Bastille Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today i'm taking a look at bastille which is a board game that came out in 2018 this was published by queen games and designed by christoph bear and this one accommodates three to four players and takes around an hour to play so but still being a few years old now and actually at the time it didn't come out to tremendous fanfare but i will say that generally i enjoy queen games i think they do a good job of striking a bounce between having some strategy in their games but still being really accessible mixed with some good production so this is a worker placement style game that takes place on this pretty generic looking board here where you have all these different action spots you can go to represented by these shields each plate is going to start with a number of shields here and at different levels you've got three level ones and a level two and this is this is based on the three player setup you're gonna have some money uh someone's gonna be the first player and also everybody's gonna be dealt um an objective card or an endgame scoring card so my end game is to try to get a level five six and seven of one of these peasants for a uh for a bonus of six points at the end of the game so uh the game is going to take place over eight rounds and halfway through the game there is going to be a little scoring phase and then you're going to continue to the final four rounds where there's going to be an end game scoring so let's talk about all the different spots here and what things we're going to go for to try and achieve victory points which of course is the actual objective of the game so uh let's start number one here so number one is a very simple one where you are going to get money um times two depending on the worker that
you've placed there or the knight you've placed there so let's say i placed uh this level one shield here is the white player that means i've got one times two for a total of two coins but this happens after all of the placements have been taken so um i suppose one of the mechanisms i should talk about is how these um ties are going to be broken because a lot of these different locations have priority or give a bonus to the person with the strongest level knight there so let's say uh the blue or so the black player here place their level two knight here that means that they would go first because again two trumps one but let's see if i played a um another level two night here the person furthest to the left would break that second tie so you're gonna get the highest knight there but also the furthest to the left by being the first to place there so yeah the first spot is just to get money the second spot allows you to upgrade up upgrade one of your night so let's say um at the end of the round i've got this knight here then i could actually swap that for a level two one of course making me more powerful and um making me more likely to break ties and get the bonuses so the first person to do that is going to get a bonus point as well but the other two slots are only going to get to upgrade their night the third slot here lets you take one of these bonuses again the person with the strongest knight there is going to get first pick and they're going to relate to the other spots on the board which we'll talk about talk about in a minute but the first play gets first option and the second player gets the second option this spot here relates to this bag where
depending if you're first or second you get to add either one or two cubes into the bag corresponding to your color and that could be important later you've got the five spot here which is how you're going to acquire these cards which is a big part of your scoring so the anatomy of these cards is pretty simple you've got the value of what they're worth here what they cost you've got these crowns which are going to give you points depending on if you've got the majority of them you've got these diamonds which give you a point for each one you have the actual victory points they're going to give you and as you can see some of these cards or in fact all of the cars have weapons on them if they're red that still means those those weapons are outstanding and they need to you need to equip those people with those weapons otherwise you can suffer negative points at the end of the game depending on this track here so if i had say four cards that aren't equipped then i can actually lose 14 points so if you're going to acquire cards you want to make sure that they are equipped with weapons you've also got flags as well and when it comes to the end of the year round whoever's got the most flags is going to gain one of these bonuses which again i like victory points i'm putting more cubes in the bag getting money i'm climbing around this bastille track here which i'll talk about shortly in fact i'll talk about it now so uh the bastille track is pretty simple so all you're going to do is depending on the strength of your knight you put there you're going to move your player piece around that track so um let's say the white player went now i'd move it two spaces like so and this is going to give you points
