Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 5 Disappointing Board Game Publishers

Transcript 8:36

all right welcome back to the channel this is the channel where we give you reviews pay for his unboxings we generally like to talk a load of bollocks about tabletop gaming in general and in this video we're going to be counting down our top or bottom five publishers that used to be pretty good but now recently just pumping out last reprints and not really producing as much innovative content as i used to back in the day so remember these are my own opinions if my opinions make you want to punch a hole through the plaster ball ball of your 250 grand help to buy a new build then feel free to smash your house up but with that in mind let's crack on with this somewhat controversial or not controversial list alex so the first publisher on this list is rio grande games what the [ __ ] happened to rio grande games they used to produce all these wonderful games like race for the galaxy they've done power grid puerto rico and for some unknown reason for a number of years now they have basically disappeared off the radar okay they did publish underwater cities and beyond the sun which are reportedly quite good games but by and large the days of bonanza and sulk and the mine canada are well and truly behind us which is absolutely tragedy i haven't got a clue what happened to rio grande games i can only think that they maybe got taken over by a bigger publisher and they've been sidelined but i do shed a

tear for rio grande games because way back in the day they did provide us with some cracking titles didn't they so number four on the list of our top five publishers that used to publish decent games but have been a little bit lazy or lackluster in their recent offerings is stonewall games right do you remember when saw was first kickstarted everyone went ape [ __ ] for that title it broke new ground in it the component quality was off the charts the gameplay was solid and it was supported for a number of years afterwards for some weird reason stonewall games have sort of stopped producing those quality games they moved away from the kickstarter model in favor of publishing games that weren't actually designed by jeremy stigma so you've had games like wingspan which whilst it looks nice it's basically just top trunks for birds in it and then you add red rising which was a really sort of weak card drafting tableau building game games like charter stone which tried to implement a legacy aspect into a worker placement game it didn't really work that well did it so for some weird reason stone mild games are sort of lost their way a little bit and i'm just waiting for scythe to to poke its head above the trenches so everyone could get a bonus ready and stab it in the eyeballs not i mean sort of two come on it's the stigma what you're doing myself so the next publisher on this list of our bottom five publishers that used to make good games but sort of just produced dog [ __ ] now is days of wonder i'll get quite

nostalgic about this because days of one day they used to produce stellar titles didn't they ticket to ride was an amazing looking game it played quite well didn't it shadows overcame a lot one of the first hidden trailer games with luscious components memoir 44 a sprawling huge game which you could take at its base level and then add to it and they kept on producing battle maps and extra content for that day wonder got taken over by asmoday and since that has happened all they've really produced is a few map packs for ticket ride you've had a game called corinth which was a tiny little small box game and there's a game called deep blue which we haven't played but it sort of flew under the radar so the days of the cleopatra game had that wonderful board in a box type thing and we used to look forward to the yearly offering of days of wonder because it was guaranteed it was going to be a really fresh original experience so again those days are sadly behind us and it looks like asthma day gobbling up all of these wonderful publishers has done irrevocable harm to the industry in our opinion so next publish on this list is fantasy flight games oh my god fancy flight games how the hell is this on this list well i'll tell you what's on this list is because years and years ago fantasy flight used to produce these semi-complex games you think about fury dracula second edition it was a lot smaller a lot more complex and there was a lot more fun in this game similarly you had tuolum period third edition a big sprawling mass of a game arkham horror whilst it was clunky it felt epic

in proportions right but at some point in the not so distant future fantasy flight changed their model and they decided to strip everything down streamline all their popular titles and to the point where there's basically nothing left if you think about arkham horror third edition they've basically taken everything that made the original charming and they've just relegated down to this sort of bare bones skeleton that you have to add to to make it playable right same thing with zwolle and appear in fourth edition okay we do like that game we do love it but they've taken out a lot of the content that made the game feel absolutely huge it's still big but it's not as big and complex as it used to be and you have to spend another 90 quid for an expansion which is the cost of a really expensive base game right what we seem to be getting with fantasy flight is just a load of second editions if you think about descent third edition where the game wasn't that complex to start with but it's been stripped back and it's just a case of rolling dice and seeing what happens and it's more of a toy with these huge elaborate miniatures and the actual spectacle of what it looks like on the table seems to be more prevalent than the actual gameplay experience same thing with manchester madness this has been digitalized i know a lot of people like this game but we found it to be too mechanical and the app sort of removes you from the actual hands-on experience of the game myself fantasy flight seem to have this idea that less is more and we don't think that that is the way to go so number one on this list of publishers that have disappointed us recently is portal games

i remember kraken knight and robinson crusoe when it was first released and the game was awe-inspiring right once i'd managed to learn sanskrit and decode the rulebook it was the first game that really took the prospect of you losing very very seriously and one of the things that we really liked about is the fact that you could defer your pain and suffering by shuffling cards back into the decks right and they might come back later and bite you in the ass all we seem to get now from portal games is second edition rehashes for some bizarre reason portal games just now focuses on their game found kickstarter type projects i think the catalyst this was the failure of rattle battle grab the loot i mean that flopped big time and deservedly so because it was [ __ ] right they changed their economic model to put the risk of the projects successful failure on the actual people who are going to play the game the backers right so you saw this with stronghold undead well around campfire is that that game is practically unplayable because the retail version doesn't have some essential content that was available in a kickstarter version and it seems that all the portal games are thrown out now are rehashes of games that have been released previously first martians is a re-implementation of robinson crusoe you had a rehash of proportion it was going to be re-themed into some weird bizarre theme but they will ended at the last minute and even with the latest game they started producing the football management simulator it's a re-implementation of a game that came previously so i don't know what's happened at portal games it just seems

that they've lost their way a little bit and i'm just hoping that i can return to the innovation happened in the early 2010s because that was a really exciting period and we were lapping up all games at that point so you go that's our top or bottom five publishers that used to excite us but now they tend to disappoint us more often than not what do you think of our list have we upset you with our lambasting of some industry heroes let us know down in the comments below right but for now if you haven't subscribed already do so hit the like button away [ __ ] see you next time

you

Progress saved