weirdest ones are the the scoring for the city and the temple, which are thankfully the same, but you count the smallest amount of tiles between all of your cities or temples, plus one per city or temple. So in this example we're looking at here you are getting there's a temple there and a temple there and a temple there.
The smallest you know amount of tiles you can traverse to get within one of them all would be 1 2 3 4 5 6 and then plus one plus one plus one. Okay. Um that's the idea. It's a it's a weird scoring but that's that's how that's gonna go. And same thing for the the little cities up here. Um the most of them do care about adjacency. These over here, which are the ones we're scoring now, the sanctuaries cannot be next to one another on two tiles adjacent to one another because they won't score at all. So let's go back to what Green was doing over here. They are scoring um where' they go? They went right there and they took this tile and they're going to be scoring those sanctuaries. They have one there and they have one here and that's it. Uh that's two of them then. And then they check the multiplier which is on their little player board over here. And there's two. You begin with two. And so very simply 2 * 2 would be four. That's not more than the amount they're allowed to make. So they make four points. Okay.
Uh now the scores in this game go bananas. Okay. You'll see the track here goes to 50 right there. And then once you go past 50, you go back to the beginning and you take one of these and this represents 50. And there's a whole bunch of these that they give you. That's just that's just a few out of the bag of these that they give you. So the scores kind of get into the hundreds. All right. Uh so be aware of that. So that's what this player did. They're going to keep this for the end of the game and some endame scoring and they are uh done. And now it goes to the next player. The next player again it's yellow. They they've already placed them all during the first three rounds and now they pick one and move it. With three players, you have one ship and two wanderers. Uh with two players, you have two ships and two wanderers. And with four players, one and one. All right.
So, they pick one, they move it, they we have to make sure we replenish this. Uh and they trigger something. There's a couple of special places where if you pass by, I do want to mention if you walk by this little tent, it's sort of like two pieces of cardboard that make a little tent. If you walk by there, past that, you're allowed to pay two um papy or papyruses, papy, whatever. I hate that word to trigger one of these scorings on the side. And if you walk past this one, you're allowed to pay 1, two, or three to move up your knowledge four, seven, or nine, respectively. Okay? So, you can score more. Uh, so those two are optional. You can do those if you want to. You do not have to do that when you walk past there. Now, as soon as any one pile is gone, a pile of scoring opportunities, of tiles, of these uh tokens, of multipliers in the middle, as soon as any one of those things is gone, let's say somebody builds the last one of these temples, then we pull this out and we're going to put in there one of these endgame tiles.
There's 12 of these, no matter the player count. You put that in there and if anybody lands there, they're allowed to trigger that. This is going to give you seven knowledge. And then it says that you may spend three lapis to take seven victory points. As soon as one of these is taken, we replenish it again with one of those. And as soon as any other tile place is empty, you put another one of those. Once you cannot replenish one of those from the 12, then the endame is going to be triggered and you're going to trigger some endgame scoring, okay? Which I'm not going to go over. I will mention one last thing. Throughout the game, one more free action you can take is looking over here at these things. And if you meet a threshold, then you can take that. So, for example, uh this player over here has already one of these temples, but if they're the first ones to get to three of those, then they would take this. This means this is the threshold down here, what they need to achieve that. This is another multiplier and this lets them score temples at the end of the game one more time. So this would go here like that and it adds two more to the multiplier for temples and there's the next one then to the next player who achieves this is the same. It still lets them score at the end. is a single multiplier and then the last one has no extra multiplier but again they can score temples at the end of the game. Uh and you have like I said some
player aids here. This is how you build and the costs. You've got here a reminder that your your score is you know limited by your knowledge and how you're going to get some knowledge. This is some final scoring. Whoever has the most of these things gets to trigger a scoring of that type. And then here is a little reminder of the actions that you may take. Uh you can move one or two steps. You can pay to bump someone else. You can pay lapis to move further spaces. And uh bonuses if you are across from yourself or across from another player, that sort of thing. So there you go. That's hopefully an idea of everything that's going on. Uh, like I said, there's a lot of little moving parts, but I think that's, you know, a general concept of what's happening.