at the halfway point at the end game point depending on which line you cross here so if you really focus on this you're going to potentially get a lot of points but additionally it's how you're going to acquire weapons and weapons are great because of course you want to equip them equip your cards with them to not suffer those negative points and the um the final slot here is to is to acquire more end game bonus cards again the first person to do so is going to get a bonus two coins and you can actually look through the whole deck and pick which card you're sorry which bonus card you're after not character cards so that card shouldn't be in there but just um just these things like this just to get all different kinds of objectives such as again the person with the most of these military troops gets uh six points or the person with the most crown gets six points all things like that and you can kind of tell your strategy depending on you on what you want to do and something i should have mentioned on this five slot here is the actual value of the knight is important because that depends or that relates to the discount you get off this value so if i place the massive massively strong level four night there i would actually get a full discount making this that eight card only cost me four coins so after you've played four rounds of all the players placing all of their workers and evaluating the spaces and getting your rewards you're going to come to the midterm scoring which as i mentioned before every player is going to get a point for each gem they have on their cards you're going to give three points to the person with the most crowns and then you're going to go to the bag phase which
is when you whoever placed the um what in fact it doesn't matter you're going to draw five cubes one at a time from the bag at least if there's five in there and you were going to allocate them depending on which cube was drawn so again the white player here has been lucky enough to have their cube drawn first you're going to allocate them to one of these spots here which give you an instant bonus and this is divided into two halves here so you've got this one here which are the more powerful bonuses that when you claim one of these rewards so let's say i took these uh the six coin uh bonus you are actually going to lose that um cube from the bag and put it back into your general supply if you go to these slightly less interesting or slightly um weaker bonuses then you are still going to get that reward but you actually get to put the cube back into the bag for the final round and these are quite cool there's a good tension here and of course you incentivize to invest more and more cubes to make it more likely that you're going to draw your cubes from the bag to get these bonuses and then um of course you are going to refer to the bastille track get your points depending on how far you've gone and then equip your soldiers um on priority depending on who's got the furthest so the the red player has got farthest along the track they're going to get to pick two weapons so let's say they pick these two and then it's going to be the black player that says pick these two and then the white player who will get the dregs of what's left and once the halfway points reach you're going to just move these tiles out of the way for the end game cue bonuses you're going to replenish all the cards etc replenish the weapons in the supply
and you're going to go again for the final four rounds where a final scoring will happen after that with the same criteria going again points for gems points for the most crowns draw five cubes from the bag best steel tracks assessed um all your characters are scored or your endgame bonuses are scored and um if every three coins you've got is going to get your point on every cube left in the bag is also going to get you a point and of course you're going to evaluate how many of your soldiers you've got without weapons which can potentially lose you a lot of points so as you can probably tell from the run through there this game is relatively simple it certainly falls in that medium lightweight bracket and is a pretty clean worker placement game with pretty succinct areas pretty understandable areas you know there's nothing tremendously complex or fiddly here all of them are pretty simple in their own regard but i do really like this um this worker system where you are choosing to either place your workers but you can also choose to invest in upgrading your workers and this reminds me of a game called lancaster which is one of my favorite work placement games this one is a lot more simple than lancaster but it does have some similarities and it does strike a certain chord with me to make me think of that game though i really like that trade-off you know if you are going to upgrade your worker you are pretty much sacrificing going somewhere else but that's going to help you in the long term particularly because the game does play over eight rounds so you get quite a lot of potential to take that option and i also like the fact that not only are you investing these workers not only to get priority on these spots but also to
boost your power on these spots you know particularly when it comes to the money you know if you're starting to smash down your level four workers here you can get eight coins in the single placement um and also with the bastille track as well you know you're placing your four workers down and you're actually flying across this track four spots at a time to get past those thresholds to get more and more points so i like the fact when in a lot of work placement games when not only are you just rewarded a um a power or a bonus just by placing there you actually have competition to get there as well because you know not only are you trying to get the first priority you can actually block people out completely because a lot of these spots only have two spots here that actually people can go to in the first place as you can see here so i do like that competition and there is a real scarcity to each of these spots which i think is a completely essential facet for a worker placement game and i do think bastille does that really well there's a lot of options but you want to do them all you're gonna have to prioritize and think about what your opponents are gonna do to make sure they don't trump you and lock you out of going a certain spot that you want to go to the character cards here are a big part of the game and you'll find yourself going here a lot not only because you want to get of course get the points on the cards in the first place you are competing for the different symbols you know the crowns and the gems to get more victory points and the competition for the facts is quite important as well for these end of round bonuses which are pretty strong especially if you lead the uh you know you lead that throughout the whole game you can actually acquire quite a lot of uh bonuses throughout and of course uh a lot of these cards
