Barbaric: Crown of the Frost (F-) Final Grade - Kickstarter Critique Clip
Transcript
Terrible, terrible job. I final grade. Do I want it? No. I thought the video sucked. I thought the video was terrible. I thought the choice to Oh, there's two of them. Oh, is this the one that's actually good? Oh, that one looks like an actual good one. I'm not judging that one. I'm judging the one that you put first BECAUSE I DON'T ASSUME THERE'S TWO VIDEOS AND I SHOULD NOT ASSUME there's two videos. I'm not even going TO GIVE YOU THE benefit of the doubt on that second video because I bet most people also did not. This video is trash. It is absolute trash. All it does is like, hey, here's a mini. Here's artwork. And then we go, hey, cards like cards. Cards every 3 seconds. There's an there's artwork. There's cards. There's cards.
CARDS. CARDS. AND THEY'RE NOT GOOD CARDS EITHER. THEY'RE NOT SHOWING THEIR BEST CARDS. THEY HAVE CARDS THAT ARE LIKE multi-use cards where it's like you pick a choice and there's multiple choices and you could there's iconography and it's like no WE'RE GOING TO SHOW THIS CHAIN LOCK WHEN YOU WHEN YARZA TAKES TWO DAMAGE MINUS ONE then the attacker immediately enters THEIR UPKEEP PHASE. OH THAT'S FUN. That's way more fun than pick YOUR OWN PATH. NO IT'S NOT. So this video absolute trash. And then then so do I want it after the video? No. They put the 8.1. I gave them a third of a point great bump up because you say wow 8.1 actually seems pretty good. Yes. until you actually, and this is why I never trust these numbers. It's actually rated 12,63 because it HAS AN ABSOLUTELY ABYSMALLY GOD-AWFUL RULE BOOKLET, and that is not my words, that's in their comment section because in the can you do it section, I am not being hyperbolic. I spent nearly 15 to 20 minutes, and it was nothing, nothing but people mad at you for a wide variety of things. It was nothing but piss POOR CUSTOMER SERVICE OF I HAVE TRIED to reach you numerous times. I am now dragging it into your COMMENT SECTION.
YOU RAN from Kickstarter to Gamefound to get away from your past and I bet it's deeper below. Like, oh, it's just so bad. It's so bad. Can you do it? No. I would not trust them with my dog. Okay. Let alone shipping out this game and it it'd be good. Will you get the game? Probably. Probably. They got $120,000. Will it be good? I can't I can't I don't see anything that that that that tells me that the game wasn't good. And then you took away text from the cards to make it so that in theory. Can you do it? No. I don't feel good about that. How much is it? Um man, it's stupid. There's 10 pledges. There's 10 pledges and I think it was six of them had less than 15 pledges which just screams you could make that an add-on.
And the bottom line is anyone who is a super backer on Kickstarter who has backed more than say I don't know 20 30 projects could look at your pledges the day before you launched and be like oh you probably just put that as an add-on right nobody's taking that nobody's taking that crap even if you sold that CRAP BETTER WHICH YOU DIDN'T they didn't sell Barbarian after the apocalypse better like oh hey you want to know more here's some text yay yippy skippy you didn't even tell me there standalone expansions You told me SO LITTLE ABOUT SO much and it's just perplexing. So, do I want it? No. Can you do it? No. How much is it? It's stupid and the price doesn't feel good. And then it's not just that the price doesn't feel good. It's that the price is incomplete. Because their shipping section, they found a way to make their shipping section god awful, too. Because they're like, "Oh, hey, we have 10 pledges, so we have two possible choices. You either have a 5 kilogram or a 15 kilogram." Now, I'm sure if you go back and you really pinpoint like, "All right, this one's probably five. This one's probably five. This one's probably five. This one's probably 50." You could probably DO THAT, OKAY? BUT YOU SHOULDN'T HAVE TO. YOU COULD easily just be like, "This pledge, this pledge, this pledge, this pledge over here, this pledge, pledge, this pledge, this pledge over here." Or you could have interweaved this up there, but you didn't want to because your shipping price is freaking terrible. And you didn't even convert the currencies.
Like, oh, you're in the UK? Well, well, we couldn't be bothered to plug $18 US to find out how much pounds it was because that would probably take us, I don't know, 13 seconds. We were much too busy doing piss poor customer service to take that 13 seconds to convert your currency and actually get maybe a customer from the United Kingdom. It's just abysmal. It's just abysmal. And it completely goes against what they were doing earlier where they wouldn't show ME THE INCHES. LIKE YOU WERE ACTIVELY LIKE [screaming] you're showing me kilograms. Like look at I just pause. You are using kilograms as your primary use of measurement to tell me about your shipping section. Yet you're using the United States dollar, which is one of only three countries in the whole freaking stupid wide world that doesn't use kilograms. Yet every single one, France, rest of the world, UK, Germany, Asia, Asia, A, Asia B.