Let's go ahead and go back up top. Let me give you some final thoughts. I tend to like the games that come out of Iron Games. Uh, and this is no exception. I like this one, too. Though, I have a few things about uh this one. There's a few aspects of it that I find uh uh a little lacking or a little not sort of fitting me so much, which means that this is not my favorite from the company. It is one I think I would still recommend with some caveats. Okay, so let's go ahead and dive into that. I'll tell you uh the good first. And the good is that the game has excellent choices that you are going to be making from turn to turn. Um, and those choices come with a nice amount of progression, a good sort of good beats in the game. At the very beginning of the game, you are placing out your characters. And that depends on the player count, how many times you'll do that, but two or three or four times, you just pick the thing you want and you put a worker out there and you take that stuff. There's some nice choices there with what you do. That's kind of the first beat of the game. Then the second beat which is the longest sort of part is that idea of picking up your character, your boat or your wander and then moving them around. So it has this sort of rondelle feel a little bit. You can pay to go uh you know to go more spaces to go farther. You can uh bump somebody else out of a space that you really wanted to and you're manipulating
all of these things. I like that. And then near the end of the game as things start to dry up, then you put those scoring tiles in their place. And that feels good because then it's like, oo, okay, if I have the right number of lapis and the papyrus I need, I can boom, I can jump in there and score a nice chunk of victory points. So, the game has a good cadence to it. There's a neat um again sort of a a neat moments and some good progression to the whole thing. There's a lot of interconnected decisions as well. And I like, for example, the the two locations where if you cross that threshold, you can pay to move up on the knowledge track or you can pay to trigger another scoring. I like those things. I like those choices. Now, things I did not like as much. I think the look of the tiles is pretty rough.
Um, and there's a lot of there's this general sort of clip art look to the whole thing with the the iconography being tossed on the tiles without any particular rhyme or reason. They do not rotate. You can rotate. I'm just saying things will end up upside down. Um, the icons don't really pop on that generally sort of very dirt brown background. Um, you will be you will have to be careful to make sure you are seeing everything you should be scoring. It's hard to visually put together. This is my biggest mountain range cuz they'll be just in random places on those tiles. Okay, so that's what I'm talking about. The the clarity and the look of the tiles is in my opinion subpar. The other big problem is the fact that the scoring in the game is has this flow that goes from getting a few points early in the game to getting dozens of points towards the end of the game.
Right? The game will end up kind of, you know, in the hundreds like I saidund or or at least over a 100 easily 182 to 214, that kind of thing. And the first few times you score in the game, it'll be like seven points, okay? But near the end of the game, and especially with the endgame scoring you're going to be doing, it could be I made 52 points and that doesn't feel very good for the first half of the game. It it it ends up making that half, those first few points feel u insignificant. It's kind of like playing a trick- taking game where every trick you win for the first round is worth one point, but then in the sixth round is worth six points. That first round just feels insignificant in many ways, and this has a little bit of that feel as well. Um, I also thought that the um the scaling in the game was less interesting towards the lower count. I think it's better with more. Having only two players means you're you're both controlling two wanderers and two ships and it's a lot of pieces to keep track of on the board. You're like, "Okay, well, which one do I want to do? Where do I want to go?" If you're playing with the higher player count, then it's one ship, one wanderer. You have two people you can move. You still have tons of options. That's not the problem. It's just it helps with the decision
makingaking in this game because it could lead to a lot of analysis paralysis in this game. There's a ton going on. There's a lot of interconnected things like I said, but if you at the two player count, there's more pieces you could move and that bogs it down a little bit more than I would like. So, I do like it with more players. Um, so those are the big ones. You know, that's like I said, some good, some bad. Would I recommend this game? I think to somebody who does not have an issue with the look of the game, you're used to games looking like this. You're not a stickler for, you know, the surface beauty of things, then yes, I think you're going to like it. Be aware, it's a very crunchy Euro game. And be aware it does have that sort of scaling curve uh or or scoring I should say uh ramp that feels a little iffy especially upon repeat plays for the first third maybe half of the game. Um but I would still recommend it because it does some interesting things. You know I I like the the the moving parts and the gears uh that are running through this game and the way they work together. I I I like those things. So, for me, this is going to get a 7 out of 10. That is still a seal of approval. Uh like I said, I like other games from this designer and this company uh a little bit better, but this is uh not a bad one. I would love to see a second edition with maybe an improved
look and a little more visual clarity, but that's okay. Beggars can't be choosers. So, there you go. Seven out of 10 from me folks for Papyria or Papiraia. Uh, it's one of those two, right? My name is Z Garcia. Thank you for tuning in everybody. I'll see you on the next one.
Hey folks, I'm Tom Vassel. Thanks for watching this video. Check out our channel. We have a lot of videos on our channel. We have live videos that go up each week from live Q&As's to videos where we take a look at the newest stuff on Kickstarter crowd surfing to top 10 lists and more. There's lots of stuff on this channel. We encourage you to explore it. You can find out more at our website dicetowwer.com. I'm Tom Bassel. Thanks for watching another video on the Dice Tower.