correspond to the end game bonuses like these for example where again it's just a more it's a more kind of um synchronized pool of points and you're going to find yourself wanting to go here because that's where a lot of the the points are going to come from i do like the way these are designed you know there are only kind of three or four types of these so they're all pretty simple but once you start collecting you can actually line them up like so i mean that you can clearly see all the symbology that you've got and um you haven't got to just sprawl all over the table and take up loads of space that's a good little graphic design choice and i do like that i also like the fact that you get discounts based on the workers you've placed there just another element of why you want to go to focus on upgrading your workers as well as just getting the actual sports in the first place so that's a really cool system now something i was initially skeptical of was this bag building mechanism here where you know if you go here you can place either two or one cubes in the cube in the bag uh depending on your priority um and i was worried that you know that's very swingy it's very luck driven but i suppose it's a a risk that you are willing to take and something that you don't have to compete in if you don't want to so you know if you see your opponent start going here again and again and again and start filling that bag then you might think you know what they're going to guarantee drawing all their cubes therefore they're going to keep getting these really cool bonuses so you are going to want to find yourself at least um getting somewhat involved here and i do like the fact that you know even if you weren't massively lucky in having your cubes drawn you are still compensated at the
end of the game by getting a point for each cube remaining in that bag so you aren't just wasting your time and throwing your turns away by going here and i think you know despite this being somewhat important in the game you're going to find yourself mostly placing your lower workers there because you're simply just um trying to trump your opponent based on how many cues you're placing rather than getting a discount or an amplified version such as this here or here um based on the strength of your worker so there's while these parts are important they're not like the main focus of the game and i don't think they're gonna dominate the game in terms of the strategy and the outcome um i do really like the tension of this bastille track as well you know you want to be uh leading the front here and leading the charge because a lot of the time your cars you've collected will want specific weapons and you want to make sure that you get the first dibs on which weapons are available and because of course you can potentially lose a lot of points if you neglect that and which can of course be very debilitating if you do fall far behind so there's a constant balancing and trying to spin a lot of plays into collecting cards making you can equip your cards trying to get points from here maybe getting dipping into the pile here and picking your end game bonuses which is quite unique because i was expecting when you came here to just maybe draw the top two or three cards pick one and put the rest of the bottom but you've actually got a lot of flexibility here to look through the whole deck of cards pick the one you want and then go from there i'm really happy that this game stayed within that 60 minute mark i think if it started to lean towards that 90 minute mark it would start to out of state it's welcome um not because it's an interesting or
anything but simply because you can get quite a a meaty or a meteor game played in that 90 minute time frame where as this one strikes a great balance of being having a lot going on and some good strategies and some good decisions but falling within that again that 60 minute mark which is a lot shorter than a lot of games of this style so i do like that and it certainly doesn't say it's welcome even the turns themselves are quick and dynamic you know just smashing workers down um and you know you do all the assessment at the end all the housekeeping once all the workers are down which keeps the game moving nicely so yeah i do like the flow of the game the tempo is really good uh yes there are eight rounds but the eight rounds do fly by pretty quickly and there's always a constant jostle for position um and the kind of tension and the dynamic or dynamism of the game is is strong in this one there's so much competition for the flags for the for the certain cards um and of course for all the other things as well so i do really like the flow the tempo and the time stamp of the game i think is is spot on for me um interaction is embedded in pretty much everything you do because essentially you're bidding for these spots by placing the workers but sometimes as i mentioned earlier you're going to have to sit back and sacrifice eternal too by choosing to invest in upgrading your workers um and of course there's the tension of the track here and so there's quite a lot going on and other players actions are going to affect what you do and um so it's not it's not a multi-player solitaire the game board is nice and tight and a player interaction is going to be a constant thread throughout this game from a production standpoint i'm really happy with the quality of the components