We're not doing any work for any of you. Even your own country, Singapore, do you get free local shipping? Where is Singapore? Is the rest of the world? Surely your own country is not rest of the world. That wouldn't make any sense at all. I hate everything about this campaign. I This feels like if someone was like, "Hey, I want you to watch every episode of Bowers Game Carter Kickstarter Critique and I want you to do the exact opposite of nearly every single thing that he ever said to do." Which once again is not my opinion. It's mostly just what the industry standard is. And you're like everything opposite. And then we do have a nice section down here where you're spotlighting your rewards. despite the fact when you look at your board game geek page, it really shines a different picture on how well the how good these games are. Like, yeah, rising star in the Thailand Board Game Awards, that means your game look like it was the best of a bunch of other new publishers. It's not really that probably impressive, but just having that award makes you look so much credible. So, it makes sense that we would bury it.
all the way down there, doesn't it? I also think they're using AI. I want to go down to that because if so, you know, then you guys can you can pound on them, you anti- AIR people. [sighs] This is This is the This is just so bad. What does it say? I don't know. I don't care. Let me know in the comments below. Final grade's an F. Final grade's an F. And I did I gave it a third of a point grade bump up because I did think they did a good job here starting with an exciting stretch goal and then trying to trick me by letting me say, "Hey, this is 8.1." I wouldn't have made this clickable. This is one of those rare times where like, "Yeah, it's 8.1 of Board Gamegegeek. You want to go check it? You can go check it. Maybe even have a picture from Boardgame Geek." But don't send me to Board Game Geek because if you send me to Board Gamegeeek and I do any amount of research, it's going to immediately immediately fall into place exactly what this game is when we go to the ratings.
I imagine like let's look at the most common rating. Actually, no. eight. That's pretty good. Ready to fun feels a bit like a hero shooter. Okay. Either way, I it doesn't like this because this is where you're shook out, right? These are the games that you are near. It's a bomb and then we are deep into this. You are you're near elephant rally. Like [sighs] final grade is an F. Just everything about this page is just so bad. From the main option image to the description to the overuse of the tags and just assuming the tags are going to tell me about your information to whether or not I don't even know if it's a standalone expansion. I don't even know if I should get the previous versions of the game. I don't know why I should get the previous versions of the game. You're in your last 18 hours. you have lost like like you pinned a comment that literally talked about how you have quote unquote lost or pulled out $27,000 in two weeks and the rest of the comments like really take that into consideration. The rest of the comments down below if I click on most popular are pro like they pin this probably to hide whatever this is for it's worth if anybody's on the fence about banking game from hexa house with the current state of the board game crowdfunding you cannot go wrong with these guys. Oh, what the heck? I back my fair share of games for different companies over these and these guys are the best company by far when it comes to backer service and just overall passion for games. Oh well, good for you bummer
cuz that that is unlike anything else that I have ever seen from you know everybody else in the comment section. Uh, thank you so much for saying this. This is somebody that really likes the concept. Ber wants to see succeed after you guys considered to cancel this campaign and relaunch after a few months after address a few months after addressing all the feedback people have given in the comments. It might this that might be the healthiest route to increase funding and secure the future of Barbaric. It would also allow you guys to iron out some things that could be fixed within a short time frame, but with the campaign structure with the actual game. So, not only does your campaign suck, but we're worried that your game's going to suck. Please take a couple months because I want to support you. I agree to uh thank you for this thoughtful feedback. Uh we really appreciate that it comes from wanting to see Barbaric succeed in the long term. We have considered the current state of the campaign carefully, but at this point we're able to proceed with caution. So we don't we are able to proceed with oh production. We don't so we don't currently plan to cancel and relaunch. The game found total doesn't represent entire production volume. We also have orders from our Thai market that are being handled separately from game found. Doesn't scream great rule booklet. We believe this is the most sustainable approach for us right now.
