Skip to main content
Loading video...

Concilium Urbis Review: Estne Bonum

Transcript 10:41

Hello everybody. This is Graeme and today we're looking at a game called Consilium Herbis. Now in this game you take on the role of one of the six great kingdoms of Infiniton that have col Celestial Quazarus, a planet that is rich in crystallon celestia. Of course, everybody knows that each player's kingdom is building up its own mining cities to extract and exploit the mineral. At the end of each year, the leaders get together to vote on the new laws that govern this new planet. Now, this is in essence an issue you choose game followed by kind of a tile placement game where players are going to be placing out tiles in their own grid to score points based on the laws. At the start of each round, there will be two new laws displayed which will be voted upon at the end of the round. Now, these new laws change how each type of tile scores, either increasing or decreasing its point value. Now, I really enjoy the isslit you choose mechanism, and I was very much intrigued by these this kind of changing laws and being voted upon by the player. So, was eager to get this one to the table. So, will this be a prize game like the Crystalon Celestia Mineral or it'll be more like plain old rock to be tossed over your shoulder? Let's get it to the table, see how it's played, and we'll come back. My final thoughts on Consilium Urbis.

Here's Consilium Urbus set up. Each player starts with an identical starting city tile. In the middle of the table, there going to be six law cards, one for each type of city tile that's in the bag. Each law card also has two kind of law updates to it. So, take those 12 cards plus two more bonus VPs, and they're shuffled all together into a faceown deck, and two of them are randomly removed. Now, throughout the game, players will be voting on these upgrades to see if they will come into law and replace the existing laws or if they're just discarded. There are three different sets of law cards. I'm just showing you the basic set here. The law cards will tell you how each type of building scores and the base scoring. The other matching cards keep the same scoring methodology, but alter the points either up or down depending on the new law card. Even the level three cards keep the same principle. It's just the scoring methodology that's a little more complex. There are three random civilization cards used for each game.

The vote tokens are placed to one side and the mineral and energy counters on the other. The yes and no zone markers are also placed off to the sides. All the city tiles for the player count go into the bag. Each player has a player screen and three markers of their color. Now, a game is played over seven rounds. Each round, except the first, you're going to be revealing two new law cards. These will be voted upon at the end of the round. Each player will then take four tiles from the bag and place them behind their screens. You're going to split them into two groups of two and pass both those groups to the person next to you depending on the direction as shown on the top card. You'll also receive two groups of two from the other player. You'll choose one set and return the other set. You can't mix and match. You have to take one set. This is all done simultaneously. And at the end of this part, you're going to have four tiles to place into your city. There are no placement rules, only that a tile has to share an edge with another city tile, and once placed, it cannot be moved at a later round. If you receive a tower tile, it is the only tile that can be placed on top of another tower tile, and there's no limit to how tall the towers can be. If you place a mine, place a number of mineral tokens as indicated on the tile. Now, this is the only time you're going to be adding minerals to a mine. Once it's depleted, it stays empty. Once all the tiles are placed, you move to the energy production phase.

Each factory that you have in your city can convert one mineral into energy. The mineral has to come from one of your mines that still has minerals on it. And each factory has a capacity limit of how much energy it can store. Remember that you're activating your factories, not your mines. If you have one factory and three mines with minerals, you're still only converting a single mineral to energy in that one factory. Players then during this phase have the option to spend six energy from their factories to place their civilization disc on one of the civilization cards. These are going to be end of game scoring. Each player can have a disc on each of the cards. Next is the voting stage where you first collect your votes from your city and your starting tile gives you two votes and each tower will give you one vote regardless if they're in a tower or not. Place all these votes behind your screen. The two new law cards are now up for voting. Pick one of the cards to start with and the players will secretly put a number of votes into their hand.

It can be zero. Then countdown and all players will place their closed fist over the approval zone or the cancellation zone and reveal what they've bid. If the card passes, place the card covering the point section of the card, but not the text at the bottom. The text at the bottom still applies to the scoring. If there are more votes on the cancellation side, or it was a tie, the card is discarded. You then proceed to the next card, and any vote tokens that are used during this phase are discarded after each vote. Players do not have to use all their voting tokens during the voting phase. You can save them for later rounds if you want to make sure that a future vote will go your way. If there's a bonus card turned over, it's just going to be the player who bid the most votes that will win the card for end of game scoring. Now, this continues for seven rounds. At the end of seven rounds, players get points for the law cards that are in play with their modifiers.

