Skip to main content
Loading video...

Making Our Dream Game | Tier-List

Transcript 42:28

Ladies and gentlemen, we're here for another tier list of sorts. We are

degree, it's kind of

degree,

discussion / tier list, yeah.

So, we're basically trying to make our ideal board game with compromises. We're going to be going through 14 categories.

Yes.

We have certain allotments amongst the different, you know, tier levels. So, we can have two S tier, three A tier, four B tier, three C tier, one D tier, and one F tier.

Yeah, and you have to fill that out completely, so you cannot just choose I want S tier all S tier components.

obviously we would all want that.

everything, yeah.

So, it kind of goes to show like what do you If you were making a game

you willing to like

care about?

What What are your priorities?

Yeah.

Oh, yeah. And so, we're going to go through these uh elements alphabetically. And I'll just tell you up front what they are. There's art, component quality, depth, game flow, gimmick, graphic design, interaction, originality, replayability, rule book, scalability, table-ability, theme, and usability. And as we get into those categories, we'll talk about them more in detail.

So, what those are.

Exactly.

what the ranges mean. What's an F tier of uh of interaction? Yada yada yada.

Yeah.

kick it off with art. Uh Mike and I are raw dogging this.

Yeah, so I I slightly misunderstood. I filled out mine beforehand. They did not. So, I know my list. And so, I kind of

he's probably his results may be a bit better than ours.

Well, I don't know about that, yeah. But unless we

so we're starting off with art.

This is pretty So, we'll say this is again, separate from graphic design. Those are two different things. The graphic design comes up later as Jimmy mentioned earlier. So, this is just pure art. Like art on cards, art on board, pretty stuff. How important is art to you in your game?

Here's the thing.

It's real nice when you can get it.

Yeah.

I'm throwing it into C, though.

Wow.

live with a plainer-looking game. I don't I would love for it to not be such, but I can live with it. I have plenty of probably objectively ugly games that I love. And so, I'm just going to I'm going to use a C slightly tactical decision here because it gets rid of one of my C's early. I'm going C.

That's fair. What about you, Jimmy?

Uh I'm going to go with I think I'll probably go with uh I I'm going to agree with Mike because like it it it enhances, but really it's not going to detract too much. I guess like an F tier art would be something like offensive and like or hard to look at where

yeah.

Yeah.

You could jump I would I'd rather go all the way down.

I'd rather you have no art than like something that's actively looks bad.

really if something is F tier, then it is a detriment to the game in terms of uh Yeah.

You know.

Actually enjoying it. Um I will go I think I'll go I'll go C tier also on that.

Woo! Well, actually I'm going to GO D TIER. WOO! Cuz some of this other stuff is like

of respect it, man.

Some of this stuff is like essential and will like break it.

So, let's see. What's Would you D tier? Maybe like stock photos or like using like screen grabs from like a movie?

Maybe, I guess.

Yeah, cheap screen grab is pretty good.

for like Terraforming Mars

Yeah, and that does actively make the game significant. I put it in A because if we're talking about like if I'm making my ideal game

Yeah, I would love it for it to be great.

Yeah, and it's like it is important for me.

You're also an artist, so

Yeah, like and it does massively enhances at least my enjoyment of a game. I do think it really matters. And there's other stuff that like And again, I'm also coming from the perspective of like how I play games, how a lot of people I think will watch. If you're again, this will come up a layer later when we talk about one specific one, but it's like if you're deep into the hobby to the point where you're watching our channel, I do think there's certain things that don't matter as much as people say they do.

Sure.

And so, whereas I think art does matter a lot. And so, I actually put it in A. One of my one of my three A's.

I did, yeah.

I did that, man. I did that.

All right, so next up we have Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

This is I'm Yes, the chits and bits. I Cuz super nice quality

Sure. Of course. Right.

Yeah. Yeah. Right. Yeah.

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. the paper

in Vegas Showdown the paper thing. And it's like literally the tour has a crease in the middle. I'm like this is just difficult to play on kind of thing, right? So what about y'all? I put it C. Again, not C is middle of the road. Like I want them to be okay.

that's like average. I think of D tier is like sub par and I think of F is just like heinous.

Um They heinous cuz they anus. You went C you said?

I went C.

I'm inclined to do the same. Oh man, there's here's where I am.

I'm also going C.

Okay. All right, let's make it a clean sweep.

C's all around.

C's all around.

Want them to be good. Would love them to be good. But unless the game really depends on it, I don't think it matters.

Please give us the greatest components you can.

C situation, you're like if you've got resources in the game, they're probably cubes.

And here's the thing. We love too many games where that is the case for me to like really argue that's game breaking like uh you know, Grand Austria Hotel before the new edition is just color cubes.

Have I upgraded that game multiple times?

Yeah. I also feel like a lot of like

easily upgradeable. I feel like components are easier to upgrade than art.