Other campaigns add the toes from non-game found camps to the stretch goals to help achieve more stretch goals. Two campaigns come to mind. I'm extremely disappointing the stretch goals for this campaign. So much to do that I may cancel before it's over. And now you see why they have a pinned comment that literally says we've lost tens of thousands of dollars over the last couple weeks. Like there's no other reason why you would pin that. They could have just easily like because they led like it's just so bad. Hey, there are some honest feedback. You're selling four core boxes which nobody really needs or likely wants. Unless you bundle it well, right? They want the variety of characters, maps, and modes you've created from them, but they don't want to reby the tokens and dice four times or have four giant boards, then two would suffice. Yeah. And you didn't you didn't sell that. I didn't feel the wide variety of things in this game, which I was slapping them about the whole time because I could. There's a huge amount of cards. There's probably a big amount of minis if you buy everything, but you did such a piss poor job of selling anything that I didn't want anything.
The concept of putting two boards together to make your character is really cool, but it's also expensive. It's also not something they showcased at all in their main video. Takes a ton of space, especially at the quantity. Instead, I think players would be fine with having just one board of space for gear and rider sheets. Yep. Yep. Make it cheaper. They're not going to do that. They are clearly sizzle over stake. You're marketing primarily. You reuse old content, which isn't exciting for anyone who already knows about your game or owns it. And I don't think the way the campaign itself is marketed is easy to purge through or understand quite frankly for new players. No. No, it's not. Because in points one and two, the boxes are massive. So players need to store four giant boxes, which is really inconvenient and a pain to set up and tear down if they just want to play a game with all the really great gear and writer options. See, these are the people. these type of people give these companies overflated egos to come come bring back up and and try and revive these games that clearly the market was like we don't love it. We don't love it without knowing whether or not you can offer painted or washed minis. Anyone who got this in your pre campaign is worried that they'll be buying as an unmatched fourth core box. Yeah, that's pretty big that they know very little about. Yeah. and the three they have are already f like this is literally like hey I'm your target market and you suck here's seven reasons why you suck and yeah you mentioned the rule book is 80% done and this is the second version OF THE GAME OH YEAH I WAS FOCUSING on the fact this is just your third expansion so that's a really stupid like that's like what why are you showing me 80 like but you're like oh no this is actually the second
the more I scroll through this it's just I keep finding things that are bad the idea of you Making a cheaper edition, as you mentioned, sounds nice in theory, except there's more you need to ship and produce, and it's sort of what I'm suggesting, incidentally, but really, I think now is your big opportunity to make one great definitive edition of this game. Yeah. Yeah. What? This is the definitive big box for the 8.1 rated on Board Game Geek. Please don't check. Please don't check. uh 14 geek thing and it has 3v3 and 2v2 and cooperative and free-for-all and there's 65 characters and there's 834 cards and there's this artwork that some people think is awesome and other people think might look AI generated but who really cares like there's so many great and then just personal conclusion solution your current backing numbers tell me people want basically everything you have to offer this game is a very fewer backing one or two core boxes why because it looks amaz if you did any sort of research you would know that why because it looks amazing the gameplay and variety sound kind of exciting. The quality is there. The rules seem clearer.
Like I said, the rules didn't seem good. They seem clearer. Well, hopefully taking away the text in the card doesn't kind of take away the there. That said, basically everyone going all in or wanting to will need to be a really pain to store and set up. It's just Did they respond? Wow.
F minus. Get out. Just get out. I need to go scream F. I have never awarded an F minus before. I HAVE TO MAKE A WHOLE new damn playlist because of you. You have now introduced the first ever F minus. Amazing request. Whoever requested this, you're like, "Oh my god, he's going to have a heart attack over this." Fminus. Barbaric: Crown of the Frost. They just they suck at everything. Can you do it? Do I want it? How much is it? They focused on all the stuff that nobody cares about. They clearly are not listening to their customers. This customer, this customer who absolutely took the time or they chat you GPT, who cares, wrote a freaking book for you. They wrote a book FOR YOU ABOUT HOW much you suck and how much they think it would be better if you did things the other way. and they did it nicely and politely and you didn't even respond with a thanks for taking the TIME TO COMMENT DESPITE THE FACT YOU HAVE RESPONDED to a variety OF OTHER DIFFERENT COMMENTS. YOU COULD HAVE PLUGGED THAT INTO CHAT GPT and said, "Hey, we're not going to do any of this stuff, but we want to seem good. Give me a response." You could have done any of this, but you were too lazy. I hate everything about this. Fminus. Goodbye.
Get out. How do I back out? That is I think that means this is the worst project I've ever seen. This is the worst best project I've ever seen. Yeah, because I've seen some worse crap ones where it's like, hah, let's point it at make fun of it. And this is just like no. What are you doing? Why are you pissing off all your customers? What do you like? You've done four campaigns now and you have this. This is what you use the F minus.