Any civilization cards that they have a marker on. Any bonus cards that they've won, and leftover minerals and energy are converted to points, and the player with the most points is the winner. Let's get back to see what I thought about Consilium Herb. Let's start with the theme and components. The theme in this one is very out there, as you heard in the intro. And as soon as you start your teach, the theme goes right out the window. It's interesting, but at the same time, pretty generic. We've seen lots of games where exploring distant worlds to harvest some, you know, special essential mineral for your for your culture. Onto the components. And here I do have several issues, and I think it comes down to two major points. The rule book and the production. Let's start with the production. In the rule book, it says that these starting tiles have an S on the back, so they're easily findable. Well, you know what? They don't. They look like every other tile in the bag. And on the first playthrough, you're going to be having to look at a tiny little picture in the rule book to try and figure out what they actually look like so you can start to play. But once that's done, you know what? For the next games, you know what they are. The game is in English.

English rule book and Spanish with a Spanish rule book. And I have three Spanish player screens and three English player screens. Again, not a big deal. The bigger deal is the law cards. They're all double-sided. you know, Spanish on one side and English on the other, except for the mines. The mines are Spanish on both sides. Again, not gamebreaking. You can go to the rule book, but it just kind of shows a lack of attention to detail. And actually, the rule book is where I have another issue. It's just not good. You want to know how to score the mines? The rule book does provide an answer. Maybe not the clearest, but you can figure out in them. The mines have a little kind of star on them. What is that? How does this score? Well, you have to go to the the factory scoring section in the rule book where it says that only factories that comply with the distributed indicated on the log cards, score what's indicated on the star of each tile. So, does this tile need to be full of minerals or can you spend the minerals on it and still score the factory? I'm still not entirely sure. Now, I do like the look of the game and the art is suitably alien, but it's let down by the overall attention to detail, which is kind of too bad because the basic gameplay loop I like. The eye split you choose is always something I find enjoyable. And this one adds that kind of twist of voting on the laws at the end of each round. So, getting those uh voting things are kind of important. And I like that there's three levels of scoring, and they do get trickier to to fill or maximize. I did like that often you're weighing the penalty of the city distribution laws with how much the tile would get you for scoring if it kind of

fell outside of those laws. And usually staying in the city laws requires you to make use of the towers as they are the only ones that can stack on top of each other to make sure you you're within that confined area. The islit you choose mechanism is one that is not as robust as other games with only four tiles and be and being forced to do two and two. I prefer the mechanism where you can do uneven piles. Oh, I see you really need X. So I'm able to give you X in one pile and all the other things in the second pile. This forced two equal pile split does speed up the gameplay though a little bit. Now the game is pretty quick uh too with only seven rounds and the phases do by go by fairly quick irregardless of the player size. I also appreciate that the changing laws and the need to make sure you get votes so when a law comes up that can drastically help or hurt you, you have the votes to influence the outcome.

So would I recommend this game? Ultimately, I would not. The basic gameplay is solid, but with the production issues and the lack of clarity on scoring, plus the lack of some basic scoring options means that I'm going to have to pass on this one. I did like the art and look of the game, and the main mechanism of the eyeplit you choose. I always find it enjoyable. I thought the voting on the new laws was an interesting touch to the game along with the three levels of laws. The laws are more complicated than other tile placement games, which I enjoyed, but maybe a negative for some players. The game lasts a good amount of time and doesn't really seem to matter on the number of players. At seven rounds, feels just about right with the restrictions. It gives a good amount of angst, which I enjoy. For the negatives though, the first the production, although none of the items were game-breaking, you can still play the game, but it's definitely a knock against it. The rule book leaves a lot to be desired. And for a game that's this rules light, you're still left with questions. And as much as I like the laws in the game, I do wish that they are more varied in both tiles and laws.

So instead of just having the six types that's come with the game, maybe have 10, pick six out of that and along with the appropriate laws because some of the tiles are just not interesting. The trees only help to offset population compared to that factory mine combination or the monuments. It's just kind of an uninteresting tile. Overall, I'm giving this one a 6 out of 10. For strictly gameplay, as a single or first few games, I really enjoyed it and would have given it a higher rating, but with the production issues and lack of diversity over the long run, it kind of knocks it down to a six for me. But that's it for the moment. Until next time, thanks for watching. Hey everybody, thanks for watching another video from the Dice Tower. Hey, you want to learn more about us, communicate with us? We have a Facebook group, we have a Discord channel, lots of different ways to get involved with the Dice Tower. You can find that in our linkree link below. So, just click that. It will take you and you can communicate with us on Facebook. Join our Facebook groups. There's lots of cool things that you can find and become part of the Dice Tower.

Thanks so much for watching. I'm Tom Bassel.

Progress saved