Yes.

But I also think like a lot of upgrade components are nice but like are overrated. Like I think dual layer boards are massively overrated. It depends on the game. It depends on the game of course, but in general I'm like I don't I don't think this makes this that much better. Um whereas I do think a massive upgrade in art is a massive deal.

the security of just being like one I just like slotting stuff.

Scratches my brain. I'm with you on the dual layer.

I think they're so overrated. Yeah.

Just having the secure It's like insurance.

Yeah.

Except you know, you only buy one scratch.

There's something nice about the cubes cuz

Yeah, I agree.

I agree. Like I said, I I do like them. I just think they're overrated. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Fair. Okay, depth. This one's interesting cuz basically this one kind of goes along with replayability which we'll talk about later, but it's basically like the way I interpret this one is like after a single play, how much of the game do you think you've seen?

Right. Well, something that I've heard cuz I heard it on a podcast and I told it to you before. It's like complexity are the like the sort of the things you learn before the game, depth are the things you discover during the game.

Yeah.

Um and so yeah, that is like how much is there to explore in this game, strategies,

And sometimes it can be that doesn't necessarily mean it's a heavy game. A lot of there's light games that have a ton of depth.

abstract games where they're like, oh yeah, it takes a lifetime to master. Those are

So, depth is depth is interesting like because

you don't play a lot of games a lot of times, so depth is less important for you than it might be for somebody who has a collection of 10 games.

I agree. Yes, I do think that's fair. I do and but I do get disappointed. We've had a couple games recently where where I'm like, we played it once and I was like, wow, I've seen I feel like I've seen 100% of this game and it's like that is a bummer.

I feel like one play, F tier. Maybe like 10 plays, D tier. Maybe it maybe not even that. Maybe five plays is fine. Yeah, and then like

I put I put B.

Okay.

I want it to have depth. I want it I don't think it's the most important thing. I really don't. I'll talk about this more with replayability. I think that's a way overblown thing. Um but I don't want to have no depth. I'm going to go B as well.

B is like a good amount of depth that would be like what? 50 25 to 50 plays or whatever.

I'd like to have a game where there's a few different lanes and and and options and ways for me to feel like I'm getting better at the game. Um not every game requires this. Like there's some games where you want it because it is a simple breezy kind of game. Um but even like something like Castle Combo, I feel like there's all sorts of ways you can exploit the combos so that it has a surprising amount of depth. Like I said, it doesn't mean massive game it is.

mean a massive game. Sometimes massive games, let's say it take like something like Merv. Like I really liked Merv. We played it like three or four times and I was like, "Cool. I feel like I've I've explored this entire game." And that's a big game, right? So, it's like being big doesn't necessarily I mean the whole like Reiner Knizia thing is like the whole point around Reiner Knizia is lot of times the games are simple, but they have like sneakily deep where you're like, "Oh, there's way more to explore here than I thought."

Sure.

What do you think? What do you think, man?

Um I think I will go with

F.

I'll probably I'll go with B, too, actually.

Yeah.

There's probably a decent amount of crossover, right? Yeah.

Um I thought about it.

I thought about I thought about going A, but I just don't have enough slots, so.

Yeah, that's the thing is you have four B slots, so that's going to be how you're like, "Hey, like I want to make sure this is good, but it doesn't necessarily be like the absolute top thing."

Yep.

Next up is game flow. This is like how it feels playing. Is it smooth? Does it go well?

S tier, right now.

S tier.

S tier.

Yeah.

I want it to feel good playing.

I want it and then that will make me come back. Even if it's not necessarily the deepest game ever, the da da da, but if it's like, "Man, this is just like satisfying to play. This has got a great game flow." I also think that game flow helps with things like intuition in games. Like it's it's easy to remember the rules because of the game flow makes sense. I think game flow is so important to a game.

I'm going S tier, baby.

I think we're all going S tier.

Oh, really? Oh, yeah. I thought I was going to be on an island with this.

Because I think I think if the flow is hitting a spot that you like, it is going to be the thing you remember. Just like, "Man, that

buttery, it was da da da." Whatever that thing is.

get to the end of the game and you're like, "Wow, it's over already?" Like

I think it would be like A, but I was I thought I was going to be the only S on that one. Yeah, cuz I was

The more to argue against. It's hard to argue against.

The more I was thinking about it, I was I really This was one of the last ones I put in. I was just kept being like, "Man, but I want my game to feel good when you play it."

That's the thing that comes you make you come back. [snorts]

Yeah, exactly. Exactly.