here as i normally am with queen games i think they do a great job of keeping things affordable but still high quality um i think the visuals are going to be somewhat polarizing it's not going to be the most uh you know not having the biggest impression on gamers it's not a massively striking beautiful game but i think it looks quite nice everything is clear everything is well symbolized and you can tell what everything does quite clearly um so i've got no real issues with the look or visuals of the game you know nothing spectacular but it does what it does quite well um additionally i think the progression of the game is strong because keep going back to the fact you're upgrading your workers and taking stronger and stronger terms as you go on so as the game goes on and on and on you do feel like you're moving forward and you know if people do neglect this part of the board they're going to start falling behind so i do like the tempo and the forward momentum of this game it certainly feels like you're taking stronger actions at the end than at the beginning but still does have a strict player count of three to four players which i think could turn a lot of people off because i know today two player games are getting more and more prolific and i would have thought that this could be quite easily scalable of course with a bit of play testing you know maybe by locking off a few of these sections just uh you know taking a blocking off one of the spots or maybe using dummy workers or a dummy player to uh to kind of infiltrate the board i'm surprised it didn't have any effort to to scale the game to two i suppose in addition to the scaling problems my biggest issue with this game is the
replayability factor or lack of it because there's not much variability here you are essentially going to get the same game from time to time yes the order of the bonuses are going to change from from game to game and some of them are taken out but i don't think that's going to have a massive impact in the feel of the game at all uh and yeah also i'd like to see maybe more different types of cars come into play that do different things but i think the more you kind of add this kind of stuff in it's maybe taking it away from the target audience of who this game is designed for but from yeah from a selfish standpoint i would like to see maybe a sideboard or something else going on here just to give you something else to focus on should you choose to do so and to give it more of a reason to get back to the table um don't get me wrong i feel perfectly happy to play this one a few more times but i do fear that when i get to that threshold it's going to start losing its appeal and it's going to feel like you've started to explore everything this game has to offer but despite those concerns i think this game is really delightful i i was really happy with my with my initial experiences of this one it's really fun it's super breezy but despite that it has got a lot of interesting decisions to make and tensions to get to the spots that you want to get to tension to get the cars you want to the tension of the track here to not only get the points but to get your weapons as well it has a lot going on here in a very simple rule set and a very clean rule set so i think this game is an absolute breeze to teach to anybody uh specifically if they familiar with worker placement games and have played any worker placement game before this one is going to be such uh it's going to
feel so familiar now this game doesn't really do anything original it doesn't do anything special but what it does i think it does extremely well and you know what just on top of everything it's fun it's fun simple clean family fun and uh i really you know despite my initial concerns about this bag system i actually do like this one and it kind of i suppose it's the the one thing this game has to offer that's maybe stands out amongst all a lot of the other worker placement style games or or games of this waiting so yeah it has a lot i like i think i don't really have any complaints about it at all apart from those concerns about the replayability but i was expecting something a lot more generic something a bit boring and kind of a bit mediocre and this was i think this is way better than mediocre very happy with the still and i think this was a bit of a hidden gem i think you can probably pick this one up for quite an affordable price now because this one did slip under that radar and i think this one should deserve more credit because i know a lot of these intro or to medium lightweight work replacement games are really popular with the masses and i think bastille is amongst the best of them so definitely check this one out if this is your jam that is bastille and this one gets my shield of quality thank you so much for checking out this video if you found it useful or at least somewhat entertaining then please hit like and consider subscribing if you haven't done so already additionally if you wish to support the show because i am a woman operation and i don't get any support from publishers then please consider backing on patreon at
patreon.com forward slash chairman of the board where you can back for as little as two pounds per month thank you so much i'll see you next time