It it is. Having a mouth feel of a good mouth feel in a game again that will make me come back more than a lot of other stuff that you would think would make you come back more like that in my opinion like you would think like oh it's got infinite strategy it's like yeah but if it's like that flow isn't super fun to play I'm not coming back to it that often you know no matter how deep it is right so okay well that was slightly different than I thought Next up Gimmick near and dear to my heart this is an interesting I love a good gimmick Interesting thing yeah it's like a game that has a gimmick has a twist to it something that is this is this is akin to originality but You know again that the functional gimmick that we all talk about is Zolkin where you have like these interlocking pieces that move and Your your workers rotate around but it is essential to the game when you get a good gimmick man it's it's really it's really solid

and a bad gimmick is really annoying I feel like there's not like a bad gimmick Couldn't think of an F tier gimmick Would you have an F tier gimmick

There's there's a game I've never played it myself but I remember there was a a roller coaster game where it was sort of like the whole idea of the game is you're building up a roller coaster and I think it's like marbles or something I remember Tom Vasel reviewing it and then it just like didn't work

Yeah

And that's kind of like the game is the main thing

I would say a pretty F tier gimmick and my maybe D is is probably better but I think the Everdell tree is like a really bad gimmick cuz it gets in the way of the players just means you can't see anything it's really hard to grab the cards out of the center of the tree [clears throat] having the other things on top of the tree [snorts] is just like in the way and if you're on the other side of the tree you literally can't see anything I think it's a horrible gimmick

say that's probably eye catching and so people love it D or C tier because you can play without it if it's a gimmick that's mandatory and it like sucks then then you're in F tier where you're like I can't play this without this and it makes the game miserable there's a specific gimmick that like will make me not play your game, and that's if your game has like 3D elements that I then need to deconstruct

Yeah, that's boring.

goes into like table ability, but yeah, for sure.

Where it's like that's one where I'm like if I can't keep this built in the box, I just won't play your game. And so I don't think that I put B. I like a good gimmick. I would like my game to have a good gimmick, but it's not that important.

Yeah, I said B.

Yeah.

I'm inclined to agree. I'm inclined to a B.

me about

I'll go D. Yeah, boring. If it works well, I will love that game for a long time.

Yeah.

Shout-out to Zolkin.

Shout-out to Zolkin. Shout-out to you know Chimera Station. Good Fromage, I think is like an absolute S-tier gimmick. Um lots of great stuff, but yeah, it's it's not that important, but it is fun though.

Yeah. All right, folks. Next one. Not going to lie, I'm burning my next my my last S on this. Graphic design.

Wow.

to be S-tier, baby. Got to be.

I'm going A with this one.

I got to know what things are and where they are and what they mean.

A-tier for for

A-tier for you?

Yeah. Where I'm like it's it's great, but it's not like my god, it's the the greatest the greatest graphic design I've ever seen. I'm like I get it. Maybe there's like one thing where you're like every so often you're like, oh wait, let me see what this endgame scoring card does. Like

Yeah, man.

So graphic design is different than art. This is like the layout of icons. Is it clear? Is it easy to read?

is everything in the game? What's the To me it's like graphic design goes such a long way to making games um whatever the word is, like intuitive. You know what I mean? Like, oh, this leads to that. Oh, that that makes sense and you know, it can be

it's it's two things.

especially for a bigger game.

Yeah, it's both readability, like is the board really busy? Readability, but it's also like understandability. You know what I mean? It's like do the does the graphic design help you like you can quickly look at it and be like, oh, turn this into this to get this. Okay, great. It's like there's sometimes like the the um player aids for like um uh Prague in a Cup of Regni. To this day, I don't know what they say. Yeah. Cuz it's just all a bunch of symbols and I'm like, I don't know what this is trying to say. It's terrible. The rest of the game is great. I went S tier for me. There are some people out there who don't think graphic design matters. They

are wrong. I'm sorry. But but beneath A would be crazy. It makes you feel unplayable. It really does. Like I really think What is a game we'd say has S tier graphic design? Oh, man. Most Lacerda games cuz Yeah, Eklund is very good at graphic design. I think most Garfield games have very, very good graphic design. It's also consistent amongst their games, which is great. The games that come into mind uh to me when I think of great graphic design is when they have There usually will be something where two things come together, like a card on a board or whatever, or two cards together where you're just like, oh, puzzle piece. That's very satisfying. It's so important. It's It's more important than art. I mean, I put it art at A. It's more important that cuz it's It's like We'll talk about it later with like a rulebook. If your rulebook sucks, I can't play your game. If your graphic design is terrible, I cannot and will not play your game. Yeah. And it's just like that's just the what it is. So, for me, it has to be S. That was the easiest S I put in the whole thing. Yeah. Again, look at like the original Triumvirate versus the new one. The original one, the graphic design and the art and stuff were like just awful. And then you also had like

alchemical symbols and thing It was crazy. And then the player aid, you would look at it similar to Prague where you're like, I don't know what this means. What am I seeing right now? And to the point where I think they were like, well, we got to do this one again. And it's great. And the new version is great cuz it has better graphic design. You know. That's right. All right. Interaction. So, this is interaction amongst players is interesting because what we are talking about with our thinking behind this is not simply a game has interaction or does not have interaction, it's that if it does have interaction, is it you know, if it's an F and B, the interaction

I really don't like to have.

Yeah, whatever your worst version of interaction is.

if the game has interaction, how important is it to you that it is interaction that makes you happy?

Yeah. So, S tier would be your your greatest version of interaction.

Sure.

That's hard cuz like I hate interaction in board games.

Even positive interaction?

No, no, no, that's not true. I I do like positive interaction. Yeah, so

That would be your S tier, whatever your game is where you're like, "Oh, I'm we're

Yeah.

So, I guess if it's a cooperative game, like it would be a cooperative game where you really feel like you're synergizing together.

Yeah, this one I I did struggle with. I I'll actually put it just kind of a a middle of the road B.

Put it C. Put it C. Middle of the road C.

Yeah, I put it middle of the road C as well. I feel like I'm more I'm the between the three of us, the most open to games with aggression in them. It's not like still what I seek out, but I do play war games and things sometimes. So, I feel like putting it at C sort of just like says I can cast a wider net of acceptability of types of interaction in games. I like games that are tactical and stuff, you know, and and where you're placing. Um I love positive player interaction, shared infrastructure type stuff the most. That's why Brass is great, Nick. Um

I kind of imagine like a sea of interaction for me being kind of like It's maybe like around like Euro solitary games where there's like maybe there's a market of cards that you're competing for or where you're placing spaces, but there's not really a ton going on and it's like things where you get in the way are mostly incidental.

Yeah.

Right.

Yeah.

Yeah. All right, so did you pick yours, Nick?

Uh I said B.

Okay.

Yeah.

All right, so the next we got originality. I'm going to tell you I'm going to F. I'm straight going to do the same. Straight F, baby. I don't think a game needs to be original at all. I really don't. I don't think it needs to be original in theme. I don't think it needs to be original in in mechanics. Arc Nova is a perfect example. That game will be number one on BGG and there's nothing original in that game. It's like it's just stuff from other games. I don't think originality matters.

Yeah, if it's like yeah, we've taken this from this, you can like tell where the Frankenstein came from, but it's just really polished. I can still hugely enjoy that game and a lot of the most popular games are that.

I'm F I'm F F tearing it as well. We have a million and one trick-taking games. They are going to by default have 70% of the same DNA and we don't care because that extra 30% or whatever can be really fun and interesting and a new puzzle, a twist on it. So I I agree. I think it's about the execution, the polish, and the way you mix flavors. Same thing with food, right? A lot of food uses the same ingredients, but you can do them in different ways and it creates a lot of

in my day. And all they were all interesting. They were still

Well, it's like it's like one of the most common criticisms for a game is like oh, does it bring anything new? I'm like it doesn't need to. Like I just it doesn't need to.

It's 2026, man. We've been around a while.

Yeah, from the thought process an F originality would probably [snorts] be whatever the most tired cuz like you did a video recently where you like trains where you're just like it is

But even then I still

But it's like it's the it's the 15th way to play the game.

clearly plagiarized.

Yeah, it's the thing that they're probably still be good. But

Don't do that. Don't do that. Originality just doesn't matter my opinion at all.

I think it's about execution.

I mean it's nice to have, but yeah, on the on in terms of all the other things, yeah.

Again, if [snorts] it was up to us, all of these would be S tier, right? But it's like if we have to do it like this, originality was the easiest F ever cuz I'm just like I don't think it matters at all, let alone

Yeah, cuz there are a lot of games that are iterative and reminiscent of other games and they're great.

And even like you know, say like a John D. Clair or like a Praise Be for Walker Harding, it's like they're just constantly borrowing from themselves Or right condition and it's like that's fine. It doesn't matter. [snorts] Yeah. Originality easy. Replayability.

I put it a replay-a- bility.

Interesting.

Mhm. So that's a A tier then.

all my C's.

All right, let me fill in some of these other spots.

go

[sighs]

This is a tough one. I know you're going to say your piece in a second.

Yeah.

This is a tough one because it's like the the If a game has tons and tons of replayability, of course that is ideal. Yeah, of course.

Um

You always want that if you can.

Given our life and everything, I'm going to make it a B.

Okay. For me it's a C. Okay, I thought it would go lower to be honest.

I I I do D I think is

do want replay- I think D is too low. I think D is too low. I don't think replayability matters nearly as much as people say it does. Again, this is coming from our perspective and also from the people watching us. Like if you have 10 games, I think replayability matters a lot. I think if you're deep enough in the hobby where you're on BGG all the time, you're watching the Brothers Murph, you probably have a lot of games. And if you have more than like 50 games, I don't think replayability is nearly as big of an issue as people say it is. Um because the vast majority of people play their each of their games less than 10 times. So like if a game only has five plays in it, for us that's great. For a lot of people that's probably better than they think it is. Again, you're like I want to play this game forever. It's like yeah, but [snorts] will you? And so things like if a game has 10 plays in it, that's fine. I think that's completely acceptable. Um I'm not going to put it D or F. Like I don't think it matters at all. It's still C. It's still pretty middle of the road. I want it to have replayability, but I think the people who comment on replayability the most are tend to have people with big collections where replayability probably doesn't matter nearly as much as they think it is. I think it's one of the more overblown complaints. Again, not that it doesn't matter at all. If you have 10 games or you play games every night so you get to really play your collection, great. I think the vast majority of people don't get to do that and so

you get to the level where you're watching this video, and this is not everybody and stuff, but like there's a lot of folks who it's like this hobby is partially a collector's hobby as well as a just utility, you know, making use of the stuff.

I think the argument is like you never know what game is going to be your favorite game. So if a game ends up being your favorite game, you're going to hope it has replayability. So even if it's a game you end up playing three times, you want it to have the the potential like also just to to just differentiate. So like difference between depth and replayability, there's some overlap possible, but there are also replayable games that don't have like a ton of depth that are like very arcadey like a flip seven where you're like

Yes. Yes. Totally. It is They are different things. Or a lot of party games or whatever. It's like yeah, the depth and replayability are different enough where we decided to put them. Again, I'm not saying it doesn't matter. I put it in C. I didn't put it D or F, but I don't think it matters nearly as much as people say it does.

least for us.

And maybe you're the you're one of the exceptions out there. That's great. That's I think that's awesome. I still want my game to have replayability.

is what we'll repeat this at the end and stuff, but we want you to put your tier list for these categories in the comments and stuff because I want to know for you maybe it is an S and stuff.

It would also depend on like what game you're designing here. Yeah. Because like if you are designing, you know, you quote unquote dream game, like maybe this is the game that you like solo all the time, then replayability becomes more significant if you're just like oh great, this is on my table.

Yeah. Whereas your dream game is to design a legacy game.

Right.

Well, technically you can't replay it unless you you will know what happens already, right? So it's like

It also it's just going to need to be replayable enough that you get through the campaign because sometimes

Yeah. That is a problem. That is a problem, yeah.

Jaws of the Lion.

All right. Rulebook.

Rulebook.

It's It's to be an A, man. I don't have an S to give it or else I would, but it's got to be an A.

I thought of It's A for me. I thought about putting it in S. It is, I think, incredibly important.

you think I'm going to give it?

I think a B.

I'm going to give it a B.

Yeah, I think it'll be Yeah, I'm like it's cuz really my thought process with a rule book is

Like once you get

I need to learn it once. Yeah, and then I'm like and if I need facts and even B is still pretty good. Like this is like above average rule book. Like yeah, you learn it once, internalize it. [snorts] If you need to go to the facts to check it out, fine.

Yeah.

then you don't need to look at it again.

I like an A because it's the rule book is the first and often one of the most important barriers to entry like of that game. And I also I'm just the again the nature of of this is a very particular

Of course.

The nature of our lives is we're moving on to the next game, moving on to the next game, moving on to the next game over and over and over again. So when I'm playing a game, I am often picking up the rule books just to make reference and make sure I got it right, put it back down, do it. And so it's like

True.

One of to me part of the rule book is not just helping you learn the game, but also like the referencing. Like is it easy to reference stuff and find that information again if I need it?

Yeah.

Um

Well, it's like for me

B also works. So B is going to be solid. I would not It's got to be at least a B.

Yeah. For me it's like I want people to If I was making a game, I want people to start off on the right foot. And I think that's like the first foot right.

I'm watching a video.

Yeah, exactly. I'll see like well someone will just teach me this game.

I'll watch the Brothers Murph play through. There you go.

Exactly. Boom, baby.

We need a rule book to be good for the people that are making the videos that you watch to learn the game. We need a rule book to be good for them. We need a rule book to be good for them. We need a rule book to be good for them. We need a rule book to be good for them. We need

Yeah. This was an A for me. I I do think it's really, really important. And yeah, it just keeps me from liking a game off the bat if the rule book If I have to slog through a rule book, I'm just already pissed off.

Okay.

Yeah.

All right. So next we got scalability. So that's how well does it play the range of player counts that it says we're saying for like an F tier game that [clears throat] that is a game that basically like it's like a two to six player game, but it is only good at like six players.

Yeah.

You really need the full player count. So it's hard to get all those people together and then it's

Donkey sauce and

a game that's going to lie to you.

No. Be be about it. If your game is a four to five player game just put it

That's okay.

Put it

Just be it.

Um I'm curious where you all put this one. I'll tell you right now I'd put it in D.

Mhm.

I'm not not again. I would like it to scale well. Don't get me wrong, but I got to put something in D.

Yeah.

Cuz there's lots of games where I'm like this has two to five I only want to play it at two, but I'm like well then I'll just play it at two. I still really enjoy it. So it's like it's not ideal that it doesn't scale well, but I don't think it as long as it plays plays well at one of them.

the as long as it plays at the count that you're going to play it at.

Exactly.

That's kind of really what matters.

Again, still not a good thing to be say two to five when it's a two player game, but it's like one of those things where I'm like I don't think if I got to put something in D and F I don't think it matters as much as other stuff.

Yeah. For me personally.

like I put it at C which in my mind is I'm like it plays great at like one player count and it plays like maybe pretty good at another count and then it's like okay and then maybe bad. So it's like it's like oh yeah one player okay like or good and then

Yeah.

I'm going A.

Really?

A.

Wow.

Just buy more games.

I yeah yeah yeah. Easy.

Different player count.

Wow. Okay.

Here's my thing. We play a lot of medium to heavy weight euro games.

Yes.

Yeah.

Often times the scalability is going to be to scale it down to a three or a two player count which is often where we play stuff. So for a lot of those games I want that

Mhm.

two player experience to be solid. I totally hear what you guys are saying about like as long as the game hits your player count.

Yeah.

But just as the people who the games are not designed for that player count and having to accommodate to that player account, I I really want it to be solid. A lot of games can easily do this by, you know, shrinking the amount of action spaces and things like that, but uh it's also partially only because I I only have A's and B's left, so I'm going A.

Spoilers.

Okay, I like that though.

Yeah, I want it to be good at whatever player count. It's nice to have a game that you can play well at all of them, so you can take it to a game night, you can, you know, play it with your partner, whatever, so Yeah, that's fair. All right, next is table-ability. This is basically like how D, interesting. This is how easy is it to get to table, the setup time, the length of the game, like basically when you pick up the game you go like Oh.

Yeah, I'm sure a lot of you have

that big box where it's like you're like, "I want to play this." And then you look at it and then you're like, "Maybe not. Maybe not today."

Going D.

That's crazy. That's So basically, yeah, in my mind like if it's F tier, it's a game that you probably play like every other year because it's such a big like chore just to get it out. And then D tier is like once a year.

That's worth the ring, yeah.

Here's the thing, the reality, and this is maybe personal to me, is that like I don't have a ton of time for like getting together with you guys and playing games, but the times that we do, I'll play a Civilisation. I don't care that the setup's hard and stuff. I you know, it's it's worth it. So to me I'm like, I you know, I'm going to I'm going to go through whatever setup stuff. I don't want it to be like deliberately annoying and long to set up, but

And I guess to tear down as well.

Yeah, but it's just like, you know,

Yeah, so I I went with A.

Oh, wow, okay.

Cuz I care about this cuz I that is one of the biggest impediments Yeah.

Yeah.

impediments to me playing a game, cuz I'm like, "How easy is this for me to just I almost went with S tier for this." Because but

We're going to do another video about a discussion video about game setups and stuff, because you think about this kind of stuff a lot. Which is also important as a game designer.

Yeah, cuz like when you're a game designer And you have to set up your prototype every time and you're playing your game, you know, 50, 60, 70 times. You notice how long it takes to set up and you're like, maybe we don't need this over here.

Yeah. And here's the thing, let's be real. I put table ability down in D. I think objectively it's one of the most important things you do. How easy is it to get into playing this game?

of it matters if you don't play the game.

100%. That's fair. I put it in C. My reasoning for C as opposed to It's funny cuz at first I wrote B, then I wrote D, then I wrote C. So like I I've changed this one around a little bit. The reason is is because yes, the setup, the length of the game, take down, all that kind of stuff is but my whole thing is like if I love a game enough I'm much more flexible on the table ability, which is why again, I don't want to be like F, but it's like I don't care as much cuz I'm like there's definitely games where I'm like this is a pain, but I love this my love of this game is overcoming that pain and so I don't mind it as much. And so that's why I put it in C. I don't think it's There's lots of games we play that have tons massive setups and stuff and I just don't I don't care that much.

like this also kind of ties in a little bit to scalability cuz in my mind, like a high table ability means that whatever that scalability is is the player count that you're like

Yeah.

Yes, I I have the people to get this player.

Yeah.

But yeah, I mean you're not wrong where it's like if you can't get it to the table, it's

If you're like I have one person that I know who will play this four-hour game with me then yeah.

No, it's it's important for sure.

All right, theme.

Theme. I'm going B here.

Okay.

Um just because similar to art, it's theme can be an enhancement. I certainly don't want a theme that's like offensive

that's that's what I think of as F tier is like an offensive theme where you're just like I'm really sorry about this game. It's so fun, but yeah, you're going to have to look past the fact that we're doing some pretty heinous things.

Yeah, yeah.

Yeah, to me that's Secret Hitler right there. We're talking about

Right. It's not disrespecting people like Santa Maria or something.

Yeah, yeah. It's colonial games.

Yeah.

Um but I'll put it at a B because it falls into the art category where it can certainly enhance a game but it is it's not going to raise the floor of a game's enjoyment. That comes more from mechanisms and things like that, other things I gave higher rankings. So it's like, yeah, nice when you can get it but it could just be a I like, you know, theme-less rolling right type games and stuff like that. It's not important. It's just cuz you're rolling the dice and the numbers happen and

I gave it a B as well. I do think that a great theme can absolutely raise the floor of something where you're just sort of like that can be the thing that grabs you and keeps you coming back because you're like, oh my god.

for getting

Any story game has like

into your collection from the store and stuff. It's very important. I agree.

Especially it can make a game easier to learn like a VitiCulture where you're like, this makes sense.

Yeah, like like it makes it intuitive.

I might be changing my mind now. I might go to A.

yeah. I went A. I almost went S for theme. For this is a thing for me. For me like I will play The Castles of Burgundy just like based it on theme games. Like I can enjoy those kinds of games but like a really good theme in my particular situation, a really weird theme will make me like a game so much more. Prodigals Club is my favorite game. It's honestly not because it's my favorite game to play but it's like the mechanic plus like the weird theme on top. I will buy a game like Service Horse Max. I didn't know anything about that game and I was like, I will buy this based off the theme alone. So to me, theme I would even put above art. Like if it's got a really interesting, a really good theme Um yeah, you did. Same. I will theme to me is incredibly Again, like I can enjoy games without themes but like if you've got a cool theme or a weird theme or just a different theme, I I go, "Ooh, what's this game about?" way more than the mechanics and stuff like that is theme.

And I'm looking at Wild Gardens over there. It's off camera and stuff. It's about foraging, and I'm like, "Oh, that's an awesome theme." And then that's like Yokohama. It's about a city, and you're like, "Eh."

So, in our minds, what do we what do we picture when we picture like a B-tier theme?

Cuz I feel like it's slightly above average theme. So, maybe it is like a a a more mundane theme, but just executed like decently.

I think a B-tier theme would be like an Uwe Rosenberg like farming, you know, or Clans of Caledonia.

I can't think of those as like S-tier themes. But those are those are kind of like the very like middle of the road where I'm just like slightly elevated

I would probably say like a This is maybe a slightly bad example. I would say like I'm looking at over here. Probably like a Lost Ruins of Arnak. Like a game where you're like exploring and stuff. I really like those themes. Yeah, but it's not like, "Oh my gosh, this is really cool," you know? I might say like even though obviously it's sold a bunch of copies, maybe like a Wingspan as a B in terms of like it is like uh it was a good original theme and stuff, but mechanically what you're doing it's not evoking that a lot. So, maybe like in a B-tier theme it's either like that's a cool theme, but they don't really do like fully execute it, or they do execute it, and it's kind of a boring theme.

Yeah, you play Wingspan, you're like, "Oh, it's birds." Like, "Oh, yeah, but the game you're bird watchers." I'm like, "Oh, I never think about that." It's like, "Look at all the cool birds," which is not a bad thing. It's a great thing.

Or you have those like Speakeasy where it's like it's got a great theme, and like the whole thing is integrated into that theme and stuff like that.

like an A because like it executes the theme The theme isn't like the most interesting, but it's like pastoral and nice. And then like an S-tier theme would be, "Wow, this is a really cool theme, and they absolutely take maximum advantage of that theme."

Yeah, I always went as though a theme is very important for me personally.

And the last one we got usability.

Fiddliness Fiddliness of the game. It's like it how how much debris is there? How hard is it to see like what's going on across the table? Am I Am I reaching? Am I getting up or

Yeah.

you know.

I threw this down in A. I threw this I gave this an A. This is I was back and forth on um theme and usability and going B or A and I I feel like I could go the other way. Um but a game being

[sighs]

is There's a lot of things where a game people can can you know, complain about a game being really fiddly that I'm kind of like, "Yeah, it's not that big a deal." But like the size of games these days where you're having to get up and then really get over there. I'm like, "What's that say over there?" That That's rough. That's really rough. Um And I feel like that happens more now. Um so yeah, I put it at an A.

That's fair.

I put it at an S tier.

Really?

So yeah, cuz in my mind I'm I'm picturing like games that are are hyper usability where sort of in that discussion where we're talking about putting stuff into double-layer [snorts] player boards where it's like games where you play where you're like, "Oh, this is so satisfying to like execute it this way." Or like any of the the friction that you might get from a game where you're like, "Oh man, I got to like tear this down and wipe it again." Or whatever that means to you. It's like it's gone. So it's like it's sort of the uh tactile equivalent of game flow.

Exactly. That's what I'm saying. It's like board games are an analog tactile experience. So if it can be satisfying to handle the components of the game, like that's nice, you know what I mean? And of course, if it's helping the functionality of the game um as well.

Yeah.

I went B. Kind of middle of the road. I I don't find it to be Again, this is kind of like the um table ability where I'm just kind of like if I really enjoy the game, I won't mind the fiddliness nearly as much.

That's why I'm going back to Danes, baby.

Yeah, exactly. Talk about table ability. Good god.

I don't

mind usability probably.

Yeah, it's

They're trying.

It It gets hard when you got a lot of stuff.

Yeah.

It gets tough. I do think it's like the physical embodiment of game flow. Um but I feel like it matters less than

[snorts]

the way the game flow makes me feel like emotionally and like strategically as opposed to like actually do physically doing stuff. I do think it's important. So, cuz I almost put it lower then I was like, "No, if a game is really annoying to play because like every round, you know, like a Vladimir thing where like, "Oh, now I got to switch all these tiles out for like tier two." And I'm like, "Oh, this is so annoying." Yeah, cuz like

And it's like that's why it's B. It's like it is important, but it's not it's not C level unimportant at least for me.

What I like about it is it allows everything else to shine because it's not detracting from those elements. Um so, you can just kind of like give yourself to the game fully. Take me in your arms.

Take me in your arms.

All right. So, let's I guess let's run down this uh Mike, you want to start? Just go through all of your

Okay, so going back up to the top with art, I gave it a C. Component quality gave it a C. I don't love those choices, but they did it.

Uh depth, B. Game flow, got to be an S. Gimmick, give me a B. Graphic design, I think it's ever important with an S tier. Interaction, C. Originality, F. Uh replayability, B. Rulebook, got to be an A. Scalability, got to be an A. Tableability, I'll deal with whatever. If it gets me if I have a chance to play a game, I'll do whatever to get through that. That's a D. Uh theme being a B and usability as an A.

All right. Going through that, mine are actually somewhat similar. So, art for me was an A. Component quality is a C. Depth is a B. Game flow is an S. A gimmick is B. Graphic design is an S. Interaction is a B. Originality is an F. Replayability is a C. Rulebook is an A. Scalability is a D. Tableability is a C. Theme is A and usability is B.

Okay. So, kicking off with D and art. I don't know what I would have swapped for because it's it's very hard.

Yeah, it's part of the thesis of our videos. We had to give something a B and an

I'd love for it not to be, but I'm like looking at the things that are C's and B's and I'm like, "No, probably not." We got C for component quality, B for depth, S for game flow, B for gimmick, A for graphic design, C for interaction, F for originality, A for replay-ability, B for rulebook, C for scale-ability, A for table-ability, B for theme, and S for usability.

Indeed. So, down in the comments, put your thing. So, just to remind you, you get two S tiers, three A tiers, four B tiers, three C tiers, one D, one F. 13, baby.

13 Is it 13 or 14? Is it 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 Oh, yes, 14. 14. Indeed.

15 categories.

19 categories. So, put it down there, and let us know what you think about our list. This is tough, because again, you have to kind of do that scale. What are you willing to get rid of? What do you think is like, "Ah, it's okay if this is bad."

And this is Yeah, and I guess when you come up against a game from a publisher, and you're like, "How could they do this?" Maybe they were dealing with this.

Yeah. Yeah. And then, 10 day Listen, if you're producing a game, you only have so much budget. You can't go out and buy a

There's things in here that I feel like cost very little. Like, coming up with a great theme just costs creativity, but

And they might cost time, right? If you're like, "Oh, I I don't want to spend another year on this game to increase increase the game flow, or whatever."

also interesting things that we talked about, like gimmick, [snorts] where if it's not at least like good, you're better off not having it. So, it's just like, "Crush that up."

Like, gimmick kind of can't go below like B or C, cuz then it's like a real detriment.

You're like, "Why is this here?" And cuz it's also a lot of the times the thing that gets people into the game and excited, cuz it's in that sort of originality category. And then, they do it, and they're like, "This sucks."

Yeah, this is terrible. Indeed. So, that's our again, very subjective list. So, let us know yours down in the comments below. Thank you for Let us know if you like these kinds of um uh videos. We enjoy doing them quite a bit.

to back these games on Kickstarter.

It's now your own personal rubric to use

Yeah, exactly what the game's going to be.

Exactly.

Uh you know, just know if we ever make, you know, more games, when we make them, it's all S tiers across the board. Just go ahead and add that.

S tier. Component.

S tier. Death.

Exactly.

Also S tier. Yep. I'm just checking. S is across the board.

Uh it is possible if it's us. Um all right, everyone. Don't forget to subscribe, please, and we will see you on the next one. Bye.

Bye.

Progress saved